OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, April 10, 2023

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: f

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording

Transcript

0:01:25 Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the April 10th, 2023 City Council meeting. I want to confirm we have a quorum. We have all seven members present in chambers today.

0:01:38 So first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. If you wish to join me please rise. Thank you. Okay, we do have a proclamation tonight and I will read that.

0:02:07 Office of the Mayor of the City of Twin Falls Proclamation for Military Child Month, April

0:02:15 2023, whereas Twin Falls Idaho is proud to support and recognize military children for

0:02:22 their resilient spirits, personal sacrifices and strong character and courage, and whereas

0:02:29 military children are part of the strength of our nation as they support and encourage

0:02:34 their service members with a fierce patriotic spirit, and whereas these children are the

0:02:40 source of pride for the City of Twin Falls and to all of us, it is only fitting that

0:02:45 we take time to recognize their contributions, and whereas military children continue to make

0:02:51 significant contributions to their family, their community, and their nation as they

0:02:57 endure prolonged and repeated absences of one or both parents, and whereas a month long

0:03:03 salute will recognize that military children serve too and whereas the citizens of Twin

0:03:09 Falls will be afforded the opportunity to don the color purple every Friday and April

0:03:15 in support of these children. Now therefore, I Ruth Pierce, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls,

0:03:21 do your bike proclaim April 2023 to be military child month and I see some purple shirts.

0:03:29 So, if you all want to come down and accept this proclamation or send a representative,

0:03:36 anyway, we can do it.

0:04:36 When Misha means a whole lot to our military kids, currently serve the military regardless

0:04:43 of what branch is serviced.

0:04:55 With our service members.

0:04:57 But most of all, our military kid is awesome in the fact that it brings awareness to what

0:05:09 those challenges are to know.

0:05:33 Craig Hawkins.

0:05:34 I just want to take a minute.

0:05:37 Thanks, Sonia, having gone through the point myself

0:05:41 and leaving eight kids in school, I know what it's like.

0:05:45 You worry a lot about your family.

0:05:47 So it's really nice to see this recognition given

0:05:50 and if you are full support.

0:05:53 Thank you, Sonia.

0:05:58 Thank you.

0:05:59 OK.

0:06:00 Next on the agenda is the consent calendar.

0:06:04 Council wishes, Chris Reed.

0:06:05 Move to approve the consent calendar.

0:06:08 Thank you.

0:06:09 Do we have a second?

0:06:11 Motion by Christopher Reed, seconded by Alex Kaval

0:06:14 to approve the consent calendar as written.

0:06:17 Amy Roll, call vote, please.

0:06:20 Chris Reed.

0:06:21 Yes.

0:06:22 Will it be a second?

0:06:23 Yes.

0:06:24 Mason Brown.

0:06:25 Yes.

0:06:26 Alex Kaval.

0:06:27 Yes, Mr. Cutler.

0:06:28 Yes.

0:06:28 Yes.

0:06:30 Thank you.

0:06:31 Motion passes seven to zero.

0:06:32 So if you were here for the Southern Idaho RV

0:06:36 show special event for Magic Valley Law Enforcement Memorial

0:06:40 Service, Special Event for Magic Valley Builders, Parade of Homes,

0:06:45 Vamp Permit for the organizers shown, shown falls after dark,

0:06:50 and I need the fact and conclusion of law for VISTA-ROM,

0:06:55 CDA, those have all been approved.

0:06:58 Okay, next on the agenda under items of consideration.

0:07:03 Confirm Mayor Pierce's recommendation to a point,

0:07:06 Point, Robin Weatherford,

0:07:10 and to serve on the Planning and Zoning Commission

0:07:12 in Randall Johnson to serve on the impact,

0:07:15 the Improvement Reimbursement Commission.

0:07:18 And we have Jonathan's been,

0:07:19 love our P&Z Director, welcome.

0:07:22 Thank you, Mayor, members of the Council.

0:07:24 We had two interviews conducted,

0:07:26 one by Mayor Pierce, myself,

0:07:28 and the Planning and Zoning Commission Chair,

0:07:30 Craig Kelly, we interviewed Robin Weatherford.

