EX-C10-2
Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments)
City of Twin Falls
View the document here · 6 pages
- Record date
- Not dated
- Source
- PRR (Leave records attempt 3 (denied))
- Record type
- Records Requests and Agency Responses
- Pages used
- all (4); all (1); all (1)
- Supports findings
- E-21 Three requests for leave and sell-back records denied within 16 to 69 minutes, with an instruction to stop asking
- Notes
- Each email rendered to PDF from the received message; bookmarks give date/sender/subject. Requester signature images omitted.
- Redaction
- 3 area(s) redacted
Chain of custody
- Obtained. From the City of Twin Falls' response to a public records request.
- As received. SHA-256 of the file exactly as the agency released it:
94a075d2ca5553fada0d89ca9010fb24cc6a7eb86cc7d2216fc5015b3e14d165
b5359fb7100d987c8da13cdf0097eaec08702c9e47ac8ec9c8d5a74463939be1
35f599e54ee960f2ee4814cfb7010deb232951e5d2eaa996f76cc9b89d0763d2 - Changes for posting.
- Combined from 3 files as released
- Redacted: 3 area(s) redacted
- Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed
- Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 5, 6); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable
- Posted copy. SHA-256 of the file you download here, checked against our index on every build:
5488e971fb2390922c2a63f754c9b8a8fe6e551d61afa784c30f9e9aa65bb600
The original as received is kept unaltered. Anyone holding the agency's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. How to verify a file · Chain of custody for every record (CSV)
Document text (read by machine for search, and often imperfect for scans and handwriting; the file is the record)
City of Twin Falls Public Records Request Requestor Information Please list your information here. Include your request details in the space provided below. Requestor First Name * Requestor Last Name * Requestor Address 1 * Requestor Address 2 Requestor City * Requestor State * Requestor ZIP Code * Requestor Phone Number * Requestor E-mail * Type of Request * Personal Commercial Legal Request Details * If you are requesting multiple records, please attach your list below. If you do not have a case/event/citation number, please include enough information to identify the records you want. If your request is for multiple items, it may be subject to fees for preparation. We have records for the Twin Falls Police Department (city, not county) only. STOP - Please take the time to read the request as it was adjusted to avoid your stated limitations prior to asking the last time. It seems you're not taking the time to examine the request as required by state law. PUBLIC RECORDS REQUEST — Hours Worked + Vacation/PTO Used (Compensation Transparency) Pursuant to the Idaho Public Records Act, Idaho Code § 74‑101 et seq., I request records showing hours worked and paid leave usage for the following City of Twin Falls employees: Travis Rothweiler – City Manager Gretchen Scott – Deputy City Manager Mitch Humble – Deputy City Manager Breanna Howard – Chief Financial Officer Kristen Kohntopp – Human Resources Director Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. Troy Vitek – City Engineer Shawn Barigar – Economic Development Director Josh Baird – Public Works Director Legal Basis for This Request 1. These records are NOT exempt under Idaho Code § 74‑106(1) Idaho Code § 74‑106(1) exempts certain personnel records except: “the public official’s name, position, salary, and publicly funded benefits.” Paid leave (vacation, PTO, holiday leave, administrative leave) is a publicly funded benefit.Hours worked are a component of salary calculation and public compensation transparency. Therefore, both categories fall under the non‑exempt portion of § 74‑106(1). 2. Vacation usage is required to validate vacation sellback payments Vacation sellbacks are direct taxpayer expenditures.Records showing vacation hours used are financial records, not personnel evaluations. Financial records must be disclosed under: Idaho Code § 74‑102(1) — all public records are open unless expressly exempt Idaho Code § 74‑103(4) — denials must cite specific exemptions for each withheld portion Idaho Code § 74‑112 — non‑exempt portions must be released even if some portions are exempt 3. Compensation records are always public Idaho Code § 74‑106(1) explicitly states that salary and publicly funded benefits cannot be withheld. Vacation/PTO usage is part of: publicly funded benefits, and compensation calculations, especially when validating sellback eligibility. Thus, these records are not exempt. Purpose of Request (Required to Avoid § 74‑106(1)) This request is made solely for compensation transparency and financial accountability, specifically to: Determine effective hourly compensation for salaried officials Understand the public expenditure associated with paid leave benefits Validate compliance with the City’s vacation sellback eligibility rules Compare administrative compensation structures with other Idaho municipalities This request does not seek any information related to performance, discipline, evaluations, medical conditions, or personnel management. 1. Hours Worked Please provide all records showing hours worked, including: Daily hours worked Weekly totals Monthly totals Annual totals Any internal breakdowns used by the City (regular, overtime, holiday, etc.) These records are part of salary calculation and therefore not exempt under § 74‑106(1). 2. Paid Leave Usage (Vacation + PTO) Please provide all records showing paid leave hours used, including: Vacation leave hours used PTO hours used Holiday leave used Administrative leave used Medical leave hours used — quantities only; no medical details For each category, provide: Hours used Totals by month and year Paid leave is a publicly funded benefit, explicitly not exempt under § 74‑106(1). 3. Records Used for Vacation Sellback Eligibility Please provide any records or summaries showing: Vacation hours used in the preceding 12‑month period Vacation balances relevant to sellback eligibility Any totals used to determine whether sellback criteria were met Vacation sellbacks are public expenditures, and records validating them are financial records, not personnel records. Under Idaho Code § 74‑102(1), these must be disclosed. 4. Scope Clarification This request applies to all records containing the requested information, regardless of: the system in which they are stored, the department that maintains them, the software used to generate them, or the format in which they currently exist. Examples of departments that may hold these records include, but are not limited to: Finance Department (payroll, sellback payments, compensation records) Human Resources Department (leave usage, leave balances, benefit tracking) These examples do not limit the scope of the request. 5. Date Range January 1, 2020 through present Or as far back as digital or stored records exist 6. Format Any electronic format (CSV, XLSX, PDF, etc.). Attach Files to Your Request If you have documentation that you wish to provide for this request, attach the files here. Signature * The City of Twin Falls will respond to this request within three (3) business days. Or up to 10 business days upon notification of the requesting party. The City of Twin Falls maintains records for the City of Twin Falls, Idaho. For records including in Twin Falls County please contact Twin Falls County at www.twinfallscounty.org Requested records will be provided electronically. We do not provide your information to mailing lists. It will only be used to fulfill this request. From [email protected] To Date Friday, October 16, 2026 11:41 AM MT Subject Copy of Form Public Records Requests Attachments City of Twin Falls Public Records Request.pdf Filed under PTO Attempt 3 Source file SHA-256 5c7120d40962399143035a852c8484d8de3626695b69162e93ea4647bf5c5b00 Your records request has been received. You're receiving this email because someone requested that you get a copy of this form. ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From [email protected] To Date Friday, October 16, 2026 12:50 PM MT Subject Your City of Twin Falls Public Records Request Attachments none Filed under PTO Attempt 3 Source file SHA-256 3352e84723fef5900e264fc0af079b3e6302a026df5e61e3085796d183d4faf8 Records requested are exempt from production under Idaho Code Section 74-106(1). Per our City Attorney, please stop requesting the same information they are exempt. Sincerely, City of Twin Falls ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive.