City Council meeting
Tuesday, January 2, 2024
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on fileMinutes on file
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:00:26 Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the January 2nd, 2024 City Council meeting. I want to confirm
0:00:34 We have a quorum. We have all seven members present in chambers
0:00:39 First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance if you wish to join me, please rise
0:00:44 Q, we have no proclamations tonight. So next on the agenda is the consent calendar
0:01:09 Council wishes. Mayor I move that we accept the consent calendar as presented.
0:01:15 Thank you to have a second. I suppose you have a second for me. All right motion
0:01:19 by Nikki Boyd seconded by Alex Kaval to approve the consent calendar as written.
0:01:25 Amy Rolkalvo please. Ruth Pierce yes. Chris Reed yes.
0:01:41 Nikki Boyd yes Craig Hawkins yes. Jason Brown yes. Alex Kaval yes.
0:01:47 Thank you, motion passes seven to zero.
0:01:51 First item on the agenda.
0:01:53 The other items of consideration is award plaques to council member Nikki Boyd and council member Alex Kaval.
0:02:02 In recognition of the years of service to the city of Twin Falls.
0:02:06 And we have Travis Rothweiler.
0:02:09 Madam members of the council as we give us one quick second if you would as we.
0:02:15 gather those and well we are I just want to make a comment I just to really
0:02:25 enjoyed serving with both of you ladies Nikki you and I were elected at the same
0:02:31 time and so we've had the last eight years together and I appreciate your
0:02:36 passion and your concern for the city and all that goes with it and Alex I
0:02:43 appreciate you even though you were short-lived. I do appreciate your candor and tough questions.
0:02:51 So thank you. Thank you to Nikki and thank you to Alex. As a city manager you often watch a couple
0:03:13 of important days. One of those important days is who's going to put their name on a ballot
0:03:20 it to be your boss. And the next one is who has earned the trust of the citizens to be elected
0:03:29 or to be appointed by the council. And I would say on both accounts they got it right. I have
0:03:37 appreciated my time. I've appreciated the opportunity to work with you and the works
0:03:44 that you've done on behalf of the citizens of Twin Falls, I really appreciate how you've
0:03:53 supported the team. As we've experimented with this thing called a high-performing organization
0:04:01 or as one city, we have had nothing but support from the council as we continue to build the
0:04:08 build the culture and create an organization that is high-performing, but
0:04:16 also one that respects the employees and the people who are on the ground every
0:04:21 single day serving. And you both did amazing and you will be missed and I
0:04:31 appreciate your time. We don't have a traditional plaque like I like to share
0:04:36 and I probably shared with you and I've shared with others inside of the
0:04:41 City of Twin Falls, we like to do things a little bit different.
0:04:45 And credit goes to Mitch Humble, who came up with this idea.
0:04:50 Mitch is not here tonight.
0:04:51 He is aching his daughter to college.
0:04:59 But early when we moved into this building,
0:05:03 we started a tradition that we give to all retiring employees
0:05:06 of the City of Twin Falls.
0:05:09 Members of our team who have sacrificed and given up
0:05:12 themselves in the spirit of public service and we want to continue that tradition and provide
0:05:20 each one of you a flag that has been flowing over City Hall and this flag was flowing for
0:05:31 each one of you and so I will start with Alex. This is presented to Alex Cabal City Council
0:05:43 member 16 months of service. This flag was flown over City Hall from November
0:05:47 29th, 2023 to December 7th, 2023. And so we will, if you want to come down, we can
0:05:55 present this to you first. I'll do this now and then Nikki, you can wrap up 16, 16
0:06:36 months, 16 months ago I stood here and I applied for this job and Ruth, whether
0:06:42 I keep asking you, your life choice or not, and I don't think you do, but I am thankful and grateful for the opportunity to have served with all of you on this council, and I thank the city employees who have made my job infinitely easier by always answering the questions that I had, and always being prepared and giving me the information that I needed to make the choices that I thought were important for the city.
0:07:11 So I also thank each and every one of you for your friendship, for the wisdom you've
0:07:19 imparted, and for the opportunity to serve alongside with you.
0:07:24 And lastly, thank you for or to the citizens of this city who decided not to give me the
0:07:32 boot.
0:07:33 So with that, my watch ends and Sherry's watch begins, but I think the city is in good
0:07:40 hands.
0:07:41 So thank you.
0:07:42 And the second flag I have presenting to Nikki Boyd, City Council Member, eight years of service.
0:08:04 This flag was flown over City Hall from September 26th, 2023 to October 31st, 2023.
0:08:12 So Nikki, if I could present your flag.
0:08:57 Well, this wraps up 11 years of service.
0:09:02 Starting with three years, I'm planning and zoning where I learned the land use process
0:09:07 and patience.
0:09:10 my many years of real estate drew me to this and I was lucky to be taught by what I see
0:09:15 as the best of the best. Two four-year terms on city council. This journey has been rewarding
0:09:25 and challenging. Sometimes drinking from a fire hose to be able to work with people dedicated
0:09:34 to serving our community is what makes all of this possible. I have many favorites but one
0:09:45 that is remarkable and demonstrates what we do here, the accomplishment, fire station
0:09:59 two, and soon three. The work that we do here is always based on our comprehensive plan.
0:10:11 The strategic plan lays out the steps, the markers by which we keep our fluent, progressive,
0:10:23 Moving forward, our progression.
0:10:27 We have a plan for that.
0:10:30 So what I say to the new council is work hard, listen to our citizens, follow the plan and
0:10:38 stay the course.
0:10:40 My best to each of you.
0:11:33 Thank you again.
0:11:34 So next on the agenda is the oath of office for newly elected city council members and Travis
0:11:42 will be giving the oath today.
0:11:44 I will.
0:11:45 I could have Ruth Pierce, Craig Hawkins, Grayson Stone,
0:11:52 Cherry Bulmer, all come please.
0:12:59 I'm going to swear that I will support the Constitution of the United States in law as a divide of all,
0:13:18 in ordinances of three of Twin Falls, that I will faithfully discharge the needs of the Councilor of the City of Twin Falls,
0:13:33 which I've been elected according to the best of my ability.
0:15:49 Okay, so next on the agenda is the selection of mayor.
0:15:53 Excuse me, and I am going to turn this part of the meeting over to Jason Brown,
0:15:58 so he can take this section.
0:16:02 You want me to sit over there?
0:16:13 Either way, it doesn't matter.
0:16:20 It in the center seat.
0:16:22 I just want to personally thank Alex.
0:16:27 It's been fun.
0:16:29 It's kind of interesting I've only been here for 24 months,
0:16:33 so I appreciate your service, but Nikki,
0:16:35 it's been fun sitting by you.
0:16:37 We've, you've helped me work through
0:16:41 some technical difficulties, and I appreciate
0:16:45 all of your help, and as an employee of the city
0:16:50 during some of your tenure, it was been fun.
0:16:55 Thank you.
0:16:59 So, as I was preparing for this, I actually went back and looked at 24 months ago, and
0:17:09 I'm going to take a page out of, at the time, Councilman Barrieger's page.
0:17:14 This part of being in Council is a little bit awkward.
0:17:18 As many of you know, we have a Council Manager form of government, and so the seven members
0:17:26 On this panel, I have the obligation to select a mayor from the group that we, that, of our
0:17:35 peers on this panel and that, that can be difficult because I have a tremendous amount
0:17:41 of respect and I hope that we all have a tremendous amount of respect for each other and so at
0:17:47 this time, I will ask who, who would like to run for mayor?
0:17:54 I'm interested
0:18:00 Councilwoman Pierce
0:18:02 I am as well. Okay council member read is there any anyone else that is interested
0:18:10 Okay, I believe we have a random generators that correct Amy for who who will speak to the council first
0:18:21 Just of the two correct as we sit here wait for technology will find out
0:18:53 I thought he got a coin.
0:18:59 Yeah, I was just going to say...
0:19:01 Watch the football games.
0:19:06 We need a coin toss.
0:19:11 Mostly the right calls, right?
0:19:13 It's one of those things that you practice all day.
0:19:17 What I would suggest is just type in their first names.
0:19:24 Not a great way to start out to hear any.
0:19:47 If this is as bad as it gets, we're going to be just great.
0:19:51 as it gets, we're going to be just great.
0:19:54 I was just going to say, who has a quarter?
0:20:03 I'll flip the coin.
0:20:05 Go ahead.
0:20:05 OK.
0:20:06 Council member Reed.
0:20:20 I believe two years ago I went first as well.
0:20:23 So it's just a repeat.
0:20:29 Good evening.
0:20:31 And thank you for this opportunity to stand before you
0:20:34 and present my case for mayor.
0:20:37 First, though, I would like to welcome Councilwoman Volmer
0:20:41 Councilman Stone. I look forward to working with you. That's a great group and welcome to the council.
