OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, February 27, 2023

Special meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: f

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:01:17 Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen.

0:01:18 I'd like to call the February 27th,

0:01:22 2023 meeting to order.

0:01:25 I want to confirm we have a quorum.

0:01:27 We have six members present in chambers.

0:01:31 First item on the agenda is an action item

0:01:36 to move into executive session to communicate

0:01:41 with legal counsel for the public agency

0:01:44 to discuss the legal ramifications of and legal options for pending litigation or controversies

0:01:51 not yet being litigated, but imminently likely to be litigated, the mere presence of legal

0:01:57 counsel at an executive session does not satisfy this requirement.

0:02:01 And that doesn't say what section we're moving into executive session under.

0:02:11 Section now.

0:02:16 Can you have a second?

0:02:18 Second.

0:02:19 Motion by Christopher Reed.

0:02:20 Second by Craig Hawkins.

0:02:21 to move into executive session, under section F.

0:02:25 Amy Rokavo, please.

0:02:29 Yes.

0:02:35 Yes.

0:02:36 And Alex Kavol.

0:02:39 New motion passes six to zero.

0:02:40 So to let everybody know, we'll be leaving chambers,

0:02:44 but we'll be back here a little bit before five,

0:02:47 and we'll start a regular meeting at five.

0:02:49 Evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome

0:04:45 to our Monday, February 27th, 2020, three city council meeting.

0:04:51 I want to call the meeting back to order.

0:04:53 We met at 4.30 this morning, this morning.

0:04:56 I was at work at 4.30 this morning,

0:04:58 but we met for executive session at 4.30 PM, and we're back.

0:05:04 So we'll just move on to, I'll call the meeting back to order.

0:05:08 Her side among the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:05:10 If you wish to join me, please rise.

0:05:32 So before we get started, I just wanna take a minute

0:05:35 to publicly think that in the women of our police department

0:05:41 and our city staff and all the law enforcement

0:05:45 and public safety individuals that helped us

0:05:49 through our crisis last week was a very scary day

0:05:55 and the teams worked together phenomenally.

0:06:00 It was kind of like practice makes perfect

0:06:02 and it was definitely perfect

0:06:06 for being as scary as it was.

0:06:08 Dr. Dickinson said the Canyon Ridge staff

0:06:12 and in parents and students also did exactly what they were supposed to do.

0:06:18 In addition, I wanted to publicly thank the many members of our city staff

0:06:24 who stepped up to the plate and handled things well.

0:06:28 The executive team was gone and just made us like we didn't miss a beat.

0:06:33 So thank you everyone and especially thanks to men and women of the Twin Falls PD.

0:06:39 Okay so next on the agenda we don't have any proclamations so we to the consent

0:06:47 calendar we have several items on the consent calendar council wishes thank

0:06:56 you Jason Brown thank you motion by allys kavals seconder by Jason Brown to

0:07:02 approve the consent calendar as written Amy Roekalvo please yes yes thank you

0:07:20 motion passes seven to zero. One thing I didn't do that I normally do is confirm we

0:07:24 have a quorum. We have all seven seven members present. So if you were here for

0:07:30 the Cedar Parks subdivision PUD, final clap for a Paris condominiums, special

0:07:37 event permits for Cinco de Mayo Mother's Day, Chochel Falls after dark, Twin

0:07:44 Fall School District, Canyon Properties, Airport Hanger Leases for five different leases.

0:07:52 Your items have been approved.

0:07:54 So next, we'll move to items of consideration.

0:07:58 The first item is a presentation by people for paths regarding a proposed expansion to

0:08:03 the Twin Falls Animal Shelter and we have Sean Stanley, our Code Enforcement Coordinator.

0:08:09 Welcome.

0:08:13 I'm excited to be here tonight to present to you the Shilter Expansion Project.

0:08:18 The city's relationship with people's pets is as strong as it's ever been.

0:08:24 Percidicence and the animals of the Magic Expansion Project has been a long journey that began in 2017.

0:08:38 We're excited for that. We have Jackie Fry. She is the President of people.

0:08:58 Welcome, Jackie.

0:09:03 Travis, our Mayor and our Commimmers.

0:09:05 And I'm going to be brief because first I wanted to address the

0:09:14 analog architecture drawings that each of you saw.

0:09:17 And this is a project that Debbie has been very proactive in the board

0:09:21 to pursue to look at the expansion of the shelter.

0:09:25 Currently we have endowments and trusts to be able to pay for

0:09:31 the expansion, so we're very excited about that.

0:09:34 So at this time we have no plans to do, we continue to do the furball

0:09:40 which is coming up. We encourage anyone to come please. And also the pooch

0:09:45 flash. So those are our two main events each year that we put on to continue to

0:09:49 maintain the care of the animals at the shelter. And how much we appreciate the

0:10:02 city. How much you support us. The fencing, the new parking lot. So many things that

0:10:08 you do with the building and it has been such an incredible resource and such a

0:10:14 blessing to our community as we continue to see the population grow we continue

0:10:19 to see the needs of the community for the animals this is one of the reasons

0:10:22 that the expansion is so critical and so we hope that at this time the reason

0:10:29 we're here is to just present where we're at currently any questions whatsoever

0:10:35 with the drawings that we're done so Jackie I do have a question if you were

0:10:43 We're talking about square footage without getting into the weeds on this.

0:10:48 How does Dave's Mansion compare to what the facility size is now?

0:10:53 So what we're looking at right now and we also is the need for our cats

0:10:59 and actually being able to have a holding room.

0:11:02 We're looking hopefully to have a place for surgery and more treatment of the cats.

0:11:10 Cats seem to be a large population base.

0:11:13 dogs are bigger we have a lot of cats we really are proactively looking at also

0:11:17 that that support but we need to have a larger area and so this is what the

0:11:22 critical part is expanding so that we can bring more resources and more of

0:11:28 those services to the animals and then of course in place educate the

0:11:32 citizens about adoption and having them go into a home where they're well

0:11:38 so would you say you're doubling the size or not quite

0:11:42 I think we were looking to speak into the mic as it is right now is 6400. Thank you. Anybody have any

0:12:11 USB? Appreciate it. Thank you Jackie. Yes, Sean. Yeah, one other thing I like to point out is a little

0:12:52 spooky out there when it's crazy busy with people and animals hacking out there. So I did want to point

0:12:58 out the rounds to be very nice. Very responsible with our funding of course. One of the biggest

0:13:18 concerns is the cost of building so we're really reviewing and looking this was a

0:13:23 plan that we hope to have as part of the five-year plan in 17 and of course

0:13:28 economic play with the increase on the cost of building so that's one of the

0:13:32 reasons why we have the funds we do those are very specifically placed so we can

0:13:39 do this but I would pray really within the next two years we're hoping to see

0:13:43 this this isn't a 10 or 20 year plan this is pretty immediate because of the

0:13:48 needs of the animals.

0:13:49 Wonderful.

0:13:50 Thank you.

0:13:53 Thank you.

0:13:56 A next item on the agenda is also an action item.

0:13:59 A request to use $33,312 dollars of library reserve funds to replace an air handling unit

0:14:07 at the Twin Falls Public Library and we have Tara Bartley, our Twin Falls Public Library

0:14:13 Director.

0:14:14 Welcome.

0:14:15 Thank you, Mary Pierce, Council members.

0:14:17 I come to you today on behalf of the Twin Falls Public Library Board of Trustees in requesting

0:14:22 that we used an additional $33,312 of our librarians serve funds.

0:14:28 We put out a bid, let me unit it, a rate for two years now.

0:14:41 So we had it currently on the 2122 budget.

0:14:45 Because of personnel issues, we were unable

0:14:47 to get that project completed.

0:14:48 And so then we put it again on the 2223 budget.

0:14:52 We put bids out early January.

0:14:54 We sent bids out to five different companies.

0:14:57 We received two bids back.

0:14:59 and our lowest bid came in at the 163,322 today to see if we eject.

0:15:16 Any questions for Tara and Nicky Boyd?

0:15:19 I want to say Tara has reserved funds. This is why we plan it.

0:15:29 Jason Brown.

0:15:48 I'll second that.

0:15:49 Thank you. Motion by Nicky Boyd. Seconded by Jason Brown to approve the request of using

0:15:55 $33,312 of library reserved funds to replace an error handling unit at the library.

0:16:02 Thank you.

0:16:04 Okay.

0:16:05 Next item on the agenda is an action item.

0:16:10 It's the Twin Falls Recreation Center Committee report on progress of the feasibility study and

0:16:32 a request for council support to continue work on this feasibility study.

0:16:37 We have Wendy David, I look like three people,

0:16:40 I don't know who's starting.

0:16:41 Wendy Davis, Parks and Rec.

0:16:44 Chris Golds, a committee member and Brian Wright,

0:16:46 a committee member, so welcome Wendy.

0:16:54 Hi Council, it's my pleasure to be here this evening

0:16:58 with members of the committee,

0:17:02 which I'd like to introduce when we get to that point,

0:17:06 but when we get to that place,

0:17:21 and then I'm going to ask Chris and Brian

0:17:23 to join me at the microphone to finish the presentation.

0:17:26 Thank you.

0:17:29 So we're here this evening to give you some background to help prepare you to make the

0:17:35 decision that we're asking you to make this evening.

0:17:39 Several of the members of this council are new since this process was started and I think

0:17:46 it's to everybody's benefit that we kind of start back up, talk about what we've done

0:17:50 and how we've gotten to where we are right now.

0:17:53 So, eventually we're getting to the place to show, to demonstrate the need for a site,

0:18:01 in order to be able to finish the study and move forward with this process.

0:18:06 In the City Strategic Plan, in the Healthy Community Area, we have to be an effective partner in

0:18:14 a rock-based focus on community health, with the initiative to explore options for creating

0:18:18 a community recreation center, and the objective to work with an advisory committee to develop

0:18:23 recreation center feasibility study that identifies community needs and support potential locations

0:18:30 and potential partners for funding options. That was kind of the overarching piece that

0:18:34 started this whole process. In 2017, the council formed the committee. At that time, there was

0:18:44 15 members. We've had a few move out of town at this point, but the remaining members are

0:18:49 listed up here. And I would like, I know there's a lot of it in the audience today, so I'm

0:18:57 rec center committee member stand up for just a moment in the years and worked really

0:19:17 are not in this process. So the first house of the committee was to select the experts

0:19:27 to guide our process, which was essentially defining our expectations in the feasibility

0:19:32 study, putting out a request for qualifications, interviewing candidates and selecting a firm

0:19:39 to work with. And we selected Pivot North in Kinsha and then they brought in BRS architecture

0:19:47 as the experts in recreation centers and community centers to help with this process.

0:19:54 At that point we identified what our goals were which was really a four-step process that

0:20:00 emphasized community input and support and provided opportunity for regular council

0:20:05 check-ins. That gave Council the option all the way through the study to stop if we didn't

0:20:12 like the direction things were going or if we learned that things weren't going to work.

0:20:17 The four steps essentially are defined up here. I don't want to spend a lot of time going

0:20:22 into all of them. But the first step we identified program spaces and we need a lot of community

0:20:30 input and then we're in the middle of step two. The end is to put a draft of the final

0:20:36 program together as well as the site plans and diagrams of the facility. I don't want

0:20:45 to go into a whole lot more of that because at this point I'm going to invite Chris and

0:20:49 Brian to come up and they're going to help with the rest of the presentation.

0:20:53 I'm giving us a time extensively for this rec center. It was not just to be a recreational

0:21:11 It was meant to be an educational center as well as a social center.

