OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, June 24, 2024

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on fileMinutes on file

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording

Transcript

0:01:55 Okay, we'll call the order, our city council meeting tonight for June 24th, 2024.

0:02:05 All those that would like to participate in the Pledge of Allegiance, please stand.

0:02:31 Thank you.

0:02:34 It doesn't look like we have any proclamations tonight, and so we'll move on to the next

0:02:40 item of business, which is the consent calendar.

0:02:43 Move to approve the consent calendar.

0:02:44 We have a second.

0:02:47 I guess we have a first and second.

0:02:50 Amy Roll call vote.

0:02:54 Chris Reed.

0:02:55 Yes.

0:02:55 Jason Brown.

0:02:56 Yes.

0:02:57 Spencer Cutler.

0:02:58 Yes.

0:02:58 Perry Bulmer.

0:02:59 Yes.

0:02:59 And Grayson Stone.

0:03:00 Yes.

0:03:02 Thank you.

0:03:03 We'll move on to item number four items of consideration.

0:03:08 This is a consideration to reappoint the Mayor Pierce's reappointments of Camille

0:03:16 and Tim Hayford to the Public Arts Commission.

0:03:22 Looks like we have, we have, we have, Mitch.

0:03:30 When he's not here yet, so I can't hear this one.

0:03:33 Sounds good.

0:03:35 Tim and Camille both have served their first term

0:03:38 on the art commission.

0:03:40 They've both been fantastic on that commission.

0:03:42 I'll add you speak up if you want to, Chris,

0:03:45 as the liaison.

0:03:48 They finished their first terms.

0:03:49 We both like to be appointed for second terms.

0:03:51 Wendy and Ruth have talked about that.

0:03:53 And I know it's weird that neither of them are hearing that.

0:03:55 Yeah, I would agree.

0:03:56 But I believe that that's true.

0:04:00 And so the recommendation from Ruth

0:04:01 was to go ahead and point them so the action time would

0:04:03 simply be reappointments for three-year terms.

0:04:06 And Camille's here, I didn't see Tim.

0:04:12 But if you want to ask her any hard questions,

0:04:15 she's council member Reed.

0:04:16 I don't have any questions, but I just

0:04:18 wanted to echo what Mitch said. I would agree, Camille and Tim are both in attendance during

0:04:24 our meetings and also participate. It is a very active group, a lot of discussion that happens,

0:04:29 and both of them are a wealth of knowledge when it comes to the Public Arts Commission.

0:04:36 So I'll make the motion if we're ready. Absolutely. I moved that we approved the recommendation

0:04:42 from their peers to reappoint Camille Barrieger

0:04:45 and Tim Hayfur to the Public Art Commission.

0:04:48 Do I have a second?

0:04:49 I'll second.

0:04:51 We have a first and a second to reappoint Camille Barrieger

0:04:55 and Tim Hayfur to the Public Arts Commission.

0:04:58 Amy, we'll call vote.

0:05:01 Jason Brown?

0:05:01 Yes.

0:05:02 Spencer Kettler?

0:05:04 Yes.

0:05:05 Barry Vomer?

0:05:06 Yes.

0:05:07 Grayson Stone?

0:05:07 Yes.

0:05:08 And Chris Reed?

0:05:09 Yes.

0:05:11 motion passes five to zero.

0:05:15 I'm doing my math correctly.

0:05:18 So next item up for consideration is a recommendation

0:05:23 for the Public Arts Commission to allocate up to 15,000

0:05:27 from the Public Arts Reserve Fund

0:05:29 to replace the murals in the downtown commons.

0:05:32 And Wendy, are you taking care of that one?

0:05:36 Okay, Wendy Davis.

0:05:43 Good afternoon, I apologize.

0:05:46 It's been a Monday.

0:05:49 So thanks to whoever helped with the first one.

0:05:53 And then this one, we had a proposal submitted by Arnal Colum to replace or rotate out some

0:06:02 of the murals on the wall out here that's adjacent to the fountain in the downtown commons.

0:06:09 And as we did some research, realized that the Urban Renewal Agency, when they allocated

0:06:15 the funds and purchased that artwork, they never intended those to be up there for very

0:06:20 long.

0:06:21 And so this, the material that was used, they had about a three-year life expectancy and I

0:06:27 think we've gotten, I'm trying to remember Chris to be decided six, six or seven years

0:06:32 out of those murals so far, but they've faded significantly and after going through a, a

0:06:40 artists for the electrical boxes, realized that we had a lot of really great

0:06:47 submissions and thought it would become an exciting project to allocate some

0:06:51 dollars to getting some artwork and then getting some new murals put together and

0:06:58 so this this request today is just simply if you are in favor of this

0:07:03 project and like the idea of it and are willing to allocate the money out of

0:07:09 And this comes out of the Public Art Reserve Fund.

0:07:14 We took a little bit of it out for the electrical boxes.

0:07:17 I believe we have about 60,000 left in there,

0:07:20 and this would be another 15 out of that.

0:07:23 And that would include 6,000 for anticipated artist fees,

0:07:29 and then we have an estimate for about 7,600

0:07:32 for the manufacturer, for the removal of the manufacturer.

0:07:39 of those six different sizes.

0:07:42 Chris Reed, thank you for bringing that.

0:07:48 I don't have any questions.

0:07:50 I know that the Public Arts Committee has spent a lot of time

0:07:53 looking into these.

0:07:54 We had one replaced a few years ago.

0:07:57 I don't know if you've seen it.

0:07:59 There is some sun damage in the report.

0:08:01 It did talk about UV protection on the ones coming up.

0:08:06 They're not on the ones currently in place because they were never

0:08:09 they were never intended to be up there this long.

0:08:13 I'm in favor of it.

0:08:15 I know that when they were originally put out,

0:08:18 there was a lot of great feedback.

0:08:20 I think it's something that really does help

0:08:21 our downtown commons and the Public Art Council.

0:08:26 They all were in favor of this and the process to do it,

0:08:29 so I'm in favor of it.

0:08:32 Any other questions?

0:08:35 So what would happen to the art

0:08:37 that's currently being displayed now?

0:08:40 So those current pieces probably are in no condition.

0:08:45 However, the idea behind doing this

0:08:50 and having a rotating stock and maybe building up

0:08:53 a repository, or a repository, not a repository,

0:08:57 a repository of work that we could kind of rotate out

0:08:59 and change and do different things

0:09:01 so we could take and get new murals made

0:09:06 out of that existing artwork at any time

0:09:09 if we wanted to. And so probably the five out of the six, the one cow that was replaced

0:09:16 fairly recently looks pretty good still. The others are probably so faded that they're

0:09:20 not worth saving. And then the intention would be that we would kind of do this on a rotating

0:09:26 basis every few years, change things out, get some new pieces, and do the celebration

0:09:33 down there too when we unveil those in October, hopefully.

0:09:37 And the process would be similar is to go out and ask the general public to do that,

0:09:43 is that, or like we did the wraps.

0:09:45 Yeah, so what we'll do is do a color artist.

0:09:47 We were going to reach out to a bunch of those artists that submitted for the electrical boxes,

0:09:52 because some of that artwork was amazing, but wouldn't look so good on a box at 35 miles an hour,

0:09:58 but might look spectacular out here in a static setting.

0:10:02 but we would open it back up, invite the community to submit,

0:10:07 go through a selection process.

0:10:08 And then when we get those pieces,

0:10:10 we'll come back like we did last time.

0:10:12 His council will have the final approval of the artwork

0:10:17 that they've selected that would go out there

0:10:19 so that we would hope to be back here in a few months

0:10:21 with the recommended pieces to replace it with.

0:10:26 You're exciting to see something new, but I do like the cow.

0:10:30 Yeah, I do too.

0:10:32 So that's what's cool.

0:10:33 So we all still have all those, too.

0:10:35 And then we just created a little bigger rotation.

0:10:40 Any other questions, Chris?

0:10:42 I'm ready for a motion.

0:10:44 Unless there's others.

0:10:45 OK.

0:10:45 I move that we approve the recommendation

0:10:47 from the Public Arts Commission to allocate up to 15,000

0:10:51 from the Public Art Reserve Fund to replace the murals

0:10:54 in the downtown commons.

0:10:56 Grace and Stone?

0:10:57 I'll second.

0:10:58 OK, we have a motion and a second to,

0:11:02 on the recommendation to reallocate up to 15,000

0:11:06 from the public arts reserve fund

0:11:08 to replace the murals in the downtown commons.

0:11:10 Any further discussion?

0:11:13 Amy Roll call vote.

0:11:15 Spencer Cutler.

0:11:16 Yes.

0:11:17 Sherry Bulmer.

0:11:18 Yes.

0:11:19 Grayson Stone.

0:11:20 Yes.

0:11:20 Chris Reed.

0:11:21 Yes.

0:11:22 And Jason Brown.

0:11:23 Yes.

0:11:24 Motion passes five to zero.

0:11:25 Thank you, Wendy.

0:11:26 Thank you.

0:11:28 Goes out of this and we'll get on to the next item.

0:11:33 Next item is a consideration to award the bid for the 2020-14-11th Avenue East Project

0:11:39 to Idaho Material and Construction in the amount of $675,720.20, an authorized contingency

0:11:48 in the amount of $50,000 for potential change orders.

0:11:50 And it looks like we have Rob Blolling.

0:11:52 I think it's on now.

0:12:03 Good evening, Mayor and Council.

0:12:04 I thank you for the time this evening to come before you and request.

0:12:10 Jason said the consideration to award the bid for the 11th Avenue East Project,

0:12:15 title, materials and construction, and the amount of $6.75, $7.20 and authorize a

0:12:21 contingency in the amount of $50,000 for potential change orders. That's roughly

0:12:27 about seven and a half percent of the total bid for the contingency. To give you a

0:12:34 a little background on 11th Avenue. Thinking back, I think it was around 2017. Water Department

0:12:44 responded to some leaks that we had on 11th Avenue. We went out there, we had a couple

0:12:50 of main breaks and then when we were fixing those main breaks and did some more investigation

0:12:55 there, found that there was actually some, it looked like steel well casing that they

0:13:02 had used to repair back in the day because that's all the parts they had on

0:13:07 the hand or whatever. Anyway it was materials that weren't really made for

0:13:13 fixing water lines. These water lines in this area were put in in the early 1930s

0:13:20 so they are reaching their useful lifespan and on top of that street

0:13:27 department has road maintenance they do and when we go in and put in a new

0:13:31 water line and we go into an area where the road's not very good shape we destroy the road

0:13:38 and everything around it so we can't really go back in and put a good product once we're in there

0:13:44 and go back in and ask for all that it was street departments had money assigned to this project

0:13:50 also we had EHM design it and we started working on it we did it in three phases and this would be

0:13:57 our last phase of this project. We were doing some ADA improvements also and those were the

0:14:10 bid alternate one and two on the project and if you wonder why we did alternate with everything

0:14:17 going on in the water that I've got going on right now. We weren't exactly sure. Marquette

0:14:23 dedicated money. I had some dedicated money but I wasn't exactly sure how much

0:14:29 we'd have left over at the end of the year so that's kind of way we wanted to

0:14:33 go ahead and move forward with doing the waterline and the last block of this.

