EX-C06-2
Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments)
City of Twin Falls
View the document here · 17 pages
- Record date
- Not dated
- Source
- PRR #4940
- Record type
- Records Requests and Agency Responses
- Pages used
- all (6); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (2); all (2); all (2)
- Supports findings
- E-14 PRR #4814/#4940: Finance request answered with HR payroll registers; AP reimbursements not produced
E-20 Request #4940 unanswered for more than 20 working days - deemed denied by law - Notes
- Each email rendered to PDF from the received message; bookmarks give date/sender/subject. Requester signature images omitted.
- Redaction
- 3 area(s) redacted
Chain of custody
- Obtained. Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4940. Request filed 2026-10-05; the City's response: No response after 26 working days as of Nov 10 (deemed denied Oct 20); five follow-ups unanswered (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the file exactly as the agency released it:
087e289cdf586d0ee0cdecf5e9715ffb79255da186ae68bdb21272a46521d264
0f7154adb7cacd16af03cb5be6e8d9fd079697c5b149691776cc09d3738be863
f9128760a760d1e11d0127421005e5e8ed34d6b616465b992b2d85044a87b57d
011a9968a863cb90d313d7d7739cf0e27659d92c15bbfbeca014dbc0306a528c
e88f0fe6a4052a3f7441a14d388dd5a04c1238a99a3546a4326ceaaf728b2a21
91398c0ea43ae0cedc4da8eb9e3bffd7f3f2da76e1774b1cc9f22ba0618f7ef6
8d1aaa71549f6c94850af13e0a2a218dee708d43da34ac9e49501c437662e755
4dad93744eae82f3e172ef925dc41ecb5a8c573948888cf162023bc1f4a33d87
1c1802f6e5b5c2a8522a5f5ce4fa5db458501d42202505d0b8892e34902595b6 - Changes for posting.
- Combined from 9 files as released
- Redacted: 3 area(s) redacted
- Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed
- Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 14, 15, 16, 17); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable
- Posted copy. SHA-256 of the file you download here, checked against our index on every build:
eedc6841665fef2f50db10b0d729252c4667a9211c44c18f52482e0188613ade
The original as received is kept unaltered. Anyone holding the agency's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. How to verify a file · Chain of custody for every record (CSV)
Document text (read by machine for search, and often imperfect for scans and handwriting; the file is the record)
City of Twin Falls Public Records Request Requestor Information Please list your information here. Include your request details in the space provided below. Requestor First Name * Requestor Last Name * Requestor Address 1 * Requestor Address 2 Requestor City * Requestor State * Requestor ZIP Code * Requestor Phone Number * Requestor E-mail * Type of Request * Personal Commercial Legal Request Details * If you are requesting multiple records, please attach your list below. If you do not have a case/event/citation number, please include enough information to identify the records you want. If your request is for multiple items, it may be subject to fees for preparation. We have records for the Twin Falls Police Department (city, not county) only. SECTION 1 — STATUTORY DEFICIENCY MEMORANDUM (PRR #4814) To: City ClerkCity of Twin Falls203 Main Ave. ETwin Falls, ID 83301 Subject: Statutory Deficiency Memorandum – Public Records Request #4814 This memorandum documents statutory deficiencies in the City’s response to Public Records Request #4814. It is provided to establish a clear record of non‑compliance with Idaho’s Public Records Act and to support the attached follow‑up request directed to the Finance Department. 1. Failure to Conduct a Complete Search (Idaho Code § 74‑102(1)) Idaho Code § 74‑102(1) requires agencies to conduct a search reasonably calculated to locate all responsive records. The City’s response to PRR #4814 did not include: All compensation records All pay codes Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. All leave payouts All vacation sellback entries All non‑payroll payments All reimbursements All vendor‑based payments All deferred compensation records All expenditure records maintained by Finance These omissions demonstrate that a complete search was not conducted. 2. Prior Request Explicitly Required a Finance‑Department Search PRR #4814 explicitly stated that the requested records were to be obtained from the Finance Department, because the records sought included: Compensation expenditures Reimbursements Vendor payments Accounts‑payable disbursements Deferred compensation contributions Other non‑payroll financial transactions Despite this clear instruction, the City’s response relied solely on HR‑maintained records, which do not contain the full financial history of payments made to or on behalf of the listed employees. Insertable Paragraph (Your Requested Addition) In addition, the City’s response to PRR #4814 acknowledged that the request “should have been directed to Finance,” yet the records provided were still limited to HR‑maintained materials. This confirms that the City understood the scope of the request and recognized that Finance was the correct department to conduct the search, but nevertheless did not obtain or produce any Finance‑system records. Because Finance maintains the City’s official expenditure, vendor, reimbursement, and payroll disbursement systems, the failure to obtain records from Finance — despite acknowledging that Finance should have been involved — constitutes a clear statutory deficiency under Idaho Code § 74‑102. 