0:21:16 The mix of needs that this facility needed to represent

0:21:23 led us to taking serious steps in order to get multiple viewpoints on what,

0:21:28 not just what the committee wanted, even though the committee was composed of a lot of different viewpoints.

0:21:35 It wasn't enough, and so with that we wanted to unify our communities.

0:21:40 to make sure that there were opportunities for individuals to become the wellness and that

0:21:48 we supported economic running areas. As far as that goes, the operational cost recovery

0:21:54 was a big goal. We weren't going to set us up for failure by just putting things in place

0:21:59 that we were the city wanted or members of the city wanted. We wanted to make sure that

0:22:05 that operational cost recovery was a big part of this. And so we went through a few processes

0:22:10 to get there. We give Chris a moment just to talk about some of the... Thanks very much for allowing us to come and present.

0:22:25 It was very important from the start of this, for us to get, not just the B-wise of the committee, but also to get input from community members into that end.

0:22:34 The public has been invited to committee workshops, which tried to bring in stakeholders from all of the relevant organizations.

0:22:41 And we've had an open house with comment cards.

0:22:44 What's called a dotocracy that we'll go into in a minute.

0:22:46 And we sent out a community survey.

0:22:49 So we wanted to have hard data as opposed to just kind of a,

0:22:53 yeah, that'd be nice.

0:22:54 So let's talk a little bit about that survey.

0:22:57 There were two parts of it.

0:22:58 The first was a random mailed survey.

0:23:00 We're 3,500 copies of the survey.

0:23:02 We sent out two randomly-dead members

0:23:04 of the Twin Falls community.

0:23:05 And then it was an open online part of the survey

0:23:08 that anyone was able to take part in.

0:23:10 most of the responses from the Open Online survey did come from the Twin Falls area,

0:23:15 but we do understand that that is a little bit more self-selected as opposed to the random

0:23:19 survey at the beginning. The results of this, I think, are very important and very impressive.

0:23:27 If you look at the random respondents, between quarters of them, and almost 90% of those in the

0:23:34 Open Survey identified a community center, a community recreation center as an important

0:23:39 priority for the city. And more importantly than that, when asked a question about an increase

0:23:46 in taxes as a potential method to pay for this, two-thirds of the random respondents and three

0:23:52 quarters of those in the open survey responded that they would be willing to entertain a tax

0:23:58 increase as a mechanism to pay for this. Now let's parse what that means. Not only is this

0:24:04 It's a good idea, you know, as somebody who's responding to the survey, but these are people

0:24:09 who are voting with their wallet.

0:24:12 They have said that this is something that they are willing to pursue, and that's an

0:24:17 extra step beyond, hey, you know, madam, on the street, would you like to do this, well,

0:24:22 of course I would.

0:24:24 This is kind of where the rubber meets the road.

0:24:27 There was another part of the survey that I think is important, that was looking at particular

0:24:30 amenities that might be included in it.

0:24:33 and that to Brian to discuss.

0:24:36 Thank you again.

0:24:37 So this is obviously informative as well as one

0:24:43 of the other angles that was taken

0:24:44 to get more of the information we needed to take one space

0:24:49 as we felt needed to be in the Rep Center.

0:24:52 You can see, not off-receive, some of these amenities

0:24:56 that people wanted out.

0:24:57 Keep in mind the goal that I talked about earlier

0:24:59 was for full-cost recovery.

0:25:02 So it wasn't enough just to say this is what everybody wanted.

0:25:05 we wanted to pair that with expert consultants that have done this before

0:25:09 and determine how are these amenities that our community wants to see in the

0:25:15 rec center, going to match up with cost recovery. And so you can see on here an

0:25:21 indoor lab pool was the top choice and that most of these on the dotocracy aligned

0:25:26 with some of the other results that we saw. So here we have a survey identified

0:25:33 priorities for these amenities and as we can see here on the screen it's

0:25:37 really blurred hard to see this graphic but this is what we're looking at in order

0:25:42 to figure out what these amenities are and then we consulted with experts that

0:25:47 have done rec centers and and determined like how are these a cost

0:25:51 recovery so the next the next slide really just gives a visual for the

0:25:58 different slivers and angles that we took to make sure that we're representing our

0:26:01 community, make sure that we're representing the experts, all that we can to get our final

0:26:07 recommendations for the Rec Center.

0:26:10 Our division statement is a big one we want more than just for athletics.

0:26:16 The cost-recover efficacy, the comment cards that Chris had mentioned briefly in the survey

0:26:21 results, the dot-op or C, and then, as we've mentioned many times in the committee and the

0:26:26 consult expertise.

0:26:27 So ultimately, we came up with this list of recommended spaces that included all the

0:26:33 those factors and again I could read through each of these but you can see this list

0:26:39 breaks together our goal and the vision for those recommended spaces. I'll let

0:26:47 Chris speak a little bit more to this from this slide is some of these are no

0:26:56 brainers you have a rexner you have to have a lobby if you have a gym you have to

0:27:00 have a locker room but look at the rest of them this is not a barn with a hardwood

0:27:05 floor this is a community center there's a couple of different studio spaces

0:27:09 studio spaces can be for aerobics, they can be for fitness for seniors, they can be for

0:27:13 spinning classes, they can be for acting classes.

0:27:16 This is not limited to 12 year olds bouncing some sort of a ball.

0:27:21 We're very specifically looking at putting parts of this together.

0:27:26 That might not have been my vision, but are things that when working with our experts have

0:27:31 been shown in their experience to increase revenue to make this a self-supporting adventure.

0:27:39 Now, let's talk a little bit about the cost, and I'm going to tell you that there are 10,000

0:27:44 asterisks on this slide.

0:27:47 In 2019, when we got to essentially a bubble diagram that had everything that was mentioned

0:27:53 on the last slide, we looked at a rough estimation of cost.

0:27:57 The rough estimation of cost is $41 million.

0:28:00 What does that include?

0:28:01 It includes everything but ground.

