EX-C07-4
Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments)
City of Twin Falls
View the document here · 85 pages
- Record date
- Not dated
- Source
- PRR #4953
- Record type
- Records Requests and Agency Responses
- Pages used
- all (3); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (3); all (2); all (1); all (2); all (3); all (3); all (3); all (4); all (4); all (6); all (8); all (8); all (14); all (16)
- Supports findings
- E-15 PRR #4953 denial turned on requester identity/residency (legally mixed)
E-22 The City enforces the requester-information rule on some requests and not others - Notes
- Each email rendered to PDF from the received message; bookmarks give date/sender/subject. Requester signature images omitted.
- Redaction
- 7 area(s) redacted
Chain of custody
- Obtained. Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4953. Request filed 2026-10; the City's response: Denied: non-compliance with 74-102(4) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the file exactly as the agency released it: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 - Changes for posting.
- Combined from 20 files as released
- Redacted: 7 area(s) redacted
- Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed
- Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 11, 12, 14, 15, 16, 17, 20, 21, 23, 24, 26, 27, 28, 30, 31, 32, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 56, 57, 58, 60, 61, 65, 70, 71, 72, 73, 75, 76, 77, 81, 82); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable
- Posted copy. SHA-256 of the file you download here, checked against our index on every build:
d4a2487250cb99fe3885ecf01110db6a6507615941c3fa6cf06142951f2d25b8
The original as received is kept unaltered. Anyone holding the agency's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. How to verify a file · Chain of custody for every record (CSV)
Document text (read by machine for search, and often imperfect for scans and handwriting; the file is the record)
City of Twin Falls Public Records Request Requestor Information Please list your information here. Include your request details in the space provided below. Requestor First Name * Requestor Last Name * Requestor Address 1 * Requestor Address 2 Requestor City * Requestor State * Requestor ZIP Code * Requestor Phone Number * Requestor E-mail * Type of Request * Personal Commercial Legal Request Details * If you are requesting multiple records, please attach your list below. If you do not have a case/event/citation number, please include enough information to identify the records you want. If your request is for multiple items, it may be subject to fees for preparation. We have records for the Twin Falls Police Department (city, not county) only. Public Records Request – Exceptions for City Management / ELT Subject: Exceptions to Employee Handbook – City Management / Executive Leadership Please accept this as a formal request for public records. I am requesting any and all records that document, describe, authorize, reference, or imply exceptions, deviations, exemptions, special rules, or alternative procedures applicable to City Management, Executive Leadership Team (ELT) members, Deputy City Managers, the City Manager, or any other upper‑tier administrative staff, with respect to the City of Twin Falls Employee Handbook. This request includes all years, all versions of the handbook, and all forms of documentation, including but not limited to: 1. Exceptions to PTO, Vacation, and Leave Policies Any records showing exceptions, special permissions, or alternative rules for: Vacation accrual Vacation sell‑back limits PTO sell‑back limits “Use‑it‑or‑lose‑it” exception approvals Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. Bonus PTO awards Administrative leave Medical leave, FMLA‑related leave, or any non‑standard leave categories Any leave or PTO benefit not available to general employees This includes: Council‑approved exceptions HR‑approved exceptions City Manager‑approved exceptions Any informal or undocumented practices Any email or memo authorizing exceptions Any payroll system notes or overrides Any special accrual rates or sellback allowances 2. Exceptions to Any Other Employee Handbook Rules I am requesting all exceptions, not limited to leave/PTO. This includes any documented or informal deviations from handbook rules for City Management or ELT, including: Work hours / flex scheduling Remote work privileges Travel policies Reimbursement policies Discipline procedures Performance review processes Bonus eligibility Stipends, supplemental pay, or special compensation not listed in the handbook Any benefit, perk, or allowance not available to general employees Any rule they are not required to follow that general employees must follow 3. Any Documents That Create, Authorize, or Reference These Exceptions This includes: Contracts Addendums Council resolutions HR memos Internal emails Policy interpretations Administrative directives Payroll system configuration documents Notes or comments in payroll or HRIS systems Any communication between HR, City Manager, Deputy City Managers, Finance, or Council regarding exceptions 4. Any Records Showing That No Exceptions Exist If no exceptions exist, please provide: A written statement confirming that no exceptions are documented Any records showing that City Management and ELT are bound by the same rules as general employees Any records showing denials of exception requests 5. Scope Clarification This request applies to: Travis Rothweiler Gretchen Scott Mitch Humble All ELT members Any other upper‑tier administrative staff Any person classified as “City Management” or equivalent Attach Files to Your Request If you have documentation that you wish to provide for this request, attach the files here. Signature * The City of Twin Falls will respond to this request within three (3) business days. Or up to 10 business days upon notification of the requesting party. The City of Twin Falls maintains records for the City of Twin Falls, Idaho. For records including in Twin Falls County please contact Twin Falls County at www.twinfallscounty.org Requested records will be provided electronically. We do not provide your information to mailing lists. It will only be used to fulfill this request. From [email protected] To Date Wednesday, October 07, 2026 10:01 PM MT Subject Copy of Form Public Records Requests Attachments City of Twin Falls Public Records Request.pdf Filed under #4953 Source file SHA-256 95e80cba55458064caa4f83e8c4f02d046d87edcf92c14236aacc53b41ceff3f Your records request has been received. You're receiving this email because someone requested that you get a copy of this form. ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From No Reply <[email protected]> To Date Thursday, October 08, 2026 11:44 AM MT Subject City of Twin Falls Records Request Extension Notice for Request #4953 Attachments none Filed under #4953 Source file SHA-256 01ea37a94c512b2ed883b7bb38246e4108e6bc0d412f090082155e1ec19f088e Your request to examine public records was received on 10/7/2026 10:01:31 PM. The City will be unable to process the request within statutory three (3) working days and a longer period of time will be necessary to locate, retrieve, and review the records. This letter is to provide notice for an extension of ten (10) working days from the date of your original request under Idaho Code 74-103(2). Your patience in this matter is appreciated and we will contact you when these records are available for release. Thank you, and we look forward to processing your request. ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From [email protected] To Date Thursday, October 08, 2026 11:44 AM MT Subject Your Public Records Request #4953 is being processed. Attachments none Filed under #4953 Source file SHA-256 41c37c4e3a364b4a27caeb959af9ad49b11acdcf71cc2626b09af1c4c5499151 Your Public Records Request #4953 is being processed and materials are being gathered. You will be updated as the status changes. ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From No Reply <[email protected]> To Date Tuesday, October 20, 2026 04:29 PM MT Subject Public Records Request #4953 is under final review. Attachments none Filed under #4953 Source file SHA-256 0cbc7f3986e2d66fac1c6038a521e9b7570a3df676cc133df990fa2e0b7ec740 Public Records Request #4953 is undergoing final review before the information is released. You will be notified upon its completion. ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From No Reply <[email protected]> To Date Tuesday, October 20, 2026 04:47 PM MT Subject Results of your Public Records Request #4953 Attachments none Filed under #4953 Source file SHA-256 663cfce38bcadbb2c237bec306908789c4e44e3e14ddff96d00940ff282e3e77 Fulfilled Request Per your records request, filed on 10/07/2026 Attached please find the records held by the City of Twin Falls in response to your request. This link is expires in 30 days. During that time you may use this link to review and/or download a copy of the data. https://lfws.tfid.org/PublicDelivery/Browse.aspx?dbid=0&startid=30319 This request is now concluded. NOTICE: PURSUANT TO IDAHO CODE § 74-115 YOU HAVE 180 DAYS TO APPEAL THIS DECISION BY FILING A PETITION IN STATE DISTRICT COURT IN THE COUNTY WHERE ALL OR PART OF THE RECORDS ARE LOCATED ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From To "[email protected]" <[email protected]>, "[email protected]" <[email protected]>, "lwells @tfid.org" <[email protected]> Date Tuesday, October 20, 2026 11:30 PM MT Subject Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) Attachments Initial Request - Filed under #4953 Source file SHA-256 505d3778f2246c536d67b1d7affce813b740332d899e6f217348401bc77da023 Dear City Attorney’s Office, I received the response to my public records request submitted on October 7, 2026, and I wanted to follow up for clarification. The notice referenced Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) and stated that the City is not in possession of a report or record of that nature. I’m hoping you can help me understand what part of § 74‐102(4) applies here. My intention was simply to request any existing records documenting exceptions or deviations from the employee handbook for City Management or Executive Leadership. If the way I phrased the request was too broad or not specific enough to identify the records you need to search for, I’m happy to adjust it. Could you please clarify whether: 1. The reference to § 74‐102(4) means the City determined the request needs to be narrowed; or 2. It means the City concluded that no responsive records exist? Once I understand how the statute applies, I can refine the request accordingly. Thank you for your time and assistance. Sincerely, ------- Forwarded Message ------- From: No Reply <[email protected]> Date: On Tuesday, October 20th, 2026 at 16:47 Subject: Results of your Public Records Request #4953 To: Fulfilled Request Per your records request, filed on 10/07/2026 Attached please find the records held by the City of Twin Falls in response to your request. This link is expires in 30 days. During that time you may use this link to review and/or download a copy of the data. https://lfws.tfid.org/PublicDelivery/Browse.aspx?dbid=0&startid=30319 This request is now concluded. NOTICE: PURSUANT TO IDAHO CODE § 74-115 YOU HAVE 180 DAYS TO APPEAL THIS DECISION BY FILING A PETITION IN STATE DISTRICT COURT IN THE COUNTY WHERE ALL OR PART OF THE RECORDS ARE LOCATED ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. From Nicole Swafford <[email protected]> To Date Tuesday, October 20, 2026 11:31 PM MT Subject Automatic reply: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) Attachments none Filed under #4953 Source file SHA-256 98a20a85f562d882d32c6a97371d539c03db960006dc585c176529c6f0984b79 I will be traversing the mountains with limited service beginning October 15 and will return October 30. If you require immediate assistance please contact my office at 2087357374. I appreciate your understanding and will get back to you as soon as possible upon my return. NS Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> To Nicole Swafford <[email protected]>, Linda Well s <[email protected]> Date Wednesday, October 21, 2026 05:24 PM MT Subject RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) Attachments none Filed under #4953 Source file SHA-256 7e3873de10e03c2655fe067a8e40688914baad5402ba682b2b10f7df489e4635 The reference to Idaho Code Section 74-102(4) refers the statutory requirement upon the requestor to provide “the requester’s name, mailing address, email address, [and] telephone number….” The City has a reasonable basis to believe you have not complied with this requirement, and thus has not processed your request. Thanks, Bruce From: Sent: Tuesday, October 20, 2026 11:31 PM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]>; Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Dear City Attorney’s Office, I received the response to my public records request submitted on October 7, 2026, and I wanted to follow up for clarification. The notice referenced Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) and stated that the City is not in possession of a report or record of that nature. I’m hoping you can help me understand what part of § 74‐102(4) applies here. My intention was simply to request any existing records documenting exceptions or deviations from the employee handbook for City Management or Executive Leadership. If the way I phrased the request was too broad or not specific enough to identify the records you need to search for, I’m happy to adjust it. Could you please clarify whether: 1. The reference to § 74‐102(4) means the City determined the request needs to be narrowed; or 2. It means the City concluded that no responsive records exist? Once I understand how the statute applies, I can refine the request accordingly. Thank you for your time and assistance. Sincerely, ------- Forwarded Message ------- From: No Reply <[email protected]> Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. Date: On Tuesday, October 20th, 2026 at 16:47 Subject: Results of your Public Records Request #4953 To: Fulfilled Request Per your records request, filed on 10/07/2026 Attached please find the records held by the City of Twin Falls in response to your request. This link is expires in 30 days. During that time you may use this link to review and/or download a copy of the data. https://lfws.tfid.org/PublicDelivery/Browse.aspx?dbid=0&startid=30319 This request is now concluded. NOTICE: PURSUANT TO IDAHO CODE § 74-115 YOU HAVE 180 DAYS TO APPEAL THIS DECISION BY FILING A PETITION IN STATE DISTRICT COURT IN THE COUNTY WHERE ALL OR PART OF THE RECORDS ARE LOCATED ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. City of Twin Falls Public Records Request Requestor Information Please list your information here. Include your request details in the space provided below. Requestor First Name * Requestor Last Name * Requestor Address 1 * Requestor Address 2 Requestor City * Requestor State * Requestor ZIP Code * Requestor Phone Number * Requestor E-mail * Type of Request * Personal Commercial Legal Request Details * If you are requesting multiple records, please attach your list below. If you do not have a case/event/citation number, please include enough information to identify the records you want. If your request is for multiple items, it may be subject to fees for preparation. We have records for the Twin Falls Police Department (city, not county) only. Public Records Request – Exceptions for City Management / ELT Subject: Exceptions to Employee Handbook – City Management / Executive Leadership Please accept this as a formal request for public records. I am requesting any and all records that document, describe, authorize, reference, or imply exceptions, deviations, exemptions, special rules, or alternative procedures applicable to City Management, Executive Leadership Team (ELT) members, Deputy City Managers, the City Manager, or any other upper‑tier administrative staff, with respect to the City of Twin Falls Employee Handbook. This request includes all years, all versions of the handbook, and all forms of documentation, including but not limited to: 1. Exceptions to PTO, Vacation, and Leave Policies Any records showing exceptions, special permissions, or alternative rules for: Vacation accrual Vacation sell‑back limits PTO sell‑back limits “Use‑it‑or‑lose‑it” exception approvals Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. Bonus PTO awards Administrative leave Medical leave, FMLA‑related leave, or any non‑standard leave categories Any leave or PTO benefit not available to general employees This includes: Council‑approved exceptions HR‑approved exceptions City Manager‑approved exceptions Any informal or undocumented practices Any email or memo authorizing exceptions Any payroll system notes or overrides Any special accrual rates or sellback allowances 2. Exceptions to Any Other Employee Handbook Rules I am requesting all exceptions, not limited to leave/PTO. This includes any documented or informal deviations from handbook rules for City Management or ELT, including: Work hours / flex scheduling Remote work privileges Travel policies Reimbursement policies Discipline procedures Performance review processes Bonus eligibility Stipends, supplemental pay, or special compensation not listed in the handbook Any benefit, perk, or allowance not available to general employees Any rule they are not required to follow that general employees must follow 3. Any Documents That Create, Authorize, or Reference These Exceptions This includes: Contracts Addendums Council resolutions HR memos Internal emails Policy interpretations Administrative directives Payroll system configuration documents Notes or comments in payroll or HRIS systems Any communication between HR, City