0:07:33 After that interview,

0:07:34 We did conclude unanimously to your recommended appointment.

0:07:38 We held a second interview for the Impact Fee Commission

0:07:41 with Councilman Reed and Tom Frank, the Chair and myself.

0:07:46 And we also recommended Randall Johnson to be appointed to that.

0:07:50 At the end of this, the planning is only commissioned

0:07:52 while having a full contingent.

0:07:53 The Impact Fee Committee also have two members.

0:07:56 vacant didn't need to be in development rate fields

0:07:59 per the mayor's request that prepared decision item

0:08:02 Can we do this in one motion or would you like to?

0:08:07 It's cleaner doing too that way should there be any sense.

0:08:14 Okay, well I might mention that I was in on the interview with Robin and

0:08:19 House Boking to Randall on the phone and both of them are very excited about participating.

0:08:24 So Chris Reed.

0:08:25 I just wanted to say as far as Randall we had a good conversation.

0:08:28 We had a good conversation.

0:08:29 I think I'll add quite a bit to this committee on his knowledge and background.

0:08:34 Perfect.

0:08:35 Thank you, Chris.

0:08:36 So do I have a motion?

0:08:38 The first motion.

0:08:39 Chris, read.

0:08:40 Go ahead.

0:08:41 I'll make the one for Randall.

0:08:42 I move that we confirm the recommendation to appoint Randall Johnson to serve on the Impact

0:08:49 Fee and Improvement Reimbursement Commission.

0:08:51 Second.

0:08:52 Thank you.

0:08:53 Motion by Chris.

0:08:54 seconder by Nikki Boyd to approve the recommendation to appoint Randall Johnson

0:09:00 to serve on the impact fee and Improvement Reimbursement Commission.

0:09:05 Amy Roekall vote please.

0:09:07 Nikki Boyd?

0:09:11 Yes.

0:09:12 Craig Hawkins?

0:09:13 Yes.

0:09:14 Jason Brown?

0:09:15 Yes.

0:09:16 Alex Gavol?

0:09:17 Yes.

0:09:18 Mr. Cutler?

0:09:19 Yes.

0:09:20 Bruce Pierce?

0:09:21 Yes.

0:09:22 And Chris Reed?

0:09:24 Yes.

0:09:25 Thank you.

0:09:26 Motion passes 7-0.

0:09:27 I'd like to go ahead and make a motion to appoint Robin Weatherford to serve on the Planning and Zoning Commission.

0:09:34 Thank you.

0:09:35 Alex Gavalle.

0:09:36 I second the motion.

0:09:37 Thank you.

0:09:38 I have a motion from Craig Hawkins, seconded by Alex to approve the recommendation to appoint Robin Weatherford to serve on the Planning and Zoning Commission.

0:09:49 Amy Roll call vote, please.

0:09:53 Jason Brown?

0:09:54 Yes.

0:09:55 Alex Gavalle?

0:09:56 Yes.

0:09:56 Spencer Cutler?

0:09:57 Yes.

0:09:58 Bruce Pierce?

0:09:58 Yes.

0:09:59 Chris Reed?

0:10:00 Yes.

0:10:00 Thank you, Boyd. Yes, and Craig Hawkins.

0:10:06 Thank you, Motion passes 7-0. Welcome, Robin and Randall. Thank you.

0:10:11 Okay, next item on the agenda is a presentation, a presentation from the City Attorney's Office

0:10:18 and swearing in of Deputy Prosecutors. We have our City Attorney, Shane, no. Welcome, Shane.

0:10:25 Thank you, Madam Mayor, members of the Council. I appreciate the opportunity to give this brief presentation,

0:10:32 presentation and also the opportunity to give the office to three deputy prosecutors, and

0:10:39 if you don't mind switching the monitor, just kind of give an overview. First, just a brief

0:10:47 introduction of who are on our team as well as what we do. We're going to talk a little

0:10:51 bit about COVID-19 and some of the successes that we had as a team during that situation.

0:10:59 And then also overview a little bit of our criminal caseload, because we are then going

0:11:05 to present the oath of office to the three deputy prosecutors.