0:28:04 That is, their ideas start to finish, plus a fairly healthy fudge factor to make certain

0:28:09 there aren't cost overruns.

0:28:11 but that does not include land acquisition.

0:28:13 Now, the reason they're asked to risk on this,

0:28:16 a couple of big things, number one,

0:28:18 who's done in 2019, some things are a little more expensive,

0:28:21 some are a lot more expensive, some are cheaper,

0:28:23 but it's all different.

0:28:24 So I would use that as kind of a,

0:28:27 or in the wind rather than a specific number.

0:28:32 What we're talking about tonight,

0:28:34 we understand as a committee that the specific details

0:28:38 of the Rec Center are not going to be made

0:28:42 until we have a location.

0:28:45 If there is a spot that is conducive,

0:28:48 has a wonderful view, we want to take advantage of that.

0:28:51 That may change how many classrooms

0:28:52 we got by many committee rooms we have.

0:28:54 If there's not, that may change things.

0:28:56 So that's really the biggest asterisk on us.

0:28:59 But this at least gives an idea.

0:29:02 So let's talk about our committee progress.

0:29:04 Wendy showed that four step process

0:29:07 that we presented to the city council earlier.

0:29:10 There's step one done.

0:29:11 We came back and said we're done with step one.

0:29:13 Do we have permission to go to step two?

0:29:15 We do.

0:29:16 So we've gone through our space list.

0:29:18 We've gone through a business plan.

0:29:19 We went through criteria for selecting a site,

0:29:21 which I'll address here in just a second.

0:29:23 And importantly, we took the next step to try to look at

0:29:27 specific property acquisition, came to council,

0:29:31 and did receive permission in 2019 to negotiate with a landowner.

0:29:37 Now it didn't work out.

0:29:38 Landowner didn't want to sell, but that's okay.

0:29:41 But what I want to make, what we're trying to do is because there was that little two-year

0:29:52 hiccup that everybody survived and a reset and get a chance to do this again.

0:30:02 It was never the case that committee members were driving around to involves seeing empty

0:30:06 fields and saying, I want that or I want this.

0:30:09 We set up a process to try to identify in screen various sites and this is the list and

0:30:16 this is ranked in order.

0:30:17 I'm not going to go through each and every one.

0:30:20 If you take a look at those top two or three, this is designed with an eye towards being able to make the self-supporting.

0:30:28 It's also designed with the understanding that not only is this facility going to change to

0:30:34 and falls red large, but it is going to make an impact on wherever it goes.

0:30:38 It would be that downtown, old town, the north end, just wherever it may be.

0:30:43 It is going to impact the neighborhood as well and the people who live there.

0:30:46 So this is every hypothetically we screened with this and we probably at least discussed

0:30:57 to something like that potential sites and evaluated all of them with us.

0:31:05 So step two is partially completed.

0:31:08 We've got the business plan, we've got space verification and now we're stuck.

0:31:14 And the reason we're stuck is to be able to actually sell a finished product.

0:31:18 I need to be able to give you details.

0:31:21 I can't give you details until we've got a spot where we can put this because the place

0:31:29 where we put the Rec Center is going to change the facility itself.

0:31:33 So a circle going, we get a site located and get sort of funding options more fleshed out.

0:31:48 We can get more public input when we can give them a specific project to say thumbs up or

0:31:53 them down. And importantly, first step two is done. Our next responsibility is to come back

0:31:59 to you and say, okay, we have step two done. Now we're here and then we can. So, and this

0:32:09 is step three and we're a little ways away from this. I just wanted to make sure it's

0:32:12 there. The conclusion is important. That's the step that I'm looking forward to where

0:32:16 we can come and say, and council, we've done it. Here's the feasibility study, but we've

0:32:24 got some work to do to get. So, out of the findings from everything that we've got, from

0:32:32 all the work that the committee that shows me that does support this, and has indicated

0:32:41 a willingness to help to pay for it. Working with our professional partners, we do believe

0:32:47 that this can be self-supporting, but we understand that without a site, this is still vapor.

0:32:55 It won't be able to give you specifics until we have a site to work with. So, in order to

0:33:00 We get to the end of our feasibility statement really to get to step 3.

0:33:04 We need a location.

0:33:07 Here's what I'm asking, and here's what I'm not.

0:33:09 I'm not asking for a check, I'm not asking for a number to say it will allocate, you know,

0:33:15 so many bazillion dollars to anything.

0:33:18 I'm asking for help, I'm asking for support, and be that and that the city already owns

0:33:24 or a land swap are working with urban renewal or buying property or whatever.

0:33:30 That's the support I'm with, well option, take a lot of the work that we've remains incomplete.

0:33:44 Project I support to keep it cool. Is there anything that we can answer any questions for Chris or Ryan or

0:33:55 That matter I'm excited

0:34:18 The slides step to progress how much time do you think it'll be between a site designation?

0:34:32 To finish out

0:34:35 That's actually that's a very good question because as soon as you could hand me the keys to the castle right now

0:34:44 The next step is to get to the North and PRS back here to walk it, say, here are the dimensions,

0:34:51 and then start the discussions on how to make specific changes that we would need to.

0:34:58 We have a bubble diagram right now, but that's a bubble diagram.

0:35:01 So I can't give you a very specific answer, sorry.

0:35:05 So in that meeting steps, you would go through another public input comment,

0:35:12 Another, this question was asked, obviously being new on the kid council, taxing districts, guys.

0:35:33 Yes.

0:35:34 Okay.

0:35:34 I would say that you guys thought it would look like, does this have the things you were hoping?

0:36:05 No, that's fair.

0:36:07 And one more question, sorry.

0:36:09 So, and this might go back to the feasibility study as well, Wendy.

0:36:13 Looking at, is that self-sufficient day one, or is there going to be a grace period that somebody is going to be on the hook?

