OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, June 5, 2023

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: a,f

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording

Transcript

0:02:59 Good evening ladies and gentlemen welcome to the June 5th 2020 3 City Council meeting want to confirm

0:03:07 We have a quorum. We have all seven seven members

0:03:11 Present in chambers first on item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. You wish to join me. Please rise

0:03:18 Thank you

0:03:37 We have no proclamations tonight. So next on the agenda is the consent calendar council wishes

0:03:44 Greg Hawkins.

0:03:46 Madam Mayor, wish to make a motion to approve the minutes as a written consent calendar.

0:03:54 Excuse me.

0:03:55 I'll second.

0:03:57 Thank you.

0:03:58 Motion by Greg Hawkins.

0:03:59 Seconded by Jason Brown to approve the consent calendar as written.

0:04:04 Amy Roll call vote please.

0:04:06 Greg Hawkins.

0:04:08 Yes.

0:04:09 Yes.

0:04:10 Alex Cabal.

0:04:11 Yes.

0:04:12 Spencer Cutler.

0:04:13 Yes.

0:04:14 Yes, thank you. Motion passes seven to zero. If you were here for the special event permit for

0:04:24 the law enforcement tortron improvement agreements for prime point trust agreement for Clara

0:04:32 subdivision improvement agreement for eastern sun subdivision or trust agreement for eastern

0:04:39 and some son subdivision, those are all approved.

0:04:43 Next on the agenda is items of consideration.

0:04:47 The first item is an action item,

0:04:49 a request to confirm the reappointment

0:04:51 of Melissa Crane, Laura Stewart, and Drew Nash

0:04:54 to the Public Arts Commission.

0:04:56 And we have Wendy Davis, our Parks and Rec Director.

0:05:07 Good evening.

0:05:09 Good evening, Mayor and Council.

0:05:12 I can't get a hold of my agenda items,

0:05:15 So I'm just going to wing this.

0:05:17 But three years ago, I won't do dates because I don't remember for sure.

0:05:21 The commission was appointed, seven members were appointed, and it was done in staggering

0:05:29 terms.

0:05:31 This year, Melissa Crane drew Nash and Laura Stewart have now served a full three-year term.

0:05:39 They're both interested in serving again.

0:05:43 I would recommend that they be reappointed.

0:05:46 I believe that you communicated with them as well,

0:05:50 and I think they've been good members on the commission.

0:05:57 I think they bring a lot to the table,

0:05:59 and it would be great to have them back.

0:06:01 And so with that, let's do it.

0:06:08 I need a motion to confirm the reappointment of those three.

0:06:13 Madam Mayor, I move that we reappoint Melissa Crane, Laura Stewart, and Drew Nash, the public

0:06:18 arts commission.

0:06:19 Thank you.

0:06:20 Do I have a second?

0:06:23 Motion by Alex Kaval, seconded by Craig Hawkins to confirm the reappointment of Melissa Crane,

0:06:28 Laura Stewart, and Drew Nash to the public arts commission.

0:06:32 Amy Roll, call vote, please.

0:06:34 Jason Brown.

0:06:35 Yes.

0:06:36 Alex Kaval.

0:06:37 Yes.

0:06:38 Spencer Cutler.

0:06:39 Yes.

0:06:40 Bruce Pierce.

0:06:41 Yes.

0:06:42 Chris Reed.

0:06:43 Yes.

0:06:44 Thank you. Motion passes 7 to 0. Thank you. Thank you for the record that this

0:06:50 will be another three-year term. Perfect. Thank you. Okay. Next on the

0:06:55 agenda is an action item a request to reconsider the revised MPOG application

0:07:02 from HCC Foundation and we have Mandy Thompson. Welcome Mandy. Good evening

0:07:08 Madam Mayor Council. As you recall a few weeks ago when you heard the

0:07:12 initial presentations by MPOC applicants. There were a few, too, to be exact. You

0:07:18 asked to go back and rework their applications with some feedback by

0:07:22 council. So I worked with HCC Foundation. Actually, I won't even say I worked with

0:07:29 them. They just got it done like that very night. It was very appreciated. But

0:07:33 this is a little bit of a refresher. What I had written down in my notes that

0:07:38 that you would, that you were asking to see is a strengthened connection with the strategic plan,

0:07:44 some demonstrated outcomes that were measurable. And then also, we requested they put a dollar

0:07:51 amount on the services that they were offering in scholarship and that they remove any specialty

0:07:57 equipment that they would be purchasing with grant funds. And so what they did is they went

0:08:01 back in and they reworked the application put a dollar amount to the cost of serving both

0:08:08 the youth and the young adult population that they're served looking to serve. And then

0:08:12 this is an application to scholarship individuals to receive this physical activity services and

0:08:19 programs through their foundation. So with that, I will let them come up and if you have

0:08:24 any questions. There are both here to answer those for you. Thank you. Welcome.

0:08:35 I wanted to address you. Okay. So do we have questions? You want me to just? So

0:08:42 why don't you just summarize what your new request is? Like we said, we were

0:08:46 asking for the sum in the application to provide services and services are

0:08:52 going to for that that funding is going to primarily pay for their ability to

0:08:59 have the services provided by myself we've figured it out it'll be I don't

0:09:08 service 21 disabled athletes are used for approximately three months

0:09:13 but we'll have all the one or complimentary cost taken care of through

0:09:21 Medicaid, Medicare as we go forward with that and that will sustain the piece to keep this

0:09:27 going.

0:09:28 Qualitative and quantitative aspects, I'll be doing attendance with tracking both attendance

0:09:38 and participants that we've helped by the services too.

0:09:47 qualitative, I'm going to have, when applicable, use the proteas system to see

0:09:53 you know data on them being being able to increase range of motion strength

0:09:59 and ability that way. Forms for feedback from parents, the physical therapists

0:10:06 they work with now because they're they're still kind of they're gonna be a

0:10:10 transition where they kind of hand them off so they're gonna be with me for a

0:10:12 little bit so we can do some things there and we can compare notes and

0:10:16 feedback from what we had from the physical therapist to where we're at now

0:10:20 and then what I see further and then my own observation and notes of how we've

0:10:24 achieved new results. Young man Isaac started this with and he couldn't

0:10:31 move his left arm at all now he can straighten that thing and lift things

0:10:34 and do all kinds of cool stuff so we'll keep track of things like that and have

0:10:39 ways to document what we've done how we've reached success and helped them

0:10:44 We have also asked me about how does it fit with strategic plan for the city.

0:10:51 Number one accessibility in the city is making these kinds of services and all services accessible

0:10:57 for all demographics in our area and our community.

0:11:00 We're the only ones doing this we're trying to create a new accessibility for a demographic

0:11:07 that doesn't typically have this.

0:11:10 And then also the healthy community.

0:11:23 So obviously we want our community as healthy as possible as part of your strategic plan.

0:11:26 I would like to do the same and provide that opportunity for them so they can continue

0:11:32 on their process and get both services to progress and to maintain.

0:11:37 Some of them may just maintain but that's good to keep them moving and keep them healthy

0:11:42 and strong and mental health and all the whole mind, body, spirit that we find in body.

0:11:50 Okay.

0:11:52 Are there questions?

0:11:53 Okay.

0:11:55 Go ahead.

0:11:56 When I read your application again through in the packet that we received,

0:12:00 it made a lot more sense from our perspective as a city.

0:12:03 I appreciate the work that you did on that.

0:12:06 You'll have to forgive my vagueness the first time around.

0:12:09 That's my first time, but I'll get better.

0:12:11 I got an idea of what you're looking for now and how it helps you to go.

0:12:14 Tell me the ins and outs getting the weeds with me so we know what we're doing, so I understand.

0:12:18 Thank you for the opportunity.

0:12:20 I'm ready to make a motion when the discussion is over,

0:12:24 over but I appreciate you taking the effort and the time to come back. It's not always

0:12:28 easy. It's not easy for us but also being an applicant understand that it is a bit of

0:12:33 a process. So appreciate you coming back and just to be clear it is in the staff report

0:12:42 that these scholarships will be specifically for Twin Falls residents.

0:12:46 So we started last week at 13 that came in and worked with us. The furthest was

0:12:54 that's where we want to stay. That's where we're trying to work with.

0:12:58 Okay, thank you. Anybody else? Jason, go ahead.

