City Council meeting
Monday, April 3, 2023
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on fileMinutes on file
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:00:08 Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the April 3rd, 2023 City Council meeting.
0:00:15 I want to confirm we have a quorum. We have all seven members present in chambers tonight.
0:00:21 First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. If you wish to join me please rise.
0:00:45 I do have a proclamation tonight from the Office of the Mayor of the City of Twin Falls proclaiming
0:00:52 April 2023, College of Southern Idaho months, whereas the United States of America is served
0:01:00 by more than 1,300 community and technical colleges that have contributed significantly
0:01:06 to the richness and accessibility of American higher education, and whereas almost half of
0:01:11 all American college students are attending a community college to pursue skilled training,
0:01:17 career development, personal enrichment, or transfer preparation, and whereas the American
0:01:23 Community Colleges provide educational opportunities at costs and locations which support accessibility
0:01:30 while maintaining accredited quality instruction and whereas the College of Southern Idaho has
0:01:37 served the Magic Valley and the State of Idaho well since its inception and has been recognized
0:01:43 for its excellence within the state, region and nation, and whereas the College of Southern
0:01:48 Idaho has transformed the economic landscape of a service region, the Magic Valley by developing
0:01:54 education, economic and workforce developed seeking to assure a qualified workforce for
0:02:01 the region and throughout the state of Idaho, and whereas the College enriches the region
0:02:06 through community education, fine arts and athletic events which provide engagement opportunities
0:02:12 for its students and regional residents, whereas the college was created by the vote of the
0:02:18 citizens of the county of Twin Falls and Jerome, counties of Twin Falls and Jerome and the
0:02:23 college open on September 1, 1965, and whereas the college continues to serve the region's
0:02:30 residents with the state of the art programs and services, whereas the American Association
0:02:38 of Community College and the Association of Community College Trustees recognizes April
0:02:44 each year as Community College Month and encourages its national recognition.
0:02:51 Now therefore, I would be the Mayor of the City of Twin Falls.
0:02:55 Do hereby proclaim April 2023, College of Southern Idaho Month throughout the City of
0:03:02 Twin Falls, and urge all citizens to recognize this observation, observance, and I think we
0:03:10 have actually three members of the board here. Anna, I've got to sign this really quick, sorry.
0:03:19 Anna's goals, Jan, mid-lighter, and Scott McClure, so I don't know if you guys want to
0:03:24 be down in front of me.
0:03:25 Well, on behalf of the colleges of Southern Idaho, we are so appreciative of this recognition,
0:04:06 We have had a very long history.
0:04:09 I know that because I've been attached to the college
0:04:11 for decades and I'm very pleased to continue
0:04:15 in some kind of connection to the college at this point.
0:04:18 And I do know that throughout the night since 1965,
0:04:22 that the city has been a very important partner
0:04:24 to the college and we look forward
0:04:26 to more wonderful opportunities working together
0:04:29 to make the Magic Valley even better than it is.
0:04:32 So thank you so very much.
0:04:34 Thank you, Jan.
0:04:34 Thank you, everyone.
0:04:37 Okay, next on the agenda is the consent calendar.
0:04:41 Council wishes.
0:04:42 Kelly, I'm not seeing the details flip up.
0:04:46 I don't know if you have.
0:04:49 I can recognize who's asking to speak.
0:04:58 It's never stopped me before, so I don't think I'm good.
0:05:02 I move to approve the consent calendar.
0:05:04 Thank you, do I have a second?
0:05:05 Thank you.
0:05:06 Motion by Jason Brown, second invite Nikki Boyd
0:05:09 to approve the consent calendar as written.
0:05:14 Thank you, Mr. Kelly, roll call vote please.
0:05:23 Ruth Pierce.
0:05:24 Yes.
0:05:25 Jason Brown.
0:05:26 Yes.
0:05:27 Thank you, boy.
0:05:28 Yes.
0:05:29 Ells Kamal.
0:05:30 Yes.
0:05:31 Chris Reed.
0:05:33 Yes.
0:05:34 Hunter Cutler.
0:05:35 Yes.
0:05:36 Greg Hawkins.
0:05:37 Yes.
0:05:38 Thank you, motion passes seven to zero.
0:05:40 Yeah, you got it.
0:05:43 Okay.
0:05:44 Next under items of consideration, the first item is an action item to request to enter into negotiations
0:05:52 with downtown or to serve as the operator of the microtransit system in Twin Falls and
0:05:58 tonight we have Sean Beriger, our economic development director, welcome Sean.
0:06:03 Thank you, Mayor and Council.
0:06:04 I'm stepping in for Mandy this evening, who is out here today.
0:06:09 So back in November of 22, the Council approved a funding agreement between the City of Twin
0:06:15 Falls and the Idaho Transportation Department, the amount of $3 million dollars.
0:06:19 Those funds were approved for the operation to be turned key micro-transit system in Twin
0:06:24 Falls.
0:06:25 A request for proposals seeking proposals from vendors interested in operating the micro-transit
0:06:31 system was released on December 2nd and closed on January 20th of this year.
0:06:37 Three proposals were submitted on a team of six that included four staff members and two
0:06:42 members of the council evaluated the proposals against the criteria outlined in the RFP.
0:06:49 But the three proposals submitted to were selected to participate in an in-person interview based
0:06:54 on the initial scoring.
0:06:56 The two firms selected to interview were via an down-towner.
0:07:00 While both were qualified firms, the unanimous decision of the interview panel participating
0:07:05 in the selection process was to recommend down-towner to the city council as the top choice.
0:07:11 Down-towner impressed the panel with their approach to microtransit, their willingness
0:07:14 to be flexible in the implementation and deployment of the service.
0:07:19 The budget was clear and transparent, enabling the panel to fully understand the potential
0:07:23 costs of the system, what decisions would result in lower costs and also the trade off of those
0:07:28 choices, reducing service time, days of operation, number of vehicles deployed, etc.
0:07:34 The overall decision was that Downtowner would be an excellent partner with the city in this
0:07:38 new service area.
0:07:40 Downtowner is operating the pilot program in Idaho Falls and will be able to offer both
0:07:44 a local manager as well as regional support.
0:07:48 upon approval staff will enter into contract negotiations with downtown
0:07:53 based upon the information provided in their proposal and once that contract
0:07:57 has been reviewed by the city attorney it would be brought back to the city
0:08:00 council or approval so staff recommends that the council approve the recommendation
0:08:06 of the selection committee to enter into negotiations with downtown or to serve
0:08:11 as the operator of the microtransit system in Twin Falls. I'm happy to my best to
0:08:16 to answer any questions. Any questions for Sean? Look, the two council members that served
0:08:23 were Jason and Alex, do either of you have any comments, Jason? I jumped in. I, you know,
0:08:29 it was an interesting process to go through, to be a part of it and listen to both presenters
0:08:36 via downtown are both are good reputable companies. But it was clear, at least from
0:08:42 my standpoint that downtown are probably more of who we were looking for and considering
0:08:47 in this option because of some of the really the flexibility that we could see in their proposals.
0:08:54 The one thing that I would add, originally when I went into that, into the interviews originally my
0:09:01 favorite one was via the bigger one. So, via the bigger one downtown or is the smaller one.
