City Council meeting
Monday, August 5, 2024
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on fileMinutes on file
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Transcript
0:03:38 Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the August 5th 2024 City Council meeting.
0:03:45 I would like to confirm we have a quorum.
0:03:48 We have six members present in chambers and Councilman Cutler is on the phone.
0:03:55 First item of the agenda on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.
0:03:59 If you wish to join me, please rise.
0:04:19 Thank you.
0:04:20 We have no proclamations tonight and next on the agenda is the consent calendar.
0:04:26 wishes to approve thank you Craig Hawkins thank you motion by Chris Reed
0:04:32 seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the consent calendar has written Amy Roll
0:04:39 call vote please Ruth Pierce yes Chris Reed yes Craig Hawkins yes Jason Brown
0:04:48 yes Spencer Cutler says yes via chat okay very Volmer yes and Grayson Stone
0:04:57 Yes.
0:04:58 Thank you.
0:04:59 Motion passes seven to zero.
0:05:02 Next we move to items of consideration.
0:05:05 The first item is action item, a request to adopt ordinance 2024-006, amending the Addison
0:05:14 Spring Subdivision Zoning Development Agreement and changes to the Subdivision Master Plan.
0:05:21 And we have, well, welcome, well, you grew a beard in between.
0:05:26 Look at you.
0:05:27 I lost mine.
0:05:28 I grew up here.
0:05:29 I grew up here.
0:05:30 Oh, is that what it was?
0:05:32 Okay.
0:05:33 Welcome.
0:05:34 You came in, man.
0:05:36 Welcome.
0:05:37 Glad you said that.
0:05:38 Yeah.
0:05:39 Yeah.
0:05:41 So, today we have, as in springs, the ZDA zoning development agreement, an ordinance.
0:05:49 This will look familiar to all of you.
0:05:54 this went to the actual amendments went to planning zoning on January 23rd.
0:06:06 This the CDA amendment came before you before this council on February 26th on March 11th,
0:06:16 the ordinance was brought before you.
0:06:18 However, when we got to examine the signatures a little bit closer, it wasn't the original
0:06:26 ink signature, so we couldn't record it.
0:06:31 It took a while to get that ink signature, and because of state statute, we had to be
0:06:38 recorded from 30 days of passage of the ordinance, and so this is just to come before
0:06:43 you again to follow that state statute of the recording ordinance timeline that they have.
0:06:55 As a reminder, this ZDA amendment was to allow for drive-throughs and to amend the master
0:07:08 plan to increase the storage area, reduce a little bit of office area. That's the really
0:07:17 the gist of what the amendment had to offer. And so if you have any questions, I'll stand
0:07:23 for you. So I understand to pass this ordinance, we can put it on third and final. Yes, that's
0:07:31 correct. Chris Reed. I don't have a question, I'll put on the motion. Go ahead, Chris. I
0:07:38 move that we dispense with the reading rules and place ordinance 2024-001 on
0:07:43 third and final reading by title only. It's actually 006. Sorry yep.
0:07:49 Sherry Volmer. I second. Thank you. Motion by Chris Reed seconded by I love
0:07:59 technology. Seconded by Sherry Volmer to put ordinance 2024-006 on third and
0:08:07 final reading by title only. Amy Roke, I'll vote, please.
0:08:16 Chris Reed.
0:08:17 Yes.
0:08:18 Greg Hawkins.
0:08:19 Yes.
0:08:20 Jason Brown.
0:08:21 Yes.
0:08:23 Spencer Cutler.
0:08:26 Yeah.
0:08:27 Sherry Volmer.
0:08:28 Yes.
0:08:29 And Grayson Stone.
0:08:30 Yes.
0:08:31 Yes.
0:08:32 Thank you. Motion passes seven to zero.
0:08:34 Okay.
0:08:35 Next would be a motion on the ordinance.
0:08:37 Let me read that, please.
0:08:38 Ordinance number 2024 dash zero, zero six.
0:08:41 In ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho
0:08:45 amending the Addison Springs subdivision zoning development agreement and changes to
0:08:50 The subdivision master plan grace and stone
0:08:54 You're up. Yeah, I'll skip you Chris read
0:09:01 Move to approve ordinance 2024 dash zero zero six. Thank you. Sherry Volmer
0:09:09 Thank you motion by Chris read second by Sherry Volmer to
0:09:12 to approve the adoption of Ordinance 2024-006 amending the Addison Spring Subdivision Zoning
0:09:21 Development Agreement and changes to the Subdivision Master Plan.
0:09:26 Amy Roll-call-vote, please.
0:09:29 Greg Hawkins.
0:09:30 Yes.
0:09:31 Jason Brown.
0:09:32 Yes.
0:09:34 Spencer Cutler.
0:09:35 Yeah.
0:09:36 Grayson Stone.
0:09:37 Yes.
0:09:38 Barry Bomer.
0:09:39 Yes.
0:09:40 Ruth Pierce.
0:09:41 Yes.
0:09:42 And Chris Reed.
0:09:43 Yes.
0:09:44 Next item on the agenda is an action item.
0:09:48 A request to approve the purchase of a 2025
0:09:51 MACCAB and chassis for $159,747 using a cooperative
0:09:59 purchasing agreement with Sourcewell.
0:10:01 And we have our street department superintendent,
0:10:04 Mark Thompson, welcome, Mark.
0:10:06 Thank you very much.
0:10:07 Appreciate you giving me the opportunity to come
0:10:09 before you tonight and make this request.
0:10:12 The purchase of this truck was taken through the LTP process and also approved through the
0:10:18 fiscal year 2324 budget.
0:10:21 The request before you tonight is to approve staff to use that to purchase through Source
0:10:27 Well.
0:10:28 In 2019, the City Council passed a resolution authorizing City staff to join and use cooperative
0:10:35 purchasing programs.
0:10:38 These staff can approve purchases up to the informal bid limit and anything above the informal
0:10:44 bid limit of 150,000 has to be approved by the City Council.
0:10:49 With the Council's approval, we'll be purchasing a 2025 MAC cabin chassis and our current
0:10:55 truck will be sold to the wastewater treatment plant.
0:10:58 This truck will be used as a dump truck.
0:11:01 We've been working with another vendor to make that purchase.
0:11:06 If you're approval tonight, we'll move forward with that
0:11:10 purchase.
0:11:11 And if everything works out, we're hoping to see delivery of the truck by mid-September.
0:11:21 So we had $210,730,000 budgeted, and we are under that budgeted amount.
0:11:28 The source has been reviewed and approved by our attorney as a cooperative purchasing
0:11:33 program to be utilized by the code 67-2807 and I can stand for any questions thank you Mark so
0:11:44 I'm happy to see it's under budget yay this has been probably one of the toughest purchases
0:11:50 we've made well it looks great grace and stone and a mayor I'm ready to make a motion if there's
0:11:55 no other discussion Jason are you good okay go ahead grace but a mayor I make a motion that we
0:12:02 approve the request to purchase a 2025 Mac cabin chassis for a hundred fifty nine
0:12:09 thousand seven forty seven he's in a cooperative purchase agreement with
0:12:13 source well thank you Jason Brown okay thank you motion by grace and stone
0:12:18 seconded by Jason Brown to approve the purchase of the 2025 Mac cabin chassis
0:12:24 for $159,747 using a cooperative purchasing agreement with Sourcewell. Any further discussion?
0:12:35 Amy Rokavo, please.
0:12:37 Jason Brown?
0:12:38 Yes.
0:12:39 Spencer Cutler?
0:12:42 Yes.
0:12:43 Grayson Stone?
0:12:44 Yes.
0:12:45 Mary Vollmer?
0:12:46 Yes.
0:12:47 Ruth Pierce?
0:12:48 Yes.
0:12:49 Chris Reed?
0:12:50 Yes.
0:12:51 Thank you.
0:12:52 Motion passes 7-0.
0:12:53 Thank you, Mark.
0:12:55 Okay, that is all under items of consideration.
0:12:59 Next, we actually have three public hearings,
0:13:03 and they're all different, so bear with me.
0:13:06 The first is an action item.
0:13:08 It's a request for a zoning title amendment
0:13:11 to Title 10, Chapter 11,
0:13:14 required improvements, and Chapter 13 building permits,
0:13:18 modifying the timing of installation
0:13:21 for required infrastructure and conditions
0:13:25 to obtain our certificate of occupancy
0:13:27 and we have our planning and zoning director,
0:13:30 Jonathan Spinn, love welcome.
0:13:31 Thank you, Madam Mayor and I'm going to reflect back
0:13:33 and have you read the public hearing portion
0:13:37 because this is a title 10 land use item
0:13:39 you probably need to read that public hearing section
0:13:42 before we open the hearing again.
0:13:47 That no, if we said no, I'll go with that.
0:13:49 Okay. All right.
0:13:50 I wasn't here to give those instructions.
0:13:52 Yeah, so we are reopening.
0:13:53 Continuing the open the here. Yes continuing the hearing. Okay. Go ahead. Alright. So first off
0:13:58 I added a few commas where we needed to as requested from last time
0:14:04 I'm gonna go through the changes. I'm not gonna read my staff report verbatim going to just get through we
0:14:11 Limited some of the items that we're confusing
0:14:13 particularly in the first section we
0:14:16 Added the commas and then most specifically if you look at the end which is in
0:14:22 in chapter 13, and what was attached, we created option number one and option number two.
0:14:31 Option number one is what was requested from the council to have the retainer be held by
0:14:38 the city in its entirety.
0:14:41 When there was failure for applicants or contractors to finish the project by the expiration
0:14:49 date. I also added a specific timeline that expires and then option two gives a sort of
0:14:55 a pro-rated 30-day timeline. And what it breaks down to is after day one expiration is 25% on day
0:15:07 15. After the expiration we retain 50% and then after day 30 would be a 100% retainer for clarity.
0:15:29 But briefly we took out the confusing portion because up here it says unless otherwise provided
0:15:35 we added in this chapter kind of cleaned that part up.
0:15:38 It wasn't a lot of changes we had in here until we get to the parking parking,
0:15:44 which is the hard surfacing, which is a subsection now,
0:15:47 as requested with the commas because that was the part we needed last time.
0:15:52 We get all the way down to chapter 13, which is where we have option one and option two.
0:15:58 So option one just states in the event to temporary certificate,
0:16:02 expires without completion of the required improvements.