0:36:21 Sometimes they pre-sell,

0:36:32 memberships and things to start building that,

0:36:35 base to start with,

0:36:38 but several facilities that have been self-supporting within less than a year.

0:36:41 I think there's to be a three or five year process,

0:36:45 and I think they hit self-supporting status within their first year.

0:36:49 Nice to see you guys again. I miss you.

0:37:01 The council members and surveys mentioned.

0:37:37 So I...

0:37:47 Alex, come on.

0:38:35 Such as, for example.

0:39:15 I'm finishing some sort of a site to be deterred programs, spaces that are dependent on location.

0:40:21 So if we selected a hypothetical location, which was a conversation we had with BRS at one point.

0:40:29 If we say, gosh, someday if we ever get a space to do this, it's ready to go.

0:40:57 And this is what it's going to look like.

0:40:59 So we haven't...

0:41:01 So my thought on what you're asking is either...

0:41:05 Is it burnt to be hypothetical? I would say probably not.

0:41:08 does it work to maybe go take a look at some of our spaces to see if any of them we want to

0:41:14 educate to a recreation center? I don't know if we really ever seriously consider that. There is

0:41:21 one space that the city mostly owns up 13 if you understand correct. Oh this package is going to be

0:42:26 put together. They're asking us to either support them moving form on the rest of step two

0:42:33 or just to say, you're done, okay, thank you for your work.

0:42:38 So we're not going deep into costs or what piece of land we've got or how much we're spending.

0:42:44 I just want to make that clear, we're just here to say, yes please go forward, pursue it, or you're done.

0:42:52 And if I might, at that time we will be back in front of council for those very questions to be debated and answered.

0:43:01 So that's where this is not a...

0:43:04 We're not asking us for any money.

0:43:08 It's just permission to move forward.

0:43:12 And we asked, just so you know, back in 17,

0:43:15 we asked for periodic check-ins

0:43:18 to where we make sure that they agreed to do

0:43:27 your hiatus.

0:43:35 They were right on track for what they said they were gonna do.

0:43:37 Yes, we support you. It's probably going to set the committee up.

0:43:47 So we'll support probably two locations,

0:44:02 whether we find our options,

0:44:08 a conversation right now in the near future.

0:44:14 So I think you can't just be simply a gosh we think this is right but you're not asking

0:44:30 Council to go find the land. No, no, okay. That's kind of right. Yeah. I just wanted to reinforce if I'm asked you what when you were saying an ad

0:44:40 that of those criteria that we used to select the space we did have a lot of

0:44:46 different land pieces that we were looking at some included city own and

0:44:51 Some did not interested to it. If we were to get council support to purchase a piece of land that would represent what we wanted the rec center to be built upon, basically a contingency if you will of how that land could potentially be used as well as we understand that there's other steps to be done past that point.

0:45:17 And so that's one of the steps that we feel really responsible for as well, making sure that it's not just a land that now used for the city as well. If the steps don't proceed past there.

0:45:29 initial was approved as far as we know now there is no additional cost so we

0:47:04 haven't spent the entire we haven't spent all of it but I think it's what I was

0:47:08 starting to get to they think we may have spent more than half already although

0:47:13 Part of the work of Phase 2 still hasn't been built for.

0:47:17 Is it self-supported? Can you define self-supported?

0:47:38 So, it's for operations. Simple expectation is on paying that back.

0:48:01 While, since I've talked to Gary over in Jerome, but I believe,

0:48:07 do you remember, it seems like some of those that we went looked at in Denver,

0:48:15 they were able to pay their on-back and anticipated with me.

0:48:23 And so it tends to snowball and work well.

0:48:27 You know, you set expectations and goals,

0:48:34 and I've heard many stories about facilities

0:48:38 that exceeded those expectations,

0:48:40 and it happened in a much faster time.

0:48:43 So not only paying back what it cost to build it,

0:48:46 but also being able to start self-supporting,

0:48:50 and then setting aside cash reserves for upgrades

0:48:54 and things that need to happen moving from the secret sauce.

0:49:07 that your citizens want.

0:49:16 What we're discussing tonight is the feasibility study.

0:49:39 Comments that I've text and things like the ability study that still has two more steps.

0:49:56 Mechanism would be discussed as well, so we're still concerned.

0:50:08 Negative sessions where we come in and say, that's what we'd like to do.

0:50:54 So that we have what we need behind us to go into that negotiation.

0:50:58 And I appreciate that I don't want to set up the council to say,

0:51:02 the importance of our, what we're seeking at this support is more than just a battle.

0:51:17 Because I have a concern with that, what we're saying yes to, we're saying yes going look, but we're actually saying yes to money at some point in touch.

0:51:34 Travis, would you like to?

0:51:35 Yeah, so I don't know if that's a fair statement.

0:51:38 I'd be sure that because while there may be a property acquisition piece, there's also maybe the possibility that we can just existing property in the city.

0:52:07 has, but the committee is saying is if they do not also support, they're saying, because

0:52:29 if the next step is to acquire the land, the council needs to be able to support that

0:52:36 step.

0:52:37 Now remember, there are conversations of land acquisition that occur, there's negotiations

0:52:41 that occur.

0:53:37 You approach us with land, and it turned out it didn't give us really a sweetheart deal

0:53:47 because they were interested in the project succeeding.

0:53:51 So there is the possibility of land donation, there is the possibility of working with somebody

0:53:55 for naming rights.

0:54:03 There is a real possibility that at the end of this when we have found what we think is

0:54:07 the right spot and promise that that is absolutely a possibility.

0:54:14 In order to build it, revisited what some alternative funding options could be.

0:54:41 If the city can't provide the land anymore by the land and the resources of the discussion,

0:55:01 that conversation hasn't shifted.