0:09:06 And my opinion on them flipped during the interviews and the reason for that was the proposals on
0:09:15 paper via is more of a adopts more of the bus stop route approach, which I don't think
0:09:22 is a good down towner, is more of a curb to account the population that's likely to use
0:09:39 it, disabled folks, I think that is a better fit for Twin Falls compared to more of a fixed
0:09:47 route. Go walk 300 meters to whatever this virtual bus stop is. And so that one along on
0:10:00 the top of it's made, this came across more as a partner willing to take our consideration
0:10:09 versus, you know, this is what we think is best for you based on our knowledge of the
0:10:17 stones and so, owner is a great fit for Twin Falls isn't that fit.
0:10:24 Any questions for Sean or Alex or Jason?
0:10:38 I would answer the question we keep getting is when is it going to be up and running?
0:10:43 That was my question timeline.
0:10:45 So I would note that the proposals have an 8-10 week window from the time that I was in the contract assigned to the council until launch.
0:10:58 So depending on how long it takes to negotiate that contract consideration, I will see this summer.
0:11:07 Thank you.
0:11:08 Summer is coming.
0:11:09 Summer is coming. I heard like next Friday.
0:11:11 Okay, well then I...
0:11:14 Chris Reed.
0:11:15 Yes?
0:11:17 Yes, thank you.
0:11:18 Talk also, uh, who that we enter to negotiations with downtown are to serve as the operator
0:11:25 of the microtransit system in Twin Falls.
0:11:27 Thank you, Craig Hawkins.
0:11:29 I'll second it.
0:11:30 Thank you, Emotion by Christopher Reed, seconded by Craig Hawkins, to enter negotiations with
0:11:36 downtown are to serve as the operator of the microtransit system in Twin Falls.
0:11:42 Kelly, roll call, vote please.
0:11:44 Alex Gavall?
0:11:45 Yes.
0:11:46 Spencer Keller?
0:11:47 Yes.
0:11:48 Yes.
0:11:49 Greg Hawkins.
0:11:50 Yes.
0:11:51 Nicki Boyd.
0:11:52 Yes.
0:11:53 Chris Reed.
0:11:54 Yes.
0:11:55 Mayor Pierce.
0:11:56 Yes.
0:11:57 Motion passes 7-0.
0:11:59 Thank you, Sean.
0:12:00 Okay.
0:12:01 Next on the agenda is also an action item.
0:12:03 It's a request to adopt Ordinance 2023-005 for the rezoning of property located at the 1900
0:12:11 block of Washington Street North PZ22-0165.
0:12:17 We have Jonathan's been love our planning and zoning director.
0:12:21 Welcome, Jonathan.
0:12:24 So this is an ordinance.
0:12:28 I will note the numbers for the next two items.
0:12:31 All four ones of five to bring your attention to it.
0:12:34 These are the good numbers that are showing up on the screen.
0:12:37 Thank you.
0:12:37 As ordinance resolutions are two different systems.
0:12:40 This ordinance is the final action for the reason
0:12:43 on the property north and Washington Street.
0:12:48 What will be a gem school that's being constructed now,
0:12:52 north of Walgreens, the dates that it went to,
0:12:57 the planning of zoning commission,
0:12:58 and speak counselor in the ordinances of January,
0:13:01 and February respectively, we've prepared the ordinance
0:13:05 for your adoption.
0:13:06 If you wish to adopt it tonight,
0:13:07 it would need to go through the dispensing
0:13:10 of the third and final rules which are in our packet.
0:13:18 Thank you, any questions for Jonathan?
0:13:23 I don't see any someone would like to make motion.
0:13:34 I would like to move that we dispense with the reading of the rules in place orders 2023-005 on 3rd and final reading.
0:13:44 By title only.
0:13:46 By title only.
0:13:47 Thank you.
0:13:48 Is there a second?
0:13:49 Second.
0:13:50 Thank you motion by Craig Hawkins second by Christopher Reed to dispense with the rules with reading the rules in place ordinance 2023-005 on 3rd and final reading by title only.
0:14:03 Any further discussion?
0:14:06 Kelly Row, call vote, please.
0:14:08 Nikki Boyd?
0:14:09 Yes.
0:14:10 Craig Hawkins?
0:14:11 Yes.
0:14:12 Jason Brown?
0:14:13 Yes.
0:14:14 Christopher Reed?
0:14:15 Yes.
0:14:16 Mayor Pierce?
0:14:17 Yes.
0:14:18 Councillor Cutler?
0:14:19 Yes.
0:14:20 Alex Kaval?
0:14:21 Yes.
0:14:22 Thank you.
0:14:23 Motion passes seven to zero.
0:14:24 So I will read the ordinance.
0:14:26 Ordinance number 2023-005.
0:14:28 The city council of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho, rezoning certain real property below
0:14:36 describe providing the zoning classification therefore and ordering the necessary area of
0:14:42 impact and zoning district's map amendment.
0:14:47 Nikki Boyd.
0:14:48 We adopt ordinance 20 3-0-0-5.
0:14:51 Thank you, Craig Hawkins.
0:14:55 Thank you. Motion by Nicky Boyd, seconded by Craig Hawkins to adopt Ordinance 2023-005
0:15:03 for the rezoning of property located at the 1900 block of Washington Street North.
0:15:08 Kelly Roquevo, please.
0:15:11 Greg Hawkins.
0:15:12 Yes.
0:15:13 Jason Brown.
0:15:14 Yes.
0:15:15 Nicky Boyd.
0:15:16 Yes.
0:15:17 Alex Kollong.
0:15:18 Yes.
0:15:19 Mayor Pierce.
0:15:20 Yes.
0:15:21 Spencer Cutler.
0:15:22 Yes.
0:15:23 Christopher Reed.
0:15:24 Yes.
0:15:26 Okay, next again is an action item with Jonathan,
0:15:30 a request to approve and adopt resolution 2023-004,
0:15:36 updates to master fee schedule.
0:15:40 Mayor, members of the council, we have conducted
0:15:42 a few things with the fees.
0:15:45 This is dealing with the impact fees
0:15:47 and the creation of the new fee for the historic property.
0:15:50 We did not have those amounts that night.
0:15:53 There'll be presumptuous during the discussion you have,
0:15:55 we've created this and put it through the notifications of the paper has
0:16:00 required and the resolution is ready for you.
0:16:04 It is below. Prove it as a. Any questions for Chris Reed? Any feedback? Any comments?
0:16:16 Anybody in the public to you? I have received no feedback from anybody in the
0:16:20 public since the public hearing night. Ocean, this isn't
0:16:28 third and final, is it? No. No, just resolution so. To approve and adopt
0:16:34 resolution 2023. That's 0.04 updates to the Master Fee
0:16:39 schedule. Thank you, Alex. Thank you. Motion by Christopher Reed, second by Alex
0:16:45 Koval to approve and adopt resolution 2023-00 or update some master fees
0:16:54 schedule. Kelly Rokov, please. Alex Koval? Yes. Mr. Cutler? No. Mayor Pierce? Yes.
0:17:06 Christopher Reed? Yes. Nicky Boyd? No. Craig Hawkins? Yes. Jason Brown? Yes.
0:17:12 Thank you. Motion passes 5 to 2. Thank you, Jonathan.
0:17:19 Okay. Next item on the agenda is an action item, a request approval of 300,000 for purchasing a mobile air scrubber and continued support from consular engineering for an order control study through the end of the current fiscal year.
0:17:38 Nathan Erickson, the city environmental manager. Welcome, Nathan.
0:17:45 Thank you, Mayor, Council members, I appreciate your time today.
0:17:56 As you can see, we're here today to talk about
0:18:01 the order issues within the City of Twin Falls.
0:18:03 I'm not sure about you.
0:18:04 The orders within the City of Twin Falls.