0:13:03 I'd move to approve the MPOT grant application

0:13:07 for HCC Foundation in the amount of $10,000.

0:13:11 Thank you. Do you have a second? I second. Thank you. Motion by Jason Brown,

0:13:15 seconded by Alex Koval to

0:13:19 approve the application of $10,000

0:13:23 from HCC Foundation for MPOG funds.

0:13:27 Any further discussion?

0:13:29 Amy Roquevo, please.

0:13:31 Alex Cabal.

0:13:32 Yes.

0:13:33 Spencer Cutler.

0:13:34 Yes.

0:13:34 Ruth Pierce.

0:13:35 Yes.

0:13:36 Chris Reed.

0:13:36 Yes.

0:13:37 Thank you, Boyd.

0:13:38 Yes.

0:13:38 Ray Hawkins.

0:13:39 Yes.

0:13:40 And Jason Grant.

0:13:40 Yes.

0:13:42 Thank you, motion passes 7 to 0.

0:13:44 Thank you.

0:13:46 OK.

0:13:47 Next item on the agenda is an adoption item.

0:13:53 It's an adoption of the 2020 Idaho standards public works construction and city revisions there too

0:14:01 And we have toy vtech our city engineer welcome Troy. Thank you mayor and council

0:14:07 Tonight I'm before you with the recommendation to adopt the new isp wc 2020 version

0:14:14 Or reference let's just document

0:14:17 So a little background um

0:14:19 We need many decades ago. There's a lot of different city engineers. They all had kind of personal preferences.

0:14:24 They went through and created a bunch of drawings that were specific to their needs and what they desired.

0:14:30 Early to 20 teens area, we thought, well, we couldn't have contractors from out of the valley come and start doing work on our project because they didn't know our standards.

0:14:41 So we said, let's go through an adoption process.

0:14:44 In 2015, 2015 ISBWC came out, we reviewed it, made our recommendations for changes and ended up being a document suchly like this.

0:14:56 This modifies this document says, eh, we like this, but we want to make minor changes, minor.

0:15:03 And in 2016 that was adopted by City and the Council, so now we're kind of uniformed throughout the state.

0:15:09 state every three years, they come up with a new document that takes all the input, the

0:15:14 ISPWC, that's a board of engineers, some construction workers, a few other cities throughout, and

0:15:22 we are lucky enough to have one of the board members working for us, Josh Baird is a member

0:15:27 of that board, so he takes our recommendations because he's very throughout and leads everything

0:15:33 and he takes it back and now they've put a lot of our recommendations into the new one.

0:15:38 This book is going to get a lot thinner.

0:15:41 We try to review it every three years.

0:15:45 It comes out every three years by the time we get it,

0:15:47 get through the effort and be down short stuff.

0:15:49 We're a little bit behind,

0:15:50 but now we're at the point where we're ready for adoption.

0:15:53 It tells contractors how to build on the future,

0:15:56 so we're going to recommend adoption of the 2020 ICBC.

0:16:01 The city revisions.

0:16:03 There are two sections that were in our book previously.

0:16:07 They're now supplemental in this binder.

0:16:09 We're going to adopt those two supplementals as well.

0:16:13 It's the pavement thickness and the pay factor.

0:16:17 It talks about how the city will pay for projects and how we will accept

0:16:22 projects from developers as well as standardized pavement thickness.

0:16:27 If you have any questions, I can get in specifics.

0:16:31 So this is the 2020.

0:16:34 So when you said they renew it every three years, so like they're going to issue one this year,

0:16:38 I would expect the 2023 to come out and then we'll immediately get a copy of it and start reviewing it to something

0:16:44 Okay, and I'll take us a year or so to get through that

0:16:46 Okay

0:16:48 Questions for a try. Oh, I forgot one thing. Yes. I apologize. We did meet with the development group because we don't want to surprise him or anything

0:16:56 there were some

0:16:58 Audification to this primarily with pavement thickness our pavement residential roads are

0:17:04 really in my mind substandard

0:17:06 they're the

0:17:08 by the Cambridge, Rome, counties that are all using quite a bit thicker. Talk to them, it's a cost to them, it's a cost to the general subdivision.

0:17:20 It's not the best, but we focus our reconstructive efforts on these large collectors, arterials, because we only have limited amount of funding.

0:17:28 We just seal coat local residential roads, we try to make them as long as possible, easiest way to do that, build them better the first time.

0:17:37 primarily see failures where correct compactive procedures happen in your

0:17:43 valley getter so we believe this will help lengthen that road span and help us

0:17:48 with that in negotiations with the developers we're also looking at a road

0:17:55 width change as part of the master transportation plan that I'm going to

0:17:58 bring before you in the future our local roads or residential roads are wider

0:18:04 when I think they need to be our desire there and maybe it's a value analysis

0:18:11 there we want to keep people kids safe residential roads they've gotten

0:18:16 conservatively wide because we want parking cars that go fast when you drive

0:18:21 a president's street you go slow because you got to maneuver around the guy that's

0:18:24 uncommon to you and you have to advocate that so we're gonna eventually

0:18:31 brief forth to counsel the opportunity to possibly narrow the roads trying to

0:18:36 leave you some of that financial impact that this change to them so other than

0:18:41 that I think it was well received by the development community there's no other

0:18:44 comments of them that dressed on those Jason Brown I yeah I've received some

0:18:54 comments from the development community and just want to make sure that we're

0:18:58 keeping them engaged keeping them you know have an open ear to them because

0:19:04 Obviously it's a cost to them, but it's also a cost to the home buyer at the back end of that, but appreciate all the effort going into this.

0:19:12 Obviously, no the amount of effort that goes into making sure that we're doing the right thing for the community at large.

0:19:20 So appreciate that. I'm willing to make a motion if Alex, do you have a comment?

0:19:25 I had a question.

0:19:26 Um, streets, when I did the tour, told me what the pavement thickness was.

0:19:32 I knew we were thinner than surrounding districts.

0:19:34 What is our current pavement thickness for development and then what is it going to be under those?

0:19:40 It is currently two and a half inches of pavement asphalt and eight inches of bait, ten inches.

0:19:48 Eight inches of base and two and a half inches of asphalt.

0:19:52 This section increases it I think 17 inches of base still two and a half inches of asphalt

0:20:02 Substantially larger

0:20:04 All right. Thank you. Hey Jason. Go ahead move to approve the adoption of the 2020

0:20:11 Idaho standard or Idaho standard public works construction and revisions

0:20:16 With the City of Twin Falls. Thank you. Do I have a second? I second. Thank you

0:20:22 motion by Jason Brown second by Spencer Cutler to adopt approve the adoption of

0:20:29 the 2020 idle standards public works construction and the city revisions

0:20:34 there to any further discussion Amy Rolkavo please Spencer Cutler yes yes

0:20:43 yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes

0:20:52 Thank you, Motion passes 7 to 0.

0:20:55 Thank you, Troy.

0:20:56 Don't go away.

0:20:58 Next item on the agenda is an action item, Consideration of Award for the 2023 ChiffSeal

0:21:04 Project to Emory Inc in the amount of $1,436.30 or $36,017.32.

0:21:16 And we have Troy.

0:21:18 Thank you again.

0:21:19 This is our yearly Zone Maintenance Program.

0:21:22 This year we're Chip Ceiling Zone 3.

0:21:25 We've broken the city into eight zones.

0:21:26 I think you're all familiar with that.

0:21:30 Zone 3 is a larger zone for us.

0:21:33 We're currently looking at rebalance in the zones, but in the current interim this is what

0:21:37 our zone 3 is.

0:21:40 And I've got a map up there, and you can either switch to the location.

0:21:49 So this is...

0:21:50 Well, it is a big area.

0:21:55 It is substantial so it's been down this kind of the shoshone street you see here.

0:22:00 It's the north side of the old town as well as everything to the west.

0:22:05 A little bit north, this is farther you see up here Washington Street.

0:22:10 It's general area.

0:22:11 So this is a chiseled project.

0:22:12 We have to do a public bidding process to the size of this.

0:22:15 We received one bid, Emory.

0:22:17 They've done, worked with us, historically in the past almost every year.

0:22:22 The bid was for $1,436,000.

0:22:24 I will note that budgeted was $1,248,000.

0:22:29 So where did we come up with the money?

0:22:32 Originally, we had a project on the books for 11th Reconstruction, and we're doing a water

0:22:37 light in the area.

