OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, October 6, 2025

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: c,e

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording

Transcript

0:01:21 Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the October 6 2025 City Council meeting. I want to confirm

0:01:28 We have a quorum. We have all seven members president chambers first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance

0:01:36 If you wish to join me, please rise

0:01:38 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:01:50 a visible for the injustice for Paul.

0:01:55 Thank you and next on the agenda is our invocation

0:01:58 and we have Paul Thompson.

0:02:00 Welcome, Paul.

0:02:03 Thank you, Madam Mayor.

0:02:05 I'm really disappointed my wife bought me

0:02:08 a pink shirt this year and it looked like

0:02:10 I missed the moment to wear it.

0:02:13 Just wear it all months.

0:02:15 You'll be good.

0:02:16 Okay, all months, all months.

0:02:18 You and me, Paul.

0:02:19 Okay.

0:02:20 Well, thank you for the opportunity to pray as well.

0:02:26 Our Father who art in heaven, hallowed be thy name, we do ask that you would guide the city

0:02:32 council and righteous decisions like you have and bring joy to their duties and let your

0:02:39 truth prevail.

0:02:41 May justice flow like an ever-present stream in the desert.

0:02:47 and hear our prayer for the city's welfare.

0:02:50 We are thankful to you for the strong labor force that supplies the tax base and that it's

0:02:56 matched with the city's finance department that transparently reports the spending with

0:03:02 integrity.

0:03:03 We truly have blessed Twin Falls with this and we count this as a kindness from you.

0:03:11 We ask you to bless the neighborhoods with safe homes where families are free from the

0:03:16 tyranny of wicked men, bless homes where men are respected, and where women are cherished,

0:03:24 and children are counted as blessings from you. We indeed are grateful for the fire department,

0:03:32 which is always ready for any emergency. And we're thankful for the police department,

0:03:37 which serves with respect for minor incidents to serious wicked crimes. And we pray for safety

0:03:45 and for justice in the city.

0:03:48 I ask that you would bless the city

0:03:50 for its diligent attention to sanitary living.

0:03:54 And we are grateful, we do not miss this,

0:03:56 that we have the blessing of clean drinking water.

0:04:01 And when it is disrupted, it is met with swift restoration.

0:04:06 And as well, even tonight, we'll know that

0:04:10 the city gives good attention to the discharge of waste.

0:04:14 And we're so thankful for this.

0:04:17 We often overlook this blessing,

0:04:19 and as well that it is because of the dedicated work

0:04:24 in the public works departments

0:04:26 that we are blessed for this.

0:04:27 And we ask that you would bless these men and women

0:04:30 who serve as deacons to the citizens.

0:04:33 They ensure the safety of all of our water supply

0:04:36 and the removal of waste

0:04:38 and the maintenance of roads and public safety.

0:04:43 And then as well Lord, we're blessed with parks

0:04:45 in a recreation department, where we live with the backdrop of beautiful parks and clean

0:04:50 air and activities that encourage healthy living. We ask that you would bless the volunteer coaches

0:04:56 of the youth league sports, bless the public events with safety, bless the maintenance

0:05:02 crews who build and clean and maintain the parks. And then Lord finally, I ask that you

0:05:09 would bless all of the kind office personnel, if it not for their attention to detail, the

0:05:19 routine, even most likely mundane duties. We would not have such a flourishing community

0:05:27 as we have. So we ask that you would bless the city with more of what honors you. Bless

0:05:33 when falls with city council members such as these, when they ask good questions and make

0:05:41 hard decisions, bless this mayor, bless the city manager in his office, bless the citizens,

0:05:48 and may the fame of our fair city reach the ears of all as a city blessed by her God.

0:05:56 in Jesus name I pray amen. Thank you Paul. Okay next on the agenda I've got a

0:06:05 couple proclamations the first one is a proclamation for 2025 fire prevention

0:06:14 week and that's October 5th to 11th 2025 whereas the City of Twin Falls is

0:06:20 committed to ensuring the safety and security of all those living in the

0:06:25 city of Twin Falls and visiting and whereas fire remains a serious public safety concern

0:06:31 both locally and nationally and the presence of lithium ion batteries in many household

0:06:37 devices introduces unique risk fire risks and whereas most of the electronics used in

0:06:44 home's daily including smart phones, tablets, laptops, power tools, e-bikes, e-scooters and

0:06:50 toys are powered by lithium ion batteries, which if misused, damaged, or improperly charged,

0:06:57 can overheat, start a fire, or explode, and whereas the National Fire Protection Association

0:07:03 reports an increase in battery-related fires, underscoring the need for public education on

0:07:10 the safe use of lithium ion batteries, and whereas residents should follow three key calls

0:07:15 to action by only listed products and charge batteries safely and recycle them responsibly

0:07:23 to prevent battery related fires.

0:07:27 And lithium ion batteries store a large amount of energy in a small space and improper use

0:07:35 such as overcharging using off-brand charges without safety certification or exposing

0:07:40 batteries to damage can result in fire or explosion, and whereas the proper disposal

0:07:47 and recycling of lithium ion batteries helps prevent environmental hazards and reduce fire

0:07:53 risk in the home and community. And whereas the City of Twin Falls' first responders

0:07:58 are dedicated to reducing the occurrence of fires through prevention, safety, education

0:08:04 and community outreach, and whereas the 2025 Fire Prevention Week theme charge into fire

0:08:12 state safety.

0:08:14 Lithium ion batteries in your home serves to remind us of the importance of using charging

0:08:21 and recycling lithium ion batteries safely to reduce the risk of fires in homes and communities.

0:08:28 Therefore, I Ruth Pierce, mayor of the city of Twin Falls, do hereby proclaim the week

0:08:34 of October 5th through 11th 2025 as Fire Prevention Week.

0:08:40 And I believe our fire, Abe, are you gonna accept this?

0:09:26 Madam Mayor, Council, thank you for your continued support

0:09:29 in teaming up with the Twin Falls Fire Department,

0:09:32 also with the Twin Falls County Commissioners

0:09:34 as we proclaim this week Fire Prevention Week every year.

0:09:37 As you know, the title, the theme does change every year

0:09:41 and that is based on data coming in across the country

0:09:45 for these fires. We recently had one this weekend that we believe was also started from a battery

0:09:50 charging, you know, the FMI on battery. So it is affecting us here in Twin Falls. So thank

0:09:55 you for helping us get this safety word out as we charge into fire safety.

0:10:00 Thank you. Thank you, Gabe. Okay. Second proclamation is Breast Cancer Awareness Month, October 2025,

0:10:09 whereas every year too many Americans are impacted by the pain and hardship caused by breast cancer

0:10:15 and whereas breast cancer remains one of the leading causes of cancer-related deaths among women,

0:10:21 the City of Twin Falls proudly honors those who lost their lives to breast cancer and the courageous

0:10:27 survivors who are still fighting it. October is Breast Cancer Awareness Month, as the, excuse me,

0:10:36 whereas October is Breast Cancer Awareness Month, the City of Twin Falls will stand with breast cancer

0:10:42 survivors and raise awareness in advancing research efforts.

0:10:46 Furthermore, we commit ourselves to support survivors,

0:10:49 their loved ones, and organizations

0:10:51 that seek to forge a future free from all cancer.

0:10:55 Therefore, I, Ruth Pierce, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls,

0:10:58 do hereby proclaim October 2025 to be Breast Cancer Awareness

0:11:04 Month.

0:11:05 We encourage citizens, government agencies, private businesses,

0:11:09 non-profit organizations and all others to join in activities that increase awareness of breast

0:11:15 cancer prevention.

0:11:16 I don't know, Danielle, do you want to come down and get that?

0:11:19 I just want to thank everybody, thank the firefighters today for wearing their shirts

0:12:07 and everybody you can wear pink all month, like I said.

0:12:11 So thank you.

0:12:13 Okay, next on the agenda is our consent calendar.

0:12:17 Council wishes.

0:12:18 Move to approve.

0:12:20 Thank you.

0:12:21 Do I have a second?

0:12:22 Second.

0:12:23 Thank you.

0:12:24 Motion by Sherry Volmer, seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the consent calendar as written.