0:18:15 And, you know, the City of Twin Falls has been working with
0:18:21 Con store engineering since 2017 on an order study.
0:18:26 The orders within the City of Twin Falls go back longer than
0:18:29 that over the years the city has done things and population has changed, the area of the city has changed,
0:18:40 where citizens are building this change, so it's changed a little bit over time,
0:18:45 but over the last six years, consort, engineering has been working with City of Twin Falls to better understand
0:18:50 what is going on with our orders, and Twin Falls is not unlike a lot of cities that have odor issues,
0:18:58 But each city is unique and we want to recognize that and we want to ensure that we address
0:19:03 the specific odors for the City Twin Falls.
0:19:11 So the objective of this study and for this last year has been to better understand the
0:19:18 causes of sewer odor, the magnitude odor, the areas of odor generation and feasibility
0:19:25 of different mitigation methods.
0:19:29 And like I said, it's been studied for the last six years.
0:19:33 And in last year, we were a little more focused
0:19:36 on our efforts.
0:19:37 And so tonight, we're going to try and share with you,
0:19:41 I guess, what we learned and some of the next steps
0:19:47 in the package that was provided to you, the report,
0:19:49 is what we were able to study in 2020,
0:19:53 the appendix, which is rather large,
0:19:55 is the past five years prior to that.
0:19:58 So you know.
0:20:01 So the priority in studying orders for the city is primarily the health and safety of our citizens.
0:20:09 We want to make sure that their quality of life is protected as our main object.
0:20:18 We also have to make sure that we maintain integrity in animals in the sewer system.
0:20:25 That's something that we don't usually or don't have to talk about because the odors
0:20:29 are usually the first indicator, but once owners are resolved, they're still, we still
0:20:36 have to make sure that the system is at a level that's manageable and protected.
0:20:43 So in this, the citizens of Twin Falls are a significant partner for our efforts.
0:20:52 The city has a link on our homepage right here that allows, gives the citizens an opportunity
0:21:01 to provide us feedback or report when there's an odors.
0:21:05 So if you look on this slide on the left side,
0:21:09 that bottom icon on our homepage,
0:21:11 that is a nose with some odors.
0:21:13 And when you click on that, you can go in,
0:21:16 fill out, it actually prompts you to provide
0:21:18 the information that will help us understand
0:21:20 where, what you're smelling in other parameters
0:21:25 that help us to catalog and then use that as a data point.
0:21:29 And that is extremely helpful in addressing these qualities, or these priorities.
0:21:36 And so, over the last year, we've had approximately 125 odor complaints in the city.
0:21:43 Now, we recognize that the surge dinks.
0:21:48 If we were to go out and pop a manhole right now and stuck our nose down there, it's going to smell, okay?
0:21:52 So, that's understandable.
0:21:54 But what is not acceptable is when that odor comes out into the community and makes it so that citizens
0:22:01 have to experience it at an unacceptable level.
0:22:08 When we see these complaints, I often, well,
0:22:13 if it's the first time I've heard from somebody,
0:22:16 I will call them up and let them know that we appreciate
0:22:21 their effort in helping us know where these odors are
0:22:25 and letting them know that it helps us to diagnose
0:22:28 and to address this problem.
0:22:30 And so, you know, we really appreciate the citizens as a, as a partner, and then also, and I mentioned
0:22:44 this already, the integrity of the manholes, even when the odor reports are gone, we need
0:22:49 to ensure that gases in the sewer are not damaging the manholes or the system.
0:22:56 Even when the odor reports go down to hopefully nothing at some point, it doesn't mean that
0:23:01 we're completely done with our work here.
0:23:06 So I'm going to explain the Twin Falls sewer system as kind of a big plot.
0:23:13 There's partners in this sewer system and when it's healthy, we all benefit from it.
0:23:23 We all contribute at varying levels and as I just mentioned, citizens are very helpful
0:23:31 in helping us to understand where we have water issues and so they can help by reporting
0:23:37 Businesses and industries can do their part by making sure that they're using their best management practices
0:23:43 with their waste and
0:23:46 Taking out things that they're able to prior to sending it to us
0:23:49 To reduce what we're having to deal with in our system and then tourism
0:23:53 I do that in there because we hope that as people this our city. They don't leave with a reminder of what it smells like
0:24:00 and I think that
0:24:02 We don't have an order that stays around all the time, it kind of comes and goes, seems
0:24:08 like.
0:24:09 And this last year, I think we have been able to get a better understanding of what some of
0:24:16 those causes are.
0:24:19 So now as you look at our sewer system, it's a very complex system, but there's no single
0:24:24 factor that controls all the odor.
0:24:26 So there's not a silver bullet that's going to solve all of our problems, and I want to
0:24:30 make that clear so that, you know, we understand that we've got to look at this as the whole
0:24:37 system and take at pieces at a time.
0:24:42 This last year we were focused on hydrogen sulfide, which here in a moment I'll turn the
0:24:45 time over to our consultant, Neil.
0:24:47 A little more technical background on that, which as we tested for it, both as a gas and
0:24:54 a liquid or a last year, you know, we found that it's not the only component that stinks
0:25:00 sensor and it's not the only source or there's not just one
0:25:06 sequel source of that hydrogen sulfide. We have identified some tools that
0:25:11 will share with you that help us to mitigate sulfide in our system but within
0:25:17 the system as you can see up on their hydrogen sulfide at one component you have
0:25:20 depth of flow, velocity, temperature, organic matter and sulfate
0:25:26 concentration, white sources, PH, chemistry, airflow, etc. These are all components that
0:25:33 play a factor in how the owners get out into the community.
0:25:38 So I just wanted to take a moment to say thank you to the people who did help on this project today.
0:25:56 I'm Mark Cummings, Craig Anderson. This is one of my co-workers, Nathan.
0:25:59 I'm a VTEC, Josh Baird, and two people formerly with the city, John Keaton and Jason Brown.
0:26:05 I've helped with this project over here.
0:26:08 I'll give a quick overview of the grantees sewer. A couple examples of those reports that were
0:26:15 for the city through the road or this morning on way to work.
0:26:21 A lot of it was very punchy. I had to bring the Sunday lunch from the Portion to the house.
0:26:27 Sewer on Cannon Railroad. Just a few. Within that reporting tool, this is an order wheel.
0:26:38 It just helps what they're smelling. So, if you look at number four and ten,
0:26:46 those sewage smell or the sulfur. So, reporting tool, the link is in there at the bottom.
0:27:01 So I'll give a little view of my Grandview sewer land.
0:27:15 The Grandview sewer flows from Washington down into the rock creek, near a green-belt pathway.
0:27:28 Pumped by the rock creek, lift station across to near the old hospital.
0:27:33 And from there it flows again by gravity to the wastewater treatment plant.
0:27:37 Mostly along Grandview and then Canyon Rim.
0:27:43 Washington here in the south, here's the golf course.
0:27:46 It isn't important sewer cooks and part of the trucks, excuse me, chunk of the system, part of the sewer.
0:28:01 The city has pretty much two large trunk lines I would consider.
0:28:05 It is five and a half miles long, cut in the area, described.
0:28:09 Pipes are 18 to 48 inches in diameter, so fairly good size for sewer line.
0:28:14 There are 103 manholes. Creek lift station is there.
0:28:20 There's an inverted siphon to go underneath.
0:28:22 I've got a schematic on the next slide that kind of shows that.
0:28:29 So we've got an upper area, and it flows the inverted siphon where it flows underneath the sewer,
0:28:37 and then back up, or beneath the creek, and then back,
0:28:41 the creek left station, comes in vertically up again, across.