0:11:11 So my name is Shane Nope, I'm the city attorney, I was appointed and took the oath of office

0:11:16 in November of 2018, have Jeff Deering, Nicole Swafford and Linda Wells who are all deputy

0:11:22 prosecutors and I'll introduce them a little bit more formally later, and Rachel Hunsaker

0:11:27 Our legal assistant and advisor, Anne Swiss Army Knife.

0:11:32 And we'll talk a little bit more about her background in a minute.

0:11:36 Idaho code, as many people know, what cities do is defined in Idaho code.

0:11:41 A lot of times when we're answering questions to citizens,

0:11:44 they want us to give them the city code that gives them direction.

0:11:47 And a lot of times we have to share that it's a state code that actually gives the power to the cities here in Idaho.

0:11:53 And there's two main focuses of the code section that authorizes,

0:11:58 or defines what I do and my team does.

0:12:01 And that is one as an advisor to the Municipal Corporation.

0:12:04 And we represent the city and suits other proceedings.

0:12:08 And then number two, we prosecute misdemeanor crimes

0:12:11 and infractions that occur within the city of Twin Falls.

0:12:15 Just for clarification through others out there,

0:12:17 because the question comes up often,

0:12:18 what about felonies?

0:12:20 County prosecutor handles all felonies,

0:12:22 matter of the jurisdiction within the county whether it be in the city or outside in the county

0:12:27 boundaries and so that's how that workload is split there. To kind of go into some of our successes

0:12:36 during uncertainty that first row you see their update starting with March 18th through November 25th

0:12:41 that's just Supreme Court emergency orders that were issued during 2020. The two that have highlighted

0:12:47 there are specific to criminal prosecuting of misdemeanor crimes and how that changed as we were

0:12:53 dealing with COVID and the courts being locked down, open back up, locked down, open back up.

0:12:59 The other orders that were issued, some of those did have implications for our team because we

0:13:05 were answering questions to citizens in Twin Falls that really didn't understand what was going on

0:13:10 federally or at the state or even locally and really combining all of those government agencies

0:13:16 into one in their mindset. And so when they were looking for answers and calling, we took many,

0:13:21 many, many calls. And that's where I wanted to kind of maybe have Rachel just stand up in

0:13:28 the wave. Sorry to do this to her. Rachel handled a 300% increase in continuances of court

0:13:37 hearings. What that means is not all of those were cases where we've had witnesses set, but

0:13:43 at least notices had to go out to witnesses that were moving these hearings. That increased

0:13:47 300% during COVID because of the orders. There was a time where we had to look at the number of

0:13:52 COVID cases and to determine if we were going to go to court that next week. And so I really wanted

0:13:59 to highlight the efforts Rachel made in reaching out to victims of cases, especially as they were

0:14:05 continually asking really getting reset again. And we still feel some of that today. Rachel started

0:14:11 her career in 1998 while attending night classes at Boise State. She has a

0:14:17 bachelor's degree in business administration. She spent 10 years working

0:14:20 for a criminal defense attorney and later for the Twin Falls County

0:14:23 prosecutor's office for 12 years. Rachel started working for the city in 2018 and

0:14:28 just marked her 27 year anniversary in the Twin Falls County justice system so

0:14:34 we can get Rachel around to applause for her. Just to highlight what's on the

0:14:43 screen below that then is our specific fifth district had all of those

0:14:48 administrative orders that went out not all of those obviously were related

0:14:51 specifically to COVID but again a significant amount of changes happened

0:14:56 that we had to deal with one of the quotes I pulled out I didn't want to get

0:14:59 into necessarily the politics but I will say that researchers noted significant

0:15:05 declines in the trade this is during COVID in the trades that help us navigate

0:15:09 social situations, trust others, think creatively, and act responsibly.

0:15:16 So if you can imagine all of these changes that we are going through as a team, as well

0:15:21 as dealing with individuals who are in some, you know, fault of their own, going through

0:15:28 this pandemic in ways that we've just never seen.

0:15:31 And I imagine Rachel would agree that in the 27 years she's worked, has never seen anything

0:15:35 like what we went through.