0:22:38 It's an older residential road to creating.

0:22:41 We thought, well, if we're going to be there fixing it,

0:22:44 just reconstruct it.

0:22:46 Due to the overage of this, streets and water

0:22:49 kind of got together, water will replace the existing

0:22:51 transport, but we're probably not going to expand out

0:22:53 and redo the whole streets.

0:22:54 The residential road, very limited.

0:22:57 They're going to chip seal it.

0:22:58 That's part of that project.

0:23:00 And utilize that money to use on this to cover that overage.

0:23:06 So we don't have to ask for additionals

0:23:08 or go on the street reserves.

0:23:09 It's just kind of a change of philosophy.

0:23:11 They do believe that that 11th will continue to hold up and just won't be a full reconstruct.

0:23:21 It looks like it was well below the engineer's estimate, which is always good to see.

0:23:29 Emory's bid.

0:23:30 It was actually slightly above the R estimate was 1.2 or our budget was 1.2.

0:23:36 No, the engineer's estimate was 1.5.

0:23:39 Oh, yes.

0:23:40 5.9?

0:23:41 Yeah, sorry.

0:23:43 So that's always good to see.

0:23:45 questions for Troy if not I'd entertain a motion. I'll make one. Thank you Jason move to approve the award of the 2023 chipsail project to

0:24:05 Emery Inc. in the amount of $1,436,017.32. Thank you to have a second second. Thank you motion by Jason Brown second by Craig Hawkins to approve the

0:24:20 award of the 2020 CHIP sale project to Emory Inc. and the amount of $1,436,017.32. Any further

0:24:32 discussion? Yes.

0:24:34 Troy, I noticed on this bid that there wasn't anything in there for potential, what is it,

0:24:43 overages? Are we contingencies? That's what I'm looking for. Are we anticipating anything?

0:24:49 Or are we okay?

0:24:51 This is above ground we can usually see this unforeseen circumstances are very rare in this case

0:24:57 The biggest thing that we work with them are on is traffic control of the sweet beat

0:25:01 Both of which we can control. All right. Thanks that answered my question. Thank you anybody else

0:25:07 Amy roll call vote, please

0:25:10 Ruth Pierce. Yes. Yes. Yes. Thank you Boyd. Yes

0:25:14 as Craig Hawkins, Jason Brown, Alex Cabal, and Spencer Cutler.

0:25:20 Yes.

0:25:21 Thank you, motion passes seven to zero.

0:25:23 Thank you, Troy.

0:25:27 OK, that is all under items of consideration.

0:25:31 Next on the agenda is general public input.

0:25:34 There's anybody in the public that wishes to come down

0:25:38 and address city council on something not on today's agenda.

0:25:42 You're welcome to see no one advisory board reports.

0:25:49 Anybody have a report? Jason Brown.

0:25:53 I'll just jump in here with the Community Foundation.

0:25:56 We've got the air show coming up here in a couple of weeks.

0:26:00 The foundation has been helping and assisting with that,

0:26:03 but just a shout out for the air show again.

0:26:07 Hopefully we can participate.

0:26:09 Yeah, 75th anniversary of the airport.

0:26:12 That was my update for the airport.

0:26:16 Yeah, it's going to be really.

0:26:21 Yeah, yeah. Yep. Still VIP tickets available. If you want to be in the VIP group, you can

0:26:30 there's still some tickets I hear. Oh, I haven't heard that. We have our meeting tomorrow. I

0:26:35 have my tickets already. I do too. So cool. I just wanted to thank everybody that participated

0:26:43 in Western days. I know that was a big lift for the city. A lot of people volunteered

0:26:47 hours and worked over time so thank you to everybody that participated and made

0:26:52 sure that that was a good event and a safe event so thank you. Yes thank you.

0:26:58 Anybody else? City manager's office. I have two things quickly to share with you.

0:27:04 Next week we're going to start our meeting at four o'clock. We're going to

0:27:07 start with an executive session so the regular business will start at five like

0:27:11 usual and the following week is a holiday Juneteenth holiday so we'll not be

0:27:17 having our meeting on Monday the following week. So no meeting on the 19th,

0:27:20 meeting on the 12th starts at 4.

0:27:22 Okay, thank you. And we have no public hearings. Next on the agenda is

0:27:29 Executive Session to communicate with legal counsel for the public agency to

0:27:36 discuss the legal ramifications of and legal options for pending litigation or

0:27:42 controversies not yet being litigated but imminently likely to be litigated. The

0:27:47 near presence of legal counsel and executive session does not satisfy this requirement.

0:27:52 And that was FJ to consider labor contract matters authorized under section 74-206A1-AMB

0:28:02 idocode.

0:28:03 So moved.

0:28:04 Thank you, Chris.

0:28:05 Thank you.

0:28:06 Motion by Christopher Reed, seconded by Alex Koval, to move into executive session under

0:28:13 704-206-A1-AMB and section F&J. Amy Rokavo, please.

0:28:21 Chris Reed. Yes.

0:28:24 Thank you, Boyd. Yes. Greg Hawkins. Yes.

0:28:27 Jason Brown. Yes. Alex Kaval. Yes.

0:28:29 Spencer Cutler. Yes. Yes.

0:28:32 Motion passes 7-0. Just to let everybody know, we will not be making any decisions in executive

0:28:39 session and we will not be reconvening down in chambers so meetings adjourned.

0:28:45 Thank you.

0:32:55 Right.

0:32:56 Can you hear me?

0:32:57 It sounds like it's working.

0:33:01 Oh, now it isn't.

0:33:10 Okay everybody, welcome to our June Twin Falls Public Art Commission meeting today and we do

0:33:17 have a quorum, yay, so we're meeting and move forward.

0:33:24 We just have a consent calendar for our meeting minutes from last month.

0:33:29 We don't have that.

0:33:31 I was just looking at that.

0:33:32 I don't see it.

0:33:36 So got it.

0:33:37 See, we switched it up and I just didn't realize.

0:33:40 Okay.

0:33:41 Okay.

0:33:42 Our first action item is to approve our minutes from May 2nd meeting.

0:33:47 So I would entertain a motion to accept the meeting minutes from last month.

0:33:58 Yellen, do I have a second?

0:34:01 Thank you, Tim. I want to do a real call vote.

0:34:05 Hello, Luis.

0:34:06 Laura Stewart.

0:34:07 Yes.

0:34:08 Drew Nash.

0:34:09 Yes.

0:34:10 Jeneel Dean.

0:34:11 Yes.

0:34:12 Tim Haver.

0:34:13 Yes.

0:34:15 Thanks, everybody.

0:34:16 All right.

0:34:18 So this first item on B is process development discussion, and you got my email with some thoughts.

0:34:28 So, this was based upon our last meeting where we had a lot of interest in projects and we

0:34:38 realized we're not sure if we have a clear direction on some things and so we're talking

0:34:43 a little more about that today.

0:34:45 Sorry.

0:34:47 Just to round robin with all of us and see where we're kind of thinking we should head

0:34:51 for just a smoother process, application process.

0:34:55 Does that make sense?

0:34:56 I'm going to.

0:34:57 So, as we were getting started, every step we take, we realize we're missing something,

0:35:04 right?

0:35:05 So, now we have all these things come at us and everybody sits and goes, and what do we

0:35:10 do?

0:35:11 So, this was kind of an opportunity, I think, to swing back on reflecting on so we give

0:35:18 people an opportunity to fill out an application, and this would probably be really centered

0:35:22 more on the things where people approach us.

0:35:25 So if you're out there soliciting work, if you identify a project and you decide you want to do some work on something,

0:35:32 and that process you can define, what you can't anticipate and define is when people submit applications and bring ideas to you.

0:35:43 So then, how do you want those things to flow through?

0:35:49 And maybe we can start with, so we have them fill out the application.

0:35:54 Eloise and I have reviewed them.

0:35:57 She takes a look at them. She asks me some questions.

0:36:00 There have been times where we've gone back to the applicant to say,

0:36:03 hey, we need a little bit more information here.

0:36:06 So that by the time it gets to you guys, we're hoping they have kind of covered the

0:36:11 basis of the information now.

0:36:13 We said we wanted to know in order to consider it.

0:36:16 it. And then, so we're not going to put something in front of you that has no, that's not ready.

