OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, October 14, 2024

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on file

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording

Transcript

0:01:09 Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the October 14, 2024 City Council meeting.

0:01:16 I want to confirm we have a quorum, barely.

0:01:19 We have four members, President Chambers today.

0:01:23 The other three council members are excused.

0:01:27 First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:01:29 If you wish to join me, please rise.

0:01:50 Thank you.

0:01:51 We have no proclamations tonight, so next we move on to the consent calendar.

0:01:56 Excuse me.

0:01:57 Thank you. Thank you. Motion from Chris Reed seconded by Jason Brown to approve

0:02:03 the consent calendar as written. Amy Roll call vote please. Ruth Piers. Yes.

0:02:10 Chris Reed. Yes. Craig Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 4 to 0.

0:02:18 Next under items of consideration we have actually three items but we are going to postpone

0:02:24 item C's discussion until we have more council members here. That's something

0:02:31 that we're not in a hurry for and it would be best if everybody was here. So

0:02:36 first under items of consideration is an action item a request to discontinue

0:02:41 the DEQ land application permit at Aug. Falls and we have our assistant city

0:02:47 engineer Lee Glesman. Welcome Lee.

0:02:49 This is a request to discontinue the DEQ land application permitted auger falls.

0:02:56 In an effort to improve stake with water quality and to help meet the department of environmental

0:03:01 quality discharge requirements, the city developed a treated wastewater land application site

0:03:07 at Auger Falls in 2013.

0:03:09 The city used EPA grant funding to improve the road doger falls and solve pipeline and construct

0:03:14 ponds for the land application.

0:03:17 This then city's been pumping a portion of its treated wastewater about two miles from

0:03:20 the city's wastewater treatment plant, dog refalls.

0:03:24 This land application process is basically we pump water down dog refalls, put it in

0:03:30 ponds, and the water just filters through the soil to remove phosphorus and other.

0:03:35 However, the last 10 years, testing results have shown that the soil's capacity to remove

0:03:41 phosphorus is more limited than expected and an unknown amount of phosphorus is passing

0:03:45 through the soil filter.

0:03:47 If the amount of hospitals removal cannot be measured, the city cannot use the agafals

0:03:50 site to help with the city's discharge permit requirements.

0:03:56 And if we can't get a discharge permit, it's difficult to justify the cost of continuing

0:04:00 with the land application.

0:04:03 Also the land application permit, it's through DEQ, has a whole bunch of things that we have

0:04:09 to do there.

0:04:10 One of them is public access is restricted, we can't let the public anywhere near it.

0:04:14 we were to expand this to 70-80 acres and we'd have to fence out the public from that area.

0:04:20 So I mean when we first started this project we didn't have public access. This project

0:04:25 actually developed the access for the public to get two agar falls. We widened the road

0:04:30 and now it's a well used park. And part of the monitoring we have to monitor the water

0:04:36 that goes down there. We have to monitor. We have to do soil monitoring. We have to do groundwater

0:04:40 monitoring and and we also have to control animals like musk rats and and

0:04:47 rock chucks they dig through the berms if the berms were to fail and the water

0:04:52 were to leave the site we'd have a violation of our permit that we would

0:04:54 have to report and so since we can't really use it for removing phosphorus the

0:05:00 way it's configured now I'm recommending that we discontinue thank you any

0:05:07 questions questions for Lee go ahead great Lee what's plan B then

0:05:12 And if we lose that ability there, what?

0:05:15 Well, it's not.

0:05:17 So right now, we don't get any credit for it.

0:05:18 As it is, it's kind of a pilot project.

0:05:21 And when we take the water, we put it down there.

0:05:24 It's shown up in the phosphorous shown up in the ground

0:05:27 water, which goes back to the river anyway.

0:05:29 So we can't get any credit for it.

0:05:31 But we are working on some other projects,

0:05:33 kind of like our TSS ponds out at the gun range

0:05:35 at the ender point.

0:05:37 We've got this rock-crick restoration project

0:05:39 that we're starting to work on.

0:05:40 We're looking at cleaning up the water quality

0:05:42 in Rock Creek, that's about six million bucks that we have a grant for, and we're just starting

0:05:48 that right now. We've done a lot of testing on Rock Creek and I think we can probably,

0:05:52 as far as water quality in the Snake River, we could probably do far more with water quality

0:05:57 in the Snake River by putting our forces and our time into those types of projects.

