City Council meeting
Monday, December 11, 2023
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on fileMinutes on file
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:00:46 You guys ready? Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the December 11th,
0:01:02 2023 City Council meeting. I want to confirm we have a quorum. We have six members present
0:01:08 in chambers and Councilwoman Kaval is excused. First item on the agenda is the Pledge of
0:01:15 Allegiance. If you wish to join me, please rise. Thank you. We have no proclamations
0:01:38 tonight so next is the consent calendar council wishes move to approve the consent
0:01:45 calendar thank you motion by Christopher Reed seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve
0:01:51 the consent calendar as written Amy Rokavo please yes yes yes yes thank you
0:02:05 motion passes six to zero. Next, under items of consideration, we're going to flip the agenda
0:02:12 a little bit because our presenter needs to make another trip to another meeting. So we'll
0:02:20 be moving item D up to item the first item and then we will just follow the items in order.
0:02:29 So first item on the agenda is an action item, a request to approve the Twin Falls County
0:02:35 Emergency Operations Plan 2023.
0:02:39 And I show we have both Travis and Jackie,
0:02:41 but I bet it's Jackie.
0:02:44 Jackie Fry from the Twin Falls County Office
0:02:46 of Emergency Management, welcome Jackie.
0:02:51 You need to turn on your mic.
0:03:00 Council and Mayor, I wanna thank you so much
0:03:02 for your time tonight.
0:03:04 I am the Emergency Manager for Twin Falls County
0:03:06 and I come in front of you asking for your support
0:03:09 for the update of the County Emergency Operations Plan.
0:03:14 It is dated 2023, but it was, we're saying on the tail end of the year.
0:03:20 So we do this every five years and the plan has been sent out for your review.
0:03:28 It's technically the first responders in the support agencies, city and county departments
0:03:35 who all work together during this or disaster sharing resources. The plan is updated.
0:03:41 This time to really address the role of those departments and also their policies and procedures
0:03:49 in place.
0:03:50 The county does not ask, nor do I ask that there be any changes with your protocol.
0:03:57 The departments already work together very well with mutual aid and are able to support
0:04:01 incidents or any kind of disasters we have in the county.
0:04:05 This is just an overview manual that can be updated or revised as needed, but it is a
0:04:10 document required through the state and federal, technically for one reason.
0:04:16 So if your city applies for any funding for your city, same as the All Hazard Mitigation
0:04:21 Plan that I do, you can check the box and it shows that you're compliant and you are a
0:04:26 party to or signature to the plan.
0:04:30 So that is why I'm here today.
0:04:34 Thank you.
0:04:35 Any questions for Jackie?
0:04:36 It's a very lengthy document.
0:04:39 Actually, Mary, it's been shortened by quite a bit.
0:04:42 Yeah, still very lengthy.
0:04:44 I'm sorry.
0:04:45 I started to read it, and then I thought,
0:04:48 I'm sure our lawyers have looked at this.
0:04:51 OK, Chris, read.
0:04:53 With 208 pages, I think.
0:04:55 Yes, sir.
0:04:56 Yes.
0:04:56 Just a quick question.
0:04:58 If you can, again, because it is 208 pages,
0:05:00 for those that are listening, what
0:05:02 are some of the significant changes
0:05:04 that you would say from five years ago to this one?
0:05:08 So for all, I'm sorry, my back's to you.
0:05:12 Some of the significant changes it actually really addresses
0:05:16 the role of each of the city and points out
0:05:19 that we do have cyber terrorism.
0:05:21 That is a new annex.
0:05:22 Also, of course, we included the pandemic
0:05:25 or any kind of a plague.
0:05:26 We work with the Health Department
0:05:28 and the local emergency planning committee members
0:05:31 who review and help support this plan.
0:05:33 The other part of the plan is that it's really,
0:05:36 the maps have been taken out,
0:05:38 And it really has driven more to be a document that is really a support resource while the
0:05:47 city's already have policy procedures in place as I had stated.
0:05:51 The thing that makes this plan a little different is, believe it or not, it was shortened by about
0:05:55 200 pages.
0:05:57 And it really addresses, I think my goal was really to not simplify, but really focus on
0:06:07 the local resources, the resources needed during an event, how quickly we would
0:06:12 deplete those resources and need a declaration for the support and then
0:06:16 federal support with our governor and then looking at federal funds. So the
0:06:22 plan has just really been redesigned so it's very specific for the needs of our
0:06:27 medical services. It doesn't list just St. Luke's, it doesn't list just North
0:06:31 It encompasses all medical services, those civic groups.
0:06:36 It also encompasses those volunteer agencies.
0:06:39 So the language is just simpler, but it's done in such a way that there is an over-arching
0:06:46 understanding of really what the role and responsibility is.
0:06:49 I hope I answered that.
0:06:53 No, absolutely. Thank you.
0:06:55 Thank you.
0:06:56 So I'm ready for motion.
0:06:57 I'll make the motion.
0:06:58 Go ahead.
0:06:59 I move that we approve the Twin Falls County Emergency Operation Plan 2023
0:07:06 as presented and authorize the mayor to sign. Yes. Do we have a second? I'll second. Okay.
0:07:14 Okay. Motion by Chris Rie seconded by Nikki Boyd. I was going to say Nikki Brown. That
0:07:20 doesn't work. Request to approve request to approve the Twin Falls County Emergency Operations Plan
0:07:29 2023 and authorize the mayor to sign. Any further discussion? Amy Roquevo, please.
0:07:39 Chris Reed. Yes.
0:07:40 Nikki Boyd. Yes.
0:07:41 Ray Coccans. Yes.
0:07:42 Jason Brown. Yes.
0:07:43 Spencer Kettler. Yes.