0:15:37 I also would be remiss if I didn't thank Nicole Swoffert, who during this time handled those

0:15:45 hearings as well as Sam Hughes, who Sam Hughes has left and gone to another agency, but if

0:15:49 we could give them a round of applause for their efforts as well.

0:15:52 I just wanted to outline briefly for you that what I mentioned before we didn't see a spike

0:16:04 in the total number of charges filed in Twin Falls, but we did see a significant increase

0:16:10 in the number of hearings that we had to attend based on some of the manifestations of lack

0:16:16 of responsibility taking and other things like that that we've definitely seen an increase

0:16:21 in the amount of time spent every time we touch a case versus previous years and that

0:16:26 continues to today.

0:16:30 I thought you might find it interesting I broke out the, I guess the number of cases

0:16:35 by category illegal drugs that includes everything from paraphernalia to drugs as well as frequenting

0:16:42 a place where the drugs are being used.

0:16:45 Those categories are the highest amount of cases per year, as you can see going across.

0:16:50 I think it's interesting you see that spike in theft, unfortunately.

0:16:54 The opportunity to wear a mask in every location in the city was an opportunity for those who

0:17:01 don't like to accept responsibility.

0:17:04 I will also point here you'll see the domestic violence.

0:17:07 We've heard some statistics talk about domestic violence as it relates to COVID and people

0:17:11 We didn't really see a spike in that, but again, we'll reiterate the fact that our office

0:17:17 to continually reach out to victims and witness his in cases and just tell them, sorry, we

0:17:22 don't know when this is actually going to go to trial, and the frustration of individuals

0:17:27 potentially feeling like they were victimized again because of the results of all of those

0:17:32 changes.

0:17:33 And again, any questions?

0:17:43 You know, that was very quick.

0:17:52 So when you get to 2023, Shane, is that what you call that, a consistent or normal?

0:17:59 Have we normalized a little bit more from the previous periods, particularly the COVID period?

0:18:05 Have we come back to what would be cases through the system?

0:18:12 It's a great question.

0:18:13 It feels, I mean, I can't really give specific data to say absolutely that points to this.

0:18:19 appears to be resolutions of cases happening on a more standard schedule you

0:18:24 see in a criminal case load however we are still personally seeing some of

0:18:30 those ramifications of the lack of accountability even trust those issues

0:18:38 that maybe bleed into the judicial system itself. Jane is this a calendar year or

0:18:44 fiscal year? It's our calendar year. So the next thing I wanted to present for

0:18:54 is this is the oath that each of the deputies will next take.

0:18:58 And the reason I bring this up is because through COVID as well as even today,

0:19:02 we often have individuals coming to our office asking questions,

0:19:06 looking for legal advice in some cases. We can't give them legal advice because

0:19:10 it would be being their specific attorney versus being an attorney for the city

0:19:14 and then advice as it relates to city code or state.

0:19:19 And I think it's very important that we have hold, this is the same oath I took

0:19:26 I took except for a few minor changes November of 2018.

0:19:31 You will uphold the Constitution of both the United States

0:19:34 and Idaho, the laws of the state of Idaho,

0:19:38 as well as the ordinances and codes in the city of Twin Falls,

0:19:41 and the rules and regulations of both my office,

0:19:45 as well as the city of Twin Falls.

0:19:48 And I just, our team, I believe, has done a phenomenal job

0:19:53 of this, has taken, in some cases, some accusations,

0:19:57 but that will always be there,

0:20:00 but I just want this council to know

0:20:02 who I report to directly that I wholeheartedly

0:20:07 believe this and uphold this to the best of my ability.

0:20:10 And with that, I would ask the three deputy prosecutors

0:20:13 to go and stand maybe down here on my right.

0:20:19 And as they're coming down, I'll give a,

0:20:20 and I'll just share that we're grateful for their families

0:20:23 who we include as part of the city family.