3. Failure to Search All Record Systems Likely to Contain Responsive Documents (Idaho Code § 74‑102(1)) The City did not search: The Finance/accounting system The vendor/AP system The reimbursement system The deferred compensation disbursement system Archived or legacy Finance systems These systems contain the official record of: Vendor payments Travel reimbursements Expense reimbursements Non‑payroll disbursements Deferred compensation contributions Leave payouts Vacation sellback payments All financial transactions involving City employees A search limited to HR records does not satisfy the statutory requirement. 4. Improper Statement That Records Were “Not Available” (Idaho Code § 74‑103(4)) The City stated that certain compensation information was “not available.”Under Idaho Code § 74‑103(4), if records are withheld or do not exist, the agency must: Identify the statutory exemption relied upon, or State that the record does not exist after a reasonable search, and Provide the name and title of the person making the determination. The City did not: Identify any exemption State that the records do not exist Demonstrate that a reasonable search was conducted Provide the name or title of the person making the determination Therefore, the response does not comply with § 74‑103(4). 5. Failure to Provide Records Maintained in Finance Systems The City’s Finance Department maintains: Payroll registers Accounts‑payable registers Vendor payment records Reimbursement records Deferred compensation records Check registers Expenditure logs Financial system pay code histories None of these records were provided in response to PRR #4814, despite being directly responsive. This constitutes a statutory deficiency. 6. Impact of Deficiencies Because the City did not provide: All compensation records All non‑payroll payments All reimbursement records All vendor‑based payments All leave payout records All vacation sellback records All deferred compensation records …the response to PRR #4814 is incomplete and does not comply with Idaho’s Public Records Act. The attached follow‑up request is therefore directed specifically to the Finance Department, which maintains the official systems necessary to produce a complete response. 7. Notice of Potential Escalation If the City’s response to the attached follow‑up request is again incomplete, omits categories of records, or fails to comply with Idaho Code §§ 74‑102 and 74‑103, I will pursue the formal avenues available under Idaho law, including: A written request for reconsideration A petition for review Submission to the appropriate oversight or ombudsman office This memorandum is provided to ensure the City is fully aware of the statutory deficiencies in the prior response and the legal requirements applicable to the follow‑up request. Thank you for your attention to this matter. SECTION 2 — REBUTTAL LETTER (Attachment to New PRR) To: City ClerkCity of Twin Falls203 Main Ave. ETwin Falls, ID 83301 Subject: Rebuttal and Clarification Regarding PRR #4814 This letter is submitted as an attachment to my new Public Records Request concerning compensation and payments made to certain City employees. It serves to clarify deficiencies in the City’s response to PRR #4814 and to ensure that the follow‑up request is directed to the correct department for a complete and accurate search. (Full text already integrated above — unchanged) SECTION 3 — NEW PUBLIC RECORDS REQUEST (Finance Department Search Required) To: City ClerkCity of Twin Falls203 Main Ave. ETwin Falls, ID 83301 Subject: Public Records Request – Comprehensive Compensation & Reimbursement Records (Finance Department Search Required) This request is submitted as a follow‑up to PRR #4814, which did not include complete compensation records for the employees listed below. The prior response did not include all forms of compensation or payments made by the City, and certain categories of records were described as “not available,” despite being maintained within the City’s Finance systems. Because the City’s Finance Department maintains the official expenditure, payroll, vendor, and reimbursement systems, this request is directed specifically to Finance to ensure a complete and accurate search. Employees Covered (All Fiscal Years of Employment) Travis Rothweiler – City Manager Gretchen Scott – Deputy City Manager Mitch Humble – Deputy City Manager Breanna Howard – Chief Financial Officer Kristen Kohntopp – Director Troy Vitek – City Engineer Shawn Barigar – Economic Development Director Mitchell Brooks – Fire Chief Josh Baird – Department Director 1. Payroll‑Based Compensation Records (Full text already integrated above — unchanged) 2. Accounts Payable & Vendor‑Based Payments (Full text already integrated above — unchanged) 3. Deferred Compensation Records (Full text already integrated above — unchanged) 4. Compensation‑Related Authorizing Documents (Full text already integrated above — unchanged) 5. Required Search Scope — Finance Department (Full text already integrated above — unchanged) 6. Format Electronic copies (PDF or native format) are preferred.Delivery via email is acceptable. Attach Files to Your Request If you have documentation that you wish to