0:36:29 You know, we'll work with whoever to get it ready enough so that the basis, so that you

0:36:35 guys wouldn't be the ones to take a look at it and say, well, how big is this? Or, you

0:36:40 know, something, so we'll try to catch that kind of stuff. But then once they come, what

0:36:46 do we want that to look like as part of the conversation that we had is okay so

0:36:50 now that it's there and we've reviewed it and it winds up on your agenda. I think

0:36:57 in addition to that I want to just call out the chalk festival that Arnell

0:37:01 brought that is an event and that is from what he presented it was like well

0:37:08 here's the idea you guys go ahead and do it and make it happen and I've got some

0:37:13 talents on the back end to help you out but that's really not our intent as an

0:37:18 event plan or do our group approver depending on what it is yes perhaps but

0:37:25 there's already an event application process through the city that anyone can

0:37:29 fill out regardless of the fair statement we have a few holes there too

0:37:37 perhaps in some of our application and we did kind of talk about this before

0:37:42 Do you guys feel like you understand what that event process looks like?

0:37:49 How, how, when we were developing our policy, we talked about this a little bit and I'm just, I'm curious, do you want me to spend a couple minutes and just kind of walk you through what that looks like typically?

0:38:01 Sure, I was, I was not here last meeting, so I need to be a refresher.

0:38:06 But I don't understand is how you can sit over there and hardly get picked up.

0:38:13 I mean I'm booming through the room and I'm like...

0:38:16 I don't need milk very well.

0:38:18 Oh and maybe mine's close to my mouth.

0:38:20 I don't know. Anyway, so sorry. I'm shouting but I'm not.

0:38:24 Okay, so typically an event.

0:38:27 I'm trying to think of western days.

0:38:32 Okay, so western days is a huge community event.

0:38:36 or crazy days, or October Fest.

0:38:39 Maybe it'll do October Fest because October Fest is on the road.

0:38:43 Let's do October Fest because it would be closer to what the talk festival would look like.

0:38:47 So October Fest, they start usually by coming to Parks and Rec, looking for space availability.

0:38:58 If you do it right, that's where you should start.

0:39:01 I want to do this event on this day.

0:39:03 Is it available?

0:39:04 Yes, it is. Here's an application. And as they fill it out, they get asked certain questions and depending on what kinds of questions, how they answer those questions, there's four things that would send them into a special event.

0:39:18 A special event has to be a gathering of over 250 or 500, 500.

0:39:24 So over 500 people and or a road closure and or amplified sound and or sale of alcohol.

0:39:35 So those four questions, if they answer yes to any one or more, it sends them into the special

0:39:42 event process also.

0:39:45 And the special event process is a big application that that's kind of managed by the police department

0:39:50 and then reviewed by everybody else.

0:39:52 So these are the kinds of events where somebody plans to put it on.

0:39:58 You know, we're going to do this.

0:40:00 We just want to know if we can.

0:40:03 And we need to get permission to put this kind of an event on.

0:40:06 So a chalk festival in my mind would be the same thing.

0:40:08 He's probably going to want to close a section of downtown.

0:40:12 He probably would want some music.

0:40:14 probably would have food vendors and things and so they'd need to know is that

0:40:22 space available it's you know don't pick the same day as the farmers market you

0:40:27 know whatever so they would be looking for space and then they would be going

0:40:30 through the special event process in my mind the only time that kind of a an event

0:40:37 would wind up in front of this Commission is if they're catering to the arts

0:40:44 and they wanted some funding.

0:40:47 We want you to buy materials

0:40:51 so that we can invite these artists

0:40:53 to do this work on the sidewalk.

0:40:54 Or we want it to be a judged competition

0:40:58 and we think it would be really awesome

0:41:00 if the public art commission would throw us $5,000

0:41:05 so that we can give rise money

0:41:08 to people that are participating.

0:41:12 So if they're needing, in my mind,

0:41:14 That would be more like a financial support piece is where it would get to you if it's a standalone event.

0:41:20 Does that, any questions on kind of how that works and that's why when we talked about this before, I thought,

0:41:26 I can't imagine very many events because I don't think, I don't think the Public Arts Commission necessarily has a role in determining whether or not

0:41:37 Twin Falls Municipal Band is an appropriate event to have in the park, or the bands at

0:41:43 Western Days, or the art in the park event, you know, unless you were solicited to be a part of it,

0:41:53 I don't think you're going to screen for appropriateness.

0:41:57 I have one additional question, one thing piece, if it were doing a contest for example,

0:42:03 Let's say there's no money involved, no contest, and planners want our help to do a call for

0:42:13 artists.

0:42:14 That could be our role in addition if we did a prize of cash.

0:42:19 But that's where we could talk in.

0:42:22 Yeah.

0:42:23 And I think there's two probably two potential entities that could.

0:42:28 One could be the public art commission, one could be the match value arts council.

0:42:32 True.

0:42:34 or interest, right?

0:42:38 Because I think on our application almost feels

0:42:42 like they're applying to the event approval a little bit.

0:42:47 You know what I mean?

0:42:48 Just by maybe, I can't remember what our questions are.

0:42:52 But it might be kind of a misinterpretation

0:42:55 of what this process needs to look like.

0:42:57 It could be that maybe the ask wasn't clear.

0:43:07 And I don't know.

0:43:08 And it might not, I'm trying to remember exactly.

0:43:11 But yes, well, I know when I had asked specifically with the Chalk Festival, like what's your role in this?

0:43:18 So are you wanting us to do it and then hire you for your services on promoting it?

0:43:24 That's when he said, yes.

0:43:26 You went okay now.

0:43:28 Yeah, that's what I wanted to do.

0:43:33 That's what I was thinking.

0:43:34 So yeah, and it could just be also that here we are new, right?

0:43:38 We're trying to figure this out.

0:43:39 And we're walking in the dark, trying to figure out our plant, and now this has happened.

0:43:48 And so now we could possibly, on the backside, say, no, wait a minute, we get something like

0:43:53 that again and we say, so this looks like an event.

0:43:57 Are you, what do you want the art to do?

0:44:04 Because if you just want them to give it their blessing, they don't need to.

0:44:08 If you want support in some way, whether it's manpower or promotion or funding, now it's

0:44:18 appropriate to go talk to them.

0:44:20 And so we could maybe vet the next thing that comes down the pipe that looks kind of like

0:44:25 this better because now we've seen what happens when it shows up in front of you and everybody

0:44:30 goes, oh what?

0:44:31 We don't know if that fits with us very well.

0:44:37 I think that's like right.

0:44:38 And then that kind of moves with the Rock Creek part.

0:44:42 That he was asking to actually put semi-permanent

0:44:46 art up on public property.

0:44:48 And to me, that's where I see the appropriateness.

0:44:50 Yeah, so if you look at those two requests,

0:44:53 if we want to use those as examples for process,

0:44:56 coming and talking to you to say,

0:44:58 here's some ideas about some event you could do.

0:45:03 That's where the commission says,

0:45:05 We don't know if we want to be event planners, but if he had come and said I

0:45:10 Need some money for this piece of this event, and that would be appropriate still, but you're right the rock Creek one

0:45:17 Isn't that far off of?

0:45:20 The electrical boxes right hey, I think this is a way to beautify this space would you consider?

0:45:28 Purchasing one of these wraps that we can put down there on that and see if that curves vandalism that

0:45:33 but could very well be a reasonable request of this group.

0:45:41 Or it could be, hey, here's a project we think would be really important to do down there.

0:45:47 Is this something you want to take on?

0:45:49 And then it might be a conversation to say, you know, how does this fit within what the city is trying to do?

0:45:57 And is putting public art down in Rock Creek a priority anywhere?

0:46:03 Do we think it's important and do we as a commission want to make it a priority and make some recommendations to say hey parks

0:46:10 Hey City Council, we think this is an important thing to do

0:46:14 My devil's advocate a little bit. I do have kind of a question on the philosophical side of it. So

0:46:24 Through this whole process, we've made really

0:46:28 careful consideration

0:46:30 to

0:46:32 represent all facets of art, including performing art, which would be more of an event-based kind of thing,

0:46:38 as well as in our mission and our values, we talk about education being a big piece,

0:46:43 which would also fall under more of the event side of things.

0:46:45 So how do we, in your opinion, still accommodate and perpetuate the educational pieces,

0:46:56 as well as in some of those other side pieces of art?

0:47:00 and fit them into our role, where it is appropriate,

0:47:05 and we're not trying to beat all these things

0:47:07 to all these people.

0:47:08 So thank you for that, Neil.

0:47:13 So I honestly, this has been the thing

0:47:16 that I have been wrestling with since we started

0:47:19 talking about this, and there's been members

0:47:25 of this commission that have pushed really hard

0:47:27 to make sure we don't forget about the performance art

0:47:30 pieces which are certainly an art thing. I agree. It gets really sticky trying to figure

0:47:41 out how to incorporate that piece. And I really feel like when you say what could that look

0:47:51 like, I would think it might be something more like the children's museum coming to the

0:47:58 Public Art Commission and saying, hey, we want to do this display and we want to

0:48:03 bring it from Minneapolis. And it's a $10,000 to have it for six months. Would

0:48:10 you guys support that? And we, and the group says, you know what? Yeah, that's

0:48:16 it's public consumption. It's going to be in the Children's Museum. Yes, we think

0:48:21 that's so maybe that hits both a performance piece or an educational piece.

0:48:26 I think you could and this is the part where we've talked about we don't have a

0:48:32 master plan yet so we haven't really made a roadmap to say here's the things

0:48:36 we want to start doing and if you were to identify some education or some

0:48:40 cultural performance pieces that you think is valuable then this group could

0:48:47 go out on the other side of it and recruit recruit stuff but otherwise I'm I

0:48:57 I still struggle in my head to figure out how they wind up here and not over there because

0:49:02 most of them are a production being put on by somebody and they've got the venue and

0:49:08 they've got the money and they just want to do it and get out of their way.

0:49:13 I mean I think if you know we wanted to do a call for action and say we want to hire

0:49:20 this local acting troupe to come in and perform during western days then that would be our

0:49:27 Performing arts thing that we would do a call for artists on and get bids or whatever like to do some sort of

0:49:33 Western day shoot out thing or something, but we would drive it

0:49:36 So if it's coming to us the only thing we're responsible for would be saying is this this is fit

0:49:42 You know our goals and values and we would just be the part of the purse as far as I'm concerned

0:49:48 Potentially like we would be okay. Well, yeah, you you you you're gonna do the call for artists for this truck thing or whatever

0:49:54 Yeah, you were asking $400 for supplies that we could say yes or no to, but that's kind

0:50:01 of where the buck stops us and that's where the one's doing the call for artists.

0:50:06 Does that answer, does that kind of get you to where, how we would have these conversations

0:50:11 and from the very beginning when we continued to push this in my mind, I was like, oh, that's

0:50:16 a good one.

0:50:19 feel like one not only what we do is the creative arm of dealing with people and

0:50:28 their ideas for the city but also when you're presenting a proposal to somebody

0:50:35 there's a lot of flexibility in room in there to you know fulfill certain rules

0:50:42 or say well instead of this me just asking you to do it would if we tweaked

0:50:48 it and went out of this direction, and that could be something we could do, whereas this,

0:50:53 like as it sits right now, isn't.

0:50:56 And so maybe that's where, you know, for instance, like with the Chalk Festival, we go back and

0:51:03 say, okay, we are not event planners, but if you wanted help with a few of these things,

0:51:13 then we could help you put it on.

0:51:16 And so, question about that piece, I always want to be with quality, anything that we engage

0:51:27 with.

0:51:28 If we feel, believe, person's coming to us, doesn't have the skills to do that, I mean,

0:51:37 I think we need to be realistic and say, you know what, it's not truly bedded out, we don't

0:51:42 believe that you can go back to the drawing board and bring it back to us, but I want

0:51:46 be careful about just, yeah, not everyone gets how to know.

0:51:51 Well, and I think that's going to be the judge or the criteria on the application where we

0:51:56 ask who the community partners are that they're with.

0:51:59 So if they're with groups that have put on events before, then that would help that.

0:52:05 But I agree, I think that kind of goes back to the appropriateness question is to me

0:52:11 whether or not somebody's qualified to even do that is a question of appropriateness,

0:52:16 not just content. Absolutely, yeah, that makes sense. And then if you think about, so this is,

0:52:21 he presents an event. What about this? Now I'm going to turn, I'm going to pivot a little bit to

0:52:29 Tim's presentation. And so Tim comes in and has, and if I were to pull what you did into a really

0:52:39 basic comment. I think you you were approaching the group saying, hey, there's

0:52:46 really cool ways we can connect this community through fun and celebrate

0:52:52 art and celebrate performance and whatever all. If we were to get away from

0:52:59 specific ideas of things that you suggested a whole bunch of things, well

0:53:04 maybe we could do this, maybe we could do this, maybe we could do this, but if you

0:53:07 we were to go back and say that here's a person saying,

0:53:12 what does the commission feel about,

0:53:15 or how does the commission feel about creating

0:53:19 some of these opportunities, or prioritizing this?

0:53:21 Which, in that case, could then flip around to say,

0:53:25 yeah, we think that's important,

0:53:28 and that's something we want to do.

0:53:29 And then maybe this group then goes out,

0:53:33 and goes out at opposites.

0:53:35 And now you say, we think this would be a really cool event.

0:53:38 We're going to work through what the philosophy behind or what's our goal here.

0:53:44 And then you put out a call for somebody to put it on for you, or a way to make it happen.

0:53:51 And then you facilitate it through getting a contractor.

0:53:57 So there's, you know, this is a comment saying, hey, here's some cool things that maybe we

0:54:03 could get behind.

0:54:04 What do you guys think about this?

0:54:06 Should we place some value on some event kinds of things with this in mind, maybe you jump

0:54:13 behind it and then maybe you put a call for, maybe it's not a call for artists, but it's

0:54:18 a call for an event planner to come in and say, yeah, that's super cool.

0:54:22 We want to get behind that versus here's an event you guys should do it.

0:54:42 And I like the idea of what are our priorities.

0:54:44 We don't have a master plan.

0:54:47 We have guidance with our mission, vision, and values, but it's pretty good.

0:54:53 Well, and we know what the public doesn't want, which is more mirrorful.

0:54:57 Which just rags me up.

0:55:00 It's kind of like pickleball.

0:55:03 And it's not really, I mean, it is, but it isn't because it's funny.

0:55:06 The whole pickleball thing just happened, and it was hilarious because there was a group

0:55:10 that really pushed heart on that survey, and this was kind of behind my, before my time,

0:55:14 and it was like every way you could ask the question, they kept saying, no, don't

0:55:18 do that and so what's the first thing we did out of the shoot was put a lot of money in the pickleball

0:55:23 and it was big deal so but I just I felt like oh this is pickleball revisited no murals okay

0:55:30 well here's what we're gonna do we're gonna pay the mural every while we can find boxes all over

0:55:36 and then we'll go down and do some down in rock creek yeah because you guys said you don't want it

0:55:40 So I think part of it would be maybe revisiting the survey results to see where that first

0:55:50 priority is.

0:55:51 I remember no murals.

0:55:52 I remember no murals.

0:55:53 I don't remember what they were prior.

0:55:54 I knew too.

0:55:55 And I just, I don't know why I just think it's so funny.

0:55:58 Okay, that's what they don't want.

0:56:00 I think with the CHOC Festival, the first thing we could kick back to or know would be

0:56:08 Find a community partner that wants to put the event on.

0:56:12 And that could be easily Southern Idaho tourism.

0:56:15 That could be, I know, or it could be a view of others.

0:56:21 You could easily just be a comment that says,

0:56:24 we really appreciate your proposal.

0:56:28 This is really not what we do.

0:56:31 If you pull this together and get it a little more well-defined

0:56:36 and figure out how you want to do it and you do have a need from us, you know,

0:56:42 we're bringing it back and we'll have another conversation.

0:56:46 But for right now, we don't see anything to act on and it doesn't fit within our purview.

0:56:51 And that's an easy answer to.

0:56:53 Because I think that could be something that's a million different ways of if you wanted

0:56:59 that event to happen to happen.

0:57:01 And I think it could be a good draw for the city, but that's not our role.

0:57:05 But I think in guiding him urging to find a partner, you know, as event planning experienced

0:57:16 I do with this because I think you need that.

0:57:29 Question for the group in connection to this project but also all projects that you consider

0:57:33 is you currently have a budget of about 60,000 money sitting in a bank and I think you probably

0:57:39 get another 6,000 each year.