0:20:27 And they'll have, they're some who would prefer

0:20:31 to necessarily be introduced so we're going to respect that but I will give

0:20:34 them an opportunity to introduce anyone who may feel comfortable being introduced

0:20:39 here today but first I'll just start alphabetically here we have Jeff

0:20:44 Deering. Jeff is an Idaho native he's a proud alumni of the University of Utah

0:20:49 appreciated adding that in their biography and the University of Idaho

0:20:55 College of Law and his 16 years as an attorney he has served as a public defender

0:20:59 a county prosecutor, a deputy attorney general and now a city prosecutor. He also

0:21:05 previously oversaw the CASA guardian at Lyton program for the third and fourth

0:21:09 traditional districts. Additionally, he has had the opportunity to twice teach the

0:21:13 Idaho Peace Officer Standards and Training Academy and was a guest speaker

0:21:17 at the family law section of the Idaho state bar. Next we have Linda Wells. Linda

0:21:23 is originally from Twin Falls. She's a two-time graduate of the University of

0:21:27 Idaho, Go Vandals, earning a bachelor's degree in English literature with a minor in German

0:21:32 and a Juris doctor.

0:21:35 She has been an attorney for almost six and a half years, began her career in voicing private

0:21:38 practice, primarily focusing on family law and bankruptcy.

0:21:42 Previously, she served as deputy prosecuting attorney for the County of Twin Falls in

0:21:46 both civil and criminal matters.

0:21:48 She is the outgoing president of the Fifth District Bar Association.

0:21:51 Next, we have Nicole Swofford.

0:21:54 Nicole is the proud lifetime resident of Idaho.

0:21:57 She obtained her associate's degree from the College of Southern Idaho,

0:22:00 a bachelor's degree from Boise State University,

0:22:02 and master's degree from Boise State University,

0:22:04 and a juris doctorate from the University of Idaho.

0:22:07 On completion of her graduation program, Nicole spent time in politics serving as a lobbyist

0:22:11 for the largest agricultural organization in Idaho prior to transitioning into position

0:22:16 as a renewable energy specialist for the office of the former Idaho governor,

0:22:20 Butch Otter.

0:22:21 After adjusting her career direction to law,

0:22:23 Nicole was selected to Ex-term for Chief Federal District Judge, Judge B. Lynn Windmill, where

0:22:29 she drafted legal opinions for the Judge's signature and publication. On the conclusion

0:22:33 of law school, Nicole began her career at a civil litigation firm before accepting an

0:22:38 opportunity with the prominent Western Water and Natural Resources firm. While there, she

0:22:43 had the opportunity to serve the firm's clients as liaison and courtrooms administrative

0:22:47 hearings, and that negotiation tables, including at grassroots, local, state, and federal levels

0:22:52 involving a variety of complex local, multi-state tribal and international water and natural

0:22:57 resource policy and legal issues.

0:22:59 She's enjoyed the new opportunities that the seat of Twin Falls provides through both criminal

0:23:03 work in the courtroom and civil advisory of the city departments.

0:23:07 Nicole has been admitted to the Idaho Supreme Court and federal district court.

0:23:11 So we'll give them a round of applause.

0:23:13 I will note that I took a play out of the police department's playbook and that is they

0:23:23 have here two copies of their office that they will hear takes shortly.

0:23:26 shortly. One copy will be given to them at their one year anniversary upon completion of that year.

0:23:34 Again, I'll remind them after, well, we'll go to that point next, after the oath of office, we invite

0:23:41 the city council and mayor to come by and as well as city management staff come by and shake their

0:23:47 hands and congratulate them. At this point, if each of them will face me or raise your right hand,

0:23:59 I state your name. You saw me swear that I will support the Constitution of the United States of

0:24:06 of America, the Constitution and laws of the state of Idaho,

0:24:16 the laws and ordinances of the city of Twin Falls,

0:24:21 and the rules and regulations of the city attorney's office.

0:24:24 And I will properly and faithfully discharge the duties

0:24:29 of Deputy City Prosecutor.

0:24:33 And that I will properly and faithfully discharge the duties

0:24:38 of Deputy City Prosecutor.

0:24:40 Congratulations.

0:24:55 I'm just happy to hear your all vandals.

0:24:58 That's all I can say.

0:25:08 And I would just invite those who would like to introduce

0:25:11 any family members who do so now.

0:25:17 today with my parents Robin and Vivian Wells, if you'll stand up and give a wave with that, I have any questions?

0:25:33 Any questions?