provide for this request, attach the files here. Signature * The City of Twin Falls will respond to this request within three (3) business days. Or up to 10 business days upon notification of the requesting party. The City of Twin Falls maintains records for the City of Twin Falls, Idaho. For records including in Twin Falls County please contact Twin Falls County at www.twinfallscounty.org Requested records will be provided electronically. We do not provide your information to mailing lists. It will only be used to fulfill this request. From [email protected] To Date Monday, October 05, 2026 08:23 PM MT Subject Copy of Form Public Records Requests Attachments City of Twin Falls Public Records Request.pdf Filed under #4940 Source file SHA-256 f07a92e5e5c78cae1b47937e8adea02ee26a7e2d817bfac04a2fc2b625a5f991 Your records request has been received. You're receiving this email because someone requested that you get a copy of this form. ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From No Reply <[email protected]> To Date Tuesday, October 06, 2026 01:59 PM MT Subject City of Twin Falls Records Request Extension Notice for Request #4940 Attachments none Filed under #4940 Source file SHA-256 df6dc5f48ec61ac164499795bebced2e62e94047daa3942a249e955d86c9f9b5 Your request to examine public records was received on 10/5/2026 8:23:00 PM. The City will be unable to process the request within statutory three (3) working days and a longer period of time will be necessary to locate, retrieve, and review the records. This letter is to provide notice for an extension of ten (10) working days from the date of your original request under Idaho Code 74-103(2). Your patience in this matter is appreciated and we will contact you when these records are available for release. Thank you, and we look forward to processing your request. ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From [email protected] To Date Tuesday, October 06, 2026 01:59 PM MT Subject Your Public Records Request #4940 is being processed. Attachments none Filed under #4940 Source file SHA-256 923d011fa62c0328fe71becbf2d1f5d2eb80d0302fabe31d5136ecc5680b4c28 Your Public Records Request #4940 is being processed and materials are being gathered. You will be updated as the status changes. ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From To "[email protected]" <[email protected]>, "[email protected]" <[email protected]> Date Thursday, October 22, 2026 10:09 AM MT Subject Records Request #4940 Attachments none Filed under #4940 Source file SHA-256 aec85e23a371b02a2432670fb4f2846639aa3e9e5d2f4d802826c927760e040b City Clerks, I'm writing to inquire as to the status of this request (4940). It's now been more than 10 business days since I submitted this request. Can you please let me know what's going on and when I can expect the results? As a matter of fact, this request is actually in response to 2 previously incomplete requests, so the results are now long overdue. I would imagine that a finance system complex enough to run a city's finances would be able to produce the records asked for in a more reasonable amount of time. The original request is on file already, but simply put I am asking for all financial payouts of any kind to some of the upper management in the city, originally asking for 2020 to present. These could be payments of any kind, from payroll to what amounts to vendor payments or bonuses, reimbursements, etc. - public funds used to compensate public employees. Please provide the results as soon as possible in compliance with Idaho Public Records law and the initial response I received providing me with the expectation of 3 working days and then extending that to 10 working days. ------- Forwarded Message ------- From: No Reply <[email protected]> Date: On Tuesday, October 6th, 2026 at 13:59 Subject: City of Twin Falls Records Request Extension Notice for Request #4940 To: Your request to examine public records was received on 10/5/2026 8:23:00 PM. The City will be unable to process the request within statutory three (3) working days and a longer period of time will be necessary to locate, retrieve, and review the records. This letter is to provide notice for an extension of ten (10) working days from the date of your original request under Idaho Code 74-103(2). Your patience in this matter is appreciated and we will contact you when these records are available for release. Thank you, and we look forward to processing your request. ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From To "[email protected]" <[email protected]>, "[email protected]" <[email protected]> Date Wednesday, October 28, 2026 12:04 PM MT Subject Re: Records Request #4940 Attachments none Filed under #4940 Source file SHA-256 7bc048f0ffc7e68ec6c5856f63c91d5e322049d7980c36cdc1cd3dcd016464ed Can you let me know the status or get back to me with the results of this request, please? I've had no communication from the city since I put in the request and it was accepted and then recieved the request for more time. On Thursday, October 22nd, 2026 at 10:09, wrote: City Clerks, I'm writing to inquire as to the status of this request (4940). It's now been more than 10 business days since I submitted this request. Can you please let me know what's going on and when I can expect the results? As a matter of fact, this request