0:12:29 Amy Rochael Rochael, please.

0:12:32 Ruth Pierce.

0:12:33 Yes.

0:12:34 Chris Reed.

0:12:35 Yes.

0:12:36 Craig Hawkins.

0:12:37 Jason Brown.

0:12:38 Spencer Cutler.

0:12:39 Yes.

0:12:40 Sherry Volmer.

0:12:41 Yes.

0:12:42 And Grayson Stone.

0:12:43 Yes.

0:12:44 Thank you.

0:12:45 Motion passes 7-0.

0:12:46 Okay.

0:12:47 So we have two presentations tonight.

0:12:47 The first one is the presentation on Southern Idaho economic development organization and

0:12:53 we have their executive director, Jan Rogers.

0:12:56 You're welcome up to the podium, Jan.

0:12:59 I think the mic might still be on.

0:13:01 Is the green light on?

0:13:04 No.

0:13:05 No.

0:13:06 There it is.

0:13:07 Welcome.

0:13:08 Well, thank you.

0:13:09 And Madam Mayor and Council, I'm excited to stand here and give you guys an update on what's

0:13:16 It's happening at Southern Idaho Economic Development Organization.

0:13:20 You know, next year, June 30th, we will be celebrating our 25th anniversary, if you can

0:13:25 believe that.

0:13:26 We've had quite a ride.

0:13:28 And this year, we're starting, in fact, this month, we're starting our fourth year as an

0:13:34 independent 501c3 organization.

0:13:36 Prior to that, we were under the auspices of the college, so we're kind of excited.

0:13:43 We've had a really good run for the last few years.

0:13:46 We have nine board members, three from the cities,

0:13:49 representing the cities and counties,

0:13:51 three representing Business Plus,

0:13:53 and three representing CSI.

0:13:56 So it's a very tight board,

0:13:59 and moving forward, and they're committed to stay on

0:14:04 until we get through the transition,

0:14:06 which we are financially stable,

0:14:09 but we are currently looking for a deputy director

0:14:13 to go through a transition, hopefully by the end of June of next year will be through the

0:14:23 initial transition.

0:14:25 I will step down at that point and then but remain a part of the organization to continue

0:14:30 that for as long as needed.

0:14:34 So fingers crossed we find just the perfect person come in and take over this amazing organization.

0:14:44 Since 2022, we've really seen in this region really strong growth, we have 10 companies,

0:14:53 either business attraction or expansion, the Travani's expansion happening this year will

0:15:01 generate approximately $1.8 billion since 2022, which is an amazing number.

0:15:08 I remember it took us almost in years to get to a billion dollars.

0:15:14 So in two years, we've done 1.8 billion and that's direct.

0:15:19 We've also created approximately 1450 direct jobs.

0:15:25 So that doesn't include any of the indirect PAPX and or jobs,

0:15:30 which is substantial.

0:15:32 But according to IDOL, the Department of Labor,

0:15:36 The workforce itself has grown in that period of time by 5,600 workers, so we are keeping

0:15:43 up with the growth.

0:15:47 If you ask me how, I don't know, but we are, so it's kind of exciting.

0:15:52 It seems as if we bring them, they will come.

0:15:55 We've never missed an initial ramp, or a full ramp of any company that we've recruited or

0:16:00 expanded here in the region.

0:16:03 So while we're still focused on attracting and retaining large industrial commercial projects,

0:16:10 the organization's really evolved its strategy to include a fairly aggressive foreign direct

0:16:16 investment program.

0:16:19 And we sort of stumbled into that, but we are taking a more holistic approach to building

0:16:27 these relationships internationally.

0:16:30 Early communities, our regions, our states, our size, when they're working in foreign direct

0:16:37 and best with a foreign direct investment, they're really going after projects, in most

0:16:42 cases large projects.

0:16:45 We're taking a different approach.