Manager, Deputy City Managers, Finance, or Council regarding exceptions 4. Any Records Showing That No Exceptions Exist If no exceptions exist, please provide: A written statement confirming that no exceptions are documented Any records showing that City Management and ELT are bound by the same rules as general employees Any records showing denials of exception requests 5. Scope Clarification This request applies to: Travis Rothweiler Gretchen Scott Mitch Humble All ELT members Any other upper‑tier administrative staff Any person classified as “City Management” or equivalent Attach Files to Your Request If you have documentation that you wish to provide for this request, attach the files here. Signature * The City of Twin Falls will respond to this request within three (3) business days. Or up to 10 business days upon notification of the requesting party. The City of Twin Falls maintains records for the City of Twin Falls, Idaho. For records including in Twin Falls County please contact Twin Falls County at www.twinfallscounty.org Requested records will be provided electronically. We do not provide your information to mailing lists. It will only be used to fulfill this request. From To Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> Cc Nicole Swafford <[email protected]>, Linda Wells <[email protected]> Date Thursday, October 22, 2026 03:47 AM MT Subject RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) Attachments City of Twin Falls Public Records Request.pdf Filed under #4953 Source file SHA-256 a177cba9392262e426ad1421fc177826c31f4f138831c5709a15bc402c5488c3 Bruce, Thank you for your reply. I’m a bit confused by the reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4). The statute requires the requester to provide a name, mailing address, email address, and telephone number. All of those items were included when the request was submitted through the City’s online form. For clarity, I'm attaching my initial request. Since the form requires each of the fields listed in § 74‐102(4) to be completed before submission, I’m not sure which specific element you believe was missing or non‐compliant. Could you please clarify which of the four required items the City believes was not provided? Once I understand what part of § 74‐102(4) you believe was not met, I can correct whatever issue you’re referring to. Thank you, On Wednesday, October 21st, 2026 at 17:24, Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> wrote: The reference to Idaho Code Section 74-102(4) refers the statutory requirement upon the requestor to provide “the requester’s name, mailing address, email address, [and] telephone number….” The City has a reasonable basis to believe you have not complied with this requirement, and thus has not processed your request. Thanks, Bruce From: Sent: Tuesday, October 20, 2026 11:31 PM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]>; Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Dear City Attorney’s Office, I received the response to my public records request submitted on October 7, 2026, and I wanted to follow up for clarification. The notice referenced Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) and stated that the City is not in possession of a report or record of that nature. I’m hoping you can help me understand what part of § 74‐102(4) applies here. My intention was simply to request any existing records documenting exceptions or deviations from the employee handbook for City Management or Executive Leadership. If the way I phrased the request was too broad or not specific enough to identify the records you need to search for, I’m happy to adjust it. Could you please clarify whether: 1. The reference to § 74‐102(4) means the City determined the request needs to be narrowed; or 2. It means the City concluded that no responsive records exist? Once I understand how the statute applies, I can refine the request accordingly. Thank you for your time and assistance. Sincerely, ------- Forwarded Message ------- From: No Reply <[email protected]> Date: On Tuesday, October 20th, 2026 at 16:47 Subject: Results of your Public Records Request #4953 To: Fulfilled Request Per your records request, filed on 10/07/2026 Attached please find the records held by the City of Twin Falls in response to your request. This link is expires in 30 days. During that time you may use this link to review and/or download a copy of the data. https://lfws.tfid.org/PublicDelivery/Browse.aspx?dbid=0&startid=30319 This request is now concluded. NOTICE: PURSUANT TO IDAHO CODE § 74-115 YOU HAVE 180 DAYS TO APPEAL THIS DECISION BY FILING A PETITION IN STATE Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. DISTRICT COURT IN THE COUNTY WHERE ALL OR PART OF THE RECORDS ARE LOCATED ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. From Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> To Cc Nicole Swafford <[email protected]>, Linda Wells <[email protected]> Date Thursday, October 22, 2026 02:55 PM MT Subject RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) Attachments none Filed under #4953 Source file SHA-256 0ebc0c74614fc618591dca8b7924de4649489c44a5638d3ae3b6880ef9cb6eb9 My reference to Idaho Code Section 74-102(4) refers to the fact that the City does not believe you have provided your actual name, address, or phone number with your public records request. Bruce From: Sent: Thursday, October 22, 2026 3:47 AM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> Cc: Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Bruce, Thank you for your reply. I’m a bit confused by the reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4). The statute requires the requester to provide a name, mailing address, email address, and telephone number. All of those items were included when the request was submitted through the City’s online form. For clarity, I'm attaching my initial request. Since the form requires each of the fields listed in § 74‐102(4) to be completed before submission, I’m not sure which specific element you believe was missing or non‐compliant. Could you please clarify which of the four required items the City believes was not provided? Once I understand what part of § 74‐102(4) you believe was not met, I can correct whatever issue you’re referring to. Thank you, On Wednesday, October 21st, 2026 at 17:24, Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> wrote: Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. The reference to Idaho Code Section 74-102(4) refers the statutory requirement upon the requestor to provide “the requester’s name, mailing address, email address, [and] telephone number….” The City has a reasonable basis to believe you have not complied with this requirement, and thus has not processed your request. Thanks, Bruce From: Sent: Tuesday, October 20, 2026 11:31 PM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]>; Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Dear City Attorney’s Office, I received the response to my public records request submitted on October 7, 2026, and I wanted to follow up for clarification. The notice referenced Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) and stated that the City is not in possession of a report or record of that nature. I’m hoping you can help me understand what part of § 74‐102(4) applies here. My intention was simply to request any existing records documenting exceptions or deviations from the employee handbook for City Management or Executive Leadership. If the way I phrased the request was too broad or not specific enough to identify the records you need to search for, I’m happy to adjust it. Could you please clarify whether: 1. The reference to § 74‐102(4) means the City determined the request needs to be narrowed; or 2. It means the City concluded that no responsive records exist? Once I understand how the statute applies, I can refine the request accordingly. Thank you for your time and assistance. Sincerely, ------- Forwarded Message ------- From: No Reply <[email protected]> Date: On Tuesday, October 20th, 2026 at 16:47 Subject: Results of your Public Records Request #4953 To: Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. Fulfilled Request Per your records request, filed on 10/07/2026 Attached please find the records held by the City of Twin Falls in response to your request. This link is expires in 30 days. During that time you may use this link to review and/or download a copy of the data. https://lfws.tfid.org/PublicDelivery/Browse.aspx? dbid=0&startid=30319 This request is now concluded. NOTICE: PURSUANT TO IDAHO CODE § 74-115 YOU HAVE 180 DAYS TO APPEAL THIS DECISION BY FILING A PETITION IN STATE DISTRICT COURT IN THE COUNTY WHERE ALL OR PART OF THE RECORDS ARE LOCATED ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. From To Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> Cc Nicole Swafford <[email protected]>, Linda Wells <[email protected]> Date Friday, October 23, 2026 09:52 