City Council meeting
Tuesday, September 5, 2023
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on fileExecutive session: b,f,i
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:02:02 Good evening, everyone, and welcome to the September 5th, 2023 City Council meeting.
0:02:10 I want to confirm we have a quorum.
0:02:12 We have all seven members present in chambers.
0:02:16 First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.
0:02:18 If you wish to join me, please rise.
0:02:39 Thank you.
0:02:40 We have no proclamations tonight, so next on to the consent calendar, Council wishes.
0:02:46 Madam Mayor, I move that we approve the consent calendar as presented. Thank you. Do I have a second?
0:02:55 Thank you motion by Alex Kaval seconded by great Hawkins to approve the consent calendar as written
0:03:03 Amy roll call vote, please
0:03:06 Yes, yes
0:03:08 Yes, yes
0:03:12 Yes
0:03:14 Yes, thank you motion passes 7 to 0
0:03:17 so if you were here for the Bicious RV Palooza show or the
0:03:23 October Fest event downtown those both have been improved next under items of consideration is an action item a
0:03:32 Request from Roberts to her middle school cross-country coach
0:03:38 Emily coats to have approximately
0:03:40 1,800 in vehicle fees waived for a cross-country meet on September 20, and I believe Wendy will
0:03:48 introduce this.
0:03:49 I'm on down.
0:03:52 So good evening, Mayor and Council. I made a mistake, and so I just want to set the record straight. First of all,
0:04:05 this is South Hills Middle School, not Robert Stewart, and Emily Coates is not available tonight,
0:04:13 I bet she has sent her husband Travis in her stead.
0:04:17 So I just primarily wanted to make sure we have school, right?
0:04:20 So go for our Travis.
0:04:31 Yeah, so I guess it's just she's wanting to have a cost
0:04:35 country made, obviously.
0:04:37 And waive those fees because a lot of the kids and their
0:04:40 parents are lower to middle class.
0:04:44 And there's only five schools.
0:04:46 So she was roughly thinking about 400 people.
0:04:50 It's gotten popular.
0:04:51 we were able to do it two years ago and then last year.
0:04:54 And I guess the base is behind it,
0:04:56 instead of running around the parking lot or a school,
0:05:01 it's more of a cross country scene down at Durkeys Lake.
0:05:05 And then basically it's giving,
0:05:12 all right, put it,
0:05:13 basically showing that area to people
0:05:15 that actually didn't even know it was there.
0:05:19 Hey, I like to come off.
0:05:24 Is if this is becoming a yearly event,
0:05:26 Is there a reason that the school is not fundraising
0:05:31 for this event?
0:05:33 I don't think they have the time or the assistance to,
0:05:38 like she doesn't even have an assistant right now,
0:05:40 so that's why I'm here representing her,
0:05:42 because she's painting her kids.
0:05:52 Jason Brown.
0:05:54 Go ahead, Nikki, if you're good.
0:05:55 So the question I have, I guess on some of this is,
0:05:59 I think the agreement with the school,
0:06:04 I guess where I'm at a little bit is getting the kids down there, obviously, is one thing
0:06:09 if there's a school bus or something, getting a bus into there.
0:06:12 I think there's a chance to work, but if you look at 400 people, you start doing some math
0:06:23 and some wear and tear on getting people down there, because I agree it's a great opportunity
0:06:28 for the school district, the city, to promote an area that we value and cherish, but also
0:06:34 looking at trying to get that amount of cars down there logistically, you said five school
0:06:41 buses and getting down, you know, waiting maybe that fee, but I have a little bit more
0:06:46 hesitancy with the parents or something like that. I'm trying to figure out how do we work
0:06:52 work that out in the long run to make that something viable for both organizations.
0:07:00 I kind of take it back to maybe our agreement.
0:07:02 I know we discussed that a couple of weeks ago between the school district and the city
0:07:06 and trying to figure out how we work into that.
0:07:08 But I guess that's where I'm at, trying to figure out, I think we can get school buses
0:07:12 down there, get the kids running, but looking at maybe how do we recoup maybe some of the
0:07:20 cost that we have associated from the city side as well. Yeah, I understand that and
0:07:25 yeah, that road's terrible too, you know, so I totally agree with that.
0:07:30 History, when I saw this come by or come through on our items, I see both sides to
0:07:39 this, the agreement that just came through with the school district, I
0:07:46 appreciate, I want to understand that relationship. I just had the lovely
0:07:56 opportunity to put a lot of kids in school. My kids ran this two years ago.
0:08:03 Great race, great place down there, great trail. The fundraising aspect. I got to donate
0:08:12 hundreds of dollars for my kids to play sports earlier this year. So as far as
0:08:20 fundraising, get it completely frustrating, challenging to buy butter
0:08:27 of braids and a card and this and that or just like we're not going to give you anything
0:08:32 just give us you know a couple bucks and we're good so I appreciate it I understand also every
0:08:38 time I walk into football game I got to pay seven bucks to get in I understand that at
0:08:44 this point in time this is something historically we've done we don't have a policy in place
0:08:52 this is going to be a one off here a one off there until we do have a policy in place
0:08:58 I personally, in this situation where we don't have something concrete that says, this is
0:09:04 the rule, this is not the rule, I don't have a problem with this right now.
0:09:08 As we move forward, I would like to get something in place so that there aren't these awkward
0:09:14 conversations here at the dias of, hey, we'd like this, what do you guys think?
0:09:20 I don't have any kids running across country this year for Robert Stewart, but it's one
0:09:27 of those have kids down there is the fifteen hundred dollars that big of an
0:09:34 expense that you will have parents that will not show because of that. Spencer
0:09:39 Heathers. Sorry. Yeah thanks similar to Chris. One of the things philosophically
0:09:45 long-term I don't think we should do but we haven't really put a policy in place
0:09:50 that people who will benefit although there are people from out of town a
0:09:54 majority are probably people that are also twin false taxpayers. I'd be
0:09:59 have to approve it this time. I realize if we don't have a policy in place before
0:10:03 next year this council may not be the same makeup but speaking for myself I'd
0:10:09 be comfortable approving it this time but in following years I'd probably say
0:10:13 no. Thank you point. That is what I wanted it was going to say earlier on is
0:10:20 I very much agree with that is we have to have something in place and I don't
0:10:25 think we need to be approving seems like this is coming up more often and but I
0:10:34 think exposing parts of our community that don't even know Durkys like is there
0:10:38 that's even hard to really wrap my mind around but that is important and and the
0:10:46 event is important but we got to figure out a better way a better way to do it I
0:10:53 I would approve it this year, but I wouldn't him.