0:55:03 possibly successful. Thank you board. There are a lot of sentiment about the desire for a

0:58:14 rec district but I always wonder if people start thinking realistically about cost,

0:58:18 you know where does that balance in the community? They see the need for the

0:58:26 community center versus cost that could come with it says a lot because we don't

0:58:49 know why for example if we have city on property land swap, buyers and if they

0:59:03 counsel supports this in concept, you know they may be willing to sell to talk

0:59:08 seriously about selling the price if they know that they're and that's just one

0:59:15 example when I say spending money I achieved skate but I forget that's okay

1:00:51 more expensive Spencer said we don't know what impossible to my concern

1:02:15 the city to a big financial decisions until we have also citizens of the city

1:02:33 of Twinfall so I am in favor of moving the feasibility study knowing that there

1:02:47 There are some caveats from my side of it, but I think it's important to collect the data.

1:02:52 And I'm just going to add, if we go back to the strategic plan, which Wendy started off with,

1:03:06 that we've been, this has been in the strategic plan for a long time, and I was involved back,

1:03:12 I'm going to guess it was 18 years ago in this, and so it's been talked about for a long time.

1:03:18 I personally support it moving to the next step.

1:03:22 You're not asking us to write a check. I know there's lots of nonprofits out there, foundations.

1:03:29 There's a lot of potential for partnerships, so I don't think we're looking at the city physically writing a bit of a check.

1:03:40 There's too many people that want to see this happen that would be willing to be involved, so I personally...

1:04:11 to have a second by Gockon second by Nicky Boyd to authorize moving forward on this feasibility

1:04:30 study and requesting the council support for continued work on the feasibility study.

1:04:36 Is there any further discussion? Anybody?

1:04:42 Yes. Yes. Yes.

1:04:57 Here's Reid. Thank you. Motion passes six to one.

1:05:04 Thank you, everyone. So we've got a couple other items on the agenda

1:05:13 I don't know that you all want to sit through that if we could take a two-minute break

1:05:18 Let you get out of here, and then we'll finish the rest margin. It's not big enough. Okay, so everybody's almost gone

1:06:44 So if somebody up there could shut the doors we'll move on to our next item

1:06:50 another action item the request to approve these of

1:06:54 $7,960 from contingent CFUNS to replace the distribution unit in the first floor HVAC

1:07:02 system and we have Mitch, our W.D. City Manager here to make a presentation. Welcome, Mitch.

1:07:10 Thank you. Prettion was going to be here to talk about this tonight but she couldn't make

1:07:15 it in today so I'm going to cover this for her. So don't ask me anything really hard.

1:07:20 So I was ready for this.

1:07:22 No, the request tonight is to use $7,960 of contingency money to replace an HVA distribution unit on the first floor, so make the ground for it.

1:07:36 There's $150,000 in the budget in contingency in this year's budget.

1:07:40 And we haven't, so this is the kind of thing that for several months this unit's been kind of high-pitched squeaking noise and it's failing.

1:07:52 We've had some people come out and look at it and they're like, yeah, that needs to be replaced.

1:07:57 So if we start today, because of the delivery of parts,

1:08:02 we're looking at probably early August before we can

1:08:05 actually get it done, and so the request is,

1:08:07 why don't we go ahead and get going on this,

1:08:11 use contingency money for it, we'll sign the contract,

1:08:14 and then we'll deal with our squeaky unit

1:08:16 for the next six or so months.

1:08:18 And so hopefully that answers

1:08:21 a lot of your questions if you have any more.

1:08:24 Chris, we did.

1:08:37 Five and a quarter issues, yeah.

1:08:51 Please, Chris, all right, I was, there was some feedback.

1:08:53 I know that we approve the use of $7,960 for contingency funds to replace a distribution

1:09:01 unit in the first floor HVAC system.

1:09:04 Thank you, Alex.

1:09:05 Come on.

1:09:06 I second that motion.

1:09:07 Thank you.

1:09:08 Motion by Christopher Reed.

1:09:09 Second by Alex.

1:09:10 Come on to approve the use of $7,960 from contingency funds to replace the distribution

1:09:17 unit on the first floor HVAC.

1:09:19 Amy Rokavo, please.

1:09:21 Yes.

1:09:28 Thank you motion passes seven to zero.

1:09:35 Thank you Mitch.

1:09:36 Next on the agenda is another action item.

1:09:43 A request to approve resolution number 2023-001 authorizing the destruction of records period.

1:09:53 Amy Luna, our administrative assistant.

1:09:58 Thank you Amy.

1:09:59 Good evening.

1:10:04 We can be for the council to destroy records that are no longer needed by the state code 50-907-B destroyed only by resolution of the city council and it applies to the city attorney which looks like everybody has a question. I'm just teasing. Not really.

1:10:43 Couldn't help it. You're looking so nervous.

1:10:47 I would welcome a motion for this unless anybody has any questions for me.

1:10:51 Craig Hawkins resolution cue Alex Kaval

1:11:09 I second the cue motion by Craig Hawkins second by Alex Kaval to approve resolution 2023-001

1:11:18 authorizing the destruction of records. Hi, roll call vote please.

1:11:24 Cruz Pierce? Yes. Cruz Reed? Yes. Nikki Boyd? Yes. Craig Hawkins? Yes. Jason Brown? Yes. Spencer Cutler? Yes. Alex Kaval? Yes.

1:11:34 Thank you motion passes seven to zero. Thank you, Amy. So that is all the items on the regular items on the agenda. We do have public hearings that are scheduled to start after this. But now is the time for general public input. If there's anybody in the community on the audience that wishes to come down and address City Council. Now is your time.

1:12:01 I've seen no one advisory board reports, a celebration coming up.

1:12:32 Flags are in half mass, yeah we got it. Anybody else down there?

1:12:38 I'm surprised that didn't garner any conversation.

1:12:43 So we had the Greater Twin Falls Transportation meeting last week,

1:12:50 week before, in disguise there were different traffic conversations.

1:12:57 branch is still part of the conversation. There's really nothing conclusive to add to that.

