OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, August 19, 2024

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on fileMinutes on file

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

Recording

Transcript

0:02:14 Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the August 19th 2024 City Council meeting. I want to confirm

0:02:21 We have a quorum all seven members are present in chambers

0:02:26 First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance if you wish to join me, please rise. Thank you

0:02:50 We have no proclamations tonight

0:02:53 So first item on the agenda is the consent calendar council wishes

0:03:05 Thank you to have a second.

0:03:06 Madam Mayor, I'll second.

0:03:07 Thank you, motion by Craig Hawkins,

0:03:09 seconded by Grayson Stone to approve the consent calendar

0:03:13 as written.

0:03:15 Amy Roll call vote please.

0:03:17 Ruth Pierce.

0:03:18 Yes.

0:03:19 Chris Reed.

0:03:20 Yes.

0:03:21 Craig Hawkins.

0:03:22 Yes.

0:03:23 Jason Brown.

0:03:23 Yes.

0:03:24 Spencer Cutler.

0:03:25 Yes.

0:03:26 Grayson Stone.

0:03:27 Yes.

0:03:28 Thank you, motion passes seven to zero.

0:03:30 Okay, next under items consideration,

0:03:33 The first item is an action item, a request to adopt an ordinance, amending city code sections

0:03:41 four dash one dash four and six dash two dash three regarding construction work hours

0:03:47 and we have our deputy city manager, Mitch, um, will commit all that in January. We had

0:03:55 some members of the community, um, the records community come to the council, um, and talk

0:04:01 about the need for an ordinance that regulated construction times and the noise that can

0:04:07 kind of come from those.

0:04:08 A couple of those folks are here tonight at that meeting.

0:04:12 You said great, let's work on a code amendment so here we have an ordinance in front of you

0:04:17 tonight that does exactly that.

0:04:18 There's two quick changes that we're proposing to make.

0:04:21 Actually, it's really one change in two different places and so what we're proposing here would

0:04:26 be to set construction times that you shouldn't do construction work after 10

0:04:32 o'clock at night before six o'clock in the morning. There are a few exceptions for

0:04:37 that. It'll be worked by us, right? Emergency work, those kinds of things. If

0:04:44 you have your scheduled concrete pour at three o'clock in the morning because

0:04:48 that's when the concrete company will deliver it to you, you can get prior

0:04:51 approval from the building official to do that. So there's a few kind of things

0:04:54 like that, but generally it'll be quiet times, right, after 10 o'clock at night before 6 o'clock

0:05:00 in the morning.

0:05:01 And so this has done that in two different places.

0:05:03 The first place in the code is the section where we adopt the building code, is the building

0:05:08 official, the ability to enforce it, including up to stopping work at the site if people are

0:05:14 not following.

0:05:15 The second place is in the nuisance part of the code section, and that defines it as an

0:05:19 infraction not a misdemeanor and so the police department or code enforcement

0:05:25 can come out and do a little citation as an infraction if it's not being followed

0:05:30 and so with that that's really all it does it drops that that language that

0:05:36 timing two different sections of the code I've been working with the neighbors

0:05:41 from that neighborhood and sharing our progress and I think the board of it so

0:05:46 with that you have an ordinance for you to look at tonight if you like it we can

0:05:49 adopted. I just need to put on third and final, dispense the rules, and I'll have it. And I can try

0:05:56 to answer any questions if you want. So in our packet, there's no ordinance number, but I have it

0:06:01 in front of me. It's 2024 dash 011. So any question? I just want to thank the group. Thank

0:06:10 for those, thankful for those individuals who brought this to our attention. Happened in our

0:06:15 neighborhood and at 1030 or 11 or 12 o'clock at night, if it's not happening knowing us, we don't

0:06:21 No, so we do appreciate that.

0:06:23 If there aren't any other comments or questions,

0:06:25 I'll make the motion.

0:06:27 Doesn't look like it, go ahead.

0:06:29 I move that we dispense with the reading rules

0:06:32 and place Ordinance 2024-011 on third and final reading

0:06:37 by title only.

0:06:38 Thank you, Grace and Stone.

0:06:40 Madam Mayor, I'll second that.

0:06:41 Thank you, motion by Chris Reed,

0:06:43 seconded by Grace and Stone to put Ordinance number 2024-011

0:06:48 24-01-1 on 3rd and final reading by title only. Any further discussion? Amy

0:06:57 Rokavo please. Miss Reed. Yes. Greg Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Spencer

0:07:05 Cutler. Yes. Grayson Stone. Yes. Gary Bummer. Yes. Bruce Pierce. Yes. Thank you

0:07:12 motion passes 7-0. Okay I'll read the ordinance. Ordinance number 2024-01-1

0:07:19 at Northness of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho providing for the

0:07:25 amendment of Twin Falls City Code sections 4-1-4 and 6-2-3 to enact

0:07:33 noise restrictions for construction sites. Chris Reed. Move to approve

0:07:38 ordinance 2024-001-01. Thank you. Jason Brown. Thank you. Motion by Chris

0:07:48 for Read Second by Jason Brown to approve Ordinance number 2024-01-1. Mitch did you have something?

0:07:56 I was just going to say I forgot to say that when we put this together I worked with the

0:08:01 building official, the chief police and the city attorney and everybody's generally in favor of

0:08:05 moving forward. That's all. Perfect. Thank you. Any further discussion comments? Amy Roll call vote please.

0:08:13 Craig Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes.

0:08:18 Grace and Stone, Sherry Bomer, Ruth Pierce, and Chris Reed.

0:08:23 Yes.

0:08:24 Thank you.

0:08:25 Motion passes 7 to 0.

0:08:27 Next is an action item, a request to use $75,000 of water reserves to hire a design professional

0:08:38 for the Hamilton Manufacturing Remediation Project.

0:08:43 We have Erin Steele, her assistance public works director.

0:08:47 Thank you very much. Good evening, Mayor and Council. Tonight I'm here to ask for a little

0:08:52 bit of money. By way of background, on June 15th of 2018, one of the main water lines in

0:08:59 the city of Twin Falls developed a leak. This leak, if we can pop up on the screen in the

0:09:05 map, this leak is near the Hamilton manufacturing building right here on your left, north, is

0:09:15 to the top of your page. This is Rock Creek Canyon, Chishon Street right here. So this

0:09:20 This water line right here developed a fairly substantial leak and caused some damage to

0:09:25 the surrounding area including some of the building and part of the slope and the city

0:09:33 of Twin Falls entered into an agreement with HMY to repair that damage.

0:09:37 This request tonight is to support that agreement to help fix some of those items.

0:09:43 So those items include slope stability down from the top down into the canyon, some underpinning

0:09:49 with the slope stability.

0:09:51 Some road and stormwater design across the entire site

0:09:54 to make sure that no water is actually getting to that area

0:09:58 and causing any further damage.

0:10:00 There's also some structural staircase that needs to be built.

