OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, July 14, 2025

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on fileMinutes on file

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

The audio for this recording isn't posted yet. It's being held back until a privacy review is finished. The transcript below is complete apart from marked passages.

Transcript

0:03:46 Good evening ladies and gentlemen welcome to the July 14, 2025 City Council meeting. I want to confirm

0:03:53 We have a quorum. We have all seven members present in chambers

0:03:58 First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance if you wish to join me, please write. Thank you

0:04:22 We have no proclamations tonight. So next is the consent calendar

0:04:28 Council wishes

0:04:30 Mayor I like to approve this consent calendar is written.

0:04:34 Thank you.

0:04:35 Do I have a second?

0:04:36 Madam Mayor I'll second.

0:04:37 Thank you motion by Craig Hawkins seconded by Grayson Stone to approve the consent calendar

0:04:42 as written.

0:04:43 Amy Rolkavoe please.

0:04:46 Ruth Pierce?

0:04:51 Yes.

0:04:52 Chris Reed?

0:04:53 Yes.

0:04:54 Craig Hawkins?

0:04:55 Yes.

0:04:56 Jason Brown?

0:04:57 Yes.

0:04:58 Spencer Cutler?

0:04:59 Yes.

0:05:00 Grayson Stone?

0:05:01 Yes.

0:05:02 And Sherri Bomer.

0:05:03 Yes.

0:05:04 Now under items of consideration, the first item is an action item, a request to reject all bids

0:05:10 and negotiate on the open market for the sale of the former fire station number three located at 929

0:05:18 Washington Street South and we have Mitch Humble, our deputy city manager, welcome Mitch.

0:05:23 Thank you. As you know, we've been going through this process to get rid of our old fire station number

0:05:29 three and old and in the report I said former old right so we went through the

0:05:38 bidding process we opened up our bids this is a reminder on this property there's a

0:05:42 cell tower that we have a lease with an antenna provider I won't say it's 18t

0:05:49 that lease goes through September of 27 so we have to deal with that lease and so

0:05:54 what we decided to do was we put the station on the market for this bidding

0:05:59 process and we were going to retain ownership of the tower so we can deal

0:06:03 with the sleest issue. Bidding came and went. You had two bids that came in. Both bids

0:06:10 required the removal of the tower. One immediately and then one delayed

0:06:15 removal. And so we reviewed these bids with the city attorney. We decided that

0:06:22 either one of the bids was really responsive to how we posted it.

0:06:26 And so the recommendation that is to reject the bids.

0:06:32 Now what that does for us is it means

0:06:34 that we've satisfied our state-required process

0:06:37 to dispose without a successful conclusion.

0:06:41 And so at this point, we can do whatever we decide

0:06:44 is appropriate.

0:06:45 When I say we, the statute says whatever the council determines

0:06:48 is appropriate to get rid of the property,

0:06:50 at this point, we can do.

0:06:51 And so we have options ahead of us.

0:06:53 I think this is not necessarily a bad thing

0:06:55 that we didn't get in bids or response to bids,

0:06:57 I should say.

0:06:59 There was interest in the property

0:07:01 and the bids that we got indicate that.

0:07:03 In fact, we had a bid that was almost $150,000

0:07:07 over a minimum asking price.

0:07:10 So I think what we need to do is an action item,

0:07:15 reject the bids and then direct staff to work,

0:07:17 sell this on the open market.

0:07:19 That's the official stuff.

0:07:21 It would be nice to maybe have some conversation

0:07:23 about how you want to handle this.

0:07:25 We can go hire a realtor.

0:07:26 We can just work directly with this high bidder.

0:07:29 We will need to work with the leaseholder on the antenna.

0:07:32 If we're going to try to do anything that involves

0:07:35 removing the tower, we need to try to relocate those guys

0:07:38 to another location.

0:07:39 We have some locations nearby.

0:07:42 And we can certainly do that.

0:07:43 So, and I believe they'll be willing to relocate

0:07:48 because they want to not have to take this

0:07:50 down in the area. So anyway, sorry that I'll out there and see what y'all want to do.

0:07:56 Thank you mayor. You know staff report mentions negotiating with the highest

0:08:01 bidder. I do think we need to make a sincere good

0:08:03 faith effort to do that but otherwise I support this request. Thank you Chris

0:08:11 Sweet. You mentioned relocating that tower. What is the cost of something like

0:08:16 that. So relocating is probably not the best term for that. The antenna holder, we own the tower,

0:08:24 right? So we're not going to move the tower, right? But we could do a new lease with the

0:08:29 with the antenna provider at another location where they could, it would be a ground lease,

0:08:33 though, in that scenario. Right now we have the tower lease. They put antennas on our tower.

0:08:39 We would do a ground lease. We'll give you this, you know, piece of dirt over here. You can build

0:08:44 the tower on it and so they would just build a new one. I don't know what the cost of a new

0:08:49 construction of a antenna like that would be. But we have space in the neighborhood where we can

0:08:58 do that. And if you're looking to install a new monopole style antenna doing it on setter property

0:09:06 in our code is like the way to do it. And so it would be they obviously would see the value

0:09:12 to that, the lease value to us would be more of a market rate. The current lease that we have

0:09:21 at our current location is not a market rate lease. It was, I want to say 2003-ish timeline.

0:09:28 And what we needed cellular, or not cellular, but we needed radio equipment. We needed

0:09:33 on towers. And so we worked with a bunch of people to build towers for us that we've been

0:09:40 put our antennas on and then in exchange for building the tower to get my

0:09:44 great each rate to also use the tower. So we're getting like peanuts for these for

0:09:49 these leases and they're all coming to you in the next couple years so this is a

0:09:52 good time for us in terms of cell tower leasing. But I think we can get a good

0:09:56 market rate lease on some land within a thousand feet of this location so it

0:10:03 would be a probably a good deal for us to do that and it would be a good deal for

0:10:07 the intent of provider is they'll be able to get it from us a lot quicker and easier

0:10:11 than they will anybody else. But I don't know the cost of it a little bit

0:10:15 of a tower. That makes sense. Thank you.

0:10:18 Grayson. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Did we get a quote on relocating the tower,

0:10:25 providing chance? So again, that's kind of what we were just talking about,

0:10:29 building a new tower. We're not going to relocate the tower. So if we do-

0:10:33 But it has to be a new bill. So we, and they would want it anyway, right?

0:10:38 The tower of the antenna that's there is the city-owned antenna.

0:10:42 So we own, I'm sorry, the city-owned tower with 18T antennas on it.

0:10:48 It had conversations with 18T and they won't move the tower.

0:10:52 They'll just abandon it and put up a new one.

0:10:54 And it would be their tower that they would construct.

0:10:57 So that wouldn't have anything to do with us.

0:10:59 We would just charge the lease for the use of the ground.

0:11:02 And then we essentially have to absorb the cost of then demoing the tower.

0:11:06 tower or sell that burden to whoever's going to buy the property when they demo the building

0:11:11 there.

0:11:12 Scott.

0:11:13 Thank you.

0:11:14 Jason.

0:11:15 Mitch, we don't need the radios anymore or we don't have anything on this tower anymore.

0:11:21 I'd echo what Spencer or Councilman Keller said.

0:11:25 I think we need to make a good faith effort of trying to work with the bidders there,

0:11:32 I would probably be more in favor of looking at a different location and doing that land

0:11:38 lease or that new cell tower out of this location.

0:11:42 It would be better long term for whatever this property ends up.

0:11:48 If we do that, it will be at least a couple of more actions by the council that will be

0:11:54 public meeting kind of actions.

0:11:55 Obviously, we can't make a decision tonight, but just know that one of those actions would

0:12:00 be a council determination that the use is appropriate on the city on property and

0:12:05 then the second action be approval of a new lease with the new provider. So all

0:12:10 you're asking tonight is to reject all bids and negotiate on the open market.

0:12:15 Okay again the feedback that I'm getting is great. Okay, Grayson. Thank

0:12:21 you Madam Mayor. So given my I guess credentials as a commercial broker I

0:12:26 I have a bit of an issue with rejecting all the bids,

0:12:30 especially over 600,000, knowing full well

0:12:33 that that bill is probably gonna need to get demoed

0:12:36 all the way through.

0:12:37 And so if we take it out to market,

0:12:40 there's gonna be significant amount of improvements

0:12:43 that needs to be done to the property.

0:12:45 And so I don't know if it's worth going to the open market

0:12:49 versus going through the auction process,

0:12:51 because you may not actually get what we have right now.

0:12:55 bird in the basket's worth one in the hand or whatever that stupid phrase is but

0:13:02 I'm hard-pressed not to engage in that high-bid mark at the 640,000 because we're going to have

0:13:08 to graze the building. That's what we're seeing. Correct. So I'll probably be voting

0:13:14 now on this one. So the other option we could do is go through the process to

0:13:20 relocate the antenna lease to another location and then we do the auction process with the

0:13:32 significant change being that we will no longer keep the tower on the property. So the lease

0:13:38 or the bids that we got were not responsive to the conditions that we posted for. And so

0:13:47 condition and do another bid process if we wanted to. That's something the council would

0:13:53 write to do. We would just change the conditions on the bid so that we're just going to sell the

0:13:58 property as is we're not going to keep the tower but we have to do something about that

0:14:02 lease first. It would delay the auction process over long. It takes for us to work through a

0:14:10 moving of the antennas.

0:14:15 I'll make a motion but I was going to address that question in the sense of we're rejecting

0:14:23 the bids because we believe they were non-responsive according to the guidelines that we gave in

0:14:28 the bid.

0:14:29 Not the fact that maybe we were not happy with the price or something like that.

0:14:33 It was the fact that they didn't follow the bidders did not follow the steps prescribed.

0:14:37 Yeah, on the contrary, we're absolutely happy with the bidding dollar amount.

0:14:41 what we did was we said we're selling the property we're keeping the tower and they

0:14:46 said nope we want to buy everything yeah so I'll go ahead and make a motion if

0:14:50 we're ready I would move that we reject all bids and negotiate on the open market

0:14:54 for the sale of the former fire station number three located at 929

0:14:59 Washington Street south thank you do I have a second I'll second thank you motion

0:15:07 by Jason Brown second by Chris Reed to reject all bits and no

0:15:12 go shade on the open marker for the sale of former fire station

0:15:15 number three located at 929 Washington Street South. Any further

0:15:20 discussion? Amy Roll call vote please. Chris Reed. Yes. Great

0:15:27 Hawkins. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.

0:15:31 Grayson Stone. No. No. No. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Thank you motion

0:15:37 passes five to two. Next on the agenda on time. A presentation of the city

0:15:51 managers recommended budget for fiscal year 2526 and followed by citizen input

0:15:57 and we have our deputy city manager Gretchen Scott. Welcome Gretchen. Thank

0:16:02 you and good evening. We're excited to be here tonight. We have a very

0:16:07 informative presentation ready and put together for you and we're excited to be

0:16:11 able to give it to you. So this is our second night of budget presentations. We'll

0:16:16 be giving an overview of the proposed fiscal year 26 budget, a presentation on

0:16:21 three of eight of the focus areas of the strategic plan, as well as we'll discuss a

0:16:27 list of unfunded projects for you to consider as part of Council directed capital.

0:16:33 So, these are the relative code sections that grant the authorities and responsibilities

0:16:39 for municipal budgeting, and I am going to be going a little bit quick because the best

0:16:46 stuff is after me.

0:16:50 This is some of our statistical information that highlights the complex work of an organization

0:16:54 that's funded by a resident population of roughly 56,000 people to provide services to

0:17:00 well over 100,000 people on a daily basis.

0:17:03 Our community continues to grow in value each year, as is really obvious by the median

0:17:10 home value that's increasing.

0:17:12 And our low unemployment rate would indicate a fully employed workforce.

0:17:22 Using January home values from year to year, the city has projected that an average valued

0:17:28 home that pays for an average amount of water, sewer, and garbage services will see an increase

0:17:35 of 13 cents per 1,000 of home value,

0:17:40 or the city services that are delivered to them daily.

0:17:43 And then additionally based on the rate increases

0:17:46 that are proposed, an average user would see a monthly amount

0:17:51 of $2.12 of an increase in the utility bills.

0:17:56 So those two amounts total, $9.05 per month

0:18:01 on the average home and the average user.

0:18:03 annually that equates to about $108.60 per year.

0:18:09 We don't actually have an example of an average home,

0:18:13 but this is how we calculate in order to demonstrate

0:18:16 what the impact is to our taxpayers.

0:18:21 Each year, as we develop our budget,

0:18:24 the city keeps these six primary objectives in mind.

0:18:27 These are the guiding principles in order to ensure

0:18:30 that our budget meets the needs of the community

0:18:34 and is barely built in order to ensure ratepayers don't see large increases or unstable increases.

0:18:44 So, this is an overview of the taxable value of the community of Twin Falls.

0:18:52 The value is set by the assessor's office.

0:18:54 We don't have any control over that.

0:18:57 And then you can see that the net expenses of the budget is included there.

0:19:01 The allowed rate increases that are included in the fiscal year 26 budget are down below

0:19:06 where it says property tax revenues

0:19:08 and the utility rate increases that we'll be experiencing.

0:19:16 This is a graph demonstrating the taxable value

0:19:19 of the community.

0:19:20 This is all properties.

0:19:22 You'll see that each year is a pretty measured

0:19:25 and stable increase in growth.

0:19:27 The one large growth year that occurred between 22 and 23

0:19:31 was the expiration of the revenue allocation area

0:19:34 and that included a large property value

0:19:36 that came into the system.

0:19:38 What this shows is that we're growing at a reasonable rate.

0:19:41 We don't have big jumps.

0:19:42 We're pretty consistent, sustained,

0:19:45 and it's pretty measured in what we can expect year to year.

0:19:53 So in addition, you can also see that our tax rate

0:19:57 that we charge the citizen for the services

0:19:59 that they receive is also one of the lowest

0:20:01 that the city has issued in the years.

0:20:04 And in comparison to other cities,

0:20:08 you can see the value in the green bar

0:20:10 for what a citizen in Twin Falls pays for similar services

0:20:14 across other cities in the state of Idaho.

0:20:19 You can see that the citizens in Twin Falls are paying less

0:20:22 for the same services in most comparable communities.

0:20:30 These next two slides then demonstrate where the budget

0:20:33 that we're proposing is spent

0:20:35 and what it looks like is a broad overview.

0:20:40 So this is the full budget for the city

0:20:43 and what these expenditures by fund type looks like.

0:20:47 Governmental funds include things like police, fire,

0:20:51 administration and planning and zoning,

0:20:53 and enterprise funds such as water and sewer.

0:20:57 These departments have to balance their expenses

0:20:59 against the fees that they charge for the services

0:21:01 that are provided.

0:21:02 So these are the kind of main categories

0:21:04 in which the expenditures by fund type are made.

0:21:09 And then you can see where by overall

0:21:12 for the entire budget, how those funds are spent.

0:21:17 We are a service organization.

0:21:19 Our employees provide the services

0:21:21 that the residents and the taxpayers receive.

0:21:24 The largest expense across all funds,

0:21:26 both enterprise and general, are personnel-related costs

0:21:29 at 42.8%.

0:21:31 The second largest is capital.

0:21:34 That's the investment that we make

0:21:36 in the infrastructure and equipment needed

0:21:38 to provide the services delivered.

