OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, December 18, 2023

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on fileMinutes on file

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:00:12 Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the December 18th, 2023 City Council meeting.

0:00:19 I want to confirm we have a quorum. We have all seven members present in chambers.

0:00:24 First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. If you wish to join me, please rise.

0:00:47 Thank you. We have no proclamations tonight, so moving on to the consent calendar. Council wishes.

0:00:54 Move to approve the consent calendar as published. Thank you, Craig Hawkins.

0:00:58 Second.

0:00:59 Thank you.

0:01:00 Emotion by Chris Reed, seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the consent calendar as written.

0:01:06 Amy Roll call vote please.

0:01:09 Bruce Pierce.

0:01:10 Yes.

0:01:11 Chris Reed.

0:01:12 Yes.

0:01:13 Thank you, Boyd.

0:01:14 Yes.

0:01:15 Craig Hawkins.

0:01:16 Yes.

0:01:17 Jason Brown.

0:01:18 Yes.

0:01:19 Alex Koval.

0:01:20 Yes.

0:01:21 And Spencer Cutler.

0:01:22 Yes.

0:01:23 Thank you.

0:01:24 Motion passes seven to zero.

0:01:25 So we have a really lengthy meeting tonight.

0:01:26 This is our last meeting of the year.

0:01:28 So we'll have a lot going on.

0:01:30 First item on the agenda is a presentation of a donation

0:01:34 from the Twin Falls City Employees

0:01:37 to the Twin Falls School District Angels Fund.

0:01:39 And we have Brianna Howard, our CFO.

0:01:43 Welcome Brianna.

0:01:47 Good evening, Mayor and Council.

0:01:49 So tonight I wanted to present a donation check.

0:01:53 We had our city retreat this last week

0:01:56 of which all the city employees purchased raffle tickets

0:01:59 city donated items and those raffle tickets were used, the money was used to donate to

0:02:07 the Twin Falls School District Angel Fund.

0:02:10 And so tonight we have Jenny Herzog here that will explain a little bit about the fund.

0:02:15 And then we also have a few of us that were on the city retreat committee that would like

0:02:19 to come down and present this check to in the amount of $2,747 to Jenny Herzog.

0:02:27 Thank you.

0:02:28 that I didn't trip. So the Angel Fund is part of I work for the school district

0:02:41 as the McKinney-Vento liaison which is working for the homeless and at-risk

0:02:46 students in the district. We have about 360 at the moment that are currently

0:02:52 living in what we would call substandard temporary housing. So about 65% are in

0:02:59 Bally house or motels or trailers, a few in the cars etc. So with our federal funds

0:03:07 we're able to buy them school supplies we're able to help them with tutoring

0:03:12 anything that is tied directly to academic but when it comes to their

0:03:18 other needs we're falling short so we return to the community to help bridge

0:03:23 that gap. So that could be, you know, shoes, it could be blankets, it could be, when there's

0:03:30 seven in a motel room, many are sleeping on the floor, so we're getting inflatable

0:03:34 mattresses, etc. Lots of jackets, clothing and hygiene supplies, etc. So we're constantly

0:03:42 scrambling for resources. The teachers are calling us very often for needs, not just

0:03:50 for homeless and at risk but for a very low income and so we tried to find

0:03:57 things for them so the teachers aren't buying those supplies because you know

0:04:02 they're unlimited budgets too. So when people reach out and do things like this

0:04:09 we are extremely grateful because I did go buy snow boots a week or two weeks

0:04:15 ago and I only bought maybe 30 pairs and that racked up to almost 400 dollars. So I

0:04:22 know when I saw how much they were I was like oh my gosh I bought snow boots for a

0:04:26 long time. They are not cheap. So you know these elementary school kids now have

0:04:32 snow boots and they're not coming and we're stopping wet feet after their recess.

0:04:36 So just small things like that add up to an incredible amount of money. So when we

0:04:40 get. Donations are very very very grateful so I'd like to say thank you to

0:04:45 everyone that participate in that and please know that those funds will be used

0:04:49 very carefully and they will go directly to the

0:04:52 children via the school mostly via the teachers when we know their

0:04:56 direct needs and so thank you very much and hope you know how much we appreciate

0:05:01 it. Thank you for all you do. Well thank you for all you do.

0:05:08 So anybody from the retreat committee come on down.

0:05:11 Shouldn't she be on there?

0:05:16 Oh, this is, he's rubbing up against it.

0:05:38 Get real comfortable with each other folks.

0:05:52 Let's give a big hand to everybody who donated.

0:05:59 Thank you.

0:06:03 Okay, next item on the agenda is an action item.

0:06:05 It's request to use $59,100 from contingency funds

0:06:11 to purchase case management software

0:06:14 for the legal department and we have a deputy city prosecutor, deputy prosecuting attorney

0:06:20 Jeff Dering. Welcome Jeff.

0:06:22 Hello. Thank you, Mayor and Council. I appreciate the chance to speak this evening. I'm here

0:06:27 to ask for authorization of contingent funds in the amount of $59,100. As you all know,

0:06:35 I believe it was the last fiscal year. There was approximately $26,000, which were previously

0:06:40 authorized for a similar purchase. However, for reasons beyond my control that money was

0:06:46 not spent or earmarked before it went back into reserves. So tonight I'm asking for the

0:06:52 contingency funds to follow through with the purchase. But obviously that's a considerable

0:06:58 jump in price between years. I can tell you that what I understand, I mean the price is

0:07:05 on pretty much everything have gone up and that's part of the factor. But also the software

0:07:09 that we're hoping to purchase, that price includes several additions that will allow it

0:07:16 to integrate with our system and the core computer system more efficiently.

0:07:19 So it's not just the base price, there's some add-ons.

0:07:22 I think you all had the quote in there, so that's kind of where that price comes from.

0:07:28 I have been working with Kathy and Mike quite a bit from our IT department to find a replacement

0:07:33 for what we're using.

0:07:35 The software we're using was put together by Fritz Wonderlake in 2002.

0:07:39 in its original form, so it's been used for a very long time,

0:07:43 and that in and of itself isn't a problem.

0:07:45 The problem is that he was designed to speak to Windows 98,

0:07:49 so part of what it's trying to do,

0:07:50 it's looking for pieces of Windows

0:07:52 that simply don't exist anymore,

0:07:54 so IT is trying to patch that and keep it functioning,

0:07:58 and we're getting weird errors,

0:07:59 like the one I've used with other people

0:08:01 is when he print out a certificate of service

0:08:04 that the address is supposed to be

0:08:05 for the public defender's office,

0:08:06 It'll say public defender, twin fall, no S, Tf, Idaho, ID 800000-1, no one knows why.

0:08:18 But so we have to go and incorrect those by hand.

0:08:21 And so this new software that we're looking at is called legal edge.

0:08:25 They're a company out of Pennsylvania.

0:08:26 They've been around for more than 30 years.

0:08:30 They specialize in prosecutor and public defender software.

0:08:34 We can also utilize it for civil purposes, too, since we obviously have civil aspects of the

0:08:40 city we advise on also.

0:08:43 And I've had a chance to speak with one of the users, it's Navajo County, Arizona's prosecutor's

0:08:49 office.

0:08:50 They've been using it in various forms for about 20, 25 years.

0:08:55 Their office manager had nothing but good things to say.

0:08:57 They said that a legal edge is responsive, easy to work with, efficiently priced, or can

0:09:04 competitively priced, and something that I think I

0:09:08 said through several demos from four or five different

0:09:11 companies on the software programs.

0:09:14 And what I liked most about this one and what IT liked as

0:09:16 well is that they didn't promise us the whole world.

0:09:19 There wasn't a lot of like, you want it, we can do it.

0:09:21 He asked for certain things, and I just said, we don't

0:09:23 think anyone can do that.

0:09:24 And we can't do it at the price you need, but let's give

0:09:27 you what you need.

0:09:28 And there was not a lot of empty promises.

0:09:31 It was really, here's what we can do for you, and here's

0:09:33 how much it's going to cost.

0:09:34 So from the legal department, we feel that this software is going to make us more efficient.

0:09:41 It's going to make it so we can connect to our existing software and systems more easily.

0:09:46 And we have a dedicated company working on this rather than our IT team trying to do it

0:09:51 for us.

0:09:52 They've got enough going on.

0:09:53 So thank you and I would ask that you authorize the use of those continuously funds.

0:09:57 Alex, come on.

0:09:59 Jeff, I had a question on the document conversion portion of that.

0:10:02 Is that for existing cases, that 15,000 line item, is it for existing cases or is it for

0:10:07 everything that's being converted, all cases being converted over to the system, what does

0:10:11 that cover?

0:10:12 It is everything.

0:10:13 Do we need it?

0:10:16 I think so.

0:10:17 Just because our current software, we have some pre-built criminal complaints in there,

0:10:24 and honestly they are so generic that we've heard from some of the judges that they might

0:10:28 not even be efficient constitutionally.

0:10:31 So rather than have IT try and pull all those out and rewrite them, it would be a fresh start

0:10:37 to have them where we need them, where the courts are asking for them.

0:10:40 Thank you.

0:10:41 Mr. E. And you might have just answered this question because I know one of the issues

0:10:47 was is our relationship with court and the information that we were sending them in your

0:10:52 best opinion judgment would this satisfy what our judges are asking from the city?

0:10:57 I believe it would because it would take, it would give us a chance to basically have

0:11:01 of a fresh start and put in what's called a charging book

0:11:06 that the Proscutors Association,

0:11:08 and I think it might have started with Ada County,

0:11:10 put together for all the charges in Idaho

0:11:12 that can be used as a template.

0:11:14 And that's the up-to-date annual,

0:11:17 everything that the courts are wanting,

0:11:18 that's what can be put into this now,

0:11:20 rather than the old version that we're gonna have to change

0:11:22 every time we print them.

0:11:24 So yes, it will make it so we're in line.

0:11:28 Thank you, Boann.

0:11:29 I it sounded like it would help prevent some mistakes. I mean the more you have to

0:11:35 keep entering stuff the more you're open for mistakes and stuff. It sounds like

0:11:39 this program had a lot to do with you put it in once it's correct and it goes to

0:11:44 where it needs and it's accessible by all who need it. Correct. Yeah and it will

0:11:49 be stored all the data will be stored locally but we'll be able to access it

0:11:52 from wherever we are and yeah we can be with them and like I said heard from

0:11:57 not a hoe county that when there is a problem they're very responsive with phone calls and

0:12:02 emails right on to problems with them there.

0:12:09 I do have a question Jeff just to be clear so we originally had 25, 950 that was budgeted

0:12:16 it went back into a general fund correct and now this request being the 59 100 there's

0:12:26 an additional 33,450. So wouldn't we take the first part out of general and the rest out

0:12:33 of contingency or what?

0:12:35 So as part of our process what we're going to do is even though they were originally

0:12:39 in the, so they originally in the capital improvement fund, um, the contingency fund

0:12:44 also rests in the capital improvement fund and also all of our general funds sweeps into

0:12:49 the capital fund and so it would be appropriate to, um, use the entirety of the cap of the

0:12:55 to do the funds out of the capital fund to authorize funding for his request if granted

0:13:00 by the council.

0:13:01 Perfect.

0:13:02 Thank you.

0:13:03 Chris Reed.

0:13:05 I'll make a motion if we're ready.

0:13:07 I move that we use $59,100 from contingency funds to purchase case management software for

0:13:14 the legal department.

0:13:16 Thank you.

0:13:17 Do I have a second?

0:13:18 Second.

0:13:19 Thank you.

0:13:20 Motion by Chris Reed.

0:13:21 to approve the use of $59,100 from the contingency fund

0:13:28 to purchase case management software

0:13:30 for the legal department.

0:13:32 Amy Roquevo, please.

0:13:34 Chris Reed.

0:13:35 Yes.

0:13:36 Thank you, Boyd.

0:13:36 Yes, Greg Hawkins.

0:13:37 Yes.

0:13:38 Jason Brown.

0:13:39 Yes.

0:13:40 Alex Coball.

0:13:41 Yes, Spencer Cutler.

0:13:41 Yes.

0:13:42 And Ruth Pierce.

0:13:43 Yes.

0:13:44 Thank you, motion passes seven to zero.

0:13:46 Thank you, Jeff.

0:13:47 Thank you.

0:13:48 Next item on the agenda is an action item.

0:13:51 It's a request that the City Council use wastewater reserve funds, not exceeding 140,000

0:13:58 to purchase a second odour scrubber with associated components.

0:14:03 We have Nathan Eric, and welcome, Nathan.

0:14:08 Thank you.

0:14:09 I appreciate your time tonight, Mayor and Council.

0:14:13 Yes, so the day, the reason I'm here is two months ago I was here and presented on the

0:14:22 results from this last summer and that was October 23rd and then as you might

0:14:31 remember the results were very positive with the Otter Scrubber we had purchased

0:14:35 this last spring and we identified that those results are beneficial to the city

0:14:43 and we're looking into options of where we might be able to make that feasible

0:14:49 option to permanently install something.

0:14:53 Now as we entered into that last meeting two months ago, we had a conceptual location that

0:15:00 we were looking at, but as we shared that with some of the neighbors in that area, there

0:15:04 were some concerns and we recognized that and so we met with them and one of the requests

0:15:13 was that we do a little bit more of a study in that area.

0:15:18 So this last summer we tested on that Canyon Rim line, or the Grand View Trunk Line on

0:15:25 Canyon Rim Road.

0:15:27 We missed about the last 300 feet.

0:15:29 We weren't right at the end of the Canyon Rim.

0:15:32 So the request was that we go right to the rim and we do a test there.

0:15:36 So to do that, we were looking at doing that test, starting to warm up this next spring.

0:15:46 we realize that we have a location on South Side of town

0:15:48 that we have to have an order scrubber at,

0:15:51 or well, currently, until some other things work out.

0:15:54 And so we need another order scrubber.

0:15:57 And so that's why I'm here today,

0:15:58 is we would like to request another order scrubber.

0:16:01 And then looking at the cost of doing that,

0:16:04 we identified that to purchase another order scrubber,

0:16:08 like what we had, or what we have currently,

0:16:12 and there's a picture of it,

0:16:14 We paid about $54,000 for that order scrubber.

0:16:17 And it's great.

0:16:18 It's on a trailer.

0:16:19 It moves around, has about 1,000 pounds

0:16:22 of carbon media in it.

0:16:25 What we found was that we could, for about twice the money,

0:16:29 we could actually purchase the size of order scrubber

0:16:32 that we would use in a permit location,

0:16:34 with the option of being able to use temporarily

0:16:37 until we find that a permit location.

0:16:39 And I want to be very clear, we do not have a location.

0:16:42 We had a conceptual location we were looking at, but wherever is going to work best is what

0:16:48 we're looking for.

0:16:49 So at this point, we still want to run the trial to figure out how it's going to work.

0:16:55 The proposed, so instead of buying another small one, in your packet, this is the estimate.

0:17:03 There's a picture up.

0:17:04 Now I want to be clear, you know, by the picture it does show that, so what's pictured

0:17:09 there, it's actually twice that size.

0:17:12 So here's actually our engineer on the project was able to put this together.

0:17:18 That gives you an idea of what it would look like.

0:17:20 So the cube there is about seven feet on each side.

0:17:26 And the idea is it will come with cube lowers.

0:17:30 So while we are still trying to figure out temporarily what's going on and as we can use

0:17:34 that mobile otter scrubber to go to the north side of town to do our tests, this can be

0:17:38 put at the south side by public works.

0:17:42 And on top of it has a smaller blower, that's what would be used.

0:17:46 So that one plugs in to an outlet, and we can use that blower.

0:17:52 That blower is also the same size, a blower that is on the mobile unit.

0:17:56 So when that's taken off in a permanent location, we have a use for that blower, it will eventually

0:18:04 be used on the trailer.

0:18:05 So we're trying to use our money wisely here.

0:18:09 And then eventually, when everything works out, when we go through zoning and all of our

0:18:15 steps are covered, it will have a blower that could be used that would be for a permanent

0:18:20 location.

0:18:21 And that blower is about three times bigger than the mobile one, so it would draw more

0:18:27 air.

0:18:28 It actually has, instead of just a carbon media, it's got more carbon media, obviously, because

0:18:33 it's a bigger one, but it also has a second chamber that has coconut shells that it takes

0:18:39 out a little bit more of the odor and cleans it up even further.

0:18:44 So in this request, for that scrubber, it's about $115,000.

0:18:52 The media inside of it lasts about one to two years.

0:18:56 Likely it's going to be more because as our H-S levels go down, that carbon will only take

0:19:05 so much.

0:19:06 If we reduce that, it may last for many more years than that.

0:19:10 But because we don't know when it's going to go out,

0:19:15 it's good to have it on hand so that when it does reach its capacity,

0:19:20 we have something to refill it with.

0:19:22 So that would be another $17,000 to have that media on hand.

0:19:30 And then we also have a missed eliminator

0:19:33 that we need to purchase for the trailer.

0:19:35 and some odour loggers for a total where we're requesting a $140,000 from council to address

0:19:44 this odour project and get us ready for this next summer so that we can continue this project.

0:19:51 If there's any questions?

0:19:53 Yes, there are a couple of chris-read.

0:19:56 I'm assuming this is an outdoor unit so we would not need to build anything around or

0:20:02 above this.

0:20:03 At this point, until we figure out the permanent location, when we do get a permanent location,

0:20:11 it would be likely a fence of some sort.

0:20:14 Okay.

0:20:15 And then how loud is this?

0:20:16 So, the mobile otoscreber is about 84 decibels at 5 feet, which I guess is within OSHA requirements.

0:20:28 The further you get away, obviously it's less.

0:20:31 are told by the the manufacturer on this that it is less. The permanent one would

0:20:37 be less because they can put a bigger silencer on the exhaust there and then

0:20:43 also the fence could be an additional insulation to noise. Thank you.

0:20:50 Alex. Nathan what is the lifespan of this unit? Like how many years can get out of it?

0:20:58 The unit itself, I would imagine, would be 20 years at least.

0:21:03 It's the media that would have to be replaced occasionally.

0:21:06 And like I said, depending on what the concentration of H2S is in the sewer,

0:21:12 1 to 2 is kind of the low end.

0:21:17 I would expect it's going to be probably twice that by the time,

0:21:21 you know, this time of year we could actually probably turn it off

0:21:25 Because it's cold. I mean, I haven't had an order complaint for probably two months.

0:21:30 Is that, does the hydrosylfuric, the fume, does that deteriorate the inside of that unit?

0:21:40 No. Okay.

0:21:41 It's made for the H2S.

0:21:44 Thanks. Nathan, what's the timing on this?

0:21:49 So if we were to able to put it out to bid, so this is, so this has to go out to semi-formal bidding,

0:21:56 so we have to get three bids. We'd give them about two weeks and then we're about three months,

0:22:01 three or four months for them to construct and get it. Late spring. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. Jason Brown.

0:22:09 So Nathan and I understood you correctly. So this, this unit you want to buy,

0:22:13 put it at the Public Works Building and then use the mobile trailer for some additional testing

0:22:18 around town to find a good location for a permanent installation, correct?

0:22:24 Correct.

0:22:25 And when we find that location, we'll go through the process of whatever process zoning you said,

0:22:33 whatever that may be at that time.

0:22:35 Yeah, we expect there's going to be some zoning.

0:22:37 And definitely, I mean, we want to be a good neighbor.

0:22:39 So we are definitely going to let people know, especially those that are going to be nearby.

0:22:44 Sure.

0:22:45 So I'll make a motion if we're ready to go.

0:22:48 doesn't look like there's any other questions go ahead move to approve using

0:22:53 wastewater reserves funds not to exceed a hundred and forty thousand to purchase

0:22:56 second-order scrubber with associated components thank you Alex I'll second

0:23:02 the motion thank you motion by Jason Brown excuse me second by Alex Koval to

0:23:08 approve using wastewater funds not to exceed a hundred and forty thousand to

0:23:12 purchase the second-order scrubber with associated components Amy roll call

0:23:17 vote please. Nicky Boyd. Yes. Greg Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Alex Cabal. Yes. Spencer

0:23:25 Cutler. Yes. Pierce. Yes. And Chris Reed. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7 to 0. Thank

0:23:31 you, Nathan. Next on the agenda is an action item. It's a request to adopt an ordinance

0:23:37 amending city code Title 6 Chapter 3 regarding animal permits. And we have Mitch Humble,

0:23:44 our deputy one of our deputy city managers.

0:23:47 Welcome Mitch.

0:23:48 Thank you.

0:23:50 If you all remember back in September,

0:23:53 then a resident came during our general public input part

0:23:57 of the agenda, Ms. Sammer Library,

0:23:59 and requested that we take a look

0:24:01 at our animal permitting code

0:24:04 that would maybe tweak some of the requirements

0:24:06 for smaller animals, specifically her request was goats.

0:24:10 I think when we were having the discussion,

0:24:12 some other types of animals came up in that conversation as well.

0:24:15 That meeting the council said,

0:24:16 why don't we go ahead and take a look at that.

0:24:18 So since that time, we went back and Amber and I have had a few conversations.

0:24:26 We involved Jeff from our attorney's office and we involved Sean from

0:24:31 their animal control office and the four of us kind of put our heads together and

0:24:34 came up with a draft ordinance that you have in front of you tonight.

0:24:37 that has been created in-house. I think Jeff wrote this all up with input from three of us.

0:24:45 This final version has been forwarded to Ms. Lionberry. I think she's good with it.

0:24:50 She's here tonight. I'm gonna ask her to come up and tell you herself what she likes it or not,

0:24:54 but essentially what we did here was we split out animals into kind of larger and smaller animals,

0:25:03 And larger animals or all animals in the current code, you need to have an acre of land, and then you need to have 10,000 square feet of pasture per animal.

0:25:15 So if you wanted to have three horses, you would need to have at least an acre and 30,000 square feet dedicated to pasture for the three horses.

0:25:25 What we did was we kept that the same, so you still have that, but we defined that for larger animals like horses or cows or llamas or those kinds of things.

0:25:35 Then we created a new section that would be a very similarly written section for smaller animals like goats or sheep.

0:25:42 And we reduced that to a half acre, total land, and 5,000 square feet of pasture per animal.

0:25:50 And when we looked around the state at other Idaho cities,

0:25:55 that seemed consistent with what some other folks were doing.

0:25:58 We did find one city that just flat out prohibited coats.

0:26:02 But for the most part, you could do that,

0:26:05 and most of them were in this half acre,

0:26:07 5,000 square feet range.

0:26:09 And so this seemed consistent with what we found.

0:26:11 It seemed consistent with how we already are treating things.

0:26:15 If we didn't change any of the permitting requirements,

0:26:17 you still have to go through the process to get a permit,

0:26:19 get some signatures from your neighbors,

0:26:21 all those kinds of things.

0:26:23 But we did, while we were in here,

0:26:24 we did make a few other tweaks,

0:26:25 we're correcting some language,

0:26:28 how it dated, some titles that are not there anymore.

0:26:32 We're going to the chief of police,

0:26:33 or his designe now, instead of the sanitation inspector,

0:26:36 which we don't really have that position anymore,

0:26:38 those kinds of things.

0:26:39 And then we also corrected, or not corrected,

0:26:42 but we added a requirement for these animals

0:26:45 to have some shelter as part of the permit requirements.

0:26:49 So anyway, that's kind of the gist of it, um,

0:26:53 Staff's comfortable with recommending this ordinance. I believe that it's supported by the by the resident you heard from this library. And I would ask her if she wants to come up and share her thoughts with you. I think she briefly will do that. And then I think both of us and Jeff's here too would answer your questions if you have any tonight.

0:27:12 So, hey, come on down.

0:27:21 Adam here and council members, sorry.

0:27:23 Always a busy one.

0:27:25 I really don't have a lot to say.

0:27:27 I'm really grateful that you guys have been considering this.

0:27:30 And it works for our land and I also hope it works for some other people's land that would benefit from having some farm animals.

0:27:40 Thank you.

0:27:41 Thank you.

0:27:42 Okay, I have a question.

0:27:46 It's one of the things I see in here is we are giving someone five years, if they're not

0:27:56 in compliance with this section prior to the amendment, did we really mean to give them

0:28:02 five years?

0:28:03 That's what the current language in the code says, and so we didn't really change that.

0:28:08 So the current code that's in place today gave somebody the opportunity.

0:28:13 I think long past, actually, because that code section was done some time ago.

0:28:22 This amendment opens up, opens the code up, and so if you weren't in compliance before,

0:28:30 you might could get into compliance now, but they wouldn't have got a permit before, so

0:28:34 they would need to come in and request a new permit under the new code.

0:28:37 But again, that five-year section was in place

0:28:42 when the code was originally adopted some years ago.

0:28:46 I think it just seems like an awful long time.

0:28:49 I thought it was a typo until I saw it was on both places.

0:28:53 Well, and that code was adopted in 1987.

0:28:55 Yes.

0:28:56 So those five years have been gotten for anybody

0:28:59 who was not in compliance.

0:29:02 At that time.

0:29:03 And so you're saying if there was anybody not in compliance

0:29:06 now they have five years. If there's any way not in compliance now,

0:29:11 what we've done is added a section that might make them in compliance.

0:29:16 That might help them get into compliance. Okay. All right.

0:29:19 I'll let's give up. Oh, I've got two questions.

0:29:27 Number one, what is the maximum number of

0:29:30 goats that I can have in city limits under this code?

0:29:33 Well, it depends on your property. Okay. So, okay, because that's what I was

0:29:37 wondering because at this point it says one goat but then it seems to be tied to

0:29:40 the half-acre so it's like half-acre per goat? No, 5,000 square feet of pasture per

0:29:46 goat you have to have at least a half-acre to even ask the question. Okay. And so or

0:29:52 for the larger animals you have to have at least an acre and then 10,000 square

0:29:55 feet per animal. So if you had a four-acre lot you could have a lot of goats but

0:30:01 you'd have to get a permit and you'd have to have signatures from your

0:30:05 neighbors within 300 feet 75% and all that kind of stuff and they have to be

0:30:09 covered and there would have to be a shelter for them yep second question for

0:30:14 you on 6-3-4 subsection C why are we measuring 40 feet from the house of an

0:30:26 adjacent homeowner and not 40 feet from a property line it feels like it's

0:30:30 really difficult to measure from someone else's house short of trespassing

0:30:35 That's just how we got written in there.

0:30:37 There's a, there's a, the intent is there to have a setback from where the animals are sheltering

0:30:43 or, or pasturing to a nearby home, not necessarily from the yard, but from the building.

0:30:50 And that was kind of the intent that, that Sean wanted to see in there.

0:30:54 Um, is there a reason why you think it could be from the property line?

0:30:59 Well, it would, so if you measured 40 foot from the property line, there could be some

0:31:07 cases where you would not have any pasture land left at that point because

0:31:11 you're coming in 40 from each side and if your house is a hundred feet wide you'd

0:31:16 have just a little bit of space in the middle for that. I'm trying to think

0:31:21 through this as I'm thinking about it. I mean you could end up with a situation

0:31:25 where you could have half an acre but not meet the 40 the 40 foot setback

0:31:31 requirement if you're going off of property lines but I'm questioning how

0:31:35 you would measure from the house someone else's house that seems like a

0:31:40 feasibility problem. What we would do when the permit comes in we would use our

0:31:44 aerial or GIS aerial photography to do that and we can measure with aerial

0:31:51 photography fairly easily actually. Not down to the inch but we could measure it

0:31:55 to within a foot or something. You every day didn't know we have that tool.

0:31:59 Thank you. And Sean would be the one. Sean and his team would be the ones doing

0:32:04 that when they were reviewing the permit.

0:32:07 Okay. Any other questions?

0:32:09 Okay. I'd be open for a motion.

0:32:14 There. I should probably tell you this is an ordinance. If you'd like to adopt it tonight,

0:32:19 we need to go find a third and final thing. And I don't remember the number, but Amy's got it on our top of our head.

0:32:24 I'm sure.

0:32:25 Twenty twenty three zero one seven.

0:32:27 Make a motion.

0:32:33 Chris Reed.

0:32:34 I move that we dispense with the reading rules and put ordinance twenty twenty three dash zero one seven on third and final.

0:32:41 reading by title only. Thank you Jason Brown. Oh second that. Thank you. Emotion by

0:32:48 Christopher Reed second by Jason Brown to put ordinance number 2023-017 on

0:32:54 third and final reading by title only. Amy Rokal vote please. Craig Hawkins. Yes.

0:33:02 Jason Brown. Yes. Alex Koval. Yes. Enter Cutler. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Chris Reed. Yes.

0:33:10 Yes. And thank you, Boyd. Yes.

0:33:12 Thank you. Motion passes seven to zero.

0:33:15 So I'll read the ordinance.

0:33:17 Ordinance number 2023-017,

0:33:21 an ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho,

0:33:25 amending city code by amending title six, chapter three,

0:33:29 regarding the permitting and keeping of animals.

0:33:34 Chris Reed. Move to approve ordinance 2023-017.

0:33:39 Thank you, Nicky Boyd

0:33:42 Thank you Jason. Did you have something? Okay?

0:33:46 Motion to approve ordinance 2023-017 was made by Chris Reed second by Nicky Boyd

0:33:53 Amy Rokal vote, please

0:33:58 Jason Brown. Yes

0:34:00 Alex Cabal yes, Center Cutler. Yes, Ruth Pierce. Yes. Yes. Yes. Thank you Boyd. Yes, and Craig Hawkins. Yes

0:34:08 Thank you motion passes

0:34:10 Thank you Mitch.

0:34:14 Next item on the agenda is an action item.

0:34:17 It's considered a recommendation from the Parks and Recreation Commission to grant Chabani

0:34:23 naming rights to a sub-element of a trailhead located at Poleyde and Eastland in recognition

0:34:31 of their significant donation and we have Wendy Davis Parks and Recreation Director.

0:34:37 Welcome Wendy.

0:34:38 Good evening, Mayor and Council.

0:34:39 I want to make this as uncomplicated as possible.

0:34:44 We haven't done a lot of naming rights,

0:34:47 and I don't know if some of you have even

0:34:51 had the conversation about one.

0:34:54 But essentially the policy reads that if someone

0:34:59 wants to submit a name that it would come to staff,

0:35:02 go through the Parks and Recreation Commission,

0:35:04 and then there's certain criteria that we would take

0:35:07 into consideration to determine the appropriateness

0:35:12 of the naming and the name.

0:35:16 So because we're on kind of a short timeline,

0:35:20 Anne Chabani would like to get approval for the naming rights

0:35:26 before the end of the year, I'm here to just talk in concept

0:35:31 on the potential to name, and then we'll come back

0:35:34 and talk about the name later.

0:35:36 So I'm splitting this in a way that we wouldn't normally split it,

0:35:39 because typically we would come forward with recommendation saying,

0:35:42 we believe this meets the criteria,

0:35:44 and therefore we would recommend this name be placed on this space.

0:35:48 So with that, we're really just looking at the criteria of what is a significant donation

0:35:57 and does these, or contribution,

0:36:00 and is this contribution significant enough

0:36:03 to warrant naming rights?

0:36:08 The way we kind of walked through this

0:36:10 and the way we figured it out,

0:36:11 you guys have seen the plan for this park.

0:36:14 And the plan that you've seen is pretty much

0:36:16 the area we're talking about.

0:36:18 The entire three acres has an access road

0:36:22 into the parking lot, some water retention, a restroom

0:36:26 and an activity area that would include the adult,

0:36:33 not necessarily adult, but a fitness space, open area

0:36:37 for classes and different things,

0:36:40 and some water-wise plantings and all of that.

0:36:44 And if we were to kind of separate those two areas out

0:36:47 into that activity zone, the $500,000 donation

0:36:53 can probably make that happen.

0:36:54 the overall park estimates, and it was rough,

0:37:02 landed at about 1.2 million for the whole park.

0:37:05 And this area, we believe, a $500,000 donation

0:37:10 would be a significant contribution

0:37:12 toward the development, if not covering it completely.

0:37:15 And therefore, the commission believes that the sub-element,

0:37:20 which is the activity space, could be granted naming rights

0:37:24 based on the significance of the donation.

0:37:27 So that's the question, do you agree that a $500,000

0:37:33 nation is significant enough to warrant naming of a sub-element

0:37:37 as described in the policy?

0:37:39 And I highlighted those two for you.

0:37:40 But essentially, it says that organization

0:37:43 has made a significant land monetary or service contribution

0:37:46 to the acquisition of property, park system,

0:37:48 or the community in general.

0:37:50 And on number five, it describes the opportunity

0:37:55 to name a sub-element within a park,

0:37:57 which would be similar to what happened at Sunway,

0:38:01 similar to, and the example in this policy

0:38:05 was before Sunway, but it talks about Carter Gibb Field

0:38:08 at Frontier.

0:38:10 So we have done this in the past

0:38:12 where there's a space that gets named

0:38:15 within a larger park area.

0:38:17 So the trailhead park name would be something,

0:38:20 And then this would be a space within that, if that makes sense.

0:38:24 And then I kind of showed you on attachment

0:38:27 the two spaces to show kind of the parking lot area,

0:38:31 and then the area we're talking about for Chobani.

0:38:34 So with that, I think I'll stop and see if you guys

0:38:36 have any questions.

0:38:37 Jason Brown.

0:38:39 Yeah, Wendy.

0:38:40 So I mean, we've done something like this prior as a city

0:38:44 as a loud first feta is the one that comes to mind.

0:38:47 You gave some other examples.

0:38:50 So really, I think the money is a part of it,

0:38:56 but it looks like is this something

0:38:57 that we want for the community?

0:39:00 Chibani has donated a portion of money.

0:39:04 I don't know what other amounts we have received

0:39:07 for Frontier Park or anything like that in the past.

0:39:11 I think, personally, I'm okay with it,

0:39:14 but the money is, it's kind of hard to say,

0:39:20 My 100,000 is not equal to that.

0:39:23 I think what to me, to me, we're looking at,

0:39:26 are we comfortable with Chobani putting that label?

0:39:30 The money is appreciated because it's

0:39:33 helped us get to this point.

0:39:35 But I'd like to make sure, I think to me, the request really

0:39:38 becomes, are we OK with having Chobani named this specific?

0:39:43 I'm comfortable with it, I guess.

0:39:44 But to me, I just, money is one of those things

0:39:49 that if we're basing everything on the amount of contribution,

0:39:52 I think we set ourselves up a little bit.

0:39:56 And that's always difficult, right?

0:39:58 And when you say a significant donation,

0:40:00 then it's what is significant mean.

0:40:02 And so in this case, earlier, the Parks and Recreation Commission

0:40:06 wrestled with this a little bit.

0:40:08 And their basic sense was that significant would mean you build it.

0:40:12 And the donation would need to be significant enough to build it.

0:40:19 And that's kind of where we landed,

0:40:21 and that's where we came back with this.

0:40:24 So I think truly the question isn't right now

0:40:29 do we want Shobami to name it,

0:40:31 but do we believe that that is a significant enough donation

0:40:35 to grant them naming rights to come back later

0:40:38 with a proposed name?

0:40:42 I just meant to color.

0:40:44 My primary concern is just the fact that the intent

0:40:47 is it's permanent.

0:40:48 Now, I realize this is a policy, not an ordinance,

0:40:51 And the language gives some of the room.

0:40:53 It says the intention that it will be permanent,

0:40:58 changes should be strongly resisted.

0:41:00 So really legally it sounds like we could do what we want,

0:41:04 or future council could do what they want.

0:41:07 But I think the most of us want to be genuine and sincere

0:41:10 what we do.

0:41:11 And that's my primary concern is that it's forever.

0:41:16 And I'm thinking 20 years down the road,

0:41:18 if a company makes a donation and they're

0:41:22 still in our community 20 years later, you know, does that mean that there's kind of this

0:41:25 expectation that the facility they name takes priority for maintenance, you know, if we have

0:41:30 limited resources and I could go on with, you know, a dozen other examples and I kind of

0:41:34 just wanted to ask my other council members, is that a hang up for you or not?

0:41:42 So if I understand the way this has worked in the past, let's use first federal as an example.

0:41:49 Well, is that not a good example?

0:41:52 I mean, in theory...

0:41:55 I don't know if that name went through the process.

0:41:57 I think my understanding was that they donated the space and they put aside.

0:42:01 They did donate.

0:42:02 So, but in the maintenance question, we take things as they come in,

0:42:08 the highest priority gets priority regardless of who named it, correct?

0:42:13 Is that's I think kind of what you're asking is...

0:42:17 That's what I would hope would happen, but human beings can be influenced and maybe we

0:42:28 feel...

0:42:29 Yeah, so one of the unique partnerships that we have with some of the individuals who have

0:42:33 made contributions to the park is that they continue to help offset the cost of the maintenance

0:42:39 of the park and the facilities and we're engaged in conversations with the first federal right

0:42:43 now where it sounds like they're going to continue to be a partner in helping maintain

0:42:49 that facility moving forward.

0:42:53 There is oftentimes, I think, Councilman, what you're getting to is when a company is going

0:42:59 to lend their name to a facility, they may have an expectation that we have a level of

0:43:08 maintenance that might be higher than what the city can typically deliver and in

0:43:16 those cases we've had good partnerships and good conversations to say this is

0:43:21 our ability this is what we can do if there's a higher level of service that

0:43:26 you would like how can we help partner with you to see that happen and we're

0:43:32 starting to have those conversations now with First Federal and we'll look at

0:43:36 having other conversations moving forward because you're right, we need to take a look

0:43:44 at the entirety of the park system and apply our scarce resources blindly to the parks that

0:43:53 have the highest needs.

0:43:54 That's kind of what I was getting at.

0:43:57 So, okay, Nicky Boyd.

0:44:00 Yes, I'm having a question.

0:44:03 I don't want to make the assumption that they would name it the Chobani, blah, blah, blah,

0:44:10 work out park or whatever it is.

0:44:13 They would also have the right to name it after a person.

0:44:18 That's very important to their company.

0:44:23 They would have to come before the park's mission and go through this naming and it would

0:44:31 have to be approved by that by that before it would come to you and it would come

0:44:37 to the council so it would have to go through to so there would be a lot of

0:44:41 discussion so but our vote tonight is saying that yes they have the naming

0:44:49 right yes and ultimately it kind of hinges on the donations so obviously

0:44:57 they want to make the donation with the expectation that they can name correct

0:45:02 but their name still what they're going to choose potentially could be a lot of

0:45:08 different things and it still has to meet our criteria. I can't really remember

0:45:13 all the naming things and we don't need to go into that but it would be

0:45:17 screened twice right okay yeah yeah and you'll hear it again I mean it'll come

0:45:23 as a recommendation to the Council of what they want the name to be and you

0:45:28 you would have the ultimate decision on the name.

0:45:34 Great, Hawkins.

0:45:35 I guess, have you been in meeting with Wendy and so forth?

0:45:39 I feel comfortable with it.

0:45:41 I think it's definitely a sizable donation

0:45:44 and feel good about them having the naming rights

0:45:47 as far as that goes.

0:45:48 And then the second half of that is,

0:45:51 we'll come before the commission again,

0:45:53 and then finally City Council for the final name.

0:45:56 I don't have any problem with that.

0:45:59 Alex Kaval.

0:46:00 I'm right up there with Craig.

0:46:02 I don't necessarily have a problem with the request,

0:46:04 but I do think in light of the discussion we had

0:46:06 with respect to maintenance,

0:46:07 it's probably a good opportunity to start that conversation

0:46:11 about what their expectations are on the maintenance side

0:46:15 so that there's no,

0:46:18 even minimize the unforeseen issues.

0:46:20 I think it would be smart to have to start that conversation

0:46:24 at the same time that we're doing this

0:46:26 if we're gonna do that.

0:46:27 The overall concept, I don't have a problem with it.

0:46:33 I'll make the motion. I just want to make a comment. Shabani's been a great community player and we really do appreciate that contribution. I really do.

0:46:44 naming rights or not. We appreciate that contribution. Thank you, Chris. Yeah, I

0:46:50 go ahead with the Mayor said so I move that we approve the recommendation from

0:46:54 the Parks and Rec Commission to grant Chobani naming rights to a sub element

0:46:59 of the trail had located at Pole Line and Eastland in recognition of their

0:47:03 significant donation. Thank you, Craig Hawkins. Second. Thank you. Motion by

0:47:08 by Chris Reed, seconded by Craig Hawkins,

0:47:11 to approve the Parks and Recmissions Recommendation.

0:47:18 You moved that, sorry.

0:47:20 You covered it up.

0:47:21 You did.

0:47:22 Recommendation to Grant Chabani,

0:47:25 naming rise to a sub-element of the trailhead

0:47:28 located at Pole Line in Eastland

0:47:30 in recognition of their significant donation.

0:47:35 Amy Rokalvo, please.

0:47:38 Yes, Spencer Cutler. Yes, Ruth Pierce. Yes, Chris Reed. Yes. Thank you, Boyd. Yes. Great.

0:47:46 Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you,

0:47:52 Bonnie. Next item on the agenda. Hang on. Is an action item. It's a request to adopt

0:48:02 ordinance number 2023 for 0 0 8 for the vacation of the East

0:48:09 meant at property located at two oh nine two dozen drive and we have

0:48:14 Jonathan skin love our planning and zoning director welcome Jonathan thank

0:48:18 you mere members of the council so please forgive me have the next three items

0:48:21 they're all ordinances so we're gonna get that process down really well by the

0:48:25 third one the numbering is also a little bit non-insequential that's I noticed

0:48:31 that. Sorry about that. The explanation on this first one is the original

0:48:35 ordinance we passed back this summer had the wrong paperwork with it. Essentially

0:48:45 we had vacating one and dedicating another thing and the easements got swapped in

0:48:51 the paperwork and we didn't realize those easements were swapped until we

0:48:54 went to record it and then we were going oh no. So this is an amended

0:48:58 Ordinance number 2023008 and it is vacating the easement on the plat up there

0:49:05 for the there's a surgery center that's looking to go in there and they need to

0:49:09 vacate the stormwater easement which was platted as part of the plat. What we're

0:49:15 doing is just reaffirming that decision so we can record the correct

0:49:20 vacation was what was actually recorded was the new easement that they

0:49:25 dedicated so we vacated something that didn't exist and I'll stand for any

0:49:32 questions the normal procedure for

0:49:35 or in final yeah third and final I don't know if you need me to read any of them I

0:49:39 have those so we did approve that in October of 2023 I have the old ordinance

0:49:46 in front of me so any just questions for Jonathan so our first amendment the

0:49:53 The first motion needs to be for third and final, Chris Reed.

0:49:58 I move we dispense with the reading rules and play and put ordinance 2023-008 on third and final reading by title only.

0:50:08 Thank you. Do we have a second? Jason Brown?

0:50:10 Second.

0:50:11 Thank you. Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Jason Brown to put amended ordinance 2023-008 on third and final reading by title only.

0:50:23 only by suspending the rules.

0:50:25 Amy Roll, call vote please.

0:50:29 Spencer Cutler.

0:50:30 Yes.

0:50:31 Ruth Pierce.

0:50:32 Yes.

0:50:32 Chris Reed.

0:50:33 Yes.

0:50:33 Nikki Boyd.

0:50:34 Yes.

0:50:35 Ray Cawkins.

0:50:35 Yes.

0:50:36 Jason Brown.

0:50:37 Yes.

0:50:37 And Alex Kaval.

0:50:38 Yes.

0:50:39 Thank you.

0:50:39 Motion passes 7 to 0.

0:50:42 So I need a Chris Reed.

0:50:43 You want to go ahead?

0:50:44 You're still up.

0:50:45 I mean, you need to read it.

0:50:46 Oh, yes, I do.

0:50:47 Thank you.

0:50:48 An ordinance of the mayor and the city council

0:50:51 of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho,

0:50:54 indicating the easement described below.

0:50:57 Now, Chris Reed.

0:50:59 Move to approve adopted ordinance 2023-008.

0:51:05 Craig Hawkins.

0:51:06 I second.

0:51:07 Thank you.

0:51:08 Motion by Chris Reed.

0:51:09 Second by Craig Hawkins.

0:51:10 To adopt amended ordinance 2023-008.

0:51:13 Amy Roek, I'll vote please.

0:51:17 Ruth Piers.

0:51:18 Yes.

0:51:19 Chris Reed.

0:51:20 Yes.

0:51:21 Sneaky Boyd.

0:51:22 Yes.

0:51:23 Craig Hawkins.

0:51:24 Yes.

0:51:25 Yes, Mr. Cutler?

0:51:27 Yes.

0:51:29 Is that it?

0:51:33 Motion passes seven to zero.

0:51:35 OK, next item is an action item.

0:51:39 Request to adopt ordinance 2023-016 for the rezoning of property

0:51:45 located at 1301 11th Avenue East.

0:51:50 Jonathan, thank you for that.

0:51:52 I'll be sure that I'm off for you.

0:51:53 You will be.

0:51:54 This one is that a rezone that placed the professional office

0:51:57 overlay on the property that was near the Oasis.

0:52:00 Those dates for the public hearings

0:52:02 were 24th of October for the Planning and Zoning Commission

0:52:05 and the 27th of November per year request

0:52:08 to be rewrote this up and brought it back.

0:52:11 Again, third and final, go through that again.

0:52:16 Thank you.

0:52:17 Nicky Boyd.

0:52:19 Mayor, I move to dispense with reading the rules

0:52:21 and put ordinance number 2023-016 on third and final reading

0:52:26 on 3rd and final reading by title only.

0:52:29 Thank you, Alex Kaval.

0:52:30 I second the motion.

0:52:32 Thank you. Motion by Nicky Boyd,

0:52:33 seconded by Alex Kaval to move.

0:52:39 Sorry. Does Spence with the rules and put Ordinance 2023

0:52:44 on 3rd and final reading by title only, and the Ordinance 016?

0:52:51 016. Okay.

0:52:55 Amy Roll call vote, please.

0:52:57 Nicky Boyd? Yes.

0:53:00 Greg Hawkins, Jason Brown, Alex Cabal, Spencer Cutler, Ruth Pierce, and Chris Reeb.

0:53:07 Yes.

0:53:08 Thank you.

0:53:09 Motion passes 7-0.

0:53:11 Ordinance number 2023-016, an ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls

0:53:17 rezoning certain real property below, described providing the zoning classification, therefore,

0:53:24 in ordering the necessary area of impact

0:53:27 in zoning district map amendments.

0:53:31 Jason Brown.

0:53:32 I'd move to adopt ordinance number 2023-016

0:53:37 for the rezoning of property located at 1301,

0:53:40 11 Avenue East, when falls.

0:53:42 Thank you, Chris Reed.

0:53:44 I'll second.

0:53:45 Thank you.

0:53:46 Motion by Chris, or Jason Brown seconded by Chris Reed

0:53:49 to adopt ordinance 2023-016.

0:53:53 Amy Roll call vote please.

0:53:57 Yes.

0:53:59 Jason Brown.

0:53:59 Yes.

0:54:00 Alex Cabal.

0:54:01 Yes.

0:54:02 Mr. Cutler.

0:54:03 Yes.

0:54:04 Bruce Pierce.

0:54:05 Yes.

0:54:06 Bruce Reed.

0:54:07 Yes.

0:54:08 Thank you.

0:54:09 Motion passes 7-0.

0:54:10 Okay.

0:54:11 Next item, action item, a request to adopt Ordinance 2023-015 for the rezoning of property

0:54:21 located at 209 Washington Street North.

0:54:26 This item, Mayor and Council, was for the reason

0:54:29 that went from C1 to R6 Pro for that property that was brought

0:54:33 forward by Friend Florence and his group 24th of October

0:54:37 of this year for the Punning and Zoning Commission

0:54:39 and the 27th of November for this body.

0:54:42 And again, a certain final.

0:54:45 Thank you.

0:54:46 Mr. Cutler.

0:54:47 I'm sorry, Jonathan, a quick question.

0:54:49 I didn't get a chance to double check this one.

0:54:51 Is this the one where there's currently an insurance business?

0:54:54 That's right.

0:54:55 Okay.

0:54:56 Thank you.

0:54:57 That is a property.

0:54:58 Okay.

0:55:00 Chris Reed.

0:55:01 I'll make the motion if we're ready.

0:55:02 Move that we dispense with the reading rules and put Ordinance 2023-015 on third and final by title only.

0:55:09 Thank you, Alex Cavalle.

0:55:11 No second.

0:55:12 Thank you.

0:55:13 Motion by Chris Reed.

0:55:14 Second by Alex Cavalle to put Ordinance 2023-015 on third and final reading by suspending the

0:55:21 by suspending the rules by title only.

0:55:24 Amy Rokalvo, please.

0:55:28 Alex Cabal.

0:55:29 Yes.

0:55:30 Spencer Cutler.

0:55:31 Yes.

0:55:32 Ruth Pierce.

0:55:32 Yes.

0:55:33 Chris Reed.

0:55:34 Yes.

0:55:34 Thank you, Boyd.

0:55:35 Yes.

0:55:35 Greg Hawkins.

0:55:36 Yes.

0:55:37 And Jason Brown.

0:55:37 Yes.

0:55:38 Thank you.

0:55:39 Motion passes seven to zero.

0:55:41 So ordinance number 2023-015, an ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho,

0:55:50 rezoning certain real property below described, providing the zoning classification therefore

0:55:57 and ordering the necessary herb impact and zoning district map amendments. Jason Brown.

0:56:03 I'd move to adopt ordinance 2023-015 for the rezoning of property located at 209 Washington

0:56:12 Street North. Thank you, Chris Reed. Second. Thank you. Motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Chris Reed

0:56:18 to adopt Ordinance 2023-015.

0:56:23 Amy Rokavo, please.

0:56:26 Bents are colored.

0:56:28 Yes.

0:56:28 Ruth Pierce.

0:56:29 Yes.

0:56:30 Chris Reed.

0:56:31 Yes.

0:56:32 Thank you, Boyd.

0:56:33 Yes.

0:56:34 Craig Hawkins.

0:56:35 Yes.

0:56:36 Jason Brown.

0:56:37 Yes.

0:56:38 And Alex Cabal.

0:56:39 Yes.

0:56:40 Thank you.

0:56:41 Motion passes 7-0.

0:56:42 Thank you, Jonathan.

0:56:43 Next item on the agenda is an action item.

0:56:44 It's a request to approve an amendment to a memorandum of understanding

0:56:49 between the City of Twin Falls and Catherine Strong regarding shared access to her property

0:56:55 at 2.007 Pole Light and Road East. And we have Mitch Humboldt. Welcome Mitch.

0:57:02 I think probably most of us are familiar with this property. So in the red box up there is

0:57:31 a house that was built back into 2003 at the time when it was built. It was built by Mr.

0:57:40 Blass. He also owned the long blue box, and the city at the time had an interest in connecting

0:57:48 the Canyon Rim Trail that dead ends at that house, somehow to get out to a street. And so

0:57:54 we negotiated with Mr. Blass at the time to purchase the blue property so that we can make

0:58:00 a trail connection down to Poline Road. And then we adopted a memorandum of

0:58:07 understanding with him at the time, and that trail connection would also

0:58:12 double as a private driveway for the house. And so that's about a 26-foot-wide

0:58:19 pavement. Half of it is, not really half of it, a portion of it is striped as kind

0:58:24 of a trail, and then a portion of it is striped as the driveway access to the home.

0:58:28 And so at the time the agreement that we had or the memorandum understanding that we had with Mr.

0:58:34 Blass was he'll sell us that property, we'll build the driveway on it in the trail so that we can connect the trail out to the street.

0:58:42 And then we would maintain it as a trail and then they would use it as a private driveway for the house.

0:58:47 And that has existed for the last 20 years.

0:58:50 Mr. Blass has sold his interest in the house.

0:58:56 It's now owned by Catherine Strong.

0:59:01 Several months ago, Miss Strong made an application

0:59:03 for zoning and annexation of the property to rezone it

0:59:08 to like a commercial purpose.

0:59:10 And the time the city was not supportive of that zoning

0:59:14 because the access to the property was

0:59:17 for a private residential driveway,

0:59:19 not for a commercial type use.

0:59:21 And so at the time, they withdrew that application

0:59:24 for rezoning and annexation,

0:59:26 not having support from the city.

0:59:28 And then following that action,

0:59:30 I would draw, you started negotiating

0:59:33 for what is before you tonight.

0:59:35 And that would be simply to change the access

0:59:39 from private residential driveway

0:59:42 to commercial public kind of access,

0:59:47 with the condition that at some point

0:59:49 the future that actually changes use to a commercial type use because that it still is a house and

0:59:58 unless that use changes we don't need to change the access to commercial access and so there's a

1:00:03 clause in this mou that sort of talks about that you know subject to the rezone actually happening

1:00:09 then these conditions will will kick in and so there's an amendment to the 2003 mou

1:00:17 and it's got a few different things going on there. One would be this this

1:00:23 changed access so no longer would it be assuming the zoning request happens and

1:00:29 actually it's approved and the use changes to a commercial use then the

1:00:34 MOU would allow across the city's property the applicant to access with

1:00:40 commercial type access to the property. In exchange for that commercial access

1:00:44 to the property. The burden of maintenance for the driveway would shift to the business

1:00:51 and away from the city. The theory behind that is that we have pedestrian walkers and

1:00:56 a few cars every now and then and our maintenance is for that kind of activity whereas a commercial

1:01:03 activity would increase the activity and potentially maybe quicker degrade the roadway

1:01:10 for access and so it makes sense for the burden that we shifted to the business

1:01:14 use and so that's kind of the gist of it there are some other clauses in there

1:01:20 that talk about you know our use of that easement you can see that there's some

1:01:27 property next door that we may need to use to get back in there there's

1:01:30 utilities that may be under this roadway we still want to be able to use it for

1:01:34 the trail and there's another piece in the MOU that talks about if we grant

1:01:41 future commercial access to another user then that user and Ms. Strong would

1:01:48 kind of renegotiate the or share the burden of maintenance as there's more

1:01:53 than one business now using it. I don't know that that will happen on the chance

1:01:58 that it could happen. We put that in the agreement as well and so if the Council

1:02:04 approves this MOU amendment tonight and that would kind of open the door for

1:02:10 another annexation zoning request and then future kind of discussions about

1:02:15 should the zoning change or not change. Those future decisions were not

1:02:21 obligating ourselves to anything tonight with this only opening the door to make

1:02:27 that request later. And then there's one other thing I see. I had our legal department review

1:02:35 the amendment and they got back to me. There's one very minor change from the one that's in your

1:02:41 packet. The first whereas statement in this updated MOU indicates that Todd Blass sold his

1:02:48 interest to Catherine Strong. That's not totally accurate. There's some people in between there.

1:02:52 So I have a new version that's also signed from a strong tonight that is, he sold his interest and now she owns an interest.

1:03:01 But there's not a direct link between them just so that it's accurate.

1:03:04 So with that minor tweak from the one that's in the packet, that's what we'd recommend for you guys to consider tonight.

1:03:13 And there's a lot to unpack in here, so I understand if there's going to be questions.

1:03:18 And Ms. Strong is here, Gerald Martins is helping represent her on this.

1:03:25 And so they both are available to ask questions if you have any.

1:03:28 I also can answer some questions if you have any.

1:03:31 And so with that, I'll just kind of pause and see if you guys want to ask anything.

1:03:36 Questions for Mitch or anyone else?

1:03:41 Any discussion?

1:03:48 Okay.

1:03:55 Okay. Someone like to make a motion?

1:03:58 Jason Brown.

1:03:59 I'll make a move motion to approve an amended amendment to a memorandum of

1:04:06 understanding between the City of Twin Falls and Catherine Strong regarding

1:04:09 shared access to a property located at 2007 Pull Line Road East. Thank you. Do I

1:04:16 have a second? Second. Thank you. Motion by Jason Brown seconded by Craig Hawkins

1:04:22 to approve an amendment to MOU between the City of Twin Falls and Catherine

1:04:27 strong regarding shared access to her property at two zero zero seven

1:04:32 pole line road east any other discussion Amy Roel call vote please

1:04:41 Ruth Pierce yes Chris Reed yes Ciki Boyd yes Greg Hawkins yes Jason Brown

1:04:48 yes Alex Koval yes and Spencer Kepler yes thank you motion passes seven to zero

1:04:55 Okay. Thank you. Next item on the agenda is a request to approve an impact fee agreement

1:05:05 between the City of Twin Falls and TENSCO, Inc. regarding the development of eastern

1:05:11 sun subdivision numbers one and two and we have a chumble again. Okay. I'm feeling pretty

1:05:21 when we finish with this one, you won't have to listen to me anymore tonight.

1:05:25 Cool.

1:05:26 This is something that we haven't done before, and so it'll be new for us,

1:05:33 but I'm kind of excited to move through this process with you guys.

1:05:39 We've had impact fees in place since 2009, and we've not ever had an impact

1:05:45 fee agreement come before the council, and so this will take a little bit of explanation,

1:05:50 I think it's fairly straightforward. What you have on your screen here is a map of the Eastern Sun

1:05:56 subdivisions. There's plural there. So number one is actually the red box that's kind of right in the

1:06:04 middle there is the potential parks that we're talking about. That's on the corner of Hankins Road

1:06:09 in Elizabeth Boulevard. So for those of you who are trying to orient yourselves, that's where we're at.

1:06:13 But the south part of the subdivision south of Elizabeth is eastern Sun subdivision number

1:06:21 one.

1:06:22 The north side of Elizabeth, Little of Art is eastern Sun subdivision number two.

1:06:28 Between these two subdivisions there's about 500 potential lots coming into this area.

1:06:35 You notice right across the street we have several subdivisions with Sapphire Drive and

1:06:39 Ruby and Denise and all those the streets over there that are underserved

1:06:43 from a neighborhood park currently and so this location was identified by the

1:06:51 Parks and Rec Department and the zoning department kind of helped out with this

1:06:54 conversation early on in these plots and we started negotiating with the

1:07:00 developer Tinsco for this park acquisition using park impact fees and the

1:07:07 location was picked so that it would serve this neighborhood as well as the

1:07:11 existing neighborhoods on the other side of Hankins that are underserved

1:07:14 currently. So we got to the point where we've got this four-acre park being shown

1:07:20 in the eastern Sun subdivision number two phase one and we're proceeding with

1:07:26 this subdivision is moving along they're about ready to get some final

1:07:32 acceptance and we should start seeing permits being requested in south of

1:07:36 Elizabeth Boulevard and so we thought the timing was right to get this

1:07:40 improvement or this agreement done. So in the negotiations the developer provided

1:07:48 an appraisal for the land value and the four acres of land came at $360,000 worth

1:07:55 of value. The developer also provided their bid tabulations for the work that's

1:08:02 being done specifically in this case would be the work in the streets directly adjacent

1:08:09 to the park and the streets being half of Hankins Road and half of Elizabeth Boulevard

1:08:15 for their adjacency to the park and the cost of that is $580,407 and so the acquisition

1:08:32 of the property, including the land value and the value of the street construction, there's

1:08:37 going to be $940,407 for those four acres of park land.

1:08:44 The, I think I have to say this, the $580,000 of that value is for the, primarily for the

1:08:56 construction value of the intersection improvements at Hankins and Elizabeth.

1:09:01 Therefore, I'm going to make the recommendation that we use street impact fees for that portion

1:09:08 of the value, since that's what we're collecting street impact fees for intersections of arterials

1:09:13 and collectors.

1:09:14 This is exactly one of those.

1:09:16 The value of the park land, the $360,000, is why we collect park impact fees, and so I'm

1:09:23 going to make the recommendation that we use park impact fees to collect, to pay back the

1:09:27 $360,000.

1:09:29 So with street impact fees, we have the money in the bank today.

1:09:36 The recommendation or the agreement is written to say that when the property changes hands,

1:09:41 we'll write a check for the $580,000 of street impact fee portion at that time.

1:09:47 The agreement also says that the park will change hands at the time that the phase, including

1:09:53 the park, is final accepted by the city.

1:09:56 why that's important is we've got an obligation to start planting some grass and growing some

1:10:00 grass.

1:10:01 We need water infrastructure, irrigation water infrastructure so that we can do that.

1:10:06 Once we accept those improvements to that section, we know we've got the water available to do

1:10:12 that.

1:10:13 And so, I don't know what the exact timing of that is, but I imagine it's incoming in

1:10:17 the next year-ish or so.

1:10:21 When that acceptance happens, the developer will deed the property to the city.

1:10:25 The city will pay the $580,000, and the city will have a years time from that point forward

1:10:31 to put the grass in on the property so we don't have kind of a mud pit at the entrance to the

1:10:35 subdivision.

1:10:36 So all of that is in this agreement, trying to think if there's anything else, the payment

1:10:42 of the impact fees for the value of the land of $360,000.

1:10:47 We will start collecting park impact fees from each one of these homes as they come in

1:10:52 with their building permits.

1:10:55 What this agreement says is quarterly,

1:10:58 we will take those funds and make payments

1:11:00 to the developer toward that $360,000 until it's paid off.

1:11:05 There's also an inclusion in there that says

1:11:06 if we want to pay it off earlier,

1:11:08 we can use our impact fees from other places

1:11:10 and just pay it off quicker if we decide to do that.

1:11:14 But the payment method, the quarterly payment method

1:11:16 is what is expected in there.

1:11:18 So, this would get us the land, the streets adjacent to the land, and then we will be responsible

1:11:26 for putting the grass and the irrigation to start that park construction when that final

1:11:32 acceptance is given for the property.

1:11:34 I believe that's the gist of it.

1:11:38 The developer's Tinsco.

1:11:39 Tinsco is represented by Gerald Martin's.

1:11:41 He's here also tonight.

1:11:44 We can both answer your questions if you have any, but I think that pretty well sums up

1:11:48 that just this agreement so if you have any questions just start firing.

1:11:52 Thank you Nick, good boy.

1:11:53 Mitch, is this the first one we've done like this where, okay, since we

1:11:59 changed our code about a year and a half ago two years ago, yeah this is the first

1:12:02 one to come in since then. I'm really excited about this because way back when

1:12:06 I was on Parks and Rec this was something that was

1:12:09 discussed and decided hey this would be a better way to do things in the future

1:12:15 And here it comes down the pike.

1:12:19 And so I'm excited to see.

1:12:21 If it actually is better.

1:12:22 No.

1:12:23 No.

1:12:25 I'm excited to see that.

1:12:26 I was going to say that.

1:12:29 But yeah, to see if it is actually better.

1:12:32 Because it gets to be strategically placed where we want a part to be.

1:12:38 All right.

1:12:39 So now my next question in this is,

1:12:43 that's a lot of park impact fees

1:12:48 that have to come in before the city can actually build.

1:12:55 In our somewhat crazy world we live in,

1:12:59 where these are developed,

1:13:01 all this stuff is ready to go.

1:13:04 You know, lots of screwy things are going on

1:13:07 and our community is doing great.

1:13:09 It looks like we're going to rebuild these houses,

1:13:12 but there's no guarantee.

1:13:14 I mean, we've looked at radical drop in building permits

1:13:17 and all these things.

1:13:18 So we have one year, make that not a mud pit,

1:13:26 but if the housing market dries up,

1:13:31 how long do we have to convert the mud pit?

1:13:33 So we have, we have park impact fees in the bank right now

1:13:39 that we can use to put in the irrigation in the grass.

1:13:42 Not collected from the subdivision,

1:13:44 but in our bank for community in neighboring parks.

1:13:48 Did that make that four acres elitable?

1:13:53 It would make it at least pretty as you drive

1:13:56 into the neighborhood and might help with sales.

1:13:59 It wouldn't necessarily be a fully developed park though,

1:14:01 right?

1:14:02 So you don't have playgrounds and parking lots

1:14:05 and restrooms and those kind of amenities

1:14:07 that we typically see at our parks.

1:14:09 But we don't have the park impact fees in the bank right now enough to pay the 360 and

1:14:16 Then put in the irrigation and grass for the four acres

1:14:19 We probably do to put in the irrigation grass for the four acres

1:14:23 And then we'll make the payments over time and the developer understands that that could take time

1:14:30 We've had that conversation. We're gonna we're gonna improve ground that we don't own

1:14:35 We will not improve it until we own it. It will turn over to the city

1:14:40 at the phase acceptance and then we will own it and then we will start improving it, yep, so we own it but

1:14:49 we are making payments on it. Only after we own it. We don't start making payments until after it's turned out, so we we get

1:14:58 tied a love it with a deferred note basically. All of that kicks in and then we'll just start making the payments as the as

1:15:05 as the permits come in for this neighborhood.

1:15:08 If we get enough to pay it off quicker, we can,

1:15:11 but we want to save the parking back fees

1:15:13 that we have in the bank,

1:15:14 but in the grass and irrigation,

1:15:17 once we take ownership of it.

1:15:19 Okay, Spencer Cutler.

1:15:23 What I like about this is it's an opportunity

1:15:25 to save money on the portion of the road construction costs

1:15:28 that the city is responsible for.

1:15:30 If we were to acquire the land

1:15:32 and later independently,

1:15:34 hire a licensed design professional, put it out to bid, it would cost us more, and so

1:15:39 we're piggybacking this, and it's a good opportunity, so thanks for working on this.

1:15:44 It's not unique, but it's a first, so thank you.

1:15:47 It's the reason why we include, again, the value of the acquisition instead of buying

1:15:51 raw land and building routes, because it's cheaper for us.

1:15:54 Yeah, it absolutely is.

1:15:58 Perfect.

1:15:59 Chris Reed.

1:16:01 As we've had discussions in the last couple of years and why we moved to this form of creating parks, we're not going to have a retention pond anywhere near this.

1:16:12 Well, there's one right across the street.

1:16:15 Across the street.

1:16:16 Okay.

1:16:17 To the south.

1:16:18 So it's not going to be part of this.

1:16:20 But it's not in the park.

1:16:22 Yes.

1:16:23 Perfect.

1:16:24 That was a key point.

1:16:25 And what's also in the agreement is this is currently an active producing farm, right?

1:16:31 So it's got good soil there.

1:16:33 When they develop this, the soil will stay to the degree that it can't not to move a

1:16:38 little bit when they build the road and stuff like that.

1:16:41 But, largely the soil will stay, we should have a pretty good time, pretty easy time to

1:16:45 plain grass on this in the near future.

1:16:48 Wonderful.

1:16:49 Thank you.

1:16:50 Nicky Boy.

1:16:51 Have we beat this up enough or are we working for a...

1:16:53 I think we're good.

1:16:54 Good, you're it.

1:16:58 Mayor, I move that we approve

1:16:59 an impact fee agreement

1:17:01 between the city of Twin Falls and Tinsco, Inc.

1:17:03 regarding the development of Eastern Sub-Sun

1:17:07 subdivision numbers one and two.

1:17:10 Thank you, Jason Brown.

1:17:11 Second.

1:17:12 Thank you, motion by Nicky Boyd, seconded by Jason Brown

1:17:15 to approve the impact fee agreement

1:17:17 between the city of Twin Falls and Tinsco, Inc.

1:17:20 regarding the development of Eastern Sun Sub-Division

1:17:24 members 1 and 2. Amy Roll call vote please. Chris Reed. Yes. Thank you. Boyd. Yes. Craig Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Alex Cabal. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. And Ruth Pierce. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7 to 0. Okay. Next item on the agenda is an action item. It's a request to expand area of impact boundary for three properties near the intersection of Chaplain Way and Kimberly Road.

1:17:55 and we have Jonathan spin love our planning and zoning director welcome Jonathan thank you

1:18:03 mayor members of the council so we received essentially a letter from property owners representing these

1:18:13 this property which is in orange hard to see up there can have to make note that doing orange at

1:18:17 the council doesn't really work um sorry about that there might be a little bit easier to see it

1:18:22 this way. These three properties represented by Gerald Martin's have requested for this area

1:18:29 to be removed from Kimberly City area of impact and to be placed into the Twin Falls City area

1:18:36 of impact. That is a tricky move when it comes to Idaho because we have area of impact agreements

1:18:42 and it becomes a three-party trade so to speak. Kimberly City has to take action to remove it.

1:18:49 we would take action to acquire it and then the county takes a further action to formalize that

1:18:55 agreement to change. What you're looking at tonight is essentially, I come up to my staff report real

1:19:02 fast, is following this Idaho statute and you submit questions to the planning and zoning commission

1:19:11 for a recommendation and your direction should include a reasonable tight line for the commission

1:19:16 make a recommendation. There's not a lot of commentary and Idaho State law if you guys haven't

1:19:21 seen that. So which questions are left for some interpretation and these are the ones that I have

1:19:27 been talking to various people. It basically is which zoning code and which comprehensive plan

1:19:32 should be applied to the area of impact for this area. That's what we've come up with. There's no

1:19:39 solid answer for many judge or legislator quite yet, but those are the two things.

1:19:43 It's basically a recommendation, should we do this in which plan and zoning ordinance should be followed in that area?

1:19:49 So this is the order that you're going to go eventually.

1:19:53 You have the Planning and Zoning Commission make a recommendation. They bring it back to you.

1:19:57 You notify the county of the request to change based on which plans to use.

1:20:02 And then we hold public hearings to get that formalized and then the council and the Board of

1:20:07 commissioners pass ordinances to make that in effect.

1:20:12 It is not super clear in the state code,

1:20:14 but that's as good as we can decipher how it's going to go.

1:20:17 So what you're asking for tonight is directing the Planning

1:20:21 and Zoning Commission, our Planning and Zoning Commission

1:20:23 to give you a recommendation.

1:20:25 And I believe I have a sample, even with a sample date,

1:20:30 if you wish to have that.

1:20:32 We believe we could do that in terms of the staff

1:20:35 have that recommendation back to you and I'll send for any more questions I can

1:20:41 go through the maps but if only if you need to. Questions for Jonathan on this?

1:20:47 Jonathan is that February 5th date the target date that you were asking for or

1:20:55 did you just pull that date? Technically February is not a real month because I

1:20:59 just saw that spelling error right there. Fabulous February.

1:21:04 That's basically the earliest that I believe we can meet that anything earlier than that

1:21:12 with the holiday we would have to kind of put out the paper pretty quick and get that

1:21:16 hearing date set up it's doable by that date and the council can certainly pick whichever

1:21:23 date if it's a public hearing we need about four or five weeks to get it done that's where

1:21:30 And that is the Monday.

1:21:32 Yeah, that would be for your day.

1:21:35 So it would be, you know, the previous one that we could get it finished on, and then you would have it by that day.

1:21:39 Perfect.

1:21:40 That's not going to require for that portion of it.

1:21:42 That's not going to require public hearing, is it?

1:21:45 Kimberly did theirs that way.

1:21:49 Nothing in here requires it talks about notification.

1:21:53 I would do it just to be safe.

1:21:55 Is it required statutes kind of silent on it?

1:21:59 I'd rather be safe

1:22:03 Chris read I'm ready for a motion. Okay. Scroll back up. Thank you

1:22:09 I move to direct the planning and zoning Commission to consider this request as

1:22:14 Presented of three properties near the intersection of Chaplin Way and Kimberly Road

1:22:21 Or an expansion expansion of the area of impact and delivered the recommendation to the city council by

1:22:28 February 5th

1:22:30 Thank you, Alex Koval. I'll second the motion. Thank you a motion by Chris Reed second by Alex Koval to

1:22:39 approve the request to expand that area of impact boundaries for three properties and

1:22:46 direct planning and zoning commission to consider this request for an expanded area of impact and

1:22:52 delivering the recommendation to City Council by February 5th, 2024. Any further discussion?

1:22:58 Thank you.

1:22:59 Thank you.

1:23:00 Thank you.

1:23:02 Amy Roll call vote please.

1:23:03 Nicky Boyd.

1:23:04 Yes.

1:23:05 Greg Hawkins.

1:23:06 Yes.

1:23:07 Aisud Brown.

1:23:08 Alex Cabal.

1:23:09 Yes.

1:23:10 Spencer Cutler.

1:23:11 Yes.

1:23:12 Ruth Pierce.

1:23:13 Yes.

1:23:14 Yes.

1:23:15 Yes.

1:23:16 Thank you.

1:23:17 Motion passes seven to zero.

1:23:18 Okay.

1:23:19 Our last action item, a review and action on the impact fee yearly report and the automatic impact fee increase scheduled January 1, 2024.

1:23:27 And we have William Clayver, our senior planner.

1:23:30 Welcome, William.

1:23:32 Thank you.

1:23:34 Good evening.

1:23:37 So today we have two things before you and one item.

1:23:42 One is the review of the impact fee report.

1:23:46 And then the last little half will

1:23:48 be the impact fee increase, if it

1:23:51 should be increased in a recommendation on that.

1:23:55 per idle statue, we need to go over this financial report detailing how the expenditures

1:24:04 have happened. The expenditures from this past year include $415,701 in streets, which include

1:24:13 construction of portions of Filer Avenue East, and can drive north along city-owned parcels,

1:24:20 $81,067 in parks, which includes a new prefab restroom at Eastland and Pole Line Trailhead

1:24:31 and purchasing the land for the expansion of Vista Bonita Park near the new fire station

1:24:36 number three location.

1:24:38 And finally $647,87, $647,875 in fire for payments for a payment toward the new fire station

1:24:49 to located at Chaney Drive.

1:24:54 The current key, sorry, my, my,

1:24:59 Tung is tied.

1:25:00 Yes, it's been a long day.

1:25:03 The current fee schedule was adjusted in April, 2023.

1:25:08 And we need to continually increase our fees

1:25:14 to stay up with inflation.

1:25:16 That way the impact to the city budget

1:25:19 minimal and we can stay current and make sure that items such as this part that we

1:25:24 talked about recently get this funded and is approved. So the MCI is the

1:25:38 municipal cost index which talks about how much prices have cost have grown

1:25:45 every year. We have October 22 to October 23 to 3 numbers which increased 1.38%

1:25:54 that is kind of the most current number that we have at this point. November

1:26:00 numbers come out at the end of December. We don't anticipate too much of a

1:26:06 change into that 1.38% so we think the 1.38% would cover it. That

1:26:14 that correlates to about $65 increase to the impact fees per residence for a single

1:26:22 family home. On November 2nd, 2023, the Impact Fee Committee met and discussed the MCI increase

1:26:35 of 1.38 and found it acceptable by about 6 to 0. Now it's up to the council to decide

1:26:45 if that yearly increase or that 1.38% increase is acceptable or if we need

1:26:53 to go higher or lower what you see fit.

1:26:59 But staff sees the 1.38% to be what we need to do.

1:27:04 With that I stand for any.

1:27:07 Thank you, Alex.

1:27:10 Why are we doing two increases in one year?

1:27:12 Why aren't we doing this or looking at this next year or a year

1:27:15 from the last increase.

1:27:17 Yeah, from my understanding, we started this process at the beginning of last year and

1:27:24 it just we got behind and so that was our yearly increase from the previous years and

1:27:33 so we are doing it at the same time as just we don't want to push it back any further

1:27:39 to fall on past, uh, last, uh, lowness, I guess, uh, so we don't want to fall behind

1:27:49 like we did last year.

1:27:50 So you're saying it was last year, it was effective one when, but we didn't figure it

1:27:56 out till later, right?

1:27:58 Wasn't that how we went?

1:27:59 Jonathan?

1:28:00 Well, it wasn't here for that one, so I, you know, the meeting actually took place in February

1:28:05 and we put a month or two ahead.

1:28:08 That increase was much larger and we had to do the public hearing, so that was part of

1:28:12 that it went beyond 5% so we did the public hearing in January, February, with a couple

1:28:17 months in advance because the increase was so large, so we did an April 1st implementation.

1:28:24 So typically our goal is to do it at this time every year, to be effective January 1.

1:28:31 Correct.

1:28:32 Or as a member it is we can change it.

1:28:34 Yeah.

1:28:35 Was there and Jonathan was there another we did that in February of last year you're

1:28:41 Yeah, and the year before that we actually modified the capital improvements list which created all the projects. That was a large increase as well.

1:28:51 Right. So it seemed like there was a large increase then there was just a short period of time and then we had to have we did over 5% or more than 5% and so now.

1:29:07 This is more I say normal if we're living in normal times now. This is more normal

1:29:14 Now this 1.38 is it and there there isn't gonna be another one next April or May where it's all jacked up again

1:29:23 Because we had two really big ones in a row. We were so far behind

1:29:27 Yeah, the CIP got took a while

1:29:29 COVID kicked it a year and so the CIP's created the fire station some extra streets

1:29:35 that's when parks changed as they were dedicating parks before that and then we

1:29:41 took all of the cost of the parks 250,000 per acre and we're collecting that

1:29:45 amount all in that 22 I think is May of 22 and then come December we're going

1:29:51 the MCI is jumped yeah whatever percent and when it goes above five you have

1:29:57 the public hearing and that's what kicked us down to having a public hearing in

1:30:01 January, February with an April implementation date.

1:30:05 Did that satisfy the question with the timeline?

1:30:08 It did.

1:30:09 I wanted to be reminded, because that's what I was remembering,

1:30:12 but I wasn't sure that was correct.

1:30:14 Did that answer your question, Alex?

1:30:16 OK, Chris, Rhee?

1:30:18 I want to thank the impact fee for,

1:30:20 I was able to attend that meeting.

1:30:22 I thought they did a great job.

1:30:23 They looked at a lot of the numbers that we're currently

1:30:25 seeing.

1:30:29 1.38 is significantly lower than what

1:30:32 we've done in the past, understanding that there was a big upgrade several years ago

1:30:38 when we got things to where they were currently needed to be and then there was

1:30:42 the very large increase last year. So I'm ready to make a motion if anybody else

1:30:48 any other questions? I think we're good. I move that we accept the yearly report

1:30:54 from the Impact Fee Committee and approve the impact fee increase to

1:30:58 match the current available MCI of 1.38 percent.

1:31:03 Thank you. Do I have a second?

1:31:05 Second.

1:31:06 Thank you. Motion by Christopher Reed, second by Craig Hawkins,

1:31:10 to approve the impact fee yearly report and the automatic impact

1:31:15 fee increase of 1.38 percent scheduled for January 1, 2024.

1:31:21 Amy Roll call vote, please.

1:31:23 Nicky Boyd?

1:31:25 Yes.

1:31:26 Craig Hawkins?

1:31:27 Yes.

1:31:28 and Brown. Yes. Alex Cabal. No.

1:31:31 Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes six to one.

1:31:37 Thank you, Jonathan. Okay.

1:31:40 That is all for our regular agenda, our action items.

1:31:46 Next item on the agenda is general public input.

1:31:49 If there's anybody in the audience that wishes to dress city council today on anything that is not on the agenda.

1:31:57 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:32:09 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:32:21 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:32:28 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:32:33 The first two weeks were run under generator.

1:32:37 The second two plus week was run under power.

1:32:42 It's noisy.

1:32:43 I'm 78 years old.

1:32:46 I have tinnitus.

1:32:48 My wife is 39.

1:32:51 She has tinnitus.

1:32:54 We could hear this scrubber at least up to 60 to 80 feet away from the scrubber on the

1:33:08 opposite side of our house.

1:33:12 At night, in the Crystal Clear Night, we could hear this scrubber constantly in our upstairs

1:33:22 bedroom.

1:33:24 So contrary to what Mr. Erickson has told you, we're living proof what the

1:33:32 manual says isn't what happens. So sir, public input is for items that we

1:33:38 haven't already discussed on the agenda. Though I appreciate your spot you're in,

1:33:43 it would be best if you spoke with Nathan and City staff and see if we can't get

1:33:49 this resolved to your liking as opposed to the public input part. We can't do

1:33:56 anything. We would direct you to staff. Madam Mayor, staff has had the

1:34:00 opportunity to engage with Mr. Barlow. I know that Nathan has had the

1:34:05 opportunity to engage with Mr. Barlow even last week according to Nathan and in

1:34:10 those conversations we've continued to renew our commitment that we are going

1:34:13 to continue to look to other spaces. Mr. Barlow came in after the very first

1:34:18 City Council meeting. He shared those concerns that he has shared with you as

1:34:23 well as some other ones with City staff and I made a commitment to him as well as

1:34:27 other members that we would continue to explore and investigate different

1:34:32 places and different possible locations for the odors scrubber so that it can

1:34:37 optimize most effectiveness so it could be most effective but also be

1:34:41 complementary to a neighborhood to where we're at and so we continue to go forward

1:34:46 With that, as Nathan had shared in his presentation today,

1:34:48 as Nathan shared with him prior to tonight's meeting,

1:34:51 and we continue to renew our commitment

1:34:53 that we will do that.

1:34:54 We intentionally have made a decision

1:34:56 not to perform any testing right now,

1:35:00 because the environment would not result

1:35:03 and create the best test results for us.

1:35:06 Most of the orders come out during the warmer months.

1:35:09 And so we are waiting for the warmer months

1:35:12 to be able to move forward with that testing

1:35:15 so that we can find that optimal location,

1:35:18 one that is harmonious with the neighborhood

1:35:19 to the best of the ability,

1:35:21 and one that also moves forward and removes odors.

1:35:25 In addition to that, we have shared

1:35:29 that we will continue to be open, that will be transparent,

1:35:32 and that we will continue to share all of the data

1:35:35 with Mr. Barlow, which I believe that we have done that as well.

1:35:39 The purpose of tonight's item, as Nathan had shared,

1:35:43 was to acquire that second order so that in the spaces

1:35:46 that we know that are problematic,

1:35:48 we can continue to maintain treatment.

1:35:51 And then the second order is a place that we're able

1:35:54 to kind of move around to other locations

1:35:57 so that we can find that best place

1:35:58 in honor of our commitment to Mr. Barlow.

1:36:01 Okay, thank you.

1:36:03 Thank you.

1:36:04 Anybody else in the audience that wishes

1:36:07 to address City Council on something

1:36:09 that was not on today's agenda?

1:36:13 Okay, see no one, advisory board reports.

1:36:18 Anybody?

1:36:20 Craig?

1:36:22 I just want to take a set.

1:36:26 I know this is the last city council meeting

1:36:29 for a couple of board members.

1:36:31 I just want to express my appreciation and friendship.

1:36:37 It's actually here on the first one too.

1:36:39 Will they?

1:36:40 Yep, they have to vote.

1:36:41 I still, what I'm saying still applies.

1:36:44 He still appreciate him.

1:36:45 But thank you.

1:36:47 Thank you, Craig.

1:36:48 Are we going to say something on my second night tonight?

1:36:55 Yes.

1:36:56 Okay.

1:37:00 I don't want to take that much time.

1:37:03 I thought I was going to say goodbye tonight.

1:37:06 No.

1:37:07 You definitely have one more meeting.

1:37:09 I do.

1:37:10 Because the second you have to vote on today's minutes.

1:37:14 Oh, I forgot.

1:37:16 You have to do that.

1:37:17 Okay.

1:37:18 You're not done yet.

1:37:20 No.

1:37:21 see the end. Yeah, but it has not arrived. Okay, anything from the city manager's office?

1:37:29 Yeah, just to kind of build upon that we're looking forward to hearing your final remarks.

1:37:34 The entire balance of the meeting will be reserved for you. But take as long as you want. You've

1:37:39 earned it, right? But in all seriousness, City Hall will be closed the next two Mondays.

1:37:48 in four Christmas day, the other four New Year's Day.

1:37:53 This is the last meeting for the calendar year.

1:37:56 Our next city council meeting will be on January 2nd,

1:38:01 beginning at five o'clock PM.

1:38:05 Thank you.

1:38:07 So next on the agenda, we have two public hearings.

1:38:12 Do you guys wanna take a break

1:38:14 or do you wanna just zoom right in?

1:38:17 Zoom.

1:38:17 Let's zoom.

1:38:18 Okay, first public hearing is, I guess I need, okay, so we have two public hearings.

1:38:37 The first one is a request for zoning title amendment of City Code 10-12-4 to JNN to modify

1:38:47 financial responsibilities of street sign and luminaire installation of new development.

1:38:53 I don't have to read these, do I?

1:38:55 Do I?

1:38:56 You want me to read them now?

1:38:57 I'm trying to move the meeting right along. I know I promised.

1:39:03 Okay, so this is a public hearing portion of the meeting testimony will be taken from the public related to each item.

1:39:12 First, the city staff will present the request and analysis. The applicant will then present their request.

1:39:20 And you are both correct.

1:39:22 The Council will then ask questions after questions have been asked. The public hearing

1:39:28 will be opened. Anyone in attendance is given the opportunity to comment. When

1:39:33 giving testimony, step up to the podium, state your name and address, present your

1:39:37 comments, and you will be given two minutes. After testimony, please sign the

1:39:42 public signing sheet located in the lobby with your name and address. After

1:39:46 public comments are concluded, the applicant will be invited to answer any

1:39:50 questions, make a closing statement, staff will then answer or clarify any comments,

1:39:55 who that's both of you. And after closing statements, public hearing will be

1:40:00 closed and then council will have open discussion. Okay, Jonathan, now go.

1:40:05 All right. This title amendment actually you heard about a few months ago, we were

1:40:10 talking about street luminaires and street signs, signs of the green ones we

1:40:16 put up at every intersection. Current city code, it's listed up there, the

1:40:21 responsibility for these two items is passed to the city whenever new

1:40:26 development occurs. This has been part of city code 1981. The city staff, when I say

1:40:34 the street department, engineering department, have facilitated the

1:40:37 installation and payment for the street luminaires and the street signs. We've

1:40:42 found this doing an audit of our current code hasn't been an issue and I

1:40:47 see an issue hasn't cost us a lot of money in the past however this year

1:40:51 Mark Thompson and Robin height brought it to our attention we're gonna have a

1:40:58 pretty good size will bill coming up and it really that's what's in your budget

1:41:02 impact we basically were notified that what we had budgeted was going to be

1:41:07 exceeded in one of the subdivisions that's due to some of the costs for the

1:41:12 street luminaries and the installation costs that we've been carrying. So we are

1:41:17 looking for a change to the code. This cost will now be part of the requirement

1:41:23 for developers to pay. We will facilitate what gets installed in terms of the

1:41:28 street sign. They'll pay for the amounts and will install it. That's

1:41:33 something for a mark and his street group to design shop to deal with and

1:41:37 figure out how they're going to do with the developers. We've brought this up a

1:41:41 a couple times with the developers group

1:41:44 wanted a

1:41:45 one of the development meetings,

1:41:47 and then another email on October 13th,

1:41:49 we sent to representatives that they had self-identified

1:41:52 as people that were going to disseminate that information

1:41:54 to their respective groups.

1:41:56 We didn't hear anything.

1:41:59 And so we had the Public Hearing

1:42:00 and the Planning and Zoning Commission on November 14th,

1:42:03 and they made a positive recommendation

1:42:05 to make this small change.

1:42:06 The small change really is,

1:42:08 it just removes the city will pay,

1:42:11 And it goes back to the main section of that code.

1:42:14 This is the developer's shell pay to install.

1:42:18 So it'll just be part of all the other improvements,

1:42:20 just like the road that they construct or the sidewalk.

1:42:24 It gets reviewed by engineering,

1:42:26 approved by the construction plans,

1:42:28 and once it's installed, we inspect it.

1:42:31 And that is all I have.

1:42:33 Perfect.

1:42:34 Any questions for Jonathan before I open up the public hearing?

1:42:40 Okay, and open up the public hearing.

1:42:45 Anybody out there that wishes to address or ask any questions or make a presentation regarding this issue?

1:42:57 Seeing no one, I'll close the public hearing.

1:43:00 Jonathan, do you have anything else to add?

1:43:04 Okay, Council wishes, questions, what would you like to do?

1:43:12 Great, Craig Hawkins.

1:43:13 I think that it makes sense to me and I'm certain in favor of it.

1:43:18 I agree. I can make the motion right now. Certainly that we update the Zoning Title Amendment

1:43:29 of City Code 10-12-4-2, JNN to modify financials responsibility of street signs and luminaire

1:43:39 installation for new developers. Thank you. Do I have a second? Second. Thank you. Motion

1:43:46 by Chris Reed, seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the zoning title amendment of City

1:43:52 Code 10-12-42J&N. Any further discussion? Amy Roll call vote please.

1:44:01 Jason Brown. He just left. Alex Kaval. Yes.

1:44:07 Senator Cutler. Yes. Bruce Pierce. Yes.

1:44:10 Chris Reed. Yes.

1:44:11 Thank you, Boyd. No.

1:44:13 And Craig Hawkins. Yes.

1:44:15 Thank you. Motion passes five to one.

1:44:19 Okay. Next public hearing is a request to improve the consolidated annual performance and evaluation report.

1:44:27 Quote, caper.

1:44:29 We have Kelly, ever saw city planner. Welcome, Kelly.

1:44:33 Thank you, mayor, city council tonight. This is a request to approve the 2022,

1:44:39 2022 consolidated annual performance and evaluation report

1:44:44 for the community development block grant program, the CDBG.

1:44:48 The 2022 program year runs from October 1st, 22,

1:44:53 and concluded September 30th, 2023.

1:44:57 So that's why we're approving the 22.

1:45:01 At the end of every program year,

1:45:02 the city is required to submit a consolidated annual performance

1:45:06 and evaluation report

1:45:08 Before approval from the City Council,

1:45:10 the caper underwent a 15-day comment period.

1:45:14 The comment period has now concluded,

1:45:16 and the draft caper is attached for your review and approval.

1:45:20 Once approved, the caper will be submitted

1:45:22 to HUD for review and approval.

1:45:26 The caper is a report on the expenditures

1:45:29 of the CDBG program,

1:45:30 as well as the city's involvement

1:45:32 in the efforts to address homelessness.

1:45:35 $75,454, the CDBG funds have been expended during the 2022 program year.

1:45:44 During the public comment period, we received no comments on the caper.

1:45:51 On December 12, 2023, staff held the public input session on future CDBG projects for

1:45:57 the City Park and the Twin Falls Library.

1:46:00 18 people responded and we're all in favor of the projects the suggestions and comments made were attached in your report

1:46:08 So in conclusion staff is recommending approval of the program year 2022 consolidated annual performance report

1:46:18 With the following conditions subject to minor amendments required by staff or the Department of Housing and Urban Development to meet federal regulations

1:46:27 And I'll stand for any questions

1:46:30 Any questions for Kelly?

1:46:32 I do. I guess I struggled with that when trying to figure out what the correlation was between the

1:46:37 library and the park and solving homelessness. Could you address that for me? I can try. Sure.

1:46:45 We have one low moderate income neighborhood and it's downtown. So,

1:46:55 part of the CDBG program allows us to make improvements to those neighborhoods.

1:47:01 And we have gone to multiple agencies in the area, in the city, and we didn't get a lot of buy-in for taking the money.

1:47:17 So we came up with this project a few years ago to address connectability with the library and the park, address some COVID issues,

1:47:29 issues because we have COVID money that we have to spend on the outdoor learning space,

1:47:35 making the playground more accessible, making it in all access playground, and also improving

1:47:42 the rebuilding the bathroom, which we've had plans for for a few years.

1:47:47 So all of this will service our only low moderate income neighborhood in the city.

1:47:52 So that's where we came up with this project.

1:47:54 Let me kind of help.

1:47:55 So CDBG does not have to be allocated just to homelessness related issues that is just

1:48:02 one of the many topics that is eligible for the allocation of these resources and funds.

1:48:08 They have to be able to help.

1:48:10 They have to be allocated to projects that have low to moderate income inside of those distress

1:48:17 census tracts.

1:48:18 projects that include our development community improvement, places that help build community

1:48:29 in those low to moderate income areas are often approved and often accepted and this project

1:48:35 was approved and accepted by HUD in advance.

1:48:39 When Kelly's talking about partnering with nonprofits, we have the opportunity to use up

1:48:46 to 15% of our allocation, which is about $351,000, $352,000 a year, and gift or give those monies

1:48:55 to those entities so that they can then help with their services.

1:49:01 There is significant reporting associated with those dollars on their end, and they weren't

1:49:05 interested in following with the federal reporting guidelines as to what Kelly's sharing was when

1:49:10 there's little interest.

1:49:12 It's not that there's little interest in receiving the funds, there's little interest

1:49:16 in working through the federal paperwork process which is required with all of the funds.

1:49:21 So all of the requirements that we have with those dollars from reporting all onto all of

1:49:27 those other entities that we share those resources with just as though we were spending those

1:49:34 dollars.

1:49:35 Thank you that, Anne.

1:49:36 That was actually a pretty good answer.

1:49:38 That answer.

1:49:39 Sorry, Kelly.

1:49:42 No, don't.

1:49:43 No, don't be sorry.

1:49:45 Any other questions for Kelly?

1:49:49 Okay, then I will open up the public hearing.

1:49:52 Is there anybody in the audience that wishes

1:49:54 to testify on this particular issue

1:49:58 regarding the paper report?

1:50:02 Seeing no one, I'll close the public hearing.

1:50:05 Council discussion.

1:50:10 Ready, would like to make a motion.

1:50:12 Here, excuse me.

1:50:13 This is basically just the paperwork

1:50:17 that goes with everything that we're doing

1:50:21 and what's going on.

1:50:22 This is just the house keeping,

1:50:24 this is the end of your report.

1:50:25 Yes, that's all this is.

1:50:27 Okay, okay.

1:50:28 I'd be happy to make the motion.

1:50:30 Go ahead.

1:50:31 Mayor, I move that we approve the consolidated

1:50:34 annual performance and evaluations.

1:50:38 Thank you, do we have a second?

1:50:40 Motion by Nikki Boyd, seconded by Chris Reed

1:50:43 to approve the consolidated annual performance

1:50:45 and evaluations report.

1:50:48 Amy Roll call vote please.

1:50:52 Spencer Cutler.

1:50:53 Yes.

1:50:54 Ruth Pierce.

1:50:55 Yes.

1:50:56 Chris Reed.

1:50:57 Yes.

1:50:58 Thank you Boyd.

1:50:59 Yes.

1:51:00 Greg Hawkins.

1:51:01 Yes.

1:51:02 And Alex Cabal.

1:51:03 Yes.

1:51:04 Thank you.

1:51:05 Motion passes six to zero.

1:51:06 Thank you Kelly.

1:51:07 So that is everything on the agenda.

1:51:08 We do not have an executive session.

1:51:11 So before we adjourn I just want to wish everybody a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year

1:51:16 and we see you in January.

1:51:18 Thank you.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, December 18, 2023. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:51:31.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    a0ca3283362ccb048a0d942c0af8ac24537e9cdbe443b5dc1784e7e6e4ff28ee
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min, with 1 passage muted for privacy. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 760dbc4e4047a7fdb1361043e3d89173600481c4e73ed1f898cadbacffc37e39
    part02.m4a b217c2c63b60d47decebc669621a9b32662a17129d026770d96c734a08426d0f
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 4 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    6f66d03476a43a000fde6a2e718d9bf0b71cc23926b131b7f1b1216b9db68b72

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file