0:28:49 But effectively there are evidence sewers.
0:28:53 That makes sense later, when it's an air flow dynamic,
0:28:58 air sampling that we've done in mannels,
0:29:09 because they are concrete structures.
0:29:10 The concrete can corrode.
0:29:12 So I've got a few pictures here,
0:29:13 a little hard to see on the screen up in front.
0:29:16 I'm not sure if they're more visible for you,
0:29:17 but the concrete on these does not look like concrete anymore.
0:29:22 And that's due to the presence of ice and sulfide
0:29:25 and bacteria that actually eat the hydrogen sulfide
0:29:29 and make sulfuric acid on the concrete walls,
0:29:32 it degrades the, also it degrades cast iron.
0:29:37 Most methyl lids are cast iron.
0:29:39 You'll have a picture there for some large looking holes.
0:29:43 Those are just due to corrosion, and the iron has rusted away,
0:29:48 but there's a lot of several metals that are in this condition.
0:29:53 Some metals on the line have been lined with us,
0:29:56 different minor systems to protect them, one is a polymer concrete that can't be corroded,
0:30:03 and then we're just traditional.
0:30:10 So I want to give a quick overview of the sheet class for hydrogen sulfide, just so everyone knew what that was.
0:30:15 So here hydrogen sulfide, drew the chemical structure and from the left side, is a colorless gas by the rotten eggs odor.
0:30:27 It can be smelled at 0.005 parts per million, which is really a very small concentration.
0:30:37 We are very good detectors of this.
0:30:39 Believe it or not, it's naturally occurring.
0:30:42 And our bodies actually can produce some
0:30:45 inside of our digestive system,
0:30:48 but our bodies have metabolism to deal with that.
0:30:56 So we can test by liquid phase testing
0:30:59 that we've done, so as grabbing a sample out of a sewer,
0:31:02 taking it to the lab and being able to report back,
0:31:05 they can tell us how much hydrogen sulfide is in sewer.
0:31:08 We can also test for it inside the mantle,
0:31:11 inside the air underneath the manhole and so the city owns several of these
0:31:15 photologers and those that have been deployed in the manholes over various
0:31:19 time periods to do the fussy grass of what that looks like here in the moment.
0:31:27 I wanted to go about, there is something called in-situ formation of
0:31:35 hydrogen sulfide in the original place. It is made in the sewer.
0:31:40 There's also presence of hydrogen sulfide in the sewer because it is charged straight to the sewer.
0:31:47 It is already formed, one formed in place, one formed before the sewer.
0:31:52 More distinct study results that we've seen.
0:32:00 We began in 2017 looking very high level holistically at the whole chunk line.
0:32:08 I want you to understand the areas of regeneration, high concentrations.
0:32:13 Really looking, yeah, the whole chunk line points where it was exiting the sewer so we can see where the sewer works.
0:32:25 Now we're focused progressively.
0:32:28 We've got a couple of graphs here.
0:32:34 These are two graphs, one, they both have the same y-axis, so the vertical axis is on the parts per million of hydrogen sulfide, and it's a scale of zero to one thousand.
0:32:47 The x-axis is, these both have pretty similar data, so one is in the streams higher up in the sewer line, in the near the sewer line.
0:33:02 on the graph on the left is the blue line,
0:33:04 which is the hydrogen sulfide is a lot higher.
0:33:07 There's a lot larger concentration of hydrogen sulfide.
0:33:15 Oftentimes if we're gonna see in situ formation in the sewer,
0:33:18 we would see a little bit downstream of the sewer,
0:33:23 so we'd have an opposite of what we observed.
0:33:27 So that was an interesting thing
0:33:28 that we saw somewhat early on in the study.
0:33:33 So again, higher concentration of the stream of the trunk.
0:33:37 Very, very well conditioned.
0:33:38 Sometimes you'll see where it's very repeatable, you kind of see the same pattern, same pattern.
0:33:45 But now in this case, when you saw a spike on an hydrogen sulfide concentration in the upstream area, we also saw it downstream.
0:33:56 All these things kind of pointed towards point sources as a source of hydrogen sulfide, not in situ, in sewer generation.
0:34:07 I did want to say though, there is some in sewer, I just hope I generate this, this is
0:34:16 over-logger data of a manhole that is quite in the far up-street reaches of the sewer and
0:34:22 you can barely see it because it's got the same y-axis scale as the two previous graphs.
0:34:26 You can see kind of repeating pattern back and forth, up and down, up and down, on the
0:34:30 low levels of, on average that was actually about, parts per million over the summer of
0:34:36 2022 months by next week looked at over the time also is some potential solutions
0:34:54 we've looked at some chemical treatments and tried some different chemicals to
0:34:58 treat some with different results some working some not working so well we've
0:35:05 looked at air scrubbers for the city that would be a pull the sewer out gases out
0:35:09 of the sewer treat them and then then discharge them above ground we've also
0:35:14 been looking at point source discharges project kind of it is at the next steps
0:35:25 things that we have seen, some point source management with point sources to reduce that,
0:35:36 a local limit, paper phase treatment, and the rehabilitation of manols are kind of the
0:35:41 four things that we see as things that we see could pursue in the future.
0:35:46 Point source management, I'll just read these to work with point sources to identify sources
0:35:52 of hydrogen sulfide and methods to resolve the contributions.
0:35:56 I want to highlight that some point sources have already switched chemicals that they've
0:36:02 used or are making changes to their system to address and control
0:36:06 hydrogens of that contribution to the collection system.
0:36:09 Local limits are a really more formalized source control.
0:36:17 There's a process to go through for that.
0:36:20 There's a study that would be done.
0:36:22 Things that are done would be to determine discharge limits,
0:36:26 sampling requirements, reporting values of the system,
0:36:31 fines for any other criteria that the city finds helpful
0:36:36 through that process or its enforcement of a local map.
0:36:46 You see that there's two steps for the summer of 2023.
0:36:50 I gave the both options there up on the screen.
0:36:54 The one option would be to get a rental trailer system
0:36:58 with a carbon odors scrubber.
0:37:00 So you pull the air out of the sewer,
0:37:02 treat it in the car through carbon that would just absorb
0:37:05 the hydrogen sulfide and then release it to the surface.
0:37:08 It would be about $225,000 or to purchase a trailer system with some other services to
0:37:19 go along with it, purchase and maintain and have this system than to rent it.
0:37:28 And then there's a long-term potential here in the step two, it would be a permanent distillation.
0:37:39 And that is depending on how far that needs to go, how many installations there are.
0:37:43 That's talking a lot of money in the $2.8 to $5.3 million.
0:37:48 That's one reason why we do think it's important to think through step one and make sure we're doing it right
0:37:53 On the high side, investments are for the sake of trying to replace men
0:38:27 And so, Zollas has been for his sake that there's a lot more to be done
0:38:40 And at a faster clip, hope you're in a placement
0:38:51 Man plays pipes, it's very similar to the insertion panels that can be inserted in the composite frame of plastic
0:39:09 Free in the cast iron frame, a mix of these things is going to be two to three million dollars
0:39:20 That's a significant, but what is our recommendation?
0:39:41 So I want to follow up with what we've learned over the last year.
0:40:13 We really want to continue to do this work and to partner with the citizens.
0:40:20 It's really critical.
0:40:21 I appreciate those that are here today and those that do let me know when there's an
0:40:27 order because that is very critical in our partnership in figuring this out and addressing
0:40:32 it.
