City Council meeting
Monday, December 2, 2024
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on file
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:02:30 No, sir. I did too.
0:02:34 It is. Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the December 2nd,
0:02:39 2024 City Council meeting. I want to confirm we have a quorum.
0:02:44 We have all seven members present in chambers tonight. First item on the agenda
0:02:50 is the Pledge of Allegiance. If you wish to join me, please rise.
0:03:10 Thank you. We have no proclamations tonight.
0:03:13 So moving on to the consent calendar.
0:03:16 Council wishes move to approve.
0:03:19 Thank you to have a second. Thank you motion by Chris Reed seconder by Craig Hawkins to approve the consent calendar as written
0:03:28 Amy Rope
0:03:31 Rachel Rolkalvo, please
0:03:34 Yes
0:03:44 Yes, thank you motion passes seven to zero
0:03:47 Okay, next on the agenda under items of consideration, we're going to rearrange our agenda a little
0:03:55 bit.
0:03:56 So we're going to start with item C, which is introduction of officers, then we'll move
0:04:01 on to A and then B. Welcome, Chief.
0:04:06 First item, introduction of the Twin Falls Police Department's new employees, Deann Taylor,
0:04:12 Sebastian, on Drocky.
0:04:14 Sorry about that.
0:04:15 Candice McCall, Hannah Smith, Megan Smith, Parker, and Logan Wilcox and we have our
0:04:21 Chief of Police, Craig Keensbury. Thank you, Madam Mayor, members of the Council,
0:04:25 those people in attendance tonight. This is an exciting night. We're going to
0:04:30 introduce you to some of our new employees. We're going to present some
0:04:35 awards and certificates to some of our employees and then finally we will have
0:04:39 of their peers swear in our two newest police officers.
0:04:44 So for starters, I'm gonna turn this over
0:04:47 to Captain Wright for the introduction of the new employees.
0:04:56 Thank you, Chief, Madam Mayor, members of council.
0:04:59 It's my honor tonight to introduce some new employees
0:05:02 to the city family.
0:05:04 If I could get Sebastian Congratky,
0:05:07 Deann Taylor,
0:05:09 Candace McCall,
0:05:11 Anna Smith,
0:05:13 and Logan Wilcox to come up.
0:05:15 Unfortunately, Madam Mayor Meghan was not able to make it tonight.
0:05:19 I am going to read her bio once everybody gets up there though.
0:05:29 I'm going to start with our newest police officer, Sebastian
0:05:31 Congratky was born and raised in Twin Falls, Idaho.
0:05:34 He attended Cannon Ridge High School,
0:05:36 where he played football and held a 3.5 GPA.
0:05:40 After high school, Sebastian joined the United States Marine
0:05:42 Corps.
0:05:43 During his time with the Marine Corps,
0:05:45 Sebastian was a martial arts instructor
0:05:47 and taught Marines hand-to-hand combat.
0:05:50 Sebastian was meritoriously promoted twice
0:05:53 and achieved the rank of sergeant.
0:05:55 Although he enjoyed his time in the military,
0:05:57 Sebastian knew he wanted to go home and serve his community.
0:06:00 Sebastian was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department
0:06:03 on October 30th, 2024.
0:06:09 Next, I'm gonna introduce some new members
0:06:11 of our communication center,
0:06:14 starting with our new manager, Deann Taylor.
0:06:17 Deann was born and raised in Riverdale, Utah.
0:06:20 She attended Utah State University,
0:06:21 where she met her husband, Robert.
0:06:23 They married in 1990 and moved to Idaho in 1993.
0:06:28 The aunt began her emergency communications career
0:06:30 on December 6, 1993 at the Cashew County Sheriff's Office
0:06:34 in Burleigh.
0:06:35 She was also a reserve police officer
0:06:37 for the Haberne Police Department from 1994 to 1995.
0:06:41 In October 2002, she was promoted
0:06:43 to Emergency Communications Supervisor.
0:06:46 The aunt has been a member of the Idaho Public Safety
0:06:49 answering point standards and training committee since 2008.
0:06:54 This committee was formed in 2007 by the Idaho Public Safety Communications Commission and
0:07:00 consists of 12 members from emergency communication centers throughout the state.
0:07:04 The end began working for the Twin Falls Police Department on August 12, 2024.
0:07:09 The end and her husband have two children and two grandsons and in their spare time they
0:07:13 loved to go camping, hiking, kayaking, fishing, and anything else in the great outdoors.
0:07:20 Next up, Candace McCall. Candace was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on May 20th,
0:07:26 2024 as an emergency communications officer. Candace was born in both Tello and raised in Filer
0:07:32 where she graduated from Filer High School in 2005. Prior to employment with the Twin Falls Police
0:07:38 Department, Candace worked in the agricultural field. Candace has always been passionate about
0:07:43 serving her community is happy to be a part of the City of Twin Falls family.
0:07:48 Anna Smith Anna was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on October 21st,
0:07:54 2024 as an emergency communications officer. She was born in Florida and relocated to Jerome
0:08:00 when she was one years old. Hannah graduated from Jerome High School in 2023 and was a member of
0:08:06 the National Honor Society, DECA and the Advanced Drama Team. She also participated in the Jerome
0:08:12 chambers leadership program during her senior year and attended CSI for one year in the business
0:08:18 administration program plans to resume her studies in the fall of 2025. Logan Wilcox,
0:08:27 Logan was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on May 20th, 2024 as a branch
0:08:31 communication officer. Logan was born in Los Angeles County. We won't hold that against him
0:08:37 and relocated to Twin Falls County six days after he graduated from high school in 2021.
0:08:46 While in high school Logan played in his school's marching band, all throughout high school as a percussionist,
0:08:52 and Logan is very happy to also join our team.
0:08:57 Logan and Candace are scheduled to attend the Idaho Post Dispatch Academy starting next Monday.
0:09:05 And last, Megan Smith Parker graduated from high school in May 2024 and joined the Twin
0:09:13 Falls Police Department as Emergency Communications Officer in September.
0:09:17 She's an avid reader, artist, and Los animals.
0:09:20 Megan moved to Twin Falls from Kerry, Idaho in August and again is happy to be part of
0:09:25 the City of Twin Falls family.
0:09:27 I know not everyone has family members in attendance tonight, but if you do, I would invite you
0:09:32 to come up to the podium and please share your family with us.
0:09:45 My boyfriend Jason's here, my son Aiden is here and my daughter Ryder is here.
0:09:50 Hi, I'm Hannah and I have my dad, Jared, my little sister Rebecca and my grandma Kristen.
0:10:07 And I think that's it. I'm gonna turn it back over to the chief.
0:10:20 Thank you, Captain. Yeah, and what we'll do, Mayor and Councils, we'll have,
0:10:28 we'll throw all three of these presentations and after we're done,
0:10:32 I'll have them stand up here so you can shake their hands and congratulate them.
0:10:37 Next up, I'd like to call Lieutenant Justin Diamond and Lieutenant Terry Thuyson to award
0:10:43 some certificates from that whole piece of standards in training.
0:10:46 Good evening, Mayor, members of Council.
0:10:55 It's a privilege I have this evening to present some of our officers for advancement and to
0:11:00 receive some certificates that they've earned over the past few months.
0:11:03 With that, the first one I'm going to award, or we're going to award this evening is for
0:11:07 a Canine certificate for patrol and controlled substance detection, so if I could have Detective
0:11:14 Bradley Beige come forward. Detective Bradley Beige was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department
0:11:26 in January 2013. Brad was born and raised in Twin Falls and graduated from Twin Falls High
0:11:31 School in 2009. He graduated from the College of Southern Idaho law enforcement program in
0:11:37 2011. In 2015 Brad was assigned to the department's Canine unit. He successfully completed a 10 week
0:11:45 400-hour dual-purpose canine handler school at the Alabama Canine Law Enforcement Training
0:11:51 Center with his dog Enzo. Enzo and Brad had over a thousand deployments and over 50 criminal
0:11:58 apprehensions in the Magic Valley area. Enzo retired in October of 2024. In 2022 Brad returned
0:12:05 to Alabama Canine to attend a 500-hour Canine Instructor course. He then received his Idaho
0:12:12 post-K9 instructor certification. In July 2023 Brad was assigned to the Criminal
0:12:18 Investigations Division as a detective in the Special Investigations Unit. Brad is
0:12:23 currently working with his dual-purpose K9, excuse me, Hugo, and tonight we are
0:12:29 here to present him with his patrol certification and his control substance
0:12:33 detection certification, Detective Brad Beige. And I'm going to put Detective Beige
0:13:08 on the spot and have him introduce us to his family and his news members.
0:13:20 Okay next we'll be awarding a post basic certificate so if I could have
0:13:44 Officer Jacob Kennedy come down. Officer Jacob Kennedy was hired by the Twin
0:13:58 False Police Department in November 2023 as a police officer recruit. Jacob
0:14:03 Kennedy was born in Mission Viejo, California and he was raised in Huntington
0:14:07 Beach, California. Jacob graduated from Edison High School where he excelled as
0:14:12 as a team member and demonstrated his leadership skills on Edison's cross-country and track-and-filled
0:14:20 varsity teams. Prior to employment with the Twin Falls Police Department, Jacob served
0:14:24 his country in the United States Coast Guard. Jacob is passionate about serving his community
0:14:29 in a law enforcement role. Jacob's life experiences have taught him that serving others is where
0:14:35 he wants to be and where he wants to focus his time and energy, Officer Kennedy.
0:15:05 will be awarding post-intermediate certificates.
0:15:08 If I could have Nicholas Hernandez, Jason Heringsma, Tyler
0:15:12 Kooter, and Sean Perkins come forward.
0:15:32 We're going to start with Officer Nicholas Hernandez.
0:15:36 Officer Hernandez, actually this evening,
0:15:38 is receiving his post-basic certificate, as well as
0:15:42 his intermediate certificate.
0:15:45 Officer Nicholas Hernandez was hired by the Twin Falls Police
0:15:47 Department in November of 2023 as a police officer.
0:15:51 He was born and raised in Indianapolis, Indiana, and graduated from Rongkali High School in
0:15:56 2012.
0:15:57 Officer Hernandez excelled as a team member in leadership and skills on his varsity hockey
0:16:03 team.
0:16:04 Prior to Officer Hernandez's employment with the Twin Falls Police Department, he was a
0:16:08 police officer for the San Diego Police Department for three and a half years.
0:16:13 Officer Hernandez attended Holy Cross College and graduated with a bachelor's degree in
0:16:17 psychology.
0:16:18 Officer Hernandez moved to Twin Falls in October of 2023
0:16:22 with his wife and three daughters
0:16:24 and welcomed a baby boy in December of 2023.
0:16:27 Officer Hernandez hopes to join the Canine Unit
0:16:30 to better serve the community
0:16:32 and make it a safe place for our citizens.
0:16:34 Officer Hernandez.
0:16:52 Officer Jason Herringsmo was hired
0:16:54 by the Twin Falls Police Department on September 26th, 2022
0:16:58 as a police officer.
0:17:00 Jason was born and raised in California
0:17:02 graduated from the Ontario Christian High School in 1999. Prior to being employed
0:17:07 with Twin Falls Police Department, he worked for the Los Angeles County Sheriff's
0:17:10 Department for 10 years. Jason has been married to Amanda Heringsma for 18 years
0:17:15 and they have three three children, Holland, Harper and Jacob. Jason is
0:17:20 passionate about serving his community and law enforcement role. His life
0:17:25 experiences have taught him that serving others is where he wants to be
0:17:28 where he wants to focus his energy. Officer Jason Herrinsman.
0:17:56 Good evening, Madam Mayor and Council. Next, we'd like to introduce Tyler
0:18:01 Kutter. Officer Kutter was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on March 30th, 2020.
0:18:06 Tyler was born in Ontario, Oregon, and he was raised in Peyet, Idaho. He graduated from Peyet High
0:18:13 School in 2010 and went on to attend Montana Western University. Tyler later transferred to
0:18:20 to Idaho State University on a football scholarship.
0:18:23 After college, Tyler was invited to,
0:18:26 who, did I announce that?
0:18:32 Tyler was invited to join the Green Bay Packers
0:18:36 as a defensive lineman.
0:18:41 Tyler's career with Packers was unfortunately cut short
0:18:44 due to a knee injury in 2016.