0:16:05 the entire retainer amount shall be forfeited to the City of Twin Falls, and we added in
0:16:09 addition we can do other items as required. Option 2 gives you those for rated or 30 day
0:16:17 after the expiration. To be clear we put in an expiration here which is 5 pm on the date
0:16:25 listed on the temporary. Under this the temporary talks about the non-refundive retainer with
0:16:32 one extension of three months on the new application.
0:16:39 So what you need is, I guess, this is part, well, it was part one.
0:16:45 Okay.
0:16:46 So those are the things we added that you requested to come back for.
0:16:50 There's two other portions of this that are also in the report.
0:16:53 One is under the budgetary portion.
0:16:55 It talks about throughout this whole conversation, we've really only ever been talking about commercial
0:17:00 projects or commercial permits.
0:17:02 We never really brought up residential.
0:17:06 I just didn't cross my mind because it wasn't really an issue that we've had however as we
0:17:12 advertised the master fee schedule it had just one change I'm going to talk about
0:17:22 this is how it's advertised on the master fee schedule that you'll be seeing coming up it says
0:17:31 temporary certificate of occupancy with an application cost of $1,200 per application and extension and
0:17:37 And then the retainer at 1.5%, which is what we talked about last time.
0:17:42 The way this is advertised, it applies to both commercial and residential.
0:17:46 I have provided if you would like to have this option, options two and three for the master fee schedule discussion, which is going to take place in the hearing after this.
0:17:57 But since they're sort of connected and bringing it up here.
0:18:01 Option two would have the new residential application fee,
0:18:04 which is less, it's cost less,
0:18:08 and the same residential retainer
0:18:11 that we currently have as practiced today.
0:18:15 But if I have a house that needs a temporary today,
0:18:18 we have just the $1,000 refundable,
0:18:20 and that applied to both commercial and residential,
0:18:22 there was no difference.
0:18:24 It can keep that 1,000 with option two,
0:18:27 and then you still have these others
0:18:30 it would apply to commercial projects,
0:18:33 where it's essentially exempting single family
0:18:35 and duplex permits as they're issued.
0:18:38 There's another option three, if you so wished.
0:18:42 The new application for the single family is $500,
0:18:45 and then you could do it, if it wanted to be similar
0:18:48 to a percentage, it'd be 0.5%,
0:18:51 minimum of 1,000, maximum of 5,000.
0:18:55 On a median household or median home of 350,000,
0:18:58 it comes to 1750, if my math is good,
0:19:01 which sometimes it's not, but it's around there.
0:19:05 The reason why it's only 500 for single family
0:19:07 is there's only one inspector that goes out for that.
0:19:11 When you're doing single family residential,
0:19:13 the engineering, the zoning,
0:19:16 and most of the public works items are already finished.
0:19:18 That's to do the subdivision.
0:19:20 When it's a commercial project
0:19:22 and you're doing all of those at the same time,
0:19:23 all of those people have to go out that second time.
0:19:26 So the 500 is really one inspector of the building official.
0:19:29 And then when you're doing any type of refundable amount,
0:19:33 we get finance people involved,
0:19:35 and it quickly gets up to around that $500 mark.
0:19:39 That discussion can happen,
0:19:41 but the action you would need to take
0:19:43 is on the Master Fee Schedule Public Hearing.
0:19:46 I provide this as an option to you.
0:19:48 When you get to that discussion for the public hearing,
0:19:52 we can have the discussion now for any consequences,
0:19:56 run at 10 to consequences that we're creating
0:19:58 with the title 10 item.
0:20:00 So it looks like we have two things to talk about.
0:20:04 Number one is this option one or two.
0:20:09 And if I understand, we'll ask you questions.
0:20:13 We will not reach any conclusions.
0:20:17 You were correct.
0:20:18 Sorry, I keep going.
0:20:19 I don't want to have to.
0:20:20 I correct me if I'm wrong.
0:20:22 So because we have a public hearing attached to it,
0:20:26 we'll ask you questions not necessarily
0:20:29 reach conclusions on option one, two, or on the other one, one, two, three, open it up
0:20:36 for public hearing, get input, and then have our discussion.
0:20:40 You're going to definitely want to have the decision or the public hearing item on the
0:20:44 Title 10 language, which is what in front of you here, which is happening in Chapter 13.
0:20:50 The dollar amounts are referred to, we just referenced the Master Fee Schedule in Title
0:20:56 so that the fees can be changed when the council wishes with that.
0:21:01 This specific item is what you'd see you'd want to have the hearing on for Title 10 language.
0:21:07 If anybody wishes to comment on the dollar amount, that is when you'd have that discussion.
0:21:13 The next hearing with the Master Fee Schedule.
0:21:15 Okay, so I kind of phrase that wrong.
0:21:18 Or write this minute before we open the public hearing.
0:21:22 Just questions on option one or two, not necessarily a decision until we have the public hearing.
0:21:28 Correct.
0:21:29 Is that clear?
0:21:30 Okay.
0:21:31 Grayson, do you have a question?
0:21:33 Thank you, Madam Mayor.
0:21:34 So, when we issue our TCO, we make it abundantly clear, and I just want to do this for clarification.
0:21:43 On issuance of a TCO, we make it abundantly clear to our development community whether
0:21:47 be residential or commercial, exactly what they have to accomplish to get their final
0:21:53 CFO correct?
0:21:54 Yes.
0:21:55 And so they're well aware of what they have to accomplish to get their CFO correct?
0:21:59 Yes, every department would put in a result code into the system that gets emailed to
0:22:04 the contractor that this is what is not finished, this is what you need in order to get the
0:22:09 full CFO.
0:22:10 And then my second question is how far are we behind when someone asks for an inspection
0:22:17 get signed off or read to actually go off, do the inspection.
0:22:21 When someone requests the inspection most, the building department is able to do that
0:22:25 most of the time within 24, almost the same day. Engineering and zoning take a bit longer.
0:22:31 We have different duties than just doing inspections. So it ends up being 24 to 48 hours.
0:22:35 From the engineering standpoint, if they're doing infrastructure, sometimes it's a little
0:22:39 bit longer to get water and sewer super out there. They try to do it within a few days.
0:22:44 It's not four weeks, it's not two weeks, it's a couple of days.
0:22:48 So let's say that somebody puts in a request for an inspection, they have it done and then
0:22:53 they go past the expiration.
0:22:55 Is it based upon when they submit for their inspection or is it based upon when it's signed
0:23:00 off?
0:23:01 You're talking about the temporary certificates of expiration day here.
0:23:04 A good question, I think we'd have to follow it up with a policy unless you wanted to say
0:23:07 that specifically.
0:23:08 I would say it's when we accept it because if it's not finished, they can't occupy the
0:23:13 building regardless. I guess, and I guess this is just a general question for the
0:23:18 council, is if they're done on the on the last day of the inspection and we
0:23:24 can't get out there to inspect it, or what we expect to then penalize them
0:23:30 because we couldn't get out there to inspect it in time or is it based upon
0:23:35 when they ask for the inspection. The good question, if they've received the
0:23:40 temporary they will have the six months to get that finished then to come to the
0:23:47 last day for us not to go good question for this council to debate on whether
0:23:52 you want to make that clearer in my opinion I think it should be based upon
0:23:57 when they request final inspection I don't I don't think that we can
0:24:00 necessarily penalize residential and commercial folks if based upon the
0:24:06 city not being out there to finalize their inspections I think it should be
0:24:09 based upon when they ask for the inspection,
0:24:15 I would stand to get everybody else's to say about that.
0:24:24 Presley.
0:24:25 I would agree with that.
0:24:26 I think we need to put it in the policy, in the code,
0:24:30 how we're going to judge that.
0:24:31 So it doesn't come down to the building department
0:24:33 saying, well, you did it the day before,
0:24:36 and now this and that, it's going to cause some problems.
0:24:40 Number two, though, option two,
0:24:42 talk to me about that process to go through it.
0:24:46 What would that look like for your team in managing, you know, the one day, 15 day, 30
0:24:55 day?
0:24:56 So in both of these options, just laying out the project, you have a project starts this
0:25:02 year, it takes you a year, or you're going to have to build, you're not finished and you
0:25:06 want to occupy the building, you're going to request the temporary.
0:25:09 We go out and do an inspection at that point and say these are the items that are not finished,
0:25:13 that you can finish within the next six months
0:25:16 while you're occupying the building.
0:25:20 They're non-life safety issues.
0:25:22 And in this case, for the Title X items,
0:25:23 we're talking about the trash enclosure.
0:25:25 We're talking about stuff that's not required
0:25:28 by the hard-surfacing.
0:25:30 We're talking about landscaping vegetation.
0:25:32 It's all we're allowed to temper,
0:25:33 that's all you can occupy the building for.
0:25:37 At the end of that time period,
0:25:38 we have an automatic calendar thing
0:25:42 to go out and inspect it.
0:25:43 We are going to put it one week
0:25:45 before your expiration date, we can do more.
0:25:49 It's not written the code, but we'd give them an opportunity,
0:25:52 hey, you're coming up on your six months
0:25:53 that you've had to finish.
0:25:56 We then put in the inspection result,
0:25:58 they get the result emailed to them,
0:25:59 whether they pass it or don't,
0:26:01 or they can call us whenever it's done.
0:26:04 If they finish in two months,
0:26:06 they're finished, we put in the result codes,
0:26:08 they're all finished.
0:26:09 If at the end of this, we don't hear from them at all,
0:26:12 and that we don't get an inspection request,
0:26:15 that is the contractor or the owner not requesting it of us,
0:26:18 we will go out eventually
0:26:19 because that time frame is gonna come up.
0:26:22 The system will give us that and get reinspection notice.
0:26:26 We're the option two,
0:26:27 we're gonna have to put those dates
0:26:28 as reinspection dates to go out and see
0:26:32 if it's finished or not.
0:26:35 So we have a mechanism to let us do that.
0:26:38 Problem is gonna be if we are a task
0:26:43 or asked to be more proactive,
0:26:44 it is going to cause us to go out more often.
0:26:47 I believe the intent of this code is to make it financially incentivize the people to finish it before we have to get involved to
0:26:56 Remind them. They're gonna lose the thirty thousand dollars
0:26:59 I think that's the intent of not giving the TCO as easily as we have as easily. It was only thousand dollars
0:27:07 It's gonna be a little bit more difficult up front. We just want them to finish the project
0:27:11 But we have a mechanism of putting those days in and getting result codes
0:27:14 I believe this is the last resort other than issuing a misdemeanor for violation of Title
0:27:20 10.