0:21:41 The last largest piece is M&O, maintenance and operations.

0:21:45 And that's things like electricity, gas, and personal training

0:21:51 and supplies that are needed to perform the jobs.

0:21:57 As an organization, we strive to provide all of our service

0:22:00 in a manner that advances the strategic plan.

0:22:04 The strategic plan is divided into seven focus areas

0:22:10 that go through the eighth focus area

0:22:12 of internal organization.

0:22:15 Tonight, we're going to be reporting out

0:22:17 on number one, healthy community,

0:22:21 number seven, responsible community,

0:22:24 and the internal organization.

0:22:27 So to kick off with the healthy community,

0:22:30 I'm inviting Wendy Davis to come forward.

0:22:34 Thank you, Gretchen.

0:22:41 Good evening, Mayor and Council.

0:22:43 It's our pleasure to be here this evening.

0:22:45 I have with me, Nabarto Orozco and Dustin Peterson,

0:22:48 who served on the long-term planning committee

0:22:51 for the Parks and Recreation Department.

0:22:54 We'll be sharing parts of this presentation.

0:22:58 Before we get started on the capital conversation

0:23:02 and some of our requests,

0:23:04 I wanted to just give you a little update

0:23:06 on some of the projects that we are currently working on

0:23:09 that have been funded in ways outside of capital.

0:23:12 So the Vista Benito Project has a $2 million allocation

0:23:17 through the state and local fiscal recovery funds.

0:23:20 That one has gone through the CMGC process.

0:23:24 We've awarded a contract and are now beginning work

0:23:28 with the design team to create the concept

0:23:31 that we can put construction documents together from.

0:23:35 And our hope is that we can get that done

0:23:39 and get that project out to bid this winter

0:23:41 so that we can get construction early spring next year.

0:23:45 the Canyon Trail Junction project is a $1.7 million project with $500,000 of donated friends

0:23:53 from Chobani and 1.2 from park impact fees. That project has gone out to bid. The bids have

0:24:01 been awarded and we were in the process of finalizing the documents and then getting a

0:24:09 construction start date, so we can do,

0:24:13 I'd like to do a groundbreaking ceremony with Chobani

0:24:16 and get that project kicked off

0:24:18 with the intention of getting that done this fall still.

0:24:22 The City Park restroom isn't fully our project,

0:24:25 we're doing that as a joint effort

0:24:27 with planning and zoning

0:24:30 with community block development grant funds,

0:24:32 that is running very smoothly.

0:24:35 If you have noticed, it's got walls up now,

0:24:38 starting to look like a building. It has had some impact to use of the park by some of the

0:24:43 events, but not major and that one's coming along well. The Frontier Restroom Project through

0:24:50 a generous donation from the Rotary Club has hit some road bumps. It's not, it's a little

0:24:57 behind schedule. We're really hoping to get that completed here soon and looking forward

0:25:02 to getting that restroom open. There's some impacts of not having any water on for a really

0:25:08 long time out there, but we sure appreciate that project and their partnership on that one

0:25:13 as well.

0:25:14 And then the last one is the City Pool of Innovation project, which is 2.1 million, and

0:25:20 I believe it was cash reserves, I put that in there with the intent to clarify that, and

0:25:24 I may have made a mistake anyway.

0:25:28 That is intended to go, I think it's to start the project in August, so we hope to begin

0:25:36 the work and have that done by next summer.

0:25:40 So the next thing, we have a little video that we've made

0:25:45 to kind of introduce the team and some of our projects.

0:25:50 So as you're enjoying the video, make sure you look for some

0:25:54 of the things that we've completed this last year,

0:25:58 kind of what we do, and then the Bartle and Dustin will share

0:26:02 some of the actual projects that we're talking about this year.

0:26:06 Good evening, all of us. My name is Embaario Park Supervisor, so we have noticed in this

0:28:22 video, thanks to the allocated funds from Capital Request from my last year, we were able to

0:28:28 complete so much needed to perish to some of our playgrounds.

0:28:33 You're about that?

0:28:37 It's okay.

0:28:38 I shouldn't be touching a computer. I was a part of the plan, but it completes how much

0:28:45 need to be perished for our playgrounds, including if you noticed at Thompson Park we got a brand

0:28:49 new playground. The community has been very excited. I don't know if you notice

0:28:54 or not, but that was the park scene that was climbing around that playground and

0:28:58 we did have one of our guys that was terrified once he had up there, but he

0:29:02 survived. Also we were able to complete the walking path out at Thompson Park,

0:29:07 which was very exciting, including also we were able to complete some of the

0:29:12 fencing replacement, the chain link mesh, primarily out at Oregon Trail, all four

0:29:19 fields in fields we were able to replace so that's exciting. We got new

0:29:24 fencing there also we had plenty of money to complete the outfield fencing for

0:29:28 fields 1 and 2 at frontier. So one of the requests for this year for capital is

0:29:34 this piece of machinery. Maybe some of you saw the ABI force on the request of

0:29:38 what it was. I was hoping for a jet to be part of Space Force but that didn't

0:29:43 happen so we'll settle for this piece of equipment. So it specializes in field

0:29:49 for Fields. So this not only will help us to prep our Fields before any events or games,

0:29:57 but more importantly if you notice that picture on the top left that's what we're

0:30:02 currently using which is working great. But what ABI does, it allows us to purchase

0:30:08 any more attachments, so we'll have an all-in-one best piece of equipment. What

0:30:14 What we're really excited about is the ability to laser level our fields.

0:30:19 So we're very interested in providing safe fields and also aesthetically pleasing but

0:30:25 we understand the importance of laser leveling our fields.

0:30:28 Last year, just out of curiosity, I requested a vote of how much would cost a laser level

0:30:34 of field and I think that vote came back to around $45,000 to $5,000 a field.

0:30:40 So it's not an expensive to say the least.

0:30:43 So we're very excited for the opportunity

0:30:46 to purchase this piece of the appointment.

0:30:48 Again, just to provide a much more safe ball fields

0:30:53 for not only those that come and play,

0:30:57 and visit Twin Falls to enjoy our fields,

0:30:59 but more importantly for our residents.

0:31:02 So that's what this piece of equipment will do for us.

0:31:08 Thank you.

0:31:12 So with recreation, we have a couple of items that we're bringing up to kind of clarify

0:31:17 and everything.

0:31:18 The first one is going to be the tiny mobile robot.

0:31:21 This is basically a robot that's controlled by a tablet, GPSed, as you see on the screen,

0:31:29 you can arrange your fields to however you like, and press go, and it paints the fields

0:31:35 out for you.

0:31:37 This will help with all the fields we paint out of the Sunway.

0:31:43 Bring and fall we paint between six to eight fields and two days span.

0:31:52 This will take that two days down to about four hours with one person instead of using

0:31:57 one person and a bunch of seasonal staff.

0:32:02 We'll be able to use it for our baseball fields.

0:32:06 We do some flag football fields and all our soccer fields.

0:32:14 Premium blue machine.

0:32:16 We might end up putting googly eyes on it though.

0:32:20 Next one is just a continuation of our field maintenance, ability maintenance, basically

0:32:25 our chain link fences around all our complexes can either work on the dugouts.

0:32:32 Okay.

0:32:36 and this is everything that is on our capital request for

0:32:41 ARCs, REC, Turkey's, and the pool, I like some of the ones you may have questions about.

0:32:50 As I did last year, I kind of wanted to put a couple things on your radar again.

0:33:02 These are some of the things that are incoming and for lack of a better name

0:33:10 for this park, I'm really following the old tradition of naming it by something

0:33:15 that's adjacent. So it's being referred to right now as Elizabeth Park and that's the

0:33:20 four acres that we purchased recently with our impact fees as part of the

0:33:27 switch from parks in lieu to using park impact fees to by land. And this is on the

0:33:32 corner of Hankins and Elizabeth. And that park will need to have grass and

0:33:40 sprinklers in within a year of purchasing that land. We're about to make

0:33:44 that purchase, so we're going to have to make some improvements out there. It's got

0:33:49 some challenges with compaction, but we believe that we kind of have a plan on

0:33:53 what to do so that we can try to grow some grass out there and make that happen, but

0:33:58 just need you to be aware that that one's coming. I would be remiss if I did not

0:34:03 mention the recreation center. The, as you recall, we had a conversation. We'll be

0:34:10 back with some property to discuss and kind of create a plan moving forward, hopefully

0:34:16 at least completing the feasibility study and figure out what to do from there.

0:34:21 Additionally, we had started a presentation, we're working this summer with some of the

0:34:29 user groups, but our intent is to come back and have a conversation with you about changing

0:34:34 some of our facility use fees to better recoup our costs in maintaining, especially when we're

0:34:41 talking about outside user groups that come in and use our facilities that we do some of

0:34:46 the maintenance for, and we're not recovering our costs on that. Additionally, the Public

0:34:52 Art Commission made a request to, they've made some recommendations and we've gone through

0:34:59 a couple of different processes, but in the budget, our fee allocation by code is 0.05%

0:35:10 and 0.05% of the general fund capital.

0:35:18 So it comes out, is it 0.05 or 0.1, 0.01, 0.05.

0:35:25 So we should, it equates to about $2,500.

0:35:30 And as you recall, they did some projects this year.

0:35:33 That's not going to last very long.

0:35:34 So they would like to raise that increment of funding.

0:35:37 So we'll be back at some point to talk about the ordinance and what that, what we would

0:35:43 like to see that look like.

0:35:45 But in the meantime, we doubled the funding for public art this year from 2,500 to 5,000.

0:35:52 So that was an increase that's beyond what code calls for.

0:35:57 And then just the last thing, obviously, and I think human resources is going to spend some

0:36:01 time talking about staff too, but we had put together a presentation a while ago that kind

0:36:08 of demonstrates how the city of Twin Falls, especially when it relates to parks, where we

0:36:15 are staff-wise compared to the national averages of communities our size.

0:36:21 And you know, you can go through that, but basically at the end, we're down about 13 full-time employees

0:36:27 based on what the rest of the, you know, kind of what the standard looks like.

0:36:34 So with that, do you have any questions about any of our requests or any of the things we've

0:36:41 presented so far?

0:36:44 Any questions for Grayson?

0:36:46 Thank you, Madam Mayor.

0:36:47 I have two questions.

0:36:48 So one was on the New Holland baseball park grader.

0:36:53 How old was that piece of machinery?

0:36:56 Oh, the blue one.

0:36:57 The new hall in TCA 18.

0:37:00 Looks like it's pretty antiquated.

0:37:03 The 2011.

0:37:04 It looks like it's been pretty hard.

0:37:07 Oh, yeah.

0:37:08 And then manicured acres.

0:37:10 What does that mean?

0:37:12 You went back and forth.

0:37:13 OK, so we'd hope to slow those down a little bit.

0:37:16 And I apologize.

0:37:17 They went quite pretty fast.

0:37:18 But manicured acres are the very, very Harman Park.

0:37:24 It's the land that we have grass and sprinklers.

0:37:29 And the reason it's important is because obviously

0:37:32 we have a lot of unmanicured acres.

0:37:36 Probably three times as many when you start talking

0:37:38 about agar falls and some of the areas down

0:37:41 around social falls and derkies.

0:37:43 So we have about 1200 of unmanicured.

0:37:46 Sure, I just wanted to make sure I was thinking about it,

0:37:49 right? Yeah.

0:37:50 Yeah. Thank you.

0:37:52 Any other questions for Wendy or her?

0:37:57 Awesome.

0:37:58 Awesome.

0:37:59 Thank you.

0:38:12 Good evening, Mayor and Council.

0:38:13 For those of you who don't know, I'm Kathy Marcus.

0:38:15 I'm the IT Manager for the City of Twin Falls.

0:38:19 We would like to take this opportunity today to focus on Focus Air S7, which is the responsible

0:38:25 community.

0:38:26 And one of the areas that you proactively thought about in the past and funded was the

0:38:31 network security.

0:38:33 So I wanted to tell you a little bit about what we've been doing with that position, how

0:38:38 it's been filled, and some of the future plans for it.

0:38:43 So in 2023, the budget was approved for the security engineer.

0:38:49 And the main reason that we did that was to make sure our network is secure.

0:38:55 There's a lot of sensitive data that we need to protect to ensure that the citizen's information

0:39:00 remains confidential, and all communications that aren't public remain confidential, and

0:39:06 financial transactions are secured.

0:39:10 Also part of network security is operational.

0:39:15 We want to make sure we have continued operations, prevent any disruptions that are in there

0:39:19 for public service, emergency response, and essential functions, and the third main area

0:39:25 is public trust and confidence.

0:39:27 We want the public to feel ensured that the data that we have and what we are doing within

0:39:33 the city is reliable, secure and transparent and necessary.

0:39:39 So in February of 2025, Mike Plain was selected as the security engineer and he started the

0:39:44 position at that time.

0:39:46 It took us a very long time to backfill his position.

0:39:51 So from February to December, he was actually doing both jobs.

0:39:56 So we were very busy, so we spread out that work a little bit, but now we're very happy

0:40:02 to have Adam Day.

0:40:03 He's doing a wonderful job as a network administrator for the city, so that is working out well.

0:40:10 We are currently fully staffed and we're glad we waited because everything worked out well.

0:40:17 So some of the things that I wanted to make you aware of is, oops, I went too far, cyber

0:40:26 attacks.

0:40:27 So one of the things about network security is we want to make sure that we are protecting

0:40:32 our network and our data from the cyber attacks that are out there.

0:40:36 Just in June, we had the threat of the Iranian government that they sent out saying, be where

0:40:42 the Iranian government is targeting governments.

0:40:45 So we're watching that and making sure that our firewalls updated, all our resources that

0:40:50 we have are available are making sure that we don't get hacked.

0:40:56 In June, there were also several big attacks that I thought were worth noting that are happening

0:41:01 out in the world.

0:41:03 Google Chrome had a hole that had to be patched that was compromised, limited natural foods,

0:41:10 grocery, created a grocery shortage because of that hack.

0:41:14 Affleck had claims and personal information released, linked in, had a password leak.

0:41:20 So that's one of the reasons why we make sure people change their passwords regularly and

0:41:24 We ask that they don't use passwords that already exist.

0:41:28 There are AI tools out there with video and voice impersonation

0:41:32 that try to get people to put money into their accounts.

0:41:37 In one week, our firewall here at Twin Falls

0:41:39 had 134 people trying to break through our firewall.

0:41:44 And there's always phishing hacks going on.

0:41:47 And we try and train our users with anti-phishing.

0:41:52 We have our own phishing that goes out.

0:41:54 if people click on it and those users need to go to training.

0:41:57 So these are just in a month, major incidents that take place.

0:42:02 So it's very important to remember to remain focused

0:42:04 on security and make sure that our networks are secure.

0:42:08 Another thing that you've heard a lot about is ransomware.

0:42:11 So Baltimore, Maryland had $18 million in recovery

0:42:16 and lost revenue from their attack.