AM MT Subject RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) Attachments none Filed under #4953 Source file SHA-256 9840fddfefc342cc3860e92844752ca0c7a8ad5bb703a240a05acb9527a0557f Bruce, I have to admit I’m confused by your response. The City’s online form requires a name, mailing address, email address, and phone number before it can even be submitted, and all of those fields were completed. Your statement that “the City does not believe” the information is actual is unclear, and I’m not sure what that means in terms of compliance with Idaho Code § 74‐102(4). I’m simply trying to request public records. If the City is refusing to process the request, I need to understand specifically what requirement you believe has not been met and what, in your view, must be done in order for the request to be processed. The statute lists the required information, and that information was provided. Please let me know what the City requires so that these records can be released. Thank you, On Thursday, October 22nd, 2026 at 14:55, Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> wrote: My reference to Idaho Code Section 74-102(4) refers to the fact that the City does not believe you have provided your actual name, address, or phone number with your public records request. Bruce From: Sent: Thursday, October 22, 2026 3:47 AM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> Cc: Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. Bruce, Thank you for your reply. I’m a bit confused by the reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4). The statute requires the requester to provide a name, mailing address, email address, and telephone number. All of those items were included when the request was submitted through the City’s online form. For clarity, I'm attaching my initial request. Since the form requires each of the fields listed in § 74‐102(4) to be completed before submission, I’m not sure which specific element you believe was missing or non‐compliant. Could you please clarify which of the four required items the City believes was not provided? Once I understand what part of § 74‐102(4) you believe was not met, I can correct whatever issue you’re referring to. Thank you, On Wednesday, October 21st, 2026 at 17:24, Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> wrote: The reference to Idaho Code Section 74-102(4) refers the statutory requirement upon the requestor to provide “the requester’s name, mailing address, email address, [and] telephone number….” The City has a reasonable basis to believe you have not complied with this requirement, and thus has not processed your request. Thanks, Bruce From: Sent: Tuesday, October 20, 2026 11:31 PM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]>; Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Dear City Attorney’s Office, I received the response to my public records request submitted on October 7, 2026, and I wanted to follow up for clarification. The notice referenced Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) and stated that the City is not in possession of a report or record of that nature. I’m hoping you can help me understand what part of § 74‐102(4) applies here. My intention was simply to request any existing records documenting exceptions or deviations from the employee handbook for City Management or Executive Leadership. If the way I phrased the request was too broad or not specific enough to identify the records you need to search for, I’m happy to adjust it. Could you please clarify whether: 1. The reference to § 74‐102(4) means the City determined the request needs to be narrowed; or 2. It means the City concluded that no responsive records exist? Once I understand how the statute applies, I can refine the request accordingly. Thank you for your time and assistance. Sincerely, ------- Forwarded Message ------- From: No Reply <[email protected]> Date: On Tuesday, October 20th, 2026 at 16:47 Subject: Results of your Public Records Request #4953 Fulfilled Request Per your records request, filed on 10/07/2026 Attached please find the records held by the City of Twin Falls in response to your request. This link is expires in 30 days. During that time you may use this link to review and/or download a copy of the data. https://lfws.tfid.org/PublicDelivery/Browse.asp x?dbid=0&startid=30319 Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. This request is now concluded. NOTICE: PURSUANT TO IDAHO CODE § 74-115 YOU HAVE 180 DAYS TO APPEAL THIS DECISION BY FILING A PETITION IN STATE DISTRICT COURT IN THE COUNTY WHERE ALL OR PART OF THE RECORDS ARE LOCATED ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. From Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> To Cc Nicole Swafford <[email protected]>, Linda Wells <[email protected]> Date Friday, October 23, 2026 10:56 AM MT Subject RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) Attachments none Filed under #4953 Source file SHA-256 d05e0e1f2b02004f97db74806ad125329a444b0369962591e563af3c8ade5d44 I am trying to convey that the City does not believe you are who you represent yourself to be in the request, and that the code provision requires you to provide your real name, address, etc., not an assumed identity. If you were to provide proof of your identity then this could certainly be resolved very quickly. From: Sent: Friday, October 23, 2026 9:52 AM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> Cc: Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Bruce, I have to admit I’m confused by your response. The City’s online form requires a name, mailing address, email address, and phone number before it can even be submitted, and all of those fields were completed. Your statement that “the City does not believe” the information is actual is unclear, and I’m not sure what that means in terms of compliance with Idaho Code § 74‐102(4). I’m simply trying to request public records. If the City is refusing to process the request, I need to understand specifically what requirement you believe has not been met and what, in your view, must be done in order for the request to be processed. The statute lists the required information, and that information was provided. Please let me know what the City requires so that these records can be released. Thank you, On Thursday, October 22nd, 2026 at 14:55, Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> wrote: My reference to Idaho Code Section 74-102(4) refers to the fact that the City does not believe you have provided your actual name, address, or phone number with your public records request. Bruce From: Sent: Thursday, October 22, 2026 3:47 AM Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> Cc: Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Bruce, Thank you for your reply. I’m a bit confused by the reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4). The statute requires the requester to provide a name, mailing address, email address, and telephone number. All of those items were included when the request was submitted through the City’s online form. For clarity, I'm attaching my initial request. Since the form requires each of the fields listed in § 74‐102(4) to be completed before submission, I’m not sure which specific element you believe was missing or non‐compliant. Could you please clarify which of the four required items the City believes was not provided? Once I understand what part of § 74‐102(4) you believe was not met, I can correct whatever issue you’re referring to. Thank you, On Wednesday, October 21st, 2026 at 17:24, Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> wrote: The reference to Idaho Code Section 74-102(4) refers the statutory requirement upon the requestor to provide “the requester’s name, mailing address, email address, [and] telephone number….” The City has a reasonable basis to believe you have not complied with this requirement, and thus has not processed your request. Thanks, Bruce From: Sent: Tuesday, October 20, 2026 11:31 PM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]>; Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Dear City Attorney’s Office, I received the response to my public records request submitted on October 7, 2026, and I wanted to follow up for clarification. The notice referenced Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) and stated that the City is not in possession of a report or record of that nature. I’m hoping you can help me understand what part of § 74‐102(4) applies here. My intention was simply to request any existing records documenting exceptions or deviations from the employee handbook for City Management or Executive Leadership. If the way I phrased the request was too broad or not specific enough to identify the records you need to search for, I’m happy to adjust it. Could you please clarify whether: 1. The reference to § 74‐102(4) means the City determined the request needs to be narrowed; or 2. It means the City