0:07:45 And Ruth Pierce.
0:07:46 Yes. Thank you. Motion passes six to zero. Thank you, Jackie.
0:07:51 Thank you very much. Mary Christmas to each of you.
0:07:53 Thank you. Drive safe.
0:07:54 Thank you. I'm off to Hanson's.
0:07:56 Okay, next item, we'll go back to the regular order, next item on the agenda is an action
0:08:04 item.
0:08:05 It's a request to approve Dana Dahan to serve as a Library Trustee, and we have Tara Bartley,
0:08:11 Director of the Twin Falls Library.
0:08:14 Welcome, Tara.
0:08:15 Thank you.
0:08:17 Hair Pierce, Library Liaison, Councilwoman Boyd, and Council, thank you.
0:08:22 It's a pleasure to stand in front of you today.
0:08:25 I come to you to ask for a reappointment of our Library of Trustee Dana DeHahn. Dana came to the
0:08:32 Library of Trustee. She served a vacancy that came open in October of 2020, so she had three years
0:08:43 left of that term to serve. During that time, Dana has been very instrumental in helping us
0:08:50 create policies, navigate through some library happenings, and she's been a true leader. In fact,
0:08:57 the last two years, she has served as our library board chair. She came to me early this year and
0:09:04 she said, you know, I would like to continue on if possible, and I would like to serve another term
0:09:12 if I could. And so I come to you today on behalf of our library board of trustees, as well as
0:09:19 talking with city manager Travis that we ask to be have Dana DeHaan be
0:09:26 reappointed. Thank you. Any questions for Sarah? Nicky Boyd. Mayor I would like to
0:09:35 first I'd like to say it's been a pleasure to serve with you Dana. You lead a good
0:09:40 meeting and a lot of good I'm gonna miss that group. It's a really good group.
0:09:45 Mayor, I move that we approve Dana DeHaan to serve as a Library Trustee.
0:09:50 Thank you.
0:09:51 Do I have a second?
0:09:54 Okay.
0:09:55 Motion by Nicky Boyd, seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve Dana DeHaan to serve as a Library
0:10:01 Trustee for another term.
0:10:04 Thank you.
0:10:05 Amy Rolconvo, please.
0:10:06 Nicky Boyd?
0:10:07 Yes.
0:10:08 Craig Hawkins?
0:10:09 Yes.
0:10:10 Jason Brown?
0:10:11 Yes.
0:10:12 Spencer Cutler?
0:10:13 Yes.
0:10:14 Ruth Pierce?
0:10:15 Yes.
0:10:16 to zero. Thank you. Thank you, Dana. Do you want to say anything? No, okay. You're welcome to.
0:10:24 Okay, next item on the agenda is an action item. It's a request to use 150,000 of cash reserves
0:10:32 for the Frontier Park Restroom Reconstruction Rotary Club Project Partnership Project,
0:10:38 and we have Deputy City Manager Mitch Humboldt. Welcome Mitch.
0:10:42 Thank you. I'm going to go back into history a little bit if you remember in
0:10:47 around fiscal year 2020 the Twin Falls Rotary Club came and asked the council if
0:10:54 well actually they shared that they would like to fundraise and get
0:10:59 together a project to rebuild the restroom at Frontier Park. For those of
0:11:03 you who might not have seen it recently I included some photos in your little
0:11:06 packet so it needs replacing and so we were happy for them to come and take
0:11:11 on that project, we asked the council if we could provide a little help at the time.
0:11:16 We approved that and then in the subsequent budget, we actually budgeted $150,000 to kind
0:11:22 of help with the project.
0:11:24 When I say help with the project, we had some things that we wanted to do like replace the
0:11:30 hour junction box there, do some more paving around the restaurant, the sidewalks leading
0:11:36 up to it, put some pads in there for like food trucks and those kinds of things.
0:11:44 Their fundraising efforts lasted a bit longer than they had anticipated.
0:11:48 Our fiscal year came and went, we let that money go into reserves and they came to us
0:11:53 about a month and a half ago and said, you know, we're about ready to submit those permits
0:11:58 and get going.
0:11:59 Which means that the part that we committed to do, we also need to commit and get going.
0:12:04 And so the request is to pull that money that we let go into reserves a few years ago, back
0:12:09 out and so we can start doing this project with the Twin Falls Rotary Club.
0:12:14 And so it's really it.
0:12:16 If you have any questions, I'd be happy to answer them for you.
0:12:20 Jason Brown.
0:12:21 Are you going to use any of the existing facility or is it going to be demolished and reconstructed
0:12:27 at that point?
0:12:28 Just looking at the images, it looked like it was probably going to be a complete reconstruct.
0:12:34 So the lava rock that's around it, they're going to preserve it and reapply it.
0:12:39 Okay.
0:12:40 And then there's a section in the back of that building that's like the park's crew has like,
0:12:46 that's a really old hydraulic based sprinkler system.
0:12:51 Okay.
0:12:52 So there's a wall internally where all of that stuff is happening.
0:12:55 We're going to put that back in place too, but otherwise it's entirely new.
0:13:00 The rocks will just be reused.
0:13:03 that design that is also in your packet was was their design and you know right so
0:13:09 yeah I'll make a motion if there's no other question Chris read you have a question
0:13:14 what's time frame on this so honestly I thought they would have already applied
0:13:20 for the building permit they got to apply for the building permit from the state
0:13:22 since it's CSI on property I think as soon as we answer some of these questions
0:13:29 Yes, we've got our money. I've reached out to the state to see if the way of our building
0:13:33 permit fee. I think they're waiting for that answer. They're just weeks away from applying
0:13:38 for the building permit. So my suspicion would be this coming construction season. So we will
0:13:44 be without, very likely without a restroom at Frontier Park or the coming, I guess would be
0:13:52 24, 24, 24, it'll likely open later in the year, but what we have, we'll have part of
0:13:58 parties and we'll have part of it. Okay. Any other questions? Go ahead, Jason.
0:14:03 A move to approve the request to use $150,000 of cash reserves for the reconstruction of the frontier park restrooms.
0:14:12 Thank you. Do I have a second? Second. Motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Chris Reed to approve the use of
0:14:21 150,000 of cash reserves for the Frontier Park restroom
0:14:25 Slash Rotary Club project
0:14:28 Amy roll call vote, please
0:14:32 Yes, Jason Brown. Yes, Spencer Cutler. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes
0:14:38 Yes, thank you motion passes six to zero
0:14:43 Next item on the agenda is an action item a request to approve a resolution of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls
0:14:51 Falls, Idaho proposing new airport credentialing slash ID badge fees and amending the city's
0:14:58 master fees schedule. We have airport manager Bill Carberry. Welcome, Bill.
0:15:04 Welcome, Mayor. Good evening, Council members. So tonight I've put together a brief presentation
0:15:12 at Matt Barnes, our operations supervisor, we'll lace in a few slides and talk about
0:15:17 those with me.
0:15:18 Tonight's meeting is a continuation of the public hearing two weeks ago on November 27th
0:15:25 where you heard from the public about their issues and concerns about the new program,
0:15:31 the Badging, Credentialing, the fees associated.
0:15:34 So it took a bit of time and built a PowerPoint here with Matt that hopefully answers some
0:15:40 of the concerns, maybe describe some of the issues a little bit better than that first
0:15:45 round back on the 27th.
0:15:47 So, this slide I think you've seen before, and it talks about the evolution of the aircraft,
0:15:59 which is critical to why things are happening the way they are now.
0:16:02 So, this probably actually goes back 40 years where the Embraer 120-30C turboprop SkyWest
0:16:10 rolled that out in the mid-80s sometime.
0:16:12 I think it was about 80-85.
0:16:14 In 2015, we graduated to the 50-seat Canada Regional Jet
0:16:21 at the airport, initially with two flights,
0:16:24 and then we settled into three for a period of time.
0:16:27 And then with our work with Delta to take over the route,
0:16:32 leading up to the summer, we saw the introduction of the ERJ175.
0:16:39 That was announced in June on Father's Day weekend,
0:16:42 weekend, right about the time of the air to show us when I think that was all announced.
0:16:49 So one of the main points here is that that's a big trigger right there, getting over 60
0:16:54 seats. So here's just a couple of very quick, high level thoughts about what these required
0:17:01 changes are, most significantly what they are. And that's for the airport to move from
0:17:05 what we have now as a supporting program to a complete airport security program, which
0:17:12 entails establishing a credentialing and ID access badge program.
0:17:17 There's two access authorizations that we'll get into a little bit more further on.
0:17:23 But basically one that's a smaller population that deals with the airline activity, the
0:17:27 airline reader flying service, airport personnel, required to get fingerprinting and more formal
0:17:34 criminal history checks and that provides them security identification, display area
0:17:41 access, and we'll point out where that is.
0:17:44 And then most of the BEDGE applicants will be general aviation airport operating area access.
0:17:52 So they don't do fingerprints, but they fill out security assessment forms.
0:17:57 We'll talk about those and their badge, and those would be the tenants and regular users,
0:18:02 and we'll talk about the regulations and the applicability to the populations.
0:18:08 The airport is required at this point to submit their revised new complete plan April 1st
0:18:14 and the GoLive date is May 24th.
0:18:22 I apologize for those behind me that can't see the nice arrows but on your screen and
0:18:27 the televisions you can and I've learned I shouldn't use a light blue color with our
0:18:32 projector.
0:18:33 But nevertheless, I'll try to just move along here and you should be able to see this pretty
0:18:38 properly on your screen.
0:18:39 So as I mentioned, June of 23, the E175 Delta service was announced.
0:18:46 So we started that initial discovery period with TSA, what would this mean?
0:18:50 On August, we were given guidance of what a template would look like, what the requirements
0:18:56 would look like, for what they called an interim security compliance plan to get us to September
0:19:02 5th, and to carry us to the point we get the complete program submitted.
0:19:08 So this also known as an AMOC or alternative means of compliance and that term will come
0:19:15 up again in our presentation.
0:19:17 Later in August, very late August, on the eve of Labor Day weekend, we received a word that
0:19:23 our plan would be approved and we would allow that flight to come in on September 5th, so
0:19:28 just in time.
0:19:31 September of 2023, the airport came to the City Council, discussed these evolving changes
0:19:38 and ask for one-time funding for capital expenses
0:19:42 to help roll out the new security plan requirements
0:19:45 to include hiring a consultant to help us write the plan,
0:19:50 also work with some technology needs,
0:19:52 and make us some recommendations
0:19:54 about implementation of new technology.
0:19:56 So we did that in September of 2023,
0:20:00 and we came for, asked for somewhere
0:20:02 in the neighborhood of $98,000
0:20:04 to get equipment technology,
0:20:06 build out the Banjing Office, all of those things, and there was some contingency built into that.
0:20:12 Moving to October of 2023, the airport with the help of our IT department,
0:20:21 who rode side saddle with us, we started to explore the application of software and technology to aid
0:20:29 in managing the credentialing and batching program. So we went through three demos from three different
0:20:35 providers and we came up with a number one preferred choice and that is a company called
0:20:41 Air Badge that is currently rolled out in Boise.
0:20:46 Couple of things played into our decision and our thoughts of moving into exploring the
0:20:52 contract with them is certainly the references from other airports, the advice we got from
0:20:59 or IT department, and their price point.