0:10:57 Jason Brown.
0:11:00 What schools are coming?
0:11:03 So there's five I put into this.
0:11:05 That's okay.
0:11:06 I mean, I have to volunteer.
0:11:08 But I basically owe Larry, junior, or Larry, Robert Stewart.
0:11:14 Valfield's obviously.
0:11:16 I think one from Haley usually comes.
0:11:19 And then I think one a Rupert.
0:11:21 OK.
0:11:21 So three of the five are from the three of the five
0:11:25 from the Twin Falls area school district and whatnot. Okay, I think that answered my question.
0:11:36 So, Austin? There's like to make a motion that we approve the request middle school cross-country
0:11:49 coach and the coach to have approximately $1,500 this year. Please wave for cross-country meet September
0:11:56 I'll second that.
0:11:58 Okay, motion by Craig Hawkins, seconded by Christopher Reed, to approve the waiver of fees for cross-country
0:12:09 meet on September 20th for, not for Roberts to it, for Fales Middle School.
0:12:20 Any further discussion?
0:12:21 I was going to say, I would echo the sentiments of my fellow council members on here.
0:12:31 I'm not opposed to the waiver this year, but it's not tenable in the long run.
0:12:35 you will have my vote tonight, but consider your approach going forward in the future.
0:12:40 Thanks. Anybody else? Anybody else? Any roll call vote please?
0:12:47 Senator Cutler? Yes. Alex Koval? Yes. Jason Brown? Yes. Greg Hawkins? Yes. Thank you, Boyd? Yes. Chris Reed? Yes.
0:12:56 And Ruth Pierce? Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. Thank you. Thank you. So, Wendy, we've had this conversation
0:13:06 several times now over the last few months about do we wave, do we not and
0:13:13 some and everybody keeps saying I won't vote for this next time but next time
0:13:18 comes up and we vote for it again so is there something that staff can do to do
0:13:27 some research come up with some proposal for us so next time we have this we can
0:13:33 say we have a policy in place and you fit within that policy or you don't. These
0:13:39 wave fees aren't. My understanding is that I was signed illegal. I think Mitch has
0:13:45 picked it up and is trying to shepherd it through. And so we'll, yeah, there's no
0:13:53 mechanism right now for me to do it. So we'll come up with something that either
0:13:59 set some parameters or gives permission at the director level or something because
0:14:05 I agree I don't like it either it's not very much fine so what's the time frame we
0:14:09 might expect some feedback do you know where he is on it yeah the coming up with
0:14:20 it wasn't mine to do so if somebody recognizes there's some urgency to this
0:14:28 and I know that's why Mitch picked it up and I know he had an emergency so that's
0:14:32 That's okay today but maybe in the Friday or something we could have an update on when
0:14:39 to expect something.
0:14:40 Perfect.
0:14:41 I'd be grilled.
0:14:42 Thank you.
0:14:43 I honestly don't think there's any more like this coming.
0:14:47 I think this is the last social and false turkeys event.
0:14:53 Yeah.
0:14:54 Yes.
0:14:55 Famous last words for this year.
0:14:59 Thank you.
0:15:00 And all the requests are a little bit different.
0:15:03 all the requests are a little bit different.
0:15:06 And so we're saying, okay, this event sounds good,
0:15:09 we get it, we hear the presentation,
0:15:12 and we say, well, we'd like to do this,
0:15:14 but we don't want to set a precedent.
0:15:16 And that was a different category than this category.
0:15:18 They're all just a little bit different.
0:15:20 So I would imagine coming up with a policy
0:15:23 is a little bit tricky,
0:15:27 but nonetheless, we still need a policy.
0:15:30 So.
0:15:32 Thank you.
0:15:33 Thank you, everyone.
0:15:36 Okay, next item on the agenda is an action item, a request approval of the yearly contract
0:15:42 amendment to the 2014 agreement between the city of Twin Falls and CH2M Jacobs for the
0:15:50 wastewater treatment plant and lift station operations in the amount of $4,022,072.71
0:16:00 authorize the mayor to sign and we have Nathan Erickson environmental manager
0:16:06 welcome Nathan yes mayor council appreciate your time tonight yes it's that
0:16:15 time of the year again that we need to renew that contract first of all I do
0:16:21 want to recognize that from Jacobs we do have Dan Black our project manager and
0:16:28 and then also Sean Moffat, the Regional Business Manager for Jacobs. I appreciate them being here tonight.
0:16:35 Also, I want to recognize that this is entering into the 36th year, that there's been an agreement between, a partnership between Jacobs and the city,
0:16:46 and we really do appreciate all that they do and how well that plant is running.
0:16:53 This year, the request is, the budget is increasing by approximately $174,000, which is 4.5% from last year, so that makes the total that we're requesting $4,022,072.6 cents.
0:17:18 do want to remind council that this contract is a little unique in that throughout the year the city does pay
0:17:25 you know a portion each month of that four million and
0:17:31 then at the end
0:17:33 Jacobs accounts for all the true costs and then what is not used is returned to the city
0:17:38 So if that's more than they actually need then we will get it back
0:17:43 the
0:17:45 Majority of the increases this year that four and a half percent
0:17:48 The majority of that is actually due to power increases.
0:17:53 And what we're seeing is that from June of this year to June of next year,
0:17:58 we've been told that the increases are going to total up to about 25%,
0:18:04 which is pretty significant.
0:18:07 And in taking that into consideration, I also do want to give a recognition to Jacobs.
0:18:17 They've been helping us as a city to partner with Idaho Power.
0:18:22 So about a year ago at this time, we actually started into a, it's called an industrial waste
0:18:30 water energy cohort through Idaho Power, it's a two-year program, and it's actually a program
0:18:36 where Idaho Power has come out to the plant, and we've gone through all the energy using
0:18:44 parts of the facility and over the last year and over the next coming year we've
0:18:49 been going over ways that we can find efficiencies that will actually reduce
0:18:55 our energy use and actually to date.
0:18:58 Mito Power has let us know that just so far with our efforts we have
0:19:06 actually saved enough, well, half a million kilowatt hours so far, which is
0:19:14 enough to power 45 homes, just to kind of put it in perspective. So, Jacobs is
0:19:21 really the driving force behind that, helping us make sure that we're we're
0:19:24 staying on top of that. We meet monthly with Idaho Power and try to make sure
0:19:30 we're keeping up on those projects and those efforts to improve our efficiency.
0:19:32 And then there's also another project that Jacobs has helped us get involved with, and
0:19:40 that's the FlexPeak program through Idaho Power.
0:19:43 And that's just recently in the summer we've been able to identify or sign up with Idaho
0:19:48 Power and on peak days, hot days when there's a lot of air conditioning and stuff going on.
0:19:55 We've identified some things at the waste of trout water treatment plant that we can
0:19:58 cut back on and reduce our power consumption during that short period so that there's more
0:20:04 available to idle power to use at other places.
0:20:07 And we actually will receive some money back from that program.
0:20:10 So I bring up these programs as these are things that are happening down at the waste
0:20:16 water treatment plant that ultimately are saving us power and ultimately money, taking
0:20:23 into account that, you know, cost of power is going up significantly.
0:20:30 Another small factor of the cost increase is a small increase for labor costs for the employees
0:20:37 down at the plant.
0:20:42 And then there is just one other thing that you want to make aware of that 4.5%, 1% of
0:20:49 that is actually a change that Jacobs has proposed to make it so that we are able to
0:20:54 more efficiently have a polymer, which is a chemical that's delivered down to the plant.
0:21:01 In the past, the way they've worked their budget is it takes a truckload and then a portion
0:21:08 of a truckload to get through a year.
0:21:11 So what they've done in the past is they ordered a truckload and then they actually have purchased
0:21:15 So like 50 pound bags in the past and hauled them in manually to get to the end of the year.
0:21:21 What they're proposing to do this year is they will buy two truckloads.
0:21:26 So that actually ups this year's budget.
0:21:29 But over the years there will be years that we will not have a full truckload or the partial that have been in the past.
0:21:37 So that is the reason the request questions.
0:21:44 Thank you. Any questions for Nathan? Jason Brown.
0:21:48 I don't have any questions. I'll make a motion if anybody. That'd be good. Thank you, Jason.
0:21:54 Move to approve the yearly contract amendment to the 20,014 agreement between the City of Twin Falls
0:22:02 and CH2M Jacobs for the wastewater treatment plan and authorize the mayor to sign the contract
0:22:08 for $4,022,072.
0:22:12 And actually, the narrative says, oh, six.
0:22:17 It's not very much, but if we need
0:22:18 to have an exact contract, so $72,06.
0:22:25 Is there a second?
0:22:27 Oh, second.
0:22:27 Thank you.
0:22:28 Motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Chris Reed
0:22:31 to approve the yearly contract amendment to the 2014
0:22:38 agreement between the city and H2M Jacobs for the wastewater treatment plant and
0:22:45 lift station operations in the amount of $4,022,072 and sixth cents and
0:22:52 authorize the mayor to sign.
0:22:56 Does the polymer will the stuff that's just sitting around? Where will that be
0:23:01 stored in? Is it looser in bags? When it's delivered in a truck, it's actually put into a big
0:23:08 container high-low so it's stored in a silo and it has no deterioration or anything like that they're using it so yeah
0:23:17 it's it's just more efficient to have it all delivered in a trunkle dance
0:23:22 very good thank you anybody else okay Amy real call vote please Alex Cabal yes
0:23:33 Yes.
0:23:34 Yes.
0:23:35 And Brown.
0:23:36 Yes.
0:23:37 Great.
0:23:38 Hawkins.
0:23:39 Yes.
0:23:40 Thank you.
0:23:41 Boyd.
0:23:42 Yes.
0:23:43 Chris Reed.
0:23:44 Yes.
0:23:45 Yes.
0:23:46 And Spencer Cutler.
0:23:47 Yes.
0:23:48 Thank you.
0:23:49 Motion passes seven to zero.
0:23:50 Did you have something?
0:23:51 I just wanted to thank the folks from Jacobson.
0:23:55 We have a great relationship.
0:23:57 Thank you for all the work that you guys do.
0:23:59 Thank you.
0:24:00 Okay.
0:24:01 Moving on to the next item.
0:24:03 is project to extreme excavation in the amount of 4,836,516 plus 5% contingency for a total
0:24:15 of 5,091,292 and we have Staff Engineer 2, John Caton.
0:24:23 Welcome John.
0:24:24 Thank you, Marion Council.
0:24:25 Good to be here tonight.
0:24:26 That was a long request, wasn't it?
0:24:29 Well, let's see, tonight I also have Tracy Arons with G.E.B. Engineers here.
0:24:37 E.B. designed the projects, so if you have some design specific questions he's here as well to help.
0:24:42 But tonight I just wanted to, well as you know I'm here to ask for approval from council to award the project to the little bidder.
0:24:55 before we do that. I wanted to review quickly briefly the purpose of the project and a little
0:25:01 bit of the background. And so in your packet but also up on the screen, this is a figure
0:25:17 of the existing pressure zones throughout the city. And we're talking about the water
0:25:21 system and there's seven different pressure zones throughout the system. So in this figure
0:25:26 here you see the snake rivers here, Rock Creek Canyon here and then downtown is right here
0:25:33 just to orient you to the map. And the Hankins pressure zone is this pressure zone in yellow
0:25:40 to the east of the city. That's where the project, we're going to split the project.
0:25:47 The second figure I wanted to share, it was not in your packet, but I think it's from
0:25:53 the water facility planet and it's a good illustration of why we're doing the project.
0:26:13 So again, this map has a lot going on.
0:26:15 It's pretty busy, so let me just briefly walk you through it.
0:26:18 So this has got the same pressure zones,
0:26:20 and it's the seven pressure zones of the city
0:26:23 underneath all this mess here.
0:26:26 We've got, on top of that, we've got the piping network
0:26:33 of the water system, and then we have these little circles,
0:26:37 and those circles are little nodes
0:26:39 that tell the system pressure under certain conditions.
0:26:43 So in this image, this is what the city looks like at peak hour demand.
0:26:51 So in July, when the system's pumping and working really hard,
0:26:59 we'll just look at the central pressure zone right here.
0:27:01 It's called the high level pressure zone right here, for example.
0:27:05 And on the northern boundary of the pressure zone right here,
0:27:08 we see a lot of these yellow circles.
0:27:10 And that's indicating a very high pressure between 85 and 100 psi.
0:27:15 And on the other end of this, same pressure zone at the other boundary, we have minimal
0:27:22 pressures 40 psi up to 55 psi.
0:27:26 So the problem that we have here is the ability of the system to distribute water pressures
0:27:33 and fire flow efficiently.
0:27:35 And the problem is the size of this pressure zone is so big and it's covering so much
0:27:41 demand that it's having a hard time providing minimum pressure and fire flow.
0:27:45 So this project, that's the problem and the purpose or the proposed project, if
0:28:03 awarded will, this map has blown up the future pressure zone. There we go. So the
0:28:28 first map showed the high-level pressure zone was much larger. Now the
0:28:32 handkins display it into two pressure zones and again the goal is to redistribute
0:28:38 water more efficiently throughout the city. I've created a vicinity map. This is a big
0:28:47 project. There's about 7500 lineal feet of pipe in the project and that includes
0:28:55 anywhere from six inch up to 30 inch water main that includes pressure control
0:28:59 valves and fiber conduit and all the surface repair related to the trenching
0:29:04 and so there's six locations throughout the city that we're going to see construction activity and trenching it in and starting here.
0:29:11 This is Blue Lakes south of Kimberly Road right here at Morningside in Addison.
0:29:18 We're going to do a little bit in the intersection sunrise from Addison to
0:29:24 Heyburn and then Filer east of East Eastland all the way to Hankins.
0:29:30 There's a control valve in Hankins north just south of Falls and then from our existing water
0:29:38 Anks at Hankins our Hankins water tanks from Marie to Kimberly on on Hankins
0:29:45 We bid the project at the end of July and through August. We opened the bid in August 17th. There were three bidders
0:29:54 extreme excavation knife river and blue sky construction the
0:30:00 The existing budget for this fiscal year was $3,054,000 for construction, and an additional
0:30:10 $2,000,000, $2,037,292 is needed to construct the project.
0:30:17 This does include some contingency, not only for construction, but for C, E, and I, which
0:30:22 is construction observation, and there are a few reasons why the project costs are in
0:30:32 higher we had. When we got into final design there was more pipe than was initially planned
0:30:41 so that the project grew in size and then of course the project estimate was originally
0:30:48 done about 18 months to 2 years old so a combination of additional scope and inflation
0:30:56 and there were some other projects that were added to it. One would be the intersection
0:31:02 of Kimberly and Hankins, that free running right that has failed.
0:31:07 This project will include replacing that.
0:31:11 There's a water line that goes through that free running right, and that will receive a concrete surface at the end of the project.
0:31:20 So there were several things added and due to inflation, those are the extra costs.
0:31:26 With that, if there are, I think I've covered everything, if council has any questions.
0:31:35 Reports says you're anticipating the extra to come out of water reserves.
0:31:39 Yes.
0:31:40 Do you know how much is sitting in water reserves right now?
0:31:44 We have talked about it.
0:31:49 We believe right now we're sitting right around $11 million.
0:31:52 Perfect.
0:31:53 Thank you.
0:31:57 Chris Reed.
0:31:58 I'll make a motion if anybody have.
0:32:06 I had a question on your calculation.
0:32:07 So when I ran a 5% contingency, I get $5,078,341 and 80 cents.
0:32:14 I'm not quite sure how we calculated $5,091,292, could you explain?
0:32:20 Yes, yes, thank you for asking.
0:32:22 I was anticipating that question because it is a little bit confusing.
0:32:26 So there's a portion of the design.
0:32:31 The design was approved in this school year, excuse me, in 2022.
0:32:38 It was about $600,000.
0:32:41 And so there's a portion of that, about $259,000 that is going to be needed for construction.
0:32:50 That's already approved and allocated for the project.
0:32:53 But because the project is longer and greater in scope, I added a 5% contingency on how much time is going to be done.
0:33:01 going to be needed to to observe the project so the difference just to help you
0:33:07 out five percent on the construction is two hundred forty one thousand eight
0:33:13 hundred and twenty six dollars and then five percent on the construction
0:33:19 observation is twelve thousand nine hundred fifty dollars which when you add
0:33:25 those all together should should make it does that that was that was my missing
0:33:29 12,950 and technically 20 cents.
0:33:32 Yes, perfect.
0:33:34 Thank you.
0:33:35 Thank you.
0:33:38 Anybody else have any questions before?
0:33:40 No engineer questions?
0:33:43 Wow, wow.
0:33:44 Chris Reed.
0:33:47 Why didn't you look at me for engineer questions?
0:33:50 Understand.
0:33:50 Yeah.
0:33:51 All right.
0:33:52 I move that we award the 2023 Hankins pressure zone boundary
0:33:56 improvement project to extreme excavation, Inc.
0:34:00 in the amount of $4,836,516 plus 5% for contingency for a total of $5,091,292.
0:34:11 Thank you, Craig Hawkins. I'll second that. Thank you. Motion by Christopher Reed, second by Craig Hawkins
0:34:17 to award the contract on the 2023 Enchids Pressure Zone Boundary Improvement Project to
0:34:24 extreme excavation or a total including contingency of 5,091,292 dollars. Any
0:34:34 further discussion? Amy Rolkov, please. Jason Brown. Yes. Greg Hawkins. Yes.
0:34:41 Thank you, Boyd. Yes. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. And Alex Koval. Yes.
0:34:48 Thank you. Motion passes 7 to their zero. Thank you, John. Thank you. Hey, next item
0:34:55 on the agenda is an action item a request for a nonconform forming building
0:35:01 expansion waiver for property located at six eleven third Avenue East care of
0:35:07 Sid Lithommies PZ 23-0055 and we have Lisa Strickland our city planner
0:35:14 welcome Lisa good evening mayor City Council this is a request for a non
0:35:42 Conforming Building Expansion Waiver for property located at 611 Third Avenue East.
0:35:51 The property is currently zoned R6 with a professional office overlay and the setback
0:35:57 for this zone is as follows.
0:36:00 For the front yard it is 25 foot from the front, 5 yards are 5 feet from the side yard
0:36:07 and for the rear it's 15 feet from the rear property line.
0:36:11 The existing home is located within three feet of the property line, and it's supposed
0:36:20 to be five feet.
0:36:22 So that's what makes it nonconforming.