0:20:49 Also, I would like to publicly thank Nikki Boyd for her work as a member of the City Council
0:20:55 and also a past mayor. I had the privilege of working on several items with Nikki and always
0:21:02 enjoyed her thoughts and her insight and wisdom she will be missed. And to Alex Kaval, thank you
0:21:09 for your time as well, your legal expertise, and also the questions and
0:21:16 knowledge that you you brought to the Council. Thank you. And of course hope for
0:21:21 the best for you in the future, and our hearts and prayers go with you. Over the
0:21:28 past seven years, as a council member, I have founded a privilege to represent the
0:21:33 people of Twin Falls, during which we as a council have made many challenging
0:21:39 decisions. At times in front of large gatherings of our constituents, we have agreed and we
0:21:46 have disagreed on issues. We have always respected each other as we have moved forward. We have
0:21:54 represented the people of Twin Falls, I believe professionally and diplomatically, always
0:22:00 with a desire for the best possible outcome. In the past two years, we as a council and
0:22:07 more importantly, as a city have accomplished much.
0:22:12 The hands of many throughout this organization
0:22:15 have made these accomplishments happen.
0:22:18 They do not rest on the shoulders of one person
0:22:21 or department, but the collective strength
0:22:25 of a group of individuals serving each other
0:22:28 with the motto of one city.
0:22:30 As a council member, I feel it a privilege
0:22:33 to be a part of that collective strength
0:22:35 representing the people.
0:22:38 Now the position of Mayor in the City of Twin Falls, as described earlier, is one that I
0:22:45 believe represents the Council to the people.
0:22:49 The Mayor does not have veto power or is a part of an executive branch, but one-seventh
0:22:56 of this Council.
0:22:58 But as I'm sure Ruth can attest, and the former Mayor's that this platform they have
0:23:03 is much bigger than the rest of the Council.
0:23:06 this platform, I would focus on several areas that I believe would make Twin Falls an even
0:23:12 greater place to live. It is not a secret that we need more law enforcement in the City of
0:23:18 Twin Falls. Each year during our budget talks, our city management team shares with the city
0:23:25 council that our police and fire ratios work for a city of 50,000, but the amount of people
0:23:33 that come to this into the city each day more than doubles, that number and it is not shrinking,
0:23:41 it is growing. Over the past 12 years as a resident of the City of Twin Falls, I heard
0:23:47 what started as a whisper and now a common conversation of a local option sales tax.
0:23:54 Now I understand that the state government at this time will not allow that this is an
0:24:00 We need to move this from a common conversation to a shout.
0:24:07 As the Magic Valley continues to grow, we need to look for additional revenue sources,
0:24:13 and that burden should not fall solely on the backs of the property owners.
0:24:18 Our City Manager has been ringing this bell for several years,
0:24:22 and with the Mayor's platform, I will add my voice and encourage the Council,
0:24:26 The city and the residents of this great city to move that shout to a deafening roar.
0:24:34 His past election cycle we heard candidates talk about the need for help with housing and
0:24:39 the cost of housing.
0:24:41 While we do not have a mechanism to implement housing cost reductions nor do I believe that
0:24:47 would represent the desire of the people the cost of living in Twin Falls has grown rapidly
0:24:53 and has affected our way of life.
0:24:55 I have heard it from more than one person that they would not be able to afford their home
0:25:01 if they were to rewrite.
0:25:03 While this is not a complete fix on housing costs, but it will allow our great city to adjust
0:25:10 the times in which we live, adjust to the needs of the people that live here and want to stay
0:25:17 here.
0:25:18 When I first ran for council several years ago, I was asked the question, why do you want
0:25:24 to be on City Council, as I'm sure many of you have been.
0:25:28 My answer now is the same as it was then.
0:25:31 I want to make sure that Twin Falls is a place where my children can and want to live.
0:25:37 When I first answered that question years ago, my children were in elementary school, and
0:25:42 that to me was a very distant concern.
0:25:45 Today, I have juniors and sophomores in high school, and I have a growing concern that even
0:25:51 of my children wanted to stay in Twin Falls.
0:25:54 Financially, it will not be an option for them
0:25:57 as they start their careers.
0:26:01 An area that is vitally important to the success
0:26:03 and growth of Twin Falls has been
0:26:06 and will continue to be infrastructure.
0:26:09 My very first introduction,
0:26:12 the workings of city was as co-chair
0:26:14 of the wastewater treatment bond.