is actually in response to 2 previously incomplete requests, so the results are now long overdue. I would imagine that a finance system complex enough to run a city's finances would be able to produce the records asked for in a more reasonable amount of time. The original request is on file already, but simply put I am asking for all financial payouts of any kind to some of the upper management in the city, originally asking for 2020 to present. These could be payments of any kind, from payroll to what amounts to vendor payments or bonuses, reimbursements, etc. - public funds used to compensate public employees. Please provide the results as soon as possible in compliance with Idaho Public Records law and the initial response I received providing me with the expectation of 3 working days and then extending that to 10 working days. ------- Forwarded Message ------- From: No Reply <[email protected]> Date: On Tuesday, October 6th, 2026 at 13:59 Subject: City of Twin Falls Records Request Extension Notice for Request #4940 To: Your request to examine public records was received on 10/5/2026 8:23:00 PM. The City will be unable to process the request within statutory three (3) working days and a longer period of time will be necessary to locate, retrieve, and review the records. This letter is to provide notice for an extension of ten (10) working days from the date of your original request under Idaho Code 74-103(2). Your patience in this matter is appreciated and we will contact you when these records are available for release. Thank you, and we look forward to processing your request. ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From To "[email protected]" <[email protected]>, "[email protected]" <[email protected]> Date Monday, November 02, 2026 04:41 AM MT Subject Re: Records Request #4940 Attachments none Filed under #4940 Source file SHA-256 e0a4bfae8d133ab7077fee4246d316e07932df07f82ab8df07a99f5986bce756 I'm hoping I can get a response soon. I've been waiting for a response for nearly a month now. I received two incomplete responses to the same request already. I'm just looking for the pieces that are not part of payroll that Human Resources provided. On Wednesday, October 28th, 2026 at 12:04, wrote: Can you let me know the status or get back to me with the results of this request, please? I've had no communication from the city since I put in the request and it was accepted and then recieved the request for more time. On Thursday, October 22nd, 2026 at 10:09, wrote: City Clerks, I'm writing to inquire as to the status of this request (4940). It's now been more than 10 business days since I submitted this request. Can you please let me know what's going on and when I can expect the results? As a matter of fact, this request is actually in response to 2 previously incomplete requests, so the results are now long overdue. I would imagine that a finance system complex enough to run a city's finances would be able to produce the records asked for in a more reasonable amount of time. The original request is on file already, but simply put I am asking for all financial payouts of any kind to some of the upper management in the city, originally asking for 2020 to present. These could be payments of any kind, from payroll to what amounts to vendor payments or bonuses, reimbursements, etc. - public funds used to compensate public employees. Please provide the results as soon as possible in compliance with Idaho Public Records law and the initial response I received providing me with the expectation of 3 working days and then extending that to 10 working days. ------- Forwarded Message ------- From: No Reply <[email protected]> Date: On Tuesday, October 6th, 2026 at 13:59 Subject: City of Twin Falls Records Request Extension Notice for Request #4940 To: Your request to examine public records was received on 10/5/2026 8:23:00 PM. The City will be unable to process the request within statutory three (3) working days and a longer period of time will be necessary to locate, retrieve, and review the records. This letter is to provide notice for an extension of ten (10) working days from the date of your original request under Idaho Code 74-103(2). Your patience in this matter is Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. appreciated and we will contact you when these records are available for release. Thank you, and we look forward to processing your request. ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. From To "[email protected]" <[email protected]>, "[email protected]" <[email protected]> Date Tuesday, November 03, 2026 08:41 PM MT Subject Re: Records Request #4940 Attachments none Filed under #4940 Source file SHA-256 0abf964ddea06a6ec7a686468d580787de42c71f5a1ecfa11c27d065e477bc6b City Clerks, I'm still waiting for a response to my request. My previous requests didn't take this long. At this point we're quite a bit over time. If neither of you can help me, please provide me with a contact that can. On Monday, November 2nd, 2026 at 04:41, wrote: I'm hoping I can get a response soon. I've been waiting for a response for nearly a month now. I received two incomplete responses to the same request already. I'm just looking for the pieces that are not part of payroll that Human Resources provided. On Wednesday, October 28th, 2026 at 12:04, wrote: Can you let me know the status or get back to me with the results of this request, please? I've had no communication from the city since I put in the request and it was accepted and then recieved the request for more time. On Thursday, October 22nd, 2026 at 10:09, wrote: City Clerks, I'm writing to inquire as to the status of this request (4940). It's now been more than 10 business days since I submitted this request. Can you please let me know what's going on and when I can expect the results? As a matter of fact, this request is actually in response to 2 previously incomplete requests, so the results are now long overdue. I would imagine that a finance system complex enough to run a city's finances would be able to produce the records asked for in a more reasonable amount of time. The original request is on file already, but simply put I am asking for all financial payouts of any kind to some of the upper management in the city, originally asking for 2020 to present. These could be payments of any kind, from payroll to what amounts to vendor payments or bonuses, reimbursements, etc. - public funds used to compensate public employees. Please provide the results as soon as possible in compliance with Idaho Public Records law and the initial response I received providing me Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. with the expectation of 3 working days and then extending that to 10 working days. ------- Forwarded Message ------- From: No Reply <[email protected]> Date: On Tuesday, October 6th, 2026 at 13:59 Subject: City of Twin Falls Records Request Extension Notice for Request #4940 To: Your request to examine public records was received on 10/5/2026 8:23:00 PM. The City will be unable to process the request within statutory three (3) working days and a longer period of time will be necessary to locate, retrieve, and review the records. This letter is to provide notice for an extension of ten (10) working days from the date of your original request under Idaho Code 74-103(2). Your patience in this matter is appreciated and we will contact you when these records are available for release. Thank you, and we look forward to processing your request. ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From To "[email protected]" <[email protected]>, "[email protected]" <[email protected]> Date Thursday, November 05, 2026 08:44 AM MT Subject Re: Records Request #4940 Attachments none Filed under #4940 Source file SHA-256 03980be740421dfce1f4894d8c41cb0359189d0ec700da230465c96e4d1156b0 City Clerks, I am still waiting for a response. My other requests were handled much timelier than this one. I think we're quite a bit past time on this one. If neither of you can help me, please let me know who can. On Monday, November 2nd, 2026 at 04:41, wrote: I'm hoping I can get a response soon. I've been waiting for a response for nearly a month now. I received two incomplete responses to the same request already. I'm just looking for the pieces that are not part of payroll that Human Resources provided. On Wednesday, October 28th, 2026 at 12:04, wrote: Can you let me know the status or get back to me with the results of this request, please? I've had no communication from the city since I put in the request and it was accepted and then recieved the request for more time. On Thursday, October 22nd, 2026 at 10:09, wrote: City Clerks, I'm writing to inquire as to the status of this request (4940). It's now been more than 10 business days since I submitted this request. Can you please let me know what's going on and when I can expect the results? As a matter of fact, this request is actually in response to 2 previously incomplete requests, so the results are now long overdue. I would imagine that a finance system complex enough to run a city's finances would be able to produce the records asked for in a more reasonable amount of time. The original request is on file already, but simply put I am asking for all financial payouts of any kind to some of the upper management in the city, originally asking for 2020 to present. These could be payments of any kind, from payroll to what amounts to vendor payments or bonuses, reimbursements, etc. - public funds used to compensate public employees. Please provide the results as soon as possible in compliance with Idaho Public Records law and the initial response I received providing me with the expectation of 3 working days and then extending that to 10 working days. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. ------- Forwarded Message ------- From: No Reply <[email protected]> Date: On Tuesday, October 6th, 2026 at 13:59 Subject: City of Twin Falls Records Request Extension Notice for Request #4940 To: Your request to examine public records was received on 10/5/2026 8:23:00 PM. The City will be unable to process the request within statutory three (3) working days and a longer period of time will be necessary to locate, retrieve, and review the records. This letter is to provide notice for an extension of ten (10) working days from the date of your original request under Idaho Code 74-103(2). Your patience in this matter is appreciated and we will contact you when these records are available for release. Thank you, and we look forward to processing your request. ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive.