City Council meeting
Monday, October 23, 2023
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: c
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:01:43 Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the October 23rd, 2023 City Council meeting. I want to confirm we have a quorum. We have six members present, and I believe it's Jason on the phone yet.
0:01:56 Okay, Jason Brown will be calling in. I know he's on the road. So first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. If you wish to join me, please rise.
0:02:08 Thank you. We have no proclamations tonight. So next is the consent calendar.
0:02:32 Council wishes. Mayor, I move to accept the consent calendar as printed. Thank you. Do I have a second?
0:02:40 Second. Thank you. Motion by Nikki Boyd. Seconded by Alex Cavall to approve the consent calendar
0:02:47 as written. Amy Roll call vote please. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Ruth Reed. Yes. Thank you.
0:02:54 Thank you.
0:03:01 Thank you. Motion passes six to zero next under items of consideration and action item a request
0:03:09 to adopt ordinance 2023-008 for the vacation of the drainage storm retention easement on
0:03:19 property located at 2092 Dawson Drive PC 23-0018 and we have William
0:03:28 Claver William welcome our senior planner welcome he did thank you before us we
0:03:37 have a just a ordinance to to move forward with the vacation request that we
0:03:44 saw on June, set 12th, 2023, that's when it came before you, and it was approved as just a reminder
0:03:57 of the approval process. We need to pass this to make it into effect, and Idaho code requires
0:04:07 that an ordinance be read on three separate occasions prior to the passage. Two of the readings can
0:04:16 be satisfied by reading the title only. Furthermore, Idaho Code allows the reading rules to be dispensed
0:04:24 if one half plus one of the members of the full council authorize the action. So if five of you
0:04:30 choose we can pass the ordinance today but we would need to have a motion that
0:04:38 would be something like I move that we dispense with the reading of the rules
0:04:42 and place ordinance 2023 0 0 8 on third and final read only and if that passes
0:04:51 then we can move approving if you have any questions I'd be happy to answer thank
0:04:56 Thank you. Any questions for William? Okay, so first I need a motion if you so choose
0:05:06 to dispense with the rules. Chris Reed. I move that we dispense with the reading rules in
0:05:16 place ordinance 2023-008 on third and final by title only. Thank you Craig Hawkins. Thank
0:05:26 Thank you.
0:05:27 Emotion by Chris Reed, seconded by Craig Hawkins, that we dispense with the reading of the rules
0:05:34 and put ordinance 23-008 on third and final reading by title only.
0:05:43 Amy Rolteau, please.
0:05:45 Chris Reed.
0:05:47 Yes.
0:05:48 Thank you, Boyd.
0:05:49 Yes.
0:05:50 Craig Hawkins.
0:05:51 Yes.
0:05:52 Alex Kaval.
0:05:53 Yes.
0:05:54 Spencer Cutler.
0:05:55 Yes.
0:05:56 Thank you. Motion passes six to zero. So I'll read the ordinance. Ordinance number 2023-008
0:06:04 and ordinance of the mayor and the city council of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho, vacating the
0:06:10 easement described below. Ready for a motion? Is that a mayor? Go for it.
0:06:18 Madam mayor, I move that we adopt ordinance number 2023-008. Thank you. Do I have a second?
0:06:26 Thank you. Motion by Alex
0:06:30 Kaval second by Craig Hawkins to adopt ordinance 2023-008
0:06:36 for the vacation of the drainage slash stormy tension
0:06:40 easement on property located at 2092 Dawson drive.
0:06:44 Amy Rolkow please.
0:06:46 Nicky Boyd. Yes. Craig Hawkins. Yes. Alex Kaval. Yes.
0:06:52 Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes
0:07:28 during the budget presentations. At that time I mentioned that we were having some pretty good
0:07:35 success with the odor control study and I offered to come and speak to Jason.
0:07:43 Yeah, hang on a sec. Is that Zion? Okay, welcome Jason. Hello. Okay, go ahead. Nathan is just starting.