concluded that no responsive records exist? Once I understand how the statute applies, I can refine the request accordingly. Thank you for your time and assistance. Sincerely, ------- Forwarded Message ------- From: No Reply <[email protected]> Date: On Tuesday, October 20th, 2026 at 16:47 Subject: Results of your Public Records Request #4953 To: Fulfilled Request Per your records request, filed on 10/07/2026 Attached please find the records held by the City of Twin Falls in response to your request. This link is expires in 30 days. During that time you may use this link to review and/or download a copy of the Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. data. https://lfws.tfid.org/PublicDelivery/Browse. aspx?dbid=0&startid=30319 This request is now concluded. NOTICE: PURSUANT TO IDAHO CODE § 74-115 YOU HAVE 180 DAYS TO APPEAL THIS DECISION BY FILING A PETITION IN STATE DISTRICT COURT IN THE COUNTY WHERE ALL OR PART OF THE RECORDS ARE LOCATED ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. From To Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> Cc Nicole Swafford <[email protected]>, Linda Wells <[email protected]> Date Friday, October 23, 2026 03:21 PM MT Subject RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) Attachments none Filed under #4953 Source file SHA-256 9a830620744cad863e615973958d5d5dce2fe5af91bc66420387a4a42da441e5 Bruce, Thanks for the clarification. I’m honestly trying to understand what I may have done wrong here. I used the City’s online form and filled out every field it required, so I thought that was the normal way to submit a public records request. If there’s some additional step or registration process I’m supposed to follow, I wasn’t aware of it. You mentioned that the City doesn’t believe the name, address, or phone number provided are real. I didn’t realize the City had a way of verifying that information for public records requests. Could you explain how the City normally verifies a requester’s identity? I want to make sure I’m following whatever the standard procedure is. I’m just trying to request public records, and I want to understand what specifically I need to do so the request can be processed. Thank you, On Friday, October 23rd, 2026 at 10:56, Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> wrote: I am trying to convey that the City does not believe you are who you represent yourself to be in the request, and that the code provision requires you to provide your real name, address, etc., not an assumed identity. If you were to provide proof of your identity then this could certainly be resolved very quickly. From: Sent: Friday, October 23, 2026 9:52 AM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> Cc: Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Bruce, Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. I have to admit I’m confused by your response. The City’s online form requires a name, mailing address, email address, and phone number before it can even be submitted, and all of those fields were completed. Your statement that “the City does not believe” the information is actual is unclear, and I’m not sure what that means in terms of compliance with Idaho Code § 74‐102(4). I’m simply trying to request public records. If the City is refusing to process the request, I need to understand specifically what requirement you believe has not been met and what, in your view, must be done in order for the request to be processed. The statute lists the required information, and that information was provided. Please let me know what the City requires so that these records can be released. Thank you, On Thursday, October 22nd, 2026 at 14:55, Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> wrote: My reference to Idaho Code Section 74-102(4) refers to the fact that the City does not believe you have provided your actual name, address, or phone number with your public records request. Bruce From: Sent: Thursday, October 22, 2026 3:47 AM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> Cc: Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Bruce, Thank you for your reply. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. I’m a bit confused by the reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4). The statute requires the requester to provide a name, mailing address, email address, and telephone number. All of those items were included when the request was submitted through the City’s online form. For clarity, I'm attaching my initial request. Since the form requires each of the fields listed in § 74‐102(4) to be completed before submission, I’m not sure which specific element you believe was missing or non‐compliant. Could you please clarify which of the four required items the City believes was not provided? Once I understand what part of § 74‐102(4) you believe was not met, I can correct whatever issue you’re referring to. Thank you, On Wednesday, October 21st, 2026 at 17:24, Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> wrote: The reference to Idaho Code Section 74- 102(4) refers the statutory requirement upon the requestor to provide “the requester’s name, mailing address, email address, [and] telephone number….” The City has a reasonable basis to believe you have not complied with this requirement, and thus has not processed your request. Thanks, Bruce From: Sent: Tuesday, October 20, 2026 11:31 PM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]>; Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Dear City Attorney’s Office, I received the response to my public records request submitted on October 7, 2026, and I wanted to follow up for clarification. The notice referenced Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) and stated that the City is not in possession of a report or record of that nature. I’m hoping you can help me understand what part of § 74‐102(4) applies here. My intention was simply to request any existing records documenting exceptions or deviations from the employee handbook for City Management or Executive Leadership. If the way I phrased the request was too broad or not specific enough to identify the records you need to search for, I’m happy to adjust it. Could you please clarify whether: 1. The reference to § 74‐102(4) means the City determined the request needs to be narrowed; or 2. It means the City concluded that no responsive records exist? Once I understand how the statute applies, I can refine the request accordingly. Thank you for your time and assistance. Sincerely, Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. ------- Forwarded Message ------- From: No Reply <[email protected]> Date: On Tuesday, October 20th, 2026 at 16:47 Subject: Results of your Public Records Request #4953 Fulfilled Request Per your records request, filed on 10/07/2026 Attached please find the records held by the City of Twin Falls in response to your request. This link is expires in 30 days. During that time you may use this link to review and/or download a copy of the data. https://lfws.tfid.org/Pu blicDelivery/Browse.a spx? dbid=0&startid=3031 9 This request is now concluded. NOTICE: PURSUANT TO IDAHO CODE § 74- 115 YOU HAVE 180 DAYS TO APPEAL THIS DECISION BY FILING A PETITION IN STATE DISTRICT COURT IN THE COUNTY WHERE ALL OR PART OF THE RECORDS ARE LOCATED ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. it will not be read. From To Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> Cc Nicole Swafford <[email protected]>, Linda Wells <[email protected]> Date Wednesday, October 28, 2026 02:39 PM MT Subject RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) Attachments none Filed under #4953 Source file SHA-256 004df89ec32ae170adefad36d25adc047adf1e4ba39cf2fe71f373991dbd64b0 Can you please let me know what I must do to get the public information that I've requested? On Friday, October 23rd, 2026 at 15:21, wrote: Bruce, Thanks for the clarification. I’m honestly trying to understand what I may have done wrong here. I used the City’s online form and filled out every field it required, so I thought that was the normal way to submit a public records request. If there’s some additional step or registration process I’m supposed to follow, I wasn’t aware of it. You mentioned that the City doesn’t believe the name, address, or phone number provided are real. I didn’t realize the City had a way of verifying that information for public records requests. Could you explain how the City normally verifies a requester’s identity? I want to make sure I’m following whatever the standard procedure is. I’m just trying to request public records, and I want to understand what specifically I need to do so the request can be processed. Thank you, On Friday, October 23rd, 2026 at 10:56, Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> wrote: I am trying to convey that the City does not believe you are who you represent yourself to be in the request, and that the code provision requires you to provide your real name, address, etc., not an assumed identity. If you were to provide proof of your identity then this could certainly be resolved very quickly. From: Sent: Friday, October 23, 2026 9:52 AM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> Cc: Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. Bruce, I have to admit I’m confused by your response. The City’s online form requires a name, mailing address, email address, and phone number before it can even be submitted, and all of those fields were completed. Your statement that “the City does not believe” the information is actual is unclear, and I’m not sure what that means in terms of compliance with Idaho Code § 74‐102(4). I’m simply trying to request public records. If the City is refusing to process the request, I need to understand specifically what requirement you believe has not been met and what, in your view, must be done in order for the request to be processed. The statute lists the required information, and that information was provided. Please let me know what the City requires so that these records can be released. Thank you, On Thursday, October 22nd, 2026 at 14:55, Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> wrote: My reference to Idaho Code Section 74-102(4) refers to the fact that the City does not believe you have provided your actual name, address, or phone number with your public records request. Bruce From: Sent: Thursday, October 22, 2026 3:47 AM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> Cc: Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Bruce, Thank you for your reply. I’m a bit confused by the reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4). The statute requires the requester to provide a name, mailing address, email address, and telephone number. All of those items were included when the request was submitted through the City’s online form. For clarity, I'm attaching my initial request. Since the form requires each of the fields listed in § 74‐102(4) to be completed before submission, I’m not sure which specific element you believe was missing or non‐compliant. Could you please clarify which of the four required items the City believes was not provided? Once I understand what part of § 74‐102(4) you believe was not met, I can correct whatever issue you’re referring to. Thank you, On Wednesday, October 21st, 2026 at 17:24, Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> wrote: The reference to Idaho Code Section 74-102(4) refers the statutory requirement upon the requestor to provide “the requester’s name, mailing address, email address, [and] telephone number….” The City has a reasonable basis to believe you have not complied with this requirement, and thus has not processed your request. Thanks, Bruce Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From: Sent: Tuesday, October 20, 2026 11:31 PM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]>; Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Dear City Attorney’s Office, I received the response to my public records request submitted on October 7, 2026, and I wanted to follow up for clarification. The notice referenced Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) and stated that the City is not in possession of a report or record of that nature. I’m hoping you can help me understand what part of Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. § 74‐102(4) applies here. My intention was simply to request any existing records documenting exceptions or deviations from the employee handbook for City Management or Executive Leadership. If the way I phrased the request was too broad or not specific enough to identify the records you need to search for, I’m happy to adjust it. Could you please clarify whether: 1. The reference to § 74‐102(4) means the City determined the request needs to be narrowed; or 2. It means the City concluded that no responsive records exist? Once I understand how the statute applies, I can refine the request accordingly. Thank you for your time and assistance. Sincerely, ------- Forwarded Message ------- From: No Reply <[email protected]> Date: On Tuesday, October 20th, 2026 at 16:47 Subject: Results of your Public Records Request #4953 Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. To: Fulfilled Request Per your records request, filed on 10/07/2026 Attached please find the records held by the City of Twin Falls in response to your request. This link is expires in 30 days. During that time you may use this link to review and/or download a copy of the data. https://lfw s.tfid.org/ PublicDel ivery/Bro wse.aspx ? dbid=0&s tartid=30 319 This request is now concluded. NOTICE: PURSUANT TO IDAHO CODE § 74-115 Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. YOU HAVE 180 DAYS TO APPEAL THIS DECISION BY FILING A PETITION IN STATE DISTRICT COURT IN THE COUNTY WHERE ALL OR PART OF THE RECORDS ARE LOCATED ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. From Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> To Cc Nicole Swafford <[email protected]>, Linda Wells <[email protected]> Date Wednesday, October 28, 2026 04:56 PM MT Subject RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) Attachments none Filed under #4953 Source file SHA-256 7542fdcbf1c00bd161385b3e583317b1207871fb648caa68a45d9a8a9c285553 You can provide proof of your identity as I previously stated. From: Sent: Wednesday, October 28, 2026 2:39 PM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> Cc: Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Can you please let me know what I must do to get the public information that I've requested? On Friday, October 23rd, 2026 at 15:21, wrote: Bruce, Thanks for the clarification. I’m honestly trying to understand what I may have done wrong here. I used the City’s online form and filled out every field it required, so I thought that was the normal way to submit a public records request. If there’s some additional step or registration process I’m supposed to follow, I wasn’t aware of it. You mentioned that the City doesn’t believe the name, address, or phone number provided are real. I didn’t realize the City had a way of verifying that information for public records requests. Could you explain how the City normally verifies a requester’s identity? I want to make sure I’m following whatever the standard procedure is. I’m just trying to request public records, and I want to understand what specifically I need to do so the request can be processed. Thank you, On Friday, October 23rd, 2026 at 10:56, Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> wrote: I am trying to convey that the City does not believe you are who you represent yourself to be in the request, and that the code provision requires you to provide your real name, address, etc., not an assumed identity. If you were to provide proof of your identity then this could certainly be resolved very quickly. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From: Sent: Friday, October 23, 2026 9:52 AM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> Cc: Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Bruce, I have to admit I’m confused by your response. The City’s online form requires a name, mailing address, email address, and phone number before it can even be submitted, and all of those fields were completed. Your statement that “the City does not believe” the information is actual is unclear, and I’m not sure what that means in terms of compliance with Idaho Code § 74‐102(4). I’m simply trying to request public records. If the City is refusing to process the request, I need to understand specifically what requirement you believe has not been met and what, in your view, must be done in order for the request to be processed. The statute lists the required information, and that information was provided. Please let me know what the City requires so that these records can be released. Thank you, On Thursday, October 22nd, 2026 at 14:55, Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> wrote: My reference to Idaho Code Section 74-102(4) refers to the fact that the City does not believe you have provided your actual name, address, or phone number with your public records request. Bruce From: Sent: Thursday, October 22, 2026 3:47 AM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> Cc: Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Bruce, Thank you for your reply. I’m a bit confused by the reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4). The statute requires the requester to provide a name, mailing address, email address, and telephone number. All of those items were included when the request was submitted through the City’s online form. For clarity, I'm attaching my initial request. Since the form requires each of the fields listed in § 74‐102(4) to be completed before submission, I’m not sure which specific element you believe was missing or non‐compliant. Could you please clarify which of the four required items the City believes was not provided? Once I understand what part of § 74‐102(4) you believe was not met, I can correct whatever issue you’re referring to. Thank you, On Wednesday, October 21st, 2026 at 17:24, Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> wrote: The reference to Idaho Code Section 74-102(4) refers the statutory requirement upon the requestor to provide “the requester’s name, mailing address, email address, [and] telephone number….” The City has a reasonable basis to believe you have not complied with this requirement, and thus has not processed your request. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. Thanks, Bruce From: com> Sent: Tuesday, October 20, 2026 11:31 PM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]>; Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Dear City Attorney’s Office, I received the response to my public records request submitted on October 7, 2026, and I wanted to follow up for clarification. The notice referenced Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) and stated that the City is not in possession of a report or record of that nature. I’m hoping you can help me understand what part of § 74‐102(4) applies Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. here. My intention was simply to request any existing records documenting exceptions or deviations from the employee handbook for City Management or Executive Leadership. If the way I phrased the request was too broad or not specific enough to identify the records you need to search for, I’m happy to adjust it. Could you please clarify whether: 1. The reference to § 74‐102(4) means the City determined the request needs to be narrowed; or 2. It means the City concluded that no responsive records exist? Once I understand how the statute applies, I can refine the request accordingly. Thank you for your time and assistance. Sincerely, ------- Forwarded Message ------- From: No Reply <[email protected]> Date: On Tuesday, October 20th, 2026 at 16:47 Subject: Results of your Public Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. Records Request #4953 To: ail.com mail.com> Fulfilled Request Per your records request, filed on 10/07/2 026 Attache d please find the records held by the City of Twin Falls in respons e to your request. This link is expires in 30 days. During that time you may use this link to review and/or downloa d a copy of the data. https://lf ws.tfid.o rg/Publi cDeliver y/Brows e.aspx? Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. dbid=0& startid=3 0319 This request is now conclud ed. NOTICE : PURSU ANT TO IDAHO CODE § 74-115 YOU HAVE 180 DAYS TO APPEAL THIS DECISI ON BY FILING A PETITI ON IN STATE DISTRI CT COURT IN THE COUNT Y WHERE ALL OR PART OF THE RECOR DS ARE LOCAT ED ⚠ This mes sage is sent from an acco unt that is NOT MON ITOR ED. Do not reply to this mes sage — it will not be read. From To Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> Cc Nicole Swafford <[email protected]>, Linda Wells <[email protected]> Date Thursday, October 29, 2026 05:51 AM MT Subject RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) Attachments none Filed under #4953 Source file SHA-256 ba30613e5126d89177838e3c9d87bd3c5ce64f59c1a9b7956c9ce8b39cfff788 OK, you're telling me that if I provide some kind of proof of ID that you'll provide the public records? How do you normally accept proof of identity from people requesting public records? Do I just email you a copy of an ID or do you have an online form that people register with your city in order to get records? On Wednesday, October 28th, 2026 at 16:56, Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> wrote: You can provide proof of your identity as I previously stated. From: Sent: Wednesday, October 28, 2026 2:39 PM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> Cc: Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Can you please let me know what I must do to get the public information that I've requested? On Friday, October 23rd, 2026 at 15:21, wrote: Bruce, Thanks for the clarification. I’m honestly trying to understand what I may have done wrong here. I used the City’s online form and filled out every field it required, so I thought that was the normal way to submit a public records request. If there’s some additional step or registration process I’m supposed to follow, I wasn’t aware of it. You mentioned that the City doesn’t believe the name, address, or phone number provided are real. I didn’t realize the City had a way of verifying that information for public records requests. Could you explain how the Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. City normally verifies a requester’s identity? I want to make sure I’m following whatever the standard procedure is. I’m just trying to request public records, and I want to understand what specifically I need to do so the request can be processed. Thank you, On Friday, October 23rd, 2026 at 10:56, Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> wrote: I am trying to convey that the City does not believe you are who you represent yourself to be in the request, and that the code provision requires you to provide your real name, address, etc., not an assumed identity. If you were to provide proof of your identity then this could certainly be resolved very quickly. From: Sent: Friday, October 23, 2026 9:52 AM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> Cc: Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Bruce, I have to admit I’m confused by your response. The City’s online form requires a name, mailing address, email address, and phone number before it can even be submitted, and all of those fields were completed. Your statement that “the City does not believe” the information is actual is unclear, and I’m not sure what that means in terms of compliance with Idaho Code § 74‐102(4). Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. I’m simply trying to request public records. If the City is refusing to process the request, I need to understand specifically what requirement you believe has not been met and what, in your view, must be done in order for the request to be processed. The statute lists the required information, and that information was provided. Please let me know what the City requires so that these records can be released. Thank you, On Thursday, October 22nd, 2026 at 14:55, Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> wrote: My reference to Idaho Code Section 74-102(4) refers to the fact that the City does not believe you have provided your actual name, address, or phone number with your public records request. Bruce From: Sent: Thursday, October 22, 2026 3:47 AM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> Cc: Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Bruce, Thank you for your reply. I’m a bit confused by the reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4). The statute requires the requester to provide a name, mailing address, email address, and telephone number. All of those items were included when the request was submitted through the City’s online form. For clarity, I'm attaching my initial request. Since the form requires each of the fields listed in § 74‐102(4) to be completed before submission, I’m not sure which specific element you believe was missing or non‐compliant. Could you please clarify which of the four required items the City believes was not provided? Once I understand what part of § 74‐102(4) you believe was not met, I can correct whatever issue you’re referring to. Thank you, On Wednesday, October 21st, 2026 at 17:24, Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> wrote: Mr. The reference to Idaho Code Section 74- 102(4) refers the statutory requirement upon the requestor to provide “the requester’s name, mailing address, email address, [and] telephone number….” The City has a reasonable basis to believe you have not complied with this requirement, and thus has not processed your request. Thanks, Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. Bruce From: Sent: Tuesday, October 20, 2026 11:31 PM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]>; Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Dear City Attorney’s Office, I received the response to my public records request submitted on October 7, 2026, and I wanted to follow up for clarification. The notice referenced Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) and stated that the City is not in possession of a report or record of that nature. I’m hoping you can help me understand what part of § 74‐102(4) applies here. My intention was simply to request any existing records documenting exceptions or deviations from the employee handbook for City Management or Executive Leadership. If the way I phrased the request was too broad or not specific enough to identify the records you need to search for, I’m happy to adjust it. Could you please clarify