0:10:04 And make sure I got to be stormwater

0:10:06 and then a retaining wall along this edge here

0:10:09 that will need to be completed.

0:10:12 So what we have to do is because it's a design professional,

0:10:15 we have to go out and do a quality qualifications-based

0:10:19 selection and through that process we'll choose a design professional to look at all of these

0:10:24 items and do just one big design on all of just one project to kind of take care of it. So tonight

0:10:29 that's the reason I'm here is to ask for the $75,000 that we anticipate to cover the cost of what that

0:10:35 design will be. I will stand for any questions if you have any. Any questions for Aaron Grayson?

0:10:42 Thank you, Madam Mayor. What does structural underpinning mean? I saw that report and I wasn't

0:10:47 I wasn't familiar with that.

0:10:48 Yeah, really what that means is when you're looking at a slope that's coming down, when

0:10:52 you put material and stuff on it, you want to pin back that material to the side of the

0:10:57 slope.

0:10:58 Thank you.

0:10:59 Jason Brad.

0:11:00 I'll make a motion if we're ready.

0:11:04 So, yes.

0:11:05 Okay.

0:11:06 I would move to approve the use of $75,000 of water reserves to hire a design professional

0:11:13 for the Hamilton manufacturing, an ink remediation project.

0:11:17 Thank you, Sherry Vomer.

0:11:18 I'll second.

0:11:19 Thank you.

0:11:20 Motion by Jason Brown, second by Sherry Vomer to approve the use of $75,000 of water reserves

0:11:28 to hire a design professional for the Hamilton Manufacturing Remediation Project.

0:11:34 Any further discussion?

0:11:36 Amy Rokow, please.

0:11:39 Spencer Cutler.

0:11:40 Yes.

0:11:41 Grayson Stone.

0:11:42 Yes.

0:11:43 Sherry Vomer.

0:11:44 Yes.

0:11:45 Ruth Pierce.

0:11:46 Yes.

0:11:47 and Jason Brown. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7 to 0. Thank you Aaron. Thank you. Next on

0:11:55 that agenda is a presentation. Presentation on the finances of the City of Twin Falls for the

0:12:02 third quarter of fiscal year 2324. This presentation will be an overview of the tax-supported funds Cited in E-31

0:12:08 in the three major enterprise funds, water wastewater and sanitation. We have our CFO Brianna Howard.

0:12:15 Welcome, Brianna.

0:12:18 Thank you.

0:12:19 Good evening, Mayor and Council.

0:12:21 So tonight I'm going to talk about the third quarter

0:12:23 of financial update for the tax-supported funds,

0:12:27 the Water, Sewer, and Sanitation.

0:12:29 And then I'm going to share a few comparisons

0:12:32 and national statistics as well as how it relates to the city

0:12:35 as a whole and the employees that we employ.

0:12:41 So this first slide is a recap of our entire budget.

0:12:44 This is what I've gone through a handful of times before,

0:12:47 for the first couple of quarters. This shows what our entire budget is. Typically, we talk about

0:12:54 tax-supported funds and we talk about just that, that budget, the revenues and expenditures related

0:13:00 to that. This slide shows what we are as a city in its entirety. So the 104 million is split up

0:13:06 between non-tax-supported funds at around 42% and our tax-supported funds at 58% or around 60 million

0:13:14 dollars. On the right is our major fund composition. So this is what makes up the

0:13:20 city as a whole when you combine it all together. Most of what we do what we

0:13:25 provide is for our general fund included in the general fund is things like the

0:13:29 fire, police, it's our finance, HR, city manager, parks and rec. Those type of

0:13:37 things are all in the general fund. You can see the next biggest one are the

0:13:40 water and wastewater funds which come in at 16 and 13% respectively. In comparison

0:13:47 to what we've gone through the last couple of months with all of you and

0:13:50 far as our as far as our budget goes and what we are looking at from 24 to 25

0:13:54 this compares to the total current budget of 109 million that we are going

0:14:00 through the process of solidifying tonight. Jumping and attack supported

0:14:07 funds only, the total revenue that we get is $60,870,000 and that is split up

0:14:14 between these categories. Property taxes make up almost 50%. We get $29,515,000

0:14:21 inside of our property taxes. Our state shared revenue is $6.6 million and

0:14:26 reserves are $6.4 million. We have transfers from other funds at $4.2

0:14:33 million, streets at 4.2 million, and franchise fees just over 2 million. Everything else is

0:14:41 in that other category. A few things that land in that other category are permits of 1.2 million,

0:14:48 grants of 1.6 million, and airport revenue of a million. Everything else is less than a million

0:14:54 and doesn't make the list. On the right, you can see how we budget our resources to our funds.

0:15:01 So, again, what makes up the most use of our funds is our general fund at 59%.

0:15:07 This slide shows a little bit of history for the last couple of years for a property tax

0:15:13 revenue.

0:15:14 In 2021, we started off with around 23, almost 24 million, and that has grown to $29 million

0:15:22 in the last four years.

0:15:24 We get more money by increasing taxes by a lot of 3% if we are allowed, or if we choose

0:15:30 to take so and then new construction in addition to the closure of the urban renewal district

0:15:36 that we did last year. What's interesting to note is we are allowed to take 3% and before

0:15:42 COVID I would have said 3% is an inflationary adjustment. We are all aware now that that

0:15:47 is not even close to to cover inflation and so the 3% that we get not nearly covers the

0:15:54 increase in expenditures that we that we also have to pay. Other major revenue

0:16:03 sources are highway money, state revenue sharing, and franchise fees. Highway

0:16:08 money is not pro-retta. We have budgeted 4.2 million and we are about to get four

0:16:13 we're on course right now getting 4.1 million. We are still have three months

0:16:19 left of the fiscal year of which people are traveling so we should see more

0:16:23 coming in. If any of you guys watch the state and try to see what they issue and

0:16:28 how we'd be project what money they're going to give to us, it is very difficult

0:16:33 if not non-existent. For us to be able to anticipate what we are going to get

0:16:37 from the state whether it's highway or state revenue sharing is hard to say the

0:16:42 least and so we are making our budget this year but it's very difficult to

0:16:46 understand or know where we're going to come in. Fortunately in this case we are

0:16:51 almost have budget and we're probably going to surpass. The state revenue sharing comes from liquor

0:16:56 licenses and sales tax and of the $6.6 million we have received $5 million to date.

0:17:03 Franchise fees are much more than budget because some of the large increases that we have seen

0:17:09 from Idaho Power and Intermountain Gas just a year or so ago they were increasing rates both of them

0:17:14 to a 25%. Just recently, our Mountain Gas announced it will be decreasing around 13.5%

0:17:22 because of over-collected gas costs and a decrease in gas commodity pieces. So to put

0:17:28 to, in perspective, the timing in our Mountain Gas just released this in August and as you

0:17:33 guys are aware, we are going to approve the budget this year so it's very difficult to

0:17:37 anticipate going forward. And the philosophy of the City of Twin Falls is to budget conservatively.