0:40:33 But also I want to report on kind of what's been done or what's being done with several
0:40:39 of our resources as we have gone through this process and identified where some of these
0:40:45 hydrogen sulfide resources are.
0:40:48 We have monthly meetings to go over the data and identify what's the problem, and then it helps them take that and then go back and look at their processes and see what's going on.
0:40:59 And I will say that everyone is at the table right now. I think that's great. I'm optimistic anyways, but I feel like we are headed in a direction.
0:41:12 It's not as quick as I think we'd all like it to be. I will say that the lines of communication are open and constantly.
0:41:22 It's also important to recognize that over the past several years, we have had some point
0:41:32 sources change cleaning chemicals.
0:41:34 We've had two that have changed their cleaning chemical and that change in cleaning chemicals
0:41:39 showed a response immediately as far as what we were seeing in our system.
0:41:44 So that was a very positive result.
0:41:48 And then another one is that, you know, Mark mentioned that, you know, and then the report
0:41:55 if you read it, this last summer we partnered with a point source to do a chemical treatment
0:42:02 of the stream and they were very vested in time and money to make that happen.
0:42:09 We found that the results weren't what we were looking for, there were impacts down at
0:42:13 the wastewater treatment plant that were not favorable.
0:42:16 So that didn't work out, as we expected, but at least we know that we tried and were
0:42:21 able to direct our efforts somewhere else for phase now.
0:42:25 And we've also had other parts of town where last year some citizens were dealing with
0:42:34 some orders, and I didn't know about it until they were completely fed up with it.
0:42:40 And when they finally let us know, we were able to partner with one of our point sources
0:42:44 and they were able to dose the line with the chemical and they cleaned it up.
0:42:47 That's the last week when I talked to one of the homeowners, they said it's been great since, so
0:42:53 It's great when stuff like that works
0:42:55 and then also need to recognize that a lot of our point sources almost all of them have
0:43:05 pre-treatment facilities and that's where they're able to
0:43:09 invest and fine-tune and improve and make sure that those are functioning and taking a lot of these
0:43:17 causing it's out of the stream that gets to the city.
0:43:23 So we appreciate being able to work with them and
0:43:27 look forward to continuing to work with them. But I want to point out that
0:43:31 as we see results, that's great. But as a responsible city
0:43:35 we have to also have a contingency. And that's why the local limits
0:43:39 are. So if we were able to get to a point where we weren't able to get the results
0:43:43 into our system from, you know, the police versus the local limits
0:43:47 We are going to, I guess what we're asking for today is to continue to partner with consort to fund the study of the sewer, so that if we had to put a local limit, we would have the science to base that.
0:44:01 Because the last thing I want to do is come to council and not have something for you to actually make a good educated decision on.
0:44:07 And so today our request is to purchase for $150,000,
0:44:15 that mobile air scrober,
0:44:16 I think it's worth the investment to have,
0:44:19 so we can move it throughout the city
0:44:21 to undertake a phase of hydrogen sulfide,
0:44:26 and also $150,000 to continue to fund our study
0:44:30 with consort through the summer.
0:44:37 Any questions for Nathan?
0:44:48 So, is the source, am I supposed to understand
0:44:53 the source of the smell the citizens are experiencing is the manholes is that
0:44:58 is that where it's escaping from yes it's coming through the manholes okay and
0:45:06 can you explain to me the connection between the air scrubber what it's supposed
0:45:13 to do and how it's supposed to how does it work and what do you attach it to a
0:45:18 and then say, let's let the carbon do its thing, how does it work? Or how is it supposed to work in that process?
0:45:29 Yes, so what it is, it's actually very simple as far as how it's just a blower, so it's actually sucking the air.
0:45:36 So you hook a six inch hose to a manhole or some access to the sewer and it sucks the air out
0:45:44 And it's just a big bat of carbon bees that it blows it through, it's just a crimson car filter.
0:45:51 So it just blows it through the carbon and extracts the hydrogen sulfide.
0:45:56 And I can't imagine that we are the first city to have ever experienced this.
0:46:02 Has this been used elsewhere and has it been successful?
0:46:07 Yes. So, and when we talk about motor scrubbers, there's two classes, and actually the city already has one.
0:46:15 We have a, and I'm gonna let Mark kind of help me out on this if I say it wrong, but we have a wet media one that uses biological extract the odors, and that's down by the golf course in the canyon.
0:46:31 If you drive by the road there, there's actually an odors driver.
0:46:37 The reason that we're looking at a dry odors driver in this situation is because when you saw that graph, you saw a lot of spikes kind of sit down.
0:46:45 So, when you're treating hydrogen sulfide that's very variable, it has to be dry, or has to be done
0:46:54 through a dry scrubber because the biological one requires a constant source of hydrogen sulfide to keep it.
0:47:01 Welcome back to that slide that had those spikes. So, is the thought process to put an
0:47:23 air scrubber on one of the manholes that's generating one of those giant columns of spikes?
0:47:28 Yeah, in those areas, correct.
0:47:31 And with the mobile scrubber, it would give us the ability to hook it up.
0:47:35 It's not the full size. I mean, if we were to build something, it would be a bigger facility.
0:47:40 But it will give us an idea of how that system is reacting.
0:47:45 And if I'm looking at this graph, the 500 milla, the concentration of 500 parts per million,
0:47:51 that's going to be, is that the level where you told me earlier that that's where we can detect smell?
0:47:56 No, so this is so zero yeah, so where we can smell it is below the zero is the
0:48:03 weight zero zero zero five
0:48:07 Perimeter, so it's my math was not great when I was messing around on the calculator during the presentation
0:48:15 What impact does that air scrubber have then on this graph?
0:48:19 Well, so I guess I want to also point out that you are our first
0:48:25 objective is to continue to partner with our point sources and we recognize
0:48:33 that a lot of this chatter that you see on that graph can be addressed through
0:48:40 our point sources and we've already seen even since the beginning here a
0:48:44 change in chemical that has helped to change that. I do not expect that we are
0:48:51 going to try and address all of that hydrogen sulfide on that graph with a
0:48:57 They order scrubber. The point source is really the best place to address that.
0:49:01 And like I said, that's our kind of our...
0:49:03 That's where we're working intensely, but this is...
0:49:06 Because we've got to be responsible within the city to address things that can't be addressed at the point source.
0:49:11 Well, because at the end of the day, I mean, you were telling us that the cost of scarce scrubbers,
0:49:15 if we put them as several million dollars at the end of the day, the question is, I guess...
0:49:19 What good do they do if they don't...
0:49:21 If I guess if the source, the point source is the biggest contributor,
0:49:26 What impact do all those air scrubbers, if you spent $5 million on air scrubbers, what impact does that have on that graph?
0:49:34 It would be significant, and that would mean that.
0:49:38 We wouldn't have taken up so much time, guys.
0:49:44 Thank you, Craig Hawkins.
0:49:46 Nathan, when I was reading through the packet, talked about the rehabilitation of manhole covers.
0:49:53 So what you're asking for today is approval of $300,000 to $150,000, and that's what I
0:50:33 towards the air scrubber and in our 52 continue the study with consort. Is that correct?
0:50:39 Correct. It would be from the wastewater reserve funds.
0:50:42 Wastewater reserve funds, okay. Council motion question. Thank you Jason.
0:50:52 I move to approve the purchase or the approval of 300,000 for the purchase of the mobile
0:50:59 air scrubbing unit and continue to support from consort engineering for an odor control
0:51:07 study through the end of the current fiscal year.
0:51:10 Out of wastewater reserves.
0:51:12 Out of wastewater reserves.
0:51:13 Thank you.
0:51:14 Do I have a second?
0:51:17 Second.
0:51:18 Motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Craig Hawkins to request the approval of 300,000 from wastewater
0:51:25 reserves for purchasing an air scrubber and continued support from consort engineering for
0:51:31 odor control study through the end of the current fiscal year.
0:51:35 Any further discussion?
0:51:36 I'll say something real quick.
0:51:38 As it was noted, my name was on some of the initial study, and this really has been going
0:51:45 on for quite some time, and it's good to see that we're now, at this point, trying to hone
0:51:53 in a little bit more on a solution, these solutions, these fixes are not immediate, they
0:52:05 can be very complex, I know there are citizens out there that are dealing with this on a daily
0:52:10 basis.
0:52:11 I appreciate you just getting to this point.
0:52:14 Okay.
0:52:19 Kelly, roll call, vote please.
0:52:21 Alex Galal?
0:52:22 Yes.
0:52:23 Mayor Pierce?
0:52:24 Yes.
0:52:25 Mr. Fareed?
0:52:26 Yes.
0:52:27 Spencer Cutler?
0:52:28 Yes.
0:52:29 Nicky Boyd?
0:52:30 Yes.
0:52:31 Greg Hawkins?
0:52:32 Yes.
0:52:33 Jason Brown?
0:52:34 Yes.
0:52:35 Thank you.
0:52:36 Motion passes 7-0.
0:52:37 Mitch, did you have some?
0:52:40 Travis?
0:52:41 Yes, I was just going to add, obviously we appreciate everyone's patience through this
0:52:46 process.
0:52:47 I also happen to live in one of the neighborhoods that can be impacted, and so I understand and sympathize.
0:52:54 But I also appreciate the work that is being done in the partnership that is moving forward.
0:52:59 One of the things that was stated is that because of this highly variable,
0:53:05 just having a conversation with the point sources isn't going to be the only solution
0:53:11 because of the length of high-picture variations.
0:53:14 There are many other potential causes.
0:53:22 Those different variables off in process
0:53:28 is going to help us find those long-term solutions
0:53:31 that allow us to hopefully have everything
0:53:35 that had shared the high quality of life
0:53:38 that we all expect and reside in neighborhoods that we enjoy.
0:53:44 But it'd also be remiss if I didn't congratulate Nathan.
0:53:49 to those who have worked on this process for a long period of time.
0:53:54 But Nathan was really able to work collaboratively
0:53:58 and took this task on
0:54:02 and has really seen it through this first phase.
0:54:06 And I would also mention it's still in that draft form.
0:54:10 We felt it was appropriate to report to share that this is
0:54:14 the state of where we're at and then to also come to the council
0:54:18 So with that request for additional funding to continue that study, we will report back
0:54:23 out with those results and we hope that through the efforts that have been taken so far and
0:54:30 the additional efforts that we continue to engage in our partners with, that this will
0:54:38 have solutions that won't have to cause us to go to local limits.
0:54:43 Thank you, Travis.
0:54:44 Okay.
0:54:46 Thank you, Nathan.
0:54:47 Thank you, everyone.
0:54:48 Next item on the agenda is an action item, a request to use $35,000 of contingency funds
0:54:57 to acquire property for a right turn lane at Hankins Road and Kimberly Road and we have
0:55:02 Mitch Humble, Deputy City Manager, welcome, Mitch.
0:55:05 Thank you.
0:55:06 I just spent everything I was going to ask you to do, and I guess let me back up just
0:55:15 a little bit, so we have the budget this year, $150,000 in contingency, and with two previous
0:55:22 requests were spent about about $98,000 left to that.
0:55:27 And so we're proposing tonight to use another 35 of contingency
0:55:31 to acquire a piece of property at the,
0:55:35 let's see, my direction's here to be the southeast corner
0:55:38 of Hankins and Kimberly to really make that right
0:55:43 term lean work and you'll all remember
0:55:45 that that right term was built several years ago.
0:55:48 It's on private property, it's not in the right of way.
0:55:51 outside the city limits and so it's kind of crumbling and falling apart and so
0:55:56 we're working with the owner there to kind of fix that and then once it's all
0:56:02 fixed up and ready to go we would purchase that property and make it part
0:56:07 of the city's road system so that we can go in the future continue to own and
0:56:11 maintain that into the future so that's what the request is tonight is to free
0:56:15 up the money so that we can go purchase once the work has been completed so we're
0:56:22 I'm not approving the purchase necessarily
0:56:24 and I just the funding scheme for it.
0:56:26 Do you have a date anticipating when that might be done?
0:56:30 So they've got a contract right now.
0:56:32 If tomorrow morning I give them the thumbs up
0:56:34 it'll be two weeks out.
0:56:36 Okay.
0:56:37 When they can start the work is what I understand.
0:56:39 Perfect.
0:56:40 It'll be probably not then when we buy it
0:56:42 it'll probably be, but we'll start working as soon as tomorrow.
0:56:49 Thank you. Chris Reed.
0:56:51 Okay.
0:56:53 Okay.
0:56:54 that we use 35,000 of contingency funds
0:56:57 to acquire property for it right now.
0:57:01 Thank you.
0:57:02 Do I have a second?
0:57:03 I second the motion.
0:57:04 Thank you.
0:57:05 Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Spencer Cutler
0:57:08 to approve a request to use 35,000 of contingency funds
0:57:13 to acquire property for a right-turn lane
0:57:15 at Hankins Road and Kimberly Road.
0:57:18 Kelly Rolkelvo, please.
0:57:20 Jason Brown?
0:57:21 Yes.
0:57:22 Craig Hawkins?
0:57:23 Yes.
0:57:24 Spencer Cutler?
0:57:25 Yes.
0:57:26 Yes.
0:57:27 Nicky Boyd.
0:57:28 Yes.
0:57:29 Mayor Pierce.
0:57:30 Yes.
0:57:31 Christopher Reed.
0:57:32 Yes.
0:57:33 Thank you.
0:57:34 Motion passes 7-0.
0:57:35 Okay.
0:57:36 That's all the items of consideration.
0:57:38 Next on the agenda is the time for public input.
0:57:41 This is a time for anyone from the public who wishes to comment on something not on today's
0:57:48 agenda.
0:57:49 Please come down state your name and whether you're a resident of Twin Falls and you have
0:57:55 to speak. Yes sir. My name is Arnelle and I'm a resident here of Twin Falls. I just wanted
0:58:00 to say that these guys did a great job because the city used to stink really bad and it just
0:58:09 went from being really stinky to not so stinky. Now there is indeed some pockets that are
0:58:15 still making some kind of weird smells, even like broad crepe, but I think what you guys
0:58:22 doing here is probably good, but what I'm here to talk about a little bit today is about
0:58:27 park. The park has a way where you can run an operation. This isn't through a park permit.
0:58:35 So an example would be, an example would be like there's a new operation being done by
0:58:42 Turkey's Lake where kayaks can be rented. There's another operation where a vendor is at Shoshone Falls and so forth.
0:58:53 So, what I'm in the process of is applying for a park permit, and this would consist of having a decline elevator that takes you from the Chofal's Park down to the bottom of Chofal's.
0:59:10 I think I've emailed some of you guys to kind of explain the park permit a little bit more, but I just wanted to see if I could get this on the agenda so that way you guys can have a formal vote to approve it or not.
0:59:24 So Travis, what is the process for Mr. Callum to do what he's asking?
0:59:33 Um, for Council guidelines and policy, citizens during the citizen input portion approach the
0:59:39 Council, or them for you to consider requests that they may have, or formally on gender moving
0:59:50 if you are interested in learning more past what has happened as we've had citizens that
1:00:02 have come to the council. They may have proposed ordinance changes and if the council believes
1:00:09 that that is appropriate for additional conversation, it takes a majority vote.
1:00:19 I guess my question was in order for him to apply for a permit, there is a process through
1:00:26 the city. That correct? In this particular case?
1:00:30 There is a permit process that requires, it allows for the use of our facilities.
1:00:35 It doesn't call for the creation of something new like an elevator that Mr. Colm is talking about.
1:00:41 Historically what will happen is we will have a concession stand in a park.
1:00:48 That concession stand will go through a concessionaire's permit.
1:00:52 If someone wants to host an event and so the concessionaire's permit would be something like the kayaks
1:00:59 that Mr. Callum was talking about at Durkeys Lake.
1:01:01 We'll enter in with a private party to be able to offer that service on behalf of the city.
1:01:08 It's a service that's demanded that the city doesn't have either the resources or the capital to be able to move forward.
1:01:15 In all cases, it is furnished by the individual. The city does not furnish the kayaks for the kayak company to be able to rent to make a prop on our facilities.
1:01:28 It sounds to me, you would follow up or want to use all the sturkeys like to construct an elevator.
1:01:42 He could then dwell down to the blank, that's something that you want to learn more about.
1:01:55 The idea would be that it would place that on a future council agenda to move.
1:01:59 Exactly. What does everybody wish to do? Answer.
1:02:10 Um, I don't feel like an initiative like that is, um, looking at our strategic plan.
1:02:17 When it rise to a top priority, so I wouldn't want to be distracted from other priorities that we're trying to focus on at this time.
1:02:26 Is the idea that the city would be paying for this elevator to the...
1:02:43 Now, so the city would not be funding this. This would be run by a private operation itself,
1:02:48 but the private operation would help be funding park operations,
1:02:52 because it seems like the city never has enough funds for park operations,
1:02:56 So this would be a way for the city to hurt some revenue,
1:02:59 hopefully to compensate some park problems,
1:03:04 like a lot of parks need help.
1:03:07 And you guys obviously don't have enough money
1:03:09 to fund all the park operations.
1:03:11 So they can only work on three parks at a time.
1:03:14 So there would be some kind of deal
1:03:16 where part of the proceeds obviously go towards the city
1:03:21 to go ahead and help park operations.
1:03:36 So you're telling me that this, which, because I think you're asking about an elevator, at least that was the email that I understood, you're telling me that a third private third party entity would build it and operate it.
1:03:48 Correct.
1:03:49 And the city would somehow generate revenue from that?
1:03:52 Correct from the cost of going down.
1:03:54 So similar, like, how the kayaks are being rented at the Tricky's Lake Park.
1:04:00 Park they're currently not giving any money to the city itself but in this scenario
1:04:06 Third party would be providing funds back based off of the cost
1:04:22 Well, this is something parks and rec the parks and rec committee would look out first or do we come straight to us?
1:04:31 The parks and rec committee would not entertain any ideas
1:04:40 more and then if you wanted to at that time you would assign it to the Parks
1:04:44 recognition later exactly again okay so the city owns the property on top of
1:04:50 the canyon the water all how far does that property line go because I know the
1:04:55 federal government jumps in there at some point to these organizations that
1:05:07 you'd have to go through to yes I'm aware of that so it takes you up to the
1:05:11 high watermark line so our property goes to high watermark correct no if that's
1:05:22 It's entirely from cases there's property on the Telus slope that's actually home.
1:05:43 Sometimes the property on the rim and the Telus slope is under a different owner.
1:05:49 So it's not easy for us to say, yes always, just because of the complex ownership that are occurring.
1:06:00 I think that answers at least in my mind a little bit. I don't know if I'm in favor of pursuing this.
1:06:07 The question is, does this fit in? Does this interrupt the flight? Is this a problem?
1:06:35 The question is, do we want to put on the agenda the idea of discussing an elevator?
1:06:45 From my perspective, the answer is going to be no. I've been down there. There's already a place to put in kayaks.
1:06:51 And I also worry about any liability. I think I should be exposing city to that.
1:07:07 What's the general field down there? No? Is there anybody that would like to see this on the agenda?
1:07:16 Okay. I guess not. Thank you. Okay. Anybody else from the public that wishes to speak on something that is not on today's agenda?
1:07:28 Okay. See no one advisory board reports. Anybody have anything? Yes.
1:07:37 One of our citizens approached me about some services for veterans last Monday, and I did look at Google
1:07:46 Joining Forces Magic Valley, the new manual is contained in there, listing various services that can help, so I just wanted to make that.
1:07:57 Okay. Anybody else? City Manager's Office. Nothing for today. Okay.
1:08:04 So next on the agenda is public hearing.
1:08:09 We are scheduled to start at six o'clock or after, so unless somebody needs a break, I'm
1:08:15 going to go ahead.
1:08:17 Okay.
1:08:18 So public hearing is an action item, a request for an amendment to the VISTA-ROM ZDA to modify
1:08:27 overall design theme, building materials and high restrictions on property located at
1:08:34 292 Canyon Crest Drive, Erev Andrew, Urstad, Urstad, and architects on behalf of John Odom.
1:08:41 We have Jonathan's been left.
1:08:43 Jonathan, why don't we just wait a minute, let everybody take off and shut the door and
1:08:50 go.
1:08:57 That was enough of a break, Jonathan.
1:08:58 Mayors, this is a land use public hearing.
1:09:04 We'll need to read the public hearing.
1:09:05 Oh, yes.
1:09:06 Thank you.
1:09:07 Okay, so the council will follow these nine steps.
1:09:17 City staff will present the requested analysis.
1:09:20 The applicant will then present their request.
1:09:23 The council will then ask questions of the applicant or staff.
1:09:27 After questions, the public hearing will be opened during that time.
1:09:31 Anyone in attendance is given the opportunity to comment or ask questions about the request being considered.
1:09:36 the request being considered. When giving testimony, please step up to the podium,
1:09:41 state your name and address, present your comments or concern. After giving
1:09:45 testimony, please sign the public. Sign in sheet located in the lobby with your
1:09:50 name and address for the record. After public comments are concluded, the
1:09:54 applicant will be invited to answer any questions and make your closing statement.
1:09:58 Staff will then answer, clarify any comments or clarify any comments as
1:10:04 needed after the closing statements public hearing will be closed. No further
1:10:09 testimony or comments from the applicant or audience will be allowed and then the
1:10:13 council will have open discussion and take action. Okay Jonathan you're up.
1:10:18 Thank you Mayor members of the council. I'm going to start with a little preamble.
1:10:22 Usually don't have this applicant has typically been on received. If there's
1:10:33 any questions on their stuff we would then be tabling the item for the
1:10:39 additional information to a specific date. We can do without them. Usually don't, but
1:10:45 if all of the questions are answered, it might have just been they got held up somewhere.
1:10:50 What's your recommendation, Jonathan? I said go ahead unless you have very specific questions
1:10:56 that I can't answer that aren't part of their narrative, which is their testimony.
1:11:01 But if we get any more than that, I would have you just table it to a specific date.
1:11:06 Is everybody good with that? Okay, so go ahead.
1:11:09 This item is, or you basically redo or over Hall of ZDA that was approved back in, go to the, show you the area first.
1:11:27 Canyon Crest is here on the right, elevation is over here towards the left.