0:14:38 If we didn't have the money to afford to do the whole project together we wanted

0:14:44 to be able to then later on after 1st of October then go back to get

0:14:49 alternates wanted to but we put it out there and luckily we got a bit that came

0:14:54 in under what we needed and so the streets department and water department

0:15:01 this is a shared project that we'll work together on and we ask that as we request

0:15:09 and approve it. Any questions for Rob? Rob what would be the time frame on this?

0:15:15 So, water department is out there. We started on it last week. They were, I think, I believe

0:15:23 they zipped the trench force today. And then once we get the water line in, it'll probably

0:15:29 be about four or five weeks. If we have no problems, hopefully, we'll get the water line

0:15:39 in and then they will start after that.

0:15:41 Okay. So, works started on it?

0:15:43 Yes.

0:15:44 Any other questions or Spencer Cutler?

0:15:50 I'll make a motion if you're ready.

0:15:51 Got one question real quick, just for clarification, Rob,

0:15:55 the project is from Maurice to Blue Lakes,

0:15:57 is that correct, on 11th?

0:15:59 So this is the final block, down to Blue Lakes.

0:16:04 And then we have the bit alternate one,

0:16:06 is some valley gutter, curb gutter at Maurice,

0:16:10 and your storm drain line and a couple of catch basins there.

0:16:16 and then belly gutter and ADA increments at low cost also.

0:16:21 Okay, thank you.

0:16:23 Any other questions or go ahead and answer that?

0:16:26 Yeah, thank you.

0:16:27 I move that we award the project

0:16:29 to Idaho Materials and Construction

0:16:31 in the amount of $675,720 in 20 cents

0:16:37 and authorize a contingency in the amount of $50,000

0:16:40 for potential change orders.

0:16:42 Sherry Volmer.

0:16:43 I will second.

0:16:44 We have a first and a second to award a bid to for the 2020-1411th Avenue East Project

0:16:51 to Idaho Material and Construction in the amount of $675,720.20 and authorize a contingency

0:16:59 in the amount of $50,000 for any potential change orders.

0:17:02 Any further discussion?

0:17:03 Amy Roll-call-vote.

0:17:05 Terry Bomer?

0:17:06 Yes.

0:17:08 Grace and Stone?

0:17:09 Yes.

0:17:10 Chris Reed?

0:17:11 Yes.

0:17:12 Grace and Brown?

0:17:13 Yes.

0:17:14 Yes, a motion passes five to zero. Thanks Rob. Appreciate it. Thank you very much for your time. Next item

0:17:24 for consideration is a request to allocate $22,585 for from the contingency to continue the title

0:17:32 10 rewrite contract and we have Jonathan Spendlove. Thank you Vice Mayor members of the council.

0:17:40 I'm not going to read the report exactly it's all there but in brief we have a contract

0:17:46 with Orion, a planning and design that was begun in June of 2022 and throughout the last

0:17:54 few years both of our entities have experienced some turnovers and issues with timing. The

0:18:00 original contract had 30, remember the amount, it was total in there, it was 39,000 and we have

0:18:09 We've utilized up to 16,000, so there's a remaining around 22,585.

0:18:18 We are not able to encumber funds past one year, and so since it's taken us longer to

0:18:22 accomplish them, they are willing to continue with the contract and to finish out what was

0:18:27 promised in the original.

0:18:30 We are continuing to work on that.

0:18:33 We're here to authorize to continue the work to finish up the contract.

0:18:36 It looks like Grace and Stone.

0:18:39 Thank you, Jason.

0:18:41 So, Director Spimlev, as we kind of talked,

0:18:47 previous discussions, laws on P&Z, this process has been going on for quite some time.

0:18:51 What's the relationship like, and what do you think it's going to take to get this

0:18:56 across the finish line, because this has been, there's been complications

0:19:01 with it with workload, and I know it takes up a lot of your time as well.

0:19:05 My preference would be on this, is that we look at allocating

0:19:09 funds not only to fulfill their set of the contract as far as getting the

0:19:13 exhibits done, then also drafting the language because it's minor standing

0:19:17 once they get the exhibits done and you and staff have to then draft the rest of

0:19:21 the code. We are currently the contract reads that we are drafting the language

0:19:26 and they're doing exhibits and compiling which is the tedious work. We have been

0:19:32 slower in drafting language than they have been in compiling and getting

0:19:38 exhibits. Two reasons, there are a couple reasons for that. It takes longer to write the law than

0:19:43 it does to compile it. We've also experienced those shortfalls in staffing over the last

0:19:49 few years, both companies, like ours and theirs. I have had conversations with them about speeding

0:19:57 it up and they didn't, instead they're willing to finish the contract, it doesn't mean they

0:20:02 were willing to speed up any faster than I can go. Or to draft a language, we'd have to

0:20:07 to renegotiate that contract at that point.

0:20:10 And I think that answers my question,

0:20:12 but I think I would be more opposed to, I guess,

0:20:17 on this maybe for the discussion part,

0:20:18 but allocating these funds and then entering

0:20:21 into renegotiating or directing staff

0:20:24 to renegotiate to get the actual Title 10 done

0:20:27 and have them draft the language

0:20:29 where we're coming up short on our end.