0:27:21 But really this is meant to dissuade people from getting to that point.
0:27:29 So Jason, I'll get you in the last time I think I asked this question.
0:27:35 As a percent of occupancy permits, excuse me, how many times does this situation happen?
0:27:46 I mean like 80% or 20% it happens versus 80% go fine.
0:27:53 So I believe that we have 60 to 70 currently getting temporary certificates if I can see
0:28:01 we're a little bit higher than that.
0:28:04 Those that go beyond the expiration date are not that so if we had 100, it's 70 of them
0:28:08 are getting temporary of the 100 original you probably have between 10 to 20 or 15 that
0:28:15 go beyond the expiration date.
0:28:17 And it's enough to be concerned, but it's not
0:28:20 Everybody okay. All right. Great. Thank you Jason
0:28:24 I would say to
0:28:28 Councilman stone was talking about I think we need to allow them
0:28:33 full time period and so to me I would I would lean towards if they call on
0:28:42 last day
0:28:44 Give them that that two days or the 48 hours to
0:28:47 for us to get out there. We're not running into this scenario or situation often.
0:28:58 Any more questions for Jonathan? Okay so we had a public hearing on this last time
0:29:21 and so I am going to reopen the public hearing or this particular item only. So
0:29:30 So if there's anybody in the audience that wishes to address City Council on this particular
0:29:36 zoning title amendment, please come forward, state your name and whether you're a citizen
0:29:43 of Twin Falls and you have two minutes to testify.
0:29:47 Is there anybody here that wishes to speak?
0:29:53 Okay.
0:29:54 Team No-One, I guess any further comments, I'll close the public hearing.
0:30:02 further comments from you? Okay, Council, discussion?
0:30:10 Chris Reed. Can we add to see under, right above, to include the things that we kind of
0:30:20 just talked about again, and make sure that we're not putting something on the building
0:30:24 department to have to get the money to the council? So what you're saying is add language
0:30:33 Under the temporary
0:30:37 Yep, temporary
0:30:39 Expires at 10 or five on the day listed and I just put time will be extended up to 10 business days
0:30:46 Understanding engineering might be a little bit farther out. Maybe 10 business days is too long to permit inspections
0:30:53 Madam mayor if I could jump in there real quick, I would just say 10 days from request of inspection
0:31:00 That's how I would phrase that
0:31:03 And I would say 10 business days, I would specify that.
0:31:08 That's right, 10 business days, not calendar days.
0:31:11 Just to make sure that we just give us the buffer that they met the timeline, the request of inspection.
0:31:17 Is 10 days? That seems like a lot. No?
0:31:21 Two more weeks for you.
0:31:23 Yeah, I just want to make sure that on your end, because you kind of meant, sorry, I didn't mean to cut you off, man.
0:31:27 But those TCOs are not engineering, correct?
0:31:31 I mean, for commercial projects, it will be having some of that and they, or those items,
0:31:38 they can, if they're not finished at the point of engineering, not accepting it, it's not going
0:31:46 to be done in 10 days, or some of that, right?
0:31:49 I mean, I just want to give my, our team a buffer to be able to schedule that and get
0:31:54 out there.
0:31:55 I think it'd be, you can extend, meaning we're not going to keep your retainer until we finish
0:32:00 the inspection.
0:32:01 Correct.
0:32:02 days or day or two like you call in the last day that you're gonna it's gonna be
0:32:07 expire for the inspection we won't keep your retainer if you pass the inspection
0:32:11 so you're gonna be scheduling an inspection on that day no matter what
0:32:19 we'll schedule it and it might not occur that day but it might occur a day or two
0:32:24 later why don't we just bump it down to five facilities or no days you don't
0:32:29 I'm not scheduling it. You're going to be there no matter what. Yeah, we're in excellent
0:32:33 Schedulant I wrote just expiration to be extended for inspections to be performed by the city and I
0:32:38 I think that's good perfect because then it's like when we do it if you pass
0:32:44 You fail that happens when you get to the last day of conference spectrum. I finished
0:32:50 I guess would be that's a hard line, but eventually that's kind of we're doing years
0:32:55 Did you have a comment? I
0:32:57 I was going to suggest maybe you just tie it to the request for the final inspection rather than extending it a number of days.
0:33:02 The next sentence would be, you know, request final inspection by five o'clock on that day and you're good unless it fails and then you're not.
0:33:11 I'd agree with that.
0:33:12 Oh, good.
0:33:13 And everybody just look at the idea.
0:33:19 If you get the comment there, that's the comment.
0:33:22 Alright, you guys, give me a break.
0:33:25 Remember, I have the stick.
0:33:27 All right, so you you understand what to be put in there. Okay, so
0:33:34 Grayson, you're up
0:33:35 Made my comment. Okay, Jason. Okay, so we're at a point in time where we need to look at option one or option two
0:33:49 Yes, Chris Reed. I'm ready to make my opinion on which option
0:33:55 I'm in favor of option one. I don't think we need to have the
0:33:58 our team spend any more time doing a one day, a 15 day, a 30 day, that's going to
0:34:09 take more time and energy from our folks let's just move forward with this. That's
0:34:13 my opinion. Sherry. I option one. Grayson. I'll disagree I think with the
0:34:26 labor force words that we can't necessarily control our subcontractors
0:34:30 so I'd be in favor of option two. Okay any other comments?
0:34:45 Just to kind of help expedite the process. It would be appropriate
0:34:52 for a member of the council to make a motion on which option to retain and to see which how the vote goes up or down.
0:35:05 Madam Mayor, quick question. That's with the additional language from Drickerson. Love, correct?
0:35:08 Yes. That comment for item C is going to be done as direct as consensus. This option 1 and 2 seems to be what we needed.
0:35:17 Great. Chris, I'll make the motion right now. We'll see how it goes.
0:35:23 thank you move that we approve option one for the temporary certification
0:35:30 expiration as presented tonight. Do we have a second motion by Chris Reed
0:35:37 seconded by Craig Hawkins to identify option one in our zoning title amendment
0:35:45 document any further discussion? Amy Rokavo please.
0:35:53 Chris and Stone? No. Sherry Bulmer? Yes. Ruth Pierce? Yes. Chris Reed? Yes. Craig
0:36:02 Hawkins? Yes. Jason Brown? Yes. And Spencer Cutler? Yes. Thank you. Motion passes
0:36:11 six to one. Okay. So we've got that taken care of. So the next item would be
0:36:19 adopting the amendment
0:36:23 Presented with option number one correct, okay any discussion on that before I entertain a motion
0:36:35 So a move to approve with the condition of the language changing on items see that you guys talked about
0:36:40 We need to make that part of the
0:36:42 Condition on the motion so that we have the clear direction from the council to include the
0:36:48 The timing to go over the 30 days like we talked about
0:36:53 So we need to-
0:36:55 Just make it part of the motion as a condition.
0:36:57 Okay.
0:36:58 So we don't have to read those.
0:36:59 Yeah, that's necessarily due to the discipline language.
0:37:01 Okay, so we think he's got the language.
0:37:03 Are you good, Chris, including that in your language and whoever's second that, we're good?
0:37:08 Okay, Amy, you got that?
0:37:10 Great second.
0:37:13 So with the condition that the additional language is added to the document.
0:37:21 This will be on the upcoming motion, not the past one.
0:37:26 So Mitch is saying we're going to include the changes you guys made to see,
0:37:30 so we have the inspection date as the date of time.
0:37:33 Never mind, Amy.
0:37:34 Next, next.
0:37:36 Okay, I'm entertaining the motion to adopt these amendments.
0:37:44 Don't all jump at once.
0:37:49 Chris Reed.
0:37:50 I'll jump in.
0:37:51 See if I can get it right.
0:37:52 Move to approve the request for a zoning title amendment to Title 10, Chapter 11,
0:37:58 requiring improvements and Chapter 13, building permits, modifying the timing
0:38:03 and installation for required infrastructure and conditions to be obtained,
0:38:08 a certificate of occupancy with additional language to the temporary certification expiration.
0:38:18 Thank you. Jason Brown.
0:38:19 Second.
0:38:21 Have a m- Thank you.
0:38:23 motion to approve the zoning title amendment and seconded by Jason Brown, zoning title amendment
0:38:30 to title 10 chapter 11, chapter 13, with the changes to the language under temporary certifications.
0:38:42 Any further discussion?
0:38:43 Madam Mayor, just to be clear, that's including option 1, correct?
0:38:47 Yes.
0:38:51 Amy Rolkow, please.
0:38:54 Sherry Volmer, yes. Ruth Pierce, yes. Chris Reed, yes. Craig Hawkins, yes. Jason Brown, yes. Spencer Cutler, yes, and Grayson Stone. No.
0:39:06 Thank you. Motion passes six to one. Mitch. And just for your information, the language you'll be able to see when we bring the ordinance back for your adoption at the future date. Thank you. Thank you for that clarification.
0:39:19 Okay next public hearing is also an action item a request to approve a
0:39:26 resolution of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls Idaho proposing new
0:39:31 fees and amending the city's master fee schedule we have our CFO Brianna Howard
0:39:37 welcome Brianna. Good evening mayor and council so we're so into Idaho Code
0:39:48 Section 63 1311 I am bringing the new fees and the increases over 5% that have
0:39:54 been published. What I have included for your review is everything that we've changed. So
0:40:00 in the last four years that we've done this, I tried to include everything, whether it's
0:40:05 a description change, it's an increase less than 5% or anything more that was published.
0:40:14 There were a handful of fees in specific departments that has changed. The airport fees were an
0:40:22 effort to keep airport raise and fees in step with the increased costs. The
0:40:28 building fees that we that were changed were just discussed by Jonathan. The
0:40:35 engineering fees are specifically increased for the the costs that are
0:40:39 directly associated with what we have to provide. So the supplies that we are
0:40:44 paying for, there were only three building fees that were increased over the 5% and
0:40:49 that was the water service line for an inch. The inch and a half and the two
0:40:54 inch. Those were over five percent. IT added a little description change and then parks added some change on the descriptions as well. So parks and rec have gone through their fees again. We try to keep up with this each year to make sure that everything looks like it's consistent, like it's accurately what we're charging that we have the authority to do so.
0:41:23 And they made some significant-ish changes.
0:41:27 There was a handful of fees that had sales tax still included.
0:41:31 If you remember last year, we changed this for pool.
0:41:34 And now we've caught up to date with, on the rec side of it,
0:41:37 where we're excluding sales tax.