0:16:47 We have been leading the delegation to select USA, which is the premier foreign direct investment

0:16:56 conference that is put on by the US Department of Commerce for the last three

0:17:01 years when I say we at Southern Idaho, our organization. The state has been a

0:17:08 part of that but they are not leading it. So, but interestingly, so by building these

0:17:17 relationships, let me just tell you a little bit about the approach. We are

0:17:21 obviously going after new business. That's, you know, our primary goal always. But we are

0:17:27 also building relationships to, for the possibility of exchange. We met with Frandi, which is the

0:17:37 oldest culinary school in France, and we are connecting them with the CSI culinary program

0:17:44 to give our kids faculty the opportunity to work in France

0:17:49 with their program and vice versa.

0:17:52 So that's an opportunity that we're pursuing.

0:17:56 We've also pursuing with the University of Idaho

0:18:00 a memorandum of understanding with the University of Burgundy,

0:18:04 both in the ag and engineering fields, again,

0:18:06 for faculty and students for an exchange.

0:18:10 for them to achieve a master's, they have to actually leave the country and go to another country

0:18:20 and do at least three months with either a business and or a university. So this is, we're hoping that

0:18:27 this exchange and that MOU is expected to happen this year still. We are also looking at a sister

0:18:35 intercity relationship with Twin Falls, business expansion into France for our companies in Europe,

0:18:46 for southern Idaho companies as well as business attraction to southern Idaho, and building

0:18:50 these relationships with regional economic development organizations in France.

0:18:55 So it's really relationship based, but as you can see it's a more holistic approach.

0:19:01 It's not just one-sided, and with that, we've had a lot of organic opportunities happen.

0:19:10 We have, through an opportunity when we were at SelectUSA, we met with the company, well,

0:19:17 actually we met with business friends who indicated that we might be one of three cities, that

0:19:26 they were going to bring 10 French companies to a delegation of 10 French companies to three

0:19:32 cities in the U.S. We were a contender for that. Those cities were Chicago, Minneapolis,

0:19:38 and Twin Falls, Idaho, so we got it. And that has led to many more opportunities. So pretty

0:19:46 exciting. That led us to, for us to present the following year in Paris to 100 French

0:19:54 And to do that, we had to take a company, a French company from Idaho, to also share

0:20:02 and how is it to do business in Idaho.

0:20:07 That company was like Talis.

0:20:08 They sent their senior vice president to Tutor Horn, which we didn't know at the time,

0:20:15 was that their facility in Nampa is their largest facility in North America.

0:20:24 So that was something we found out, they're not our client,

0:20:28 they're not our business, but they were horrific

0:20:31 and really took our horn over there.

0:20:35 So that opportunity is still moving forward with Pernandi,

0:20:39 as I said, we're looking at an opportunity for CSI

0:20:44 to visit with them next year in 2026.

0:20:49 While we were there presenting our first trip over there, while we were presenting not only

0:20:59 to those French companies with business trends, but we also met, as again, with the University

0:21:03 of Burgundy, an inoculum plus, which is a startup bio-nutrient company, and their regional

0:21:10 economic development organization.

0:21:12 This year, we received an introduction to a company also considering expanding to the

0:21:20 U.S. and potato equipment manufacturer in January by business France.

0:21:28 So again, this was an opportunity we wouldn't have had but for the fact that we have been

0:21:32 attending SelectUSA.

0:21:35 So this is interesting.

0:21:37 This past Friday, I met with their CEO and two others to discuss opportunities in Idaho

0:21:43 and specifically in Southern Idaho.

0:21:46 We're excited to work with Project Sun King, so as you hear that as we move forward, you'll

0:21:52 know that that's the new French company that's looking, of course, at us because we are the

0:21:58 potato state and to find the right location and to start their expansion to the U.S.

0:22:06 currently applying for, as a subsidiary in the U.S. and then further more. So we also,

0:22:15 I also had the Department of Commerce, Adam Boyer, join us for that conversation. So,

0:22:23 I mean, I was completely blown away that, you know, they're ready to go. So we are too.

0:22:32 This year, we led two delegations to France.

0:22:40 The first one was to both Dijon and Ren.

0:22:44 And in Dijon, we took Redox, the bio-nutrient company,

0:22:51 and Burling with us.

0:22:55 To me, with this new startup, they

0:22:58 were interested in having a conversation with them.