1:13:05 They're still looking at some funding opportunities and some different things and working through

1:13:09 the study. That's really all I have at this point. No confirmation on when they might be back to

1:13:17 talk to us? No, not right now. It appears that the funding source that they thought they might

1:13:24 be able to secure may not necessarily be there still and so they're still working through some

1:13:29 the state processes to interesting. Thank you. Chief.

1:13:35 Mayor, thank you. First of all, thank you. That's Travis.

1:13:48 So I just want to stand before you. Thank you to everyone of you.

1:13:59 On Wednesday, we had a call for service with the Sheriff's Office

1:14:32 at a state place. Responded post-hays to

1:14:38 the Canyon Ridge High School to take immediate action

1:14:41 and stop any, we also had our many partners from

1:14:50 of St. Luke's, obviously, the school district, specifically.

1:14:58 Lots of people try to determine,

1:15:20 committed this crime against our community.

1:15:22 Make no mistake, this was a crime against our community,

1:15:26 whether or not something of the best.

1:15:28 When he said this is actually terrorism,

1:15:30 and I stand by this act,

1:15:40 communities throughout this nation.

1:15:42 So, it was an act of international terrorism.

1:15:45 We will be working with our federal partners,

1:15:47 specifically the Federal Bureau of Investigations.

1:15:52 resolution and bring the people responsible to justice. We'll continue to learn from this event

1:15:59 and work with our partners to continue to have discussions. See age if and ready to especially

1:16:21 each of the most vulnerable citizens, those being our children.

1:17:25 I was the one who left the school, told Brizzy in responding, that no one thought about calling

1:17:44 school and she had no idea that it had been an incentive to lock somebody's sort of

1:18:10 It's an interesting, I would say that...

1:18:37 Chief, I actually want to give a shout out to Jonathan because he had a lee URA meeting, and he was like 8th in line, so did a good job on Wednesday.

1:19:29 Okay, so anything from the city manager's office, Mitch.

1:19:36 But Shane's going to talk 0-0-3 in our first one of the year.

1:19:55 I believe it's...

1:20:03 ...a motion...

1:20:13 ...a solution number...

1:20:15 ...a new second in Alex.

1:20:19 It's like a key motion by Craig Hawkins second in bi.

1:20:24 I'll ask of all to amend the motion to read resolution number 2023 dash zero zero three

1:20:31 authorizing the destruction of records

1:20:34 Amy roll call vote

1:20:38 Yes

1:20:44 Thank you motion passes seven to zero. Thank you Shane

1:20:52 So that is all the items next are probably two public hearings

1:20:59 Before we move on to the

1:21:02 Take a five minute break you good. Okay, so we'll move on

1:21:07 public hearing is an action item.

1:21:17 Request for annexation with the zoning designation of C1

1:21:21 for property located at 1881.

1:21:23 The line wrote east care of EHM engineers on

1:21:28 engineers on behalf of J Foundation LLC.

1:21:33 Before we get started, I'm going to go ahead and read the rules.

1:21:39 were to follow these steps under the public hearing portion of the agenda. City staff will present the request and analysis. The applicant will then present their request. The council will then ask questions of the applicant or staff. After questions have been asked, the public hearing will be opened during that time. Anyone in attendance is given the opportunity to comment or ask questions about the request being considered.

1:22:07 If you are giving testimony, please step up to the podium, state your name and address and present your comments or concerns.

1:22:15 After giving testimony, please sign the public, sign in sheet which is up in the lobby with your name and address for the record.

1:22:23 Once public comments are concluded, the applicant will be invited to answer any questions and make a closing statement.

1:22:30 the statement, staff will then answer, clarify any comments as needed after those statements,

1:22:36 the public hearing will be closed, and then the council will have an open discussion and

1:22:42 take action.

1:22:43 So, Jonathan Spennlev, Penny and Zoning Director, welcome.

1:22:50 This item, request for annexation of the properties outlined recently hold real things, including

1:23:08 A and some other properties, he said to look this rectangular shape for quite a while,

1:23:18 Is outside city limits the property immediate east is also outside the limits.

1:23:24 I'm going to rest for around it is inside city limits.

1:23:31 Requested annexation various reasons one of which is potential expansion size.

1:23:53 This item did go.

1:24:42 Any questions for John is a zone.

1:24:54 It is only there's outside city limits that are typically for one acre larger residential.

1:25:06 but it is a residential designation.

1:25:08 At was zoned, S-U-I to blast round elements

1:25:20 that Jason too, as well as usually reserved

1:25:26 for one acre or larger, with well-acceptance.

1:25:29 Any other questions for Jonathan before we call up the outcome?

1:25:34 Welcome, Terrell.

1:25:48 My name is Terrell Barnes, representing the J Foundation

1:25:52 on the J Foundation.

1:25:54 The J Foundation was in the county requesting

1:26:12 to deny a sample annexation as a C-1 property.

1:26:17 First of all, counseling for the C-1 of the facility through the city.

1:27:13 Years ago we had been at the county, glad to be working with the city.

1:27:35 Staffs have been very cooperative on working with us on this.

1:27:39 So we simply ask for your approval and annexation.

1:27:59 But almost totally sure on our city, the neighbors asked for the zoning in this area.

1:28:46 Anybody have any questions for Gerald?

1:28:48 Before he sits down, Alex?

1:28:52 How does the C-1 designation fit in out there?

1:28:56 The C-1, North, one step to the C-1's and it's a comprehensive plan.

1:29:07 The C-1 activity primarily with the real deals and the office facility, the only difference now.

1:29:19 We will incorporate into counseling and some physical therapy and other care all fit.

1:29:38 Okay, so next we'll be, we'll open up the public hearing and again, if you wish to comment, please step up to the podium, state your name and address, present your comments and you will have two minutes.

1:29:57 So I officially open the public hearing.

1:30:01 Is there anybody in the public that wishes to come down and address City Council? Oh, close the public hearing.

1:30:15 I don't know that we need a closing statement.