0:41:39 So there's some decreases there for the recreation ones.
0:41:42 There are a handful of fees that we published as new fees for the rec department.
0:41:49 These are not really new fees.
0:41:51 fees. There were ones that were on older resolutions, but because we present this
0:41:55 master fee resolution and it overwrites all the prior resolutions, it dropped off
0:42:00 the list. So there was a handful of new fees that were published that were not
0:42:04 necessarily new. They were just something that did not make the last
0:42:07 resolution. And then after that is utility services. So along with our budget that
0:42:15 we've been presenting, water has increased by two and a half percent. So
0:42:19 all of our water fees are increased by two and a half percent and then the wastewater fees have
0:42:24 increased five percent. The reason behind the wastewater fees going five percent is because we
0:42:30 have a bond covenant calculation where our net system revenues has to be over 125 percent of our
0:42:37 debt. So with that I will ask if there's any questions on any of the fees that were published
0:42:43 or that were presented.
0:42:46 So just to clarify, the fee that Jonathan just went over on the residential side,
0:42:55 residential slash commercial building, that is under the building,
0:43:01 the 1200 is the new fee that we just, that he talked about,
0:43:07 the thousand or whatever number that's going to be.
0:43:11 you have deleted, but I believe that's something we will be discussing as to whether it's 1200,
0:43:22 it's a thousand or it's 500 because there were three options.
0:43:26 Right.
0:43:27 Right now, the way it was published was a conservative approach, we're publishing the
0:43:30 highest amount that it would be, and the way we published it is $1200 that would be applied
0:43:35 to both residential and commercial.
0:43:38 Perfect.
0:43:39 Okay.
0:43:40 Thank you.
0:43:41 So, any questions for, before I open up the public hearing, doesn't look like,
0:43:55 Briana? Thank you. Okay, so, I will be opening up the public hearing here in a
0:44:05 second. It's, and what we're discussing are basically the fees changes. I mean,
0:44:14 everything else has been previously approved in prior fee schedules, so we
0:44:19 would are more appropriately focusing on the fee changes, but we will be approving
0:44:25 the whole fee schedule. So any comments someone might have are welcome on anything.
0:44:31 So with that I will open up the public hearing. Anyone in the audience that
0:44:37 wishes to speak please come up and state your name and whether you're a citizen
0:44:43 or a business owner in Twin Falls and you will have two minutes to make your
0:44:50 presentation. So public hearing is open, is there anybody that wishes to give input
0:44:57 on this item? In Madam Mayor, just for the audience and for clarification I believe
0:45:03 this is also we know that we have members of our tow industry here and this would
0:45:11 be the time in which they would want to have a conversation with the council about any potential
0:45:16 increases as it relates to the fees that are in this. I would hate for our processes to
0:45:23 kind of bypass them through a public hearing system for their awareness.
0:45:26 Okay. Thank you. Is there anybody here that wishes to come up and testify?
0:45:48 Thank you, sir. When you come up, please, is the mic on? We have the mic on for sure. Okay.
0:45:54 please state your name whether you're a citizen, business owner in Twin Falls and
0:45:58 you have two minutes and Amy will be timing you.
0:46:01 Yes, this is my name is Dan Kellinger from Highway 30 garage and Highway 30 going.
0:46:08 The admin fee that we're talking about is coming up that's going to be a $40 fee added
0:46:16 who are as that are impounded to the city and the
0:46:22 I apologize, that's correct. There are two fees that we have publicized as reimbursements of our actual costs that are going to cost the city.
0:46:35 This fee will be able to be passed through to the customer. You mean?
0:46:45 I just wanted to clarify that these fees will be able to be passed to the customer.
0:47:03 Okay, so I think that's an individual business decision.
0:47:08 I would guess there isn't anything holding you back from passing it on to the customer.
0:47:13 Because the contract with the city does that we have guidelines that we have to provide by on what we can and cannot charge a customer.
0:47:23 I'm just making sure that I get it.
0:47:28 Okay, that this is one that qualifies for the what you can charge the customer. Is that are we good?
0:47:34 Yes, it is. Yes, it is
0:47:41 So then this is a new fee
0:47:47 Met America captain Matt Hicks
0:47:52 Didn't see the signals
0:47:54 Thank you, sir
0:47:56 Madal address that sorry for the confusion folks the short version of this is the idea of transportation department
0:48:03 Just very recently had a reinterpretation of the codes that governor our involvement in towing
0:48:09 Katie Garner with our records bureau is here tonight
0:48:12 She manages this process for the city
0:48:14 But it's going to require increased fees for us to be able to manage any toes that we're involved in navigating it
0:48:19 We do have a policy that outlines tow companies that are called at our request
0:48:24 And we will be adding this to the policy, but given the timeline that we have from the
0:48:28 Addera Transportation Department, literally just weeks ago, to try to implement this request
0:48:33 in front of you tonight.
0:48:34 We'll end with it knowing that this one will actually take effect until October, we'll make
0:48:38 sure that the policy is very clear.
0:48:40 Okay.
0:48:41 Thank you.
0:48:42 Does that answer your question, sir?
0:48:43 Thank you.
0:48:44 Is there anybody else in the audience that wishes to address Council on this particular fee
0:48:52 resolution?
0:48:56 Okay.
0:48:57 Seeing no one else, I'll close the public hearing and open it up for council discussion. Grace and Stone.
0:49:04 Mayor, I'm ready to make a motion if there's no further discussion.
0:49:07 Any further discussion with anybody?
0:49:10 Spencer, do you have any comments? He's probably on mute.
0:49:20 Do we need to comment?
0:49:23 Thank you.
0:49:24 We need to discuss the options that Jonathan presented in his public hearing before the final motions made so we can put that in.
0:49:33 Probably should. Good point. Unless you're including that in your motion. Right now the fee as presented is without it.
0:49:43 And it doesn't need to include it. Well it's 1200 for everything as opposed to the option 1, 2, or 3.
0:49:53 And maybe we can put that back up for everybody. Sorry, Grayson. Jason, thanks for good point.
0:50:00 I could call this, right, Councilman Brown.
0:50:06 Okay, so right now on the,
0:50:10 what was published is option one.
0:50:14 And so what was proposed is,
0:50:16 and that covers commercial and residential,
0:50:21 what Jonathan showed us earlier was option one, two, or three.
0:50:29 And so for this discussion before we adopt the resolution,
0:50:34 probably need to make a discussion on this and make a decision as to which item
0:50:38 should be included. So Jason. So Jonathan as I'm looking at this so option 1 is it
0:50:47 doesn't matter if it's residential or commercial correct. Option 2 and option
0:50:53 3 are breaking residential and commercial into two different categories correct.
0:50:58 Yes residential single family and duplex permits which are the so commercial
0:51:03 temporary certificate of
0:51:05 Application is $1,200 correct residential is 500 correct
0:51:12 That's for the non-refundable just the paperwork dollar amount and then see the of $500 with a thousand dollars or five hundred with
0:51:23 Percent and I put the same minimum and maximums just in case yeah, so I mean that'd be a big house could be but
0:51:31 What's the easiest to manage? Are they pretty about sixes?
0:51:43 I give you the absolute easiest to not have a refundable retainer because that is the time,
0:51:48 but it's not necessarily too difficult speaking a little bit for the finance department.
0:51:53 Okay.
0:51:54 Brianna can answer how difficult it is to refund that money more specifically from just an inspection standpoint.
0:52:00 That's why separating single-family and duplexes, there's really very few people that go out on those.
0:52:06 And so it should be a much smaller amount than the 1200.
0:52:09 That was our...
0:52:10 Is that your thought as maybe Option 2 is the way to go?
0:52:13 I believe it is the least intrusive to those that are doing it now.
0:52:19 It is just an extra 500 to deal with the paperwork.
0:52:21 Which in thousands is what they're used to paying.
0:52:24 That would be the least intrusive.
0:52:27 The other one is a bit more.
0:52:29 value into more money and just mimicked what we're doing for commercial was simply why I gave it as an option.
0:52:35 Okay, great, Chris Reed.
0:52:37 I was looking at option three, but if the building department that they think option two is easier for them, I'm in line with going what is easiest for the department.
0:52:48 Thank you, Sherry.
0:52:49 I think the numbers on option two make more sense overall.
0:52:52 So maybe we could first have a motion on which option to include in our
0:53:03 resolution and then the second motion could be the resolution itself.
0:53:07 Grace and Stone.
0:53:08 How do we all make a motion that we include option number two, new residential application?
0:53:12 Do you see a residential retainer?
0:53:14 I really have.
0:53:16 Thank you, Jason Brown.
0:53:17 Second.
0:53:18 Thank you motion by Grace and Stone, second by Jason Brown to use option two for
0:53:24 residential and commercial retainers. Any further discussion? Amy Roll call
0:53:33 vote please. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Chris Reed. Yes. Craig Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes.
0:53:40 Benter Cutler. Yeah. Grayson Stone. Yes. And Sherry Wilmer. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7 to 0.
0:53:49 Okay, now I take a motion on the resolution, Chris, do you want to?
0:53:55 Absolutely.
0:53:56 And include option two and one and off.
0:54:00 I move that we approve a resolution of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho
0:54:06 proposing new fees and amend the City's master fee schedule, including option two in the
0:54:13 temporary certification occupancy.
0:54:17 Thank you, Chris Reed or Jason Brown.
0:54:22 Thank you motion by Chris Reed seconded by Jason Brown to approve resolution 2024-006 proposing new fees and amending the city's master fee schedule including option
0:54:37 to under permits.
0:54:44 Does that make sense?
0:54:45 Good.
0:54:47 Okay.
0:54:48 Amy Roll call vote please.
0:54:49 Chris Reed.
0:54:51 Yes.
0:54:52 Greg Hawkins.
0:54:53 Jason Brown.
0:54:54 Yes.
0:54:55 Spencer Cutler.
0:54:56 Yeah.
0:54:57 Grayson Stone.
0:54:58 Yes.
0:54:59 Jerry Vollmer.
0:55:00 Yes.
0:55:01 And Ruth Pierce.
0:55:02 Yes.
0:55:03 Thank you.
0:55:04 Motion passes seven to zero.
0:55:05 Thank you.
0:55:06 Hey.
0:55:09 Next is an action item.