whether: 1. The reference to § 74‐102(4) means the City determined the request needs to be narrowed; or 2. It means the City concluded that no responsive records exist? Once I understand how the statute applies, I can refine the request accordingly. Thank you for your time and assistance. Sincerely, - - - - - - - Forwarded Message - - - - - - - From: No Reply <[email protected]> Date: On Tuesday, October 20th, 2026 at 16:47 Subject: Results of your Public Records Request #4953 To: Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. Fulfilled Request Per your records request, filed on 10/07/2026 Attached please find the records held by the City of Twin Falls in response to your request. This link is expires in 30 days. During that time you may use this link to review and/or download a copy of the data. h t t p s : / / l f w s . t f i d . o r g / P u b l i c D e l i v e r y / B r o w s e . a s p x ? d b i d = 0 & s t a r t i d = 3 0 3 1 9 This request is now concluded. NOTICE: PURSUANT TO IDAHO CODE § 74- 115 YOU HAVE 180 DAYS TO APPEAL THIS DECISION BY FILING A PETITION IN STATE DISTRICT COURT IN THE COUNTY WHERE ALL OR PART OF THE RECORDS ARE LOCATED ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. From To Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> Cc Nicole Swafford <[email protected]>, Linda Wells <[email protected]> Date Wednesday, November 04, 2026 09:39 AM MT Subject RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) Attachments none Filed under #4953 Source file SHA-256 ccc3f9f51445834c6a39b48dbb5355642b76ae0c5918c45c6751ce0d6a67212a Sir and Madams, Can I please get a response to this so I may get the records I'm seeking? This is all in response to a public records request. I thought getting public records would be easier than this. On Thursday, October 29th, 2026 at 05:51, wrote: OK, you're telling me that if I provide some kind of proof of ID that you'll provide the public records? How do you normally accept proof of identity from people requesting public records? Do I just email you a copy of an ID or do you have an online form that people register with your city in order to get records? On Wednesday, October 28th, 2026 at 16:56, Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> wrote: You can provide proof of your identity as I previously stated. From: Sent: Wednesday, October 28, 2026 2:39 PM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> Cc: Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Can you please let me know what I must do to get the public information that I've requested? On Friday, October 23rd, 2026 at 15:21, wrote: Bruce, Thanks for the clarification. I’m honestly trying to understand what I may have done wrong here. I used the City’s online Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. form and filled out every field it required, so I thought that was the normal way to submit a public records request. If there’s some additional step or registration process I’m supposed to follow, I wasn’t aware of it. You mentioned that the City doesn’t believe the name, address, or phone number provided are real. I didn’t realize the City had a way of verifying that information for public records requests. Could you explain how the City normally verifies a requester’s identity? I want to make sure I’m following whatever the standard procedure is. I’m just trying to request public records, and I want to understand what specifically I need to do so the request can be processed. Thank you, On Friday, October 23rd, 2026 at 10:56, Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> wrote: I am trying to convey that the City does not believe you are who you represent yourself to be in the request, and that the code provision requires you to provide your real name, address, etc., not an assumed identity. If you were to provide proof of your identity then this could certainly be resolved very quickly. From: Sent: Friday, October 23, 2026 9:52 AM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> Cc: Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Bruce, I have to admit I’m confused by your response. The City’s online form requires a name, mailing address, email address, and phone number before it can even be submitted, and all of those fields were completed. Your statement that “the City does not believe” the information is actual is unclear, and I’m not sure what that means in terms of compliance with Idaho Code § 74‐102(4). I’m simply trying to request public records. If the City is refusing to process the request, I need to understand specifically what requirement you believe has not been met and what, in your view, must be done in order for the request to be processed. The statute lists the required information, and that information was provided. Please let me know what the City requires so that these records can be released. Thank you, On Thursday, October 22nd, 2026 at 14:55, Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> wrote: My reference to Idaho Code Section 74- 102(4) refers to the fact that the City does not believe you have provided your actual name, address, or phone number with your public records request. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. Bruce From: Sent: Thursday, October 22, 2026 3:47 AM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> Cc: Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: RE: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Bruce, Thank you for your reply. I’m a bit confused by the reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4). The statute requires the requester to provide a name, mailing address, email address, and telephone number. All of those items were included when the request was submitted through the City’s online form. For clarity, I'm attaching my initial request. Since the form requires each of the fields listed in § 74‐102(4) to be completed before submission, I’m not sure which specific element you believe was missing or non‐compliant. Could you please clarify which of the four required items the City believes was not provided? Once I understand what part of § 74‐102(4) you believe was not met, I can correct whatever issue you’re referring to. Thank you, Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. On Wednesday, October 21st, 2026 at 17:24, Bruce Castleton <[email protected]> wrote: Mr. The reference to Idaho Code Section 74- 102(4) refers the statutory requirement upon the requestor to provide “the requester’s name, mailing address, email address, [and] telephone number….” The City has a reasonable basis to believe you have not complied with this requirement, and Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. thus has not processed your request. Thanks, Bruce From: Sent: Tuesday, October 20, 2026 11:31 PM To: Bruce Castleton <[email protected]>; Nicole Swafford <nswaff[email protected]>; Linda Wells <[email protected]> Subject: Clarification Regarding Reference to Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Dear City Attorney’s Office, I received the response to my public records request submitted on October 7, 2026, and I wanted to follow up for clarification. The notice referenced Idaho Code § 74‐102(4) and stated that the City is not in possession of a report or record of that nature. I’m hoping you can help me understand what part of § 74‐102(4) applies here. My intention was simply to request any existing records documenting exceptions or deviations from the employee handbook for City Management or Executive Leadership. If the way I phrased the request was too broad or not specific enough to identify the records you need to search for, I’m happy to adjust it. Could you please clarify whether: 1. The reference to § 74‐102(4) means the City determined the request needs to be narrowed; or 2. It means the City concluded that no responsive records exist? Once I understand how the statute applies, I can refine the request accordingly. Thank you for your time and assistance. Sincerely, - - - - - - - Forwarded Message - - - - - - - From: No Reply <[email protected]> Date: On Tuesday, October 20th, 2026 at 16:47 Subject: Results of your Public Records Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. Request #4953 To: Fulfilled Request Per your records request, filed on 10/07/2026 Attached please find the records held by the City of Twin Falls in response to your request. This link is expires in 30 days. During that time you may use this link to review and/or download a copy of the data. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. h t t p s : / / l f w s . t f i d . o r g / P u b l i c D e l i v e r y / B r o w s e . a s p x ? d b i d = 0 & s t a r t i d = 3 0 3 1 9 This request is now concluded. NOTICE: PURSUANT TO IDAHO CODE § 74- 115 YOU HAVE 180 DAYS TO APPEAL THIS DECISION BY FILING A PETITION IN STATE DISTRICT COURT IN THE COUNTY WHERE ALL OR PART OF THE RECORDS ARE LOCATED ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read.