0:36:25 In our code, per city code 1034, the requirement of this section to go through a public hearing
0:36:34 for a nonconforming building expansion permit may be waived for residents and residential
0:36:40 uses by motion of the Council. If the Council wishes it can waive the public hearing from
0:36:46 the Planning and Zoning Commission as per requirements in this section and it would allow
0:36:51 the applicant to proceed with the building permit process. If the Council feels the applicant
0:36:57 needs to proceed through the public hearing then it would be heard at the Planning and
0:37:02 Zoning Commission and the process takes about 45 days from the date it's submitted to
0:37:07 date that it's heard. Staff has looked at the request. The proposal is to add, to put
0:37:16 an addition on the back of the house, and they want to continue down the same line of
0:37:23 the existing building. They don't want to encroach further into the setbacks, but they
0:37:27 just want to follow the line and to modernize the house a little bit. We have reviewed the
0:37:34 request, and we do not foresee any overtly negative impacts if the request is approved.
0:37:41 So the commission is, or the council is tasked with acting on the waiver as requested, and
0:37:48 said the applicant is here this evening as well.
0:37:52 Hey, Spencer Cutler, thank you, just double checking.
0:37:58 So in the write up, it sounds like there's currently a porch, it will be in enclosed condition
0:38:03 space now but it's essentially the same footprint correct okay thank you anybody
0:38:11 else thank you Nicky yes mayor I move that we grant the request for a nonconforming
0:38:25 building expansion waiver for property located at 611 third Avenue East
0:38:30 Thank you, Chris Reed.
0:38:37 Second.
0:38:38 Thank you.
0:38:40 Motion by Nikki Boyd.
0:38:42 Seconded by Christopher Reed to approve the request for a nonconforming building expansion
0:38:48 waiver for property located at 611 third Avenue East.
0:38:53 Any further discussion?
0:38:55 Amy Roll call vote please.
0:38:57 please.
0:39:00 Craig Hawkins.
0:39:01 Yes.
0:39:02 Thank you, Boyd.
0:39:03 Yes.
0:39:04 Chris Reed.
0:39:05 Yes.
0:39:06 Bruce Pierce.
0:39:07 Yes.
0:39:08 Spencer Cutler.
0:39:09 Yes.
0:39:10 Alex Koval.
0:39:11 Yes.
0:39:12 And Jason Brown.
0:39:13 Yes.
0:39:14 Thank you.
0:39:18 Motion passes seven to zero.
0:39:19 Thank you, Lisa.
0:39:20 Okay.
0:39:21 Next item on the agenda is an action item.
0:39:23 It is a request to adopt ordinance 2023-010 for the rezoning of property located at the northwest corner of Washington Street and Robbins.
0:39:31 and Robbins Avenue, care of Elmer Blakey on behalf of Penelope Parker, PZ23-0028, and
0:39:42 we have our P&Z Director, Jonathan Spinn, welcome, Jonathan.
0:39:46 Thank you, Mayor, members of the Council.
0:39:48 This ordinance coincides with the item that was described on the agenda.
0:39:54 The meetings were held on 13 June from the planning zoning commission.
0:39:57 They forwarded a recommendation to this body.
0:39:59 It was heard on July 31st, and the Council made a decision and directed staff to create
0:40:05 this ordinance.
0:40:06 If you wish to pass this ordinance, you need to follow on the regulations for the placing
0:40:11 on third and final by title only waiver process and I've read that in the staff report.
0:40:18 The exact wording to use, if you wish to do that, any questions for me, that concludes
0:40:23 what I have.
0:40:24 is finding the exact words that John it's in regular it's under the regulatory
0:40:30 of the regulatory section looking for it it's on that piece of paper on your
0:40:40 screen well that's but it's not the exact wording that John oh John at the
0:40:45 morning on your screen I think we're probably working it should be the same
0:40:48 that we dispense with the reading rules in place ordinance 2023 dash 0 1 0 on
0:40:56 on third and final by by title only thank you Jason Brown second thank you motion by
0:41:02 Chris Reed second by Jason Brown to put ordinance 2023 dash 010 on third and final reading
0:41:11 by title only waving the rules close enough okay any further discussion
0:41:19 Thank you.
0:41:21 I'm going to go ahead and
0:41:22 I'm going to go ahead and
0:41:23 I'm going to go ahead and
0:41:24 I'm going to go ahead and
0:41:25 I'm going to go ahead and
0:41:26 I'm going to go ahead and
0:41:27 I'm going to go ahead and
0:41:28 I'm going to go ahead and
0:41:29 I'm going to go ahead and
0:41:30 I'm going to go ahead and
0:41:31 I'm going to go ahead and
0:41:32 I'm going to go ahead and
0:41:33 I'm going to go ahead and
0:41:34 I'm going to go ahead and
0:41:35 I'm going to go ahead and
0:41:36 I'm going to go ahead and
0:41:37 I'm going to go ahead and
0:41:38 I'm going to go ahead and
0:41:39 I'm going to go ahead and
0:41:40 I'm going to go ahead and
0:41:41 I'm going to go ahead and
0:41:42 I'm going to go ahead and
0:41:43 I'm going to go ahead and
0:41:44 I'm going to go ahead and
0:41:45 rezoning certain real property below described providing the zoning classification, therefore
0:41:51 in ordering the necessary area of impact in zoning district's map amendments.
0:41:58 Chris Reed.
0:41:59 I move that we approve Ordinance 2023-010.
0:42:03 Thank you.
0:42:05 Thank you.
0:42:07 Motion by Chris for Reed, seconded by Nikki Boyd to approve adopt Ordinance 2023-010.
0:42:15 Any further discussion?
0:42:18 Amy Rokavo please.
0:42:20 Chris Reed.
0:42:21 Yes.
0:42:22 Ruth Pierce.
0:42:23 Yes.
0:42:24 Senator Cutler.
0:42:25 Yes.
0:42:26 Alex Kaval.
0:42:27 Yes.
0:42:28 Jason Brown.
0:42:29 Yes.
0:42:30 Yes.
0:42:31 Hawkins.
0:42:32 Yes.
0:42:33 And Hickey Boyd.
0:42:34 Yes.
0:42:35 Thank you.
0:42:37 Motion passes 7 to 0.
0:42:38 Thank you, Jonathan.
0:42:39 So, now the next item on the agenda is an action item, authorization for city staff
0:42:43 to begin the process for amending title, tan zoning, and subdivision regulations and associated
0:42:50 development agreement policies to address imminent issues with street luminaire, street
0:42:57 signs and proposed water capacity fee program.
0:43:02 Jonathan's been in love, name shorter than that sentence right there.
0:43:07 It's a long one.
0:43:10 We've got three different issues and their staff report goes through each one of them.
0:43:13 I won't read it verbatim, but starting with the street
0:43:16 luminaries and street signs.
0:43:18 There's a code section entitled 10
0:43:20 under the subdivisions as chapter 12.
0:43:23 Been in place since 1981, when we first enacted
0:43:27 the subdivision ordinance, where the city pays
0:43:31 for street luminaries and street signs
0:43:33 to be installed through the materials.
0:43:36 Street luminaries are those that are illuminate street,
0:43:38 not signals, traffic signals.
0:43:41 They go at every intersection of the public roadway.
0:43:44 So every intersection gets a street luminaire
0:43:46 to illuminate the intersection.
0:43:49 The streets signs get placed on one side of the street
0:43:52 at every intersection.
0:43:54 Up until now, we're hoping up until now,
0:43:57 the city has actually had that cost
0:43:59 on our side of the ledger.
0:44:01 We have paid for every street luminaire,
0:44:05 and what I mean by every street luminaire,
0:44:07 we paid for the regular ones,
0:44:09 the wood poles with the lumina on it.
0:44:12 If there's a specialty pole in some subdivisions,
0:44:15 the developer in the city then co-pay for it.
0:44:19 We pay for the cost of the wood pole,
0:44:21 the developer then would carry the cost
0:44:23 of the specialty pole, so we end up paying equally
0:44:27 the amount of the difference goes to the developer.
0:44:30 Street signs we have been paying for the materials.
0:44:34 In the staff report, there's a cost
0:44:35 associated in the budget section.
0:44:38 this year, I'm getting to where that was,
0:44:43 we in the 24 budget, we budgeted to 70,000
0:44:47 for street luminaire installation,
0:44:50 so it'd be the upcoming year.
0:44:52 We've received a preliminary cost from Idaho Power
0:44:55 to expend $88,000 for basically a singular subdivision
0:45:01 for every street luminaire in that subdivision.
0:45:05 So we believe in the short term of the new budget year,
0:45:09 the street department will be basically behind or in the whole that 18,000 approximately, with the rest of the year to go if this code section stays in place.
0:45:20 For the street signs, we had also in there, in 23 and FY23, we have spent 7,100 approximately for the street sign items in that budget line.
0:45:38 I don't believe that includes. We don't usually include like a man hour cost to that. That's I think that's material. I would need the public works or mark to kind of clarify that for me. I didn't get that clarification from him just yet.
0:45:52 That's a real cost to the city's budget for those two items to continue to be within that Title 10 section.
0:45:58 We had authorization still have that working towards a Title 10 update to remove those.
0:46:04 The problem is we've seen this come up, we think it needs a more imminent change, and these are really quick changes as opposed to the entirety of Title X that we can make pretty quick.
0:46:16 So we're seeking authorization to bring it out of the original Title X update.
0:46:22 I'm going to pause there for any questions on those two items before I get to the water issue.
0:46:27 So currently, like the cost of luminaires, so is actually coming specifically from the street fund or is it's not impact fees or something like that?
0:46:39 It's coming straight from the street fund, they have a line item for it specifically.
0:46:43 The way it works is this is what makes it difficult and developers construct the subdivision, they order the street luminaires, they decide on their construction plan, whether it's going to be just a usual one or a specialty one.
0:46:55 do you want? They order it through Idaho Power. When Idaho Power gets to it in their
0:47:01 work order and when they finish it, they bill us. Essentially goes to Robin and Mark,
0:47:06 and then we pay the bill. So we kind of don't know when they're gonna happen. We
0:47:12 have like a couple months lead time, but we don't really know when that will happen.
0:47:16 Any other questions? I like some. What does 70,000 represent in terms of numbers of
0:47:26 lights like what am I looking at looking at Troy is for the subdivision I believe
0:47:31 was in subdivision of somewhere around say 100 to 200 and something homes so don't
0:47:40 know how many luminaires that actually is I didn't get that information how does
0:47:43 that how does that projected budget kind of line up with what we're
0:47:47 anticipating or building permits for 2024 you don't know because I'm not quite
0:47:56 sure how the building permit is going to line up for 24.
0:47:59 All right.
0:48:01 Thanks.
0:48:02 Nothing else.
0:48:03 Anybody else?
0:48:05 Travis?
0:48:06 So, in terms of building permits for the City of Twin Falls, we anticipated a downward
0:48:13 trend from 23 to 24.
0:48:18 We estimated that total net revenues would be off about $200,000, where we had budgeted
0:48:26 about a million to a million one in past years,
0:48:29 we budgeted $800,000 for building permit revenue
0:48:34 for the next year.
0:48:36 Currently building permits through the first 11 months
0:48:40 are among the lowest, if not the lowest month
0:48:44 that we have in our database.
0:48:47 So it's either going to be the lowest
0:48:50 or just eke above 2000 and.
0:48:59 Any other questions on those two items?
0:49:03 Hey, let me know.
0:49:04 OK, the last item is a bit more.
0:49:12 League Laysman Staff Engineer came here recently
0:49:14 talking about the Pressure Irrigation Master Plan.
0:49:17 Pressure Irrigation Master Plan.
0:49:19 Part of that plan includes a list of capital improvements
0:49:22 to do as we migrate towards regional pump stations.
0:49:29 The fewer pump stations the city operates, the fewer maintenance costs issue ends up being
0:49:34 how do we pay for these regional stations when we can't predict development or force development
0:49:40 in certain areas.
0:49:41 Developers and owners of properties develop.
0:49:44 In their time we see them, we've improved the plans, but forcing it is difficult and getting
0:49:48 the capital to construct regional stations is what's being looked at.
0:49:54 of that is to look at a capacity fee. It's a water capacity fee or press
0:49:59 resolution capacity fee where building permits get charged to hook up to the
0:50:05 system. We're ready to look at what that capacity fee, that's why it's written as
0:50:12 a proposed capacity fee. We need authorization to look at that fee and
0:50:17 how that would impact the code in Title X. Because Title X in the
0:50:23 The subdivision section requires all subdivisions to be hooked up to PI, with zero allowance
0:50:32 otherwise, but a water capacity fee there might be some interim steps to take between
0:50:38 having pressurized irrigation fully functional and when they first develop because the regional
0:50:43 stations won't be in place yet.
0:50:45 We wanted to open up the window to investigate this capacity fee that includes looking at
0:50:50 changing Title 10 for the pressure irrigation section
0:50:54 I cited that section specifically.
0:50:56 There'll be other sections in Title 7 and 8 to look at.
0:51:00 In any case, no code will be changed
0:51:02 without first coming here, and there's no fee
0:51:04 that's in place without the council looking at it
0:51:07 with the full public hearing type of issues.
0:51:09 We just needed authorization to look at that section.
0:51:12 Because Title 10 is in the land use section,
0:51:15 we have to have authorization to start working on it.
0:51:18 But that's what I'm here.
0:51:19 I hope I gave enough information without muddying too many waters.
0:51:25 So you're basically asking to pull those out and get working on them right now?
0:51:29 Yes.
0:51:30 Okay.
0:51:31 Any?
0:51:32 Thank you, Boyd.
0:51:36 I guess that was my question.
0:51:38 Yeah, there's a lot.
0:51:39 I mean, I've gone down a few rabbit holes on this topic.
0:51:43 So, okay, so right now it's just we're going to take it out of Title 10.
0:51:48 Yeah, that general update didn't include that water change. We didn't propose that at all. It was gonna stay as it was
0:51:56 We now are looking for authorization to start potentially changing that section
0:52:00 The other two and all three of those together will be pulled out of the giant title 10 rewrite right and dealt with quick quickly
0:52:07 And you're gonna come back with
0:52:12 What you want to do with that portion of it. Yes, that's a big deep topic
0:52:17 topic. Yes, they would they would go through the full public hearing process in title 10 goes to
0:52:23 Planning and Zoning Commission public hearing recommendation from them to you for a change on the
0:52:29 ordinance. The water capacity fee thing also has a separate issue with a new fee as to go through
0:52:34 you and that whole public hearing process as well. We'd probably try to combine those together.
0:52:39 But that's what we'd be working on separately. Yeah, or in a more expedited timeline.
0:52:45 Okay, how do you notify people that that's going to be on the agenda because this is going to affect
0:52:55 homes that are being built that aren't, their pressurized irrigation isn't hooked up yet, but it
0:53:03 technically exists, their pump station exists, then you're going to make it regional. Yeah, there's
0:53:11 gonna be people who already are all going with it. They need to be notified too, don't they? Yeah,
0:53:17 Yeah, so there's going to be a time in, like, basically a time going forward that people
0:53:22 would be most affected.
0:53:24 Typically it's going to go at the development level when they go for subdivision approval
0:53:27 in a final plot.
0:53:29 That usually hooks people into the code today.
0:53:34 So when we change the code on, let's just say it's January 1, anything that's applied
0:53:38 for after January 1, new rules apply.
0:53:41 Those people would be moving forward with the new rules, the ones that are currently being
0:53:45 built, follow the old rules until they're finished, or they expire, and then they go
0:53:49 with the new ones. In terms of notifying most affected, the Luminaire and Street
0:53:54 Sign conversation we've had with the Developers Group and the Builders Association
0:53:59 some time ago, hey we're aware that we're going to change it. The timing will be
0:54:04 different, so we will end up having a notification separately saying, hey we're
0:54:07 gonna do this now. It's not that they didn't know it was incoming, it's just
0:54:11 going to be an advanced timeline and that doesn't really rock somebody's whole
0:54:15 world the water situation has potential to do so yes so that would have a
0:54:23 similar notification to builders association developers group realtors
0:54:30 group we can do that kind of routes we anticipate doing that kind of outreach
0:54:33 when we change something like this in our code it's usually those three big
0:54:37 groups and they kind of get the word out that kind of gets everybody from the
0:54:41 beginning all the way to the homeowner buying it. Right. Right. Okay. Very good.
0:54:46 Thank you. But again this is just the process we're just beginning the process
0:54:53 to have that conversation to make the amendments. This is authorizing us to
0:54:57 work. Yep. I'll make a motion if we're ready. I think we are. All right. I move
0:55:03 that we approve city staff to begin the process for amending Title 10 zoning and
0:55:08 subdivision regulations and associated development agreement policies to
0:55:12 address immediate issues with street
0:55:15 luminaries, street signs and a proposed water capacity fee program.
0:55:20 Thank you. Jason Brown? Second. Thank you. Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Jason
0:55:26 Brown, to authorize the staff to begin the process for
0:55:29 amending title 10 zoning and subdivision regulations and associated
0:55:34 development agreement policies to address imminent issues with street
0:55:40 luminaire street signs and proposed water capacity fee program. Any further
0:55:46 discussion? Amy roll call vote please. Ruth Piers yes Chris Reed yes Nicky Boyd
0:55:54 yes Craig Hawkins yes Jason Brown yes Alex Kaval yes
0:55:59 Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. Thank you, Jonathan. So that's it for under items of consideration.
0:56:10 The next item on the agenda is the time for public input. I want to remind everybody that
0:56:18 please come down if you're interested. Come down to the podium state your name and whether
0:56:23 your resident or property owner in Twin Falls, you will be limited to two minutes.
0:56:30 You can address anything not on the agenda, but may not address personnel or personnel related
0:56:37 issues.
0:56:39 Any personnel issues should be directed to either me or the City Manager Travis.
0:56:46 Anyone failing to follow these rules will be provided one warning.
0:56:50 of the speaker continue to disregard the warning,
0:56:53 the mic will be shut off.
0:56:55 So anybody out there that wishes to come down?
0:56:59 Yes, sir.
0:57:16 Prior to last week's council meeting,
0:57:18 I emailed each of you a motion,
0:57:21 which I'd hoped magistrate Judge Benjamin Harmer
0:57:24 would sign seeking administrative relief
0:57:27 from a construction constructive eviction
0:57:30 leveled at my tenants August 24th.
0:57:34 I submitted a public records request
0:57:36 for the affidavit in which the mop warrant was based
0:57:39 and was assured it would be returned
0:57:42 within the 10-day statutory timeframe.
0:57:45 I'm somewhat concerned, however,
0:57:47 that the motion was not read
0:57:50 and that the city council is taking a legal stance
0:57:53 where no lawsuit is pending.