0:57:41 So how much budget are you willing to put at a time?

0:57:47 think you should consider that because if you put it all in one thing you all are

0:57:52 doing just one thing and that's it. That's exactly it. Sorry that's the bankruptcy

0:57:57 attorney talking to you. One thing Alex that piggybacks on that and this is like

0:58:02 a continuation of a Sean strategy when we first formed because the budget is a

0:58:10 a disheartening topic. He thought that it might be a good idea for us to do at least

0:58:19 a project and a successful project and then use that as a tool to take to city council to

0:58:26 either ask for an increase or start getting creative on additional places that a budget

0:58:33 could be formed and come from and so for instance since we have limited funds and

0:58:39 we might have to only put it into one thing like to me even though the traffic

0:58:46 boxes are really benign project it's one that would have a presence all over the

0:58:53 city instead of just being one little thing that is there it's the multiple

0:58:58 things around the entire community.

0:59:01 And so that could be one project that has a bigger impact

0:59:06 on more people served and more people seen it.

0:59:10 I don't know.

0:59:13 That could potentially take.

0:59:16 Or we just say, you know, we'll do up to four

0:59:19 and five or whatever, and then use that as a pilot.

0:59:32 How do we feel that we're, where was process development?

0:59:35 Are we event planners?

0:59:40 You're not an endo.

0:59:43 I'm not an agreement.

0:59:44 I think we totally could be event plans.

0:59:46 You haven't spoken.

0:59:47 I was going to say feel free to.

0:59:49 We can get the subcommittees.

0:59:50 We can bring in people.

0:59:52 I think our budget would go better towards planning a big event

0:59:56 than to just put a couple boxes around down.

0:59:59 Sure.

1:00:00 Some of the traffic will go in through there, but we're not going in with the model

1:00:03 that we say about in livening the community and livening public spaces

1:00:07 because we're making a public space look pretty, but

1:00:10 It's still just the same sidewalk.

1:00:12 It's the same traffic hell that is the US in concrete jungle.

1:00:17 But now I think we could totally go the event planning route.

1:00:21 I like the kind of what you've talked about,

1:00:23 how there are those, what is more the city side and more what's us.

1:00:26 But I could see the chalk festival easily fitting

1:00:29 in our jurisdiction as long as he said,

1:00:31 hey, all the funding is going to go towards public arts,

1:00:34 like any profit that's made from it.

1:00:37 So I could see that side if they just said,

1:00:39 Hey, I want the events and all proceeds to go back towards public art, then it is going to be under our purview.

1:00:44 But now I feel like if we focus more on connecting people through art and connecting people,

1:00:52 then that's how we get the art to grow. That's how we get the funding.

1:00:55 Because, I mean, like Camille said before, meeting last week was, what's the big event and to involve?

1:00:59 That pulls everybody.

1:01:01 There's not one left there, which is the same thing it's been for 50 plus years.

1:01:07 They just add a couple more rides and a couple more saws.

1:01:11 Western Days is the fair, as I've heard a quote of the fair without rides, but not

1:01:18 downplay those parts that are part of our community and have been around, but it's

1:01:22 the same thing.

1:01:23 And how can we pull in the big thing that's going to bring in tourism, so the first idea

1:01:27 throughout was the Snake River Bakes Toming Festival.

1:01:29 A lot of facets there, but it does capitalize on a huge tourist attraction we have in the

1:01:34 area that brings people from all over the world to come jump at our bridge.

1:01:37 Now we have a focused event to try and get in tourist funds because yeah, people spend

1:01:42 every summer or do a trip every other summer, come to Twin Falls, jump off the bridge and

1:01:46 then go to some other high adrenaline activities, but I feel like if we capitalize on that, the

1:01:52 culture of that area there, I think if we did that, become the big event.

1:01:57 Then that's also, let's everyone know that the Public Arts Commission is a thing.

1:02:00 Because a lot of people don't know where the thing is.

1:02:04 Can we?

1:02:05 Can we use events as fundraisers for our own budgets?

1:02:12 Kind of think we can.

1:02:14 This was something I wrestled with when I was in NAMPA,

1:02:18 and so I would want to double check it.

1:02:20 But, you know, when we used to put on events in NAMPA,

1:02:23 the intent was never to make money off of it.

1:02:27 But then we started trying to get sponsors,

1:02:31 and then finally we thought, you know,

1:02:33 we need to communicate what we're doing.

1:02:35 were doing and we were actually raising money and then donating it to scholarships for kids

1:02:41 to participate in programs and things. So it was a way to raise some money for that kind

1:02:45 of thing. And I think we need to be careful and we probably want to ask some questions

1:02:50 but in essence that's kind of what recreation does. It's kind of what the pool does. It's

1:02:59 kind of what we do with utility billing. We, the city does generate funds to provide services.

1:03:07 And so in a kind of loose term, I would think that doing of doing something to generate revenue,

1:03:19 to support public art, it happened. I have another secondary type legal question.

1:03:35 So, if we wanted to do the Chuck Festival, since our now brought the idea to us without

1:03:44 the willingness to actually execute on it, and we took it and made it our event and we

1:03:51 used it to fundraise for our budgets and things like that, would there be any ramification

1:03:56 of him turning around and saying, well I brought the idea to you guys and you took it and

1:04:00 ran with it. Second piggyback question is he was part of his proposal, he was

1:04:06 pitching us hiring him to do marketing services, and if we were to say we don't

1:04:12 think that's the appropriate channel to hire somebody to do that or they might

1:04:17 not be the right fit, are we allowed to not consider that portion of the proposal?

1:04:22 Yeah.

1:04:23 Then he's really deleted from the process, to be the case.

1:04:28 I'd be curious on openness of being able to take these projects and do it even if one

1:04:41 the person doesn't want to be a part of it or two they're not the appropriate fit for it.

1:04:51 Are very limited.

1:04:52 Well and I think that we could not have to spend money on it.

1:04:57 I think the city's channels could do it adequately without having to spend the additional money

1:05:04 on marketing.

1:05:05 One of the city contracts out for media services like that anyways.

1:05:10 And it's more of a Josh Palmer question I think, or perhaps, but yeah,

1:05:15 obviously our funds I don't think can go towards marketing.

1:05:18 No.

1:05:20 But the city's funds can and do.

1:05:23 Because I'd be willing to entertain it because Tim has about a point on

1:05:36 what would be our first Make Us Flash project that we could use it as a use case

1:05:42 to increase the budget. I said I would like to start smaller with something to

1:05:54 ensure we have that subcommittee parts of participation and this is a much bigger

1:05:58 ask of this commission or others that we haven't started with yet but Tim I

1:06:05 love the enthusiasm and I think but I want to make sure that we do it

1:06:10 or softly as I'm saying. Have all the details and cost comparisons on what it

1:06:18 cost and what we could hope to get out of it. And then we'll judge that from some of

1:06:23 the other projects on our plate to pick one we feel like would be the best.

1:06:27 Yeah, I just worry that as time goes on, we hear some other projects and then here we

1:06:36 are June next year and we still haven't done anything because we're just hearing all these

1:06:40 different things, all this budget versus that one really we have no budget ahead.

1:06:45 No, I totally get it. Anything we're going to commit to is going to be a big project

1:06:49 because it's going to take up at least 20% to 60% of our budget

1:06:54 in any one project we choose to do.

1:06:57 But what it is going to have the biggest impact, you know?

1:06:59 The boxes, I think, could be good for that community engagement.

1:07:02 It's all over the place, but at the end of the day,

1:07:05 you know, we just blew 25% of our budget to paint six boxes.

1:07:09 What if we looked at, because we're waiting

1:07:12 for the updated quote from Lidl on the rafts,

1:07:16 what if we saw how much it is per box

1:07:18 and we could look at doing a small scale event,

1:07:22 whether it's a chalk festival or something else,

1:07:24 but then had, and that one we find just a community partner,

1:07:29 maybe the Arts Council or something to help do it,

1:07:33 and we could keep the budget relatively low,

1:07:36 and we split budget between a couple of projects.

1:07:39 So we have...

1:07:44 So I think on a point of order here, I feel like...

1:07:49 Kind of all the way.

1:07:50 I feel like, yeah.