0:26:16 While infrastructure discussion never draws a large crowd,
0:26:20 when we discuss them, our city does not function without it.
0:26:24 In the next two years, we will continue to have conversations about increased water demands,
0:26:30 wastewater regulations, lift and transfer station builds and repairs, road improvements and
0:26:36 widenings, maintenance to city owned properties, sidewalks, parks and a host of others.
0:26:44 I am asking for your vote as mayor.
0:26:47 As mayor, I will represent the council in a way becoming of this position.
0:26:52 I will hold myself to the highest standard,
0:26:54 encourage ensuring honesty and integrity.
0:26:59 I will never ask the council that which I will not do myself.
0:27:03 I will not portray the trust of the council, city,
0:27:06 and our constituents by not following the open meeting laws.
0:27:10 I understand the responsibility of this position tonight.
0:27:15 May God bless you as you make this decision.
0:27:17 May God bless this great city as we move forward.
0:27:20 Thank you.
0:27:43 Thank you.
0:27:44 Good evening city councils, city staff,
0:27:46 and citizens of Twin Falls.
0:27:48 Thank you for this opportunity,
0:27:51 given me to address you tonight.
0:27:54 First of all, I'd like to welcome both Sherri and Grayson
0:27:57 as our newest council members.
0:27:59 I am confident you both will serve
0:28:01 in the passion you showed during your campaigns.
0:28:04 I would also like to take this opportunity
0:28:06 to thank the executive team
0:28:08 and all the city staff for their hard work and dedication.
0:28:13 As I mentioned at the City Retreat,
0:28:15 we have accomplished a lot this past two years.
0:28:18 All of you have worked through the many challenges
0:28:21 we have faced, and we are a better and stronger community
0:28:24 because of your commitment.
0:28:27 To my fellow City Council members,
0:28:30 I am here to ask for your support
0:28:33 and to elect me as Mayor of Twin Falls for the next two years.
0:28:38 The seven City Council members make a great team.
0:28:41 I've had the pleasure of serving on City Council
0:28:44 the past eight years with some of our city's
0:28:47 greatest community leaders,
0:28:49 having served as vice mayor and most recently as mayor.
0:28:53 I'm looking forward to working with all of you
0:28:56 the next four years.
0:28:58 In addition to my years on City Council,
0:29:00 I have served in various leadership roles
0:29:03 for many community partners and nonprofits.
0:29:06 My personal involvement in economic development
0:29:09 through serving on the Twin Falls City Ready Team,
0:29:13 Southern Idaho Development Organization,
0:29:15 and Business Plus have been the most rewarding,
0:29:18 facilitating job growth, economic fatality,
0:29:22 and quality of life in our community
0:29:25 are keys to a strong and vibrant Twin Falls.
0:29:29 During my 10 year on City Council,
0:29:32 I have served as liaison to many committees and commissions,
0:29:36 as I have most of you.
0:29:38 During the past two years as liaison to the Urban Renewal Agency, I participated in critical
0:29:45 discussions to determine the important steps as we close out one revenue allocation area
0:29:52 and establish another.
0:29:54 I've also represented the City Council on the MPO Metropolitan Planning Organization for
0:30:01 the past four years as we work to determine the key stakeholders involved and finalize
0:30:07 the formation of the official organization later this month.
0:30:12 Because I am a CPA, my financial and budgeting background gives me the expertise to understand
0:30:18 city finances and budgets.
0:30:20 I also understand our resources are strained with the influx of people coming to Twin Falls
0:30:26 every day to workshop or use our services.
0:30:30 We need to continue to think strategically and be creative with the resources we have.
0:30:37 It is important to ensure the City continues to be the employer of choice.
0:30:42 It is imperative that we work to retain our current employees and attract new quality
0:30:48 employees by being creative and keeping our compensation and benefits competitive.
0:30:55 We have many areas to focus on this year.
0:30:58 We will be opening Fire Station 2 later this month.
0:31:02 We will be playing a critical role in the new MPO and updating our strategic plan.
0:31:09 We also will be focusing on performance based budgeting and of course our water.
0:31:15 I would like to lead this organization as mayor as we work through these crucial items.
0:31:22 Because we operate under a city manager form of government, each of the seven city
0:31:27 council members play an important oversight role.
0:31:31 It is one member, one vote, but we work as a team.
0:31:36 The role of Mayor in our form of government is not just to run the City Council meetings
0:31:41 and sign documents.