0:23:01 What we didn't know at the time was that they were also looking for a co-op, and they've

0:23:08 been trying to get into the European market for quite a while.

0:23:11 To do that with the bio-nudrine, you have to test your product in Europe.

0:23:15 And to do that, you have to be connected to a co-op.

0:23:19 And at that event, they were introduced to the two of the largest co-ops in the region.

0:23:24 They are now doing business with them, so they are going to be able to test their product

0:23:30 in Europe, in France, and when that is done, it will open up the entire European market

0:23:39 for this company. So it's a but for the opportunity that we were able to take them and make these

0:23:45 introductions this opportunity for them wouldn't have happened. So that's kind of exciting.

0:23:51 So we're looking at bringing companies here and we're helping our companies, excuse me,

0:23:56 expand into Europe. So again, that was in April. In September, we, just this past month,

0:24:07 we were again in REN for a number of reasons, but for space, which is their largest ag show

0:24:16 in France. And at that show, we, Department of Commerce, had a booth and we invited four

0:24:24 of our southern Idaho companies to join us.

0:24:27 So that's HMI, Hamilton, manufacturing,

0:24:31 redox, reverence, and Bowda IQ.

0:24:35 And all had made fantastic contacts while they were there

0:24:40 and really excited about the opportunity.

0:24:43 And we were excited that we were able

0:24:45 to give them that opportunity.

0:24:47 Because, but for that, they wouldn't have had,

0:24:51 it's a quite expensive show to go to,

0:24:53 So we wouldn't have had the opportunity, so we're kind of excited that that worked out as well as it did.

0:24:58 And because Redox joined us for both visits, they now have also made contact with co-ops in RIN,

0:25:10 and so their businesses continuing to expand.

0:25:14 So again, but these are the but for opportunities that we're allowing.

0:25:19 allowing the lieutenant governor joined us on our both our visits this year to

0:25:25 France along with Mark Skinner who is the CEO of the University of Idaho and Idaho

0:25:30 Falls to continue to work with the University of Burgundy, MOU. We are also

0:25:39 exploring as I said a sister city relationship with St. Rior. It's in

0:25:46 Brittany with Twin Falls. We received word that that community is interested in

0:25:52 considering the relationship so there's more to come on that. We opened also an

0:25:59 Idaho Business Development Office and ran at the World Trade Center. This is the

0:26:05 very first office that Idaho has had in Europe ever and that is with our with the

0:26:11 to do is consult at Daniel Dozier.

0:26:14 So it was a pretty exciting opportunity.

0:26:18 It's a new experience for the state of Idaho,

0:26:22 and of course, for us.

0:26:23 But again, we put a pin in it.

0:26:26 We have an address in Europe, and it's in Renn, France.

0:26:30 So the state, at our request, also joined case,

0:26:34 which is the Council for American States in Europe.

0:26:38 So that's going to open up other opportunities.

0:26:40 It just so happens that our consultant, Daniel Dozier,

0:26:44 sits on their board of directors as their treasurer,

0:26:46 so that's another organic moment for us.

0:26:54 The other thing that I really wanted to accomplish

0:26:57 on our first visit in April,

0:26:59 we met with a company,

0:27:00 they're a dairy ingredient distributor,

0:27:04 and for the agri-food industry,

0:27:08 and they're headquartered in RIN,

0:27:12 but they also have offices in Shanghai and in South America.

0:27:16 There is no dot on North America for this company,

0:27:21 but they are looking at entering our market.

0:27:24 And so my goal this time in September

0:27:30 was to get a date to get their CEO to come to Idaho

0:27:36 because I'm convinced if they come here

0:27:38 and they meet with our dairy folks,

0:27:41 that we will be that dot in North America.

0:27:45 And so I sent Daniel and the lieutenant governor

0:27:50 to make that opportunity happen.

0:27:52 And as I'm gonna sit here and say,

0:27:56 I'm pretty excited about it,

0:27:58 because not only do we have a pin in it,

0:28:01 April 22nd next year, that company,

0:28:05 He is also a member of the World Trade Center, so they're having an event here in the U.S.,

0:28:15 and then they will be coming here April 22nd to Idaho to meet with our dairy people.