0:42:18 Atlanta, New Orleans, Oakland, there's been so many

0:42:22 ransomware attacks and even one locally here in Twin Falls County a couple years

0:42:27 ago. So we do want to focus on network security making sure we're secure. So

0:42:34 some of the ways that we're doing that, employee training that I've already

0:42:39 mentioned, we've implemented multi-factor authentication for almost all users that

0:42:46 will be coming to you soon. We're working on parks, parks is the last

0:42:50 department that we had left to implement it on and then we have a couple areas

0:42:56 where we want to where we haven't implemented yet for example MDCs where

0:43:00 in the fire trucks where they need immediate response and they may not a

0:43:04 different firefighter may be jumping in so we don't have the exact solution for

0:43:08 those yet but majority of the city is all multi-factor authentication at this

0:43:13 point. We're implementing firewall intrusion detection and constantly

0:43:18 monitoring our firewall, doing upgrades, seeing who's trying to attack us. We have

0:43:24 eliminated a lot of countries from being able to even make it through our firewall.

0:43:29 We won't accept emails from some countries, so we're focused on that. Network

0:43:35 segmentation is another method of securing the network that we're doing,

0:43:38 where there are certain areas where this data is only for this department and

0:43:43 nobody else can get to it.

0:43:45 Endpoint security, so we have the firewalls

0:43:49 and the virus scans on the different machines.

0:43:54 Network monitoring and system audits,

0:43:56 so we have devices that are out there monitoring

0:44:00 what's going on in our network.

0:44:01 It tells us if something's changed

0:44:03 so that we know we can say, okay,

0:44:05 that was a change that we created or else

0:44:09 that's a change that someone else is trying to do

0:44:12 and then it rejects them.

0:44:14 Software and system updates helps keep us secure also.

0:44:18 Data encryption for some data that is not supposed

0:44:21 to be available to anyone.

0:44:23 We keep encryption.

0:44:24 A lot of email messages are encrypted.

0:44:28 Well, not all email, but some email messages are encrypted.

0:44:32 And then we also use the OneDrive and different methods

0:44:35 like that to transmit data where it requires

0:44:38 that the user is protected when they're accessing

0:44:41 information. We do risk assessments. We are in the process of creating our

0:44:47 incident response plans and our policies. We have backup and disaster recovery

0:44:51 systems in place and we have a whole new area of the library where we're working

0:44:58 on segmenting and creating the isolated areas and the public areas and making

0:45:05 sure that the data there is secure and that we get connected to the library but

0:45:10 but we don't allow connections from the public back to the city.

0:45:13 So all of these things are based on network security

0:45:18 and having a person dedicated to that has been really helpful.

0:45:21 And so we just wanted to thank you for being proactive

0:45:24 and giving us the funding for the security engineer

0:45:27 and we're very happy to have the mic playing

0:45:29 in that position.

0:45:31 Do you have any questions?

0:45:33 Any questions for Kathy?

0:45:36 Oh, look like it.

0:45:37 Thank you.

0:45:38 Thank you. Good evening, Madam Mayor and Council. The HR team is excited to be here tonight speaking

0:45:51 about the internal organization. We're used to being one of the last presentations on the

0:45:56 last budget days, so switching it up is fun for us. So tonight throughout our presentation,

0:46:03 we're going to cover a variety of topics, but I'd like to highlight one specific piece of

0:46:08 of our 2030 vision, but HR continues to focus on its,

0:46:12 the bold sentence there, which is a key aspect focuses

0:46:17 on ensuring a high level of competency is provided

0:46:20 from a lean, properly compensated,

0:46:23 and respected core staff.

0:46:26 Ninth HR team is going to discuss upcoming projects

0:46:30 related to compensation, a snapshot of our recruitment efforts

0:46:34 over the last fiscal year, and our continued efforts

0:46:37 to advance and promote our One City and high-performing concepts.

0:46:42 Our overall objective is to position the City of Twin Falls

0:46:45 as an employer of choice,

0:46:47 where all of our employees are fairly compensated,

0:46:50 feel valued and are equipped and motivated

0:46:52 to contribute their best every day.

0:46:56 As we prepared updates to share with you,

0:46:59 I wanted to start off by highlighting the addition

0:47:01 of our Assistant HR Director.

0:47:04 As you may remember, this was presented

0:47:06 improved in last year's long-term planning process. The addition of this role was

0:47:11 instrumental as there's an ongoing increase to the HR workload. We continue to

0:47:17 experience a difficult labor market. We've added approximately 30 new employee

0:47:22 libraries or library employees and we've continued to see an increased number and

0:47:28 complexity of ADA, FMLA, and workers compensation cases. So this position not

0:47:36 not only provides critical support to our HR team,

0:47:39 but to the organization as a whole

0:47:42 throughout employees and departments.

0:47:45 On that note, I'm thrilled to welcome Lauren Nicholson.

0:47:49 She joined our team this March as our Assistant HR Director

0:47:52 and has made a significant positive impact so far.

0:47:56 And she's going to be leading the next portion

0:47:59 of our presentation.

0:48:01 Please join me in welcoming Lauren.

0:48:05 Welcome.

0:48:06 Thank you. Thank you, Kristin. Good evening, everybody.

0:48:09 The city manager's team has communicated the updates regarding salary,

0:48:13 table adjustments, performance increases.

0:48:16 So we would like to briefly discuss self insurance and a $65,000

0:48:21 compensation study request for the 2025, 2026 fiscal year.

0:48:27 For the self insurance update, we have submitted our initial documents to the

0:48:32 department of insurance and received a letter back with some areas to provide

0:48:36 additional information. Our additional information was submitted last week, and we are excited Cited in E-18

0:48:42 and hopeful that we will receive approval from the Department of Insurance within the next

0:48:46 couple of weeks. Regarding the $65,000 compensation study request, we wanted to provide some background.

0:48:54 Historically, we partnered with Ameribin for HR Consulting Services, which included job

0:48:59 description updates. However, Ameribin Services ended in 2024. In response, this fiscal year

0:49:06 we carried out a comprehensive request for qualifications process.

0:49:11 After evaluating our options, we are pleased to have established a new partnership with Hub International,

0:49:16 who is our chosen HR consultant going forward.

0:49:20 With Hub International, we will formulate a compensation philosophy, a first for our organization.

0:49:27 We're committed to offering fair and competitive pay, so we can attract, reward, and keep talented people on our team.

0:49:35 We're also planning to base our compensation on fair market comparisons, focusing on equitable

0:49:41 benchmarks instead of only where we're hiring from.

0:49:45 Additionally, we'll launch a job description update project.

0:49:49 This initiative aligns with HR's priority-based budgeting program, classification, and compensation

0:49:55 management, focusing on monitoring classification, evaluating reclassification requests, and

0:50:02 reviewing our compensation structure.

0:50:07 When discussing the creation of career paths

0:50:09 and the development of future organizational leaders,

0:50:12 it is crucial to consider the broader growth

0:50:14 and evolution of our organization.

0:50:17 We must integrate our strategic objectives

0:50:20 with new position proposals to ensure

0:50:22 cohesive development and address our long-term goals.

0:50:26 Notably, several proposed positions were not funded

0:50:30 in this year's long-term planning process,

0:50:32 amounting to approximately $560,000 in fully loaded costs.

0:50:38 Despite the lack of funding, it is essential to highlight these positions in relation to

0:50:42 the ongoing needs and priorities of our organization.

0:50:46 Now, I'll turn it over and you'll hear from Evan regarding our recruitment efforts.

0:50:51 Thank you.

0:50:52 Thank you.

0:50:57 Good evening, Mayor and Council members.

0:50:58 I want to take a few moments to highlight our recruitment efforts from the past 24-25 fiscal

0:51:03 year.

0:51:04 The Human Resources Department has conducted 23 recruitment campaigns to date for a wide variety of positions.

0:51:10 An Assistant Human Resources Director departs seasonal technician.

0:51:13 In total, we received over 1,000 applications and successfully hired 30 full-time employees and 102 part-time employees.

0:51:21 In HR, we often say that retaining great people is easier than constantly recruiting new ones.

0:51:26 One of the ways the city supports this is by living out its core values.

0:51:29 Values that foster connection, integrity, and honesty.

0:51:32 On a personal note, I'm proud to say that I'm a product of those values.

0:51:36 I began my journey with the city as a volunteer on the Twin Falls City Youth Council while in high school.

0:51:41 From there, I worked part-time at the city pool, who later joined the HR team as an intern,

0:51:45 and today I stand before you as a full-time HR generalist.

0:51:48 I hope to continue growing within the organization.

0:51:50 We are proud to report 20 internal movements this past year.

0:51:53 It makes the promotions and transfers,

0:51:56 showcasing that the city of Twin Falls is not only a tracking talent

0:51:59 but providing meaningful opportunities for growth.

0:52:01 Thank you for your continued support for our people and the work that you do. Thank you.

0:52:05 Thank you. I'll turn it over to Ancino for organizational development.

0:52:15 Good evening, Madam Mayor and City Council members. I'm excited to provide a brief update on an

0:52:21 important initiative supported by this year's fiscal budget, the creation of the Future Leadership

0:52:27 and Management Development Committee. Why this matters as our city continues to grow and evolve

0:52:34 So too, must our leaders.

0:52:37 The Future Leadership and Management Development Committee

0:52:40 was established as a parallel team

0:52:43 with the goal of cultivating leadership potential

0:52:46 within our organization and building a strong internal pipeline

0:52:51 of future supervisors and managers

0:52:54 who are prepared to meet the challenges of public service.

0:52:58 Our approach, our approach is intentional.

0:53:01 We're focused on providing opportunities for growth,

0:53:04 leadership training, and mentorship to employees

0:53:07 who aspire to lead.

0:53:09 The community is made up of individuals

0:53:11 from various departments and levels of the organization,

0:53:15 bringing with them a diverse set of skills,

0:53:17 perspective, and experiences.

0:53:20 That diversity is one of our greatest strengths.

0:53:23 It creates a space for collaboration, innovation,

0:53:26 and shared learning.

0:53:29 So our progress and our next steps,

0:53:31 our development efforts are intentionally aligned

0:53:34 with the City of Twin Falls long-term strategic goals.

0:53:38 We've identified that leadership and management

0:53:41 while connected are distinct skill sets

0:53:45 that require a separate focus based on feedback

0:53:48 from our employee conversations, surveys, and meetings.

0:53:53 You guys were part of that even at the One City Retreat.

0:53:57 We're currently developing our first training module,

0:54:01 centered on effective communication,

0:54:03 a skill set that sits at the heart of both good leadership,

0:54:07 as well as strong management.

0:54:09 Additionally, two of our committee members

0:54:11 will attend leadership leap training in Virginia this fall.

0:54:16 It's a program designed specifically for new supervisors,

0:54:20 and they'll return with best practices and insights

0:54:23 to help strengthen our local development efforts.

0:54:28 We're proud of our momentum,

0:54:30 and excited about what lies ahead.

0:54:32 your support enables us to invest in our people.

0:54:36 And this committee represents a meaningful investment

0:54:39 in those individuals and the future of the city of Twin Falls.

0:54:48 In 2025, the city of Twin Falls proudly celebrated

0:54:52 our first ever public service recognition week,

0:54:56 officially proclaimed by Mayor Pierce

0:54:59 for May 4th through the 10th.

0:55:01 This week gave us the opportunity

0:55:03 to recognize the remarkable individuals

0:55:05 who show up every day with a commitment

0:55:08 to serving our community.

0:55:10 While I had the honor of organizing the weeks of VANCE,

0:55:14 none of it would have been possible

0:55:16 without the unwavering support of departments

0:55:19 and employees across the entire organization.

0:55:24 We celebrated with department tours and various activities,

0:55:27 including our CPRAD first aid training,

0:55:30 which was even featured on the K&BT News.

0:55:34 helping highlight our commitment to safety and preparedness.

0:55:39 Our hope is to continue this new tradition

0:55:43 with your support, building on this foundation

0:55:45 to honor the remarkable individuals

0:55:48 who make our city better.

0:55:51 To close, I'd like to show and share a short video

0:55:54 that captures some of the special moments

0:55:56 from this inaugural celebration.

0:57:06 This concludes our portion of focus area eight

0:57:10 internal organization presentation.

0:57:13 Now I'll turn the time over to Gretchen.

0:57:16 Thank you, Essina.

0:57:22 Okay, so that concludes the presentation

0:57:25 on each of the individual focus areas,

0:57:27 what is currently budgeted in some updates

0:57:29 on strategic plan objectives.

0:57:32 Now some of the things that we're gonna present to you

0:57:35 are unfunded things for the council to consider.

0:57:40 Each week moving forward as the focus areas present,

0:57:43 There'll be additional pieces that will be added to this,

0:57:46 and at the end we'll have a list for your consideration.

0:57:51 Each year, previously, the council has had $770,000

0:57:56 that you have allocated for a variety of different projects.

0:57:59 Sometimes that's incorporated like sidewalks,

0:58:02 major improvements that you're looking to try to fund.

0:58:05 This year, the budget is a little bit different,

0:58:08 and there is more for you to consider

0:58:10 and decide how you would like to allocate funding.

0:58:13 should the council decide to no longer move forward with the M-POG, municipal powers outsource

0:58:18 grant program. There's an additional $50,000 that would be added to the 770. And some unanticipated

0:58:26 revenue that came into the budget, very close to the end of our, close to the start of the

0:58:32 presentation last week, $365,000 has been just put into contingency that also could be

0:58:39 allocated if the council chose to do that. You could leave it in contingency or you could

0:58:43 allocate it to any of the projects that are going to be coming forward to you in the next

0:58:47 couple weeks. So we have two groups that will be presenting as part of this tonight. We'll

0:58:54 start with Parks and Recreation and then we'll ask Courtney Cunningham from the Police Department

0:58:58 actually from, she works in the Police Department but she's representing a parallel team to come

0:59:03 forward with her presentation as well.

0:59:13 So in preparation of preparing a list for you this evening, we had a meeting with Parks and

0:59:20 Recreation Commission and we asked them to review some of these projects and try to prioritize

0:59:27 them based on their understanding of the Parks and Recreation Master Plan as well as needs

0:59:32 in the community and just kind of the value these different projects can bring.

0:59:36 As we know, the Council-directed capital is intended to benefit the community and a lot

0:59:44 of the stuff that Parks and Recreation does fits that criteria really well, and so I'd

0:59:48 like to just kind of go over a few of these so you understand what they are.

0:59:53 This is the list and this is an order and then I'll present them an order of priority

0:59:57 assigned by the Parks and Recreation Commission and supported by staff.

1:00:02 So the Harman Parks Gate Park redesign was part of the Community Transformation Grant.

1:00:10 And so several years ago, Blue Cross awarded $90,000 to the city Parks and Rec Department

1:00:17 to do some work out at Harman to kind of revitalize part of the park and fix some of the safety

1:00:26 issues identified associated with the skate park.

1:00:32 project and I think I mentioned it to you a little bit last year. I just wanted you

1:00:36 to understand this this picture. So you've got all these different colored areas

1:00:41 with different numbers attached to them. When we did it we didn't phase it

1:00:45 necessarily. We just identified each of the improvements and put a dollar amount

1:00:51 to it with the team that did all the design with the expectation that we could

1:00:56 go out and try to get funding for different pieces of this. And so we're

1:01:00 hoping to get some of this donated or sponsored or whatever, but we need to

1:01:06 start with the infrastructure and obviously that's the, that's not very sexy

1:01:10 and it's hard to sell. So this is the one that would put some lights in there, this

1:01:14 would put conduit in place for future lighting and parking lot. So this is a

1:01:18 $385,000 request to put some of that basic infrastructure in and add lights

1:01:25 around that skate park right now. And the reason the Parks and Recreation Commission

1:01:29 mission, ranked that number one as they felt the safety component of lighting that area

1:01:35 was pretty critical.