0:07:51 Okay. All right. So during the budget presentations, I mentioned that we had some results that we could
0:08:00 share with Council and I was told that you would be interested in receiving those results. And so
0:08:04 several months ago, we set this up to come represent our findings to this point. So I'm excited to show
0:08:12 you not just tell you that we've sought some positive improvements but to show you the data. We had
0:08:20 thought we might have something to present or to, I guess, request at this time, but we're
0:08:24 not to that point yet, so we still have some zoning, possibly, and funding to work out before
0:08:31 we get to that.
0:08:32 So today, we'll just present what we have as far as the data that we've collected.
0:08:37 I do want to recognize Mark Cummings from consort engineering is here.
0:08:42 He is the brains behind me as far as he knows these older studies and has a lot of experience
0:08:49 working on them. So I appreciate his help in putting this together. So as you may
0:08:59 remember, last time was here in presenting the Elder Study earlier this year. From
0:09:06 the 2022 results we came up with kind of the five next steps and these were
0:09:10 kind of an order of importance and so we'll go through the first three is really
0:09:15 what we'll focus on today and kind of show you what we're seeing. So
0:09:19 So Point Source Management is the first one.
0:09:22 And our Point Source Management is where we have seen that we really needed to focus on.
0:09:27 We realized kind of late last fall as we started to measure at the Point Sources that
0:09:32 we were able to identify hydrogen sulfide coming directly from those Point Sources and
0:09:37 things that they could do that would help resolve some of their discharges.
0:09:40 So we have continued to have monthly meetings with our Point Sources.
0:09:46 The city collects H2S data using over loggers in the sewer trunk line and also at the discharges
0:09:54 from those point sources.
0:09:59 And then as we meet monthly, it gives us an opportunity to review the data and discuss
0:10:04 what's happening and opportunities to improve ways to address those hydrogen sulfide discharges.
0:10:11 So I remind you that our Grand View trunk line is what we're focused on.
0:10:16 This kind of shows you distribution of how on the right side is the up gradient, so kind
0:10:23 of the start of the trunk line that moves down.
0:10:26 There's homes at first and then there's some point sources that contribute and then it
0:10:31 goes under Rock Creek, Long Rock Creek, a couple more point sources contribute and then it's
0:10:37 toward the end, all the way to the left, you'll see that there's a lot more homes in the neighborhood
0:10:43 there that the trunk lane goes by.
0:10:48 So one thing that's, I think, important to recognize is the point sources, they vary.
0:10:54 In the amount of wastewater they contribute to our system.
0:10:58 So this slide shows that we have four point sources that we've kind of focused in on that
0:11:04 we're able to see some good results with.
0:11:07 And you'll see that their amount of wastewater discharge
0:11:10 to the system varies.
0:11:13 The blue is very minimal.
0:11:16 It's like 10 to 20,000 gallons per day.
0:11:21 And then you get your green, which is just over half
0:11:24 a million gallons per day.
0:11:25 And then the gray and brown are close to 2 million gallons
0:11:32 day at their peak. So that kind of shows you the different contributions and now
0:11:39 we'll just go through the H2S data. So all the rest of these charts show the H2S
0:11:44 data that we've collected from the manholes. This one what we want to show is
0:11:50 that this was part of our H2S study last year so we have all the way from
0:11:55 from about the end of April of 2022 to current, and so on the left side you're seeing last
0:12:03 summer. So last summer we had a lot of H2S activity, a lot going on. We were trying to
0:12:10 do a trial with one of the point sources and it just wasn't, we weren't getting the results.
0:12:18 And then this year we had a point source, we'd identified that, you know, there was some
0:12:24 chemical that was being used that had some sulfide in it and by them changing
0:12:31 the chemical you see in here that early January when they changed chemical there
0:12:36 was a spike when they changed and then you know the H2S levels were down and there
0:12:42 was the power outage there was a power pole that was hit by the winner so the
0:12:48 power pole being hit power went out and then also they were discharged to the
0:12:52 system from just the loss of power.
0:12:55 And so we saw a spike there.
0:12:56 But since then, the results compared
0:12:59 last year are significantly better
0:13:02 than what we experienced last year.
0:13:04 And same with complaints or reports of odor were down,
0:13:09 and their severity was less this year.
0:13:13 So this is Zoom's in to October of 2022,
0:13:19 is when this starts, this is actually
0:13:20 when we started measuring at the point sources.
0:13:23 So what I want to show here is that measuring H2S
0:13:28 in the vapor phase is very useful,
0:13:30 but sometimes there's airflow dynamics
0:13:32 in the ability of within the sewer.
0:13:36 So here you'll see that that chemical change
0:13:39 that I showed in the last slide,
0:13:41 and then the power outage.
0:13:42 But then if we go just 650 feet down the trunk line
0:13:47 from that point source,
0:13:49 you'll see that the H2S levels have come up.
0:13:51 We still see the spike of the chemical change
0:13:54 and the power outage.
0:13:57 But it's higher because what we believe is happening
0:14:01 is at this last location,
0:14:04 as the sewers, you know, at the discharge point,
0:14:07 it's sucking air in at that manhole.
0:14:09 And so you're getting some fresh,
0:14:10 clean air coming in with,
0:14:12 so it's kind of diluting the H2S concentration there.
0:14:15 Whereas you get into the sewer itself
0:14:17 And this is kind of a more kind of representative H2S concentration of what we're seeing in this year.
0:14:24 And we do see, and this is where with some of these point sources, when we can identify power outages or spills,
0:14:31 which are biological upsets to the system.
0:14:34 So they have something discharge that's not normal, or they have to report to the city,
0:14:41 we can correlate those to some of these spikes.
0:14:44 So, the other thing I wanted to show are, along the bottom, when you see the red lines,
0:14:51 those are gaps in data.
0:14:52 So we have to pull those otolary loggers out occasionally, and they have to breathe for
0:14:57 a little bit.
0:14:58 So they get, and then also we don't have enough necessarily to cover everywhere all the time.
0:15:03 So the reds, this means there's no data there along the bottom.
0:15:09 This is another point source.
0:15:10 This one's unique in that there's not a chemical change that occurred here.
0:15:16 Last October, when we started to measure this one, this is actually the point source that
0:15:20 on that discharge, the amount of discharge, it was a very low one, so it was that blue
0:15:25 line across the bottom, so very minimal discharge from this point source.
0:15:30 In October of last year, compared to what we were seeing at other locations, it was pretty
0:15:36 low, and so it kind of fell off of our radar.
0:15:39 And honestly, we had been looking at other places and it wasn't until August, late August
0:15:47 of this year.
0:15:48 So just recently when our staff that collects our samples from the discharge that's for testing,
0:15:55 they noticed that there was an odor, an H2S odor.
0:15:58 And so they reported it to me and we decided we need to go out and start logging again.
0:16:04 Well, what they had realized is that they had left the logger in there.
0:16:08 So this would be, I guess, what you could call a happy accident, in that we had a logger in
0:16:14 there all summer and it recorded all the data.
0:16:17 So what we're seeing here is the blue is the H2S and the green is the temperature.
0:16:23 And you see a very strong correlation between the H2S and temperature.
0:16:27 What's happening is the bacteria in the system is eating the sulfate and creating hydrogen
0:16:35 sulfide.
0:16:36 And so that's why we're seeing the temperature, as temperature increases, there's more activity
0:16:41 with the bacteria and it produces more H2S.
0:16:45 So working with this point source, they've identified ways that can start cleaning their
0:16:49 system and try and reduce the amount of bacteria in the system.
0:16:53 Just barely, we didn't realize this till the end of August, and so starting that process
0:16:57 we're able to work with that point source to try and reduce their H2S contribution to the
0:17:04 system. This is another point source that, in this instance, they have a
0:17:14 pretreatment system and in October of 2022, they had some mechanical failures
0:17:20 and some issues that created a pretty high and steady spike there. Once they
0:17:27 were able to get it back online, they realized what needed to happen and in
0:17:32 In April, they were able to get parts to replace it.
0:17:35 And you can see a pretty significant change.
0:17:38 And from last year to this year, the H2S that's
0:17:43 coming out of that point source is nearly zero most of the time.
0:17:51 This is in the trunk lines for this along Rock Creek.
0:17:55 This is after all the point sources have kind of collected
0:17:57 together, just showing that we can still pinpoint some of those
0:18:03 spikes as it goes down the line.
0:18:09 And then this goes all the way to the end.
0:18:12 So this is down at Canyon Rim.
0:18:13 This is before it goes off the Canyon Rim
0:18:15 towards the treatment plant.
0:18:19 And again, those spikes kind of follow through the system.
0:18:24 And these are significantly lower than what
0:18:27 obviously on the left side, that was summer of 2022.
0:18:31 see the summer of 23 is a lot less than what we were seeing. So, reduction, you know, changing
0:18:40 chemical improvement of pre-treatment plant equipment has helped significantly in addressing
0:18:50 these issues. Now, this one is zooming in, so if you look at this slide on the right side
0:18:59 around August 13th, so that spike that goes to about 300.
0:19:04 We zoom in on the next slide,
0:19:07 and you can see where the Otter scrubber was turned on
0:19:10 at Canyon Rim.
0:19:11 So these are the two instances where we turn the Otter scrubber
0:19:14 on at Canyon Rim.
0:19:15 And what we saw when the Otter scrubber was at either Canyon
0:19:21 Rim or we had it at Public Works.
0:19:23 So those were the two locations we bounced it back and forth.
0:19:27 Wherever it was, our odor reports went down,
0:19:32 nearly to nothing.
0:19:33 It can be in rim.
0:19:34 The only complaint we would usually get was further,
0:19:37 I think, probably too far for it to make a difference.
0:19:39 It wasn't on the other side of the neighborhood.
0:19:42 So the odor complaints, there was a very strong correlation
0:19:47 to odor complaints, and if the odor scrubber wasn't there.
0:19:53 And so we were able to show that it works,
0:19:59 and pulling that era of the system
0:20:01 is one of the best ways that we have come or concluded
0:20:08 to try and address the order complaints that we have in the city.
0:20:15 So this brings us to the next point of a local limit.
0:20:20 So I presented last April.
0:20:23 The next month after that in May, the city
0:20:25 actually received a violation from the Department of Environmental Quality about our hydrogen
0:20:32 sulfide limits or hydrogen sulfide concentrations in our system.
0:20:36 And that was due to some concerns of human health and safety, which is a top priority
0:20:43 and we definitely want to make sure that we do not let anybody get sick from anything coming
0:20:49 out of the sewer.
0:20:50 And so we've been working with DEQ as far as letting them know what we're doing.
0:20:54 They requested that we put in a limit on hydrogen sulfide.
0:20:59 The problem that we had at that time
0:21:02 with jumping right to that is that,
0:21:05 as I showed you in some of those earlier slides,
0:21:08 the airflow dynamics in the sewer are very variable.
0:21:12 They change, and if a man holds a sucking air
0:21:16 or if it's blowing air, the concentration of H2S
0:21:19 can vary significantly.
0:21:21 And so to start to regulate a point source
0:21:24 based on that, can be very problematic.
0:21:27 And honestly, it's a struggle to make sure
0:21:31 that you're being fair to how you're measuring
0:21:33 each point source.
0:21:36 So we've explored other options.
0:21:39 The first option was a hydrogen sulfide analyzer.
0:21:43 This is a technology that's very well used
0:21:48 and through the oil and gas industry, but it's very costly.
0:21:54 So it's about $78,000 per location,
0:21:58 and that's just for the equipment.
0:22:00 So installation and then just maintenance of it
0:22:03 is a pretty significant cost.
0:22:05 But fortunately, there has been new technologies
0:22:10 come out through HOC.
0:22:12 So HOC, just about two months ago,
0:22:14 came out with a sensor that will measure H2S in the gas phase,
0:22:19 but also in the liquid phase, which is in real time.
0:22:23 So this is pretty, you know, it's very beneficial
0:22:28 for the city, but it's pretty cutting edge as far
0:22:29 as being able to have this something available
0:22:31 and at a price that is, you know, $10,000 per site.
0:22:36 So we had money last year, we actually purchased five
0:22:39 of these, and so these should be here
0:22:42 first part of November.
0:22:44 Now, with this data, what we expect to get with this
0:22:48 is we'll actually be able to measure what the H2S
0:22:50 concentrations are in the solution at each point source, which will then allow us to understand
0:22:56 down the line as it's coming out of the solution. Those spikes as they continue to come out,
0:23:01 will be able to tell where exactly is it coming from and be able to work with our point sources
0:23:05 to help them identify what can be done to reduce those amounts. This is a much more, I guess,
0:23:14 responsible way to measure and work with our point sources and identify what needs to be done
0:23:20 to reduce H2S in the system.
0:23:22 So we're excited to get these.
0:23:24 There's definitely some hurdles in getting them installed
0:23:26 and getting them to work, but this is a much better fit
0:23:31 for what we want to get done with the industry
0:23:34 or the point sources to continue to address them.
0:23:42 This is what it looks like, so it just sticks down
0:23:45 in the system or into the sewer,
0:23:48 and we'll measure the hydrosulfide numbers.
0:23:53 So with the vapor phase treatment,
0:23:57 as you're probably seeing,
0:23:58 this is a picture of our mobile air scrubber.
0:24:01 This is what we've been using.
0:24:03 And it's very basic technology,
0:24:06 just carbon pellets and a blower
0:24:08 that sucks the air through it,
0:24:09 sucks it out of the sewer and through
0:24:11 and the car or the H2S attaches to the carbon.
0:24:15 There's not a smell around it.
0:24:19 And we now, so we have had quite a few complaints.
0:24:30 And, you know, I want to share some of those with you so you can kind of understand that, you know, this is real.
0:24:37 These are the reports that I get quite often.
0:24:41 And with the odor scrubber, the reports have been very positive as far as, you know, they really do recognize the difference.
0:24:51 Again, just recognizing that having the machine just down the street, they recognize when it was gone, that it did make a difference,
0:25:01 and the citizens are looking for a long-term solution.
0:25:05 This was, I have a lot.
0:25:11 So those others were comments as far as recognizing the need for the otter scrubber.
0:25:19 And then also when the otter scrubber wasn't there, we get comments like this, that there's people that do get sick, sore throat, nausea, cough.
0:25:31 It also makes it so that people are not able to be out in their yards or have guests over.
0:25:39 And then also, you know, this one, my grandson, who was four, asked me what stinks yesterday.
0:25:48 You know, these are things that come in that, you know, I hope, I hope the community recognizes
0:25:56 that we really do want to alleviate this and make it so that they do not have to live in
0:26:00 these conditions.
0:26:04 And then there's that one, and this, okay.
0:26:08 And then, so getting back to the grand view trunk line, one question you might have is
0:26:20 that we've talked about point sources and dressing at the point source.
0:26:23 And what we are expecting, you know, are hoping to propose in the coming months is a permanent
0:26:32 solution to use the technology of the odors scrubber to put something in place that could
0:26:39 be a permanent way of sucking those odors out of the trunk line.
0:26:44 Now, the reason that we can't just address it at the point source is because our system
0:26:53 does not run just like a typical gravity sewer line.
0:26:57 So, you know, in a typical gravity sewer line, you would have your sewer flow running across
0:27:02 the bottom and the air would be running along the top with it.
0:27:08 In this diagram it shows that, you see typically the top one is what we would expect, but because
0:27:15 of it going off of the canyon rim we hit it at end, and so the air stops, and so even
0:27:24 addressing it at the point sources we expect that there's still going to be nowhere for
0:27:28 that air to go. We're looking at other options to try and, you know, more significant changes
0:27:35 to the system, but today the best judgment that we have is that an older scrubber permanently
0:27:44 installed in the area would provide an alleviate the H2S getting out into the neighborhood. And
0:27:54 I do want to say that we have, you know,
0:27:59 what I've presented today is what we have seen
0:28:02 as far as the results.
0:28:04 And we've concluded that a permanent scrubber
0:28:09 would be the best solution.
0:28:12 Now, please understand that that's not the only thing
0:28:14 we've looked at.
0:28:16 Mark, I do appreciate him.
0:28:18 He does work really well with me as far as I get contacted
0:28:24 quite often by a lot of companies that hear in the news about our odor problems, and they
0:28:29 have a solution, they have a magic cure.
0:28:34 And we have listened to quite a few of these, we've looked at chemical treatment, we've looked
0:28:38 at oxygenating the sewer and quite a different angles.
0:28:45 And he helps me kind of go through the process of listening to him and determining that, you
0:28:53 you know, and that they're not going to work for our situation, but I do appreciate his
0:29:00 help and his expertise in kind of going through this process. So, if there's any questions.
0:29:05 Any questions for Nathan? Chris Reed. The air scrubber. You remind me how much the
0:29:13 temporary one we have cost. So, we had expected it was going to cost, I think, around $75,000.
0:29:20 It actually came out under. It was only 55,000.
0:29:23 Okay.
0:29:24 And so you believe a permanent one is the one we currently have with that?
0:29:28 Oh, something a little larger.
0:29:32 Okay.
0:29:33 But yeah, in a permanent location.
0:29:37 We need it in multiple locations because it looks like you have two that you've kind of moved it back and forth.
0:29:42 But we need, would we ultimately need two of them?
0:29:45 It's possible.
0:29:46 So, and it depends on the location.
0:29:49 So, the north side, we have a lot more reports over there just because if you remember that
0:29:56 schematic, that's where a lot of the homes are.
0:29:58 So it's a community, you have a lot more people living there.
0:30:02 So the need there is, and the trunk line is larger and it's kind of, you know, it's the
0:30:07 end of the line.
0:30:08 So it's a little more significant in its impact.
0:30:13 And when would you, what's the time on determining what you need and being able to put that in?
0:30:20 So we just barely last week got the first kind of design in some of the preliminary information.
0:30:28 So we're hoping that the next couple months we can kind of work through some of the details,
0:30:34 get it if it has to go through zoning, we can do that and figure out the funding,
0:30:38 and then be back to council in a few months if possible.
0:30:42 It would be great to have this in place next summer at least started so that we don't have to go through another summer.
0:30:48 And that was my comment is it looks like summer and people are outside but also with rising temperatures that's when the smell really starts to peak.
0:30:56 Making sure that it's in place before next summer would be correctly important. Thank you.
0:31:02 Any other questions for Nathan?
0:31:07 The hawk the hawk sensors are they they're not going to help you determine where to place the air scrubbers
0:31:13 Are they they're just monitoring points?
0:31:16 Levels correct correct. Yeah, that's that's the point source aspect of it
0:31:20 So do you know where for the air scrubber? Do you?
0:31:26 Have you identified where they need to go in the system? So towards the end? I mean towards the end of the line is ideal
0:31:36 and
0:31:38 I mean, initially along Canyon Rim,
0:31:40 Love Road, before it goes off the Canyon Rim,
0:31:43 City Hills and Property there,
0:31:44 which would be an ideal location.
0:31:47 But again, we do need to work through some of the specifics on that.
0:31:50 Thanks. Anybody else? Okay. Thank you, Nathan.
0:31:55 Thank you. So that's it for items of consideration,
0:32:00 Amy, for some reason. I've lost my ability to
0:32:03 with the detail, who's speaking or wants to speak.
0:32:10 So, the next time for general public input, this is the time that anybody from the audience
0:32:17 who wishes to address City Council can come down and speak.
0:32:23 If you do wish to address City Council, please come down and approach the microphone state
0:32:28 your name and whether you're a resident or property owner of the City of Twin Falls and
0:32:33 then go ahead and speak.
0:32:36 will have two minutes I will remind you that public input will not be about any
0:32:42 items on this agenda personnel or personnel related issues so is there
0:32:48 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:32:52 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:33:16 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:33:27 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:33:39 that depends on which way the wind is blowing, but I definitely think that to
0:33:47 him to make the improvement to take care of the problem is welcome that I think
0:33:57 also that I would like to see a little bit more of study. I like a little bit
0:34:04 more input maybe from those that walk the trail.
0:34:08 I think that would be something that would be important to, for the public comes about.
0:34:16 So other than that, we've enjoyed living there, but it definitely is a problem that needs
0:34:27 to be fixed.
0:34:28 Thank you.
0:34:29 So I need to remind everybody, and I'll make an exception tonight, that typically public
0:34:35 input is not for any items on the agenda, but specifically if you can keep your comments
0:34:44 down to a couple minutes, I would take comments on this particular item.
0:34:49 I don't usually do that.
0:34:51 So if there's anybody else in the audience that wishes to speak, it looks like, oh, you're
0:34:59 leaving and come on down for any.
0:35:09 My name is Fran Florence.