0:25:35 They want some questions.

0:25:36 Well, come down.

0:25:38 Thank you.

0:25:39 Let's give our team another round of applause.

0:26:34 Thank you, Shane.

0:26:35 Okay.

0:26:39 That is everything on the agenda for tonight.

0:26:42 Next on the agenda is a general public pamphlet.

0:26:46 It's a time for anybody in the public who wishes to come down and address the city council on something

0:26:52 on something, anything not on today's agenda. I ask that you come down and

0:26:58 state your name and with your resident of Twin Falls and you have two minutes.

0:27:03 Thank you. Thank you Council. My name is Arnelle and I'm here to talk to you guys a

0:27:08 little bit about additions. You are a citizen of Twin Falls. Yes. Thank you,

0:27:13 Arnelle. And I'm here talking about petitions. So currently the city of

0:27:18 when falls does not have any codes related to petitions and I'm hoping that moving forward

0:27:25 City Council takes some initiative and puts some code related to petitions such as Buell.

0:27:32 You can take a look at Buell's City Codes related to petitions and I've also started a petition

0:27:42 myself. I'm here today to ask City Council for an action item to be placed on the next

0:27:49 week's agenda. Basically what I'm looking for is I'm looking to see where the City Council

0:27:56 stands on the strong mayor system. Currently we run on a manager system which is where City

0:28:06 Council elects a manager and the mayor is elected by City Council and I'm wanting to have an action

0:28:17 item to go ahead and potentially change the way the city is governed with placing this

0:28:25 on a ballot. So there's two ways to go ahead and make this strong mayor change. One is

0:28:31 an initiative. So this is currently in play right now. And another way to go ahead and

0:28:35 make a change to a strong mayor system is to have city council vote on the matter itself,

0:28:41 where if four of you, I believe four of you vote yes,

0:28:45 then this would then be placed on the ballot.

0:28:50 So again, I'm just here to ask city council

0:28:53 to put this on the agenda

0:28:56 where you can actually make an official vote.

0:28:59 Right now, this is just public input,

0:29:00 so you don't have to make a decision now,

0:29:04 but the ask is to place this on the agenda

0:29:07 to make an official vote on another date.

0:29:12 Okay, so as usual, this is our opportunity to

0:29:18 approve or just

0:29:19 We're not approved putting this request on the agenda, so I welcome

0:29:27 What is everybody feel?

0:29:30 Okay, now you go about this a lot and it's something that you get asked when you're on City Council and when you travel to other states

0:29:45 you become aware of

0:29:47 So, I could remember side to look it up, but 59% of all the cities in the U.S.

0:29:55 According to the International City Council and Management Association

0:30:00 used this form of government.

0:30:07 There are specific reasons.

0:30:10 I wanted to share two of those that I learned, a little bit of history,

0:30:16 and then I wanted to say what my personal experience has been.

0:30:21 So, this form of government was actually created in the early 1900s, and it was created specifically

0:30:30 to prevent the corruption that was so dominant in our big cities.

0:30:37 This big machine of politics that was going on at the time of times have ever changed,

0:30:44 but I did think that was interesting that because of my personal experience, it's a team.

0:30:53 there isn't one person as or has more influence over a budget, there are seven of us and we represent

0:31:05 everybody in the city. Processed that we go those counts. So great about having a man is that you get to

0:31:22 have some higher somebody as specific education, experience, things that go with a person needs

0:31:48 specific skills. So, I believe it's really

0:31:58 to understand, instead of having a strong

0:32:02 layer, is a very deep space. So, there's

0:32:34 a, and share what their concerns are in

0:32:41 the community. And, we get to hear

0:32:43 individually, you know, decision, we get to

0:32:49 sing. It's just, so, all the power and

0:32:53 authority to set policy rests with us.

0:32:57 But, it's a process we go through to get

0:33:00 to that point, which is very important, a city manager who is a nonpartisan

0:33:08 administrator to see the day-to-day things. And I think that

0:33:14 citizen's input, the seven years I've been doing this, links, citizen input.