0:21:02 They really hit a point where they're fairly affordable
0:21:06 for the smaller airports.
0:21:07 A lot of the bigger airports, the large hubs
0:21:10 and such spend exorbitant amounts of money
0:21:13 and have thousands of badge holders.
0:21:16 So we really liked the product and started
0:21:19 to look to a contract with them.
0:21:27 So August, excuse me, November 7, the airport board
0:21:31 was briefed on the happenings staff discussed with the airport board that I would be moving
0:21:39 to the City Council with a request to consider fees that are public hearing.
0:21:44 On November 20th, airport mailed out information about a public hearing on the 27th to lease
0:21:50 holders.
0:21:51 I know there was some concern with about the type time frame and the advance notice and
0:21:56 And I apologize to them for that and perhaps we could have done things better so I do apologize
0:22:01 for that.
0:22:02 But we did have a good turnout and subsequently we've had, I'll discuss some of the more interactions
0:22:07 we've had in the interim since our last meeting.
0:22:11 And November 27th was that date that we had that public hearing and you heard those concerns.
0:22:21 So one of the things we did getting with Jim O'Donnell or Chairman and the airport board,
0:22:27 We held a meeting with really a singular topic on December 7th.
0:22:32 We set up in the baggage area, we had a lot of seats, we anticipated good involvement,
0:22:38 which we did.
0:22:39 We had probably two dozen tenants and users that came and we invited Roland West, the TSA
0:22:45 supervisor.
0:22:46 He was very generous with his time.
0:22:48 We had a 90-minute meeting in your packet.
0:22:51 I think there's some details and things of some of this outline.
0:22:56 So a handout was also provided to those in attendance, and these are the types of things
0:23:01 that were discussed.
0:23:05 His presentation in the public input to Q&A, I think it was extremely helpful in us hearing
0:23:11 things, providing information, what those concerns were, as well as getting those bits of information
0:23:17 out to people that had concerns about how this would affect them, some of the applicability
0:23:23 was discussed, and so on.
0:23:26 So he started off the meeting about what security sensitive information is, and he stuck to
0:23:31 what are the regulations.
0:23:33 There's certainly some things that will come out to a policy level that people that have
0:23:38 to interface with these programs will understand.
0:23:40 But during the discovery, the development of the program, there are certain limits about
0:23:45 what you can talk about with the development of your plan.
0:23:48 But his topics talked about everything from the evolution of the 175, the background, that
0:23:54 benchmark of the 60-seat rule, what a complete program was about and the R&D to do it, talked
0:24:02 about the code of federal regulations where people could find those online electronically.
0:24:07 They wanted to research that.
0:24:09 And most importantly, the most significant thing in a complete airport security program
0:24:13 is credentialing and access ID media that's involved with badging that you've heard about
0:24:19 the security threat assessments.
0:24:22 Those are much higher levels than the plan that we have now, and I'll talk a little bit
0:24:27 more about that, and that's a supporting program.
0:24:30 We talked about an AMOC and an alternate means of compliance.
0:24:35 He made it clear that the AMOC or the interim plan we're in now is very temporary until
0:24:41 we get to a complete program.
0:24:43 People talked about trying to just extend the date and just keep this interim plan in
0:24:48 effect.
0:24:49 was not a viable path in the TSA's eyes.
0:24:53 We heard things about maybe using cell phone technology
0:24:56 and things like that to actuate the gaze
0:24:59 in place of ID media.
0:25:02 And although he, you know, uploaded the innovative thinking,
0:25:05 he didn't think that those technologies would really represent us well now.
0:25:09 One of the things about the Access Media is that the airport essentially has to control that.
0:25:15 It's on the loan and issued to someone and has to be, there's a 100% audit every year
0:25:22 to see that you don't have a high loss rate, there's certainly some minor acceptability
0:25:27 of badges being lost.
0:25:29 So right now a cell phone doesn't, we don't have the capability to control that and identify
0:25:34 a person with the phone, those types of things.
0:25:36 So really the only viable way, as he explained, was to use these kinds of badges, which we'll
0:25:42 talk about more.
0:25:45 Identity identification systems explained.
0:25:48 So I talked about our supporting program
0:25:50 and how we, what we do now.
0:25:52 So we have an access control program now
0:25:55 and have had it for quite some time.
0:25:58 And we issue people apply, we evaluate who they are
0:26:02 and why they want to go on the airfield.
0:26:04 And we give them personal identification number codes, right?
0:26:07 So they're supposed to use them, not share them.
0:26:10 They put in their numbers to get open and then they get in.
0:26:14 Those types of programs are not going to cut it for a complete program, and that's why an access badge is going to be more appropriate.
0:26:27 One other thing about payments codes is that there's the right for abuse or people to share them with each other,
0:26:34 and there's no accountability for that type of access control where, as I show you some of the badges,
0:26:39 you'll see it's more tied to the individual that is authorized.
0:26:43 One of the things we started out is talking about those two areas, the AOA in the site that we illustrate here.
0:26:54 So the security identification display area is in red, and you see it's around the terminal.
0:27:02 And that's the parking area, the airplane.
0:27:05 But it also includes like the holding room, the checkpoint, the airline office.
0:27:10 There's a bag of makeup when your bags go down the belt to the back room.
0:27:14 are all areas that are sterile and high-security areas with access by those with
0:27:21 CITA access. The AOA are all areas inside the fence and that's an AOA badge and not
0:27:29 a CITA badge and those would be for the for all the tenants that either occupy
0:27:34 the work in the buildings on the airport inside the fence for the users, the
0:27:38 delivery drivers, everybody who needs reasonable access inside the fence and
0:27:43 pass those gates. And it was clearly discussed that those needing that access into the AOA
0:27:49 would need to apply for a badge and follow the badging protocols.