0:18:47 He moved to Twin Falls in 2018
0:18:50 with his beautiful wife, Lindsey,
0:18:52 and they recently had their first child.
0:18:55 Tyler has always wanted to help people.
0:18:57 He takes his role as a law enforcement officer seriously
0:19:00 and is passionate about serving his community.
0:19:03 Tyler Gooder.
0:19:15 Tyler, do you want to introduce your family?
0:19:32 Sean Perkins, Officer Perkins was hired
0:19:34 by the Twin Falls Police Department in December of 2021.
0:19:38 He was born and raised in Twin Falls,
0:19:40 so serving his hometown community as special to him.
0:19:44 Sean graduated from Twin Falls High School in 2016
0:19:47 and attended Treasure Valley Community College
0:19:49 on the soccer scholarship.
0:19:51 After junior college, he attended Boise State University,
0:19:55 graduating with a bachelor's degree
0:19:56 in criminal justice in 2021.
0:20:00 In his free time, Sean loves to hunt, fish, camp,
0:20:03 and be with friends and family, Sean Perkins.
0:20:29 I'd now like to ask Officer Kevin Warner to join us.
0:20:40 The Knight Officer Warner is being awarded
0:20:43 his Idaho Post Advanced Certificate
0:20:46 in order to qualify for an advanced certificate,
0:20:49 the applicant must possess or be eligible to possess
0:20:53 his intermediate certificate,
0:20:55 as well as have a combination of a minimum
0:20:57 of 15 college credits in conjunction
0:21:00 with post-training hours combined with years of service.
0:21:06 Officer Warner was born and raised in northwest Ohio,
0:21:09 Kevin attended the University of Toledo until 2016,
0:21:13 when he was hired by the San Diego Police Department.
0:21:16 He enjoyed his time with San Diego PD until 2016,
0:21:20 or excuse me, from 2016 until 2021.
0:21:25 Kevin moved to the Magic Valley
0:21:27 and began his career with the Twin Falls Police Department
0:21:29 in August of 2021, Officer Warner.
0:21:50 I'll turn the time back to the chief.
0:21:57 You know, as I'm standing back there listening to these bios
0:22:00 of some of the newer members of our department,
0:22:03 as well as some that have been here for a while
0:22:05 and achieved these different levels
0:22:07 of training certificates through our governing body
0:22:10 at the Idaho Peace Officer Standards and Training Council.
0:22:14 I think it, I hope that it shows to our community
0:22:18 the job that we do in hiring and selecting people
0:22:21 to join the Twin Falls Police Department
0:22:23 and to join the city of Twin Falls family.
0:22:27 Now we're gonna do something that is very exciting,
0:22:31 I always like to do this
0:22:33 because we want to bring two new members on
0:22:37 that going to the department a little while ago,
0:22:40 they're just getting ready to complete their training
0:22:42 in the academy, and I'll talk about that in a minute.
0:22:46 But we're gonna have Mayor Pierce wear them in,
0:22:49 then they'll be pinned with their badges
0:22:51 by their loved ones, always a huge moment
0:22:55 in our progression.
0:22:58 So you've seen a little bit of everything here tonight,
0:23:00 council and to our community.
0:23:02 I would like to have recruit officers,
0:23:05 Cesar Cervantes Jr. and Michael Rich come down and join me here, please.
0:23:19 If I could have you just turn the face of the council real quick.
0:23:26 Mayor, council, members of our community, before I get into their background,
0:23:31 I want to talk a little bit about what this means, this journey that they are about to embark on.
0:23:39 Our city was founded in 1904. In 1907, the Twin Falls Police Department became a police department in the state of Idaho
0:23:47 C. W. Dyer. Since that time, many brave men and women have served this community, keeping
0:23:55 our community safe and at times risking their lives. And as this council is aware, two members
0:24:04 paid the ultimate sacrifice during the history of our agency. As you see, me and other members
0:24:11 of the command staff wearing our Class A uniforms, we're wearing a badge. It's a little bit different
0:24:16 that will be being pinned on these two new officers.
0:24:19 The badge that we're wearing this evening
0:24:21 is what we wear for special occasions like this.
0:24:24 We refer to it as the Bracken badge.
0:24:27 Has the number three and it's a replica badge
0:24:30 of what Craig Bracken was wearing the night
0:24:32 that he was murdered in the line of duty many years ago.
0:24:38 Taking this oath for both Officer Savantes and Officer Rich,
0:24:45 it's a big step, gentlemen.
0:24:48 You're joining a legion of men and women that have taken the same oath to wear that patch representing this community,
0:24:57 wear the badge that will be pinned on you by your loved ones shortly, and then, more importantly, wearing that nameplate that sits on your uniform.
0:25:07 Because all three of those things have so much history.
0:25:10 City of Twin Falls, the Twin Falls Police Department.
0:25:16 I know you both have family members here and I would say,
0:25:19 more important to your family members,
0:25:21 that last name that you're both wearing
0:25:23 upon your uniform today.
0:25:25 Hostess to me, Mayor and Council,
0:25:29 is Recruit Officer Cesar Cervantes Jr.
0:25:32 He was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department April 8, 2024.
0:25:36 He's a graduate of Kenya Ridge High School back in 2019.
0:25:40 I like getting some of the local talent, right?
0:25:43 Even back then, he had aspirations
0:25:45 to become a police officer.
0:25:47 He worked several jobs from retail
0:25:49 to working in the hospital as a transporter,
0:25:52 where he grew a heart for helping others in need.
0:25:56 Caesar, members of our community,
0:25:57 members of the law enforcement team,
0:26:00 throughout his adolescence due to his passion
0:26:02 for Brazilian Jiu Jitsu and wrestling
0:26:05 over the course of nearly 10 years
0:26:07 and going into his mixed martial arts career.
0:26:11 I will tell you that when we do arrest control techniques,
0:26:16 they don't put us old guys with Caesar
0:26:18 because he will hurt us very badly.
0:26:20 So, Caesar is very honored and humbled to be a member
0:26:25 of the select few that will be checked
0:26:27 and serve our community, the community that he
0:26:29 was born and raised in.
0:26:32 Standing next to him is Michael Rich.
0:26:34 Michael was hired by us on April 8, 2024
0:26:37 as a police officer recruit.
0:26:39 He also was born and raised here in Twin Falls County.
0:26:43 He attended school and graduated from Castle Ford High School.
0:26:46 He enjoyed being involved in every sport that he could play there.
0:26:49 He graduated from high school in 2018
0:26:51 and then went on to serve in the United States Army National Guard
0:26:55 where he continues serving.
0:26:57 Michael is eager and ready to serve his community of Twin Falls
0:27:01 as a police officer.
0:27:05 Mayor Pierce, if I could have you come down
0:27:07 to administer the oath of office.
0:27:13 Yeah, I'm going to have you kind of stand this way face here.
0:27:18 As the mayor's coming down, there's going to be two
0:27:21 of these oaths that you will be signing.
0:27:23 So you have to sign it twice, right?
0:27:24 There's two.
0:27:25 And the reason we do two is because on your one-year
0:27:29 anniversary, we will present you a signed copy
0:27:32 of this oath of office as a reminder of the oath
0:27:35 that you were about to take this evening
0:27:37 and what this oath means as you move forward in your career.
0:27:40 I still have my oath of office hanging in my office and hope that when you get yours one
0:27:44 year from now, you will hang it somewhere prominently where you can review it from time to time, okay?
0:27:50 Madam Mayor?
0:28:40 So, gentlemen, as the mayor is signing this, I know you both have family here, and a moment
0:29:14 we'll be calling down some family members to pin your badge on, but Cesar, why don't you
0:29:20 introduce who's here in the audience with you?
0:30:46 And pinning the Recruit Officer Cervantes will be his father, Cesar Cervantes, senior.
0:31:31 Officer Rich will be his wife Victoria and his two children, Michael and Madeline.
0:31:37 Thank you very much. I'm going to have all of our officers employees come back up and
0:32:20 line up and then I would ask members of the council, city management team, as well as members
0:32:26 executive leadership team to come down and shake their hand and congratulate them.
0:32:30 Go for the bad knee.
0:33:32 Go for the bad knee.
0:33:35 Congratulations.
0:33:43 Congratulations.
0:33:51 It's always a pleasure, sir.
0:33:54 Congratulations.
0:33:55 Congratulations.
0:33:55 Congratulations.
0:33:56 You're going to win.
0:33:57 How many?
0:33:57 I'm in.
0:33:58 Thank you, sir.
0:33:59 You're okay.
0:34:01 All right.
0:34:03 All right.
0:34:04 Thank you, sir.
0:34:04 Thank you, sir.
0:34:05 Congratulations, Chief.
0:34:07 I appreciate it.
0:34:12 Glad you're here, man.
0:34:23 Thank you.
0:34:23 It's a great event.
0:34:24 I appreciate it.
0:34:25 It's a great event.
0:34:25 Congratulations, Chief.
0:34:26 You're welcome.
0:34:27 You guys are good.
0:34:34 Thank you.
0:34:36 Thank you, Chief.
0:34:47 and we'll take a minute break and allow the families of all the officers to leave if you want.
0:34:55 Well, while they're doing that, just to update the council, you met Hugo tonight,
0:35:03 just a couple of weeks ago, our newest member of our K-19, newest member of the department,
0:35:08 Mookie came home from Alabama, Officer Rivers went down there and trained for 14 weeks with him,
0:35:14 So you'll be meeting him later.
0:35:15 He'll be hitting, he's working patrol right now,
0:35:18 but he'll be getting certified over the next several months.
0:35:21 Thank you, Mayor.
0:35:22 Okay, thank you, Chief.
0:39:14 Next on item on the agenda is an action item.
0:39:17 Consider adopting the International Code Council ICC Building
0:39:23 Evaluation Data Table to standardize the process
0:39:26 of determining permit valuations
0:39:29 within the Building Safety Department.
0:39:31 We have Matt Long, our Building Official.
0:39:33 Welcome, Matt, Matthew.
0:39:37 Thank you, Madam Mayor, members of the Council.
0:39:40 Can you guys hear me?
0:39:41 Okay.
0:39:44 Yeah, so tonight, I'm gonna try to make this as quick as I can.
0:39:49 Basically, the proposal in front of you is to
0:39:53 the Building Valuation Table as published
0:39:56 by the International Co-CAMM.
0:39:59 I'd like you to know that the Building Advisory Group
0:40:02 reviewed this proposal on June 26th of this year,
0:40:06 and it received pretty strong backing
0:40:09 with the six to one vote that indicated right to come to council.
0:40:16 We recommend adopting the August version of these tables each year starting on October
0:40:23 1st.
0:40:24 This timing aligned with our processes despite the ICC's biennial updates, facilitating
0:40:30 smoother implementation.
0:40:32 So that all that means is every year this table would be adopted October 1st and we
0:40:40 would take up in your packet pull this up I'll get right to the table so if you
0:41:03 look at this table if you look at or three on the left-hand side talks about
0:41:08 residential one and two family will keep this simple today and to the right on
0:41:13 the upper it has type of construction 5B so if you follow the table over a
0:41:20 a standard house cost per square footage would be $167.37.
0:41:27 So what this means is we're just trying to even the playing field for
0:41:34 valuation as they come into the city.
0:41:38 The aim is to streamline the building valuation process using this formula where
0:41:43 we can compete the valuation based on square footage.
0:41:47 instead of guesstimation and some of the values we get are significantly low and some
0:41:53 of the valuations we get are high.
0:41:57 This proposal, this table reflects national averages or construction cost per square foot
0:42:05 and we're not including the regional cost modifiers that it talks about in the beginning
0:42:12 of this table.
0:42:13 Let me take you to another sheet here, and it gives you an estimate.
0:42:22 Well, this project value examples that's in your pocket.
0:42:34 The first page, there's six examples.
0:42:36 You can show a new square footage calculations that we've received in the last six months.
0:42:44 And as you can see, can you guys see red up there?
0:42:48 So there's red and blue.
0:42:50 The red shows that there would be an increase in the valuation, and the blue shows a decrease.
0:42:57 So out of six, four would increase, and two would decrease.
0:43:04 That would be residential.
0:43:07 What this does to the fees is it would directly affect the fees.
0:43:10 So the fees would either go up or go down based on the square footage.
0:43:14 But again, this creates a fair, even playing field for everybody coming in.
0:43:19 It would help us with our timelines as well with plan review and not have to go back and
0:43:25 forth with the people submitting arguing the square footages or the cost of the evaluation
0:43:31 of the project.
0:43:32 The commercial reviews, as you can see, we've got six and three would be high and three
0:43:43 would be low.
0:43:44 And what's interesting if you look at the schools, they're significantly low and that's
0:43:50 again based on the table that I showed you and it's type of construction and square footed
0:43:57 just is what the numbers would be based on. Does that make sense to you guys? I know there's
0:44:02 a lot of information to try to give you at one time.
0:44:05 So Matt, the declared value is what the customer comes in and says the value of this edition
0:44:13 is a million five. Yes, ma'am.
0:44:15 Okay, it's interesting there's like on the church edition,
0:44:23 there's a real discrepancy.
0:44:27 Is what would cause that?
0:44:30 I mean, obviously it's because they declared the value higher, but.
0:44:34 Well, see, we get the cost square footies.
0:44:36 I'll just use single family because it's the easiest to reference.
0:44:40 So we could get the cost per square footies.
0:44:42 Someone come in and say it's gonna cost me $69 a square foot to build my house.
0:44:47 Well, if you tell me at $69 on square feet,
0:44:49 I'm going to challenge that because in today's market, $69,
0:44:52 it's just not reasonable.
0:44:54 And then we base our fees off of that.
0:44:56 So you could have, the code doesn't really
0:44:58 differentiate if you've got for my cabinet versus slate.
0:45:03 We're just trying to set an even number.
0:45:06 And that $167.37 for single families
0:45:09 was a pretty even playing field.
0:45:11 It's actually low compared to what really happened.
0:45:16 But it's not like we're getting out
0:45:18 on our fees here or our evaluations so it's it's dependent on the honesty or what
0:45:26 the contractor or developer would ever submit and we got them to submit real low
0:45:30 and we got them to submit too high. It's both sides of the playing field it's not
0:45:35 just low we would lower fees on high ones and raise fees or evaluations on the
0:45:43 Well, and the residential includes garage and covered adios, so I would tend to bring
0:45:51 it down per square foot, right?
0:45:53 That's actually a really great question, and if you go to the first table I showed
0:45:58 you on the bottom of that table, there's a footnote that talks about private garages.
0:46:04 So yeah, you'd reduce the garage, it would go down to the bottom right, it would be
0:46:10 Yeah, it's significantly. It's about 100 colors in square foot, that's about the garage.
0:46:17 And then the patio, what do you do with the patio?
0:46:20 It'd be the same thing. Let me take you to a note real quick.
0:46:25 Hey, Madam Mayor, if I could just interject here real quick. Matt, can you pull back up that table?
0:46:30 Yes, sir.
0:46:32 So, with that table being up, I think it would benefit just so the council knows I'm the liaison for the building department.
0:46:40 There you go, good remember the exact term, to help everybody understand Matt, can you
0:46:49 leave that table up and then walk us through an example of the permitting fee?
0:46:55 The permitting fee itself.
0:46:57 Like on how you got to that value based upon the table?
0:47:03 I didn't really come equipped to do that but yeah, with the example on how you apply the
0:47:08 value to the square footage.
0:47:10 So you want me to break down just like a single family?
0:47:12 Yeah.
0:47:13 Just pick number one.
0:47:14 Yep.
0:47:15 Number one would be great.
0:47:16 And then walk how you associate example number one to the table, how it applies.
0:47:23 We walk through that during our advisory board meeting and I think it was really beneficial.
0:47:27 And I think it benefit the council to understand how everything applies based on the square
0:47:31 footage.
0:47:32 So if you could just apply the table to an example, I think that would behoove everybody
0:47:36 pretty well.
0:47:37 Okay.
0:47:38 So item number one, we're looking at 1,480 square feet of living areas, right?
0:47:44 You take the 1480 times the table and the table's at 167.37.
0:47:54 So you'd multiply 1480 times that number, it would come up with a number.
0:48:01 Then you go to 568 which is a garage and you'd do the same thing at 64.85.
0:48:08 And I believe on this example we did the same thing with the covered panel.
0:48:13 baddie also we did 208 square feet times 64.85 that is the total valuation. Now to get the
0:48:21 fees that Grayson's talking about you have to go to our master fee schedule and I'm not
0:48:26 adjusting any of the fee numbers and that's based on how much we're looking at. If you
0:48:35 go to the table and I didn't bring that here today to really discuss but I think I can
0:48:41 pull it up and make it happen. The tables in our schedule, the key schedule, our packet,
0:48:48 yeah. The next one. So can you guys see in the building site where it talks 22, you can
0:49:06 see the breakdown on the right. I can't even read it on the screen. Sorry. It's 22 hours
0:49:14 time. It's just based on the normal purpose. Yeah, so we're not changing any of the fees.
0:49:18 and is looking at the square foot each cost
0:49:19 and then applying the fees that we have.
0:49:22 Correct.
0:49:22 One of the things that I did do is we added the footnote.
0:49:25 If you look up there and says see building footnote number one,
0:49:28 that was one of the modifications we made to this table.
0:49:39 The other modification to this table was a footnote we added
0:49:46 or it says building valuation data
0:49:52 from the International Code Council Public's East August
0:49:55 will be adopted starting October 1st each year
0:49:58 for residential commercial projects.
0:50:01 for remodels and tenant improvement use IBC section 1093
0:50:07 for estimating permit values.
0:50:09 So what that means is you go back to the basic code
0:50:11 and we'd have to rely on the information
0:50:13 that they give us and see if it was fair and equitable.
0:50:17 Four remodels and tenants.
0:50:20 Tenant improvement.
0:50:22 Because they're not adding a new square footage.
0:50:24 Right.
0:50:27 It looks like you have some questions Matt.
0:50:29 So maybe start with Spencer.
0:50:33 Thank you, Mayor. Matt, thank you for your work,
0:50:36 because the building official appreciate what you do.
0:50:38 I've got some takeaways and conclusions I've drawn.
0:50:41 I just kind of want to summarize them.
0:50:42 You can tell me if I'm correct or not.
0:50:45 But we charge fees for permits, and we're not trying to make
0:50:50 money, we're just trying to cover our costs.
0:50:52 And we apportion those fees based on how big, complex,
0:50:58 or expensive projects are.