0:20:31 And I'm not blaming level two at all for that,

0:20:35 but just so we can put this thing to bed,

0:20:37 I think that that would be appropriate.

0:20:39 So then your conversations with them,

0:20:42 it seems like that that's something they would entertain

0:20:44 if we approached them about it.

0:20:46 We just need to enter another contract.

0:20:48 It did not come up in my conversations

0:20:49 with them to go fast work or to draft it.

0:20:52 So I could have those conversations.

0:20:54 This was simply, are we willing to fulfill

0:20:56 the contract to finish it out?

0:20:58 Cool.

0:20:59 And we did, Jonathan, and you can correct me,

0:21:00 but we'd have to also go through some of the budgeting process

0:21:03 to make sure that that money was allocated

0:21:06 for that additional scope.

0:21:07 If you're going to change the scope, that would be what we'd have to change and ask them.

0:21:10 Whether they have time is what I'm, I don't know, Chris Reed, Jonathan, what is the time

0:21:20 frame that you're looking at right now?

0:21:22 If you'd asked me three years ago to have been to yours, right now.

0:21:26 So where we are at, the reality is we've got two chapters that are largely unwritten,

0:21:31 right at this point.

0:21:32 One of them is the subdivision chapter, reevaluating it and changing a bulk of what's happening

0:21:39 to update it.

0:21:40 And the other is the land use chapter.

0:21:42 The land use chapter is about half way, but I'd say it's like some days it feels half way,

0:21:46 some days it feels a quarter, and some days it feels 75% done because things come up and

0:21:51 it's just they all interact.

0:21:52 So those are the largest chapters undone, the rest of them are drafted and compiled, but

0:21:58 They're also the largest chapters with the most implications.

0:22:03 I really want this done this year.

0:22:06 I said that last year, but I don't think so much time of the day for me.

0:22:12 And so it's really left, I mean, to be very sincere and frank, it's me writing it.

0:22:17 It's like nobody else writing it in my staff.

0:22:20 I'm getting people up to speed as they're newer, but I've been doing that now every

0:22:24 year for the last three.

0:22:26 So it really comes down to the limitations of time.

0:22:29 I want it done this year, and I'm working diligently to get it some days better than

0:22:33 others.

0:22:34 I would say calendar year is my really hope.

0:22:38 I have no movement or changes, I think that can be accomplished.

0:22:44 I know that's six months being done drafted and then having some work sessions with you

0:22:49 all this fall to get direction on some items, that's the plan.

0:22:54 I think that's fair, I think if it goes longer than that we can start having those conversations

0:22:59 because I remember originally we chatted about these and from the original time that we did this

0:23:06 to now there's a lot that has happened and so there is no finger pointing on that I think we

0:23:13 fulfill this we hope that you know six months eight months whatever it is kind of within that

0:23:20 calendar year maybe a little bit for us to work on it understanding that when you bring it to the

0:23:27 council we do we drag things out yeah you still have to go to the public hearing

0:23:32 on all of them so absolutely time to implementation I think that's that's

0:23:36 fair right now and if something happens in the period of time I think we can look

0:23:41 at getting you some help and and maybe it's talking with our advisors our help

0:23:48 over here. Grayson, Councilman Stone. Yeah, Vice Mayor Brown and maybe this is a

0:23:55 question more direct to mention Gretchen but can we modify a motion on

0:24:01 on something like this.

0:24:02 So I'm ready to make a motion,

0:24:04 but I wanted to add a contingency on it to,

0:24:06 my motion would be to request,

0:24:08 we approve the request to allocate 22,585

0:24:12 from constituency to continue the title 10 rewrite contract,

0:24:16 but then I wanted to add additional language that would say

0:24:18 and to direct city staff to explore

0:24:25 an agency to draft a language for us.

0:24:28 Is that something that we can do,

0:24:30 or does that need to be a separate item consideration?

0:24:33 I think we can do that.

0:24:34 I'll jump in just a second if I can.

0:24:36 I kind of echo and one of the questions I had for Jonathan

0:24:40 is what percentage do you believe we're complete right now?

0:24:44 The whole of what this contract included.

0:24:49 The contracts that we are, they have spent less than 50%.

0:24:53 But we're more than 50% through the code

0:24:56 in terms of just pages or words, is that answering your question?

0:25:01 that and then I'll follow it up with another question of what we intended for

0:25:06 this rewrite of Title 10. How far do you think we are on getting that done? I know

0:25:15 we have a time frame of six months-ish and we also now have a desire to maybe

0:25:21 start looking at an outside firm to help us get over that finish line. But how

0:25:28 How much more percentage wise do you think we need?

0:25:31 We're talking 100% of the code.

0:25:32 I think we're somewhere in the get it varies on day to day.

0:25:36 When I think about it, it's between 65 and 85%.

0:25:40 So we're over 50% of the way there from that standpoint.

0:25:44 And I guess where I was going with some of that

0:25:46 is I'm leaning more towards councilman read

0:25:49 in the sense of looking at getting that done by years in.

0:25:55 But then now also looking at Councilman Stone's request

0:25:59 to maybe start looking,

0:26:01 looking at defining the scope,

0:26:03 if we can't get over that finish line,

0:26:05 can we have a conversations with this group

0:26:08 to help us get together to that point?