1:07:51 And so we're having a process discussion right now and the process discussion is kind of like

1:07:55 how do we want these, how do we want to move these requests through the process?

1:08:02 And I don't know if we really landed exactly on how we want to do that, but maybe it, maybe

1:08:08 what we start to think about and we can revisit this in the next meeting is so you get an application

1:08:13 and it comes in and they present it.

1:08:15 And you know, does, is there an expected decision to be made at that time or do we hear it?

1:08:22 And then we discuss it and then we, you know, so is it like a three month process that includes

1:08:28 an opportunity for, um, to hear the request and then process the request as a group, ask

1:08:38 more questions, whatever, have it come back, you know, I don't know, and maybe that's

1:08:44 kind of where we were headed is, I think part of the problem was we heard those

1:08:47 things and the group didn't know what to do about it. Like, do we make a decision?

1:08:51 How do we get there? What does that need to look like? And so maybe we dial that

1:08:55 back in a little bit and say, okay, how do you want your process to go? And what's

1:09:02 the reasonable expectation that we tell people? Okay, so you submit an

1:09:05 application, this is a six-month process or a five-month process or a

1:09:08 three months process or something that says you'll present the first time and

1:09:13 then they'll deliberate the next time. Well I think it kind of depends on what

1:09:18 they're asking for like for the donation request we've been able to make a

1:09:22 decision same time we hear the pitch and so that's just weighing whether or

1:09:26 not it makes sense and then asking for money I feel like we could hear the request

1:09:32 and then we could have a meeting to discuss it and then approve it but like

1:09:36 a whole project proposal to me is much more of a lengthy time period because we

1:09:41 have to kind of consider and weigh in a lot of things. So if they're asking for a

1:09:46 project to me that would be like maybe the three to six-month process or we just

1:09:53 decide it goes into the parking lot and we don't have the availability to do

1:09:57 that. So you're free to do it if you want but if you want us to do it it is

1:10:01 gonna have to go into a project parking lot until we have the means to do it.

1:10:06 or a no. We can give them one or the other. And then if they're asking for money I

1:10:12 feel like with one meeting we could take a look at our budgeting what we have

1:10:16 planned coming up and could make a realistic decision in a short order. And

1:10:20 then the donation probably like we have been in the past just consider the

1:10:28 request and then have a quick deliberation and make a decision. So to me it kind of

1:10:34 depends on what they're asking for.

1:10:39 I just have maybe just a tail on tears.

1:10:45 I think the donation is a separate thing.

1:10:47 I mean, I think we can make that fairly simple.

1:10:49 Kind of like the artwork that's being requested by the smart shower.

1:10:52 We can look at it and make a decision.

1:10:56 Anytime something comes to us, proposal of some sort,

1:10:59 I like the idea of we're presented the proposal.

1:11:02 It's been vetted by you and you and you.

1:11:04 Talk about it.

1:11:07 We hear it.

1:11:08 We don't talk about it because the person's there, we ask questions.

1:11:11 But then the next meeting, we review it and kind of go through the process.

1:11:14 Next meeting, we would do an yes or no voting basically.

1:11:20 I know that's a three month process, I get it.

1:11:22 But if it's something rather large, like a festival or something project,

1:11:28 then I think we need to take the time to get it out.

1:11:31 Sorry if I'm not being heard properly, but I'm just okay.

1:11:35 So that's just my two cents.

1:11:37 Put it right up on your lips and you're reading it for years, I've been doing this, it's always the same.

1:11:47 Tim and Jerry, what?

1:11:52 Concerning the process.

1:11:54 Yeah, but what makes logical sense to you?

1:11:56 I think donation, I mean it's already basically a different application process, I think.

1:12:01 Yeah, that can take one to two months, I think.

1:12:04 Yeah, I mean I basically read with everything that Janelle said in a year yourself, so.

1:12:09 a large project work should take at least three to six months.

1:12:14 Donations stuff can take one to two months,

1:12:16 and I think if it's just a money-funding mechanism,

1:12:19 you're probably looking at them once again,

1:12:21 one to two months, at once a month.

1:12:24 That's how much more we can do.

1:12:26 We have an hour.

1:12:28 Okay, Tim.

1:12:31 Let's see, so I was going to ask this,

1:12:32 so what if we say we have a project come in, we like it,

1:12:36 but we don't have the funding for it?

1:12:38 Could we at our next meeting be like,

1:12:40 Hey, we would like to move forward with this,

1:12:41 but could you come back with us with more sponsors

1:12:44 or something, and then come back to us with a project

1:12:46 again later on, and then maybe we could afford it then?

1:12:50 Yeah, you can definitely set limits on things.

1:12:52 Okay.

1:12:55 But we no longer have a quorum once she's gone, so.

1:12:58 I'd make any decisions, so I'll make a decision thing.

1:13:01 We can have the conversation,

1:13:02 but you cannot make any decisions now.

1:13:07 Well, we had three action items.

1:13:09 One is Mark Shauver, one is the electrical box, and then our nails too.

1:13:22 And we hear about Mark Shauver stuff without being able to make a decision on it?

1:13:32 It's a task, right?

1:13:33 I can display it too.

1:13:36 It sent me the link, right?

1:13:46 I think maybe the fastest thing is to cast my phone to the person.

1:14:00 while you're doing that. Do you want me to give a little background? Yes, please. So, essentially,

1:14:09 this artist reached out to us and had a series of paintings that he made. They're acrylic 24 by 24

1:14:18 soon, two feet. They're already framed, ready to hang. He's willing to deliver. He's willing to

1:14:24 to assist with the hanging of necessary.

1:14:28 He does request that they are permanent,

1:14:31 and the definition of his permanence

1:14:33 wasn't very clear in terms of whether we could remove it

1:14:39 after a certain period of time,

1:14:41 whether it's five years, 10 years, et cetera,

1:14:43 and he's looking for a public place

1:14:46 that's indoors to house these paintings.

1:14:48 We don't have to take all of them

1:14:50 because he's reached out to other cities as well.

1:14:54 As of right now, the last correspondence I had with him was in April, and he said he had 10 pieces left, and they're historic in nature.

1:15:03 Thank you.

1:15:06 So he has not yet submitted the proposal, but he has submitted resume and things like that.

1:15:21 that we can consider, but based on the conversations I've had with Wendy, we think that it would

1:15:28 be appropriate to deem the appropriateness of the work first before we pursue the location.

1:15:33 Yeah.

1:15:34 About while I'm trying to get there.

1:16:45 Meeting question.

1:16:48 Is it like I know we're 12 meetings a year for one hour.

1:16:53 Is it possible on any of the months to do like extended meetings like a long period?

1:16:56 I think we're doing an hour and a half and we did an hour and a half for a long time

1:16:59 And then we backed it back off because we didn't really need it anymore.

1:17:03 We can definitely go back to that.

1:17:04 Okay.

1:17:05 So technically the problem is these meetings have now been advertised as 12 to 1.

1:17:12 And we have a calendar posted.

1:17:14 Yeah.

1:17:14 So we could post a special meeting and go longer.

1:17:18 Okay.

1:17:18 Anytime we might.

1:17:20 Okay.

1:17:20 Because I feel like we could benefit from having a longer meeting if we get everybody here.

1:17:24 Because right now it kind of feels like we're all in the same college class.

1:17:29 and we've got a group paper due at the end of semester and we can only work with our group

1:17:34 five minutes a week and we cannot talk to each other at any other point during the week.

1:17:40 So we get that five minutes and then let's see you next week.

1:17:43 So we did do a couple of subcommittee groups where it was like this come down here in workshop

1:17:48 and we did make some reasonably decent headway on a lot of process stuff. So that's probably

1:17:55 would be my suggestion adding another 30 minutes to this meeting the once a month

1:17:59 would be fine too but really I think we got a lot more of this carve out three

1:18:04 hours on this one day and just go that way now we did that for the public survey

1:18:10 we did that for the mission vision so we knocked that out and then just got

1:18:17 approval from the other ones with minor tweaks but it was just let's sit down and

1:18:22 get the start. And those ones we did find out that even if it's two people, you still

1:18:29 have to advertise it and livestream it, record it. We decided to change just the

1:18:42 monthly meeting time. I don't know that I can accommodate that to be perfectly

1:18:48 honest. Tuesday is a big meeting day for me. I figure if we just planned out like a

1:18:53 a three hour meeting ahead of time a couple months, then I guess everyone time to schedule

1:18:58 it and then also we get a lot of work done.