1:01:36 And they also felt that it would open the door for the future efforts to try to get some funding

1:01:42 to do some of this other work.

1:01:45 The next one is to start a tree grant program similar to the sidewalk grant program.

1:01:55 So currently, you can apply for a grant to replace sidewalks out in front of homes that

1:02:00 I think business is too, I'm not sure.

1:02:03 But this one would add another $5,000 seed money in a grant that would allow us or allow

1:02:10 homeowners with a tree such as the one you can see right there.

1:02:15 That needs to be removed and replaced.

1:02:17 They could apply for $500 to give us 10, $500 grants that could be used to purchase and plant

1:02:24 trees as part of the tree removal process. This one is kind of a thorn in all of our

1:02:32 sides. The pulling medians are obviously a thing of concern and it's hard to figure

1:02:42 out what to do about them. And really the best thing to do is to redesign them. I

1:02:47 think we all agree that this is not, they're not unsightly, it's not the entrance to the

1:02:52 community that we would like to have, but that we'd like to have something. And

1:02:56 And we'd like it to be attractive.

1:02:58 We wanted to reflect the community.

1:03:00 And so to start with, we'd like to ask for $50,000

1:03:05 to design sustainable, easy to maintain,

1:03:10 medians that also have a level of attractiveness to them

1:03:16 that kind of provides a gateway, but also

1:03:19 would be easy to keep looking good so that we're not

1:03:23 fighting the weeds and taking those phone calls all the time.

1:03:25 So this would be the start of that project.

1:03:29 The next one is the Harmon West Tennis Courts.

1:03:32 And we've been talking about this one for a while.

1:03:34 It was funded through LTP about three or four years ago.

1:03:39 These courts, this is the old set.

1:03:41 This is on the West side.

1:03:42 They have become essentially unplayable at this point.

1:03:46 The big cracks in the courts I fell on Wednesday playing tennis.

1:03:51 And I landed on my nose and my chin.

1:03:53 Stacey hoped that I had tripped over one of these cracks and I said, sorry I don't play on those.

1:03:59 But anyway, this is 351,000 for post-tension concrete that would build, our request is for

1:04:09 two tennis courts and then we would add four pickleball courts. And the idea out there is to

1:04:14 spread out the pickleball a little bit, give another opportunity for pickleball,

1:04:18 and put five courts out at Harmon, that would be playable both by USTA League, by individuals,

1:04:25 high schools could use them, and we thought that was kind of a decent compromise there.

1:04:30 And then the last one, I don't remember how many years ago, maybe four years ago,

1:04:35 counsel allocated $40,000 to design improvements to Baxter's. And we've been back to LTP and to

1:04:42 Council several times with this construction estimate for those improvements.

1:04:49 And so for 595,000 we can make these improvements.

1:04:53 And the problem we've talked about phasing this one a little bit.

1:04:56 And I thought Chance did a great job in the Parks and Parks Commission last week explaining

1:05:02 that the problem with phasing it is the things you would try to phase out are low dollar items.

1:05:07 The big ticket item is the overall improvement to the space.

1:05:12 You could pull out the agility course.

1:05:14 You could pull out the wash station.

1:05:17 You can pull out some of those things, but they don't amount to very much.

1:05:21 And so really, by the time you spend the 400,000 or whatever it would take to get it ready for

1:05:27 the other improvements, you might as well just do all of it.

1:05:30 So those are the five that we are adding to the list.

1:05:34 And I think next it's you Courtney.

1:05:39 Thank you Wendy.

1:05:40 Oh, Grayson has a question.

1:05:41 Yeah, Madam Mayor.

1:05:42 Thank you.

1:05:43 So, pardon my ignorance and maybe Travis you can like me on this too.

1:05:47 But on the poll line meeting, isn't that all owned by I.T.D.?

1:05:51 But then we just maintain it, isn't that what that contract is?

1:05:56 It's technically state highway, but we maintain it.

1:06:00 And we maintain it because leadership at the time in which

1:06:04 Pollline was constructed insisted that it be full of

1:06:10 vegetation.

1:06:12 And when ITD said that's fine, however, you'll maintain it

1:06:17 into perpetuity.

1:06:19 It has become our responsibility.

1:06:20 So yes, it is ITD property.

1:06:22 It is part of the ITD and the US Highway System.

1:06:25 They would be involved in any redesign.

1:06:29 But based upon early decisions that we made,

1:06:32 we have put 100% of the responsibility associated

1:06:35 with the maintenance and the appearance

1:06:37 of the polling medians and also the medians down Washington.

1:06:40 So we had an unfunded mandate more or less.

1:06:43 That we created on our own.

1:06:44 Nice, perfect, cool.

1:06:46 And we can't end to it.

1:06:47 Nice, 11 years ago.

1:06:50 But it's not there, all of us.

1:06:52 Let's not do that again.

1:06:54 OK, anything else for Wendy?

1:06:58 Okay, next Courtney, welcome, Courtney.

1:07:05 Good evening, Madam Mayor and members of the council.

1:07:06 Thank you for having me this evening.

1:07:08 My name is Courtney Cunningham.

1:07:10 I am an employee of the Twin Falls Police Department,

1:07:12 as Gretchen mentioned.

1:07:13 However, tonight I'm not here on behalf of TFPD,

1:07:16 but a citywide parallel team.

1:07:18 I know this is kind of a unique situation,

1:07:20 so first I'm gonna explain what our team is,

1:07:22 what our goals are, and then we'll get

1:07:23 into our request for you all.

1:07:26 Last summer, the executive leadership team

1:07:28 created five new parallel teams

1:07:30 that city employees were invited to join,

1:07:32 one of which was the emergency management parallel team.

1:07:35 As we all know, emergencies today don't just involve

1:07:39 severe weather and acts of God,

1:07:40 but they can include things such as pandemics,

1:07:43 civil unrest, aging infrastructure,

1:07:45 and a variety of other emergencies

1:07:47 that are environmental law enforcement related

1:07:49 or fire related.

1:07:52 In October, our team was initiated

1:07:54 and includes approximately 12 employees

1:07:56 throughout the city, a few of which are here today,

1:07:59 if I could ask them all to raise their hands please.

1:08:04 As you can see, we vary from line level employees

1:08:06 up to department heads all across the organization

1:08:10 from police and fire, library to IT

1:08:13 to the airport, building safety and public works.

1:08:17 Now, before I start into the goals of our team,

1:08:20 I wanna make one thing clear.

1:08:21 We are addressing our emergency preparedness

1:08:23 and what we need moving forward,

1:08:24 but this team is fully confident

1:08:26 in the capabilities of this city

1:08:28 to respond to emergencies.

1:08:29 We have incredible first responders, incident command,

1:08:32 and the equipment to do our jobs.

1:08:34 The best example I can think to demonstrate this happened

1:08:37 in February of 2023, as we received reports of shots fired

1:08:41 inside the Canyon Church High School.

1:08:42 That day, we saw law enforcement from across the region

1:08:45 run down the hallways of Canyon Church High School,

1:08:47 ready to handle the threat.

1:08:48 We saw firemen put on their tactical gear,

1:08:51 as they prepared to enter a warm zone and treat wounded.

1:08:54 We saw medical aircraft landing in a nearby field

1:08:57 and city employees from across the organization

1:08:59 respond to the area helping to block roads

1:09:02 and help wherever else they could.

1:09:04 We were prepared as a city that day

1:09:06 to respond to this emergency.

1:09:07 And our community was too.

1:09:09 We saw our teachers and our students

1:09:11 ready to protect and defend themselves.

1:09:13 We saw a nearby church open its doors to us

1:09:15 offering their building, their parking lot

1:09:17 and their field to land in.

1:09:20 We saw other businesses open their doors

1:09:21 and offer shelter to the students

1:09:23 that were fleeing the school.

1:09:25 We have an incredible community that each one of us

1:09:27 should be thankful for and a great city team that is prepared for all of this.

1:09:30 But there are things that we need to be prepared for as we continue to grow and that's why our

1:09:34 team is here today. Thankfully this incident was just a hoax and nobody was injured and it

1:09:40 ended up being an unintentional yet very effective training exercise for all of us which kind of

1:09:45 led the creation for this team. We began by identifying a few goals for the team. The first was just

1:09:53 looking at some risks and vulnerabilities that we face. Some of these are related to our geographic

1:09:58 area and are fairly specific and others are things that can be seen across the

1:10:03 nation. You'll see a list of them up there. Our second goal is to look at what

1:10:07 we would need to establish an emergency operations center that would be

1:10:10 multi-jurisdictional and act as a place for incident command to allocate our

1:10:15 resources during an emergency. Our third goal is to establish an emergency

1:10:20 operations plan that is one large comprehensive document that will

1:10:24 address how to mitigate disasters, coordinate emergency response and recover

1:10:29 afterwards. And our fourth is establishing emergency building plans for city

1:10:34 facilities. Now the City of Twin Falls owns dozens of buildings, approximately

1:10:38 20 of which house city employees on an everyday basis. Now as far as we are

1:10:44 aware only two of these buildings have emergency building plans in place, the

1:10:48 airport and the library. So these last two goals are mainly why we are here

1:10:53 today. We are here to request that you use a portion of your city council directed

1:10:59 capital not to exceed $100,000 to hire a consultant to develop an emergency operations plan and

1:11:06 emergency building plans for the city health facility.

1:11:09 Very too far.

1:11:13 An emergency operations plan is a very extensive document.

1:11:17 This contains everything from disaster mitigation to emergency response, recovering after an

1:11:22 emergency.

1:11:23 partnerships, be it bus companies and health care institutions, new churches and

1:11:31 volunteer organizations in our local region, but also across state and federal

1:11:36 resources as well. It also includes training and outreach for our community

1:11:40 and our employees to help us respond. Now of course these documents would comply

1:11:45 with all federal and state mandates and also work alongside the pre-existing

1:11:49 Twin Falls County All Hazard Mitigation Plan and Emergency Operations Plan.

1:11:53 And it would also include building response plans for the City of Twin Falls City Health

1:11:59 Facility as it is our largest building with the most employees and is open to the public.

1:12:07 This plan would also include assigned roles and responsibilities throughout the existing

1:12:11 positions within our organization that are specific to us.

1:12:15 This would include an organizational chart that shows our department structure, our chains

1:12:19 of command and continuity of operations planning.

1:12:22 Now, like I said, this is a little bit unique as I'm here representing multiple departments,

1:12:30 so I might have cheated a little bit on this next slide here.

1:12:34 I stole some strategic plan goals from not only the responsible community that we've

1:12:38 been discussing tonight, but also some from our secure community presentations.

1:12:43 My team and I think that this is a very worthy project to fund, to help us grow into the future.

1:12:51 It relates to a lot of our strategic plan goals throughout responsible community, secure community,

1:12:56 and even others.

1:12:58 We really appreciate your time this evening and your consideration for this project and

1:13:02 my team and I would be happy to stand for any questions that you might have for us.

1:13:07 Thank you, Courtney.

1:13:08 Any questions for Courtney or her team?

1:13:10 Looks like we're good.

1:13:15 Thank you.

1:13:16 Thank you very much.

1:13:21 It's intimidating to follow her.

1:13:24 Yep.

1:13:25 Okay. So that concludes our presentation this evening. Anybody

1:13:33 stands ready? Should the Council have any questions? We're happy to come back up. This is the schedule

1:13:38 of presentations coming to you next. Next week you have focus areas 4, 5, and 6, and then

1:13:45 on the 28th, 2, and 3. We'll have an opportunity to review and go through some things. I believe

1:13:52 the decision relative to your council directive capital priorities that the council would like

1:13:59 to see funded, that discussion I think is going to take place on August 18th. I got confirmation

1:14:06 nod. All right. So with that, thank you very much. Very soon did you have some?

1:14:12 Oh, yeah. Thank you, Madam Mayor. So regarding focus area number eight with HR, my favorite

1:14:18 department. What was the extra documentation that was requested? And did we fulfill all

1:14:26 that stuff? Did we get any pushback? Are you guys think that that's going to get resolved?

1:14:34 So I don't recall the exact extra documentation. There were some supplemental insurance pieces

1:14:40 that they were looking for regarding like our life insurance. Just kind of a variety of things

1:14:46 to review. It was submitted last week. There was just a handful of items. Overall, the

1:14:52 majority of the original documents, there were no questions back to us.

1:14:56 And we did get a copy of the letter and the response last week.

1:15:00 Yep, great. Okay. Make sure on the same page.

1:15:04 Any other questions while she's up there? It looks good. Thank you.

1:15:12 Okay, so did you have something else, Gretchen?

1:15:16 Sorry. Okay. So next is,

1:15:24 we have a couple of public hearings tonight, but we're going to move on to general public input.

1:15:29 So, I'm going to break this out into two sections.

1:15:32 The first round will be anybody in the audience that wishes to comment on the budget or you

1:15:41 have any input for City Council on the budget portion only and then we'll move on to general

1:15:48 public input.

1:15:49 So, is there anybody in the audience that wishes to address City Council on the budget?

1:15:59 And if you come up to the podium, please state your name, whether you're a resident of Twin

1:16:03 Falls, and you have two minutes.

1:16:06 My name is Francis Florence, I'm a resident of Twin Falls on 98th Avenue East.

1:16:10 I want to speak to the budget, specifically the funds that, the extra funds that you have

1:16:20 to spend, the presentation that talked about the mediums on the streets and specifically

1:16:27 be the tree grant that comes in.

1:16:31 I want to be supportive of those kind of issues.

1:16:34 And I speak to the quality of life kind of issues

1:16:37 that sometimes we forget about.

1:16:39 And when we talk about the mediums and we kind of roll our eyes

1:16:42 like, boy, that was stupid having those mediums put in there

1:16:45 because now we have to take care of them.

1:16:46 I disagree with that.

1:16:47 I think that was a good move then.

1:16:49 What maybe hasn't happened since is we haven't taken care

1:16:52 of those in a manner that we maybe

1:16:55 could make our community proud of.

1:16:57 And when I see, you know, if we have a recruit

1:17:00 trying to come in, we're trying to hire somebody

1:17:01 and they want to look at a quality of life

1:17:03 and Twin Falls and they drive down whole line road

1:17:05 as their first impression go, well, this place is going to heck

1:17:10 because they're not paying attention to the small things.

1:17:13 And I'd like to encourage us to pay attention

1:17:15 to those small things because they are a quality

1:17:17 of life things and they do add to the value

1:17:19 and the perception of Twin Falls, even by its citizens.

1:17:24 And when we look at these surveys and we say, gee,

1:17:26 what's going wrong with these comments,

1:17:28 some of those comments negatively

1:17:30 might just be the perception that we all have a responsibility

1:17:33 of trying to make a good impression and a good perception.

1:17:37 So I'm supportive, especially with the landscaping items,

1:17:40 because I think those are things that we oftentimes move

1:17:43 to the bottom of the list,

1:17:45 possibly as evidenced by the budget we put into the Parks

1:17:49 and Rec being so substandard to the average budgets

1:17:54 of parks and wrecks in other cities.