0:28:21 So that's a pretty exciting opportunity.

0:28:23 And I'm convinced if we get a dot in it, I'm going to be really, really excited if we're

0:28:27 the dot in North America.

0:28:32 So I think I'm going to stop there and open up for any questions.

0:28:35 I want to thank you and the city for all your continued support over these many years.

0:28:42 So with that, I didn't answer any questions.

0:28:45 Any questions for Jan?

0:28:48 Chris?

0:28:49 I don't have a question, but thank you for everything you're doing.

0:28:52 I know that you and your team there and the board has been working extremely hard, so thank

0:28:59 you for everything you do for Southern Idaho.

0:29:02 Thank you.

0:29:04 Anybody else?

0:29:05 Okay. Thank you, Jim. Thank you. Okay. Next item on the agenda is also a presentation.

0:29:16 It's a presentation of the sanitation request for proposal RFPs for solid waste and recycling

0:29:23 services and we have our CFO Briana Howard. Welcome Briana. Good evening, Mayor and Council.

0:29:32 So I get to present to you tonight the request for proposals for our sanitation contract.

0:29:38 sanitation contract with PSI if you'll remember ends December of 2026. The reason

0:29:44 why we are bringing this to you a year in advance is because we want to allow

0:29:48 plenty of opportunity for a proposal to capitalize if necessary. Our goal is to

0:29:57 have a firm selected by mid-January and to have a contract finalized then. Some key

0:30:04 points of interest on the RFP. We did quite a bit of work on this RFP trying

0:30:09 to analyze what are we looking for, what do we need, and maybe some significant details

0:30:15 or items that we would like in the future.

0:30:18 If you'll note on this RFP, we've split it out into a couple of different things.

0:30:24 We are now trying to get a definitive value on, question ends raise, definitive value on

0:30:32 our recycling.

0:30:33 So as you know, we've come to you many times talking about frustration of sorts that we

0:30:39 can't just pull that number out. We want to be able to give you the information so

0:30:43 that you can make a decision saying this is what we want to provide to our

0:30:47 citizens, our residents. Also of note,

0:30:51 when we were going through this process,

0:30:55 we asked Sean, who's here and can answer any questions as well,

0:30:59 what his thoughts were on the unlimited

0:31:03 bins. So the bags that you have off the side,

0:31:07 the cards, the containers that you do personally, and I thought it was

0:31:12 interesting that he said, him and his team don't see that anybody are really

0:31:18 using those extra cards. I will give you a picture, Rachel, if you can switch over.

0:31:23 Sean just took this a couple of days ago to show just alleys where we go up and

0:31:32 down the alleys and what are there and what he has said is typically we don't

0:31:36 actually use those those extra carts. He doesn't see citizens putting those extra

0:31:41 bags or carts out. What will be important to analyze later is what about leaves. So

0:31:48 we don't know, we know people are going to do some fall cleaning, etc. I think it's

0:31:52 good to analyze what those numbers are, how much we're going to charge each

0:31:57 resident on a monthly basis for those extra leaves. I think at that point in

0:32:01 time we can determine if this is a necessity that we want to pay for by year

0:32:05 or if we want to build it into as an extra bin.

0:32:09 So more knowledge is going to be beneficial going forward.

0:32:14 In this RFP, we're maintaining all of the normal stuff

0:32:17 that we want going forward.

0:32:20 We have the weekly solid waste,

0:32:22 potential at biweekly recycling,

0:32:23 if we decide to do that,

0:32:25 there's still a bulk in yard waste,

0:32:27 as well as ADA compliance.

0:32:30 So our timeline going forward,

0:32:32 after we get some discussion from you,

0:32:34 is to publish on November 6th and 13th with the bids opening in November and to be immediately

0:32:41 determined in 2026. So at this point there's no action item here. I'm just presenting this

0:32:48 to you so that you can look it over and let me know if there was something else that you were

0:32:52 expecting or would like in this RFP before we go forward. And with that I stand for.

0:33:01 So I do have one question. Is that timeframe typical print on the 6th and the 13th and then a week later open the bids?

0:33:09 Is that a pretty typical seems like a quick turnaround for if it's published for somebody to pull together a big?

0:33:16 bid I was just curious

0:33:19 The RFP will be posted on November 20th the bids will be due

0:33:28 He said posted 6th and 13th and 13th to on the 20th. It just seemed like a short time frame

0:33:35 And I'm, but I don't know if that's typical.

0:33:38 This is what we had the last time it was published.

0:33:40 This was before we had the contract with PS and I.

0:33:43 I'll let you state if you have some more.

0:33:45 Yeah, so that's the minimum that we would want to go forward with.

0:33:48 And we can certainly increase that.

0:33:53 That there wouldn't be any issue with that. One of the things that we were striving to do and it just requires all of our timeline is we wanted to have.

0:34:01 this council's elect

0:34:04 who the next vendor would be with a

0:34:08 Contract that had been negotiated and cleared

0:34:11 And that's important because we want to make sure that should there be a change that the next firm has

0:34:18 That full calendar year to capitalize because they'll respond they'll be responsible for the garbage bins

0:34:23 They'll be responsible for the place the location the trucks

0:34:27 That's going to be a pretty significant lift I would imagine

0:34:30 So we wanted to give them enough time.

0:34:32 We could creep that decision

0:34:34 into towards closer to the end of December.

0:34:39 If the council felt that a longer window of time

0:34:43 was necessary, contract negotiations shouldn't be hard

0:34:49 or in depth because we're asking for all

0:34:51 of their price proposals on the front end.

0:34:54 I was just wondering whether we could back it up a month

0:34:58 do it like the 30th and the 6th and then forbid openings on the 20th but I don't know how fast

0:35:04 you can get. I mean this looks pretty final to me. It's ready to go. We've already gone to

0:35:09 pre six etc so we could we could back it up and we could have it we just have to have it we have

0:35:14 to be able to submit it to the Times News on the Thursday before to get it on the Monday on their

0:35:19 date so we could back it up. And I I'm just wondering it's such a large contract and you guys

0:35:25 no better than I do but it just seems like if I had an opportunity to bid on

0:35:30 something that is a major contract I would hope that I'd have more than a week

0:35:34 or so to throw something together but I don't know how everybody else feels.

0:35:40 There's certainly enough time for us to begin that process earlier and still hit

0:35:46 the November 20th date so I think that's a great suggestion and we will look at

0:35:50 Okay. Anybody else have anything to add? Sorry. I hog that. Do we have any

0:35:57 indications? Sorry, Mayor. I'll do. Do we have any indication of who else other

0:36:02 than PSI may might be interested in our service and serving the city? Western

0:36:08 waste is is indicated. I think they're now doing business as

0:36:12 republic. So and then in the past we've also had how to state corporations submit

0:36:20 bids and proposals so we believe that there will be a few for the council to consider and choose from.

0:36:26 I think Brianna stated this by one to reiterate it. The question of the value of recycling

0:36:34 to the community in comparison to the cost to our resident is going to be one of those primary

0:36:40 considerations moving forward. Like Brianna said, if we do continue to move forward with the recycling

0:36:46 component, we are going to insist in the contract that that cost be separated, because right

0:36:53 now as a combined rate, it's really hard for us to understand without looking at other entities,

0:37:00 the true cost of the recycling program in comparison to the benefits, so we want to

0:37:03 be able to better understand the ROI.

0:37:06 If you look at surrounding cities, our costs seems to be higher than some surrounding cities,

0:37:11 and so by breaking out these couple of pieces, it'll give us a lot more information to analyze

0:37:15 what we're passing off onto our residents and what we want to do.

0:37:20 Perfect.

0:37:20 Good street.

0:37:21 I think this is fantastic.

0:37:23 I'm excited to see what comes back to just, well,

0:37:28 as I was reading through this some things, some thoughts,

0:37:31 it would really be nice for, in this RFP, allowing them

0:37:35 to tell us what they're doing as well.

0:37:39 I've lived in communities.

0:37:40 For example, leaf pickup wasn't a thing.