0:51:00 And what ends up happening is if somebody undervalues
0:51:03 their project and somebody else values their project correctly, the person that's done it correctly
0:51:09 is in effect subsidizing someone who's undervalued their project because we're just asking people
0:51:14 what's it worth and then we have no subjective way to judge them on that.
0:51:22 This just kind of sets it level for everybody.
0:51:25 There's no arguing.
0:51:26 It's just it is what it is.
0:51:28 in the long run our fees net us money or lose us money we've looked at adjusting
0:51:33 our fees that's not what we're doing right now we're just saying hey we need
0:51:37 to have a reasonable way to value these projects so if that's correct I'm totally
0:51:43 on board with this you are correct that's the intent of everything we're trying
0:51:51 to do I'm currently adopted under our master fees get if you look at the
0:51:57 evaluation, the definition, it talks about including profit. And if you get into the code,
0:52:04 our code really don't establish that you've got to tell us the profits that you're making.
0:52:08 And recently, one of my footnotes in here that I wanted to share with you is recently I had
0:52:15 someone pretty much tell me in a nice manner that it was none of my damn business, what
0:52:21 kind of profits they made on it. And you can't argue that point. I don't have a place to stand
0:52:27 on that, even though it's adopted by code, yet, and that's just not a good argument for me to be in.
0:52:35 So I think the intent of this is just to establish a fair playing field for everybody coming in.
0:52:41 The ones that are too low, we raise them, the ones that are too high, we can decrease them.
0:52:45 And that's some of the examples I showed you with the commercial and residential.
0:52:51 Sherry. So as your commission went through this and the staff went through all of these numbers,
0:52:58 How close are these numbers to our actual real local numbers?
0:53:04 Do these numbers tend to be conservative or do they, how do they fare?
0:53:09 They're pretty consistent with what we're charging now with the fees.
0:53:16 What you're saying is it costs the square footage equivalent if we break it down.
0:53:21 This would even the playing field.
0:53:24 We have some that are coming in and single families that are four or five hundred square foot.
0:53:28 that we got some, so like I say, where it comes in is just a balancing point.
0:53:33 Is that your question?
0:53:34 So I think what I'm asking is what you guys feel the actual real number is on price per
0:53:43 square foot.
0:53:45 Do you feel that that is, that these numbers represent what our local actual price per
0:53:51 square foot?
0:53:52 Absolutely.
0:53:53 I think they're probably more conservative.
0:53:55 they're lower than that. I'm in the process of doing someone on the site personally and the
0:54:02 Cosper Square Footage is significantly more than what we charge here. Thank you. Chris Reed.
0:54:12 In the advisory committee it was a six to one vote. Do you remember what the one vote? What
0:54:16 was the concern was with that one individual? I knew someone was going to ask that.
0:54:23 Yeah, the concern was the regional modifier and going in and that ties in with what Sherry
0:54:32 was saying.
0:54:34 The regional modifier is you should, we looked at it 90%, 88%, so you looked at it and you
0:54:41 reduce it and then you can tabulate it.
0:54:43 But the concern was we didn't clearly show that and it came up after the vote.
0:54:49 It wasn't during the vote.
0:54:51 you got any comment on that, you were in that meeting as well.
0:54:55 Yeah, Councilman Reed, to kind of piggyback off that, what Matt's talking about, is that
0:55:00 it's not for profit, and so he was worried that we would have an overage based upon the
0:55:05 permits that we were bringing in on the value and what we were doing with that excess balance
0:55:10 if I was correct.
0:55:11 But there are bigger projects that take more evaluation, and so it's in my regulation that,
0:55:19 And I talked to that individual afterwards after the meeting, and I think that was kind
0:55:26 of his biggest concern is what are we doing with that excess balance, but in reality,
0:55:29 we don't really have an excess balance off of those fees that we're trying to stay, you
0:55:36 know, the non-profit.
0:55:37 Yeah, in a nutshell, it's kind of hard to give you the best understanding I can on this table.
0:55:47 But when you get into the upper square footage or the upper cost per square footage,
0:55:53 I can assembly an A1 type 1A building.
0:55:57 That's $333 a square foot.
0:56:00 The reason why the numbers go up and why it's important
0:56:03 to a building department, building fire, mechanical plumbing,
0:56:06 and electrical is the firewalls increase.
0:56:09 You've got special inspections.
0:56:11 You've got structural concerns.
0:56:12 You've got soil parameters.
0:56:14 You've got different, maybe growate.
0:56:16 You've got CMU.
0:56:18 So the level of inspections increase
0:56:20 quite significantly do a larger process like that than like a typical single family.
0:56:26 I had to chime in there too on this table, Councilman Reed kind of your kind of question
0:56:30 again. When we look at this table and correct me if I'm wrong that but from left to right
0:56:34 we go from a more sophisticated building to a less sophisticated building based upon building
0:56:39 structure correct. Yeah five five would be you could build it pretty much out of anything
0:56:44 in the code type 1a is steel concrete non-combosable material.
0:56:49 So you've got higher occupancy, you've got it more hazardous,
0:56:54 the gabby assembly type uses,
0:56:59 assemblies, high right, well we don't have high rises here,
0:57:02 but like 160 main here, the lower two floors was all type 1a construction.
0:57:08 Hospitals, a lot of times end up being.
0:57:11 And then who makes the determination of that?
0:57:20 the type of construction that's regulated by the codes so it's based on how many square foot
0:57:26 you're building code only that you go so big with a certain type of construction and you can
0:57:31 sprinkle it and increase that type of construction or you change the type of construction.
0:57:34 That makes sense. It's pretty confusing. I hope I'm making sense to you guys up here. Oh yeah okay.
0:57:43 I was just going to make a comment so I'll make a comment. I'm in favor of this. I think
0:57:49 one of the things that is a council we've tried to do is take the human side out of the,
0:57:55 is this right, is this wrong, our opinion versus somebody else's opinion and the standardizes
0:58:01 it, which I appreciate. So somebody coming in with an opinion of this is how much this is going to
0:58:06 cause versus this, we're eliminating it. It's equal for all participants.
0:58:13 Thank you Chris Spencer. And as I'm thinking about this, it feels to me like
0:58:17 like if like we don't need a regional modifier,
0:58:21 just because everyone's judged the same,
0:58:24 whether they're slightly inflated or slightly undervalued,
0:58:28 it's the same for everybody.
0:58:30 We're apportioning the costs based on the type of project
0:58:32 we're actually doing, so it doesn't really matter.
0:58:35 But anyways, I support this, so thank you.
0:58:40 Mason.
0:58:41 Thank you, Madam Mayor.
0:58:42 How much time does your department
0:58:44 spend going back and forth with developers and builders
0:58:47 trying to have an energy negotiating the value of that property.
0:58:51 And where I'm going with this is because I'm also in support of this very much.
0:58:58 So in my head, I'm in full support of this in the sense that it allows your department
0:59:03 to say, all right, here's the square footage, here's your billing type.
0:59:07 Here's the valuation.
0:59:08 It's not every permit, but it's a significant number of permits that will come in and tell
0:59:13 me they can build something for a square footage.
0:59:16 It's just not realistic.
0:59:19 So then what happens is the plan's examiner asks,
0:59:22 we have to challenge it and say, give us a bid or that.
0:59:25 The site to this is when that happens,
0:59:28 when that takes place, the plan review timeline
0:59:30 to also increase, so it takes longer for a permit to get out.
0:59:33 And that's across the board.
0:59:35 So making this consistent also is going to reduce that.
0:59:39 Hopefully our plan review timelines will,
0:59:42 because we don't have to challenge that kind of stuff.
0:59:45 That answer your question, absolutely.
0:59:47 Thank you.
0:59:48 Thank you.
0:59:49 I think this makes some even playing field
0:59:54 and is consistent, and I don't see a problem with it at all.
0:59:58 So I would entertain a motion if somebody would like
1:00:00 to make that a letter.
1:00:03 I'll make a motion to adopt the International Code ICC
1:00:06 Building Valuation Data Table to standardize the process
1:00:08 of determining permit valuations
1:00:10 within the billing safety department.
1:00:12 Thank you, Jason Brown.
1:00:14 I'll second.
1:00:15 Thank you motion by Grayson Stone seconded by Jason Brown to adopt the International
1:00:22 Code Council ICC Building valuation data table to standardize the process for determining
1:00:28 permit valuations within the building safety department any further discussion Rachel
1:00:35 roll call vote please yes yes yes yes yes yes yes thank you motion passes 7 to
1:00:48 0 thank you Matt thank you very much okay next item on the agenda is an
1:00:55 action item consider a request to allocate 1.2 1 million two hundred eight
1:01:03 $8,000 of park impact fees to fund the Canyon Trail Junction Project and we have our Parks
1:01:10 and Rec Director Wendy Davis. Welcome Wendy.
1:01:12 Good evening, Mayor and Council. So this is the first of two requests this evening. The
1:01:18 first one is to make sure we have the money to do the project before we award a contract
1:01:26 to walk through the process.
1:01:27 So as I mentioned, we got an estimate for the total project.
1:01:37 And that, again, is just an estimate,
1:01:39 but that's the number we're using to ask for the money.
1:01:42 So back in, I think, 2019, Council allocated 600,000
1:01:48 in park impact fees for this project.
1:01:52 And obviously, over the years, we've come back and forth
1:01:55 for some money here and there and at this point all of that money is back in the
1:02:00 total so that 1.4 million that you're seeing is what is in the park impact fee
1:02:05 balance right now and that is certainly adequate to cover the 1.2
1:02:11 1,208 I see what your problem was.
1:02:17 1,208,000 to cover the estimated cost of the project and remember that part of
1:02:25 those dollars for the total fee are coming from Chobani. So we have the $500,000
1:02:31 donation from Chobani coupled with this 1.2 million and then obviously when we
1:02:36 sit down with them we'll work on that price and try to get it down a little bit.
1:02:40 So hopefully this is clear and there's no math to be done. Pretty clear. Anybody
1:02:49 have any questions for Wendy. Okay, I had to entertain a motion. Jerry? Jason
1:03:03 Brown? Hey, I got Jason said. Sherry can make it in all second, but I'll move to
1:03:09 approve the to allocate 1,208,000 in park impact fees to fund the Canyon Trail
1:03:17 Junction project. Thank you to have a second second. Thank you motion by Jason
1:03:22 Brown, seconded by Sherry Vomer, to approve the allocation of $1,208,000 in
1:03:29 park impact fees to fund the Canyon Trail Junction project. Any further
1:03:35 discussion? Rachel Roekal, please.
1:03:39 Yes, sir.
1:03:40 Cutler? Yes.
1:03:41 Sherry Vomer? Yes.
1:03:42 Grayson Stone? Yes.
1:03:43 Jason Brown? Yes.
1:03:44 Great Hawkins? Yes.
1:03:45 Chris Reed? Yes.
1:03:46 Yes. Yes. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes seven to zero. Okay. The next item is also an action item a request to accept the CMCG contract for the county
1:04:00 and trail junction project with Wright brothers and authorize the mayor to sign. Wendy Davis again. Thank you. And thank goodness you guys approved that because I don't know what we would have done now.
1:04:16 So back in September, we went back and negotiated
1:04:22 with Wright Brothers after Council gave us
1:04:25 authorization to move forward.
1:04:27 As the code describes this process,
1:04:33 we need to make a selection based on qualifications
1:04:36 and then we can negotiate a price.
1:04:38 And code also allows for a CMGC contract
1:04:41 which is described in that second part of code
1:04:44 which is basically just saying you can do this
1:04:47 And you have to do it based on qualifications.
1:04:49 So we believe that Wright brothers as well qualified.
1:04:52 We were pleased with the numbers we came up with
1:04:55 in our negotiation.
1:04:57 The total is $63,600 in their administrative costs
1:05:02 and then 8.5% of the guaranteed maximum price
1:05:07 which would be our next step.
1:05:08 So if you are comfortable with the contract
1:05:12 and that's moving forward with Wright brothers,
1:05:14 then we'll sit down with them
1:05:15 and work through and bring a guaranteed maximum price back
1:05:20 for you to accept that.
1:05:22 I do have Zack Carter, who is the project manager
1:05:25 with Wright Brothers here.
1:05:27 If you have any questions or would like to talk to him.
1:05:33 Any questions for Wendy or contractor?
1:05:40 Doesn't look like it.
1:05:45 I would entertain a motion.
1:05:48 Thank you, Jason.
1:05:50 I'd move to accept a CMGC contract
1:05:54 for the Canyon Trail Junction project
1:05:56 with Wright Brothers and authorized the mayor
1:05:58 to sign the contract.
1:05:59 Thank you, do I have a second?
1:06:01 Okay.
1:06:02 Thank you, motion by Jason Brown, second by Craig Hawkins.
1:06:06 To accept the CMGC contract for the Canyon Trail Junction,
1:06:11 project with Wright Brothers and authorized the mayor
1:06:14 to sign any further discussion?
1:06:17 Well, I'm gonna make all right, I do have a question.
1:06:20 Constructed a councilman color. Is that eight and a half pretty reasonable? I've been out of the construction game for a while
1:06:26 But it seems pretty fair to me. Yeah in this market. That's um, well, you're relevant to the market. It's a very average
1:06:35 That was my only question. Thank you, Madam Mayor
1:06:38 Anybody else? Rachel Rolkow, please
1:06:44 Ruth Pierce. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, Jason Brown. Yes, Mr. Cutler. Yes, Gary Fulmer. Yes
1:06:52 Yes.
1:06:53 Thank you.
1:06:54 Motion passes 7-0.
1:06:55 Thank you, Wendy.
1:06:56 Do you want?
1:06:57 Yes.
1:06:58 You could bring it up.
1:07:00 Okay.
1:07:20 So that is all for the regular agenda items.
1:07:29 Even though it's not in the agenda, I'm going to go ahead.
1:07:35 The next item on the agenda is public input.
1:07:38 There's anybody here from the public that wishes to address city council?
1:07:43 You have your an opportunity come down to the podium and address us
1:07:53 See no one advisory board reports anybody have anything for yes, mary
1:07:59 Quick update historic preservation Commission. They haven't had a lot of
1:08:04 Request lately they did meet today and has some training
1:08:08 but the
1:08:09 Council's or the Commission's still intact and they're attending and seem enthusiastic. So it's good news
1:08:14 Great, thank you. Anybody else have anything? Anything from the City Manager's office? Yes.
1:08:22 Well, we hope everyone had a great Thanksgiving holiday and then this coming Friday as our light parade.
1:08:29 We just wanted to remind everybody that Main Street will close down for parking around three-ish in the afternoon
1:08:35 and the parade starts at six capping off with the three lighting. So I hope everybody comes.
1:08:41 That was a good time. Perfect. Anything else?
1:08:45 Okay, so next is the public hearing and it's an action item.
1:08:54 It's a request to approve the program year 2023 consolidated annual performance and evaluations
1:09:01 report, EY23 caper, and we have Jonathan's been love or planning and zoning director.
1:09:09 Welcome Jonathan.
1:09:12 This is not a regular land use item so you don't have to read that whole public hearing.
1:09:16 This is the 2023 report that we upload to the federal government for the CDBG program.
1:09:23 The report is all closed in the staff report.
1:09:27 We've got the actual report that gets printed out.
1:09:30 The federal government has a lot of language in there.
1:09:32 So if you have questions on their language, I'll try, but I don't know all of the CFR part 20,
1:09:38 next chapter, etc, etc language.
1:09:40 I'll do my best.
1:09:41 I'll do my best. Anything else that we've written it can certainly answer or I can have Kelly help me answer it out
1:09:46 She's the one that puts the report together
1:09:49 This year we spent around
1:09:52 $4,500 with some staff time the bulk of the money and we've been budgeted for 24 to do the park restroom and we are
1:10:00 Now as most things with the federal government takes years to get to we are going to be ready to bid that project in December
1:10:08 Now we have Loth and Rick's architecture on board with an addendum contract and they are going to be bidding it
1:10:14 Hopefully December or the January for construction in spring and summer that will encompass the bathroom portion as well as
1:10:22 Some ancillary things in the park and some concrete as all some electrical panel work
1:10:28 From that we will now we'll then know the amount to do what would be left for the sidewalk in the plaza and that will then
1:10:35 influence how much we do for those two other projects. Other than that we do this
1:10:41 every year around this time and it is up to the council to essentially approve the
1:10:46 consolidated annual performance evaluation report and we will upload that to the
1:10:52 federal program. Okay so Chris Reed I'm ready to make the motion. I think we
1:11:00 have to. I'll look here. Yeah even though I didn't read the rules so I'll open up
1:11:06 the public hearing if there's anybody in the audience that wishes to comment on
1:11:11 the caper you're more than welcome to going once okay I will close the public
1:11:26 hearing so are you ready Chris yes to approve the program year 2023
1:11:34 consolidated annual performance and evaluation report the program year 23
1:11:40 Thank you, Grace and Stone.
1:11:42 Thank you, Madam Mayor.
1:11:43 I will second.
1:11:44 Thank you.
1:11:45 Motion by Chris Reed.
1:11:46 Second by Grace and Stone to approve the program year 2023 consolidated annual performance and evaluations report.
1:11:55 Any further discussion?
1:11:57 Rachel Rolkow, please.
1:11:59 Yes.
1:12:00 Yes.
1:12:01 Yes.
1:12:02 Yes.
1:12:03 Yes.
1:12:04 Yes.
1:12:05 Yes.
1:12:06 Yes.
1:12:07 Yes.
1:12:08 Thank you, motion passes 7 to 0.
1:12:10 Thank you, Jonathan.
1:12:12 So there is nothing else on the agenda,
1:12:14 so our meeting is adjourned.
1:12:16 Thank you, everyone.
1:12:19 Thanks for hanging in there, everybody.
1:12:22 .
1:12:27 .
1:12:30 .
1:12:33 .
1:12:36 .
1:12:39 .
1:12:42 .
1:12:45 .
1:12:48 .
Download
- Transcript (text) 54 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 71 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 98 KB
- Audio (M4A) 17.1 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, December 2, 2024. The recording started at 16:58 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:12:22.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
72bc91ec73ba373089c5afc7933542179a9f2676e059ae13b4e4ec44e8b3e1d2 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a d62101dc514911d8b1ddc3168ffa1b5af587789165c4f496205cab25d6e47568 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-11. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
35c18d4e6ce9a16135d21cdba0f62c84cc69deec8359ef529017755b74cb5ddb
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file