1:17:56 I think it's something that given the opportunity to speak,

1:18:00 this is my opportunity, I want to remind us all,

1:18:03 my slooted, to keep those things in mind

1:18:05 because I feel like I'm played an active role

1:18:08 in trying to make Twin Falls better for the community.

1:18:11 And I want to focus my efforts on doing that.

1:18:15 And if it sounds like I'm scolding,

1:18:16 I apologize for that, but it's just a reminder

1:18:19 that we can all do better, I think.

1:18:21 Thank you.

1:18:21 for any.

1:18:23 Amy, do you have the ability to do a timer?

1:18:27 Okay.

1:18:28 Anybody else that wishes to address City Council on the budget portion of our agenda tonight?

1:18:37 Okay.

1:18:38 Seeing no one, anyone who wishes to address City Council on any other issue that is not

1:18:45 either are public hearing or the budget, please come down, state your name and you have two

1:18:52 minutes. I'm mayor and council. My name is Maria and my head and I'm just a native of, sorry guys,

1:19:13 of Twin Falls Idaho and sorry I wasn't here last week. I got dentures, it's hard to talk.

1:19:22 Anyway, I'm here because there's going to be a protest on Thursday in honor of congressman John

1:19:28 Lewis and his lifelong fight for justice. It's nationwide, it's a day of action, it's a good

1:19:36 trouble, demonstration and it's also a food drive. I think we're the only protesters that

1:19:42 have the rules with it being peaceful and also an objective to help the community. And I'm

1:19:49 kind of proud to be a protester. I thought I'd never say that, but I have someone that

1:19:57 that I honor with that is John Lewis.

1:20:00 So we're fighting for racial justice, voting rights,

1:20:02 immigrant rights, and defending democracy.

1:20:06 I have a quote in the back of my shirt I got two years ago,

1:20:10 but the quote is from him.

1:20:11 When you see something that's not right,

1:20:14 not just and not fair,

1:20:15 Lewis said you have a moral obligation to say something.

1:20:19 He also said never ever be afraid to make some noise

1:20:22 and get in good necessary trouble.

1:20:25 And there are times when I've been an object of racist comments

1:20:31 and things like that.

1:20:33 It's all of what I have to do.

1:20:34 Most of the time I walk away, but don't think I don't go home angry.

1:20:39 And then I have to give my anger to the God of Justice

1:20:43 and put it in his hands.

1:20:45 But I want to say that I am really proud to be part of this community.

1:20:52 And I'm really don't even see you guys' councilman anymore.

1:20:57 I see you guys' family because I speak so much here.

1:21:00 So anyway, that's my time.

1:21:02 Thank you.

1:21:03 Thank you, Marie.

1:21:05 Anybody else in the audience that wishes

1:21:07 to address City Council on an item not on today's agenda?

1:21:15 Okay, scene no one, advisory board reports.

1:21:19 Anybody have anything?

1:21:21 There's probably no meetings last week.

1:21:24 City Manager's Office.

1:21:28 Okay.

1:21:30 So we, like I mentioned, we have two public hearings tonight.

1:21:33 Do you guys need a break?

1:21:35 Take five?

1:21:36 Okay.

1:21:37 Back by 6.30, 28.

1:21:41 Okay, 6.28.

1:21:43 Thank you.

1:21:53 Before I do that, I'm gonna read the public hearing procedure.

1:21:59 The council will follow these steps for each request listed

1:22:03 under the public hearing portion of the agenda.

1:22:05 City staff will present the request and analysis.

1:22:09 The applicant will then present their request.

1:22:12 Council will then ask questions of the applicant or staff.

1:22:16 After those questions have been answered,

1:22:18 the public hearing will be opened during that time.

1:22:21 Anyone in attendance is given the opportunity to comment

1:22:24 or ask questions about the request being considered.

1:22:28 When you're giving testimony,

1:22:30 please step up to the podium, state your name and address,

1:22:34 present your comments, their concerns,

1:22:36 and after giving testimony, there's a public signing sheet

1:22:40 in the lobby if you could sign your name for the record.

1:22:44 Once those comments are concluded,

1:22:46 the applicant will be invited to answer any questions

1:22:50 and make a closing statement.

1:22:51 Staff will then answer or clarify any comments.

1:22:56 After the closing statements, the public hearing

1:22:58 will be closed and then the Council will have open discussion and take action on the

1:23:03 request. So our first item is an action item. It's a request for a zoning development agreement,

1:23:12 zoning district change from neighborhood commercial to R6, high density residential on property

1:23:19 located at the 900 block of Falls Avenue West, care of EHM Engineering's Inc. On behalf

1:23:25 Grandview Farms LLC and I believe we have Jonathan, no Kelly tonight. Yeah I needed

1:23:34 to be here so I gave her the night off. Oh okay, excellent. Thank you. Welcome Jonathan.

1:23:38 Thank you Madam Mayor, members of the council. The location we are talking

1:23:42 about here is on the map it's highlighted in blue. This is the southwest corner

1:23:46 falls in Grandview. It is part of an overall planned unit development currently.

1:23:51 that encompasses essentially I believe it's 60-ish plus acres that goes to the West.

1:23:56 It has currently been developed with this Twilight Loop down here with some residential.

1:24:02 These are modified lots that are smaller with some smaller setbacks. The current zoning, I will get

1:24:10 down to, these are the pictures of the location. Not a lot because only the north side has been

1:24:16 developed and then the east is also a little bit developed with houses that are

1:24:21 towards the east. The zoning map will show R2, and then there's also a PUD on it, so it's R2

1:24:27 PUD with some portion of a neighborhood commercial. Within that planning and development document,

1:24:34 it allowed for offices, different types of office, and some light commercial. We get into that in

1:24:40 a minute as to what they're asking for, but the current zone has R2 with that planning development.

1:24:45 the north of this area is also similarly zoned for

1:24:49 neighborhood commercial, although it has an R6 designation,

1:24:53 which is different from residential base zone. The

1:24:57 development agreement also has commercial with offices.

1:25:01 That is where the base camp convenience store is located on the

1:25:05 hard corner there at the northwest corner of Grandview

1:25:09 and falls. So that was part of that development agreement

1:25:13 to allow some of that, most of it will then be offices.

1:25:17 The future land use map shows neighborhood commercial

1:25:20 is in that pink, so now I'm in the right side map here.

1:25:23 It's just a block that doesn't have a,

1:25:25 it's not defined in a certain area,

1:25:27 it's just that intersection of the two arterials.

1:25:31 On our future land use map, we put those intersections

1:25:34 because they end up being high volume traffic intersections.

1:25:38 So most single family homes don't necessarily enjoy

1:25:42 on those and new ones aren't necessarily built a lot of the time and if they are

1:25:46 it's usually the rear of the house, something like you'd see on Eastland.

1:25:50 Sometimes that can be an undesirable look. Anyway, that's what the Future Land Use

1:25:54 Map shows. This application that you're seeing in front of you is actually a

1:26:00 rezone of the property. So what they're asking to be done is to be extracted

1:26:05 from their current PUD agreement, put into their own agreement with an R6

1:26:10 designation and to be constructed or developed per the agreement you'll see in

1:26:14 front of you today and I'll go through that. So they're looking to rezone the

1:26:17 property. That's important because your criteria for rezone is looking towards

1:26:22 whether it complies with future land use map, complies with the general area. The

1:26:27 essentially have that harmonious neighborhood type of feel. It's different

1:26:33 than some other things you would see like an annexation. It's a different

1:26:35 criteria. So we're looking at does it comply with the comprehensive plan which

1:26:39 is here on the right-hand side and is the general construction method and what

1:26:44 they're showing to be constructed going to fit in with that area. This is the

1:26:50 exhibit that was shown to the Planning and Zoning Commission. It has a certain

1:26:56 number of dwelling units. I can zoom in here and you can kind of read and then

1:27:00 within your package you have it as well. It has a certain review and some parking.

1:27:05 There are 36 one-and-two bedrooms, 48. I'm trying to read that without zooming in

1:27:13 again, sorry, there we go, 96 and 48. You will see the in your packet, you'll see

1:27:25 the elevations in the next slide. The exterior of the project actually has the

1:27:32 two-story units and the interior are the three-story units. I'll show those in a

1:27:40 The exterior has garages and look like a townhome style, so they're two-story vertical.

1:27:51 They do have access through stairwells on the exterior of the interior of the similar.

1:27:56 That is how this is constructed or shown on here.

1:28:00 During the planning and zoning meeting and you see that in the minutes, there was testimony

1:28:03 and then some discussion from the commissioners.

1:28:06 They do not feel the tandem parking in multifamily areas like this necessarily works.

1:28:13 So they added a condition and you'll see it later to remove the tandem parking and that's

1:28:17 what you would see here is these dotted lines on the east and the west.

1:28:22 And they made the condition that that provision be removed.

1:28:27 Dave who's representing the applicant has a modified version that he's come up with.

1:28:31 I don't have it to show you.

1:28:33 Generally describe that.

1:28:35 we can show up on the picture. In the end, what David was took the parking over here,

1:28:40 swapped it to the opposite side of the drive aisle, created some parking areas, essentially

1:28:48 where my cursor is here on both sides of these, and then added some parking in some other

1:28:54 strategic areas to essentially take away the parking in front of the building, and now

1:28:59 the drive aisle is just near that. People park in their garage, which is legal, and we count

1:29:04 spaces and then there would be an additional space just on the other side of the drive aisle.

1:29:09 You also added a few spaces in the middle here like I think it's three or four on either side of

1:29:15 this to accommodate that tandem parking to be just elsewhere not in front of the garage.

1:29:23 These are the elevation renderings. This is the what they're calling the 18 which is the three story.

1:29:32 You have access through the doors basically the stairwell here and here. This would be the back

1:29:39 Yes, is it back, slash front, back, you know, rear on this side, and then these are the two

1:29:45 story, which would be what you would see from any public roadway or access point.

1:29:52 These are what's in the front of the property along the frontages.

1:30:02 The actual agreement is short, it is literally right here, is R6, which allows for a multifamily.

1:30:11 They're going to follow every other zoning code that we have for the base's own, except

1:30:19 the building height, ostrich parking, and multiple buildings on one lot, believe it's in, maybe

1:30:26 not Dave can talk about that, but yeah.

1:30:32 They wanted to go taller, 42 feet for the third, the three story.

1:30:36 The reason for that was to accommodate, and their narrative is to accommodate the pitched

1:30:41 roof, so they can have a pitched roof on the three-story.

1:30:45 Current code has 35 feet as the maximum height,

1:30:49 so they're asking essentially for seven more feet.

1:30:52 And then the two-off-street parking spaces,

1:30:56 and they just were not going to allow that to be tandem.

1:31:01 That was commissioned to basically remove that.

1:31:06 That is the development agreement.

1:31:13 It can go through all of this if you wish in the end.

1:31:16 R2 is more of a residential, but the NCO

1:31:18 allows a lot of other things in it. A lot of the businesses and retail trade, which is going

1:31:25 away like bakery, bookstore, craft shop, eating places which ends up being, those end up being

1:31:30 a special use standpoint or certain sizes. Those are going away and it really just becomes a

1:31:38 R6 with a certain request for a lot of residential. And I'm looking for anything else. We receive

1:31:48 multiple comments. You've already had those in the packet. Your minutes also contain

1:31:52 some discussion from a let me get the name correct so I can give you a mr. Kirby so

1:32:02 he spoke on behalf of other people in the minutes reflected his items I was not

1:32:06 notified of anybody seeking to represent anybody else in terms of

1:32:10 getting extra time tonight and so you would just follow the normal time allotment

1:32:15 from a zoning staff standpoint I'm gonna go back to my staff report real quick so

1:32:21 for you first real quickly. We had three main staff conditions, our normal number one

1:32:32 is the SIPUN amendments. Number two, we were dealing with the construction of

1:32:36 Falls Avenue West, bringing brought up to City Current City standards. We've talked

1:32:41 about that with the applicant. Number three was a six-inch race curb. On Falls

1:32:46 Avenue West, we are essentially trying to prevent people conflict when they're

1:32:50 turning left on falls for a certain distance.

1:32:53 And then we'd get that on the first building permit

1:32:56 or construction.

1:32:57 And then number four is to removing the tenant parking

1:33:00 allowance from the agreement.

1:33:01 That was added by the Honey and Zoni Commission.

1:33:05 So that concludes the report.

1:33:08 The only, I guess clarifying piece of information

1:33:11 could give you is any of those,

1:33:15 particularly condition number four.

1:33:16 If you wanted to allow that provision,

1:33:21 You could simply just leave it off your motion.

1:33:23 Or if you wanted to have that discussion separately as a

1:33:26 council, you could vote on that one specifically if you wish,

1:33:29 just kind of giving us some direction.

1:33:30 However you'd like to do that.

1:33:33 That includes what I have.

1:33:34 Thank you.

1:33:36 Any questions for Jonathan, right?

1:33:39 That's Sherry.

1:33:40 I just have a quick question.

1:33:42 And I was trying to read through the P&Z notes,

1:33:44 but what is the issue with tandem parking?

1:33:48 Yeah, so the commissions, I'm going

1:33:50 to be truncating like seven people's views.

1:33:53 And we've had this discussion with them in multi-family settings.

1:33:56 It happens to where someone, I mean you have multiple households,

1:34:01 not necessarily multiple families in a unit.

1:34:03 And they don't always communicate and work out.

1:34:07 And oftentimes if we're finding in other locations

1:34:10 where multi-family happens, it becomes dispute-ridden.

1:34:16 Someone's still sleeping and they're parked in the back.

1:34:18 The person needs to get out and they don't like to talk to each other.

1:34:22 And sometimes some places, not this one particular,

1:34:26 but in some places they assign different numbers

1:34:28 to different people and they say, oh,

1:34:30 you're in behind that guy's garage,

1:34:33 but you're assigned space as a subleasing the bedroom

1:34:37 and the commission just feels like it doesn't work

1:34:40 in multifamily settings.

1:34:42 Okay.

1:34:43 Because there's so many units and people coming and going,

1:34:45 so that's just how they thought.

1:34:47 Okay, and so then without the tandem,

1:34:49 there will still be equal amount of parking.

1:34:53 That's always my concern is having enough parking.

1:34:54 That's what the applicant is.

1:34:56 Yeah, that's kind of what they have accommodated

1:34:58 to meet the code per the number they need on the site.

1:35:04 They just moved it to a different spot.

1:35:07 Anybody else for Jonathan?

1:35:10 Hey, Applekin, welcome Dave.

1:35:13 Thank you Madam Mayor, members of the council.

1:35:15 My name is Dave Tebow with the EHM Engineers

1:35:17 at 621 North College Road.

1:35:19 And this evening I'll be representing

1:35:20 Grandview Farms, probably right there, Jonathan, thank you.

1:35:23 And they're a request for rezone.

1:35:26 As Jonathan described, this property

1:35:28 is part of a PUD.

1:35:30 It's that old prior to our ZDA, so it's a PUD.

1:35:34 It's sat vacant and dormant while being advertised

1:35:36 for neighborhood commercial overlay,

1:35:38 and we courted a couple different commercial enterprises,

1:35:41 including the base camp store to this corner,

1:35:43 rather than the corner to the north.

1:35:46 And then also, I think, a lumber yard and materials yard,

1:35:50 to look at this site.

1:35:52 Over that intervening decade and a half,

1:35:55 we've kind of looked at the growth in the area

1:35:57 and we've determined that the adjacent property

1:36:00 to the north is R6 and we think that we could develop

1:36:03 and design and lay out a very viable apartment complex

1:36:08 and project that you see before you today.

1:36:10 So that is the reason for the request to rezone to R6

1:36:14 and utilize a ZDA to get two specific provisions.

1:36:19 One, being the additional height to accommodate the three-story units that are identified in the center of the project.

1:36:24 And two, to allow tandem parking in a multifamily project exactly like

1:36:30 Ufeloud or this body has allowed in other projects.

1:36:33 For instance, latitude 42, west of the Twin Falls Reform Church has garages in parking and tandem parking being specifically permitted

1:36:42 despite the recommendation from the Planning and Zoning Commission to not permit such parking.

1:36:48 So we feel that the layout provides good access,

1:36:53 not only to falls, but also the interior residential roadway

1:36:56 to the south.

1:36:58 It's laid out with the buildings having their facade

1:37:02 and their exterior elevations dressing up the street side.

1:37:06 There's pretty good setback distance all the way around.

1:37:08 Access is good for utility routing and fire access.

1:37:12 However, we feel like if we had to flip the tandem parking

1:37:17 that I'll kind of point on with the cursor.

1:37:20 It's along here, and just move it across the street to here.

1:37:27 And we take up some of this green space,

1:37:29 and then similarly on this other side.

1:37:32 And then we tuck in a few here and here and there

1:37:35 that we really don't add anything to the project.

1:37:38 In fact, we take away some green space.

1:37:41 And as long as this facility operates with the intent

1:37:44 that they require and the applicant spoke at the planning

1:37:49 and zoning level and said, hey, our rental agreement

1:37:52 will require that they use the garage space for parking.

1:37:55 And if they can manage that and satisfy that,

1:37:58 why would they be denied the same opportunities, I guess,

1:38:02 that are permitted elsewhere in the city

1:38:05 via this same application process.

1:38:07 So our preference, just so I'm clear,

1:38:10 is that we are permitted to attend the parking.

1:38:13 In the event that that becomes a sticking point where approval is going to hinge on that point,

1:38:17 we have developed an alternate plan that we would substitute out as the master plan attached

1:38:22 to the zoning designation agreement that would satisfy the parking requirement without any

1:38:27 tandem parking.

1:38:28 So I wanted to just be clear on that.

1:38:32 Anyhow, pursuant to the staff report, the conditions and the decision making that we're

1:38:38 going to try to achieve this evening, we're seeking for your approval of the rezone.

1:38:42 We agree with this particular portion of the staff report that says the project is well

1:38:46 laid out.

1:38:47 The buildings are spaced apart appropriately and there are two accesses to the complex,

1:38:52 both on the north side and the south side.

1:38:54 Plenty of green space and landscaping surrounding the complex which is cohesive to the surrounding

1:38:58 area.

1:38:59 And we accomplish the specific goals found in the comprehensive plan under land use goal

1:39:03 three and number five.

1:39:05 And I would stand for any additional questions that the council might have at this point in

1:39:11 time.

1:39:13 You have a schematic, well this is a schematic, so you have the pictures of the architect rendering.

1:39:22 Yes.

1:39:23 So can you show me a garage side?

1:39:26 Yeah, let me get to the 12plex.

1:39:29 So right here, Madam Mayor, are the garages as they look to the exterior.

1:39:33 You can see those right there.

1:39:35 And one car?

1:39:36 Two car.

1:39:37 Yes, one car, single car.

1:39:38 So when you mean tandem, you mean somebody's going to park behind, and it's going to be

1:39:43 a resident of the person with the garage.

1:39:49 Yeah.

1:39:50 So these are attached units.

1:39:51 I think Jonathan did a good job describing that.

1:39:53 So in this instance, what you would envision is there's a car parked in the garage, and

1:39:58 then there would be a car parked tandem right in front of the garage.

1:40:01 I should have took a picture of my place.

1:40:02 I have three sons, two of which are driving.

1:40:05 We own six vehicles.

1:40:06 Jason has to live in the vicinity.

1:40:09 but you can drive my place and we operate like that.

1:40:11 In fact, I actually have a tandem garage,

1:40:13 so I'm 3D, but you just can't tell.

1:40:16 Okay. Thank you. Sherry.

1:40:19 So removing the tandem,

1:40:26 are you then removing any other parking spaces,

1:40:33 or is it because you would be moving them over towards the middle?

1:40:37 Yeah. So what that looks like,

1:40:39 I did bring some exhibits and I apologize,

1:40:41 They just didn't get them to John up and to have in your packet.

1:40:44 But basically these dotted lines, they'd go away.

1:40:47 We'd reconfigure the drive aisle to be out shifted out set

1:40:51 a little bit.

1:40:52 And then we would pick up stalls right in here

1:40:54 in the green spaces that are created there.

1:40:57 But instead of having, if I zoom in,

1:41:01 that's a 20 foot parking stall and then a 26 foot drive aisle.

1:41:05 So if I just mirrored that and I'll put the drive aisle

1:41:07 closer to the buildings, the drive aisle actually

1:41:10 has to set off just a little bit.

1:41:11 And then I'd have the parking that would actually

1:41:14 impede into the landscaping a little bit.

1:41:16 So how about going up and where the driveway comes in

1:41:21 from the other parking?

1:41:23 And there's a tan and you're,

1:41:24 I'm seeing two tandems here that would be.

1:41:28 It's not helping me out, Sherry with the cursor.

1:41:30 I know, yeah, I know.

1:41:33 Yeah, yeah, right around in there a little bit down.

1:41:37 Yeah, yep.

1:41:38 So I just have the one tandems stall.

1:41:40 But those ones and the ones further down.

1:41:41 I just have the one tan install here and you're talking about these three. That's why I captured some over here

1:41:48 To get the same count and I captured some in here to get the same count is because by eliminating these

1:41:54 I don't have a parking spot here because it's a drive-out. So I pick them up here, here, here, and here

1:42:01 And that's really what's driving my opinion and design decision

1:42:05 I'm losing a lot of green space, you know, 20 by 9, 20 by 10, pretty good square footage.

1:42:14 All of a sudden we're talking about, I think it's close to like 23 stalls, net gain versus

1:42:19 net loss, and it works out to quite a bit of square footage of green space.

1:42:25 Are there any interfacing anywhere?

1:42:27 You have to look over my shoulder.

1:42:31 We don't get into that at this point.

1:42:32 Yeah.

1:42:35 Yeah, there'll be some type of fencing around the perimeter of the project.

1:42:39 Okay.

1:42:40 Thank you.

1:42:42 Great.

1:42:43 Yeah.

1:42:44 Grayson.

1:42:46 Well, thank you, Madam Mayor.

1:42:47 Hey, Tebow.

1:42:48 So I have two kind of material questions.

1:42:50 So when you're talking about tandem parking, it is literally arcing a car behind the garage of this same unit.

1:42:58 Yeah.

1:42:59 So it's somebody that's in the same unit with you.

1:43:02 Yeah.

1:43:03 So theoretically, you would have a relationship with that person to say,

1:43:07 to say hey go move your car. You and I were roommates I'd always want to be the

1:43:12 guy that's tandem on the outside not in the garage. Dave T but you and I would

1:43:16 never be roommates. So yeah you see that right here. What is the civic to that

1:43:22 unit? Right here that's the garage here and then that's the spot right there.

1:43:27 Want to clarify? Jason. Yeah Dave as I look through this and trying to figure

1:43:35 out. It's kind of working through my own issues and trying to, trying to say I put

1:43:42 myself on the on the street view. The biggest thing for me is, is flipping so

1:43:51 the north and south apartments flip them 180 degrees so the front is facing the

1:43:57 road instead of the garage facing the road. Is that something that you could do

1:44:02 and still make that that footprint work? So as I'm driving down what I can't

1:44:07 remember what let's say you're talking about right here correct where where's

1:44:13 your cursor again I just switched switched off just just on the on the West side

1:44:17 so I'm talking about falls yeah so so you see there on falls flip it 180

1:44:23 degrees so the front is facing the front door is facing the road and so as

1:44:27 people are driving by they see the front of the apartment complex instead of the

1:44:31 back of the apartment complex and then do that also on the on the bottom trying to get to the

1:44:39 the road sorry I moved my map and I shouldn't have yes I'm sorry yeah so summer miss would be the

1:44:49 one that I would so having those units flipped 180 degrees doesn't appear that that would mess

1:44:56 up but at least from an aesthetic standpoint I'm looking at someone's front garage or front door

1:45:01 instead of the back.

1:45:03 Yeah. So what that would look like is if I understand you correctly is instead of seeing this from the street

1:45:10 from the street side, you would see this correct.

1:45:13 Correct.

1:45:14 No, I don't have any harbor over that. I don't think there's anything wrong with that. That's easily accommodated.

1:45:19 Okay.

1:45:22 Thanks for right now. That's that'll be my comments. But may have a few more as we move on.

1:45:27 Thank you, Chris.

1:45:28 As we're talking about the stacking, it looks like it's the one and two bedroom units that

1:45:38 are all going to be stacking the three which are in the center would have their own individual

1:45:47 or they would have two parking spots as they do not have garages, is that correct?

1:45:53 That is correct.

1:45:54 Anybody else?

1:46:03 Okay, thank you.

1:46:05 Okay, so I'm going to open up the public hearing.

1:46:13 when you come up to the podium, please state your name, whether you're a resident of Twin

1:46:18 Falls and then present your comments. Each individual will have two minutes tonight to

1:46:25 [Muted for privacy: street address]

1:46:32 [Muted for privacy: street address]

1:46:47 [Muted for privacy: street address]

1:46:52 One of those was the height of the buildings, and number two was the streets going north

1:47:01 on falls and south on some amiss.

1:47:09 There are approximately 315 units there, therefore there would be about, I'm sorry, there are

1:47:16 315 vehicles, parking spots that would be available.

1:47:20 And what I'm concerned about, at the end of the meeting, the gentleman from Base Camp had come up and said,

1:47:32 this is going to be great. At the end of the meeting, also, Mr. Wolverton came up and said,

1:47:39 this is going to be beautiful. And the only thing that went through my mind was between all about profit.

1:47:47 And not about the actual effects that this property is going to have on roads and traffic.

1:47:58 Imagine having 350 cars trying to get out of either the north side or the south side.

1:48:06 That's going to be really hard on Grandview trying to get those cars out.

1:48:13 And the other thing is, as kids go back to school,

1:48:18 parents are going to be driving their children to school.

1:48:21 There are buses on that, on Grandview,

1:48:25 that go up and down there.

1:48:28 And the cat traffic is going to be huge.

1:48:32 And when we look across the way that those that are trying

1:48:35 to cross over falls and going east and those going west,

1:48:42 How difficult that's going to be if we don't do something now

1:48:46 about taking care of lighting, meaning stoplights and so forth.

1:48:55 The other item was I would request that if you haven't gone

1:49:04 out to the property, go out and look at that property

1:49:09 and envision what's going to be there

1:49:12 And how do we get those cars out of there as we're trying

1:49:16 to see the traffic go from east to west,

1:49:23 or even down to summer mist going east to west?

1:49:31 If you could, I'd really like for you to wait till August

1:49:34 when it schools back in and all of them,

1:49:39 white birch all the way to college.

1:49:44 There is a lot of traffic there, and it's a stop and go,

1:49:49 and there's four stop signs there.

1:49:52 So it becomes more and more congested

1:49:55 as these vehicles come out.

1:49:58 And I just want to say that I would request

1:50:05 that the property actually go to something less density

1:50:12 and not continue along this path.

1:50:16 Sir, your time is up. I'm sorry.

1:50:19 Thank you. Okay. Good evening, City Council and mayor.

1:50:32 My name is Steve Woods. I am not a member.

1:50:34 I am not a resident of falls. I live on the east side of town in the impact area.

1:50:40 I am. We are my wife and I are here because we have friends who are who live

1:50:45 nearby to this develop proposed development and they are unable to attend

1:50:50 because they're out of town. So we are there surrogates.

1:50:52 When we first heard about this, we had very little detail.

1:50:58 The detail that I see right now satisfies all my concerns,

1:51:04 and I would feel very comfortable telling our friends

1:51:07 that this is a nice, nice facility.

1:51:11 Relative to the reorientation of those particular units,

1:51:17 my only concern would be those outside units

1:51:22 facing the road, facing falls and grand view, I would not want that. I wouldn't want my front door to be facing the noise of the traffic.

1:51:32 I would rather have the back of my house facing that noise and so doing the noise a little bit.

1:51:40 As far as the traffic coming out of that, the gentleman was concerned about.

1:51:45 about. I would only say watch the kids coming out of Twin Falls High School when the bell rings.

1:51:53 Everybody is coming out at the same time and everybody is anxious to get somewhere real quick

1:51:59 as opposed to a community like this where it's not everybody's going at the same time.

1:52:05 So it might be a little bit of a problem, traffic's always a problem, but it wouldn't be a major

1:52:10 problem. Thank you. Thank you, sir. Is there anybody else in the audience that wishes to address City Council on this issue? Okay. Oh, here we have one more.

1:52:35 [Muted for privacy: street address]

1:52:47 [Muted for privacy: street address]

1:52:52 or Broadmoor, but we have a problem right now that we need to have homes that are

1:52:57 one bedrooms, two bedrooms, three bedrooms that are affordable, and we need

1:53:00 to have them on the side of town. We have great schools, we have great facilities,

1:53:03 great resources, and it'd be nice to have homes there that people can afford and

1:53:11 it's not just always about profit, it's about the community and getting people

1:53:17 Thank you.

1:53:19 Okay.

1:53:23 Anybody else from the public?

1:53:26 Okay, Dave, did you have anything you want to address?

1:53:31 I think that the only thing that I'd add is I think we tried to do a better job for Mr.

1:53:37 Winsborough on the height and kind of where we located those buildings.

1:53:41 That was pretty deliberate by the time you transitioned from two story to three story.

1:53:46 You're further interior to the property.

1:53:48 So the impacts are minimized.

1:53:49 And then also with regard to the streets and the traffic,

1:53:52 I understand that those concerns are typically what I hear

1:53:55 when I come to these meetings, but Twin Falls is determined

1:53:58 to assess an impact fee for the streets specifically

1:54:01 and that process has been working really well.

1:54:04 We do have Grandview and Falls, which are both classified

1:54:06 as an arterial and like major collector,

1:54:09 and they have sufficient capacity right now.

1:54:12 In fact, you know, Falls really doesn't have a destination

1:54:14 to the West, so it's capable of having four lanes

1:54:18 to travel lanes in each direction and then actually a fifth lane for center turn if needed.

1:54:24 We have good access in and out of here that not only meets the city's requirements, but

1:54:28 it also meets the requirements of the international fire code and the fire department.

1:54:32 So we feel really satisfied that this project is going to be positive and adequately served

1:54:38 by all of the municipality services should you choose to rezone it tonight for our request.

1:54:44 Thank you, Dave.

1:54:47 Anything else Jonathan from you?

1:54:49 unless you have any questions for me to clarify anything.

1:54:52 Any questions for Jonathan to clarify?

1:54:59 Yes, yes, okay.

1:55:03 I was reading through the ENSI,

1:55:08 and it talked about here,

1:55:10 somebody had asked about street lights,

1:55:13 and it said, I talked on here that,

1:55:16 I'm trying to find it really quick.

1:55:19 Mr. Buckley asked if traffic light was going in

1:55:22 at the intersections,

1:55:23 been loved, explained that the City Engineer deems it appropriate as needed.

1:55:28 Can you expand a little bit on that?

1:55:30 Yeah.

1:55:31 As Dave mentioned, so we do the, we have an impact fee program, every dwelling unit will

1:55:35 pay a street impact fee, and those go to the street impact fee fund that can be used for

1:55:40 a few different things.

1:55:41 One of those is intersection improvements, including street lights, meaning signals.

1:55:47 When it is deemed appropriate or necessary by the City Engineer, to use those funds for

1:55:53 that we would go through a process to say it's now warranted and needed in the area and

1:55:58 hypothetically everybody in the area has paid into that program a certain amount to help

1:56:02 fund the street signal when it's needed and that I don't know all the specifics on the

1:56:08 criteria they can hit so I don't go through those but the city engineer and their staff

1:56:14 can go through that in terms of the number of trips north south versus east west time of

1:56:20 day, the destinations that need to be, you know, forget to, that kind of thing.

1:56:25 Thank you.

1:56:27 Chris Street, Jonathan, have we done a traffic study in that intersection recently?

1:56:33 I'm going to say yes, in terms of, Troy.

1:56:38 Troy.

1:56:39 Troy just jumped up.

1:56:40 Has some numbers.

1:56:41 I'm glad he's here.

1:56:42 I'm like, yes.

1:56:43 Great.

1:56:44 He was just waiting.

1:56:45 He was.

1:56:46 That's why he's here.

1:56:47 So we have done a traffic study.

1:56:48 There is a now warrant for a stop signs on Falls Avenue and Grandview, a four-way stop.

1:56:56 It could be a four-way stop, however, when we go out there and we do visual analysis of

1:57:02 it, there's never more than one or two people waiting for the falls.

1:57:05 I'll let you come with me next time I go through that.

1:57:08 Okay, I might.

1:57:09 If you tell me the next times.

1:57:10 Maybe it's just when I'm driving through it, but it could be the van.

1:57:13 Yeah, maybe it's the day that I was when I'm going through it and thank you.

1:57:18 Yeah, so to impact the Grand View drivers like that, we have the opportunity to do that

1:57:23 now, but it is nowhere close to a signal.

1:57:27 So, Troy, when you see something like this and let's say that it's approved and it's

1:57:33 going to go in, do you wait until the traffic is done or do you pre-plan for something like

1:57:41 this?

1:57:42 pre-planning. We're watching the east side of town right now, Chaney and Eastland. I believe that will

1:57:47 probably be the next one because of that subdivision that's going out there and how that's growing.

1:57:53 But we are planning with something at that point as well as part of you and Chaney is another

1:57:59 opportunity there more for safety reasons. But this one is on our horizon, see North College

1:58:07 and Grandview being impacted probably more with that four-way stop. We see a lot of people back

1:58:11 up there that would do a falls right now but and I won't lag this on but there's a

1:58:18 couple schools really close put by there so that might buy this intersection so

1:58:24 that might we we believe that's just my concern you're gonna have a lot of kids

1:58:29 around that area to be able to walk this subdivision and the subdivisions to the

1:58:33 west fully develop there will be a need at that point but we'll have funding

1:58:36 separated or associated with it.

1:58:39 Sure.

1:58:40 Okay.

1:58:41 Thank you.

1:58:42 Okay.

1:58:43 Anybody else?

1:58:46 Okay.

1:58:47 I'm going to close the public hearing and council deliberation.

1:58:51 Grayson?

1:58:55 Well, thank you Madam Mayor.

1:58:57 I'm a little baffled on why tandem parking wouldn't work in that scenario, especially

1:59:04 with, you know, tenants in common in the same unit.

1:59:09 So I'm prepared to make the motion.

1:59:10 Obviously we can have more deliberation.

1:59:11 I'm more than one to make a motion and then in addition to add that Tandon parking be allowed

1:59:18 Okay, that's right. I've got a couple other people that wish to comment Craig

1:59:25 My feeling is that the height does not bother me when I

1:59:30 Tandon parking I think both solutions are not the best and I'm perplexed about that part

1:59:40 Thank you, sir

1:59:42 And I think it's a much needed facility.

1:59:46 I completely understand the residents that are there.

1:59:51 And my question on the fencing was more so along, some are missed.

1:59:59 I don't know how, if fencing would, I think of my words today, it's on Monday, it would

2:00:09 would help to border that along so we don't get street parking from visitors that are going

2:00:17 to the apartments and things like that. Otherwise, I think it's good and I think tandem parking,

2:00:25 I mean, we're not here to manage adults or people who are supposed to be adults. I think

2:00:30 tandem parking works out quite well.

2:00:34 Thank you. Jason.

2:00:36 Yeah, I just want to address the comment of why I said flip the summer mist on or the flip the building on summer mist and falls and understand and recognize that the noise concern it was more of driving down a street looking at someone's front front door is far more appealing than maybe the barbecue or some of the stuff on the back of a building.

2:01:00 And that was the premise of it.

2:01:03 And I think the separation from falls down to that first complex.

2:01:08 I think there will be some noise hampering from trees and things as they get a little

2:01:15 bit more grown.

2:01:16 So, Grace, if you make the motion, I would actually ask that that request be put in there

2:01:20 that those four buildings, you get 180 degrees different if that's okay.

2:01:27 Okay, Spencer.

2:01:33 So let's turn mine everybody on.

2:01:35 This was part of a larger PUD, where they say, look, we're going to make some exceptions

2:01:39 to the rules to consider the totality of the development, and at the time it was done, it

2:01:43 was considered this corner is going to be lower height and less dense.

2:01:47 That's two big changes we're making.

2:01:49 We're increasing density.

2:01:51 We're adding height.

2:01:52 And I really don't like changing a PUD after it's already started before things are built.

2:01:59 before there's neighbors there is a time to do that.

2:02:02 You know, it's not supposed to be detrimental to the surrounding neighborhood.

2:02:07 And obviously that's a change to the negative for anyone that's already around there.

2:02:12 So I'd be against this.

2:02:15 You know, one thing is apartments.

2:02:19 If you go around to existing developments, there's a lot more hubbub in the evenings.

2:02:23 That's where you're going to notice the change.

2:02:25 I don't think the traffic overall will be that big of a deal.

2:02:28 There's a lot more commotion around apartments in the evening

2:02:31 versus where this is supposed to be.

2:02:34 High-end retail offices.

2:02:38 So I just don't think it's fair to neighbors

2:02:40 to change things midstream.

2:02:42 I understand we have a need for housing in Twin Falls.

2:02:45 There is existing R6 property that's not developed.

2:02:48 So we're not shutting that off.

2:02:51 So I think that tells Council

2:02:53 how I'm likely to vote this evening.

2:02:55 Okay, I have three people still up, but I think you've all spoken, so Greg, are you good?

2:03:02 Okay, so go ahead, Grayson, you said you wanted to make a motion?

2:03:06 Thank you, Madam Mayor.

2:03:07 So I make a motion that we approve the request for a zoning development agreement, the zoning district change from neighborhood commercial to R6, high density residential, on property located at 900 block of Falls Avenue, care of EHM engineers,

2:03:21 I think on behalf of Grandview Farms, LLC,

2:03:25 and we have the entry of the dwelling space roadway

2:03:28 and allow for tandem parking.

2:03:31 And the other conditions as outlined.

2:03:34 And the other conditions as outlined in staff report.

2:03:37 Thank you, Chris Reed.

2:03:40 Before seconding this, can we take these?

2:03:45 I feel like the switch, the 180 degrees,

2:03:48 can we vote on that separately?

2:03:50 The tandem, I'm fine with that one,

2:03:52 but that switch over there is a pretty big one and make an amendment to that would be

2:04:00 okay with Grayson. Travis, how would you do that?

2:04:06 Madam Mayor, it would be appropriate so that if Councilman Reid wanted to make an alternative

2:04:12 motion, that motion could separate the two items that would be voted on independently

2:04:20 then you would vote on the second item independently.

2:04:24 Perfect.

2:04:26 So essentially, I'll retract and modify my motion

2:04:29 to have it just say tandem parking,

2:04:31 and then you can come back and make a motion.

2:04:34 Jason can come back and make the motion to invert 180 degrees.

2:04:38 Is that correct?

2:04:39 That works.

2:04:40 OK, so I'll retract my original motion.

2:04:43 And I will make a motion to approve a zoning development

2:04:47 agreement, zoning district change from neighborhood commercial

2:04:49 the R6 high-density residential and property located at 900 block of falls

2:04:53 Avenue West. Here at VHM engineers ink on behalf of Grandview Falls and

2:04:58 allow tandem parking. Is there a second? I'll second that. Thank you. Motion by

2:05:04 Grayson Stone second by Chris Reed to approve a zoning development agreement

2:05:09 zoning district change from neighborhood commercial to R6

2:05:12 identity residential on property located at the 900 block of falls Avenue West. On

2:05:19 on behalf of ground view farms,

2:05:22 including allowing tandem parking.

2:05:27 So this is where I'd make that alternative motion.

2:05:28 No, we vote on this first and then you, yep.

2:05:32 Okay, any further discussion on that particular motion?

2:05:37 Okay, Amy Roll call vote, please.

2:05:41 Craig Hawkins.

2:05:42 Yes.

2:05:42 Jason Brown.

2:05:43 Yes.

2:05:44 Spencer Cutler.

2:05:45 No.

2:05:46 Grayson Stone.

2:05:47 Yes.

2:05:48 Jerry Vomer.

2:05:48 Yes.

2:05:49 Ruth Pierce.

2:05:50 Yes.

2:05:51 Thank you.

2:05:52 Motion passes six to zero or six to one, excuse me, six to one.

2:05:57 Jason.

2:05:59 I'd like to make an alternative motion or an additional motion to change the four complexes,

2:06:08 the two facing summer mist and the two facing falls Avenue 180 degrees.

2:06:15 second Spencer. Sorry I jumped again. I'm just gonna make a comment after it's

2:06:22 okay. I need a second. Madam Mayor I'll second. Thank you. Motion by Jason Brown

2:06:29 seconded by Grayson Stone to add the addition of flipping the units on falls

2:06:40 and what is that spring? Summer missed. Summer missed 180 degrees. Spencer

2:06:47 I was going to say I think that would be a mistake to change it because it's really,

2:06:53 if we're considering the people that are outside this development or people just driving by

2:06:57 the feeling you get, so generous setbacks really give you that sense of openness like

2:07:02 it's a more luxurious feeling.

2:07:04 So if you consider like on Main Street we have the old historic courthouse with the

2:07:09 judicial annex, the one is setback, it's far from the road, it just feels a lot more

2:07:14 grand versus what's crowding the road and I understand there's this concept of

2:07:19 well maybe we don't want the garage door or something facing the the public but I

2:07:23 think that's less a lot less noticeable when it's we got to be 80 feet maybe a

2:07:30 hundred feet off the road versus you flip that whole thing all of a sudden you're

2:07:33 putting a tall building right next to the road it's gonna fill a lot more

2:07:37 dance and crowded so if this move was just for aesthetics I really think that's

2:07:42 going to actually do the opposite what you're trying to accomplish. So I guess the

2:07:47 motion would not be to push it closer to the road it would be to leave it at the

2:07:50 same setback and flip at 180 degrees. It won't work. I guess I was maybe jumping

2:07:59 a little bit here I don't see how they could lay out the parking and make that

2:08:02 work. Chris did you have a comment? Yeah because we're just though from where

2:08:11 where they're at those four. We're just on the site that they're currently at

2:08:15 rotating them. So the parking would still be to the north on falls. The problem

2:08:20 would be how do you get to the garage? I may jump in. I know I'm going to, maybe I

2:08:25 shouldn't necessarily, but I think what ended up happening is just this parking

2:08:28 layer here becomes the parking layer right there. Then they come out on the

2:08:33 back and go into the garage. So you really are just taking them. So you're still going

2:08:38 have parking on the street. The curb via the parking up here still stays the same

2:08:42 and if I'm looking at Jason you really can just take this line right here and

2:08:47 you just rotate it the curb on the curves just swap so what you'd have is

2:08:53 falls landscaping parking now you'd have this row of parking here yep and then the

2:08:58 building and the garage would be on this slide and I guess that was my intent to

2:09:03 do it that I guess that was what I was trying to include is that so what is the

2:09:10 distance between the parking stalls and the road you said that's about 80 feet

2:09:17 is that what I heard there's like a I think there's an 80 foot setback from

2:09:23 the center of the road so they've got to meet at least a I'm hearing 60 maybe but

2:09:29 I'm trying to see that number.

2:09:31 So my intent was actually, I think Spencer or Councilman Keller,

2:09:35 I don't want the front doors right on the road on that setback.

2:09:40 I guess that was so that was definitely not my intent was to put them right on the road

2:09:47 or go into that envelope of.

2:09:52 That makes a lot more sense.

2:09:54 I know the public hearing portion is over,

2:09:56 but can we allow the applicant to address the feasibility

2:09:59 making that change?

2:10:09 I don't, that's up to me, I guess.

2:10:12 Technically, we-

2:10:13 You'd have to open the public hearing.

2:10:15 Yeah.

2:10:16 I'd have to open the public hearing again.

2:10:18 It's a big change.

2:10:20 That's fine.

2:10:21 And I can retract my motion and we can vote on it

2:10:25 and see what happened.

2:10:26 But I definitely don't want to create a scenario

2:10:28 or a situation where our proximity to the road

2:10:33 increases the intent was to do what Jonathan said was to flip it 180 degree take this back

2:10:39 part take the park internal parking put it on that external aspect and then the back

2:10:47 that was the intent but if that's not what we're if that's not what is perceived I definitely

2:10:51 don't want to create a scenario where it moves forward. Well we do have a motion on the floor so

2:10:59 So we need to vote on it.

2:11:02 Can I can retract my motion if I need to, can I not?

2:11:06 Even if it's been seconded?

2:11:08 So, I mean, I'll retract the motion, so, or, or, yeah, add, add the, I'll just retract

2:11:16 your motion and then we'll, they will not have to worry about it if the second, if the

2:11:20 second.

2:11:21 Yeah, so my second, I was going to vote no against it anyway.

2:11:24 I was just seconding it to get it to, I was trying to get it to discussion, but I was

2:11:29 Okay, so the motion's been retracted.

2:11:34 Okay, so that ends this particular item.

2:11:40 Thank you, Dave.

2:11:42 Okay.

2:11:43 The next item is also a public hearing.

2:11:46 It's an action item.

2:11:48 And we don't have an applicant on this.

2:11:55 So it's just staff request for a zoning title amendment to repeal and replace title 10.

2:12:01 items to include or regulations pertaining to supplemental regulations and well-head protection

2:12:08 overlay district here of the city of Twin Falls and we have Jonathan and Will or Will.

2:12:14 We have Will.

2:12:16 Thank you Madam Mayor.

2:12:20 We have two items under this one, two chapters, the well-head protection overlay and then supplemental

2:12:25 regulations.

2:12:26 The well-head protection overlay I want to start with, because right now, or the proposal

2:12:34 is to keep the language the same and to move it into its own chapter.

2:12:41 We researched this well-head protection regulations with some state models or codes, model codes

2:12:54 for well head protection overlays. And ours was essentially on par if not the exact same

2:13:01 where with the regulations I've talked with Nathan Erickson our environmental engineer

2:13:05 and he's also been supportive of him for it as well. We are not proposing any amendments

2:13:14 to the well head protection overlay boundaries as well and so this one would be a we're going

2:13:21 to keep going as is, but rather than having it buried in a chapter, in a zoning district

2:13:27 chapter, make it more prominent, and then that way we have a little bit more eyes on

2:13:32 it, can remember a little bit more thoroughly, and make it a little bit more visible to the

2:13:37 public and to staff.

2:13:41 As far as, I'll close that, unless we have any questions on the wellhead protection, really.

2:13:55 What I'm going to do is I'm going to pull up the supplemental regulations, what we currently

2:14:00 have on one side, and then what we're proposing is on the right side.

2:14:08 The one on the left is what we currently have, and you'll notice how it is color-coded with

2:14:14 some notes.

2:14:17 essentially what we want to do is keep the effect of supplementary, so we back up.

2:14:28 The supplementary section is basically been our catch-all section.

2:14:33 If we forgot it in the past and we didn't know where to put it, it didn't meet, fit nicely,

2:14:38 we threw it in this way.

2:14:40 So it kind of became the zoning regulation junk drawer.

2:14:46 we clean that up with this regulation. So a lot of the regulations that you'll see on

2:14:51 the left side that we currently have, we're keeping them and we're moving to them to other

2:14:56 sections of the code. Effect on supplementary regulations, sale or lease of required space

2:15:04 and additional height. Okay, my apologies. Seven, one and seven, two, though, so the effect

2:15:14 on the sale or lease of required space, that is not changing. Where we get our first

2:15:20 change is additional height and that is in our zoning chapters chapter 8

2:15:27 regulations so there should be a box on here that says it's moved to chapter 8

2:15:33 where we get our processes that one has not come before the council at this time

2:15:38 we anticipate that coming in August about a month from now

2:15:46 Canyon Room setback was repealed and replaced in 1995, so we are removing that.

2:15:54 The detached accessory building setbacks have been changed to 10-4, which is our

2:16:02 conditional use section. Though this has already come before the Planning

2:16:07 Zoning Commission, this has already come before the Council and has found a spot

2:16:13 it's home there. A big item that we're changing or proposing changing is the

2:16:19 front yard setback. These are additional front yard setbacks on arterial and

2:16:25 collector roads that are not from property lines but are from the center line. When

2:16:31 we started going through this, I'm gonna go right here. There's a 93 foot setback

2:16:38 from the center line of the road.

2:16:42 If you times that by two, that's 186 foot right away

2:16:45 for a setback.

2:16:47 Typically, if you have those type of setbacks,

2:16:49 you're aiming to get more right away.

2:16:52 And we do not anticipate having 186 foot right away

2:16:57 on our materials or our collectors.

2:16:59 They seem owners, they seem a little bit over necessary.

2:17:07 and we believe that our setbacks, property setbacks of that's based

2:17:12 on our zoning designations will be adequate, provide for that look,

2:17:17 that feel, but also for the right-of-way improvements that we may need.

2:17:24 Any questions on?

2:17:31 We have kept filling of canyons.

2:17:33 It's right here.

2:17:33 We have not changed any words or verbiage in there,

2:17:37 but we are proposing keeping special landscape requirements

2:17:42 for properties fronting the College of Southern Idaho.

2:17:45 We've removed that and we've kind of leaned on the PUD, the ZDA that the CSI has in place

2:17:54 and we're going to remove that for removing that section.

2:18:02 Adult entertainment businesses is a conditional use so that we're proposing putting it into

2:18:08 the conditional uses section.

2:18:11 Then we get to special landscape requirements for gateway arterials. This

2:18:22 has been moved to our landscaping section. Again, we wanted to keep the

2:18:27 landscaping section with the landscaping and so this was a big portion of it that

2:18:32 we wanted in that section. That has been brought before the Commission and

2:18:37 Council and found a spot there as well. We are this section vehicle stacking

2:18:45 requirements for drive-through facilities would be repealed and replaced. It was

2:18:49 amended and put into the parking section. We're just cleaning that up. Outdoor

2:18:57 storage and display. This is the first time that we've kept it in the same spot

2:19:03 but we've updated it for clarity. We've this paragraph right here, what's

2:19:13 highlighted. There was questions on what was the exceptions. So there was an exception, but

2:19:22 there's an exception to the exception. So we wanted to clarify what that actually meant.

2:19:28 So how it ends up reading is merchandise should not be stored or displayed outside of the primary

2:19:32 business building unless the areas that are screened from public view. Exceptions are included

2:19:39 vehicles as defined in idle code, pickup shells, large agriculture implements and so

2:19:47 instead of it going from three sentences or one really long run-on sentence, we

2:19:53 brought it to two sentences to clearly say what the exception is and what the

2:19:58 intent of our regulation is. Then we get to placement of satellite dishes, we

2:20:13 We removed that. We felt that was also overreach and where we go into wireless communication

2:20:20 facilities that could be seen as that. We wanted to simplify and we felt that was over-regulation

2:20:29 at that point.

2:20:32 I'm going to make sure I'm not missing any recreational vehicles on residential lots. We kept that

2:20:37 the exact same. We're not proposing any changes. Then wireless communication facilities, this

2:20:44 This is also, we felt, was a, I apologize, that is moved further down.

2:20:53 We have a section on this in our conditional uses section and it points to this portion

2:21:02 where the regulations will be guided.

2:21:04 A lot of this regulation is dictated to us by the FCC,

2:21:13 where if we have micro, they go and get into the minutia,

2:21:18 the micro, first micro towers.

2:21:20 And essentially, we have to allow micro towers.

2:21:22 And so we're trying to adhere to those FCC regulations.

2:21:27 And one thing further to note about this

2:21:33 is, yeah, no, so what I was going to say was collocations,

2:21:50 collocations, collocations, there's different ways to say it.

2:21:55 Those, if you built it to the collocation standards right

2:22:02 here, that you'll be able to have it be just

2:22:05 a conditional use permit, rather than going through a special use

2:22:09 permit and for the longer process.

2:22:12 These are the regulations that dictate it.

2:22:16 We also have further regulations in that special use

2:22:19 or the conditionally used permit

2:22:20 that will say if it has to be designed this way

2:22:23 and if you build it this way, then you're good to go.

2:22:27 If you don't want to build it to the stealth method,

2:22:31 then it's a special use permit.

2:22:35 Thanks, Sherry.

2:22:35 Did you have a question?

2:22:37 Yeah, I just had a quick question on the drive-throughs.

2:22:40 Did you change how many automobiles for stacking, or was that looked at to where we would need

2:22:48 to increase the number of vehicles, I think right now it's five.

2:22:53 Is that correct?

2:22:54 Yeah.

2:22:55 Current regulations is five.

2:22:56 When we went through the parking regulations, that's where backing requirements proposed

2:23:03 to be held.

2:23:05 We proposed 300 feet and from the order board on, if they can keep 300 feet to from the pickup

2:23:15 window, from the pickup window onto their property, if they can figure out how to show

2:23:20 that 300 feet of stacking, then they're okay.

2:23:24 That added an additional five-ish spaces, but it also took into consideration what drive-threes

2:23:33 are already taken into consideration from the order board to the pickup window.

2:23:40 So, I'm going to jump in here and help you out of the sack.

2:23:46 So we have a lot of drive-throughs that kept giving us different numbers, and they were

2:23:49 seeing we have X number in our drive-through.

2:23:53 Some of them are 15 or 12 from the pickup window where you get your food to where you

2:23:59 ordered, right?

2:24:00 And then they were counting, well, I've got 12 here, and then I have additional 5.

2:24:03 were saying I have 17 or I have 30 and that number between the order and the

2:24:08 pickup was what changes between the industry they all have their own number

2:24:12 that they want to hit and most of them were just like well I have this many

2:24:15 already and then they just added five I want to take all that discrepancy and

2:24:21 that I guess confusion I would say from your window where you're picking up we

2:24:25 just want you to have 300 feet it gets you a certain number 300 divided by 20 is

2:24:31 parking space, not everybody's really that close to each other, but it gets you

2:24:35 generally the number we're seeing across the board to accommodate, I'm gonna say 95%

2:24:42 of the drive-thru's. Not all of them are as popular as others. There's a few

2:24:51 they're really really popular and one of them like, I'll use the name because

2:24:55 we've had them peer report dash brothers has an extensive one.

2:25:00 So it doesn't really accommodate that one,

2:25:02 but for the most of them.

2:25:03 So we just went from pickup window 300 feet on private property

2:25:06 before you get to the public way.

2:25:08 We believe we'll accommodate almost everybody.

2:25:11 And going forward into the future with more population,

2:25:14 that will also, you think that will, what you've done.

2:25:18 I'm not quite, I mean, I'm no question that I'm asking

2:25:20 the question is all.

2:25:21 We think it's gonna be okay.

2:25:22 I'm gonna say it's gonna be okay.

2:25:25 That's the base minimum requirement, but we kept drive throughs as a special use.

2:25:29 So.

2:25:31 And they're not in this section, right?

2:25:33 They're not here.

2:25:34 It's not even here.

2:25:35 It's in the parking.

2:25:36 Yeah, it's in the parking when you've already seen it.

2:25:37 We've already seen it.

2:25:38 We do know we need to have a follow up conversation with this group about drive

2:25:43 throughs downtown because 300 feet on property downtown is going to be very

2:25:47 difficult.

2:25:50 Put a plug in from like my professional view.

2:25:52 That's why drive throughs aren't found in most downtown areas because they

2:25:55 just have a conflict with pedestrians.

2:25:57 So we need to have that conversation if that number's good,

2:26:00 and if someone can make it work, great.

2:26:02 Otherwise, you can drive through in a downtown area.

2:26:04 Okay, thanks.

2:26:05 Yeah.

2:26:09 Commercial painting.

2:26:11 We're proposing to keep that the exact same,

2:26:15 not touching that.

2:26:16 City services.

2:26:23 City services, I believe, went to chapter eight

2:26:29 or conditional use permits, chapter four or chapter eight,

2:26:32 one of those two.

2:26:34 We did not, we're not proposing removing this,

2:26:36 we're just proposing it needs a new home

2:26:38 rather than in our juncture.

2:26:42 So it's either in four, eight, I can get you four.

2:26:46 Okay, so it's in chapter four conditional uses.

2:26:51 Public hearing notice requirements,

2:26:53 that is in our chapter eight section,

2:26:57 which is for our zoning actions.

2:27:01 It's outlines our processes and then it outlines

2:27:04 what requirements we would have to get through those requirements or those processes, public

2:27:09 hearings and no other requirements, but really nicely in there.

2:27:12 So we're proposing moving that section into our chapter eight.

2:27:18 The last one we have is our sports shooting range indoor, where these are all conditions

2:27:24 of a use.

2:27:25 We threw this into our chapter 10, or title 10, chapter 4, conditional use section.

2:27:35 And so in summary, what we're going to have is bench, it is seven items with wireless communication

2:27:49 facilities being a little longer.

2:27:50 But seven items in our quote unquote trunk drawer where we couldn't find a meat place

2:27:56 for them.

2:27:57 But this was the best place that we felt to put these items and what we're keeping were

2:28:06 So we're not adding anything new.

2:28:08 We're keeping or we're clarifying what the intent is

2:28:12 to make sure staff and the public,

2:28:17 the end user is fully aware of and will be on the same page

2:28:21 if they read the regulations.

2:28:29 With that, that concludes my presentation.

2:28:31 If you have any questions.

2:28:34 Any questions for Will on this particular section?

2:28:38 I'm all for taking 21 items and moving that down to seven.

2:28:43 So I think this is good.

2:28:46 Anybody else have any comments?

2:28:50 So you want this in one motion?

2:28:53 Or you want to?

2:28:54 You need a public hearing.

2:28:55 Oh, I'm sorry.

2:28:59 735.

2:29:02 We have two publics here, so.

2:29:04 Chief Justice.

2:29:05 I'm sure Chief Hicks has some comments.

2:29:08 I can't believe he's not in the front row.

2:29:11 Yeah.

2:29:11 I need to want to talk to you, too.

2:29:13 Okay, so we don't have an applicant,

2:29:16 so I will open up the public hearing.

2:29:19 Is there anybody in the public that wishes to say something?

2:29:25 Oh, here we go.

2:29:26 Thank you.

2:29:27 Yeah.

2:29:29 Yeah.

2:29:30 Gear pressure.

2:29:35 Don't forget to state your name.

2:29:37 Yeah, seven, seven, four, midnight sun looped

2:29:40 with al-Zydho.

2:29:42 I think what the staff is doing here is great

2:29:47 and everything in order to be, sounds good to me.

2:29:51 Thank you.

2:29:54 Anybody else that wishes to address City Council?

2:29:57 Yeah, no.

2:29:59 She got you to do that.

2:30:00 OK, I'm going to close the public hearing.

2:30:04 Council wishes, Chris Reed.

2:30:09 Madam Mayor, you can do it in one motion if you'd like.

2:30:12 Thank you.

2:30:13 Chris Reed.

2:30:14 I'll make the motion if we're ready.

2:30:16 I think we are.

2:30:17 I move that we approve the request for a zoning title

2:30:20 amendment to repeal and replace Title 10.

2:30:22 Include items to include all our regulations

2:30:26 pertaining to supplemental regulations

2:30:29 and well-head protection overlay district

2:30:32 as presented tonight.

2:30:33 Thank you, Sherry Vomer.

2:30:34 I will second.

2:30:35 Thank you, motion by Chris Reed,

2:30:37 seconded by Sherry Vomer to approve the request

2:30:40 for a zoning title amendment to repeal and replace Title 10.

2:30:44 Items to include a regulations

2:30:46 pertaining to supplemental regulations

2:30:48 and well-head protection overlaid district.

2:30:52 Any further discussion?

2:30:55 Amy Roek, all vote please.

2:30:58 Jason Brown.

2:30:59 Yes.

2:31:00 Spencer Cutler.

2:31:01 Yes.

2:31:02 Grayson Stone.

2:31:03 Yes.

2:31:04 Sherry Bulmer.

2:31:05 Yes.

2:31:06 Ruth Pierce.

2:31:07 Yes.

2:31:08 Chris Reed.

2:31:09 Yes.

2:31:10 And Craig Hawkins.

2:31:11 Yes.

2:31:12 Thank you.

2:31:13 Motion passes 70-0.

2:31:14 And that is all.

2:31:15 So our meeting is adjourned.

2:31:16 Thank you.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, July 14, 2025. The recording started at 16:58 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:31:30.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    470e5bd16354b433725efa34918fe7710d606487bcf2a422da5c7fdb1b827225
  5. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-11. Not edited, except that 5 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    4c0560ad3fd17859444575df79719469b5c218e773994af235d8eaa3b2cf2a06

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file