0:33:29 And I read another thing, that political scientists and policy analysts comment on

0:33:36 comment on our form of government. It was a real trend. The reason it caught on in so

0:33:43 many people, it was a real trend toward professionalism, municipal administration of all of our smaller

0:33:55 towns and cities. And what was helping to drive this work is state laws, transparency and

0:34:04 accountability those were the things that drove this that has really been my

0:34:11 experience in getting involved in this is learning how why it worked so well I

0:34:22 just we all have an equal voice up here I would not be at all interested in changing

0:34:32 our thank you Nikki down there have comments I'll just jump in and echo what

0:34:42 Nikki said, I think that what has worked for the City of Twin Falls,

0:34:52 work, there's a desire and a history of this form of government.

0:34:57 There are pros and cons to every form of government oversight,

0:35:02 but what is working currently a good job,

0:35:09 the place that are doing it next.

0:35:14 Having that on.

0:35:20 I'll jump in to say, again, I think I just say echo and amen too.

0:35:26 What's been said so far, you know, the last year and a few months

0:35:31 It's been an interesting opportunity for me

0:35:34 to learn about the city of Twin Falls

0:35:36 in a completely different aspect,

0:35:39 but I think Chris hit on it.

0:35:40 We've had a lot of stability in this community.

0:35:45 I grew up in another town in Idaho.

0:35:50 One of the key factors there is that they had city management

0:35:56 and had been there for a long time,

0:35:58 different form of government moving to the city

0:36:01 I believe the City of Twin Falls, being a former employee of the City of Twin Falls, the stability is a huge benefit and I believe the City of Twin Falls has that stability because of the former government.

0:36:15 Alex, all of us here on City Council, I have the shortest tenure, but my experience with you, Mr. Arnell, has been somewhat limited.

0:36:25 I know that you have an interest in water, or it's a show of falls, and when the city staff tells you the answer is no, or it's not with it.

0:36:37 I can't give you access to where you spent. I understand you don't like the answer to that.

0:36:50 You have always done to use whether it's a quick records request, and those are handled.

0:37:01 Jews wanted us to hire yourself to remove the charges, but when those didn't work at lakes,

0:37:22 us the city to pay for the

0:37:33 access to that easement.

0:37:35 And when the answer is perpetually no, it seems like you just upped the anti-soap petition

0:37:44 that you're seeking is notably directed towards the city councilor's to the

0:37:50 and to our city attorney. And I can't help thinking

0:37:56 that from my perspective the city on this side of the diocese looks like to

0:37:59 I think the form of government that we have is fine. I don't think there's a reason to change it at this point.

0:38:07 And reason, reasons, my answer is going to be no. I'm not going to vote anybody else down there.

0:38:19 So, I'm going to have to answer.

0:38:22 Yeah, I actually had one way of opinion about the type of government we should have.

0:38:27 But simply to say, in my tenure, I haven't actually had any other residents bring this concern to me.

0:38:33 to me so I just as a council member haven't felt that ground swell of interest and so as

0:38:39 a council member I want to take the initiative to start this simply because I just don't

0:38:45 think that's our prerogative at this point based on one request so far so thank you.

0:38:51 I just want to reiterate too my feeling is it's a well-oiled machine I don't see any

0:39:07 is satisfied with basic operations in the city.

0:39:11 Having a city manager is a blessing.

0:39:14 I know myself, I don't have the expertise

0:39:17 that I could run a city if I were mayor.

0:39:24 I'd be educated and be able to make recommendations.

0:39:36 Well, and I would concur as well.

0:39:39 I've lived under both forms of government,

0:39:41 and this is very much the preferable form.

0:39:46 I lived in a community where the mayor was there

0:39:49 for a hundred years and really had no clue

0:39:51 what he was doing, but he just won

0:39:53 by popular vote so I would say no as well so I don't think you have anybody at this

0:39:58 point in time are now to support putting it on the agenda for next week.

0:40:03 Okay thank you very much. Okay anybody else in the public that wishes to come

0:40:11 down and address Council at this time? Okay, see no one. Advisory Board

0:40:19 reports. Madam Mayor the Public Arts Commission met last week and they are

0:40:29 finalizing I believe their website and they are also narrowing down the projects or the intersections

0:40:37 that they're interested in pursuing you.