0:26:10 So I think Councilman Stone,

0:26:13 I think the request would be appropriate,

0:26:16 but I'd also like to ask maybe to put,

0:26:18 let staff finish their portion of the commitment,

0:26:21 and if we're not done by maybe years

0:26:23 And as we're working through some of the budgeting process,

0:26:26 we might have a better chance of capturing

0:26:29 an additional scope or a modification

0:26:32 to that scope in the budgeting process.

0:26:33 Is that fair?

0:26:35 Yeah, but I think at the same time,

0:26:36 if we put that modification onto the motion,

0:26:38 it would allow them to figure out what a dollar amount would be.

0:26:41 I agree.

0:26:42 We'd really empower them to enter a negotiation

0:26:44 so we can get a scope of that where we are short-handed.

0:26:47 Yeah, I don't think it would cost.

0:26:49 I don't think a change or a modification

0:26:53 asking for that modification is a big deal I think it's something that can be done it looks like

0:26:58 councilman reedy have a yeah just quick question and this might be a little bit

0:27:04 challenging to answer understanding you you've just said six months so all of us

0:27:10 now are you through that out there we've all worked together we understand

0:27:21 what's going on at what point in time in the next few months would you know

0:27:27 whether or not you will hit that deadline and and the reason is understanding

0:27:34 where we're at right now if you were two months down the road and you're like yeah

0:27:39 no way or in two months I just and the reason I ask is I would love to have a

0:27:46 follow-up if two months if a month if three months is when you can come in

0:27:50 and say, yep, I'm going to hit it, or snowball's

0:27:53 chance and you know where, and that's

0:27:55 where we come in and we start having that.

0:27:57 My concern, anytime we bring in another third party,

0:28:01 even with their help, now is it going

0:28:05 to be a year down the road, because you're

0:28:06 going to have to help them understand what we're doing

0:28:10 for them to help us, and now it's going to take even more time.

0:28:14 Sometimes external help isn't helpful.

0:28:18 So that's kind of where I'm at.

0:28:22 When would you be able to say, yep, January, we're good?

0:28:27 Or not at all?

0:28:28 I hope to know by January.

0:28:31 I think it's going to be sometime in September knowing.

0:28:34 So I know our workload, we're getting what's happening

0:28:39 to like, currently in the queue, and I have tomorrow.

0:28:44 The current workload for the next six to 12 weeks

0:28:48 is less in terms of applications.

0:28:51 And that's what's really, some of this issues come up with,

0:28:54 is applications I don't get to predict

0:28:56 when subdivisions come or development occurs.

0:29:00 And so that ends up being a primary

0:29:01 because they have certain deadlines.

0:29:03 This is the one that gets pushed.

0:29:04 But I know in the next 12 weeks, we have less items

0:29:07 that are gonna take less issues

0:29:10 or time for me to deal with.

0:29:12 So I think by September,

0:29:14 and I know that puts the council in a difficult spot

0:29:16 in terms of budgeting some of those things,

0:29:19 the budget would have been done at that point.

0:29:20 but I think September, I'll know if I'm going to meet it by January.

0:29:24 The idea is to have most of the things that are controversial in front of you for some work sessions

0:29:30 scheduled out between August, September and October.

0:29:35 And I would be comfortable and we don't need to add this.

0:29:38 It can just be something we work with staff saying in September, we would like an update.

0:29:43 And Mitch, I was going to ask you a question, anyhow, and so I'm glad to see pop up.

0:29:51 But my question was, would we have to have a motion to ultimately direct staff to start

0:29:57 scoping some of that additional scope and looking at the budget process?

0:30:02 Could we approve this contingency and then just ask staff to start looking at a potential

0:30:08 negotiation with that?

0:30:10 So I have a couple of thoughts.

0:30:15 I don't necessarily need a motion to have us look into that kind of thing.

0:30:20 The bigger problem would be the funding for it, right?

0:30:24 So what we're asking for tonight is use some of the contingency money in this year's

0:30:29 fiscal year 24 budget to do that.

0:30:32 It's a little bit difficult for us to go negotiate scope when we don't have funding for the scope.

0:30:38 And so the motion might be necessary if we want to tie up some money.

0:30:43 Go along with the negotiations like maybe the rest of the contingency or or some amount, right?

0:30:49 I kind of would prefer maybe to go where Chris was going and I actually when before you said what you said,

0:30:56 that's what I put my thing in there.

0:30:57 Maybe what we do is we come back to you like the first or second meeting in September,

0:31:03 give you a progress report of where we're at and that will give us still a couple of weeks left

0:31:07 in the fiscal year to where we, if we need to at that point,

0:31:10 we can still grab some of that contingency money that might be left

0:31:12 over or end of your savings that we might have

0:31:15 and do something without that.

0:31:18 Because we also have not put anything in the budget for fiscal year 25

0:31:22 for this project and at that point, I mean that,

0:31:25 we're delivering that budget to you next week, so it's a little,

0:31:28 it'll be a little bit of a rush to get something in there.

0:31:32 I think my preference would be why don't we come back in a couple months,

0:31:37 give the status, you know, let Jonathan and his team work for the next 12 to 16 weeks

0:31:42 that we set up.

0:31:44 And then see where we're at.

0:31:46 And Jonathan and I have had this conversation too, and we do feel like we can get some of

0:31:51 those work sessions that process started before the end of the year fall, late fall kind of

0:31:57 time frame.

0:31:58 So I do agree with you, Chris, that it might be difficult getting a new contract up to speed

0:32:06 if these guys can't add it to their workload.

0:32:11 All right, and that sounds reasonable and logical to me

0:32:14 to be able as long as we have some idea of when an update

0:32:18 would come so we can just move in and help BAF is.

0:32:25 If you want to, or do you want to make this,

0:32:27 still make the motion or, Chris, recent?

0:32:32 Yeah, thank you, Vice Mayor Brown.

0:32:34 I will make a motion to allocate $22,585 from contingency

0:32:39 to continue the Title 10 rewrite contract.

0:32:42 Do I have a second?

0:32:43 I'll second then.

0:32:45 We have a first and a second to reallocate $22,585

0:32:51 from contingency to continue the Title 10 rewrite.

0:32:54 Any further discussion?

0:32:57 Maybe roll call vote.

0:32:59 Grace and Stone?

0:33:00 Yes.

0:33:01 Chris Reed?

0:33:01 Yes.

0:33:02 Hayson Brown?

0:33:03 Yes.

0:33:03 Spencer Cutler?

0:33:04 Yes.

0:33:04 And Sherry Wilmer?

0:33:05 Yes.

0:33:08 Motion passes 5-0. Thank you Jonathan, appreciate it. Next item for consideration is a request

0:33:15 to reject single-bed review received from the Canyon Trails Junction Project in accordance

0:33:21 with Idaho State Law. It's statute 67-2805 and it looks like we have Wendy Davis.

0:33:29 Good evening again. So this is a request and the Canyon Trail Junction Project is that park

0:33:39 and trailhead at the corner of Pulline in Eastland.

0:33:43 We have the design concepts.

0:33:45 We put the bid packet together.

0:33:47 We had a pre-bid meeting, put it through the public bid process,

0:33:53 the formal bid process.

0:33:55 We had a estimate of about $1.1 million on the project.

0:34:02 And the bids came in at 2.9.

0:34:05 The one bid we got.

0:34:07 We are hoping that that's something we can rectify.

0:34:10 We're not sure exactly how, but at the moment,

0:34:13 we're about $2 million short on the project.

0:34:16 So we're requesting to use 67-208-2805-2A8,

0:34:27 which gives you guys the discretion to reject the bid,

0:34:35 and then we'll kind of look at some options

0:34:37 as we move forward from there.

0:34:39 But that's what our request is at the moment is.

0:34:42 Rejection, see if we can do better.

0:34:44 Okay, thank you, Wendy.

0:34:46 Any questions?

0:34:51 So Wendy, this gives us an opportunity.

0:34:53 Will we go back to the contractor

0:34:57 and kind of go through that bit

0:34:58 and try to figure out with them first and foremost

0:35:00 if there's an area that we can work with

0:35:04 because this does allow us to do some open negotiation

0:35:08 at this point, correct?

0:35:09 Not the way I'm reading this.

0:35:12 So the way I read this is we first reject.

0:35:16 I have about 15 plan holders,

0:35:18 so I was going to reach out

0:35:20 and try to find out why they didn't bid

0:35:23 and see if I can see some sort of a trend or something.

0:35:26 At that point, based on the way this is written

0:35:32 and the advice I'm getting from legal

0:35:34 is that we can take it back out to bid,

0:35:38 change the bid documents and re-bid it,

0:35:41 or if we can determine, find fact,

0:35:45 that it can be done cheaper, I can come back,

0:35:48 and we're still a little unsure exactly

0:35:50 what that process would look like.

0:35:53 But either way, I'll be back with a proposal

0:35:55 of here's how we wanna go forward with this,

0:35:57 whether it's re-bid it or negotiate.

0:36:00 But in order to negotiate because we have a bid,

0:36:03 we'd have to pass a resolution in order to do that.

0:36:08 Perfect, so any further discussion or a motion?

0:36:20 Okay, Sherry Volmer.

0:36:22 Hi, I'll do the motion to consider the request to reject or to reject a single bid received

0:36:28 for the Canyon Trail Junction Project in accordance with Idaho Statute 67-2805.

0:36:34 Have a motion, do I have a second?

0:36:36 I have a motion and a second to reject the single bid received for the Canyon Trail Junction

0:36:42 projects in accordance with Idaho State statute 67-2805 any further discussion.

0:36:50 Amy roll call vote. Chris Reed yes Jason Brown yes

0:36:56 Spencer Cutler yes Jerry Volmer yes and Grayson Stone yes it looks like motion

0:37:03 passes 5 to 0. Thank you and I'll be back with some recommendations. Thank you

0:37:08 Wendy the next item up on our calendar is a presentation and an update on the

0:37:15 preliminary remodel concept for the city pool at Mitch Humpel.

0:37:20 So if the council will recall in the fiscal year 24 budget, we have included some funds

0:37:33 to hire architect to design a remodel to the pool.

0:37:38 If you'll recall a year or so ago, we were talking about this project and how the pool

0:37:43 is kind of dated, it needs some attention, right?

0:37:47 needs primarily what the remodel is trying to accomplish is to put restrooms and locker

0:37:53 rooms in changing areas, showers in place that are more single or family-style rather

0:37:59 than just big locker room kind of style to kind of change with the times.

0:38:04 And so we went through a process, we selected coal architects out of Boise, coal has done

0:38:10 similar projects like this across, and I know they've been helping us skip to this

0:38:15 point. This first phase of the contract with Cole was a schematic design. So this

0:38:22 is what you're going to see as not construction plans at this point. This was

0:38:26 just to kind of get us a floor plan to see if we liked what we were at, and then

0:38:31 if we do, we'll continue to move forward with them and to create some sort of

0:38:35 construction plan type thing. We do at some point need to have a conversation

0:38:39 about funding Travis mentioned a couple of weeks ago

0:38:42 where we kind of think we might be landing on funding

0:38:44 and he has some ideas on how to do that.

0:38:47 And so we don't want to spend a whole lot of money

0:38:51 on design until we can really have a conversation about,

0:38:54 can we even do the project in the first place?

0:38:56 And so that's why we structured the contract the way it is.

0:38:58 And so what we have here that I just wanted to show you

0:39:01 is the current, I guess, what we would call our final schematic.

0:39:06 I want to throw it out there for you guys

0:39:08 to shoot holes that or tell us it looks fantastic or whatever you want to do.

0:39:12 So, that's just the site you all know where the pool is, right?

0:39:18 That is the current layout of the pool in its current form.

0:39:23 I put that up there so that if you want to we can flip back and forth so we can see the changes.

0:39:27 But this is the current layout of the pool.

0:39:29 Then the next one would be the new or proposed floor plan.

0:39:33 And on your screens you probably have a little bit of color on this one up here.

0:39:39 I don't know why that is, but anyway, so I'm going to just kind of show you what we've

0:39:45 done here.

0:39:46 Let me back up to the current floor plan.

0:39:50 The current floor plan, you see this front wall is like a big CMU wall and then you've

0:39:55 got some landscaping out in front of it.

0:39:57 And when I say in front of it, this would be to the west of the pool.

0:40:02 So what we've done is we've added basically square footage to the facility.

0:40:06 This is about 1,300-ish square feet that we're proposing to add, and it's basically pushing

0:40:11 the facility out toward the drive-through drop-off lane, and all of this stuff up here

0:40:18 in the front, you'll see this new square footage, and what we've done is we've moved

0:40:24 the entry, and this is actually not – wasn't one of our primary reasons for doing this,

0:40:30 but once we got into it, this was a fantastic thing that we could accomplish, right?

0:40:34 right now that main front door is facing the setting sun, it's facing the prevailing wind,

0:40:40 and so every time those doors open and close, it's just like a wind tunnel through there and

0:40:45 it's got giant windows and so the sun just kind of bakes them all afternoon. And so moving

0:40:50 this main entry to the south, right off the parking lot, made a whole lot of sense to

0:40:55 us for several reasons. And so that was just kind of a stroke of luck. That wasn't the

0:41:02 plan, but it works out really well. So the entryway is there. We create an office

0:41:06 space for the pool manager, which he's never had an office space. He just kind

0:41:09 of has to sit out there with all the lifeguards, and so this will give him a

0:41:12 little bit more ability to do his job. And then right beyond that, we put right

0:41:18 down the middle where the current office is. We've dropped in these kind of single

0:41:24 user restrooms, showers, change rooms with a with a ADA family kind of a

0:41:31 restroom shower kind of in the back. And so folks can come into this route, walk past

0:41:37 all these singles and if you're the kind of person that would prefer one of

0:41:41 those you can jump into one of those. If you're the kind of person would prefer the

0:41:44 locker room style you can go straight into those same entries that you would go

0:41:47 into for the locker rooms as they currently exist. And the locker rooms as

0:41:53 they currently exist felt it was important to maintain a locker room style of changing

0:42:01 area because we still have a lot of teams that will have a lot of people come and go

0:42:05 at the same time and we'll still need some of that type of space.

0:42:09 And so what we've done is we've maintained that kind of space, although we've cleaned

0:42:12 it up and freshened it up a bit, you'll notice the big difference in the showers right now.

0:42:19 If you walk out through those showers, they're just kind of open for everybody and they're

0:42:23 just spraying you from both sides as you go in. Here we're creating little shower

0:42:27 cubicles I guess you'd call them. That's probably not what I was probably not

0:42:32 really calling but stalls. There you go. And it's a little bit more, well not

0:42:40 everybody who walks by is going to get sprayed with the shower, right? And it's

0:42:44 a little bit more covering folks up, right? Some others are just out there, right?

0:42:50 And so those those chains are made in both sides of the lockrooms and then

0:42:54 we've put these single use ones kind of right down the middle and then the

0:43:00 final thing not really the final thing two more things so we've created this

0:43:03 training space up here right now when the when the team gets out there and they

0:43:10 train lifeguards with CPR and all those kinds of things we do classes they're

0:43:15 doing it on the pool deck and this will give more like a training room to kind

0:43:18 of do that kind of thing they also have some ideas for programming that they

0:43:22 would like to start offering inside of a training room, not necessarily in the

0:43:26 water. And so this creates that space for that. And then finally the guard room

0:43:32 right here. Right now the guards are kind of all cramped in a closet, kind of off

0:43:39 the back of the building over here and it's super tight and not in the building

0:43:43 and not conditioned space and all that kind of stuff in here. We can move the

0:43:47 guard room and give them actually some good space with a big window where they

0:43:51 can look right out on the pool and they can see what's going on. And so I guess in

0:43:56 short you feel like this layout really improves the pool operations. It

0:44:02 freshens it up to a more modern kind of a standard. It provides all the single-use

0:44:08 facilities that we wanted to try and provide while still maintaining the

0:44:12 locker room type facilities. And so at the staff level, the folks at the pool

0:44:19 have been in on this Parks and Rec has been in on this and I've been in on this

0:44:23 and we all kind of landed like this is probably a good layout that we want to

0:44:29 move forward with. So what I wanted to do tonight was show it get your thoughts if

0:44:35 you want us to go back and make any significant changes all or this is the

0:44:41 opportunity to do that. This is not an action item tonight so we don't necessarily

0:44:44 need a motion in the vote just looking for feedback I guess and if you got questions

0:44:52 we can certainly answer questions I think Wendy might still be here and the other

0:44:58 thing is this all this also provides a whole bunch of windows along the front

0:45:01 wall here so it's not just a big block wall anymore so I think it's actually

0:45:05 probably gonna be more attractive from the street too. The questions or comments

0:45:11 from Sherry Volmer.

0:45:15 This looks fantastic, like the entryway and the training space and whatnot, the locker rooms.

0:45:21 The only question I have is from vestibules into both locker rooms. Looks like there's a clear line of sight.

0:45:30 Yeah, so let me show you. On the current plan, you see there's this little kind of sneaky looking walkway to go in there.

0:45:40 And on the new plan, that space has been used for one of the showers and a storage room for the training.

0:45:48 And so what we did instead is we put a series of two doors.

0:45:51 And so the thought would be doors are going to open and close separately rather than just have an open view.

0:45:59 Better use of the space, but still kind of with the double door we maintain.

0:46:03 But there will be enough space in between there that we don't have some people.

0:46:06 All the doors open.

0:46:07 That's going to be probably a dish feeding the two doors.

0:46:13 Awesome.

0:46:14 Looking at it, it looks like eight to ten feet.

0:46:16 I think it looks great.

0:46:18 It'd be hard to hold them both open, but two people could do it, I guess.

0:46:21 Yeah, well, yeah.

0:46:22 Then we're really stretching there.

0:46:24 Okay, thank you.

0:46:26 Any other questions or comments?

0:46:28 Mitch, I think myself, I think the concept looks good, Mitch, I think for tonight's purposes.

0:46:37 I think we, to move forward and see what this looks like on the future.

0:46:44 These pictures here are just some shots about what those locker room showers might turn out to be once we

0:46:54 except provide a little bit more privacy, but still have the showers and lock rooms. I forgot those were there.

0:47:03 Just a few ideas. I haven't landed on one yet.

0:47:07 Appreciate it. Okay.

0:47:09 Hey. Any other thoughts? No. Anything else from Council?

0:47:13 Okay. No, I think-

0:47:14 Thank you Mitch. Sounds good.

0:47:16 Appreciate it.

0:47:17 So it looks like we've concluded this portion of our council tonight.

0:47:29 Now we'll move into the general public input portion.

0:47:33 There's any general public out there that would like to comment, just as a reminder,

0:47:39 anything that was discussed on tonight's calendar or personnel items, we won't discuss

0:47:46 Any further at this point, do I have anybody that stand?

0:47:53 Okay, seeing nobody, we'll move on to advisory board reports

0:47:58 and city management updates.

0:48:00 Any advisory reports, okay?

0:48:05 City manager's office.

0:48:07 Oh gosh, if nobody else is gonna say anything,

0:48:09 I feel like I should say something.

0:48:11 I have a few things that I wanted to share

0:48:15 with the council this Thursday evening.

0:48:17 at five o'clock at Harman Park.

0:48:22 The Parks Department is gonna be hosting an open house

0:48:25 to get some feedback and public input on a design

0:48:30 or some improvements we're proposing at the Skate Park.

0:48:34 And we've been working with some community partners

0:48:38 at a contract with a designer.

0:48:40 So this will be the opportunity for the public to come

0:48:43 and kinda share their thoughts

0:48:44 of how the Skate Park could be.

0:48:46 And so we would encourage folks who have an interest in skate

0:48:49 parks, so up at Harmon Park, at five o'clock on Thursday.

0:48:54 Thursday at five o'clock.

0:48:55 So this coming Thursday at five o'clock,

0:48:58 right near the skate park.

0:48:59 Near the skate park at Harmon Park, yep.

0:49:02 So we'll also be sending out a PSA.

0:49:05 Josh has got it ready to go tomorrow on this same issue.

0:49:10 Secondly, week from today is the most wonderful time

0:49:16 of the year for some of our folks and it's budget season kicks kicked off and so

0:49:21 you are reserving pretty much your entire meeting to hear from Travis in the proposed

0:49:27 budget. It's going to be the whole thing, right? The preliminary presentation on the

0:49:32 budget. Following weeks then we'll just dive down into folks series and the

0:49:37 strategic plan but this presentation next week is going to be the whole thing of it.

0:49:41 So, if you will be delivering books, if you want books, if you want hard copies,

0:49:47 you'll have PDFs if you just want electronic copy later this week.

0:49:51 And so, we'll be looking for those and if you have questions, anything, it's all fair game, the whole thing, right?

0:49:57 So, I'll be prepared for that on Monday and then the following week on the 8th, we will not have accounts meeting, look for a busy meeting on the 15th.

0:50:08 Okay, sounds good. Thanks. I appreciate it. Well at this point it looks like this is the conclusion of our meeting. So meeting adjourn

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, June 24, 2024. The recording started at 16:58 by the recorder's clock and runs 00:50:26.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    99784d6d51286f6c9eff0fd894eb06467d476088dd5cae324fe6280dc269a0b7
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 4d116e1c2bb47a198056ed4c664d4479b59dc6e2422d3579c8eef84c2f1f860e
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    999247bbf5ef9e34deffa102ff775903eb8d29ba0ad6fc98f4ad11114b11a4fa

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file