0:37:44 They had a leaf truck where there was a vacuum and you just pushed it into the, into your

0:37:49 curb and they drove on by and, and sucked it all up and off they went.

0:37:53 It was fantastic.

0:37:54 I didn't have the bag leaves.

0:37:56 So those types of things lived in another community where they would have a massive,

0:38:02 it was for large bulk stuff and twice a year it was kind of like your spring cleaning.

0:38:07 This neighborhood would have a huge dumpster and you could go and throw those things in

0:38:11 there.

0:38:12 that normally we don't think of because we've never done that in this community. I

0:38:16 would love to hear from them as well in this.

0:38:19 Great. Jason. Yeah I'd like to so under the premise of we think we're gonna get

0:38:27 some more or have some people bid I think opening up that time frame allows them to

0:38:34 think through even some of the things that Chris has done or mentioned to maybe

0:38:40 be proposed something that's a little bit of an area, but I think giving them more time

0:38:46 to really look through that, the request and provide a good bid for the city a little bit

0:38:54 more time, a bigger window, I think it would be appreciated.

0:38:59 Great. Anybody else? Grayson, did you have something?

0:39:06 Oh yeah, thank you, Madam Mayor. I would kind of push back on that. I like the tighter

0:39:09 time window because anybody that we want to contract with needs to be on their A-game.

0:39:13 Typically, those people are able to procure those numbers quicker and on the spot.

0:39:21 So I don't, I wouldn't necessarily be a fan of opening the window wide open.

0:39:26 So.

0:39:28 Anything else you need from us?

0:39:34 That's good.

0:39:35 Okay.

0:39:37 Got it?

0:39:39 Okay.

0:39:40 So that is it for items of consideration.

0:39:44 The next item is our general public input.

0:39:47 time for anybody in the audience who wishes to address City Council on City

0:39:52 Business, anything that is not related to personnel and was not on today's agenda.

0:39:58 Is there anybody out there that wishes to address City Council tonight?

0:40:04 Hey, seeing no one, Advisory Board reports, anything from good of the program here?

0:40:16 Anything from City Manager?

0:40:18 So next week.

0:40:19 I'm sorry.

0:40:20 I just wanted to mention the AIC's district meeting is on 23rd in Verde.

0:40:24 I really encourage everybody to attend that with a can.

0:40:28 Thank you.

0:40:29 Go ahead, Travis.

0:40:33 Just really quick, just next week, agenda will be one item in which I believe that the

0:40:40 members of the golf committee will be coming forward and presenting their results, we hope.

0:40:48 And then after that, we'll be moving into a series of workshops.

0:40:51 So we'll start in here, we'll move into the overflow room, and we'll continue the dialogue

0:40:57 on a series of workshops and gauging the Council's opinion on a few different issues.

0:41:04 And then we will not be meeting on the 20th.

0:41:07 Great.

0:41:08 Thank you.

0:41:09 Okay.

0:41:10 So next on the agenda is an executive session, excuse me, a request to adjourn to executive

0:41:18 session pursuant to Idaho Code Section 742061c to acquire interest in real property not owned

0:41:26 by a public agency and e to consider preliminary negotiations involving matters of trade or

0:41:33 commerce in which the governing body is in competition with governing bodies in other

0:41:38 states or nations.

0:41:41 So moved.

0:41:42 Thank you.

0:41:43 Do I have a second?

0:41:44 Second.

0:41:45 Motion by Chris Reed.

0:41:46 Jason Brown to move into executive session under I don't code section 74 206 1c and

0:41:54 e Rachel Rocha please yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes

0:42:09 yes yes thank you motion passes 70-0 just to let everybody know we won't be back

0:42:14 in chambers of so meeting is adjourned. Thank you.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, October 6, 2025. The recording started at 16:58 by the recorder's clock and runs 00:42:20.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    834deedf8e321ef0d7910bbc372507ca133728b00c2a3e835fb7304f93e3e47d
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a ea2c8d12fef2ad9b9a7ef0f9a2b123c0b898a55f4aeff9ecbeb2d8d18a227294
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-11. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    a6270032a8b1d38e05f0c6116604b23c011f2830dce7a78fd0b47c55db561613

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file