1:19:00 Yeah.

1:19:01 There's discussion and whatnot.

1:19:04 Yeah, I'm not quite sure how many people we can have in a subcommittee.

1:19:06 I think we were for whatever reason, but I could be wrong on that.

1:19:11 I think the important thing about the subcommittee is that if it's two, it's a public meeting.

1:19:16 You can have as many.

1:19:17 I'm like if the entire commission wanted to be on the subcommittee, they could.

1:19:20 I think we could do it.

1:19:21 I just can't have more than one person meeting without it falling into the...

1:19:29 Open meeting law.

1:19:31 Well, and I think what he's getting that to is you wanting just our normal meeting to be longer,

1:19:37 and maybe to have like one or two, like three hour ones instead of one hour ones, is that right?

1:19:42 Possibly, yeah.

1:19:43 Just kind of just different ways we could work and get more discussion going on.

1:19:48 I think that would just be like a special meeting that gets on the calendar and it's like our normal

1:19:56 Commission, it's just a special I just can't go earlier

1:19:58 I need to I would need to go later and I know currently we were doing it earlier

1:20:02 I was never able to make that extra half an hour up. Oh if we did do that

1:20:07 I would need to probably be more of a 12 to 130 and not an 11th or just be late

1:20:18 Are they like abstracty paintings or is there a subject?

1:20:40 The historical nature like magic value historical like out of historical or like

1:20:49 Austin tea party

1:20:54 Native American

1:20:59 For sure

1:21:01 What about this rock Creek reimagined I again? I didn't I was able to get through the entire minutes or video from

1:21:12 and Rock Creek Park putting wraps around them,

1:21:15 but then he also had a third bridge,

1:21:17 but it's public property, so we have no jurisdiction on there.

1:21:20 What's not public property?

1:21:21 It's public property we do.

1:21:23 I mean private, private, yeah.

1:21:24 So the two of them are public, one of them is private.

1:21:27 The big of a notch was he's talking about today.

1:21:30 So there's the Victory Bridge,

1:21:31 and then I forget the name of the other one.

1:21:34 I do too, this victory is the same.

1:21:36 So Old Town in history.

1:21:39 Yeah, Old Town Bridge.

1:21:40 And Old Town is owned by I.T.D. and Victory is a city owned bridge.

1:21:47 And Arnout did say, I think he got I.T.D. approval already for doing that.

1:21:52 And we talked to the street department and street department was fine with something on

1:21:56 Victory as well.

1:21:59 I don't think I'll look at the...

1:22:06 So if you'll turn your attention to that T.V.

1:22:12 sample of, do any of these pieces have a connection to...

1:22:40 That looks like it could be part of the barn storming tour that actually did come through

1:22:44 Twin many, many moons ago, but yeah, I don't know if I'll have some sort of Idaho connection.

1:22:53 Not necessarily Magic Valley or Twin, but Idaho.

1:23:12 Then there was 10 pieces left, so we're not quite sure out of the 20 plus photos or images or

1:23:19 we don't know which ones we've already spoken for and which ones are still free though.

1:23:26 I probably need to know that at this point.

1:23:31 From a high level overview, I would assume that most all of these could be appropriate.

1:23:42 Yeah.

1:23:44 They look like kind of historic.

1:23:49 A me family.

1:23:50 A cultural.

1:23:51 Yeah.

1:23:53 Old Westy, kind of railroad, old towns, old cars, gold mining.

1:23:59 I kind of like this one here, like the ones that fall more under the 1950s to the 1930s.

1:24:15 I feel like there's not a lot of historical art that's not pioneer-y.

1:24:20 And so that's kind of a nice little historical twist where it's a not overly focused on time

1:24:27 period.

1:24:28 Yeah, I mean a lot of these remind me of

1:24:31 Of the things that I've seen in done in Idaho, you know the training thing

1:24:34 You know we had a steam engine come through a few years ago

1:24:38 I made a photo almost just like that. It almost looks like the Boise Depot in the background

1:24:45 Depending for gold that was huge

1:24:48 In the Snake River right there by a auger falls. Yeah, I mean there's a stuff that can yeah

1:24:54 That would relate to the area. I like the little kid with the bike

1:24:58 to something that's not overly like historical that one is just I do I mean yeah I think it's

1:25:06 appropriate I think it's a library yeah that's fine yeah yeah obviously we have wall space

1:25:12 and city hall and probably the library as well so yeah I think it's appropriate to there we

1:25:19 could take a look at what he's got left and see if anything is would work and you also ask

1:25:26 If he has any paintings of the prime bridge, I don't think we have enough of those

1:25:33 Very nice. Thank you for sharing those

1:25:43 You have any ideas of public spaces where you want to see any of these or that there is an opening

1:25:50 Hello, we's and I talked about it and thought City Hall. You know this lobby. There's there's some wall space here

1:25:57 It's kind of gotten taken up with flags and

1:26:01 But there's another wall on this side

1:26:05 that side, that by the restrooms, that we've hung art for art and soul on, but there's potential

1:26:16 there. You know, maybe you wanted it in a public, he wasn't public. And so putting it up on the

1:26:22 second or third floor would be a little harder. We thought about the, Eloise and I talked about

1:26:27 the library. Well, it is even, I mean, I don't know about Wall Space, but Parks and Rec, over

1:26:36 off Maxwell. I mean, there's a lot of public buildings. County West is technically in the city. And then you also have the police department. Yeah, so safety complex. So if you're, if you guys, you can't take any action today on it. But, but if you are kind of, so sometimes with council, we'll just say, you know, if you guys think this is something we can kind of move forward on, you can

1:27:08 kind of do sort of a head knotty kind of thing and then we could reach out to some of these

1:27:13 other spaces and see if anybody has any interest in taking some pieces and we could kind of

1:27:22 start that direction. Has he made any qualms about wanting all these pieces to stay together

1:27:28 as some sort of series or anything? You could take all ten and put them in ten different

1:27:34 spots as long as it's all public. We could take one. Yeah. I think his his

1:27:41 criteria was he wants it displayed in the public space and he wants to donate

1:27:46 them. So here's my picture. I'm sure we could find the bicycle with a triangle on

1:27:55 that wall. Or the tiny clock? You know what, a clock is a clock. It was nice to find a clock.

1:28:02 It was a nice addition to the empty wall.

1:28:07 Well, there used to be a clock. I don't know what happened to it. And then when you're somebody like me who's spending a lot of time in here running meetings and then constantly glancing at the blank wall going, and then you'd watch chair people look over their shoulder and be like, what time is I?

1:28:21 Speaking of time, it is one o'clock.

1:28:24 Speaking of time, Tim.

1:28:25 No, I would like more information on whether or not his pieces are available.

1:28:31 Which ones? Okay.

1:28:35 Would that be an adequate next step that we don't have to make a decision on?

1:28:39 Yeah, we could find out what's still available and we could kind of test the waters to see if the library anybody's interested in.

1:28:47 And also the definition of permanent.

1:28:50 Yes.

1:28:51 Yeah, I think we need to build in some language that, you know,

1:28:55 allows us to, you know, put a time, some sort of tentative timeframe on that, yeah, permanent for 10 years, and maybe re-evaluate or something.

1:29:05 And then I guess the last thing is, was the consensus of the group that we wanted to take a look at another meeting day in June or July?

1:29:17 The fifth, yes.

1:29:18 The fifth, I believe.

1:29:19 We'll take a look and see if rooms are available and if that can happen.

1:29:23 We'll figure it out because it sounded like

1:29:27 They might not have Melissa or Laurie for that

1:29:31 Someone also have to run the meeting, but we should be able to probably hit a quorum is what the hope was

1:29:37 But we don't have Camilda even check in. I don't know, but yeah, take a look at the fifth. I think it's what we came up with

1:29:43 For your time

1:29:49 You are able to back in the weeds. You said a good job

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, June 5, 2023. The recording started at 08:59 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:29:54.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    b7fa486b0d8694e1b357066304702c5f846ffd495c7f80772ed0967dbf6bed7e
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a edaf48a57944a265504067222d449da08d5742f43578bf5694a325089f97a587
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    139e949b60a4e2730e084044d08b3dae6151c6cbbc7e2d3f99b7b10da9ba796c

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file