0:06:01 Thank you.

0:06:02 And it's non-regulated water, so we don't have to do all the recording.

0:06:05 No hoops.

0:06:06 No hoops.

0:06:07 Chris Street.

0:06:08 Lee, what is the process to discontinue this?

0:06:10 What happens to the land over there, those pools that we currently have in?

0:06:15 Well, we'll shut off the water.

0:06:17 You know, eventually remove fences so the public can get in there where it was at.

0:06:22 I need to talk to DEQ, see what they need.

0:06:24 I probably have to do some additional reporting.

0:06:27 But as it is right now, I've got to do an annual report anyway.

0:06:29 This is what an annual report looks like.

0:06:32 I don't know if there's going to be any additional things they'll want us to do other than just close it out.

0:06:39 Jason?

0:06:40 Yeah, I follow up on Chris just a little bit.

0:06:43 So if we ever had to, you know, we discontinue that now

0:06:47 and if forever some reason we'd want to redo that again

0:06:50 in the future, that's still an option, correct?

0:06:52 Yeah, the infrastructure is still there.

0:06:54 If we wanted to, whatever we do, you know, one of the initial

0:06:59 ideas we had was to go pop through trees and things like that.

0:07:01 It's much easier to demonstrate phosphorus removal

0:07:03 if you're growing plants and you're moving

0:07:05 to soil tissue analysis.

0:07:07 So the infrastructure is there so we can still send the water

0:07:09 down there and do something, but the way we're doing it right now is just soaking it into

0:07:13 the ground. That doesn't really work for the phosphorus removal.

0:07:15 Any other questions? I'll make a motion if that's what we're looking for. I've moved to

0:07:26 discontinue the land application permit for agar falls through the Idaho Department of

0:07:31 Environmental Quality. I'll second that. Thank you. I'm motioned by Jason Brown, second by

0:07:38 Chris Reed to approve discontinuing the DEQ land

0:07:42 application permit at Arger Falls.

0:07:45 Any further discussion?

0:07:48 Amy Rokavo please.

0:07:50 Chris Reed.

0:07:51 Yes.

0:07:52 Ray Cawkins.

0:07:52 Yes.

0:07:53 Jason Brown.

0:07:54 Yes.

0:07:54 And Reese Pierce.

0:07:55 Yes.

0:07:57 Motion passes 4-0.

0:07:58 Thank you, Lee.

0:07:59 Thank you.

0:08:01 OK.

0:08:01 Next item on the agenda is also an action item.

0:08:04 It's consideration to use water reserves toward the base

0:08:09 bid and bid alternate for the 2024 Lateral 38 Improvement Project to PMF Inc. in the

0:08:17 amount of 369,477 and 30 cents and authorize the contingency in the amount of 35,000 for

0:08:26 potential change orders and we have our Water and Superintendent Rob Bulling.

0:08:32 Good evening Madam Mayor and Council. I appreciate your time to bring this forward to you this evening and as the Mayor stated we're requesting the bid award to PMF in the amount of $369.477.30 and authorizing project contingency, the amount of $35,000 for a total of $404,000.

0:09:03 of 404, 477-30. There's also a grant that we applied for through the flood management

0:09:15 grant through Department of Water Resources, and Canal Company helped us acquire that grant.

0:09:21 And that grant was for $5,914 that will be taken off of that. So just kind of give you a background

0:09:32 on it we had a project that we were looking out on lateral 38, which is downstream of our

0:09:39 Brian Cooley pump station, pressurized irrigation station, and the city is looking at expanding

0:09:47 that station and using more of our shares there for us to be able to do that and to have the

0:09:54 ability to deliver those shares to that station there was some downstream improvements that

0:09:59 needed to be made it there for us to be able to deliver all of our shares there and when

0:10:04 we were not using the shares not to flood out other people downstream because currently

0:10:12 the ditch was designed to take X amount of shares and when we build the station and move

0:10:19 shares and send a bunch more shares over to a station that didn't originally have those

0:10:23 shares in it then that can cause problems when we're not using them all downstream.

0:10:28 So that's kind of what this project is.

0:10:31 There was two projects actually that we were looking at doing.

0:10:35 And we also had some improvements

0:10:39 that we needed to do with the piping underneath the road

0:10:42 and some existing structures on that lateral also.

0:10:47 So since we looked at doing the one project in 22

0:10:51 and didn't get it fulfilled, that money went back into reserves.

0:10:55 And when we looked at doing this project and the piping

0:11:00 and other structure improvements,

0:11:01 we decided to package those together.

0:11:04 And that's why there's a bit of alternate there,

0:11:08 because we figured we could probably get a better pricing

0:11:11 if we had a contractor coming in and doing concrete structures.

0:11:16 And rather than having them come in twice,

0:11:20 you get a mope fee and all that on that.

0:11:21 So we figured we could probably get a better price doing

0:11:25 that way. You have a better, so there you can see the base bid,

0:11:42 original language, 279, 763, 40, and then the bid alternate was

0:11:48 this 89730, and then plus the contingency, and just make note,

0:11:55 contingencies to cover what ifs that we run into, we may use none of that, or $10

0:12:02 of it or a thousand. Hopefully where this is kind of out in a rural area if we won't run

0:12:08 into a whole bunch of stuff that we have to use that contingency for. But nowadays you need

0:12:14 to have something that otherwise I'll be back here asking. I hate doing that. So with all

0:12:19 that that came to 404 or 7730 and previously budgeted money for this project was in 2083.

0:12:29 We had $107,000 that we didn't use in this last budget, 24.

0:12:34 We had $280,000 for the project, but we didn't get a bid out in the contract.

0:12:41 Everything done in time, so now we have money also rolled back into reserves, and then we

0:12:47 have the $5,914 that we'll receive through the grant.

0:12:55 equals the 392 914 and so if you have the 392 914 we're asking for is

0:13:06 404,000 or 7730 that leaves us still with 11,563 30 wasn't any money allocated to

0:13:18 either one of the previous projects so hopefully that's kind of breaks that

0:13:23 down and explains the numbers there for you so we do use on budgeted for this

0:13:28 project that amount what is the timing on this project so we are just waiting for

0:13:42 council approval already got the did out received the bid back from PMF has a

0:13:48 little bit or some we're here to ask for moving forward right now yes any

0:13:54 questions for Rob. You did a very good job. Want to tackle that Jason? No I don't

0:14:05 need to add anything but if Chris and so you know just looking at this project

0:14:12 and and part of it, I think ultimately it helps prove the system downstream so

0:14:20 I'll go ahead and make a motion for the use of water reserves to award the bid

0:14:27 and bid alternate for the 2024 lateral 38 improvement project to PMF Inc. in the amount of 404,477 and 30 cents.

0:14:39 Thank you. Do I have a second?

0:14:41 Second.

0:14:42 Thank you. Motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the use of water reserves to award the base bid and bid alternate for the 2020 for lateral 38 improvement project to PMF Inc.

0:14:56 a math ink for the total of 404 you took it down for 77 30 thank you any further

0:15:06 discussion Amy Rokal vote please great Hawkins yes Jason Brown yes Ruth

0:15:16 Pierce yes and Chris Reed yes thank you motion passes 40 0 thank you Rob

0:15:25 We'll get started on that tonight, right?

0:15:29 Oh, okay, okay, yeah.

0:15:34 Okay, so that is all for items of consideration.

0:15:37 Next on the agenda is a time for public input.

0:15:41 If there's anybody in the public that wishes

0:15:44 to address City Council on an issue not on today's agenda,

0:15:49 please come down.

0:15:53 See no one advisory board reports.

0:15:55 Craig.

0:15:57 I just wanted to mention that the Friday Cliff Bar sent, I guess, their entire outfit,

0:16:06 and all the employees came down to Rock Creek, and I think it was, what, 230-some?

0:16:10 It's close to 300 people.

0:16:12 Close to 300 people.

0:16:13 Close to 300 people.

0:16:14 Yep.

0:16:15 And they started, I think, about eight or nine o'clock and worked till four o'clock.

0:16:19 Got a lot done.

0:16:21 It closed down the factory for the day and sent everybody to Rock Creek.

0:16:25 Wow.

0:16:26 Yeah.

0:16:27 It was pretty cool.

0:16:28 think and they were tired it was one day but they got a lot done and I'm sure

0:16:33 they saved the city a whole lot of money when you add up all the manpower and

0:16:37 stuff so anyway I just wanted to mention that that's great any other advisory

0:16:42 board reports anything from a manager okay so we'll move on to the public

0:16:50 hearings we have two public hearings tonight and before we start I'm just

0:16:55 going to read the rules so we have them in everybody's mind so we will follow this process

0:17:02 for the public hearing portion of the agenda. City staff will first present the request

0:17:08 and analysis. The applicant will then present their request. The council will then ask questions

0:17:15 of the applicant or staff. After questions have been asked the public hearing will be

0:17:20 opened during that time anyone in attendance is given the opportunity to

0:17:24 comment or ask questions about the requests being considered. When giving

0:17:29 testimony please step up to the podium to state your name and address and present

0:17:33 your comments or concerns. You will be given two minutes after you give testimony

0:17:39 please sign the public sign-in sheet which is located upstairs with your name

0:17:45 and address for the record. After public comments are concluded the applicant

0:17:50 will be invited to answer any questions and make a closing statement. Staff will then

0:17:55 answer, clarify any comments as needed. After the closing statement, public hearing will

0:18:01 be closed and then the council will have open discussion and take action. So our first public

0:18:07 hearing is a request for City Council to amend the Federation Point Zoning Development

0:18:13 agreement and conceptual plan to specify lot sizes for each building on property located

0:18:20 at 2035 Washington Street North, here of EHM engineers on behalf of Federation Point

0:18:27 property LLC, PZ24-0081 and we have William Clayver, our senior city planner.

0:18:36 Welcome William.

0:18:37 Thank you Madam Mayor and grateful to be in front of you today.

0:18:43 Today we have an application for ZDA,

0:18:45 a zoning development agreement amendment.

0:18:48 This amendment is for Federation Point.

0:18:53 It is located on Washington Street North,

0:18:58 right where Federation Road they're going together.

0:19:08 This is for the entirety of the Federation Point,

0:19:11 but really focuses on the residential portion,

0:19:15 on the south portion of the ZDA.

0:19:19 For your reference, the ZDA goes all the way up

0:19:21 to the Federation Road and down,

0:19:24 and this is your south border.

0:19:30 The, this Federation Point ZDA was created originally

0:19:34 in 2021.

0:19:35 In 2022, the ZDA was amended to accommodate

0:19:41 the Chem Prep Charter School,

0:19:43 which is permitted by right.

0:19:45 And then now before you today is again,

0:19:48 just to accommodate the residential aspect of it.

0:19:53 Essentially, everything stays the same,

0:19:55 besides one comment before I get to that.

0:19:59 Let me go through some zoning and future land usage.

0:20:04 But again, it's the ZDA zoning map,

0:20:11 the Federation Point ZDA.

0:20:14 It's currently used as residential and institutional.

0:20:18 to the east is E1, and then also to the west and south,

0:20:26 and then is residential primary single families.

0:20:30 And to the north is residential with a gun range

0:20:35 and the Canyon Rim Trail.

0:20:39 As far as the future land use map goes,

0:20:41 this is a town neighborhood.

0:20:44 I'm sitting on the other side of Washington.

0:20:46 is easy, but really it's a town neighborhood feel, which is primarily residential.

0:20:56 Though the current verbiage simply states that the lot or parcel area shall be a minimum

0:21:09 of six and one-tenth acre and shall contain nineteen-four plexes and seven duplex buildings

0:21:15 with a total of ninety residential one acres as depicted in the master plan.

0:21:23 The proposed verbiage keeps that verbiage, but then adds that the four plex and duplex

0:21:28 buildings may be on any individual water parcel of not less than 8,000 square feet.

0:21:36 So what does this mean?

0:21:38 It means that the develop is now eligible to split up the property or would be eligible

0:21:43 to split up the property into different lots where it was tied to the 6.1 acre lot.

0:21:50 would not allow for smaller lots to be in existence.

0:21:55 So this would allow for them to split it up,

0:21:57 potentially sell off the individual parcels

0:22:00 that that's how they wanted to do it,

0:22:02 or it also gives them the ability

0:22:06 to utilize creative financing and make it a phase development

0:22:11 rather than all that once.

0:22:14 Then the last part is it means that all previous entitlements

0:22:17 stay on the same, such as density,

0:22:19 the high proposed uses, the previous conditions

0:22:22 approval with the fence being built, that would all stay the same. This is the

0:22:29 criteria, I know this is criteria I apologize for that. Criteria for review has

0:22:38 outlined in our city code. This is really what we need to address today. I

0:22:45 wanted to conclude my portion with the last portion of the applicant's

0:22:53 narrative. So the change will not add any effect to the surrounding area other

0:22:56 them to allow the development to proceed with construction and stages as the market determines

0:23:02 intent in terms of the original originally approved CDA remaining attacked with the minor

0:23:06 change throughout individual individual plots for each building. Staff concurs with that

0:23:12 agrees with that statement and with that I will stand for any any questions you may have.

0:23:22 So Will, could you flip back a couple of three slides real quick, right there.

0:23:28 So what you're saying is the 19, four plexus and seven duplexus for a total of 90 will not

0:23:35 change.

0:23:36 It's just the lot size, basically.

0:23:38 Correct.

0:23:39 Okay.

0:23:40 Thank you.

0:23:41 The density and everything stays.

0:23:42 Thank you.

0:23:43 Any other questions?

0:23:44 Great.

0:23:46 I guess my understanding is that basically they want to start some income and sell some

0:23:54 property.

0:23:55 They can go ahead and start that, but the parameters are still the same, right?

0:23:58 Yes, that's correct.

0:23:59 Okay.

0:24:03 Any other questions for Will?

0:24:07 Hey, the applicant?

0:24:08 Good evening, member, mayor and members of the council, Tim Vosser with the HM engineers

0:24:20 representing the applicant.

0:24:24 So I love the Councilman Hawkins question at the end there because that's exactly the case.

0:24:33 What we have is a lot of paperwork to basically do something relatively simple.

0:24:40 The owners of the property when they first went to pull a building permit and that was

0:24:47 applied for earlier this year.

0:24:52 They realized that they had to move forward with the whole development in order to get

0:24:59 that done.

0:25:00 As you might know, lending is somewhat difficult and procuring money to get all of those units

0:25:09 built in order to releasing a certificate of occupancy so they can start renting out units

0:25:15 that are already complete.

0:25:17 It gets tied up pretty quickly when you get into financial institutions and your guarantees.

0:25:25 So by doing nothing more than applying law lines to each individual unit, that enables

0:25:32 the owners to come in and do a group of two to six units at a time, get those in compliance

0:25:40 with all the city standards, and then get those released for certificate of occupancy

0:25:46 and just roll right into the next phase.

0:25:49 It's really basically orderly development

0:25:53 that allows them to move forward more easily.

0:25:57 The base ZDA does not change and we're not asking

0:26:00 for any specific use of those applications

0:26:05 of individual lots for the unit.

0:26:09 If you have any questions, I'd be happy to answer any.

0:26:13 Any questions for Tim?

0:26:15 Doesn't look like it. Thank you. Thank you very much. Okay

0:26:22 Time to open up the public hearing

0:26:25 So I'll open that up officially is there anybody in the audience that wishes to give testimony on this particular item

0:26:33 You know when I will close the public hearing

0:26:41 Is there probably aren't any questions or any additional comments before I close the public hearing well

0:26:49 Just for the record, there has been one letter sent out that was included in your packet, otherwise it's not.

0:26:58 Yes, thank you for saying that. Thank you.

0:27:01 Okay, so I will close the public hearing.

0:27:05 No further testimony will be allowed. Council time for discussion, right?

0:27:13 It just makes sense. The conditions we're facing today and cost the money, at least they can get started.

0:27:21 Thank you. Anybody else? Good? Yeah, I'll add, you know, the environment of borrowing money right now has changed since 2001 and this was originally presented, so understanding the desire and the need to be able to do that is perfectly fine.

0:27:36 I do hope that whatever happens with this does move forward quickly so we don't have a piece of dirt and really eye traffic beautiful area that's just not sitting there for years and years and years to come that they're going to do something they move quickly on it.

0:27:55 Hey, make a motion?

0:27:58 Yes.

0:27:59 Yeah.

0:28:00 I move to approve the request to the City Council to amend the Federation Point Zoning

0:28:04 Development Agreement and Conceptual Plan to specify lot sizes in each building on property

0:28:11 located at 2035 Washington Street, North, care of the HM and engineers on behalf of

0:28:17 Federation Point property LLC.

0:28:20 Thank you.

0:28:21 Do I have a second?

0:28:22 Second.

0:28:23 Thank you.

0:28:24 Motion by Chris Reed.

0:28:25 Craig Hawkins to approve the amendment to the Federation Point Zoning Development Agreement

0:28:30 and Conceptual Plan to specify a lot of sizes for each building on property located at 203.5

0:28:38 Washington Street North, Car of EHM Engineers. On behalf of Federation Point property, LLC.

0:28:46 Any further discussion? Amy Rolkow, please?

0:28:50 Case in Brown. Yes, Bruce Pierce. Yes, Chris Reed. Yes, and Craig Hawkins. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes four to zero. Thank you gentlemen. Hey, next public hearing are requests for City Council to approve the annexation of approximately two acres located on the southwest corner of Park Avenue and Washington Street, South.

0:29:18 Here of Jim State dairy products LLC

0:29:22 easy 24-082 we have our city planner Lisa Strickland welcome Lisa good evening mayor council

0:29:48 This is a request for an annexation with the zoning designation of M2 for property located at the southwest corner of Park Avenue

0:29:55 Washington Street, South

0:29:57 The subject property is located within the counties area of impact and although we do not have jurisdiction over its land use

0:30:05 designation, we do know it was entitled in the county as M1. In 2019, Jim State,

0:30:12 Derry rezoned the undeveloped agricultural property to the Northwest from R4 and M1

0:30:18 to M2 for future development. They have since purchased this project or this

0:30:24 property and are requesting it to be zoned to M2 if annexed. Although the

0:30:28 declaration of land use is not required with the zone request, the Commission took

0:30:32 into consideration the differences between the zones and the land uses allowed when making

0:30:38 the recommendation to approve the request from M1 to M2.

0:30:44 A review of the M1 and M2 zoning designation districts revealed that the land uses within

0:30:50 each zone are very similar except for the uses are categorized and permitted in special

0:30:55 uses.

0:30:56 The M2 zoning district also has uses that are not listed in the M1 zoning district but these

0:31:01 additional uses do require a special use permit within the M2 zone.

0:31:07 As a part of the consideration, the commission also reviewed the comprehensive plan to determine

0:31:12 if the change would be appropriate and compatible with the future land use map.

0:31:16 Keeping in mind that the comprehensive plan is a guide to what the city's proposed uses

0:31:22 for the area and that the designations are not attached to the property boundaries, rather

0:31:27 represent what would generally be compatible in the surrounding area.

0:31:31 The property therefore has two designations, neighborhood commercial on the east and industrial

0:31:36 flex on the west.

0:31:49 The neighborhood commercial is characterized by small-scale commercial development designed

0:31:54 to complement the neighborhood's character.

0:31:57 Examples of neighborhood commercial land uses are offices, small-scale retail, civic and

0:32:03 community facilities and apartments.

0:32:05 The industrial flex is characterized by businesses

0:32:08 for bride non-retail employment and support local industries

0:32:12 within the community such as hotels, restaurants,

0:32:14 and other retail uses and are located near regional roads

0:32:18 and railways.

0:32:19 Staff has determined that the current entitlement of M1

0:32:23 and the requested zone of M2 are very similar in nature

0:32:26 and are compatible with the Future Laney's plan.

0:32:29 The proposed zone change, if approved,

0:32:31 would support the goals of the comprehensive plan,

0:32:34 which is to allow for future industrial growth in this area.

0:32:38 Prior to hearing and annexation requests,

0:32:40 the council shall receive a recommendation

0:32:42 on the zoning designation for the subject property

0:32:45 and the commission on September 10th of 2024

0:32:48 held a public hearing to make a recommendation

0:32:51 on the zoning designation for this property

0:32:53 and has recommended M2.

0:32:56 Upon conclusion, the council is tasked

0:32:58 with making a final decision on the annexation

0:33:01 and the zoning designation of this property.

0:33:04 The council may approve the request as presented,

0:33:06 approve with conditions, table the request

0:33:09 for additional information or deny the request.

0:33:12 Should the council approve the request,

0:33:14 staff recommends that it be subject

0:33:16 to the following conditions,

0:33:18 subject to applicant dedicating right-of-way

0:33:21 for Park Avenue with of the dedication

0:33:24 to be determined by the city engineer

0:33:26 and subject to Park Avenue right-of-way improvements

0:33:28 to be installed by owner of the property

0:33:31 at the time of development,

0:33:32 design of improvements to be determined by the City Engineer.

0:33:36 So if we're looking at the conditions,

0:33:39 this is Park Avenue, this is the property in question.

0:33:43 When they decide to develop this property,

0:33:45 they will need to extend Park Avenue,

0:33:49 and therefore that's where the condition comes in,

0:33:51 where they dedicate right away.

0:33:54 And I'll stand for any questions.

0:33:57 Questions for Lisa?

0:34:05 We can now hear from the applicant.

0:34:08 Welcome.

0:34:13 Good afternoon, Mayor, Council members.

0:34:16 This is just a simple request for annexation and changes.

0:34:19 Your name, please.

0:34:20 Oh, I'm sorry, Mayor.

0:34:21 All right, I'm at a couple of your comments.

0:34:23 Manager of Jim State.

0:34:26 Thank you.

0:34:26 Great products.

0:34:28 Just a simple request stated by the City Planner.

0:34:32 Hey, any questions for Hank?

0:34:37 OK.

0:34:39 So I will open up the public hearing.

0:34:42 Again, if you're giving testimony,

0:34:44 please step up to the podium, state your name,

0:34:46 address and present your comments. Is there anybody in the audience that wishes to address

0:34:52 City Council on this item? Hey, see no one, any additional information, Lisa? Okay, then I will

0:35:04 close the public hearing. Um, doesn't make sense to me. Somebody want to make some motion? Hey,

0:35:21 you're looking at you. Okay, I'll give it a try here and move there that we approve the

0:35:26 the request for City Council to approve the annexation of approximately two acres located

0:35:31 on the southwest corner of Park Avenue in Washington Street, South, Fair of Gem State

0:35:36 Dairy Products, LLC, EZ24-0082 with the conditions stated.

0:35:44 I'll second that.

0:35:46 Thank you.

0:35:47 Motion by Craig Hawkins.

0:35:48 Second by Chris Reed to approve the annexation of approximately two acres located on the southwest

0:35:55 Corner of Park Avenue in Washington Street, South,

0:35:59 Carav Gym State, Dairy Products, LLC, PC, 24,

0:36:03 Dust 0082, Subject to the Conditions

0:36:07 Recommended by Staff.

0:36:09 Any further discussion?

0:36:11 Amy Rokow, please.

0:36:13 Ruth Pierce?

0:36:14 Yes.

0:36:15 Russ Reed?

0:36:15 Yes.

0:36:16 Greg Hawkins?

0:36:17 Yes.

0:36:17 And Jason Brown?

0:36:18 Yes.

0:36:20 Thank you, Motion passes forward to zero.

0:36:23 So that is it on our items on the agenda tonight.

0:36:27 So we're adjourned.

0:36:28 Thank you.

0:36:29 Do you want to do general public input?

0:36:31 We skipped that one real quick.

0:36:32 No.

0:36:33 I did.

0:36:34 Oh, OK.

0:36:35 I didn't.

0:36:36 Sorry.

0:36:37 I wasn't paying attention, and apparently I did that.

0:36:40 OK.

0:36:41 So we're adjourned.

0:36:42 Thank you, everyone.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, October 14, 2024. The recording started at 16:59 by the recorder's clock and runs 00:36:47.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    a1cb2fc1da02da55efceb784bef64ccee0af7cd74fbd19e0a7c74a6da726a215
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a c783e2aa379bd74dce98db0c0972dcca76a5878ce03f624a0a6fbed3894d7ba2
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-11. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    0a274c1a16b87f3222571ec4c0584314627e1c47b51e626227a3227d72663ca9

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file