0:55:12 presentation of the city managers recommended budget for fiscal year 2024 and 2025 strategic
0:55:19 plan focus areas 8 and a request to adopt the preliminary budget in the amount of 1 million
0:55:27 and 102 million 649 and $38 and setting the public hearing for August 19th 2024 and this
0:55:38 This is not, Travis is a Mitch, welcome Mitch.
0:55:42 I'm going to start us out.
0:55:43 Before I start, I have a couple of, like,
0:55:45 just clarifications.
0:55:48 I printed out the hand, the papers for you.
0:55:53 Travis put a bunch of slides at the back that didn't get printed.
0:55:55 I don't know why they didn't get printed.
0:55:57 It's probably operator failure.
0:56:01 The PDF study email does have them on it.
0:56:04 Presentation tonight does that.
0:56:05 No, yeah, my printing, right?
0:56:09 Oh, okay, now we're pointing fingers.
0:56:11 I got it.
0:56:12 There it goes.
0:56:13 Oh, hey.
0:56:15 So Spencer has on my note, because I emailed it to him.
0:56:18 We're like, I think you all got the PDF in the email.
0:56:19 Yes, we did.
0:56:20 So they're all there, and they're all
0:56:21 in the presentation for tonight.
0:56:23 So that's the first thing.
0:56:24 The second thing, there's two things
0:56:26 we're going to do tonight.
0:56:26 We're going to do our regular budget presentation
0:56:28 like we've done the last several weeks.
0:56:30 And then at the end of that, Travis
0:56:31 is going to come up and he's going to talk to you
0:56:32 about the preliminary budget.
0:56:34 And there will be an action item.
0:56:35 That's why tonight's is an action item, not just a presentation.
0:56:39 And then the third thing, I'm gonna try something a little new tonight that I haven't really done before and I'm a little bit nervous about it.
0:56:45 So, um, some of you who know me know that I can tend to get emotional and I talk about people I care about.
0:56:53 I'm gonna be talking about people I care about tonight.
0:56:56 It just comes right out on the surface for everybody to see.
0:57:02 So, I'm gonna apologize up front.
0:57:05 I'm sure that's gonna happen, but we're gonna get through it.
0:57:08 Okay, so before we get to the emotional part,
0:57:17 like this picture, because it's a great picture
0:57:19 of like our city hall and it's kind of representative
0:57:22 of the city of Twin Falls government.
0:57:24 And so I wanted to start by what,
0:57:25 talking about the purpose of government is.
0:57:27 And so from the preamble of the Constitution,
0:57:32 purpose of governance, establish justice,
0:57:34 ensure domestic tranquility,
0:57:36 provide for the common defense, promote general welfare,
0:57:39 and secure the blessings of the liberty
0:57:41 to ourselves and our posterity.
0:57:44 Essentially, we protect the public health safety welfare.
0:57:47 This is about serving others.
0:57:51 If you look, let me get a little pointer out.
0:57:55 If you look right up here, it's kind of smallish,
0:58:00 but on the city logo, people are serving people.
0:58:03 This is about service.
0:58:08 And that's what we do come here.
0:58:12 We serve the people of Twin Falls, and we're happy to do it.
0:58:22 George H. W. Bush, one time said public services and
0:58:25 noble calling in their communities, in their states,
0:58:42 and in their country.
0:58:47 Handsome couple there is my mom and dad, circa 1959.
0:58:55 So this is a little while ago.
0:59:00 My mom didn't work outside the home, but she raised six kids,
0:59:05 and I actually did that, a lot of service right there.
0:59:07 And when I think back, all I can remember is her serving
0:59:12 serving the community, serving the church.
0:59:24 She gave a good example for me for that.
0:59:27 My dad when he was 17 enlisted in Navy.
0:59:31 He was 18, so he had to wait for months,
0:59:34 I think, to actually get in.
0:59:36 And he did his three-year term,
0:59:38 and then he got out of Navy and went right back
0:59:41 to work for the Navy and worked until he retired.
0:59:48 Was a civil servant working at China
0:59:50 like Naval Weapons Center, developing weapons
0:59:55 and guidance systems for missiles and that kind of stuff.
0:59:58 When I was about seven, I remember he switched to a different
1:00:07 division where they were doing alternate energy installations.
1:00:15 And he asked him why they did that, or why he made the move.
1:00:18 And he said he was tired of devising new ways of killing
1:00:21 people.
1:00:22 He wanted to start helping people instead.
1:00:35 My folks taught me that public services are no-call.
1:00:41 I'm going to fast forward 30 years from 1959, and this skinny guy with the full head of hair,
1:00:48 that's me or was me some time ago, that was about the start of my senior year in high school.
1:00:57 And I remember about this time having a conversation with the guidance counselor or a high school counselor,
1:01:03 and he says, what do you do when you grow up? And I said, I want to be a dad. He goes, okay,
1:01:07 What you can do for a job so you can support your family.
1:01:11 I remember when my folks taught me service.
1:01:16 I don't really know exactly, but I wanted to do public service.
1:01:24 I thought this was a great quote.
1:01:29 Help others and give something back.
1:01:33 I guarantee you will discover that while public service improves the lives in the world around you,
1:01:38 its greatest reward is the enrichment and new meaning it will bring to your own life.
1:01:46 Working for local government for 25 years,
1:01:50 a would venture to say that I've got more from it than others have got from my
1:01:55 service. It has definitely enriched enriched my life, gave me new meaning, but
1:02:03 that's why we do it. We do it for the service. It's just kind of a cool side
1:02:08 effect of doing the public service, right? We get something out of it. We have 350
1:02:19 employees at the city. There's 350 stories, kind of like mine, of how
1:02:25 people got into the business of public service, right?
1:02:35 They're not old, they're not exactly like mine, but they all have their stories.
1:02:40 Everybody can be great, because everybody can serve.
1:02:45 We have people that choose this work, it's not always easy, oftentimes it's kind of hard
1:02:54 and messy and difficult, oftentimes without much thanks, but we do it the best.
1:03:10 And so tonight, in this budget presentation,
1:03:13 we're going to spend some time talking about what
1:03:18 are we doing in the budget to retain these fantastic people
1:03:23 and attract new ones that are just as good or better.
1:03:27 And it's the things that we're doing for our employees that
1:03:29 make us an employer of choice.
1:03:35 And we want to maintain that.
1:03:37 We want to keep and continue to be an employer of choice.
1:03:40 And so we've got some things in budgets
1:03:41 We want to talk about to do that, and we're going to share this tonight.
1:03:45 But one more quote before we do.
1:03:48 And I put this one up there for Brianna's sake.
1:03:51 The budget is not just a collection of numbers, but it's an expression of our values and our aspirations.
1:03:57 So I threw a few of our values and aspirations up there on the slide.
1:04:02 This budget does reflect values and aspirations as much as me.
1:04:11 Brianna wanted to just be a collection of numbers.
1:04:14 It does that and so we're going to get into that tonight.
1:04:19 But before I do that I want to tell you just a couple of quick things.
1:04:23 You've seen this slide before.
1:04:24 I kept it in here.
1:04:25 I don't intend to go over it in great detail.
1:04:27 This is just some interesting statistics and information about the city.
1:04:32 If you have any questions we can start and come back to this.
1:04:34 But again you've seen this last few weeks.
1:04:37 But I did need to show you this slide.
1:04:41 Last week, between last week and this week some things have changed
1:04:44 in the budget document that you're going to have.
1:04:46 First, the county decreased our evaluation.
1:04:50 You've done this enough years to know that as we go through our budget process, our
1:04:54 regulations kind of go up and down.
1:04:56 This one was a decrease.
1:04:57 So the community evaluation is $6.2 billion, and that went down a little bit.
1:05:03 We also added both the expenditure and the grant revenue for a construction project over
1:05:09 on the Eastland Drive.
1:05:10 That grant amount is $8.2 million, and so that is now in the budget.
1:05:16 Travis has been talking for the last couple of weeks about funding a couple of projects
1:05:21 with cash reserves and so those three projects, the city pool, the attorney's office and the
1:05:26 GM and then the design for the evidence of training facility, those three total one or
1:05:31 three point one eight million dollars that is now in there along with the cash reserves
1:05:35 revenue coming in which makes our total net budget 102 million six hundred forty nine
1:05:43 that's up from about $91 million that we saw last week and do primarily to the
1:05:52 decrease in community valuation the tax rate that we shared with you last week
1:05:57 has changed from $4.91 to $4.93 $4.93 per $1,000 taxable value. So this is the
1:06:05 significant stuff that changed since last week. Any questions about any of those
1:06:09 before we move on? Hey this slide we've shown you for a couple times this
1:06:17 This has the updated information in it, and what this does is it tells kind of the impact
1:06:24 of the budget on that average resident of Twin Falls.
1:06:28 Average being a median valued home with the average amount of water and sewer usage, and
1:06:34 you'll see that this budget, if adopted as presented, would have about an $8.98 per month
1:06:42 impact to the average resident $107.76 per year.
1:06:53 So now we're going to get into the strategic plan.
1:06:57 Our focus area is, again, based on our strategic plan, it helps us decide what we're going to
1:07:03 spend our money on.
1:07:04 Tonight, we're going to talk about, as we've been talking about for the last several weeks,
1:07:08 we're going to talk about our focus area.
1:07:10 The last several weeks, we've talked about these seven around the perimeter, right?
1:07:15 These are all the other projects and the good stuff done.
1:07:21 They all go through our internal organization.
1:07:23 They all go through our employees.
1:07:24 None of that can happen without the people that we have doing work.
1:07:31 And these are the people that I was talking about that I care deeply for.
1:07:50 These are the people that we need to take care of.
1:07:55 And so, Kristen and her team of HR professionals are going to come talk to you
1:08:03 about the things that we're doing to take care of our people,
1:08:07 to keep us as a leading employer of choice in the community.
1:08:11 And Kristen, her team are done, Travis is going to get up
1:08:14 and he'll go over that capital stuff, the council director capital,
1:08:17 and we'll kind of close with that, and then he'll move right
1:08:19 into the adoption of the perimeter budget after that.
1:08:22 So there'll be times for questions along the way.
1:08:25 So I'll let Kristen go back.
1:08:27 Thank you, Mitch.
1:08:29 Welcome, Kristen.
1:08:30 Good evening.
1:08:33 So before we get started, I'm going to tell on myself a little bit and be thankful that you can't see my notes, because I am known to like commas.
1:08:43 So tonight we're going to focus on focus area eight as Mitch discussed, which pertains to our internal organization.
1:08:53 As I reflected on what I wanted to share with you tonight, I was brought back to seven years ago when I joined the city team.
1:09:03 Some days it seems like a blink of an eye and another day it seems more like 10 years.
1:09:09 So as I have grown and progressed with this city, I reminded of the impact that the HR
1:09:16 team has in the service mentality that it provides for our organization.
1:09:22 Some of the things that came to the top of my mind were when the HR team supports employees
1:09:27 at their happiest when they get that job offer, when they achieve a promotion, when they get
1:09:33 married and get edispoused to their insurance or when they welcome new additions to their
1:09:38 family.
1:09:40 I also think about the times when HR provides comfort, support and resources to our employees
1:09:46 during their most difficult times, such as the loss of a loved one or loss of a coworker.
1:09:53 And while this is a budget presentation, I feel it's important to connect the numbers
1:09:57 that we discuss with the employees behind them. Our employees are the heart of our organization.
1:10:04 They are the ones doing the services that make a difference in the lives of our citizens every day.
1:10:11 By investing in their well-being and professional development, we are not just improving our employees
1:10:16 lives, but enhancing the quality of service and life provided for our community. On this slide,
1:10:22 I've highlighted a sentence that has been the HR team's focus, ensuring that a high level of
1:10:28 competency is provided from a lean, properly compensated and respected core staff. We aim
1:10:35 to do this by nurturing a positive, safe and fair work environment. Overall, our goal is to make
1:10:42 the City of Twin Falls an employer of choice. Where every employee is fairly compensated and feels
1:10:48 valued and motivated to contribute their best. So keeping in line with the goal of being an employer
1:10:59 of choice. You can see our internal organizational goals listed. And I like to view this slide
1:11:05 as how we aim or how we strive to be an employer of choice. We do that by investing in salaries,
1:11:13 facilities, training, and our employees. We offer competitive salaries and we continually
1:11:19 evaluate our total rewards and invest in the retention efforts to retain existing talent
1:11:26 while also attracting new talent and new employees.
1:11:31 As you can see, the bottom section talks
1:11:33 about the compensation adjustments
1:11:34 that we'll be providing or proposing this year.
1:11:37 A 6% performance adjustment, a 3% table adjustment
1:11:41 to the general employee table, the funding of $1,000
1:11:47 into the employee's HSA contributions.
1:11:51 And I wanted to talk about that bullet for just a moment.
1:11:56 We will provide that $1000 to employees HSA's who qualify.
1:12:01 Our individual healthcare deductible or medical deductible is $2,500.
1:12:06 Our family deductible is $5,000.
1:12:09 By having a higher deductible, the employer
1:12:12 and the employee costs are lower.
1:12:15 This $1000 employer contribution helps employees offset
1:12:19 the higher deductible.
1:12:21 Additionally, it allows us to fund a health savings account
1:12:26 for our employees that's portable, meaning that if they retire or leave us, that money
1:12:31 goes with them.
1:12:32 Well, continuing on, we are also going to fund the Employee Retention Pay Program, which is
1:12:44 a program that offers a financial incentive for a three-year commitment of service.
1:12:50 Employees who have served five years are eligible for a $2,500 incentive, and those with 10 or
1:12:55 more years of experience are eligible for a $5,000 incentive.
1:13:00 We offer this program annually to employees for achieving those service milestones and we
1:13:08 are funding a two and a half percent increase for our health insurance premiums with select
1:13:12 health as well as continuing the $900 employee VBA contribution.
1:13:21 Alright switching gears to requested positions in accordance with our vision we strive to
1:13:27 maintain a highly qualified and lean staffing.
1:13:30 careful review and consideration. These are the six new full-time positions and
1:13:35 one position upgrade requested with the fully loaded costs tied to each of
1:13:40 them. You've heard from the various departments throughout the budget
1:13:44 presentations about their requested positions, so I wanted to touch briefly
1:13:49 on the HR assistant director role. There has been an increasing workload to HR
1:13:56 as we experience a difficult labor market. The addition of approximately 30 new
1:14:01 employees from the library and an increased number and complexity of ADA,
1:14:06 FMLA, and workers compensation cases. This position would be a fluid and nimble
1:14:13 member of our HR team and would be able to shift their focus based on the needs of
1:14:17 the team and organization at the time. When we recruit for this position, our
1:14:23 goal would be to find somebody that's well-rounded and experienced across
1:14:26 various HR aspects. And my role as a director, I feel like we could deepen our
1:14:31 our HR bench and Delve D Brand is some of these more complex tasks and situations that
1:14:37 we're faced with every day.
1:14:39 This position would be a key support and resource not only to the HR team, but to all employees
1:14:46 and across all departments as well.
1:14:53 And so as you can see, there were six positions that were requested but not brought forward
1:14:58 for funding.
1:15:01 These six positions represent roughly $960,000 in fully loaded costs.
1:15:08 While these positions were not funded, I think it's important to show the ongoing needs of
1:15:12 our organization.
1:15:14 As we continue to grow and evolve, we will want to continue to look at our overall organization
1:15:19 and strategic objectives when bringing new positions forward in future years.
1:15:26 I've laid the foundation for compensation.
1:15:30 Are there any questions up to this point?
1:15:32 Questions for any questions?
1:15:37 Thank you.
1:15:38 And with that, I will turn it over to Kaylin for a recruitment
1:15:40 update.
1:15:40 OK.
1:15:44 Welcome, Kaylin.
1:15:46 Good evening, Madam Mayor and Council members.
1:15:50 As you know, my name is Kaylin Gibson.
1:15:52 And I'm one of the human resource, excuse me, generalists.
1:15:57 So over the last year, we've seen an increase
1:16:00 and applications for our positions.
1:16:03 While we're thrilled to see in a higher amount of interest,
1:16:07 it has also highlighted the opportunity
1:16:08 to further refine our search for the most qualified candidates.
1:16:13 So far to date, we have run around 25 recruitments
1:16:16 and welcomed about 20 new hires.
1:16:18 We have seen about 11 current employees receive transfers
1:16:22 or promotions within the organization growing their careers.
1:16:26 In an ongoing effort to attract better suited candidates,
1:16:29 we have continued to broaden our recruitment efforts.
1:16:32 While we are continuing to post open positions
1:16:34 on numerous websites, reaching out to our department heads
1:16:38 for ideas on where to post their department openings
1:16:40 and continuing to hold hiring events
1:16:42 for police and dispatch, we have also completed
1:16:45 multiple videos showcasing these departments
1:16:48 as they are some of our most challenging positions to fill.
1:16:51 Our own city of Twin Falls employees
1:16:53 star in these videos highlighting the perks
1:16:55 of working for the city and showcasing the Magic Valley
1:16:58 as a fantastic place to live and grow a family.
1:17:02 He worked in commitment, our two of our core values,
1:17:04 and our employees in these videos embody them perfectly.
1:17:08 There are best recruiters in their enthusiasm,
1:17:11 is sure to resonate with anyone considering a career move.
1:17:14 So with that, I'd like to show you
1:17:15 a couple of these videos.
1:17:20 In this Mitchell Brooks, I'm the deputy chief
1:17:22 for the Twin Falls Fire Department.
1:17:24 I interact with our dispatch center
1:17:26 almost on a daily basis to make sure that the vehicles
1:17:29 and our people get to the calls that they need to.
1:17:31 Being a dispatcher is no different
1:17:33 than being a first responder on police or fire.
1:17:35 They are first responders.
1:17:37 They are part of our team.
1:17:39 Without the dispatch center,
1:17:40 the Twin Falls Fire Department
1:17:42 would not be able to serve the community.
1:17:44 If you think dispatch is for you, apply today.
1:17:56 What does it mean to put down routes
1:18:04 to carve out a place for yourself in the world
1:18:06 and share it with the people you love, serve, and protect?
1:18:25 Join the Twin Falls Police Department
1:18:26 build your life in a city you love. One more thing I would like to add is the
1:18:49 idea behind the dispatch video was to try and paint a picture for potential
1:18:53 candidates to show them what dispatches and how important of a role dispatchers
1:18:58 play. It is not just a call center like so many of our applicants believe. So with
1:19:03 that, I'll board Kristen. Thank you. When we interviewed for the recruitment
1:19:13 coordinator now generalist position, one of the things that stood out to me
1:19:17 Dr. Kaitlyn's interview was her talk about doing a day in the life video and so being
1:19:24 able to see some of those come to fruition throughout these videos has been really cool
1:19:28 to see.
1:19:35 Alright, so I'm going to shift focus and talk about our city's investment in employee training
1:19:39 and development.
1:19:40 And Sina Durham is out today and asked that I present for her, but I wanted to recognize
1:19:46 her and the time and effort that she invests in our employees and their training and development.
1:19:51 position which is the organizational development coordinator was approved by
1:19:56 Council in fiscal year 21. In her three years with the organization I feel like
1:20:01 we have taken our trainings to a new level and have established a year-long
1:20:06 training calendar that we will continue to refine and expand upon. Some of the
1:20:12 highlights that Ancina wanted to share are our One City training employee
1:20:16 orientation and Myers-Briggs training in our One City book club. Some of the pictures
1:20:21 that you see in front of you are from our One City Training and Employee Orientation Mires
1:20:25 Brakes training. Regarding One City Training, since October of 2022, EMT members have delivered
1:20:33 six four-day One City trainings. We conducted our first two-day session last December for
1:20:41 our frontline employees and will be introducing a new schedule of one day per week starting
1:20:46 this September. This shift in scheduling is to help ensure that we can reach our frontline
1:20:52 employees without significantly impacting the daily work and services that they provide
1:20:57 and we're optimistic that it will be successful. We aim to have 200 employees complete our
1:21:04 one-city training by the end of this fiscal year at an approximate cost of $1,600 per training.
1:21:11 Moving on to employee orientation in Myersburg's training, we offer these training sessions to give
1:21:16 our new employees a comprehensive overview of the City of Twin Falls and a high-performance
1:21:22 organization and get to have time connecting with one another.
1:21:27 And in November of this year, Chief Ken Worthy will facilitate our second One City Book Club
1:21:33 where the discussion will focus on the five dysfunctions of a team by Patrick Lencioni.
1:21:45 Moving on to celebrating and connecting.
1:21:47 As an organization, we make a conscious effort to celebrate our success and take the time
1:21:54 to connect with others.
1:21:55 Employee Recognition Committee, which you can see in the slides, is a program that brings
1:22:00 us together quarterly to celebrate and recognize our colleagues who exemplify the one city
1:22:07 values of honesty, integrity, commitment, connection, and teamwork.
1:22:12 We also have events like the City Retreat, Military Plaquening Plates, and Employee Breakfast.
1:22:19 These events provide opportunities for our employees to connect outside of their departments,
1:22:25 foster teamwork and breakdown silos.
1:22:28 This year we had 195 employees attend the employee breakfast
1:22:33 and over 200 attend the one city retreat.
1:22:38 We plan to continue these events in the upcoming budget,
1:22:41 but have reduced our budget for employee recognition
1:22:43 by $10,000, which will be tied to the cost of the venue,
1:22:48 speaker costs, and a re-evaluation
1:22:51 of the employee recognition lunches.
1:22:53 They've been doing some fun, like summer barbecues
1:22:55 staff to help control costs. So that highlights some of our training and
1:23:02 development and connection collaboration pieces. If there are no
1:23:06 questions up to this point I will turn it over to our HR intern Evan Maughan.
1:23:12 Thank you. Welcome. For the College of Interning for the Human Resources
1:23:23 Department this summer I am a senior business management major at Utah Tech
1:23:27 University in southern Utah. Oh, sorry. Oh, sorry. A little excited to do this. Start over.
1:23:37 I am a senior business management student at Utah Tech University and will be graduating this
1:23:41 spring. Having been born and raised in this great city, my interest in public service was
1:23:46 parked in high school when I served on the Twin Falls City Youth Council under the mentorship
1:23:50 of former Mayor Hawkins. While attending CSI, I started working at the Twin Falls City pool
1:23:55 where I discovered my affinity for human resources, former HR Director Clark frequently visited
1:24:00 the pool to provide staff training for their inspiring my passion for this field.
1:24:05 During my time as an HR intern, I have had the opportunity to shadow our HR Director
1:24:10 Kristin, organizational development coordinator, Encina, and HR generalists Janie and Kaylin.
1:24:17 This experience has allowed me to gain a comprehensive understanding of the various departments within
1:24:23 in the city and how they operate.
1:24:26 I have been able to spend time with many departments
1:24:28 within the city participating in a police department
1:24:30 rattling with officer man sick,
1:24:32 touring all the fire department facilities
1:24:35 with deputy fire chief brooks,
1:24:37 sitting in with dispatch,
1:24:38 visiting the airports and public work facilities.
1:24:43 I've also had the privilege of participating
1:24:45 in several interview boards,
1:24:46 including those for patrol officers,
1:24:49 911 emergency communications officers,
1:24:52 and payroll administrators.
1:24:55 I've also been able to observe negotiations between the city administration and fire department
1:25:00 representatives regarding the fire collective bargaining agreement.
1:25:03 A few of my contributions have included in-depth research projects assisting with recruitment
1:25:08 tasks, onboarding new employees, responding to employee inquiries, assisting with random
1:25:14 drug screens, and aiding with the U.S. Census salary survey.
1:25:19 I was also involved in collaborating with the consultant to facilitate the integration of
1:25:24 Twin Falls Public Libraries aligning their position with our organizational structure.
1:25:29 Additionally, I have been able to write job descriptions and job postings further enhancing
1:25:34 my understanding of the recruitment process. Likewise, this internship has provided me with
1:25:40 numerous professional development opportunities. I participated in the one week long high performance
1:25:46 organization training known as One City. I also took part in the Myers-Briggs personality type
1:25:52 testing, proudly identifying as an ISTJ like many in this organization.
1:25:58 Additionally, I have attended several webinars through various HR memberships, including navigating
1:26:03 AI future, catalyst or calamity, and modern leadership, blending culture and compliance.
1:26:09 I wish to give a heartfelt gratitude to the City Administration and my HR team
1:26:15 for providing me with these invaluable experiences this internship has provided me
1:26:19 with significant invaluable experiences.
1:26:25 This internship has significantly contributed
1:26:27 to my public servant and HR professional development.
1:26:32 I will always cherish this experience
1:26:33 and will frequently refer back
1:26:34 to the knowledge and skills I gained.
1:26:35 Thank you guys.
1:26:36 Thank you.
1:26:37 Thank you so much for joining us.
1:26:39 Thank you.
1:26:39 I appreciate it.
1:26:46 That's a tough act to follow.
1:26:47 Evan has been a joy to have with us this summer.
1:26:52 Not only has we been able to teach him things,
1:26:56 but he's taught us as well.
1:26:58 I like to think that I'm somewhat tech savvy,
1:27:01 not compared to Evan.
1:27:03 So I look forward to seeing what the future brings for him.
1:27:09 And speaking of the future,
1:27:10 what does the future with the City of Twin Falls
1:27:13 look like regarding the internal organization?
1:27:16 So HR along with the city manager, Roth Weiler
1:27:19 and Captain Matt Hicks will be moving forward
1:27:22 with a future leadership and management development committee.
1:27:26 As you read the mission statement of the committee, I want to focus on a couple specific things.
1:27:33 Cultivating a culture of leadership excellence and providing targeted opportunities and trainings
1:27:38 for employees to enhance their leadership skills, foster innovation, and drive toward
1:27:43 our strategic plan.
1:27:45 Sorry, I got off on my notes.
1:27:49 I apologize.
1:27:50 I think this is a great future opportunity for us as an organization to drive forward
1:27:55 our strategic plan and emphasizes the importance of building and equipping our employees with
1:28:01 the tools and resources to grow and be successful not only today but in the future as well.
1:28:09 Another future item that I wanted to provide a quick update on is self-insurance funding.
1:28:15 We continue down this path and will continue to do so over the next 11 months.
1:28:20 The Health Plan Trust has been created, and the Board of Trustees consists of the City
1:28:25 Manager, both Deputy City Managers, the Finance Director, and the HR Director.
1:28:32 We have submitted our initial plan to the Department of Insurance, and we'll work with
1:28:36 them to be fully compliant and answer any questions throughout the process.
1:28:43 We anticipate that there will be an impact on our internal workload, especially for finance
1:28:48 and possibly the HR teams.
1:28:51 There will be an additional reporting requirement that we're aware of, and we predict that there
1:28:57 will be some unknown tasks or assignments to come to light as we move through these next
1:29:03 11 months.
1:29:04 I think it's important to share that we also anticipate that our move to self-funding will
1:29:10 reduce the overall cost to providing that benefit to our employees.
1:29:15 We hope to provide more details and information over the next few months as we work through
1:29:19 that process with the Department of Insurance.
1:29:23 So we've covered a lot this evening.
1:29:25 I know it's your last budget presentation,
1:29:28 but in conclusion, I wanted to reiterate
1:29:32 that as an internal organization,
1:29:34 we are committed to fostering a workplace culture
1:29:38 that values and respects every employee,
1:29:41 our investment in training and development reflects
1:29:43 in our commitment to building a high performing organization.
1:29:48 We celebrate our employee's achievements,
1:29:50 support them through challenges and ensure that they have the resources they need to succeed.
1:29:55 Thank you for your continued support and with that I will stand for any questions.
1:30:00 Any questions?
1:30:01 Great job.
1:30:03 Thank you.
1:30:04 Welcome Travis.
1:30:05 So Madam Mayor, members of the Council tonight we're going to go through the formality parts
1:30:19 of the budget but I want to provide a brief recap of the conversation that we had really
1:30:26 last week that was built on the past weeks of information that you received from the various
1:30:31 department leaders members of our organization throughout the team. Earlier today I sent a
1:30:38 spreadsheet so that if you had the opportunity to kind of navigate some of the different spending
1:30:45 opportunities that you have or might consider we can certainly entertain those as we move
1:30:53 but just as a recap, the council has requested that we include the $3,185,000 into the budget
1:31:02 to cover these three projects.
1:31:04 Mitch had shared that those were included in the preliminary number that was presented
1:31:10 to you of $102,000,000 earlier.
1:31:15 Right now, the audited, the conclusion of the audit for the fiscal year 23, the city had
1:31:19 at $12,476,000 available of unrestricted cash reserves
1:31:25 in its capital fund, conservatively we're estimating,
1:31:29 we're going to add about $2,000,000 at the conclusion
1:31:32 of this fiscal year, that rough balance
1:31:36 that you should be thinking about of how to apply
1:31:38 and move projects forward will be right
1:31:40 around $14,500,000.
1:31:44 Any questions on that?
1:31:46 Any questions for Travis?
1:31:49 Okay, so this is where it's going to get a little bit
1:31:51 different and I'm going to kind of jump through a couple of slides. So we've always asked that
1:31:57 the council be nimble and this is a great example of being nimble and being kind of adapting
1:32:03 through to new information. So last week the city council voted to provide 15% of the estimated
1:32:10 engineering cost for the three sidewalk projects that are listed above. You can see that there's
1:32:16 a zero and the zero is because as we did further exploration, Aaron Steele had completed those
1:32:22 documents and so there are no costs associated with hiring a consulting engineer to do those
1:32:27 two projects.
1:32:30 Projects number one for Elizabeth on May Drive to Apache Way and project number three, Locust
1:32:35 Street, Kimberly Road to 4th Avenue East.
1:32:38 Those two projects are still in its conceptual stage as we had presented previously.
1:32:45 This is just a refresher.
1:32:47 This is the May to Apache Way.
1:32:51 And then this is the Kimberly Road and Fourth located on Locust.
1:32:56 Those are the two projects that the council
1:32:59 had elected to continue to move forward
1:33:04 in the plenary of budget conversation.
1:33:09 We also had a conversation about the fleet lift replacement
1:33:13 to mention shared that and how there was concern
1:33:17 the lift and our compliance with potential ADA standards. As we looked back, we
1:33:24 believe a better cost is $275,000 for that lift as opposed to the 150 that we
1:33:29 had shared with you during the meeting. So what we did was we then went through
1:33:34 and said how do we right size and get close to 770 based upon looking at the
1:33:41 fleet's replacement and also in that process we had received information outside
1:33:46 of this meeting and so this is or outside of the last meeting so this is the
1:33:51 revised list that I would recommend to you and so I kept it in its entirety and
1:33:57 then I went through and I removed portions and pieces to help you get to
1:34:02 some semblance of budgeting and I thought I'd go through that. This was also done
1:34:07 with some input by members of our parks team who are here. We had an
1:34:12 opportunity to go through the numbers that was one change to the numbers in
1:34:19 terms of a cost and that's on the Parks Department F-360-F mower. That means
1:34:26 something to somebody. It to me it's a mower. That cost was elevated to $50,000.
1:34:32 That is an unchanged priority by the fleet management team. You'll notice that
1:34:39 there is a golf course mower item number 17 that was removed from the list and what
1:34:46 the suggestion was is rather than have that one the golf course believes that
1:34:52 they would be best served by having two of the mowers that are listed as priority
1:34:58 number 18 and so that $92,000 is reflective of the cost of two mowers in
1:35:05 that total project cost. The next one, project number 19, in order for me to
1:35:12 preserve the fleet management work and the work they're doing and having
1:35:16 conversations and some back and forth with some department leaders, I really
1:35:20 believed that that was a deviation from what had been previously discussed and
1:35:26 vetted in our fleets during committee and that process is incredibly important.
1:35:30 It is a parallel team. Many minds are coming together to really discuss the
1:35:35 total needs of the organization, the proper equipment moving forward. I didn't think it
1:35:39 was appropriate to advance a project or a piece of equipment that had not gone fully vetted
1:35:44 through that process. And so very rarely do I have to, but I did. I pulled my boss card
1:35:50 and I struck it from your list. You can certainly include it, but I believe in what we're doing
1:35:56 in fleet management and I think it needs to go through that process. And so I removed
1:36:00 And then I had a conversation with Gretchen and Norm earlier today and I said if I could
1:36:06 afford just one of those two advanced replacement vehicles that we had shared with you last week,
1:36:14 that because of the cost of the repairs, they are generally more than the value of the vehicle,
1:36:20 which one would you retain?
1:36:23 And Norm said that he would remove the Silverado because of its the number of hours of use in
1:36:30 comparison to the police department vehicle that is used by our CSOs and so that is why
1:36:36 that change there so going back that total with the $324,000 of project priorities that
1:36:46 were removed as a result of long-term planning effort with the addition of the advance funding
1:36:54 of the other project or the other vehicle gets you to the 337-622 and so that total cost of
1:37:03 the 770 that the council has in its budget is $757,672 and that is where I would suggest
1:37:14 as the starting point unless the council says that's good.
1:37:20 tonight you don't have to make a final decision as if you're going to advance
1:37:27 any of these projects. You just can't exceed the $102 million
1:37:35 by statute because of the publication of the preliminary budget number and with
1:37:43 that we're happy to stand for questions unrelated to the 770 council
1:37:49 capital and just to be clear for the two new council members year 102 million
1:37:58 includes 770 not 757 it includes 770 and so there would be a little
1:38:06 $12,000 amount that could be retained and then allocated at any point in the
1:38:14 next fiscal year through adjusting journal entries even though that is a term that
1:38:19 that our finance team doesn't like.
1:38:21 I'm not even going to look at that.
1:38:22 Barnes, that Barnes over on this shoulder,
1:38:24 who's the one cringey?
1:38:25 Just so you know.
1:38:26 Didn't even have to look at him.
1:38:28 I love adjusting journal entries.
1:38:30 What do you mean?
1:38:33 Okay, council discussion, Chris Reed.
1:38:40 When I got this, I liked it as far as understanding
1:38:44 what we're going to be doing.
1:38:46 Kind of two areas right here with cash reserves.
1:38:50 What would be paid out of that pool?
1:38:52 and then the council directed capital.
1:38:56 There was one that I was just had a question about.
1:38:59 Yeah.
1:38:59 The dog park.
1:39:00 Have we pulled that one?
1:39:04 So the dog park was one that did not move forward.
1:39:07 The dog park at this point in time
1:39:09 had a total build cost of $600,000.
1:39:14 It had a rough phasing.
1:39:16 So Chance tried to really break out
1:39:20 a back of the napkin path or number for me.
1:39:24 I knew that he didn't want to do this.
1:39:25 In fact, one of the things to share
1:39:27 is that he would actually probably cost us more than the 600,000
1:39:31 by breaking it out, because you could pay double of mobilization
1:39:35 and double of other costs.
1:39:37 And so the $600,000 was the estimated cost
1:39:39 of the project as designed, trying
1:39:41 to get to an affordable number.
1:39:44 I was hoping to be able to have something smaller,
1:39:46 but I trust the members of the team
1:39:48 when they're trying to dissect complex projects.
1:39:52 You'll also notice that the harm improvements were not included.
1:39:58 I did put that Silverado truck on that list,
1:40:01 and then I also put the tractor,
1:40:03 you'll notice on the tractor,
1:40:05 it was listed as $18,000 in the fleet management costs.
1:40:09 The tractor that was desired came back at $47,000,
1:40:13 and so that's why I had made the decision to.
1:40:18 Councilman Reed, I think you'd be reminiscing
1:40:20 not to acknowledge the fact that in reference
1:40:21 to a dog park that used the word rough, rough design, rough fashion.
1:40:30 I'll look at you guys.
1:40:31 Well done, Jim.
1:40:32 And only if I meant to do that.
1:40:34 I'd be like, yeah, look at Jason's.
1:40:37 I believe that was out of order.
1:40:40 Thank you, Mayor.
1:40:42 Jason Brown.
1:40:44 I, you know, I look at it as well, knowing that we have a couple of projects that people
1:40:50 people are very interested in, you know, I support the list of $77,000, $57,000.
1:41:02 I think the project helps us get some equipment that it looks like it's been hanging on for
1:41:07 quite some time, just like the fact that we can have some designs for our streets department
1:41:15 and some sidewalks sitting on the table ready to go once that opportunity.
1:41:25 So we do have a public hearing that will open up.
1:41:28 I want to continue this discussion, Grayson.
1:41:31 Yeah, I'm an mayor.
1:41:32 Do you think probably in the longest game,
1:41:34 does that give us a big enough buffer at that seven?
1:41:37 Oh, yeah, yeah, the longest stand in.
1:41:46 Thank you. Anybody else? Yes.
1:41:51 I'd just like to say I concur with what's been said.
1:41:57 We need to add a comma.
1:41:59 Comma, but.
1:42:03 All right, knock it off, everybody.
1:42:06 I do carry the big stick.
1:42:08 I keep telling you.
1:42:10 Okay.
1:42:10 Anything else before I open up the public hearing,
1:42:14 Travis, do you have anything to add?
1:42:15 So again, just from a process standpoint for those that may be watching or observing the process online,
1:42:25 we've gone through a process to do our best as a city staff to communicate the needs
1:42:32 of a growing community.
1:42:34 we believe that the budget that we presented to you is not only stable, it's
1:42:40 thoughtful. I'm hoping that the process that we've used really reflects the many
1:42:45 hands and minds that have gone into creating this document. And that proposal
1:42:50 before you tonight, adjusted as Mitch had described, is 102,649,038 dollars. Now
1:43:00 Now tonight you are not adopting the budget.
1:43:03 Tonight what you're doing is you're setting
1:43:04 the maximum spending cap for this budget
1:43:09 including the collection of property taxes moving forward.
1:43:13 And so that's why earlier we did the rate hearings
1:43:16 in which you approved,
1:43:18 tonight you're going to set the maximum cap
1:43:20 and also you are going to set the official public hearing date
1:43:24 for August 19th, 2024.
1:43:28 And so after that, you'll be able to move forward.
1:43:35 So we, but we still can ask for a citizen comment?
1:43:39 Yes, for a citizen comment.
1:43:41 But it's not really a technically.
1:43:43 It's not a technically public hearing, that public hearing.
1:43:46 Well, the August 19th.
1:43:48 It will.
1:43:48 And we, the reason from a logistical standpoint,
1:43:52 the reason this appeared after all of the public hearings
1:43:55 is because if the council elected to not move forward
1:44:00 with any of the rate adjustments that are required
1:44:03 to balance this budget, we would need you to go back
1:44:05 into that process and to make reductions
1:44:08 in your expenditures accordingly.
1:44:11 Okay, does that make sense to everybody?
1:44:14 Okay, so at this point in time,
1:44:24 I ask for input first and then we'll do the motion.
1:44:27 Okay, so anybody in the audience that wishes
1:44:30 to comment on the budget.
1:44:33 That is specifically public input I'm looking for.
1:44:41 Anybody see no one.
1:44:47 Next is a motion Jason Brown.
1:44:52 All right.
1:44:53 Yeah, I'll make the motion.
1:44:54 OK, go ahead.
1:44:55 I'd move to adopt the fiscal year 2024 to 2025 preliminary
1:45:00 budget in the amount of $102,649,038
1:45:06 the public hearing for the final budget adoption on August 19th, 2024.
1:45:12 Thank you, Grace and Stone. Thank you, Madam Mayor. I'll second.
1:45:16 Thank you. Motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Grace and Stone to approve the adoption of
1:45:23 the preliminary budget in the amount of $102,649,038 and set the public hearing for August 19, 2024.
1:45:33 or any further discussion?
1:45:36 Amy Rolkow, please.
1:45:39 Craig Hawkins.
1:45:40 Yes.
1:45:41 Jason Brown.
1:45:41 Yes.
1:45:42 Spencer Cutler.
1:45:45 Yeah.
1:45:46 Grayson Stone.
1:45:47 Yes.
1:45:47 Mary Vollmer.
1:45:48 Yes.
1:45:49 Ruth Pierce.
1:45:49 Yes.
1:45:50 And Chris Reed.
1:45:51 Yes.
1:45:52 Thank you.
1:45:53 Motion passes 7 to 0.
1:45:55 Thank you, Travis.
1:45:57 So that is it for items on the agenda.
1:46:00 Next, on the agenda is a time for general public input
1:46:04 on any item not on today's agenda are not related to personnel anybody in the
1:46:12 audience that wishes to address City Council see no one advisory board
1:46:20 reports City Manager's office nothing else this evening oh national night out
1:46:32 is tomorrow night five o'clock lots of fun lots of food lots of great things
1:46:42 Anything else? Okay, meeting's adjourned. Thank you all.
Download
- Transcript (text) 93 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 123 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 168 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.2 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 4.0 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, August 5, 2024. The recording started at 16:57 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:46:51.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
a206815a2805ebb08ebbf66df4a0caea3351edcae6f1fba951eabae7da3ffe66 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a db3e100e2787f9ce3b4b9f28ab81f4d349610732681cfd054ad8a5ddf510f8e9
part02.m4a e8a04b036280710c0b7dc91ca5e80bd846254fd0ac3b720f5eb116fc071028dd - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
c68bc7e6acda94dd557dd6416b1b4dac0a8126b0135938a68fefbc0e139ac283
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file