1:11:32 Canyon Crest drive is where the access, some of you may remember the plan actually has two accesses on Canyon Crest, one over on the east side.
1:11:41 I'll show you a little bit. One of them actually goes through this joint parking lot, and this is a dentist office.
1:11:47 These are town-home type of construction, and this is the zone. It's a Vistorim ZDA.
1:11:56 There's some residential those previously done. The area's been re-zoned multiple times.
1:12:07 It would be a nice way to put it. The North Bridge PUD was in the early 90s. Some stuff got built in the 90s,
1:12:13 and then later it was re-zoned in the 2000s with the pinnacle and the river
1:12:17 of east of PUDs. That's where you get elevation, that's where you can't even crest.
1:12:21 And then you have the apartments to the south. So there's kind of a true
1:12:26 actual mix of uses in this area. We have single-family residences, condos,
1:12:30 apartments, professional offices, even some retail down by Pole Line Road. The
1:12:36 future map has it as mixed use and this kind of shows what's occurred around it.
1:12:40 putters is here, two hotels, some storage units, these are duplexes and multiplex
1:12:49 townhomes, and to professional offices, a restaurant. That's what's near it.
1:12:55 Their narrative, which is in your pack you want to read the entire thing, is to get a
1:13:01 new overall design theme for the property. They had their master plan,
1:13:08 actually eliminated a couple dwelling units along the rim in order to make
1:13:14 this unit fit better and to actually accentuate the view to the bridge. That was their reasoning.
1:13:20 So they eliminated one of these spaces out the original um, CDAs in your packet.
1:13:24 This is the joint axis here and then they come down and you crest drive here.
1:13:30 The real reason was they wanted to change the elements of what they looked like.
1:13:35 Um, the original is in the packet, I'll show in a minute.
1:13:37 Um, they were more of like a flat top single slope proof.
1:13:41 They sent a big pitch proof. Um, the original buildings are more black with wood accents
1:13:46 and this is more of a gray, um, sighting materials, and then it has some dormers over the windows
1:13:54 and windows in different spots. The other part was to make some of the buildings on the south part
1:14:01 of the property three stories instead of just two. And so the three stories go up to 39th. They want
1:14:08 to take advantage of the new caner overlay that allowed that, um, 150 foot marking go up to 50 feet.
1:14:15 so we go the rim at one end in 50 feet up to 25 feet high then going from there
1:14:22 past it it goes up to 50 at 100 so I wanted to take advantage of that new
1:14:27 mode section and allow for these buildings to be 39 feet tall these are
1:14:34 renditions these are the actual buildings that are next to the rim
1:14:41 they are still two-story and still meeting the minimum at maximum height
1:14:45 not asking for anything more and this was the building is 39 feet tall they
1:14:59 actually build anything in 50 feet because it's in the ZDA and they're showing you the height that
1:15:03 they have so they'd still be restricted to that third-night-foot tall building. But this is the
1:15:10 original ordinance from 2020 with this scroll down so there's the building number up here so they
1:15:20 modified that to basically be one building and these are what they used to look like two-story
1:15:25 buildings and then the three-story units. So today you're looking at this as a ZDA to modify essentially
1:15:37 this picture and replacing with the new ones and to modify this master development plan with the new ones showing the
1:15:45 smaller number as well as that height exhibit that was up above but is also down here.
1:15:59 That's all I have in terms of the report. There's more in it if you have more language in there.
1:16:05 I would propose and what this does keep is the there's a projection limit from the council that stays in place.
1:16:12 with this red level is for the council only allowed this special projection on
1:16:18 the outer two units along the rim that stays in place because it was part of
1:16:24 the original still on this exhibit and they're really just talking about new
1:16:29 look of the building and building something up to 39 feet so Jonathan
1:16:38 would you go back to the plan the layout the new one or the new one please
1:16:45 and where are they proposing the taller three story but part of that layout these
1:16:52 buildings right here in front end up being down here okay I believe this one
1:16:57 might portions of this one I believe this one might as well because it'll meet that
1:17:01 hundred and fifty-foot mark so it'd be these three area these three sections front ones
1:17:05 The ones along the rim are still two-story.
1:17:07 Okay, thank you.
1:17:10 Hey, some brown?
1:17:11 So the question I had is, you know, those new apartments to the south of Canyndris.
1:17:18 They're three-story, correct?
1:17:20 Some of them are actually four.
1:17:22 What is the height there?
1:17:24 What was 50?
1:17:26 Okay, so these would be lower than that, so the ones on the top would potentially be able to see over the top.
1:17:31 I mean, they could see over it.
1:17:34 They even have to see the canyon itself depending on they are taller to the south
1:17:40 Chris, remember when this game for office was here the east of it it's shown at 26
1:18:01 I believe part of that is too way because of fire truck access it becomes a fire lane instead of going through the parking lot
1:18:09 Yes, go ahead so that
1:18:18 Chris sparked my next question is
1:18:21 have we talked to the dentist officer has that always been part of the plan to
1:18:25 send him through that parking area I mean I'm trying to catch up some history
1:18:29 yeah I think as well from a business standpoint having those cars come through
1:18:33 yeah this property actually had has an access easement through that parking lot
1:18:42 okay the dentist owner the owner of this property is notified of this hearing in
1:18:47 the last one. I don't call about this new application, but they did not submit anything
1:18:55 in the language that a conversation about what they're asking for.
1:18:57 They're at least aware that there's an easement. They know what's going on in everything.
1:19:02 Thank you, Jason. Any other questions?
1:19:10 Yes, because not here. Their statement isn't writing. I'd just have a few more questions
1:19:17 than public hearing.
1:19:22 I'm going to go ahead and open the public hearing if there's anybody here that wishes to comment on this
1:19:30 Request please come down state your name for the record and make your comments
1:19:36 the no one I'm going to close the public hearing and
1:19:43 Allow for any questions for Jonathan
1:19:48 And then let's have a conversation
1:19:56 I didn't review the minutes like before I got here today, did last week, but that's been the weekend.
1:20:01 I just finished going through them and at the very end unanimously approved by a vote of 6-0-0.
1:20:09 Hey, Council. What would you like to do? Spencer Cutler.
1:20:19 Make a motion if you're ready. I move that we approve the amendment to the V-Easter Rim ZDA to modify the overall design theme,
1:20:31 Building materials and high thrift restrictions on property at 292 Canyon Crest Drive.
1:20:37 I need to state the...
1:20:40 No, that's good.
1:20:42 I'll second that.
1:20:43 Thank you.
1:20:44 Motion by Spencer Cutler, second by Chris Reed, to approve the request for the amendment to
1:20:49 the VISTA room, ZDA, to modify overall design-themed building materials and high restrictions on
1:20:55 property located at 292 Canyon Crest Drive.
1:20:59 Any further discussion?
1:21:02 Elly Roll Call vote please. Mayor Pierce. Yes. Christopher Reed. Yes. Nikki Boyd. Yes. Craig Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. Alex Kavon. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. Thank you Jonathan.
1:21:19 Okay, given that, our meeting is adjourned.
1:21:22 Thank you, everyone.
Download
- Transcript (text) 67 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 87 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 116 KB
- Audio (M4A) 19.3 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, April 3, 2023. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:21:38.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
43c9ddbdaf4921948ebfc48f69ccb49a99ed093be4df35fd96101df8bdb57881 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 4ee041ca96f14ed1c396d54489616ab8c4e9e0de0e1b9e0f902eb29ba1001a07 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
e83e9bcb4b6030c7bd1a3db45dae5b536b87b746fefc06a50df9cf780fe6adc8
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file