0:57:55 I urge the city council to consider the following,
0:57:59 what was the legal basis for the search
0:58:03 and why were police officers involved
0:58:05 and what was termed a fire safety inspection.
0:58:08 In the absence of due process and a clear legal framework,
0:58:11 such inspections, not only undermine citizens' trust
0:58:15 in city institutions, but may open the door
0:58:18 to legal challenges.
0:58:21 I asked Travis for organic conversation after,
0:58:25 I think it was Tuesday morning, he declined,
0:58:28 he referred the matter to city attorney,
0:58:32 and indicated that he hadn't read the motion
0:58:34 that I filed, which was a plea relief based upon what I believe are the Constitution violations.
0:58:43 I'm not seeking a lawsuit or anything, you know, I know what I'm doing, necessarily
0:58:48 in code and I'm probably going to need some guidance, you know, to figure out how to get
0:58:53 around that, but I wasn't interested in doing that this morning, so that's really all I
0:58:57 have for now.
0:58:59 Thank you.
0:59:03 So, Travis, do you have my understanding?
0:59:06 I was delivered a packet.
0:59:08 My understanding was, there was, this was a legal issue
0:59:12 that we couldn't comment on.
0:59:13 So, my understanding.
0:59:15 So, Mr. Wreckert invited a holder on my desk,
0:59:20 I believe it was very similar to yours,
0:59:21 in which there he had a legal brief that was prepared.
0:59:24 And in that legal brief, he also had a series of attachments.
0:59:29 So, when a folder appears on my desk and it appears
0:59:32 to be a legal brief and a legal proceeding, whether it's drafted by an attorney or not,
0:59:39 which they're not required to be.
0:59:41 And it does say that it's Mr. Record versus the City of Twin Falls and it's heading.
0:59:46 I don't know how else to take it other than a potential lawsuit.
0:59:50 That information was then given to our legal counsel in addition to that we forwarded on
0:59:55 to I-Cramp as a matter of standard practice and policy.
0:59:58 I shared that in an email with Mr. Record.
1:00:02 And Mr. Record acknowledged that.
1:00:03 Mr. Record acknowledged my email, and he said in that that he understood.
1:00:09 And so I don't know.
1:00:11 I also understand that Mr. Record had a meeting with members of our city staff today in which
1:00:18 he met with our fire chief as well as our building official, and hopefully they're going
1:00:22 to be able to rectify the situation, and that the actions that have led to this point
1:00:30 are going to be corrected and they're going to be taken care of.
1:00:36 It has historically been the stance of the City of Twin Falls to disengage in an administrative
1:00:43 process when a lawsuit has either been presented or it has been challenged.
1:00:50 And that has been the recommendation of ICRIB for as long as I've been working in this
1:00:56 profession.
1:01:00 No.
1:01:01 You can't.
1:01:02 Sorry.
1:01:03 That's I'm not comfortable saying anything discussing this at all just because I also received the legal documents
1:01:11 So that's what council said. I think we stop it here
1:01:16 Okay, anybody else from the audience that wishes to come down and address City Council on
1:01:22 Non-personnel issues or something not on the agenda
1:01:25 Hey seeing no one advisory board reports
1:01:36 meeting this morning that included a ribbon cutting for the delta, the second delta flight.
1:01:44 We had a lot of people shot, Mayor gave a speech, Bill Carberry gave a speech, a lot
1:01:49 of people were there. It's a pretty big deal. I think everybody, all of us were there today.
1:01:55 So it was fun to see. It's a good looking bird, I have to say. It was pretty nice seeing
1:02:00 that fly in.
1:02:01 and I was happy to see that it was half full.
1:02:04 It was.
1:02:05 The first flight on the first day, so that was good.
1:02:08 Look forward to more of that.
1:02:10 Anybody else?
1:02:13 Okay, we have no public hearings tonight.
1:02:16 The next is Executive Session, an action item under 740061B
1:02:24 to consider the evaluation dismissal or discleaning
1:02:26 of or to hear complaints or charges brought
1:02:29 against the public officer, employee, staff member,
1:02:32 or individual agent or public school student,
1:02:35 F to communicate with legal counsel for the public agency
1:02:39 to discuss the legal ramifications of and legal options
1:02:43 or pending litigation or controversies not yet being
1:02:46 litigated but imminently likely to be litigated.
1:02:50 The mere presence of legal counsel at an executive session
1:02:54 does not satisfy this requirement.
1:02:57 and I to engage in communications with a representative
1:03:01 of the public agency's risk manager or insurance provider
1:03:05 to discuss the adjustment of a pending claim
1:03:08 or prevention of a claim, imminent likely to be filed.
1:03:11 The mere presence of a representative
1:03:14 of the public agency's risk manager insurance provider
1:03:19 how an executive session does not satisfy this requirement.
1:03:24 Alex?
1:03:26 I move that we adjourn to executive session pursuant to Idaho Code 74-206-1B, F, and I.
1:03:35 Thank you.
1:03:36 Do I have a second?
1:03:37 Second.
1:03:38 Thank you.
1:03:39 Motion by Alex Cavall, seconded by Nikki Boyd to move into executive session under 74-206-1B,
1:03:47 F, and I.
1:03:51 Amy Roll-Co-Vote?
1:03:52 Chris Reed.
1:03:54 Yes.
1:03:55 Nikki Boyd?
1:03:56 Yes.
1:03:57 Yes.
1:03:58 Face and Brown.
1:03:59 Yes.
1:04:00 Alex Kaval.
1:04:01 Yes.
1:04:02 Spencer Cutler.
1:04:03 Yes.
1:04:04 Henry Pierce.
1:04:05 Yes.
1:04:06 Thank you.
1:04:07 Motion passes seven to zero.
1:04:08 Just to let you know we will not be coming back here after we finish executive session tonight.
1:04:14 So meeting is adjourned.
1:04:16 Thank you.
Download
- Transcript (text) 55 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 73 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 99 KB
- Audio (M4A) 15.2 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Tuesday, September 5, 2023. The recording started at 16:58 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:04:22.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
d223b83be2317d457a0605e343b0c5153e210e8d72b654d3ab7cc1c7b5695ede - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 2c704e476e935fe1d50627a79eaecda278c9ff5b02ec6ae474c305c947ed070c - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
48832041dc2757df61e6a3a04f6daf8ea0121e920e7ee13c2e5ffdd009efb9e6
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file