0:17:44 If we budget too high, we are going to budget expenses to cover the income that we have

0:17:49 coming in, so we would end up spending more than what we had received and create a hole

0:17:55 for the following year.

0:17:58 On these three pieces, if you add all of that up, we have received a cumulative 11.3 million

0:18:04 of the 13.1 that we budgeted.

0:18:07 This is 86% of our budget.

0:18:10 Most of our budget is pretty static.

0:18:12 We don't receive a lot extra.

0:18:14 The only way to be able to put money into reserves for like a rainy day fund or for a

0:18:19 fire station that we want to build is by getting more revenue than we've anticipated or expending

0:18:25 less than we have expected on the expense side.

0:18:29 So as you can see in these couple of areas, we're actually making a little bit more than

0:18:33 we had anticipated which will help us to build our reserve fund or a future project like the

0:18:39 ones that you are currently approving in the budget with the police station, storage center

0:18:46 and then the pool, etc.

0:18:49 This next slide is jumping into state revenue sharing a little bit.

0:18:53 This is one that is very, very difficult for us to understand and anticipate what are they

0:18:57 going to give us.

0:18:58 We all know inflation has increased prices so people are spending more just because they

0:19:03 have to spend more.

0:19:04 But we also know that there's a mitigating factor.

0:19:07 spending less because they're spending more in certain prices. So I've taken the

0:19:11 last couple of years to analyze just a little bit where we have come from. In

0:19:16 21 we were at four million dollars. This is just right after COVID and we

0:19:20 jumped in 22 to 4.7 million and then again to 5.1 million in 2023. What's

0:19:29 behind these numbers and important to note is that in 2023 we reached a

0:19:34 relatively new cap of 1% that we cannot get more of. So we were capped in 23. What's interesting

0:19:42 now is that we have reached what we reached last year by just barely jumping over. So what

0:19:50 that means to me is people are spending more because prices are increasing, but I think

0:19:57 there's a medium that's being reached. People are spending more but they're potentially buying

0:20:02 less, which means ultimately the City of Twin Falls receives less in the long term than

0:20:08 what we have in the last few years.

0:20:13 A little more on the franchise fees that we receive.

0:20:16 These are the right-of-ways that we have to allow cable and electric and gas.

0:20:22 They, in-around gas and I-O-Power, have an agreement with us to pay 3% of revenues.

0:20:27 So when they receive more, they pay us more.

0:20:31 You can see the last few years, Idaho Power has gone from 1.1 million to 1.4 million, and

0:20:39 Intermountain Gas has gone from 300,000 to 500,000 dollars.

0:20:44 Significant increase is not necessarily dollar figures for where we are at in our entire budget,

0:20:49 but interesting, especially coupled with cable and how cable continues to fall on our 1,000

0:20:56 down to the 85 that we have just received.

0:21:01 permits since COVID. We have zoned in on this because it's fascinating where housing

0:21:07 permits, where are we going building, where do we expect to go. There this is

0:21:12 another four-year slide showing where we've gone the last few years. What I want to

0:21:15 know is I want you to draw your attention to the red line. That red line

0:21:19 even though we have gotten significantly more money from building permits, we

0:21:26 have been relatively consistent in where we've budgeted. That red line is our

0:21:30 budget numbers. The yellow line is where we've come in as actual. Another just

0:21:35 another proof of how we we conservatively budget is we don't jump or we don't

0:21:39 react to where the environment is and we are either shooting over it too high or

0:21:45 we are going a little bit less but we try to be conservative in our budget so

0:21:50 that we have a sustainable budget from year to year. We have currently reached

0:21:55 105 percent of what we budgeted. There was some unanticipated building permit revenue

0:22:02 from North Canyon Medical Center and the housing company that we didn't know of last year when

0:22:07 we were creating our budget. Over time, this is where we've gone since 2007. You can see how it

0:22:15 dips down to the first, okay maybe not first, but the most recent housing crisis that we had in

0:22:22 in the 2008-9 timeframe and how we gradually increased to our record year of 2021, where

0:22:29 we'd received $2.1 million of building permit revenue, dropped significantly, and we're

0:22:35 right at $1.2 million now here to date.

0:22:38 To put these numbers into perspective, in fiscal year 21, so our record year, we had 486 single

0:22:45 family permits for the total year.

0:22:48 Last year to date, we had 77 and this year we have had 195.

0:22:54 As of the most recent July report, we're at 209, which is up 122% from last year.

0:23:00 So we are doing better than we did last year, but the bar was somewhat low last year.

0:23:09 On the expenditure side, personnel is typically the largest of our budget.

0:23:13 almost half of what we have and we are about 71% 75% of the way through the

0:23:21 year. We still have 18 open positions across the city for have actually been

0:23:27 filled just so this last quarter but in part of these numbers and part of this

0:23:32 24 million of the 33 we have an artificial inflation of $1,500 that we

0:23:38 paid every city employee in December for the amount of work that they were

0:23:42 over working to accommodate for some of the open positions that they have over

0:23:47 the city. So even though we're at 71, almost 72 percent, three-quarters of the

0:23:51 way through the year, it's still low compared to what we budgeted because we

0:23:56 budget for full employment in the hopes that we are full employed at some point.

0:24:01 MNO is right on track. Capital improvements, a few things that are inside

0:24:07 of this number. We have streets overlaid maintenance of 720,000 which has not

0:24:12 been started significantly yet. We have only about $8,000 in expenditures, which makes sense,

0:24:17 because streets typically does most of their work in the summer and hot months.

0:24:22 Chip seal is $1.9 million and we've only spent about $81,000 on our streets chip seal.

0:24:28 Across the city, we have auto equipment of about $1.5 million and we've spent a little

0:24:34 just about half of that. In the budgeted numbers for capital improvements, we have

0:24:39 the fire station roof of 300,000 and a COP certificate of participation payment of 650,000. What's not

0:24:47 budgeted but is included in these actual numbers is the fire station 3 of 3.3 million dollars that

0:24:55 we have expended. When we created the budget last year, we were not aware of how we were going to

0:25:01 finance station 2 finance or pay for cash station 2 or station 3. At the time we were talking about

0:25:07 paying cash outright. We were talking about financing at their debt, leveraging, and we were also

0:25:12 talking about maybe using a COP for both stations. In the end, we ended up doing a COP for Station 2,

0:25:18 and we decided to use our reserves for Station 3, of which we've spent 3.3 million.

0:25:25 Inside of the budget number is the state and local fiscal recovery funds of two million dollars,

0:25:31 of which of Idaho housing has spent of $1.7 million in Vista Bonita. Idaho's housing is spent and

0:25:38 Vista Bonita is starting on the design. And we also have transit of $1.3 million of which we've spent

0:25:45 980,000. Transfers are significantly less because in this fund they are not Corrata. We have budgeted

0:25:53 $2.4 million to Durkis and Sichon Falls that will be made in November and another million and a half

0:25:59 to the shop. Any questions on tax-supported funds, revenues, and expenses?

0:26:06 The jumping over to water, wastewater, and sanitation. Enterprise funds mean they are

0:26:14 similar to a business without a profit motive. So we'll do the similar route. We'll talk

0:26:22 about revenue expenses on each fund and a little bit of history.

0:26:27 Users pay specific fees for water services, and this graph shows the actual water fund user

0:26:31 fees through the last four years. We budgeted around nine million and have increased that

0:26:37 to eleven million dollars after we changed the mandated arsenic fee and this shows where

0:26:43 we are coming out with here to date actual. We are starting to see a tapering off of accounts.

0:26:49 Houses take one to two years to finish after permitting and we are starting to see UB account

0:26:54 growth drop substantially following the reduction in permits. Looking at usage we are continuing

0:27:01 a downward trend on what we use. The max gallon per day is a calculation that Rob Bulling,

0:27:06 our superintendent uses quite often, is calculated as the highest day of use in July. Our max

0:27:14 gallons per day was 25 million in 2021 and it decreased to 23.7 million in 22, 23.3 million

0:27:22 in 23. And just as of last week, Rob shared with me, we were just a little bit less than

0:27:27 in the 23.3 million, so similar, but a little bit less.

0:27:34 This could be because of a demographic change.

0:27:36 Maybe people don't want bigger yards.

0:27:38 It also could be because the city is requiring

0:27:40 the use of our PI system and has been since

0:27:43 every new subdivision of 2006 and on.

0:27:50 On the expenditure side, personnel has the same $1,500

0:27:54 payment that was made in December,

0:27:56 and they are still at 74%, 73.9%,

0:27:59 recorders the way of the year through.

0:28:03 MNO, it is typical for water to use much less,

0:28:06 similar to the streets when it is warm

0:28:08 and they use power to pump.

0:28:11 In the capital side, the largest budget item

0:28:14 is Kimberley Road at 3.5 million

0:28:16 and main line replacement of 1.5 million.

0:28:19 Kimberley Road has not been started yet

0:28:21 and we are starting mainline replacement,

0:28:24 about 150,000 of the actual numbers there.

0:28:28 As far as debt goes, we only have one bond left

0:28:31 And there's no significant payments as of yet,

0:28:34 because we make principal payments in September,

0:28:36 and only interest payments in March.

0:28:40 Grants per surge per rate at 75%.

0:28:45 Wastewater side, last four years,

0:28:47 a little bit more consistent than water.

0:28:49 We have budgeted 9.5 up to the 10.5 million,

0:28:52 the last four years.

0:28:54 We had a high amount of industrial usage in 2022,

0:28:57 which is actually why our actual numbers increased.

0:29:02 We are starting to see a decline in the past few years that has tied the improvements over

0:29:06 at Chobani.

0:29:07 Chobani is made to their pre-treatment plant, with Chobani being one of our largest industrial

0:29:12 users as a direct correlation to what we receive.

0:29:17 On the expenditure side, personnel is not the biggest percent of the budget as we hire

0:29:22 out our personnel.

0:29:26 The prices inside M&O are a constant battle and we've had large increases in the Jacobs

0:29:30 contract the last few years due to labor and chemical.

0:29:35 that capital improvement fund number. Some of the biggest items are $1.5 million for

0:29:40 budgeted for the primary and secondary clarifier, $500,000 for the sludge pad, and $300,000 for

0:29:46 a sludge truck with $550,000 for mainline maintenance. Debt, we have $28 million left of debt that

0:29:54 will be paid off in 2033. Sanitation is much more consistent than water and wastewater,

0:30:03 And we don't see significant fluctuations we contract out most of our sanitation.

0:30:07 It's around $4 million per 2024.

0:30:13 On the expenditure side, we have no capital expenditures or debt, just our M&O.

0:30:20 Any questions on the enterprise funds?

0:30:24 Any questions for Brianna?

0:30:30 So the next section I want to go into is to jump into a little bit of what I see, what

0:30:33 I'm reading as far as nationally, some of the statistics that I see, some of the charts,

0:30:38 how it relates to where we're at at the City of Twin Falls. This is the fun part. I really

0:30:45 enjoy getting some of the graphs and reading some of the stuff and seeing how we are normal

0:30:50 compared to the nation or not normal. So, taxes. Taxes is a big topic of conversation

0:30:59 and property taxes are huge here. It's something that everybody talks about. Everybody, we're

0:31:03 frustrated. We pay a lot in property taxes. I liked this chart because what it really does

0:31:09 is that it shows, again, the three-legged stool that we have with taxes.

0:31:14 Government, city, state, local, we are all run by three pieces of taxes.

0:31:18 You have property taxes, sales tax, and income tax.

0:31:21 What I liked about this, in this chart, yellow is good, that's the lowest tax rate, and red

0:31:27 is the worst.

0:31:28 I know it's actually really good.

0:31:29 We're at 7.9%, even with our high-property taxes.

0:31:33 When you factor in our income tax rate and our sales tax altogether, holistically, we're

0:31:37 still in a pretty good spot. This one's just for fun. We all know inflation is

0:31:45 hitting us and it's interesting. I love doing a poll to see if people have

0:31:49 started going out to eat less and it's amazing to me how some have and some have

0:31:54 not. It's actually pretty 50-50 split. What was fascinating to me is in the last

0:31:58 ten years McDonald's has actually increased their prices by 100%

0:32:03 food for thought. That has nothing to do with the City of Twin Falls but I thought

0:32:07 was interesting. This is an interesting slide. So I just got this last week and I really wanted to

0:32:14 highlight what we are doing with the City of Twin Falls with our employees, our personnel,

0:32:19 and show. So this article was really trying to key in on the real wage growth, which is actually

0:32:25 payroll increases less inflation. What they were trying to discuss and talk about was how high-income

0:32:32 earners are making making much more, especially since COVID. I'm not going to go in on focusing

0:32:37 on that because I think that's a different topic for a different day. What I do want to

0:32:41 key in on is the lower to middle wage employees' wages and then the middle wage wages. Lower

0:32:48 middle wage in this article is defined as $18 an hour and our middle wage is $23.79 an

0:32:54 hour. So we have a significant part of our population that is in this. This lower middle

0:32:59 wage has increased since COVID. So from 2019 to 2023 has increased 5% and the middle wage

0:33:06 has increased 3%. The City of Dwin Falls has actually decreased by 2.1%. This is a pretty

0:33:16 important because as you are aware through the budget that we are going through currently,

0:33:21 we are proposing a significant increase, one of the highest, if not the highest, that the

0:33:26 City of Dwin Falls has given. Part of it is because we are trying to just catch up. We

0:33:31 are behind the eight ball in giving our employees what they need to survive. And if you compare

0:33:35 it nationally with everything behind these numbers in this graph you can see

0:33:40 that they're already behind in inflation. I went a little bit further just to see

0:33:45 where matching on this graph you can see 20 lower middle wages 20.8 and middle wages

0:33:50 17.4 where do we fit? So City of Twin Falls if we go back to the data that I

0:33:55 have from 2000 and we was I actually was 1990s we have increased by 16.8% so we

0:34:07 are not off the charts we're not negative here but it's still not enough and it's

0:34:13 still something that we are trying to get ahead of and try to make sure that we

0:34:18 are helping the people that we have employed here. So our first decrease since

0:34:30 COVID. So lower gasoline CPI, lower gasoline prices and airfare is partially offset by

0:34:35 higher food, again, shelter and medical care. Of the five major headline CPI components,

0:34:41 only food is the one that noted a year over year increase. The June inflation data should

0:34:47 reinforce the Fed's confidence to lower rates in September, especially as the labor market

0:34:52 shows signs of softening. The odds of a September rate cut increased to nearly 100% from 75% prior

0:34:59 the release of the CPI report. Everything I'm reading and seeing is showing that the feds are

0:35:04 going to increase rates in September which correlates directly to what people pay for houses, what they

0:35:11 pay for credit cards, and then ultimately how much spending that they have. On the home side,

0:35:17 new home sales continue to fall short. New home availability is the highest since 2008 with 9.3

0:35:24 months supply which is well above the six month mark indicating a balanced market. New home sales

0:35:30 are underscoring the negative impact of high mortgage rates and record housing prices on consumers,

0:35:35 despite homeboodlers efforts like price reductions and mortgage rate buy downs. Travis has referenced

0:35:41 an article that we have shared amongst our executive team on the NBC naming Twin Falls as one of the

0:35:46 roughest home buying markets. We are 27th worst in the nation and Travis has shared a few times

0:35:52 with us that he has a philosophy that people can't buy homes in Twin Falls who will not be able

0:35:57 to employ frontline to mental management employees. Schools won't be able to hire teachers, etc.

0:36:03 It could put even more strain on our labor markets. In the housing sector, we see multi-family permits

0:36:11 continue to search and single-family permits still declining. Single-family homes remain the key

0:36:16 indicator of the housing sector's health due to their large market share. These homes are closely

0:36:21 tied to home ownership rates and are particularly sensitive to shifts in consumer confidence in

0:36:26 and broader economic factors, such as employment and interest rates.

0:36:30 Starts for single-family homes have declined for four consecutive straight months and six months actually going.

0:36:37 Ongoing weakness that is indicated in our permit numbers as well.

0:36:41 The reason why we have had an increase this year so far is because the multifamily homes, not single-family homes, is banking.

0:36:50 Ideal with banking, I deal with the numbers with the investment size, so I want to share a couple things here.

0:36:55 or weighed down by signs of consumers slowing down.

0:36:58 They're spending and falling behind on their bills.

0:37:01 Major banks have benefited from higher interest rates

0:37:03 the last two years, which is a circular effect.

0:37:05 Higher for longer interest rates,

0:37:07 persistently high housing prices, softening used

0:37:09 vehicle values and signs of a cooling labor market,

0:37:12 merit focused scrutiny from the banking sector.

0:37:17 There's always a conversation about cash.

0:37:19 Is it better to have cash?

0:37:20 Is it better to have debt?

0:37:21 And there's a happy medium.

0:37:23 The benefits of cash are maintaining liquidity,

0:37:25 having flexibility.

0:37:27 So there's also disadvantages who suffer during easing cycles when heels drops, our purchasing

0:37:32 power drops.

0:37:33 In the city, we are constantly battling balancing reserves, debt, and investments.

0:37:38 Should the economy undergo a recession, investors gains are likely to continue after the federal

0:37:42 begins seizing cycle.

0:37:47 And of course, recession.

0:37:48 Are we in a recession?

0:37:49 I don't like crying wolf, and so I'm not typically a negative person, but you see a lot

0:37:56 of these articles, I thought I would bring in something that I read that was interesting.

0:38:01 Recessions typically start only after the Fed begins cutting rates.

0:38:04 This is a pattern that I thought was interesting, was observed over the past six decades.

0:38:09 Our initial rate cut is supposed to be in September of this year, which means it may

0:38:13 be quarter four or 24 or quarter one of 25.

0:38:17 There's been comments that this is a selective recession.

0:38:21 High-end consumers are thriving, contributing over 50% of all consumers' spending.

0:38:25 20% of consumers are contributing just 10% of the economy's total spending.

0:38:31 But in a nutshell, where is the city at?

0:38:35 Our financial position is strong, our compensation structure is strong, it's getting better, and

0:38:40 our conservative budgeting is paying off.

0:38:44 Any questions for me?

0:38:47 Any questions for Brianna?

0:38:50 Very thorough.

0:38:51 Thank you.

0:38:56 Okay, next before we move into general or our public hearings we have to tonight

0:39:02 The time for general public input so if there's anybody in the audience that wishes

0:39:08 To address City Council on an issue not on today's agenda and not about the budget

0:39:15 You're welcome to come down to the podium. Hey, see no one advisory board reports

0:39:33 Anybody have anything from this last week?

0:39:38 City Manager's Office.

0:39:39 Just a reminder that we will not be having a meeting the week of Labor Day, correct?

0:39:49 So no, which would normally be the third of September.

0:39:53 We will not be having a meeting that week.

0:39:55 Okay, next we'll move into public hearings and we have two tonight.

0:40:00 They're both action items.

0:40:01 The first one is a public hearing on the use of 307,591,000 of foregone revenue in the 24-25

0:40:12 fiscal year to cover ongoing operation and maintenance costs beginning October 1, 2024

0:40:20 and ending on September 30, 2025.

0:40:23 And we have our city manager, Travis Rothwiler.

0:40:26 Welcome.

0:40:27 Thank you, Madam Mayor, members of the city council.

0:40:31 Idaho cities have the opportunity to collect or to incorporate what is commonly referred

0:40:37 to as a foregone balance into their operating budgets and as we have shared over the course

0:40:43 of the last several weeks we've incorporated the 1% to cover ongoing operation and maintenance

0:40:49 costs.

0:40:50 In 2021 the city had a cap placed on to them by the legislature and you have the opportunities

0:40:59 to take 3% of your total foregone of your revenues, of your foregone balance, so 3% of the revenues

0:41:07 of your property taxes coming in, or one-time capital projects, or you can take the 1% and

0:41:14 bring that into your budget to support those ongoing maintenance costs.

0:41:17 I think as Brianna pointed out during her PowerPoint presentation, while we are seeing

0:41:23 a slight reduction in cost.

0:41:27 We are still well below the cost of what it is taking for us to perform basic services,

0:41:33 and that 1% for us equals the $307,591 that has been incorporated into this budget.

0:41:44 Per Idaho Code, prior to including it into your budget, you are required to host a public

0:41:50 caring to receive public comment about receiving that money into the budget. Should the council

0:41:58 elect not to incorporate those funds, we will then go through the process of reducing the

0:42:04 budget by a like amount prior to its adoption to ensure that we're balanced. That's why

0:42:11 when we have the conversations throughout the entire budgeting conversation, we want to

0:42:15 be incredibly transparent with the council on the sources of money. And as we have shared

0:42:20 then I will share in the regular presentation.

0:42:22 We are asked for the 3% statutory increase,

0:42:26 the equivalent value of 90% of the new construction role

0:42:30 and annexation roles, and 1% of the foregone balance.

0:42:34 All of those are already compulated into the tax rate

0:42:37 that we have been sharing with you

0:42:39 for the entire presentations.

0:42:41 Would that be happy to stand for any questions?

0:42:44 Any questions for Travis on the foregone revenue?

0:42:51 Does it look like it?

0:42:53 Okay. So with that being said, I'll open up the public hearing,

0:42:58 and this is specifically for discussion on the use of the 307,591

0:43:08 of foregone balance to be included in this particular budget.

0:43:13 Is there anybody out in the audience that wishes to all one

0:43:16 one of you wishes to comment on the foregone balance, okay, seeing no one, I will close

0:43:26 the public hearing, I'm waiting for council direction. Any discussion?

0:43:34 Mayor, I think it makes sense to move forward on that.

0:43:42 Okay, Chris Reed.

0:43:43 I was going to say the same thing. I'm going to move forward.

0:43:47 Anybody want to make a motion to that effect?

0:43:50 All right.

0:43:51 I move that we approve the use of $307,591 a foregone revenue in the 2024-2025 fiscal year

0:44:01 to cover ongoing operations and maintenance costs beginning in October 1, 2024 and ending

0:44:06 on September 30, 2025.

0:44:09 Thank you, Grayson Stone.

0:44:10 Thank you, Madam Mayor.

0:44:11 I'll second.

0:44:12 I might mention that that is actually resolution number 2024-007, which is the resolution we

0:44:20 should officially be adopting.

0:44:23 I'll add that to my motion.

0:44:25 Okay, perfect.

0:44:26 Second, good.

0:44:27 Okay, excellent.

0:44:30 So I will read the resolution real quickly, resolution number 2024-007, a resolution of

0:44:37 the city council of the city of Twin Falls,

0:44:40 declaring the intent to levy and use $307,591

0:44:46 of forgorn property tax funds in fiscal year 2024,

0:44:51 and declaring the purpose for which the forgorn funds

0:44:54 are budgeted.

0:44:56 Any further discussion?

0:44:59 Amy Roll call vote please.

0:45:02 Brace and Stone.

0:45:03 Yes.

0:45:04 Jerry Bomer.

0:45:05 Yes.

0:45:06 Ruth Pierce.

0:45:07 Yes.

0:45:08 Chris Reed.

0:45:08 Yes.

0:45:09 and Brown and Spencer Cutler yes thank you motion passes 7 to 0 Madam Mayor we

0:45:16 ask that you stand in recess till six o'clock we publish the public hearing

0:45:20 for the budget to begin at six okay we will recess and be back here just a

0:45:26 couple minutes before six thank you and the lit if we didn't have or if we had

0:45:41 public here sorry okay I'll call the meeting back to order at 6 p.m. next on

0:46:01 the agenda is a public hearing on the fiscal 24-25 budget for the City of Twin Falls, and

0:46:08 we have in our City Manager, Travis Rothweiver.

0:46:11 Welcome, Travis.

0:46:15 So, Madam Mayor and members of the City Council, thank you for allowing us to take a quick recess.

0:46:27 We had published the official public hearing for the budget for 6 p.m. and we'll begin that

0:46:33 process now.

0:46:35 So as you have before you, you have an ordinance that we are later tonight going to ask you

0:46:41 if you're ready to adopt the budget for the upcoming fiscal year.

0:46:48 Our fiscal year in the state of Idaho begins on October 1st and it concludes on September

0:46:52 30th.

0:46:53 And I can affirm to you that our budget is in line not only with the appropriate sections

0:47:02 of Idaho Code, but it is also in alignment with best practices moving forward.

0:47:11 Throughout this entire process, you've engaged the citizens, or at least provided an opportunity

0:47:15 for the citizens to be engaged in our process.

0:47:19 This is a process that we started back in April.

0:47:22 We've had a series of monthly conversations, and then those conversations went from monthly

0:47:27 to weekly, beginning throughout the month of July and August.

0:47:32 And so oftentimes, if you ask how did you spend your summer,

0:47:34 you can happily say, we were at budget camp.

0:47:37 And you've learned how to do and talk about the budget

0:47:40 all the way through.

0:47:41 But engaging our citizens is one of the values

0:47:44 that we have as part of our organization.

0:47:46 Being transparent, being inclusive,

0:47:48 and having them be a part of that process.

0:47:51 So engaging in our citizens is certainly a part of it.

0:47:53 But also engaging our employees and helping us transform

0:47:56 government because this process began back as part of the long-term planning

0:48:01 process. Back before that budget was even presented to you, we engaged our

0:48:07 employees. In fact, you may be interested to know that last week many different

0:48:13 departments had already started engaging with one another in the creation of the

0:48:18 fiscal year 26 budget. So as we are still in fiscal year 24, we're asking you to

0:48:24 to adopt fiscal year 25 budget,

0:48:27 we are now moving forward and planning

0:48:29 for fiscal year 26.

0:48:31 And so budgeting for an organization this size

0:48:35 really has become much, much more complex.

0:48:39 In our initial conversations,

0:48:41 we started with some overarching goals.

0:48:44 These goals were created for this budget

0:48:46 and they're very, very similar to all of the budgetary goals

0:48:49 that we've had because while the environments

0:48:52 have always changed, the one thing that we can be certain of is that the environment is

0:48:58 going to change.

0:48:59 And so we need to be nimble.

0:49:00 We need to be making sure that we are following our strategic plan and not chasing the shiny

0:49:06 things that we are making sure that the budget that we are presenting recognizes the community

0:49:13 in which we're operating.

0:49:14 And I thought Brianna did a great job in her economic data portions talking about how this

0:49:21 to involves compared to the various national

0:49:26 and then the awards.

0:49:28 This is really a credit to our finance team

0:49:33 and Matthew Farms who works very, very hard to ensure

0:49:36 that our budget isn't just a collection of spreadsheets

0:49:39 but it is really a document that individuals can read.

0:49:43 It is graphs, it is words, it is pictures, it is numbers.

0:49:48 We want to make sure that it is following best practices

0:49:51 and planning horizons.

0:49:52 Brandon did a really good job in talking about the economic pieces and again we've spent a

0:49:58 lot of time sharing what is Twin Falls through the lens of the city manager and members of

0:50:03 the staff as we look at preparing a budget and that is we're not a community of 56,000.

0:50:08 We're a community that sees 81,700 vehicles come in every single day and it causes our

0:50:14 population to exceed 100 to 105 individuals and at the current rates of growth we're going

0:50:21 to be a community of 65,000 people.

0:50:23 And what are we doing to prepare for that level of growth?

0:50:27 What are we doing to preserve infrastructure?

0:50:30 What are we doing that the community that we love today

0:50:35 resembles the community as we continue

0:50:38 to grow through significant growth?

0:50:41 Talked about housing and challenges associated

0:50:44 with housing as it relates to median incomes

0:50:48 and individual buying powers.

0:50:50 We talked about the Unis, the cost index.

0:50:52 We talked about the labor market.

0:50:55 And earlier tonight, we showered you

0:50:57 with a whole lot of economic data that, while I think at least

0:51:01 two of us find incredibly interesting,

0:51:03 I'm hoping that it puts a place that we don't just break out

0:51:09 the magic eight ball.

0:51:11 And Jacob to see, is this the right expenditure?

0:51:14 There's a lot of science that's going into the budget.

0:51:17 And that's why we're in the financial position

0:51:19 that we are today. I don't do that by myself. We have an amazing team of leaders, an amazing

0:51:26 team of individual employees that have really immersed ourselves in the budget process and

0:51:31 this budget is complete because of their efforts. So let's drive into the numbers and really quickly.

0:51:37 The first thing, if you're paying attention to Brianna's financial presentation and then

0:51:41 you're going to look at my numbers, you're going to say, well, Mr. City Manager, these

0:51:45 numbers are a bit different than what we're just presented, not less than 40

0:51:49 minutes ago by your CFO in terms of what is the total budget, and there's a real

0:51:55 simple easy answer for that. The first is the budget that we focus and present,

0:52:01 whether it be throughout the entire budget document, and the documents and all the

0:52:05 presentations as we focus on the net budget. And in that net budget, we remove

0:52:10 transfers, those rents that the enterprise funds pay for the services that are

0:52:17 rendered city attorney, city manager, HR. All of those different services have a

0:52:24 cost. So we essentially build them a cost which is a transfer. And so when you look

0:52:30 at Brianna's budget of $104 million of total expenditures last year and I'm

0:52:36 I'm saying it's $94 million this year.

0:52:38 Some of that number is in that transfer.

0:52:42 So net budget is what we focus on.

0:52:44 So I'm focusing on the entirety of the net budget this year,

0:52:49 just as we have throughout the entire conversation.

0:52:54 So our net budget this year is bigger.

0:52:56 And earlier, if you were following along,

0:52:58 we were reflecting a budget of about $91 billion.

0:53:03 And then right before we increase that by $11 million because we received a $8 million grant

0:53:11 from the state that we incorporated to help us with Eastland, and then we asked the council

0:53:16 to use $3.18 million of cash reserves to be able to help complete some significant one-time

0:53:23 projects moving forward.

0:53:25 And inside of this budget includes the 3% statutory increase of property taxes, 90% of

0:53:32 the taxable value of the new construction and annexation roles, and a portion of our foregone

0:53:40 balance that equals 1% in revenue, and we've been taking that 1% and incorporating it in

0:53:46 fear that the legislature is ultimately one day going to take it away, and we still have

0:53:52 nearly a million dollars in foregone balance.

0:53:55 That is an opportunity, and it demonstrates the fiscal conservativeness of the Council

0:54:00 over a period of time to build a foregone balance,

0:54:03 because what it simply says is you did not levy all

0:54:06 of the taxes that you could have otherwise collected.

0:54:09 It is also the source of the 770 that the council applied

0:54:13 and used back in 2019 to complete some significant

0:54:17 one-time projects that have really benefited the community.

0:54:22 So here's the city's total taxable value.

0:54:24 You can see it one up by 1.43%.

0:54:27 What's interesting in this numbers,

0:54:29 if you really dive into it,

0:54:30 the new construction number for the City of Twin Falls this year

0:54:34 was right around $90 million.

0:54:37 So without new construction,

0:54:39 the base of the City of Twin Falls

0:54:41 actually decreased in value.

0:54:43 And we saw a lot of that decrease

0:54:45 on the residential homeowner side this year

0:54:49 in comparison to last year.

0:54:51 In the past presentations by Brianna,

0:54:53 she has illustrated that the most significant growth

0:54:57 the different sectors operating properties operating inside the city of

0:55:01 Twin Falls has been on the residential side. This is an illustration of the tax

0:55:07 rate that is associated with this budget. It is reflected in green. You can see

0:55:12 that the tax rate is going to be $4.93 per thousand dollars of taxable value.

0:55:18 It is among the lowest tax rates and what we would share with individuals is

0:55:24 is that the tax rate, whether it goes up or goes down,

0:55:28 is not the complete story as to what

0:55:32 happens to individual property tax burdens that

0:55:36 are paid for by the residents.

0:55:38 Remember, the tax rate is just the multiplier.

0:55:40 And the multiplier is what you use

0:55:42 to determine the individual tax loads that you're paying.

0:55:45 And so, for example, the value of my home decreased greater

0:55:50 than the value of the tax rate going up.

0:55:53 And so I'm looking at paying less than property taxes this year

0:55:56 as a result of this budget than I did under the current budget.

0:56:03 And like the mayor said on the radio today,

0:56:07 I've yet to meet a single person that enjoys paying property taxes.

0:56:12 The property taxes really is that piece that drives the core responsibilities

0:56:18 of government of keeping a safe voting for the public welfare.

0:56:24 So, here is the couple of quick graphs

0:56:28 that can be found in the budget,

0:56:29 and I also will say that I recognize

0:56:31 that we're going through,

0:56:32 I'm going through this relatively quickly,

0:56:34 and appreciate that you've had this conversation,

0:56:39 what may feel like 10 times.

0:56:41 There's a great Bill Murray movie called Groundhog Day

0:56:45 that some of you might feel like you're going through

0:56:48 over the course of the last several weeks.

0:56:50 And if anybody is really interested in the city's budget,

0:56:54 I will share that it is online, individuals can take a look at it, and these charts and

0:56:59 graphs come from that budget where it reflects the total expenditures by type, which are going

0:57:05 to be the tax-supported and non-tax-supported, and then the other major pieces, as well as

0:57:10 the expenditures by category, which I thought was nicely laid out in Brianna's financial

0:57:16 presentation earlier today.

0:57:19 One of the main areas of our focus is on our employees, we want to be the employer of choice,

0:57:25 you'll notice that we have added what would appear to be a significant number of employees

0:57:31 to the city staff this year.

0:57:34 It's really what I would describe as a paper entry where we're incorporating the library

0:57:38 employees into the city's larger structure.

0:57:42 In total, we may be asking for six employees, three of which are directly dependent upon

0:57:48 the city receiving the fire safer grant which the council allowed the city to move forward

0:57:54 with earlier in the year.

0:57:56 The other employees are assistant HR director and open space supervisor where a portion of

0:58:03 that salary will be paid for with Durkies Lake proceeds and the fleet service advisor

0:58:09 in which it will be paid for by transfers by all departments that have rolling stock and

0:58:14 than a increase in a street operator from a grade 8 to a lead operator which is a grade

0:58:21 9.

0:58:26 Maintenance and operation is up by 1.95% which is lower than the MCI at the time in which

0:58:32 we are creating the budget.

0:58:37 You can see that there's an increase this year in capital expenditures over last year.

0:58:44 That increase really is attributed to the $8.2 million for the improvements on Eastland

0:58:50 to have new $3.1 million of improvements associated

0:58:54 with capital projects from cash reserves.

0:59:00 Carries over from SLFRF and completing some of those projects.

0:59:05 But what's impressive about this number is since 2018,

0:59:09 the City of Twin Falls has spent more than $141 million

0:59:12 in capital.

0:59:14 That capital is the basic platform

0:59:16 that we're using to build that community that we're talking

0:59:19 that is going to become 65,000 persons.

0:59:27 Again, here's the strategic plan over the course

0:59:31 of the last eight weeks members of our team

0:59:34 presented on the various areas of the strategic plan,

0:59:38 breaking down expenditures.

0:59:40 I thought that the members of the team

0:59:41 did a phenomenal job coming in and communicating

0:59:44 the activities of the organization,

0:59:46 the needs of the organization.

0:59:47 And everything that we're doing is rooted

0:59:49 in the city's strategic plan.

0:59:50 And again, as this project ends, and you can take that breath, we won't let you stand

0:59:58 around too long.

0:59:59 We're going to begin rating the fiscal year or the strategic plan in this upcoming fiscal

1:00:04 year, which will begin to envision what the community is going to look like by the year

1:00:09 2040.

1:00:10 So to sum it all up, we've been sharing this slide.

1:00:15 We've also shared other slides.

1:00:18 What does it look like for the median person inside of the City of Twin Falls and if the

1:00:24 median person's home grew by $5,000, which the homeowners exemption as set by the legislature

1:00:32 remained flat, they would pay about $6.11 per month or $73 or per year under this budget

1:00:42 then what they did last year based upon the adjustment to both the tax rate as well as

1:00:46 increase in the individual home value. But in my own particular case, as I share the value

1:00:52 of my home decreased significantly. And as a result of that decrease, I'm actually going

1:00:58 to be paying less until we would encourage individuals to focus in the multiplier and

1:01:03 we'd be happy to help them walk through what that individual tax-individual circumstance

1:01:08 would be for them. And then we shared the increases in terms of water rates and sewer rates and

1:01:15 utilities moving forward and those are reflected down below as well. So in closing

1:01:22 I want to thank the members of the team, the staff. I also want to share that I

1:01:26 believe that this is a solid budget. I hope that we demonstrated that over the

1:01:32 course of the last several weeks. It is stable and it is one that we can build a

1:01:37 future of Twin Falls upon. I'm happy to stand for any questions. Any questions for

1:01:43 Travis before we move on to the public hearing.

1:01:46 Hey, that being said, I'll open up the public hearing if there's anybody in the audience

1:01:55 that wishes to address City Council on this particular item, the budget.

1:02:03 You're welcome to see no one.

1:02:08 We'll close the public hearing.

1:02:12 Travis, my understanding is we need to put this is an ordinance and we need to put that

1:02:16 on third and final.

1:02:17 Is that correct?

1:02:18 Okay.

1:02:19 That is right. And the ordinance number is before you. It is ordinance 20 to 24 0 1 0. You'll need to put it on third and final.

1:02:31 Should you choose to want to adopt the ordinance tonight? If you want to have another week conversation of the budget, you do not have to approve it tonight.

1:02:40 I move that we dispense with the reading rules and put ordinance 2024-010 on third and final

1:02:54 reading by title only.

1:02:55 Thank you, Chris Reed.

1:02:57 Thank you.

1:02:59 Motion by Spencer color second second by Chris Reed to dispense with the rules and put an

1:03:06 It's 2024 on dash 010 on third and final reading by title only.

1:03:13 Amy Rolkow, please.

1:03:15 Sherri Bomer.

1:03:18 Yes.

1:03:19 Ruth Pierce.

1:03:20 Yes.

1:03:21 Chris Reed.

1:03:22 Yes.

1:03:23 Great Hawkins.

1:03:24 Yes.

1:03:25 Jason Brown.

1:03:26 Yes.

1:03:27 Yes.

1:03:28 And Grayson Stone.

1:03:29 Yes.

1:03:30 Thank you.

1:03:31 Okay.

1:03:32 I will read the ordinance ordinance 2024 dash 010.

1:03:34 the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, appropriating $102,649,038 for the 2025 fiscal year to defray

1:03:45 all necessary expenses and liabilities of the City of Twin Falls, providing for the objects

1:03:52 and purposes for which such appropriations are made and the amount appropriated for each

1:03:57 object or purchase, levying at Valoram taxes in the amount of $331,66,677 for the 2025 fiscal

1:04:10 year, providing that a copy of this ordinance shall be filed with the county commissioners

1:04:15 of Twin Falls County Idaho providing for this ordinance to take effect upon its passage

1:04:20 approval and publication according to law, rules required that an ordinance be read on

1:04:26 three separate occasions has been suspended. Chris Reed moved to approve

1:04:33 Ordinance 2024-01-0. Thank you Sherry Volmer. A second. Thank you. Motion by

1:04:39 Chris Reed. Second by Sherry Volmer. To pass Ordinance number 2024-01-0. Any

1:04:47 further discussion? Amy Rowe call vote please. Spencer Cutler. Yes. Jason Brown.

1:04:54 Yes, Greg Hawkins Chris Reed. Yes. Yes. Yes

1:05:00 Gary Volmer. Yes, and Grayson Stone. Yes

1:05:03 Thank you motion passes seven to zero

1:05:07 Thank you everyone for a very thorough

1:05:11 Budget

1:05:12 Okay, that is all that's on our agenda. So our meeting is adjourned. Thank you all

1:05:19 Thank you staff for hanging out with us

1:05:23 Instead of going

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, August 19, 2024. The recording started at 16:59 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:05:25.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    8c87fad09ed4872ca179a85f1ffd59982d00558f6e0b0f2eaa848977eecc638f
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a b5fb8a5c38cf2f614f754e86e62aa98340c781c643496b9629b0f30896656cf6
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    4b590d1d597f96e7719eb66c6ad67f8da04c96c849f212d15a4d468faf8de1fa

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file