0:27:57 Here are some examples of what those badges might look like. We were anticipating probably
0:28:04 four to five hundred badges being issued. We have pin codes now that totally approximate
0:28:10 that number. You know, they have the picture expiration date last name. If they work for
0:28:15 company, their job, all of those basic ingredients on the IED badge.
0:28:22 And these really are just nothing, they're not pain codes, but really they act the same
0:28:26 way.
0:28:27 They're an electronic key.
0:28:28 He's swiping in front of it.
0:28:29 Many of you may have them in your businesses, or I know in this building itself it has them.
0:28:34 So they act the same way instead of a pain code, they have your picture on it.
0:28:38 There's something you wouldn't tend to lend out to others, and we would have to audit
0:28:44 these and it would be quite clear when we do that Joe Smith has Joe Smith's
0:28:49 badge when we audit and we have to do that quite frequently every year. I want to
0:29:00 talk a little bit about air badging, identity management systems and what was
0:29:04 behind our desire to utilize software. So it is a most cost-effective way. You know
0:29:17 I was asked is there some cheaper way we can do this and this when I start to
0:29:22 show you some of the airport costs related to ongoing costs. We don't even include staff
0:29:28 time, right? But I would argue that it is the most cost-effective approach. It's, as Matt
0:29:35 shows you in a few moments, it's interoperability with our access control systems, with our appointment
0:29:41 systems, with all these other things. It's going to help us ensure TSA compliance. It's
0:29:46 becoming a best practice, these identity management systems.
0:29:50 And in a time where we're seeing technology and automation take over many areas of our lives,
0:29:57 everything from how you do your banking, how you do your healthcare, you use apps, you order
0:30:03 hamburgers, you do all of these things through the use of technology to aid in your customer
0:30:08 and your service delivery.
0:30:10 So it's really becoming a strategic principle of our organization to start to look at new
0:30:17 solutions, to use technology.
0:30:20 At a time when human capital is scarce and valuable to utilize technology as something that we're
0:30:27 looking at very seriously, and I'm sure in the rooms that you're in with staff, you have
0:30:32 these conversations from times to time about strategic principles for the future.
0:30:37 So I would argue, it does all of these wonderful things.
0:30:42 We, like the price point, we think it's very cost effective in the long run.
0:30:47 And additionally, it helps ensure TSA compliance.
0:30:50 Now, Matt and I won't mention any names, but we know airports that have struggled from
0:30:55 complications not done well with their program, whether they have too much of a loss rate,
0:31:01 the audits aren't going well.
0:31:03 They find themselves in a status of probation with the TSA, those types of things.
0:31:09 If you don't have FAA compliance, TSA compliance, foundationally at the airport, nothing else
0:31:16 matters.
0:31:18 So we find it very, very attractive.
0:31:20 So at this point, I'd like to introduce Matt Barnes.
0:31:22 He just has a few handful of slides just to talk about this and I'll return.
0:31:27 Matt.
0:31:30 Thank you, Bill.
0:31:31 Hi, Matt.
0:31:32 Hi.
0:31:33 Good evening, Mayor and Council.
0:31:37 So why do we want to automate IDMS systems like AirBag will help us improve security because
0:31:44 it makes it possible to have instant triggers between any kind of processes with users, what's
0:31:54 going on with users.
0:31:55 Are they allowed access or are they not allowed access and are physical access control system?
0:32:01 So we can immediately turn on and off that access and make sure that we stay compliant
0:32:07 and the facility stays secure.
0:32:11 It'll also save a lot of time.
0:32:14 As we go through this process with our customers,
0:32:16 there's going to be a lot of data entry.
0:32:18 We're going to need to collect identifications, data,
0:32:25 such as name, place of birth,
0:32:29 all kinds of different, very personal information.
0:32:31 And if you don't do that very carefully
0:32:33 and very deliberately, you'll have security issues,
0:32:36 you could have errors. There's a lot of things that can go wrong. The IDMS, like AirBag, helps
0:32:42 ensure that that's quick, safe, accurate, and secure. It also will make it very difficult
0:32:52 to not follow a predetermined process that is compliant with TSA regulations. So we can
0:33:00 ensure that compliance by following what AirBag asks us to do at the appropriate time.
0:33:06 And finally, by speeding up all this data entry, the ensuring compliance, and making sure that
0:33:15 we have integration with our physical access control system, we help the customer have a
0:33:20 better experience.
0:33:22 Things are much more clear.
0:33:24 They're easier to follow, and there's less delay in communication between airport staff
0:33:35 and that customer that's seeking the badge.
0:33:41 So this describes really briefly,
0:33:44 this describes some of the processes
0:33:46 that we're gonna need to go through.
0:33:48 And the identity management system will help us do this
0:33:51 in a very deliberate and step-by-step process.
0:33:54 This is very important so that we don't skip any steps,
0:33:58 that we gather data or transmit data appropriately
0:34:02 so that it's safe and secure,
0:34:03 and that it's the correct data
0:34:05 so that we're not wasting customers' time.
0:34:08 We want to make sure that we get applications that are complete
0:34:11 and accurate so that we can send them off to for vetting
0:34:16 through the transportation clearing house.
0:34:19 So we'll go through these steps
0:34:21 and ultimately ends up with either authorizing
0:34:25 and issuing a badge to our customers,
0:34:27 or denying that badge,
0:34:29 but everybody will be treated the same.
0:34:31 It'll be fair and it'll be clear
0:34:34 as we go through the process for the airport personnel,
0:34:38 and more importantly, the customer
0:34:40 that's applying for this badge.