1:30:19 Gerald, any other comments from you, Jonathan?

1:30:24 Okay, so, Council discussion.

1:30:27 Anybody wish to ask any questions?

1:30:31 Make a motion.

1:30:32 Go ahead, Jason.

1:30:34 Move to approve the annexation with a zoning designation of C1.

1:30:44 Thank you, Alex Gavall.

1:30:45 I second that.

1:30:46 Thank you.

1:30:47 Motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Alex Gavall to approve.

1:30:51 The request for annexation of property located at 1881 Poline Road East with a zoning designation of C1. Any further discussion?

1:31:03 Amy Rokoffo, please.

1:31:05 Yes.

1:31:11 Yes.

1:31:12 Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. Thank you, Gerald.

1:31:21 Okay. So the next action item is public hearing or a request for zoning district change in zoning map amendment from C1.

1:31:33 PUD to R6-PRO for approximately 4 acres on property located at the 1900 block of Washington

1:31:41 Street North. EHM engineers, Inc. on behalf of Gerald Martin's. Jonathan Smith, welcome.

1:31:51 The Council of this property has a little bit more of a story to pass than the last one.

1:31:57 It is part of the North Ocean, but it's gone through many conditions that original PUD were

1:32:15 We're in Harrison, all the way down to UC out there today.

1:32:42 It's actually in the Duffer process that we're going through right now,

1:32:47 which is they rezoned the property where they went through a new process.

1:32:57 This is the original sub-uses that we're talking about is kind of the area.

1:33:06 In the region of what's here, this is rezoning the property out of this PUD.

1:33:22 Basically to just our base zoning code or six with the professional VISTA, PUD.

1:33:58 What they're talking about are these two properties, rezoning it from a C1 PUD designation to R6.

1:34:04 The R6 is a residential zone. It's written in city code. It allows for single-family

1:34:11 up there. It still does not have cloth as overlay, ask for through a special use permit process

1:34:42 to have a professional office like a dentist's office, medical office. In essence, what it

1:34:51 is doing is allowing the similar, there is some duplexes and trifort plexes over here

1:35:06 out the east. If you go further to the east, that's where river crest apartments are. This

1:35:12 This property is a little bit more restricted than that one is it's smaller, minimum sizes.

1:35:17 We'll kick into discussions with these.

1:35:24 There were some items in the original for not specific, but in general.

1:35:56 This area over here is a mixed use.

1:35:58 Retail office, restaurants, economy, councils, taxes, making a final decision on to do so.

1:36:34 R6.

1:36:35 The R6 actually limits it back down to 30.

1:37:08 It limits it to 35 as a maximum height.

1:37:10 Thank you, Jonathan. So now we'll hear from the applicants. Welcome again, Gerald.

1:37:36 Representing the Food Service. We, it is an essentially some professional offices, but

1:38:53 they get that conducive to, I think the city manager is new, everybody is new, except me.

1:39:38 Time to retire, Gerald?

1:39:42 It's time to retire, right?

1:39:44 So this is the last phase that you won't see me on this development again.

1:39:48 Okay, so if that's a reason to vote in favor, please do so.

1:39:53 Thank you.

1:39:56 But I'll be glad to answer any questions.

1:39:59 We do have no specific plans for the property.

1:40:03 We had people that are interested.

1:40:05 All of the interest is based upon residential.

1:40:09 There's been some interest on professional offices, especially this smaller parcel to the south.

1:40:15 Any questions for Gerald before he sits down?

1:40:59 Looks like you're off the hook.

1:41:01 Thank you.

1:41:02 Thank you, Gerald.

1:41:07 Next, we'll open up the public hearing if there's anybody out in the public that wishes to address City Council now is your time.

1:41:15 The no one concludes the public hearing.

1:41:23 Next, any other comments, Gerald?

1:41:26 Probably said your piece.

1:41:28 You good, Jonathan?

1:41:30 Okay, council wishes. Any discussion?

1:41:34 Emotion?

1:41:35 Key void.

1:41:41 For zoning is from C1.

1:42:01 Jason Brown?

1:42:02 I'll second that.

1:42:03 Thank you. Motion by Nicky Boyd. Seconded by Jason Brown to approve the zoning district.

1:42:08 Change in zoning map amendment from C1 PUD to R6PRO for four acres on property located in 1900.

1:42:16 Chris Reed.

1:42:19 Other questions or comments?

1:42:27 Let me roll call vote please.

1:42:30 Yes.

1:42:31 Yes.

1:42:36 Yes.

1:42:39 Thank you.

1:42:40 Motion passes 7-0.

1:42:41 Yes, Chris.

1:42:42 I just want to say that I'm excited.

1:42:44 Something's happening here for sidewalks.

1:42:46 I'm missing a huge junk there.

1:42:49 So we've discussed sidewalks in this community.

1:42:52 And always comes up.

1:42:53 So I'm excited.

1:42:54 Something's moving forward.

1:42:55 Potentially to have a sidewalk there.

1:42:57 Which if that means we have to have you come back?

1:43:06 Come back.

1:43:07 Thank you, Gerald.

1:43:09 Anything else, Jonathan?

1:43:13 Both of these items, um, councils, and anybody else, there will be a few more public hearings.

1:43:22 You won't see the public hearings in your planning. Both of the actions tonight will come back.

1:43:41 So, that's all on the agenda, so we are adjourned. Thank you all.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, February 27, 2023. The recording started at 16:29 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:43:50.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    97cb24c7338ecf6dfe8b647ecc36fc5d8b64d64a101d0c09e68185376d3a2b4b
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 1af2ce5b27e740fdca469ac63729e707a2dea40378662828ab3d575e584b17eb
    part02.m4a 2649c47a2c23ea2a6880b1c0a3748537b382b4e2ad340c9467b68b3d8e3b734b
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    b9acfe7f0b73bc70c8e30d7201194348668f9c256473bea6a05bae6af493fad4

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file