0:40:42 Great.

0:40:43 Anybody else?

0:40:44 Anything?

0:40:46 Yep.

0:40:47 It's from the city manager's office today.

0:40:49 Madam Mayor, members of the council, so I want to give you a couple of weeks' warning.

0:40:54 We're about ready to begin.

0:40:57 that some of us describe as the happiest time of the year, others don't really look forward

0:41:03 to summer budgeting. I think I got a couple of next to me to say that he really was the

0:41:11 happiest time of the year. So we're going to start with that budgeting process and one

0:41:14 of the things that we want to do is we always at the beginning want to first invite the

0:41:19 community to participate in the process. And we also want to have the council begin to

0:41:28 be thinking about the priorities that you would like to see funded and move forward in fiscal year

0:41:34 24. So in two weeks, I believe it's two weeks from tonight, we'll be having our first of 14 public

0:41:43 budgeting conversations. Alex, I apologize. I'm listening to the council. I promise that we're

0:41:53 trying to streamline our approach, so we're not as redundant. But we do hope to continue the process

0:41:59 of having members of the long-term planning team present, we believe that

0:42:04 where the information best lies is the information to be best presented. In

0:42:09 addition to that we hope to be able to incorporate your thoughts and ideas. Also

0:42:14 at that time one of the things that I've requested is an update on the SLFRF

0:42:19 schedules that will also be presenting and outlining the schedules of how we're

0:42:24 going to be able to make those self-imposed deadlines to make sure that

0:42:28 that were in compliance with the spirit of the federal rules

0:42:32 as it related to the allocation of dollars

0:42:35 for those projects.

0:42:35 So didn't want to spring it on to you.

0:42:38 And also it's an invitation for the citizens

0:42:40 to be reaching out to members of the council

0:42:44 be sharing thoughts and ideas.

0:42:46 Our process is better because the public is involved.

0:42:50 I think that we've done a really good job

0:42:52 incorporating the public in that process.

0:42:55 Thank you, Travis.

0:42:56 It is kind of my favorite time of the year.

0:42:58 So, sorry guys, but it is really are really probably one of the most important parts of what we do is that's a taxpayers money is very near and dear to our hearts because we pay in the system too.

0:43:13 So we welcome any public input and any public participation in this process.

0:43:19 Okay, so, no public hearings tonight, next on the agenda, we have an Executive Session

0:43:27 and Action Item under Code Section 74-206-1F to communicate with legal counsel for the

0:43:35 public agency to discuss the legal ramifications of and legal opinions for pending litigation

0:43:43 or controversies not yet being litigated, but imminently likely to be litigated, the Mayor

0:43:49 presence of legal counsel out of the executive session does not satisfy this

0:43:54 requirement. Thank you, Chris Reed. Thank you. I have a motion by Nikki Boyes

0:44:01 seconded by Chris Reed to move into executive session under 74-2061F.

0:44:08 I want to remind everybody that we will not be making any decisions in

0:44:12 executive session and we will not be returning tonight. So meeting is a turn.

0:44:19 Thank you. Oh, I'm sorry. The weather's so nice. Come on you guys. Tax season's almost over. Let's go. Okay.

0:44:30 So the meeting is not adjourned. Amy Roll call vote please.

0:44:34 Alex Cabal? Yes.

0:44:36 Spencer Keller? Yes.

0:44:38 Ruth Pierce? Yes.

0:44:39 Chris Reed? Yes.

0:44:40 Nicky Boyd? Yes.

0:44:41 Craig Hawkins? Yes.

0:44:42 Jason Brown? Yes.

0:44:43 Thank you. Motion passes 7-0 and we will not be returning. Thank you.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, April 10, 2023. The recording started at 16:58 by the recorder's clock and runs 00:46:50.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    67f56058119fe29b320708b4cff32e30a80dac3292ecc79aedc7aa06b2b5b653
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a bc20c6c0abbfb61fd1728288b0c2fcfd1b0e5da6bfeac05db8b3651d2b71f283
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    b394846a85afac9953a3c0a5cdeb1df2f8832d46960f7801fe601168e7b4107d

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file