0:34:45 Here's another key feature that makes the IDMS
0:34:48 so important to us.
0:34:50 It allows customers to get online and choose
0:34:55 a day in time to come see us.
0:34:58 Even though we're driving towards a lot of automation
0:35:01 with this system, there are still points
0:35:04 that the badge applicant will need to come in
0:35:06 and allow us to physically look at identification media like a driver's license and things
0:35:12 like that to verify that it is that person and that it's a authentic piece of identification.
0:35:21 And also once they've completed the process and they finally get their badge, then we'll
0:35:26 need to print that out and physically hand it over to them.
0:35:29 So this is a simple step, but it's very important.
0:35:33 And now the customer can get online, see where availability is, and make sure it aligns with
0:35:39 what's convenient for them.
0:35:43 Thank you.
0:35:53 So why charge fees?
0:35:56 I just wanted to touch on this.
0:35:58 So maintaining the system like this has cost associated with and I'll break that down a
0:36:04 little bit.
0:36:05 What these software costs are primarily.
0:36:07 And we don't have funding to offset those costs.
0:36:10 So much like we do in other areas of our organization, like planning and zoning, building fees, recreation
0:36:16 fees and other things, we look at trying to pass through some of these to a user that
0:36:22 gains benefit that helps us be compliant, try to offset some of the costs.
0:36:29 So the airport has some fees currently, so landing fees, they don't really apply to base
0:36:34 tenants, they primarily airlines, cargo and some large general aviation transients that
0:36:40 go through reader. We have fuel flowage fees with everyone that buys again on a fuel. We
0:36:45 receive nine cents. Air prep, rescue, firefighting fees are the airlines that pay those and they
0:36:53 help offset airport costs. Just parenthetically, some have said I pay a ground lease from my
0:36:58 hangar. The hangar ground lease rates apply to the fair market value that lease ground
0:37:03 and that's how the agreement is priced. So it all pops into the same pot and we can
0:37:10 use those monies and those revenues, it's more related to the fair market value.
0:37:14 That's how the agreement is structured.
0:37:19 So the costs, so these are what we're looking at for ongoing costs.
0:37:26 We're looking at the IDMS system, these are annual costs of $48.
0:37:31 Criminal history checks those initial for the site of Badger here, but for
0:37:36 the AOA and the groups that we've mostly heard from and began speaking with her.
0:37:42 In this column, there's no FBI wrap-back that's associated with the CITA and those results.
0:37:48 There's some costs with the security threat assessment and some material costs, and right
0:37:54 there it's about a tiny $55.
0:37:56 So the fees proposed here are $55 annually.
0:38:01 As an annual—no, if you come in, I have a damaged badge, so there's no loss, but we'll
0:38:08 gladly replace that.
0:38:10 We certainly want to deter people that might be repeatedly losing their badges, particularly
0:38:16 in an environment where we have to be accountable for them.
0:38:20 So we have an escalating sort of a fine structure, if you will.
0:38:25 That's where we are with costs related to those ongoing, you know, the fees and the cost
0:38:32 that relationship there.
0:38:36 This is a survey of other commercial service airports in Idaho.
0:38:40 I did a telephone survey to individuals there in the interim since we last met.
0:38:46 So Sun Valley has an annual fee of $40 in first time set up the Idaho Falls is assessing
0:38:54 and they're looking at adopting fees in 2024.
0:39:00 Lewis and in charge $65 every two years, they are planning to review their fees for an increase
0:39:06 in 24.
0:39:07 had a long conversation about excessive staff time to run the program, talking with somebody
0:39:13 who's been there.
0:39:14 They were very curious about our IDMS application that we're looking at.
0:39:20 Picatello is sort of a sister airport, they've gotten the new service as well, and they're
0:39:26 looking at writing their full program, instituting their badging, and then looking at adopting
0:39:33 fees for fiscal 25.
0:39:34 So they're delaying that implementation to the fall.
0:39:40 Boise is an air bash software user.
0:39:43 I think they've got 5,000 badges in Boise.
0:39:48 They're $65 annual.
0:39:51 Twin Falls, once again, we're looking at 55.
0:39:54 One of those things that also points out
0:39:56 is although fees vary and different states of evolution
0:40:00 with that, all of them are required to do a credentialing
0:40:05 and vaging program for every single one in this small sampling.
0:40:14 Next steps.
0:40:16 So at our meeting with the tenants,
0:40:18 we talked about having a special meeting January 9
0:40:21 with this singular topic of the program.
0:40:23 I invite tenants and users to come and talk about that
0:40:27 and engage with us.
0:40:30 It's not that we normally don't meet in January and July,
0:40:32 that we can post a special meeting.
0:40:35 And we're looking at future tenant user workshops regarding
0:40:40 implementation details and continuing with the program.
0:40:43 And I just wanted to make an important note
0:40:46 that how much I appreciate the engagement of the tenants
0:40:48 and users.
0:40:51 They came to the meeting here in the 27th.
0:40:53 They came to the meeting we had on the 7th.
0:40:56 I think the meeting on the 7th went well.
0:40:59 We were able to listen.
0:41:00 And it's critical that we have productive conversation, because as we develop our plan,
0:41:05 if we're able to know, even if there were one-off situations, what about this, what about that,
0:41:10 we could write a plan which will be held to that maybe can address some of those things.
0:41:15 Some of the things that we heard, for instance, are what if I'm in a flying club and I want
0:41:23 to bring my wife and kids flying with me.
0:41:25 We could create an escort procedure with a certain amount of folks that if you're an
0:41:30 authorized user with a badge, you have the ability to escort people onto the airport, engage
0:41:36 with them, certainly be a part of that group, and keep them within eyesight, you know, that
0:41:41 type of thing truly keep on or the thought of being an escort.
0:41:45 So there's things like that.
0:41:47 We've heard from some of the Lyma mechanic, I can't wear a lanyard, and I think we have
0:41:52 flexibility, maybe they carry that in their pocket or nearby in their desk, whatever it
0:41:57 may be.
0:41:58 When you're out on the area of the plan, you have to be visible and it's a requirement
0:42:02 to have that land here to be very identifiable.
0:42:04 But there's things we can work with in the plan to try to work with some of these issues.
0:42:13 So once again, I really appreciate all the input and I look forward to continuing the
0:42:17 dialogue with them in some of these future workshops and meetings.
0:42:20 So with that concludes our presentation and I'd be happy to answer any questions you might have.
0:42:28 Thank you Bill. Any questions for Bill on this batching fee topic?
0:42:35 Do you have any comments, Nikki, about did you go to the meeting?
0:42:40 All four and a half hours of it.
0:42:43 Oh, great.
0:42:44 It was good. It was really good to talk to people, but more to listen, to have them.
0:42:52 You always learn something when you're talking,
0:42:56 somebody's just sharing what they're,
0:42:57 and they did have quite a few concerns,
0:43:00 but I also think on the 9th of January,
0:43:04 what a great opportunity to have them articulate more of them
0:43:10 and to see how that's gonna lay out,
0:43:13 lay out with the policy.
0:43:17 I think it's gonna all work out just fine,
0:43:20 And it is part of the process we're going through
0:43:24 in many parts of our city, and this is an important one.
0:43:29 This being TSA compliant doesn't sound very fun.
0:43:33 I don't even like the sound of it.
0:43:35 But I really like having a nice airport
0:43:38 where I can fly out of.
0:43:39 So do all the other citizens in business.
0:43:45 Thank you, Ms. Reed.
0:43:47 I don't have a question, but I just want to say thank you.
0:43:50 I know this was extra work.
0:43:52 Thank you for meeting with everybody on the seventh.
0:43:55 That sounds like it was a great meeting a little bit long,
0:43:58 but you know, four hours.
0:44:00 Thank you for doing that.
0:44:02 So it looks like we have some folks here.
0:44:04 Thank you for being engaged in this process.
0:44:08 Thank you for the presentation as well.
0:44:09 It answered a lot of questions that we had.
0:44:12 Thank you, Chris.
0:44:15 Just one note, Councilman Boyd references four and a half hours.
0:44:19 So we had an annual airport tennis dinner meeting.
0:44:22 was a little bit more casual after our formal 90-minute meeting, which we were able to also
0:44:28 kind of continue the discussion in a much briefer context as well as provide other information.
0:44:33 So it was a good night for connection as well afterwards to turn the meeting.
0:44:38 Perfect.
0:44:39 Yeah, instead of just having a 90-minute meeting and then everybody leaves, it was nice to get
0:44:47 to listen to more people and what they had to say.
0:44:50 It was good.
0:44:51 Okay, Chris Reed. I'll make a motion. We approve resolution 2023-017 of the City Council of
0:45:01 the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, proposing new airport credential, credentialing slash ID
0:45:07 badge fees and amending the city's master fee schedule as presented.
0:45:12 Thank you. Do I have a second? I'll second. Thank you. A motion by Chris Reed, seconded
0:45:19 by Craig Hawkins to approve the resolution of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls
0:45:25 proposing new airport credentialing ID badge fees and amending the city's master fee schedule.
0:45:33 Any further discussion?
0:45:36 Amy Roll call vote please.
0:45:40 Jason Brown.
0:45:41 Yes.
0:45:42 Spencer Cutler.
0:45:43 Yes.
0:45:44 Ruth Pierce.
0:45:45 Yes.
0:45:46 Chris Reed.
0:45:47 Yes.
0:45:48 Thank you.
0:45:49 Boyd.
0:45:50 Yes.
0:45:51 to zero. Thank you, Bill.
0:45:52 Thank you very much.
0:45:53 Okay, next item on the agenda is we got through the whole thing.
0:46:04 Wow. Item E, request of city council to reject all bids
0:46:09 for Shoshone Falls Grade Roadway project.
0:46:12 And we have Troy the tech, our city engineer.
0:46:15 Welcome, Troy.
0:46:16 Thank you, mayor and council members.
0:46:18 Tonight I kind of come bearing some bad news.
0:46:21 We recently bid a project, Shoshone Falls Grade.
0:46:23 This was part of the SLF RF funds that were set aside for that.
0:46:27 We've had plenty of discussions about what should be done there.
0:46:30 Now to go about it, we did some design.
0:46:33 About that done, we sent it off for bid.
0:46:35 We received only one bid on this project.
0:46:38 Fortunately, it was about $1.1 million over our estimate.
0:46:42 What to do?
0:46:43 There's only so much money left in the SLF RF funds and reserves.
0:46:49 We could utilize those at this time with only receiving one bid
0:46:53 and there's been others that have reached out
0:46:56 and showed an interest now since the bid has been completed.
0:47:00 I feel it would probably be safer and best for us
0:47:03 to reject the bids.
0:47:06 Unfortunately, with the schedule
0:47:08 and the tour season starting next summer,
0:47:10 we wouldn't have time to re-bid it
0:47:12 and get it constructed before then.
0:47:14 So my recommendation would be actually reject the bids.
0:47:17 We'll finalize the plans to make sure
0:47:19 we have a better, more coherent document set
0:47:23 of what is absolutely necessary,
0:47:24 and then re-bid the project to bring the summer
0:47:28 and try to award it in the next fall
0:47:29 when the tour sees some kind of slacks off again
0:47:33 and try to connect the constructor
0:47:34 over the next winter period.
0:47:36 I believe that's probably the safest, most effective
0:47:41 at this time in hopes of giving additional bids.
0:47:44 There are a couple other options that was including
0:47:46 their packet we could go forth and do this project right now.
0:47:49 We just have to pull reserves from somewhere,
0:47:51 Or we can just neck down the project to just get the absolute bare bones minimum stuff.
0:47:55 I recommend the show show falls great in the rock fall because that was kind of the primary focus.
0:48:00 The Derkeys road is also in major disrepair and I know a big theme was the connection between the show show falls park and the Derkeys park with the bike path.
0:48:09 I would also have to go away as well as the boat ramp connection point.
0:48:14 We'd be losing a lot of other options in this and I believe in next summer we'd probably get a better bid.
0:48:20 I think prices are starting to kind of top out and possibly even fall down so our my recommendation is to reject the bids
0:48:27 We'll read that income next summer and then I'll be in front of you again. I have any questions for me
0:48:34 Thank you Jason Brown
0:48:37 Troy and you may or may not know this question specifically
0:48:41 Do we run up against any timelines spending the SLO SLR F funds?
0:48:48 Yeah, sure it's slur slur fucks
0:48:50 So we don't. We, because we were under the $10 million threshold, we were able to take
0:48:59 the standard allowance. And we reported out the standard allowance. But what we wanted to
0:49:05 do is we wanted to spirit, follow the spirit and the intention moving forward. And so the
0:49:11 deadlines that we set were internal in nature. We wanted to follow the guidelines set by the
0:49:19 federal government but in terms of federal compliance we have met that so we
0:49:24 still want to go forward with the having the plans approved by the council
0:49:29 which they were by December 31st of 2024 and with the goal of having all the
0:49:34 projects completed by December 31st of 2026. Thank you. Spencer Cutler. I would
0:49:42 make a motion if you're ready. I agree with your recommendation Troy so I would
0:49:49 move that we reject the bid and
0:49:51 re-bid late next summer or early fall.
0:49:55 Thank you. Do I have a second? Jason?
0:49:57 I'll second. Thank you.
0:49:59 Emotion from Spencer Cutler,
0:50:01 seconded by Jason Brown to reject the bid for
0:50:06 the Shoshone Falls Grade Roadway Project and
0:50:09 re-bid later in the fall or the next year.
0:50:12 Any further discussion?
0:50:15 Amy Rolkelvo, please.
0:50:17 Spencer Cutler?
0:50:20 Yes.
0:50:21 Ruth Pierce.
0:50:22 Yes.
0:50:23 Chris Reed.
0:50:24 Yes.
0:50:25 Thank you, Boyd.
0:50:26 Yes.
0:50:27 Great.
0:50:28 Hawkins.
0:50:29 Yes.
0:50:30 And Jason Brown.
0:50:31 Yes.
0:50:32 Thank you.
0:50:33 Motion passes six to zero.
0:50:34 Thank you, Troy.
0:50:35 Thank you.
0:50:36 Hey, that's all for items of consideration.
0:50:39 Next item on the agenda is a general public input.
0:50:42 It's time for a time for anybody in the audience who wishes to address city council.
0:50:46 They can come down to the podium and do so.
0:50:49 needs to be on items not otherwise on the agenda or any personnel issues and you will
0:50:56 have two minutes. If you choose to come down, please state your name and whether you're
0:51:02 resident of Twin Falls. Is there anybody here that wishes to address the City Council
0:51:08 tonight? Okay, seeing no one, advisory board reports.
0:51:17 We had a library meeting, Sherry, one of our new council women, was there, but it was all
0:51:27 our state legislature, but it was really fun to see the library that abuzz with moms and
0:51:36 kids and the participation level.
0:51:40 It was really a nice event and I think educational for a lot of people to get more involved in
0:51:47 in what goes on at the library.
0:51:50 That was a good meeting.
0:51:52 Spencer.
0:51:53 Hey, just comment on the Historic Preservation Commission.
0:51:56 There's at least one vacancy open,
0:51:59 and that is open right now,
0:52:01 and looking for interested people
0:52:03 that we don't want to apply for that.
0:52:05 And I might add there's that opening,
0:52:08 there's the P&Z opening one,
0:52:10 and there's two impact fee openings.
0:52:12 So we actually have four positions
0:52:15 that are open up right now
0:52:16 for and the application.
0:52:18 The information that applies online, yep.
0:52:22 Anything from the City Manager's Office?
0:52:25 Just a reminder as we shared last week's City Hall
0:52:27 and other non-emergency parts of our organization
0:52:34 will be closed tomorrow for the City's annual retreat
0:52:39 and business meeting.
0:52:41 We will reopen on Wednesday
0:52:45 at eight o'clock and for individuals
0:52:49 who have emergency services,
0:52:50 they're still encouraged to dial 911
0:52:53 as all of those services will be deployed.
0:52:57 And I might add that next Monday
0:53:00 is our last council meeting for the year.
0:53:03 And after that, both Mondays fall on holidays
0:53:07 so we won't be meeting.
0:53:08 So anything else?
0:53:12 Hey, our meeting's adjourned.
0:53:13 Thank you, everyone.
Download
- Transcript (text) 50 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 66 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 90 KB
- Audio (M4A) 12.6 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, December 11, 2023. The recording started at 16:59 by the recorder's clock and runs 00:53:22.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
ed5b072ed1b73f663ce1da21f95349ca7f45b0fc8b0410ec6f6dbe1fd58a735a - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 8ab6c3898efdbc2ad9216a1ad748227572822101af0be081140710065db635a3 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
19232c68468fe561f7263c92128249a5fdc0b6c08cef57e4c71c685db3e6c866
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file