0:31:43 The Mayor also represents the City and the City Council at community and other events.
0:31:50 The Mayor acts as an advocate for the citizens of the City of Twin Falls and is the connection
0:31:57 between the citizens, city staff, and our various community and regional partners.
0:32:03 The mayor also serves as a legislative advocate in a legislative advocate role representing
0:32:09 the community at the state and federal levels.
0:32:13 Fortunately, with my extensive involvement in community service and my tenure on city
0:32:19 council, I've developed strong personal and professional working relationships with
0:32:24 our community partners as well as representatives in other cities, Twin Falls County, other counties
0:32:32 and at the state and federal level.
0:32:35 And also because of my personal schedule and the fact that I own my own business, I do have
0:32:40 the time available and the flexibility to attend important meetings and events.
0:32:46 We have many challenges and opportunities facing us in the next few years.
0:32:52 We all know the financial and staffing challenges and the issues we face as our population doubles
0:32:58 on a daily basis.
0:33:00 My goal is to continue to be a local and state legislative advocate for the City of Twin Falls
0:33:08 to protect the tools we currently have and to advocate for new tools to maintain the quality
0:33:14 of life our citizens expect and deserve.
0:33:19 I appreciate the opportunity to speak to all of you tonight
0:33:22 and ask for you to support me as mayor
0:33:25 for the next two years.
0:33:26 Thank you.
0:33:37 So I think as we did it last year,
0:33:40 it looks like our random generator,
0:33:42 or last two years ago, it looks like our random generator
0:33:45 is not working, so it looks like Amy Shike
0:33:47 and the dice over here.
0:33:49 We're going old fashioned.
0:33:50 Okay.
0:33:53 So seat number five will be first.
0:33:59 I'm assuming we're going to select all the seat numbers, and then we'll call for a vote
0:34:05 after that.
0:35:02 So the order has been drawn by random lot, not quite by randomizer as we had hoped.
0:35:11 It's one of those things that we practiced.
0:35:14 It worked.
0:35:15 I brought my computer.
0:35:16 We were really excited.
0:35:20 That just didn't work.
0:35:24 There are, there is the voting order as a refresher for the council and for those watching,
0:35:37 it requires four votes to become the mayor and no abstentions while uncomfortable are
0:35:44 allowed.
0:35:47 Okay, so at this point I guess Amy will call vote Ruth Pierce.
0:35:59 Ruth Pierce.
0:36:03 Ruth Pierce.
0:36:07 Thank you, Chris, for serving as vice mayor.
0:37:00 That's been fun for us.
0:37:03 And I want to just do a hoo shout out to my friends and family that's all here.
0:37:07 not going to call you by name. I got chastised last time. So thank you for being here and I know
0:37:15 everybody's got some friends and family here. So the next item on the agenda is selection of vice
0:37:21 mayor and that is nominated by mayor and confirmed by the council. So at this time I would like to
0:37:28 put forth the name of Jason Brown for vice mayor and so I think we I don't know that you have a vote
0:37:37 order. We need a second. We do need a second. I'll second. And then in terms of vote, we
0:37:46 can do it by normal lot. Hey, so I've made the nomination and Grayson Stone seconded
0:37:53 it. Amy Roll call vote, please. Craig Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Mary
0:38:05 Yes.
0:38:06 Grace and Stone?
0:38:08 Yes.
0:38:11 Councillor Cutler?
0:38:13 Yes.
0:38:14 Ruth Pierce?
0:38:15 Yes.
0:38:16 Chris Reed?
0:38:17 Yes.
0:38:18 Hey, thank you.
0:38:19 Jason Brown, seven to nothing.
0:38:21 Thank you, Jason.
0:38:22 I won't make you make a speech till your first meeting.
0:38:31 So that is it on the agenda.
0:38:34 We don't have public hearing or any public hearings tonight.
0:38:38 So the meeting is actually adjourned.
0:38:40 Thank you, everyone.
0:38:41 one.
Download
- Transcript (text) 24 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 32 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 43 KB
- Audio (M4A) 9.2 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Tuesday, January 2, 2024. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 00:38:49.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
30a4f27818d2121e7d9c170afb2d63bbdd9382c6f2e03837cefb9f22fe774744 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a f46ab3a6c4dc34645d8de6070783d79236e747172a4862b55e11066f3c3df769 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
bfb077259445d1aa6ac1c44d62fde0d7f47fe6b8a5f99a9d4348abfa1c89e98c
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file