0:35:10 I have a 198th Avenue East in Twin Falls, and thank you for opening it up for comments
0:35:15 on the subject, on the smell.
0:35:19 It looks like they're making great progress.
0:35:21 In fact, I've noticed it myself in when I go down to Rock Creek and I do that quite
0:35:27 often on the trail down there.
0:35:31 And just, I think it's justified that the concentrated efforts really are where most
0:35:39 the people live because they don't have a choice. That's where they live and it smells. But I would
0:35:44 like to encourage the City Council that the trail system on the canyon, but also in Rock Creek,
0:35:53 is a great amenity. And you won't get so many people complaining because they just don't go down
0:35:59 there when it smells. And they have an option not to do that. But I think looking forward, making
0:36:09 that an amenity that's more enjoyable is really beneficial to the community and so
0:36:12 please don't focus only on on those who are you know living with it but consider
0:36:20 those that may come in the future that would want to use the amenity and that's
0:36:25 my comment. Thank you for any anybody else in the audience that wishes to address
0:36:31 City Council on this subject or any other subject. Okay, seeing no one I've met you
0:36:39 at the beginning of our meeting ask you, we have a officer from the city of post files
0:36:49 that was killed or died in the line of Duney yesterday, a 39 year old officer by the name
0:36:56 of Nicholas McDaniel and if we could take a moment and just have a moment of silence please.
0:37:03 Thank you.
0:37:14 Okay.
0:37:15 Thank you very much.
0:37:16 is Council Advisory Board reports.
0:37:20 Anybody have anything?
0:37:28 There is a new, the library has outside story time,
0:37:34 and I believe they do have a new story,
0:37:38 or a new thing out there that's open, open last week.
0:37:44 Well, there's something else to do
0:37:46 if you're at City Parking Walk,
0:37:47 West Street and do that too.
0:37:50 Perfect.
0:37:51 Anybody else, Chris Reed?
0:37:52 I just wanted to thank all those that were involved
0:37:55 with Fire Station 2 and the open house
0:37:58 that we had last Tuesday, I believe it was.
0:38:02 Absolutely beautiful, really excited for that.
0:38:06 Being able to tour that building, that facility
0:38:10 makes me excited for Fire Station 3.
0:38:12 That will be coming on board in the next couple of months.
0:38:14 So I thought it was fantastic.
0:38:16 Thank you to all those.
0:38:17 I know that was a big lift to make that open house happen.
0:38:20 and thanks for everybody out there who showed up.
0:38:23 Yes.
0:38:23 It's great.
0:38:24 Anybody else?
0:38:26 Sitting down to your office.
0:38:29 Okay, so we have no public hearings tonight.
0:38:32 So the last item on the agenda is executive session
0:38:36 under an action item under code section 74-2061C
0:38:43 to acquire an interest in real property
0:38:45 not owned by a public agency.
0:38:48 So moved.
0:38:49 Okay.
0:38:50 Thank you motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Alex Koval, to approve them moving into
0:38:56 executive session under 74-2061C.
0:39:01 Amy Roll, call vote please.
0:39:03 Yes.
0:39:05 Chris Reed.
0:39:06 Yes.
0:39:07 Thank you, boy.
0:39:08 Yes.
0:39:09 Greg Hawkins.
0:39:10 Yes.
0:39:11 Jason Brown.
0:39:12 Yes.
0:39:13 Spencer Kettler.
0:39:15 Yes.
0:39:16 Thank you.
0:39:17 Motion passes 70-0.
0:39:18 motion passes 7-0. I want to remind everybody that we will not be making
0:39:23 decisions in executive session and we will not return. So our meeting is adjourned.
0:39:28 Thank you for attending.
Download
- Transcript (text) 33 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 43 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 58 KB
- Audio (M4A) 9.2 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, October 23, 2023. The recording started at 16:58 by the recorder's clock and runs 00:39:31.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
ed5fcbfb32a2a967640212d188c40aa4a559c6329084a2029a0b784805c8c97c - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min, with 1 passage muted for privacy. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 8ac45b95fe01f32f57bd084269d7ba7fb35dddb7a52a459e64d61d064b607943 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 4 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
a484b0a1229fd88d1e8bfebcd2c854b991f3b6bfc546d00dc264602718dbe3db
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file