OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, October 16, 2023

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Minutes on fileExecutive session: a,f

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording

Transcript

0:01:37 Okay, good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the October 16th, 2023 City Council meeting. I want to confirm we have a quorum. We have all seven, seven members present in chambers.

0:01:51 First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance and we have some scouts here.

0:01:57 If you all want to come down, I've asked them to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance, and

0:02:02 Jeff, will you turn on that mic for them right here so they can, yes, thank you. And please rise

0:02:12 to join them in the pledge. Please follow me in the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:02:32 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:02:47 Thank you.

0:02:47 And before you sit down, if you could just take a minute

0:02:51 to introduce yourself and tell us what troop you're with

0:02:55 and what badge you're studying.

0:03:01 This is Moses Pashmead for Pack 63.

0:03:15 Part of St. Edward's is what we've heard her through.

0:03:17 And what badge are you working on today?

0:03:20 We need a country.

0:03:24 Thank you.

0:03:26 next is macing a board and you're with the same group and you're studying for

0:03:33 the same batch got it okay I'm Evan Fisher thank you I'll take that for

0:03:44 granted now okay my name is Oliver Melny thank you thank you appreciate it

0:03:54 okay next item on the agenda is proclamations we have no proclamations

0:04:04 tonight. So I'll move right into the consent calendar. Council wishes move to

0:04:09 approve the consent calendar is published. Thank you. Second motion by Chris Reed

0:04:14 seconded by Jason Brown to approve the consent calendar as written. Amy Roll

0:04:19 call vote please. Ruth Pierce yes. Yes. Yes. Thank you Boyd. Greg Hawkins. Yes.

0:04:26 Jason Brown. Yes. Alex Cabal. Yes. Yes. Thank you. So if you were here to for

0:04:34 the Special Event for the Fire Station Grand Opening, which we'll talk about, or the final

0:04:39 plan for El Malagro.

0:04:41 Those were both approved.

0:04:43 Next on the agenda under items of consideration, we have an action item, approval of an agreement

0:04:48 between the College of Southern Idaho and the City of Twin Falls, exchanging real properties,

0:04:55 settling water bright protests, and authorizing the mayor to sign the agreement.

0:05:00 And we have our city manager, Travis Rothweiler, welcome, Travis.

0:05:04 Thank you, Mayor, members of the City Council.

0:05:06 So tonight is an agreement before you that has been, some would argue, many years in the

0:05:13 making.

0:05:15 Inside of this agreement, there are lots of pieces to unpack and we've had several conversations

0:05:20 over the course of the last few months about this agreement and all that it entails.

0:05:27 At first I want to thank President Dean Fisher, the Board of Trustees for the College of Southern

0:05:32 Idaho and all of the members of our team, Mitch Humble, Wendy Davis, Travis Thompson, that

0:05:39 really assisted in lifting and creating the document that it is before you.

0:05:43 It's the partnership that we have with the College of Southern Idaho that makes this conversation

0:05:48 tonight possible.

0:05:52 So it would be, I'd be remiss if I didn't thank them on the front end.

0:05:57 So the agreement before you this evening exchanges real property.

0:06:03 There are two pieces of property that the College of Southern Idaho is going to acquire from

0:06:10 the city or interest in real property.

0:06:11 The first is going to be Fire Station Number 2.

0:06:15 Fire Station Number 2 is located on Falls Avenue and it is contiguous to the College

0:06:23 of Southern Idaho's property.

0:06:25 As you know, and as we discussed, we're opening up a new fire station number to tomorrow, and

0:06:33 that property is surplus property.

0:06:35 We've described it as surplus property.

0:06:38 We've gone through all of the requirements, according to Idaho Code, to provide that property

0:06:42 and exchange that to the college.

0:06:45 The college would like to square up their boundaries, and they would also like to see how they

0:06:49 they may be able to transform that facility and turn it into part of their

0:06:53 instructional environment in the future, and so they had an interest in that property.

0:06:58 The second is our half share of the armory.

0:07:03 So the City of Twin Falls owns one half share of the armory should the National Guard

0:07:10 move out of that facility.

0:07:13 And in the event that they move, the city would own one half of that facility,

0:07:17 which is wholly located inside of the center of the College of Southern Idaho

0:07:21 and that we would not have any necessary or use of that property. So the college is receiving

0:07:28 those two pieces of property. So what is the city receiving? The first is that we are going to

0:07:33 receive Pre-B Springs. It is a fish hatchery where the aquaculture program for the College of Southern

0:07:39 Idaho has been taking place for the last several years. It is inside of Rock Creek Canyon and

0:07:45 And the college is moving its aquaculture program to a different location where they believe that its sustainability and long-term viability would be better and needs would be better met at a place at a different location.

0:08:01 And so that piece becomes pretty important as we talked about the improvements to rock springs and the opportunities to create and expand our larger urban trail system and park system that we are able to acquire that.

0:08:14 believe that it is a key piece of the work that we've been doing with Congressman Simpson's

0:08:20 office on our Rock Creek Water Quality Project. And so we'll receive that piece. In addition

0:08:28 to that, and for several years, and as a part of the Pre-B Springs Agreement, there were

0:08:36 a series of water calls and protests between the College of Southern Idaho and the City

0:08:41 of Twin Falls that both would be settled as a result of this project.

0:08:47 The first is we have a water right that has about 14 CFS of water that we will be able

0:08:56 to augment into our system and the agreements as upon our call the college will lift its

0:09:04 water right protest.

0:09:07 We want that row at water right protest to remain in place for a little bit while longer

0:09:12 as the way water law is written so that we can find opportunities to incorporate that

0:09:18 into our system.

0:09:20 The second is the water, the second protest was we're looking at commingling all of our

0:09:25 water rights so we can use different points of diversion for those water rights.

0:09:30 So right now our water rights are tied to singular points where we pull that out

0:09:35 with wells. We're working through a process to make sure that we can use a single source

0:09:42 for many of our water rights. We've often talked about the Council of Well Number Five.

0:09:47 Well Number Five is the space that Mitch found. He was out water-witching one day. We like

0:09:52 to joke. The truth of the story is we had our water team. They were looking for a piece

0:09:57 of property to be able to move forward and create a new well for the south well field.

0:10:04 We struggled to find another location, and Mitch says, well, why don't you just go look

0:10:07 at the property that we already own?

0:10:09 And sure enough, it was a high producing well, and from that point forward, we've been working

0:10:14 to create well number five.

0:10:16 The funding is in the budget, and solving that protest allows us to begin construction

0:10:22 onto that well site.

0:10:24 It will also augment and create more water and more sustainable opportunities for water

0:10:30 supply in our community.

0:10:33 The last piece of the agreement you'll notice is that we've gone through and there is a joint

0:10:39 use agreement for the different properties that are in there.

0:10:42 Because we're transferring properties to the College of Southern Idaho, namely the fire

0:10:46 station, part of that agreement need to be rewritten and so that is also included as part

0:10:53 of this overall agreement that is there for your consideration and I'm happy to answer

0:10:57 any questions that you might have.

0:10:59 Thank you, Spencer Cutler.

0:11:00 Hi, Mayor.

0:11:02 I may employ the College of the Idaho, so for this matter, I won't offer any comments

0:11:06 on it and I'll abstain from voting.

0:11:09 Thank you.

0:11:10 Any questions for Travis on this issue?

0:11:13 Thank you very much, Justin.

0:11:15 Thank you very much for a very succinct explanation of the over 100 pages of documentation that

0:11:23 came through.

0:11:24 Yes.

0:11:25 Thank you.

0:11:26 Thank you.

0:11:27 Thank you.

0:11:28 Chris Reed.

0:11:29 I just want to say thank you.

0:11:30 you stated that this is something that has been in the works for years and I

0:11:34 don't think people understand how much time and effort went into this agreement.

0:11:38 So thank you for the hard work. Thank you to the College of Southern Idaho and

0:11:42 other I hear but thank you for working with us to solve this. Thank you. Hey.

0:11:49 Yes, I'll make a motion if we're ready. Chris, a move that we approve the

0:11:54 agreement between the College of Southern Idaho and the City of Twin Falls

0:11:57 is exchanging real property, settling water, right protest, and authorizing the mayor to

0:12:02 sign the agreement.

0:12:05 Thank you.

0:12:06 Jason Brown.

0:12:07 I'll second.

0:12:08 Thank you.

0:12:09 Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Jason Brown to approve the agreement between CSI and the

0:12:14 City of Twin Falls, exchanging real property, settling water, right protest, and authorizing

0:12:21 the mayor to sign the agreement.

0:12:23 Any further discussion?

0:12:25 Amy Roll call vote please.

0:12:28 Spencer Cutler abstain Alex Cabal. Yes, Jason Brown. Yes, Greg Hawkins. Yes. Thank you, Boyd. Yes, Chris Reed

0:12:39 Yes, motion passes six with one of six four with one abstention. Thank you

0:12:49 six in favor

0:12:52 Hix for so I not the number six and the number four six in favor

0:12:58 Thank you. Sorry. Six voted yes and what abstained to be perfectly clear. It's

0:13:06 going to be one of those nights. Thank you all. Okay. Next, thank you Travis. Next on

0:13:14 the agenda is an action item. City staff requests that the Council approve the

0:13:19 use of water waste water reserve funds not to exceed 50,000 to pay quality

0:13:26 Coding's inspection and consulting, Inc. for service as a third-party inspector during the

0:13:32 application of the entire Coding on the East Digestor. And we have Nathan Erickson, welcome

0:13:38 Nathan. Thank you, Mayor Council. Sorry, that was kind of a mouthful to read off. But yes,

0:13:50 I'm here today to discuss the East Digestor, Digestor number two. I've been here previously

0:13:58 about the west digester, the east digester, just kind of a little geography there.

0:14:06 It is the one there with the, it looks like it was orange on my screen, but it's more

0:14:11 yellowish there, arrow.

0:14:15 That digester was originally built in 1980.

0:14:21 The interior originally did not have a coating, and then in 2010 when they went in and inspected

0:14:27 that they decided to put a coating on it and so they put a coating on the interior

0:14:31 dome and the way the digester works the importance is that you get all your

0:14:36 biogases in the interior dome and that's to protect the concrete that's why the

0:14:44 coding was put in in 2010 and council was approached in 2021 about some issues

0:14:57 they were having with the interior of that that digester. The coding was coming

0:15:00 off. They were getting some of the pieces in through the pumps and so in 21 council

0:15:06 approved money to contract to have the digester drained and a new coding put

0:15:12 on. A money was approved for that, and it was put out to bid. Merit professional

0:15:19 coatings was contracted to do the interior coating at that time for $345,000. They

0:15:29 completed that work, and it was put back into production in March of 2022. In April,

0:15:36 So the next month, Jacob's engineering that operates the plant started noticing that there

0:15:44 were some leaks in the dome.

0:15:47 So on top, so there was the interior coating had failed, they weren't sure to what degree.

0:15:56 At that time we were in construction of the West digester, and so this digester had to

0:16:02 stay active in use and so merit professional coatings came up with a temporary fix they

0:16:10 went and they tried to patch those leaks from the outside and it worked on some but not on

0:16:18 all and it was when they proposed that it was understood that that was a temporary fix

0:16:23 that we knew that the leak was from the inside.

0:16:26 So when the work was done on the west digester in October of 2022, it was determined we were

0:16:37 also going through some changes in our boiler, so we had some other things going on.

0:16:43 The plant was not comfortable going through the winter with just one digester, and so

0:16:47 we had to hold off being able to get inside the east digester to see what was going on.

0:16:53 So this summer, we were able to finally get the digester drained in June, and then soon

0:17:05 after that we were able to get inside the digester, and this is what we found.

0:17:12 It was very evident that the interacoding, you can see the wrinkles, that was some delamination

0:17:17 from the ceiling and then also right away the rapaches that were just falling off in

0:17:25 large quantities. So we ended up, so Merit, the product they installed was from Sherwin

0:17:35 Williams and so Sherwin Williams came out, they wanted to take some samples. The city

0:17:40 just for our own legal protection contracted with a third party inspector to come out and

0:17:46 take some samples and do our own analysis of why the Coding failed and at that time it

0:17:54 was found both Sherwin Williams and the City's inspector found that the problem with the Coding

0:18:00 was a problem with the mixture when it was applied.

0:18:04 So there was an off-ratio because it had two parts and when it was applied it wasn't mixed

0:18:10 at the right percentages.

0:18:12 And so with that, Merritt is responsible to help fix or replace that coding.

0:18:24 On September 20th, so just recently, Merritt was able to get in and start to sand blast

0:18:30 the roof and take off all those codeings.

0:18:35 The approach to the city and Jacob's engineering is representing us in this process and they

0:18:42 They proposed a new product to install that's a different producer, it's Carbeline, a very,

0:18:51 I guess, well-known company in coatings, and they've provided, you know, they meet our specifications,

0:19:02 actually meet and exceed those.

0:19:04 They've also proposed to give us a longer warranty.

0:19:06 So on the re-application of a liner, the standard warranty is just one year, carbeline is saying

0:19:14 that it will give us a five-year warranty.

0:19:17 So that's definitely a positive.

0:19:23 The recommendation of the city's engineer is that just because this project has had issues,

0:19:29 it is in the city's best interest to have someone on site that specifically represents

0:19:33 the city during that application to make sure that we don't end up with another

0:19:37 off-ratio sort of situation. And so the city has identified quality coatings

0:19:45 inspections and consulting as a company that will go on site. They were the ones

0:19:50 that did the original I guess testing of the coating that we contracted with but

0:19:57 that they would contract with the city to go in and be there throughout every step of

0:20:04 the process of the new application of the liner.

0:20:08 They estimate that it will take about six weeks and the cost would be about $31,000.

0:20:16 Just because we don't know, I mean, things go wrong and we're proposing to request $50,000

0:20:24 needed. And the $31,000 is only if needed also. So if they do not, there's a chance actually

0:20:31 the schedule that just came out today. They should be done with the removing of the existing

0:20:36 coding by the end of this week and then next week they can start and they think that they

0:20:40 could have it done in five weeks if everything goes good. So it could be less than the $31,000.

0:20:49 And so if there's any questions.

0:20:55 Any questions for Nathan on this?

0:21:00 I would entertain a motion.

0:21:02 Mayor, I'd like to.

0:21:03 I have a question if that's all right.

0:21:07 Oh, yeah.

0:21:09 OK.

0:21:09 Mayor, it's going to be doing this again.

0:21:11 They are.

0:21:12 Are we comfortable with Mayor doing this again?

0:21:14 So the first time didn't go so well.

0:21:19 Absolutely.

0:21:20 So they have been cooperating, and they have been performing.

0:21:25 So, at this point, legally, they have not provided any circumstance that the city could say,

0:21:30 no, we don't want you to do it.

0:21:32 So, as long as they continue to meet our expectations and the specifications,

0:21:37 my understanding is that we have to continue through this process with them.

0:21:42 They do have a deadline that, I mean, if, you know, if it does not happen by November,

0:21:50 So if they delay by their own doing, then the city could,

0:21:55 I guess, pull the bond on the project and go after that.

0:22:00 But at this point, we don't really have the cause to do that.

0:22:02 Okay.

0:22:03 And if there's an issue with this new coding, that's why the

0:22:08 inspector, the agreement's still in place, they would do it again.

0:22:12 We don't want them to do it a third time, but an agreement that they will

0:22:17 have to, there's a cost associated with this.

0:22:20 So the inspector, the intent of the inspector

0:22:23 is to make sure that every step of the process

0:22:26 needs the specifications.

0:22:27 So we shouldn't run into the same issue.

0:22:32 But the agreement just in case protects us,

0:22:37 is there going to be another agreement in place?

0:22:39 There's the five-year warranty.

0:22:41 Five-year warranty.

0:22:41 Yes, perfect.

0:22:42 So which is, like I said, is far more than the one year

0:22:46 that we typically.

0:22:48 OK.

0:22:49 Jason Brown.

0:22:51 I'll make the motion less than you want.

0:22:53 I move to approve, or I move to approve the use of wastewater

0:22:58 reserve funds not to exceed 50,000 to pay quality coding

0:23:03 inspection and consulting services of third party inspection

0:23:07 during the application of the interior coding for the east

0:23:10 time water treatment plan.

0:23:13 Thank you, Nikki Boyd.

0:23:14 Second.

0:23:15 Thank you, motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Nikki Boyd

0:23:19 to approve the use of wastewater reserve funds

0:23:22 not to exceed $50,000 to pay quality coding inspection and consulting for service as a

0:23:29 third party inspector during the application of the interior coding on the east digester.

0:23:35 Any further discussion?

0:23:37 Amy Rokalvo please.

0:23:39 Alex Kaval.

0:23:40 Yes.

0:23:41 Jason Brown.

0:23:42 Yes.

0:23:43 Craig Hawkins.

0:23:44 Yes.

0:23:45 Hakey Boyd.

0:23:46 Yes.

0:23:47 Chris Reed.

0:23:48 Yes.

0:23:49 Ruth Pierce.

0:23:50 Yes.

0:23:51 7 to 0. Okay next on the agenda is again under items of consideration and action item a request

0:24:01 to approve the purchase of a 2025 Freightliner truck fitted with heated asphalt bed at the cost

0:24:09 of $251,262.77 using a cooperative purchasing agreement with Sourcewell and authorized the

0:24:19 public works director to execute the contract and we have Mark Thompson welcome

0:24:23 Mark thank you

0:24:26 and council I appreciate you give me the time to present to you tonight yes I am

0:24:31 here to request a purchase of a twenty five

0:24:35 great liner truck first I'll give you a little background on why we're here

0:24:39 and then I'll kind of go into a little bit about our replacement program for

0:24:43 our equipment and then at the end have a little bit of time if you have any

0:24:49 So Idaho Code 672807 went into effect on July 1, 2019, and it states, with the approval of

0:24:58 its governing board, a political subdivision may participate in cooperative purchasing agreements

0:25:04 with the state of Idaho, other Idaho political subdivisions, other government entities, or

0:25:10 associations thereof, but political subdivisions may also participate in cooperative purchasing

0:25:16 programs established by any association that offers its goods and services as a result

0:25:22 of competitive solicitation processes. Goods and services be procured by participation

0:25:29 in such cooperative agreements or programs shall be deemed to have been acquired in accordance

0:25:34 with the requirements of this chapter. A few months later on December 9th of 2019, our

0:25:41 Council approved a resolution, two zero one nine dash one dash zero one four

0:25:48 authorizing staff to use cooperative purchasing agreements and join

0:25:53 cooperative purchasing programs. City staff can approve purchases up to the

0:25:58 informal bid limits if the purchase is greater than the informal bid limit which

0:26:04 has recently increased to a hundred fifty thousand dollars city of council

0:26:07 City Council approval, but back in 2010 the street department developed its equipment replacement

0:26:16 program and in that program we have a replacement schedule. It's our goal using that schedule to

0:26:24 replace our trucks in that 10 to 12 year mark but due to budget other equipment priorities

0:26:31 that come up and recently the availability of actually getting brought to some problems

0:26:39 replacement. So this truck that we're replacing was originally purchased in

0:26:45 October of 2007 by in October of 2008. A manufacturer actually discontinued making

0:26:54 this truck. So 16 years later we're here and imagine hearts are getting pretty

0:27:02 tough to find on the truck that's not produced anymore. So we currently run two

0:27:11 trucks in our fleet with, well, let me back up a little bit, but you're going to

0:27:18 hear me talk about patch trucks. In our, in the action item it says it hasn't

0:27:26 heated asphalt bed. Our guys usually just refer to them as a patch truck. If I

0:27:32 refer to it as a patch truck, it's talking about the heated asphalt bed.

0:27:37 We're able, so we have two trucks in our fleet which play a vital role in the

0:27:43 maintenance of our roads. Because of these beds, we're able to use them

0:27:48 around. We're able to set the temperature of these trucks and we can

0:27:52 maintain the asphalt temperatures. We're able to use it in the winter. When

0:27:58 hot mix is not available, we're able to get cold mix and we can heat it so it's

0:28:03 pliable enough to match potholes and the other imperfections that we find in the

0:28:11 or they need to be repaired.

0:28:13 We also use these trucks when we're preparing for our chip seal.

0:28:18 Each one of our zones in our maintenance program

0:28:23 has roughly 65 to 70 lane miles of road.

0:28:28 So we're able to fill these trucks with 4 ton of asphalt.

0:28:32 We send these trucks out with our crews.

0:28:34 They're looking for low spots.

0:28:37 They're looking for benches that have sunk.

0:28:40 They're looking for those square bore holes that we seem to see all over the city.

0:28:47 So we repair all that.

0:28:49 They're also looking for alligator spots.

0:28:52 Spots that are too big to patch at the time.

0:28:55 And then we come back with a milling machine.

0:28:57 We mill it out and we repave it using these trucks to all the asphalt.

0:29:03 We're also limited, like I said, to fork down for trucks.

0:29:06 So that's why we have two trucks and these bigger projects.

0:29:11 We can do bigger projects with these two products.

0:29:15 So back in February, we presented our equipment replacement

0:29:18 needs for fiscal year 2324 to the long-term planning

0:29:22 committee, where they were approved and later adopted.

0:29:26 But the City Council is part of the fiscal year 2324 budget.

0:29:31 As you know, vehicle and equipment purchases

0:29:35 have changed over the last couple of years.

0:29:39 We understand it now.

0:29:42 dealers are allotted so many build slots per year.

0:29:45 Once those build slots are full,

0:29:48 there is no availability of those trucks.

0:29:51 When we started this program,

0:29:52 or when we started looking at this truck,

0:29:54 we originally were going with a different manufacturer.

0:29:57 They came to us about a month ago

0:29:59 and said that their build slots are full for the year,

0:30:01 for 24, so we quickly, quickly hurried

0:30:05 and a good thing about Sourcewell

0:30:07 is they have multiple contracts with multiple dealers

0:30:09 so that we were able to find another truck.

0:30:14 If you approve this purchase tonight, it looks like

0:30:18 we will be able to get a build slot

0:30:21 in the second quarter of 24.

0:30:22 Between, by the 10th of the second quarter of June, July,

0:30:25 going into 24, puts a build of that truck.

0:30:31 It's gonna be pushing it, getting in,

0:30:33 finished by the next, before we go into the next fiscal year.

0:30:37 So we'll end up probably having to encumber the money.

0:30:40 So usually, four, 20, 20, six months was a long time

0:30:48 for a truck build, now it's six months before you can even

0:30:53 get a build slot to build the truck, so things have changed.

0:30:57 As far as the budget impact goes,

0:30:59 we had $260,000 budgeted for the replacement of this truck.

0:31:03 Our quote is under our budget.

0:31:07 I can, if anybody has any questions,

0:31:10 I can share an answer.

0:31:12 Any questions for Mark?

0:31:16 Nicky Boyd?

0:31:18 We'll make a motion if you're ready.

0:31:19 Perfect.

0:31:20 Yes, thank you.

0:31:23 Mayor, I move that we approve the purchase

0:31:26 of a 2025 Freightliner truck fitted with a heat assault

0:31:31 bed at a cost of $251,262.77 using a cooperative purchasing

0:31:39 agreement with Sourcewell and authorized the public works

0:31:43 director to execute the contract.

0:31:46 Thank you, Craig Hawkins.

0:31:47 Second.

0:31:48 Thank you motion by Nuki Boyd, seconded by Craig Hawkins

0:31:52 to approve the purchase of a 2025 Freightliner truck,

0:31:56 fitted with a heated asphalt bed at the cost of 251,262.77,

0:32:04 using a cooperative purchasing agreement with Sourcewell

0:32:07 and authorize the public works director

0:32:09 to execute the contract.

0:32:11 Alex Kaval.

0:32:13 Mark, how does this vehicle compare to the one

0:32:15 that you were originally eyeing?

0:32:16 And have you used this type of before and are you happy with it?

0:32:22 So the truck we're going to go with was an international,

0:32:26 this one's a freight liner, same truck, same size.

0:32:29 And yes, we have an older thermolay bed in our fleet right now.

0:32:34 So it is our bulletproof.

0:32:37 I'm hoping that this will be the last one I see in my career.

0:32:41 You never know.

0:32:42 Thank you.

0:32:43 Any other questions?

0:32:46 Amy Rolkow-Voh, please.

0:32:50 Jason Brown.

0:32:51 Yes.

0:32:52 Craig Hawkins.

0:32:53 Yes.

0:32:54 Thank you, Boyd.

0:32:55 Yes.

0:32:56 Chris Reed.

0:32:57 Yes.

0:32:58 Ruth Pierce.

0:32:59 Yes.

0:33:00 Spencer Cutler.

0:33:01 Yes.

0:33:02 And Alex Cabal.

0:33:03 Yes.

0:33:04 Thank you, Motion Passes 7-0.

0:33:05 Thank you.

0:33:06 Thank you, Mark.

0:33:07 Next, we have an action item, a request to award a bid for the sale of surplus city property

0:33:12 located at 912 Caswell Avenue West to Mazzier-Soby in the amount of $70,000 and we have

0:33:21 Mitch Humble, our Deputy City Manager, welcome Mitch.

0:33:27 This is my final time coming before the Council on this particular item.

0:33:31 If you remember, we've been here like three or four times already.

0:33:34 Logs 28th, we have the public hearing, we authorize the auction of the property at 912 Caswell.

0:33:42 After that, we went back and notified it, we received about four weeks worth of time for

0:33:49 people.

0:33:50 I had three different conversations with different people along the way, and the end when we opened

0:33:53 bids, Maziar Sobi was the high bid.

0:33:56 If you remember, we set our minimum bid at $64,500, his bid came at $70,000, and so he's

0:34:02 the high bidder.

0:34:04 It's not, interestingly enough, not the individual that started this whole process.

0:34:09 Somebody else I'll bid them anyway, so that's where we're at tonight. We just need to award the bid and then if if we

0:34:16 We'll go work with the

0:34:19 Applicant and kind of figure out the closing kind of details. You don't need to worry about the closing details

0:34:23 We'll do all that there may be a little bit of cost

0:34:26 With title companies that we'll have to pay for with that, but that'll just come out of the 70,000 and we'll move forward that way

0:34:32 So anyway, that's where we're at. I just looked and mr. So he's not here tonight

0:34:36 I've had a conversation.

0:34:38 He indicated that he probably wouldn't be here tonight,

0:34:40 but he didn't have to be.

0:34:43 So anyway, if you have any questions I can answer for you,

0:34:46 otherwise we just need to award the bid in $70,000.

0:34:50 Perfect.

0:34:51 Any questions?

0:34:51 I should say this is going to the Water Fund.

0:34:53 I don't know if I've said that before,

0:34:55 but the Water Fund acquired the property.

0:34:57 The money that we get will be unaccounted for revenue

0:35:01 or an anticipated revenue in the Water Fund.

0:35:04 Perfect.

0:35:05 Any questions for Mitch?

0:35:08 I would entertain a motion.

0:35:11 Thank you, Nikki.

0:35:13 There, I move that we award a bid for the sale

0:35:18 of the surplus city property located at 912 Caswell Avenue

0:35:23 West to Mazari Sobie in the amount of $70,000.

0:35:28 Thank you, Craig Hawkins.

0:35:30 Second.

0:35:30 Thank you, motion by Nikki Boyd, second by Craig Hawkins

0:35:34 to award the bid for the sale of the surplus city property

0:35:38 912 Caswell Avenue West, Tomazier, Sobie, and the amount of 70,000. Any further

0:35:45 discussion? Amy Rokal, please. Thank you, Boyd. Yes. Chris Reed. Yes. Bruce Pierce. Yes.

0:35:52 Spencer Cutler. Yes. Alex Koval. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. And Craig Hawkins. Yes.

0:35:58 Thank you. Motion passes 7 to 0. Thank you, Mitch. Okay, that's it for items of

0:36:06 consideration next on the agenda is public input. It's a time for anybody in the public

0:36:15 who wishes to come down and address City Council on an issue that was not on today's

0:36:20 agenda. Please come down. In addition, we will not be taking input on personnel or personnel

0:36:29 related issues. Any of those issues should be directly communicated with the mayor or

0:36:35 the city manager. So if you wish to speak, you have two minutes, please come down to the

0:36:40 podium and state your name and whether you're resident of Twin Falls. So anybody here that

0:36:47 wishes to address City Council? Okay, seeing no one. Yes. Oh, sure. Come on down. Now you're

0:37:09 Yeah, pretty many where your mouth is right. I guess so. Yes. Good afternoon. My name is Matt Fisher. I'm a resident here in Swin Falls. So, um, I just had a question. Um,

0:37:18 with about how sidewalks work in Twin Falls, I know you walk on them. But what I mean is some places have them, some places don't. And literally, as I work to send, and in some places in Twin Falls, it looks like

0:37:33 This sidewalks have eroded away to nothing, literally crumbled, especially in the old town.

0:37:38 I'm just wondering how that works. We moved last year from Iowa.

0:37:42 In our city, they had people come out and inspect the sidewalks, make sure they were in good condition.

0:37:47 I'm not disabled or anything like that. I can walk down them, but I'm wondering about people in wheelchairs.

0:37:54 Are there ADA, how the city addresses that? I was just curious how that worked.

0:37:58 So, thank you. We actually had a meeting last week. We did have a report on sidewalks and

0:38:05 we do have a sidewalk plan. I will say that there is also a grant program that's available

0:38:13 if a resident has a sidewalk in front of their home that needs, there's a cost-sharing grant

0:38:19 available. I think if you contact Aaron probably, Mark, maybe you don't have to come down, Mark.

0:38:31 Maybe if you just contact Mark or somebody in that department, public works, you could

0:38:37 have a conversation, any specific questions. But there is a sidewalk plan and council has

0:38:43 worked very hard to fill in some of those blanks, especially in front of schools over the last

0:38:50 several years. In fact, the report last week was, we have built over two miles of sidewalk,

0:38:56 which for sidewalk, that's a lot of sidewalk over the last several years as part of us trying

0:39:02 to focus on that. So, okay, perfect. Thank you. Thank you. So anybody else that wishes

0:39:10 to address Council, advisory board reports. I just want to mention Craig and I attended

0:39:17 the Family Police Academy on Saturday and it was really interesting and it was great that

0:39:24 it was a one-day all-day session. I think I encourage everybody from City Council to attend

0:39:32 and it's the Family Academy, not the Citizens Academy. Any other advisory board reports?

0:39:41 I've got one, so the greater Twin Falls transportation met last week, and I think the

0:39:50 biggest thing in that meeting that came out was I.T.D. is putting some final

0:39:55 remarks on their latest study from the third bridge, so hopefully they put a

0:40:03 time frame by the end of the year. So I'm hoping it's a little bit quicker than

0:40:07 that that'll be open for public consumption.

0:40:11 And at some point the city will have some input on that

0:40:14 along with other residents in the city and the county.

0:40:18 Thank you.

0:40:21 Anybody thing from the city manager's office, Travis?

0:40:24 Just really quickly a reminder about tomorrow's grand opening

0:40:27 for the fire stations.

0:40:28 It's going to begin at 11 o'clock.

0:40:31 We would ask that individuals who are attending

0:40:34 would park on the west side of the building.

0:40:37 So as you approach on Chaney that you park on the west side to ensure that you can get in.

0:40:43 We're discouraging individuals parking on the roadway or in the parking lot that is to the east of the building.

0:40:50 Okay.

0:40:53 Thank you.

0:40:54 Is it a field?

0:40:55 It is a field.

0:40:56 Okay.

0:40:57 Parking in the field.

0:40:58 Park in the field.

0:40:59 Please.

0:41:00 I won't wash my car tonight.

0:41:01 No, I would not.

0:41:02 Yeah.

0:41:03 That's not.

0:41:04 That idea.

0:41:05 Okay.

0:41:06 So next on the agenda are two public hearings.

0:41:08 Madam Mayor, we do have an executive session that is published on the main agenda.

0:41:15 For some reason it's not showing up on your video screen, but we do have on the official

0:41:24 published agenda for the City of Twin Falls, we do have an executive session, 74-28-01-A,

0:41:32 to consider hiring a public official employee, staff member, or individual agent, wherein

0:41:37 the respective qualities of the individual to be evaluated in order to fill a particular

0:41:41 vacancy or need. This paragraph does not apply to filling the vacancy of an elected

0:41:47 office or deliberations about staffing needs in general.

0:41:51 Right. And it was on my agenda, but it's after the public hearings on this one. So are

0:41:58 you suggesting that that?

0:42:00 We do have time to cover that item before if the council would like to.

0:42:04 Okay, so how does everybody feel? Go ahead. I will not be coming back to handle the public hearings at six o'clock. I have another mayoral engagement, so I will be turning the meeting over to Chris Reed.

0:42:20 So in those public hearings we'll start around 6 p.m.

0:42:26 So I will just need a motion about the Executive Session 74206 1A.

0:42:33 Madam Mayor, I move that we move into Executive Session pursuant to Idaho Code 74-2061A.

0:42:39 Thank you. Do I have a second?

0:42:41 Second.

0:42:42 Thank you. Motion by Alex Kaval, seconded by Jason Brown to move into Executive Session

0:42:48 session under 742061a. Amy Roll call vote, please.

0:42:54 Miss Reed. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. Alex Kamal. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Craig Hawkins. Yes. And Nicky Boyd. Yes.

0:43:04 Thank you. Motion passes seven to zero. Just to remind everybody, we will not be making any decisions in executive session and we'll attempt to return by six p.m. Thank you.

0:43:19 have Mitch Humble come up and introduce one of our new employees who's going to be presenting

0:43:24 tonight. Okay so last week I asked Jonathan how's this going to go on Monday night. He's

0:43:30 like I don't know how many of you think. So tonight I wanted to introduce to you all

0:43:35 Clavin. Clavin. Clavin. Clavin. Very close. He's our new senior planning started about a month

0:43:42 and a half ago right. So Will will be doing the presentation today. I want to make sure

0:43:46 you all knew who he was, um, were super glad he's here and so welcome and you can do your thing now.

0:43:52 All right, welcome. Okay, so before you jump in, we're going to start with a couple of things we

0:43:58 are going to be moving on to public hearing 8a, a request for a vacation of Magic, uh, Magic Road

0:44:05 right of way and Jason Eesman's on property located within Block 4 of the Perrine Point Subdivision

0:44:12 care of Gerald Martins on behalf of Trace Green Goes LLC and we will start turning it over

0:44:18 to Will Claver for a presentation.

0:44:23 For the sake of time and the history on both of these items are very, very similar.

0:44:31 So if it's alright with you, we'll do one presentation and then that way when the voting

0:44:38 comes you make two separate motions and vote on two different distinct ones so

0:44:43 when you make the motions make sure that it's very clear on what one you're

0:44:47 making a motion yeah if we want to do the background on both that's fine we'll

0:44:52 have public hearings for the 8a yes and then we'll go into the second one but

0:44:58 you have already told the history on it so that's fine okay we're gonna talk

0:45:01 on them together you might want to read go on me to read both of them right now

0:45:05 Yeah, that's going to both out there and we'll just vote on them independently.

0:45:09 So then public hearing 8B, an action item, request for a vacation of Perrine, court rights

0:45:15 of way and adjacent easements on properly located within block 18 of the Prine Point subdivision

0:45:22 care of Gerald Martins on behalf of trace green goes LLC.

0:45:25 But both of them are out there.

0:45:27 Are we going to have two separate public hearings or are we going to do them both together?

0:45:31 You have one hearing together and this vote on them independently.

0:45:34 Okay.

0:45:35 Here it needs to be for both items very specifically.

0:45:37 That's why you've read them both in.

0:45:39 Perfect.

0:45:40 Okay.

0:45:41 Okay.

0:45:43 There we go.

0:45:45 Okay.

0:45:46 So this is the overall subdivision that we are talking about.

0:45:49 Perign point subdivision.

0:45:52 The first magic road.

0:45:57 Vacation is right here.

0:46:01 and they want to just get rid of this so they can redo these reconfigure these

0:46:13 these parcels. The second one is these pyrhine core right here and so they want

0:46:24 to redo those and get rid of the public right away in there. So all this that

0:46:30 that is considered public property right now,

0:46:33 would go back to the property owner,

0:46:35 and that they would get that property to themselves.

0:46:44 The impact to the city would just be

0:46:51 that there wouldn't be roads to these parcels back here.

0:46:56 However, we want to put a condition on approval

0:47:00 the state that they would have to rededicate Rose and reconfigure their

0:47:06 their easement so that there would be access to all the parcels when they do

0:47:11 when they go through the repladding of this subdivision. The city council on

0:47:22 September 12th voted to approve this 6 to 0 with the following conditions there

0:47:29 as follows, that is subject to continued compliance

0:47:33 with all local state and federal code requirements,

0:47:36 that is subject to Block 4 being re-platted.

0:47:43 This is for application 53, and then 57,

0:47:53 as that is subject to Block 18 being

0:47:57 re-platted identifying the right-of-way and access agreements, and then that this magic

0:48:13 road right here would be subject to sidewalk remaining and that the pedestrian path being

0:48:20 dedicated and constructed through block four during the re-plat process.

0:48:24 So it's still keeping the sidewalk and pedestrian access

0:48:28 in that process.

0:48:30 If you have any questions, I'd like to be happy to answer.

0:48:33 OK.

0:48:34 Any questions for William?

0:48:39 We might in just a few minutes, but we'll

0:48:41 give some time to Gerald.

0:48:50 Thank you for the record.

0:48:53 My name is Gerald Martin.

0:48:54 I'm here representing Chris Ringo as a developer of this property.

0:48:58 This property was planted back in 2008 by a prior owner that developed a planet.

0:49:05 That was when the economy hit the tank.

0:49:08 Anybody that's in financing or realty would remember that.

0:49:13 And nothing really happened until about 2018 or 19 when ownership changed.

0:49:20 The bulk of the area north of Magic Road was sold in one block.

0:49:25 scenic west subdivision and built as a multifamily project.

0:49:30 And so that's precluded and eliminated the accesses

0:49:33 onto this road.

0:49:34 So that precluded the need for this road.

0:49:38 So the use change or the type of use change,

0:49:42 still residential, over on the preserved court

0:49:45 on the west boundary, a bulk of that property was sold

0:49:50 or exchanged with the city and the new pressurized irrigation

0:49:55 takes up several of those lots down at that end and freed up some lots in block four which

0:50:01 impacts the magic road. So basically things have changed. These roads as they were planted

0:50:07 and conceived no longer serve the purpose for which they were originally intended.

0:50:13 We have presented the city conceptual plans for both of these parcels and way back when the

0:50:22 the City Quest development was done.

0:50:25 It was obvious that it was discussed

0:50:27 and that this road development would be vacated.

0:50:30 When we did the stormwater pond,

0:50:32 the same discussion was had.

0:50:33 We're now cleaning up these documents,

0:50:36 getting ready to move forward

0:50:38 to the development of these properties.

0:50:39 No change in land use,

0:50:41 no change in zoning,

0:50:43 elimination of roads that the public

0:50:46 will have to maintain into the future.

0:50:49 The saves of the developer money,

0:50:51 not building them, say it's the city, not many,

0:50:53 maintaining them in the future.

0:50:55 They would be superfluous.

0:50:57 They just, all of the connectivity is retained

0:51:02 as the staff report states.

0:51:03 So what we're asking for this evening is just

0:51:07 these two vacations.

0:51:08 We understand that you need to address them individually,

0:51:12 take testimony individually,

0:51:14 but you only get to hear from me one time.

0:51:17 Unless you bring me back up here for questions.

0:51:21 All right, thank you, all right.

0:51:23 We'll wait for Gerald to sit down to ask him questions to come back up because he's told us he's going to come back up.

0:51:28 Any questions for Gerald? Sorry, Gerald, come on back up. Alex Cabal.

0:51:35 I had to sit down if there wouldn't have been a question.

0:51:40 The question I had, so the conditions that were outlined by planning and zoning,

0:51:46 does the developer have any objection to?

0:51:48 No, we could occur with the, I should have said that.

0:51:50 We could occur with the conditions.

0:51:52 All right, great.

0:51:53 Thank you.

0:51:53 Thank you.

0:51:56 Any other questions for staff or the applicant?

0:52:01 Before we open up the public hearing,

0:52:02 let me just read the procedures.

0:52:04 Some of them we have gone through.

0:52:07 City staff has already happened.

0:52:09 We'll present and request the request in an analysis.

0:52:13 The applicant will then present their request as has happened.

0:52:16 The council will then ask questions of the applicant

0:52:19 staff after questions have been asked the public hearing will then be opened during

0:52:23 that time.

0:52:24 Anyone in attendance is given the opportunity to comment or ask questions about the request

0:52:30 being considered.

0:52:33 When given testimony, please step up to the podium right here, state your name and address,

0:52:38 then present your comments or concerns.

0:52:41 After giving testimony, please sign the public sign and sheet located in the lobby with your

0:52:47 name and address for the record.

0:52:50 After public comments are concluded, the applicant will be invited to answer any questions that

0:52:56 may have been made and make a closing statement.

0:53:00 Staff will then answer or clarify any comments as needed.

0:53:03 After a closing statement, the public hearing will be closed, no further testimony or comments

0:53:09 from the applicant or audience will be allowed.

0:53:12 The council will then have an open discussion and take action on the request.

0:53:18 At this time, we will open the public hearing comment anybody in attendance that would like

0:53:23 to comment on the vacation of the Magic Valley right of way and adjacent easements on property

0:53:32 located within Block 4 of the Perine Point subdivision.

0:53:36 We will open up the public comment for the first item.

0:53:41 Please come forward.

0:53:47 Seeing no comments, no one.

0:53:49 We will close that public hearing.

0:53:53 We will open up the public hearing for the second item,

0:53:57 the vacation of Perine Court right-of-way

0:54:01 and adjacent easements on property located

0:54:03 within Block 18 of the Perine Point subdivision.

0:54:08 Anybody wishing to speak on that, please come forward.

0:54:13 Seeing no one, we will close that public hearing.

0:54:16 Okay, any comments from the applicant?

0:54:20 Okay, any clarifications from city staff?

0:54:24 Any comments, any discussions?

0:54:25 Let's start with the first public hearing a on the vacation of the Magic Road right

0:54:34 away.

0:54:40 I think it's straightforward.

0:54:41 Okay.

0:54:42 Anybody like to make a motion then?

0:54:49 Question is, have we laid enough foundation for the record that all of this complies with

0:54:55 our comprehensive plan, our land use requirements so that way nobody can go back and vision?

0:55:03 William if you can, did you hear the question?

0:55:06 Yeah, if I heard it correctly,

0:55:09 it's if we laid enough foundation

0:55:11 for the comprehensive plan

0:55:13 and make sure that we have a sound decision.

0:55:15 Correct, so the proposed vacation,

0:55:19 how does it comply with our comprehensive plan

0:55:22 and our current zoning rules?

0:55:26 Start there.

0:55:27 Yeah, right now the zoning doesn't change,

0:55:31 so that's in line with our comprehensive plan.

0:55:34 future land use map is not being changed, so it aligns great, replating it, it doesn't

0:55:44 affect any of the, where we're making them replat it or they want to replat, and still

0:55:54 grant us the access and give us, it's just allowing him to update to market value, it

0:56:02 lines pretty well with our market with our conference plan to be flexible and

0:56:08 our land use and help developers get the most out of their properties. And what

0:56:14 is your opinion on the vacation of the prying courts right away in block 18

0:56:19 also meet the same requirements? Yes everything I said for block 4 for the

0:56:25 magic road would would go for the prying court as well. All right thank you

0:56:30 I have no further questions.

0:56:36 Okay.

0:56:37 Any other questions?

0:56:39 Any other discussion?

0:56:43 The conditions for both of them,

0:56:45 are they the same conditions

0:56:46 or are there different conditions recommended

0:56:48 by planning and zoning for the first public hearing

0:56:53 or for the vacation of Magic Road

0:56:55 and then for Pride and Court?

0:56:56 They do have separate conditions.

0:56:59 Okay.

0:57:01 The first one for Magic Road.

0:57:05 There's three of them.

0:57:07 They're very similar.

0:57:09 Just the difference in the wording,

0:57:12 in addition to, it just says block four

0:57:15 rather than the block 18.

0:57:17 And then the condition three is maintaining

0:57:21 that sidewalk access.

0:57:23 So that is an additional condition

0:57:25 that we would like to have on this approval.

0:57:28 Okay.

0:57:36 I'll go for the first one.

0:57:37 All right, Jason, go for it.

0:57:39 and make a motion to approve the vacation of Magic Road

0:57:43 right away in adjacent easements on property located

0:57:46 on block four of the Prine Point subdivision

0:57:50 with conditions as stated.

0:57:55 Do we have a second?

0:57:57 Second.

0:58:00 Okay, so we have a motion on the floor by Jason Brown,

0:58:03 a second by Craig Hawkins for the vacation

0:58:05 of the Magic Road right away,

0:58:07 and adjacent easements on property located

0:58:10 block four of the paren point subdivision any roll call vote please.

0:58:17 Nikki Boyd. Yes.

0:58:19 Ray Hawkins. Jason Brown. Yes.

0:58:21 Alex Kaval. Yes.

0:58:23 Spencer Cutler. Yes.

0:58:24 And Chris Reed. Yes.

0:58:27 Okay. Let's move on.

0:58:30 Emotion passes six to zero.

0:58:35 We'll now move on to the second item request for a vacation of paren court

0:58:40 The Prine Court writes of way and

0:58:43 adjacent easements on the property located within block 18 of the Prine Point

0:58:48 subdivision. Any questions, discussion?

0:58:53 No, but I'll make a motion if you're ready.

0:58:55 I am ready.

0:58:57 I move that we approve the request of vacate the Prine Court right away and

0:59:03 adjacent easements on property located within block 18 of the Prine Point

0:59:08 subdivision care of Gerald Martins on behalf of trace green goes subject to

0:59:11 the two conditions outlined by planning and zoning.

0:59:14 Okay.

0:59:16 Do we have a second?

0:59:18 I'll second.

0:59:19 Okay.

0:59:20 So we have a motion on the floor by Alex Kaval and a second by Jason Brown for the

0:59:25 variation of the prime court right away and adjacent easements on property located within

0:59:30 block 18 of the prime point subdivision.

0:59:33 Any discussion?

0:59:34 Amy, roll call vote, vote please.

0:59:39 Greg Hawkins?

0:59:40 Yes.

0:59:41 Jason Brown?

0:59:42 Yes.

0:59:43 Alex Cabal, yes, Spencer Cutler, yes, Chris Reed, yes, and Nicky Boyd, yes, and that motion passes six to zero.

0:59:51 Okay, thank you very much. Okay, and the next item is adjournment, so we are adjourned.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, October 16, 2023. The recording started at 16:58 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:00:05.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    df17bf8947957763b356da4045238b0be04487bed1be09a61892ee5db86c6bf6
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a a043d77a8d567ede363f4a12dc8fcbe50747b83e4f5f8dafc5d4216320554542
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    f889070d119b14d71521cf7a103a79103c5fe778f9e4bf0b02e8527c012d299e

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file