OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

EX-C03-1

Request letter

City of Twin Falls

View the document here · 5 pages

Record date
Not dated
Source
PRR #4729
Record type
Records Requests and Agency Responses
Pages used
all (5)
Supports findings
E-22 The City enforces the requester-information rule on some requests and not others

Chain of custody

  1. Obtained. Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4729. Request filed 2026-08 (approx.); the City's response: Produced HR documents (request log).
  2. As received. SHA-256 of the file exactly as the agency released it:
    9c158cbb9db42842ff8689e3fc87dabe6d54e2ea6b6df3e010fbb14cf2c1a6e8
  3. Changes for posting.
    • Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed
  4. Posted copy. SHA-256 of the file you download here, checked against our index on every build:
    8342fc36316c12d9ee119e460d68311bfc85f368f1f1cae4416904cc7290779c

The original as received is kept unaltered. Anyone holding the agency's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. How to verify a file · Chain of custody for every record (CSV)

Document text (read by machine for search, and often imperfect for scans and handwriting; the file is the record)
RE: Public Records Request Pursuant to Idaho Code § 74-101 et seq. 
– Senior Executive Leadership Compensation Records (FY 2020–21 
through FY 2025–26)
I. Statutory Authority and Basis for Request
Pursuant to the Idaho Public Records Act, Idaho Code § 74-101 et seq., the 
undersigned, a member of the public and a resident of Twin Falls, Idaho, 
hereby submits this formal written request to inspect and obtain copies of 
public records in the custody or control of the City of Twin Falls. This 
request is made in an individual capacity as a taxpayer and concerned 
citizen and is not made for any commercial purpose. The City is respectfully 
requested to treat this correspondence as a formal public records request 
requiring a timely response in accordance with applicable law.
II. Records Requested
I hereby request all public records — including but not limited to 
documents, data, agreements, resolutions, correspondence, and 
electronically stored information — for the period of October 1, 2020 
through September 30, 2026 (Fiscal Years 2020–21 through 2025–
26, inclusive), pertaining to the compensation, benefits, and employment 
terms of each of the following named City of Twin Falls employees 
(hereinafter, "the Named Employees"):
● Travis Rothweiler, City Manager
● Gretchen Scott, Deputy City Manager
● Mitch Humble, Deputy City Manager
● Breanna Howard, Chief Financial Officer
● Kristen Kohntopp, Human Resources Director
● Shawn Barigar, Economic Development Director
For each of the Named Employees individually, the requestor seeks all 
records related to the following categories:
1. (a) Base Salary and Salary History: All records reflecting base 
salary and any changes thereto during the request period, including 
but not limited to step increases, merit increases, cost-of-living 
adjustments (COLA), and compression adjustments, together with the 
effective dates and any documentation supporting or authorizing each 
change.
2. (b) Supplemental Compensation: All records reflecting any and all 
forms of supplemental compensation provided in addition to base 
salary, including but not limited to bonuses, performance pay, 
incentive pay, longevity pay, and any one-time or recurring stipends of 
any nature.
3. (c) Employment Contracts and Agreements: All employment 
contracts, offer letters, employment agreements, and any 
amendments, addenda, memoranda of understanding, or side letters 
thereto, reflecting the terms and conditions of each Named 
Employee's employment with the City.
4. (d) Above-Range or Exception Compensation: Any records 
reflecting salary or compensation set above the standard pay grade or 
classification range applicable to the Named Employee's position, 
including any written justification, administrative authorization, or 
City Council authorization for such exceptions or deviations from 
standard pay classification schedules.
5. (e) Non-Standard Leave and PTO Benefits: All records reflecting 
any extra, enhanced, or supplemental paid time off (PTO), vacation 
accrual rates above standard policy, vacation bank balances awarded 
outside standard policy, administrative leave with pay, or any other 
non-standard leave benefits negotiated, awarded, or granted to any of 
the Named Employees.
6. (f) Fringe Benefits and Perquisites: All records reflecting vehicle 
allowances, housing allowances, cell phone allowances, technology 
stipends, deferred compensation contributions (including but not 
limited to PERSI supplemental plans and 457(b) contributions made 
by the City on behalf of the employee), and any other fringe benefits 
or perquisites provided beyond the standard City employee benefits 
package.
7. (g) City Council Authorizations: Any City Council resolutions, 
ordinances, meeting minutes excerpts, or executive session 
summaries (to the extent not otherwise exempt from disclosure under 
Idaho Code § 74-206) that authorized, approved, or memorialized any 
compensation, bonus, benefit, or benefit adjustment for any of the 
Named Employees.
III. Format of Production
The requestor seeks all responsive records in electronic format — 
preferably PDF or native electronic format — delivered electronically via 
email or secure download link.
IV. Statutory Response Deadline
I respectfully remind the City that Idaho Code § 74-103 requires the public 
records custodian to respond to this request within three (3) business 
days of receipt. That response must, at minimum: (1) produce the requested 
records; (2) deny the request in whole or in part with a specific statutory 
basis for the denial; or (3) provide a reasonable, good-faith estimate of the 
time required for production if the volume or nature of the records 
necessitates additional time to compile. I expect the City's strict and timely 
compliance with this statutory obligation and respectfully request that the 
City acknowledge receipt of this request in writing at its earliest 
opportunity.
V. Request for Fee Waiver
The requestor is aware that, pursuant to Idaho Code § 74-102(9), the City 
may assess a charge for personnel time spent locating, compiling, and 
reviewing responsive records beyond the initial two (2) hours, which must 
be provided at no charge. The requestor respectfully requests that, before 
incurring any billable personnel time beyond that two-hour threshold, the 
City provide advance written notice that it anticipates the threshold will be 
exceeded. The requestor further requests a reasonable opportunity to 
narrow or prioritize the scope of this request before any such charges are 
incurred, so as to minimize burden on both parties.
Additionally, the requestor asks that the custodian exercise the discretion 
afforded under Idaho Code § 74-102(9) and waive any applicable personnel-
time charges in connection with this request. This request concerns the 
compensation and employment terms of senior public officials compensated 
entirely with taxpayer funds. Disclosure of the requested records is 
unambiguously in the public interest — it bears directly on the stewardship 
of public resources and public understanding of government operations — 
and is made solely in the capacity of a private citizen and taxpayer, with no 
commercial purpose. Waiver of fees is fully warranted on these grounds.
VI. Notice Regarding Claimed Exemptions
In the event that the City determines that any portion of the records 
requested herein is subject to a statutory exemption and will be withheld in 
whole or in part, I request that the City provide the following in connection 
with each withheld or partially withheld record:
8. A specific citation to the applicable statutory exemption under the 
Idaho Public Records Act or other governing law upon which the City 
relies in withholding the record;
9. A brief description of the nature and subject matter of the withheld 
record sufficient to allow me to assess whether the claimed exemption 
is properly applicable; and
10.All non-exempt portions of any partially exempt record, produced in 
redacted form with the exempt portions clearly indicated.
I reserve all rights to challenge any exemption claims that I believe to be 
improper or overbroad.
VII. Closing
Thank you for your attention to this request. The requestor has endeavored 
to make the scope as clear and specific as possible to facilitate efficient and 
complete production.
The requestor is available to clarify any aspect of this request or to discuss 
the most practical means of production in order to facilitate an efficient 
response.
I look forward to the City's timely response in accordance with the Idaho 
Public Records Act.